Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Concerning alleged "medical benefits" of circumcision:

How could natural selection create, and preserve, an anatomical feature that is actually harmful to the organism

That is a misconception about natural selection known as adaptionism. From Dawkins' The Extended Phenotype - "that approach to evolutionary studies which assumes without further proof that all aspects of the morphology, physiology and behavior of organisms are adaptive optimal solutions to problems". Dawkins lists six constraints to perfection - time lags, historical constraints, available genetic variation, constraints of costs and materials, imperfections at one level due to selection at another level, and mistakes due to environmental unpredictability of "malevolence".

There are numerous example of vestiges and remnants of formerly useful parts hanging around where the drive of harm has not yet been sufficient to lead to their loss. Don't read too much into it.

Linda
 
How could they think that when the physician will have told them that the procedure is not medically required for their child?

Does any parent elect to have their child's wisdom teeth removed unless a dentist advises it?

A parent could make all sorts of judicious changes to their child's anatomy to give it an 'advantage'.

.

How many other anatomical changes were supposedly commanded by a certain angry Middle Eastern deity, though?

That whole thing sure is one heck of a coincidence, isn't it?

Either that, or religion really is good for science.
 
How many other anatomical changes were supposedly commanded by a certain angry Middle Eastern deity, though?

That whole thing sure is one heck of a coincidence, isn't it?

Either that, or religion really is good for science.

How many bits and pieces are there that could be easily lopped off in an infant that wouldn't be immediately harmful, though? I also wonder whether this is a pattern that would emerge any time you finish the job of removing something that is on its way to becoming vestigial - a small benefit that would not have been sustained if the process of evolution had led to the disappearance. For example, if men had evolved to lack a foreskin, the rate of HIV acquisition would be the same as it is now for uncircumcised men.

But I think we should do it on mice, first.

Linda
 
How many bits and pieces are there that could be easily lopped off in an infant that wouldn't be immediately harmful, though? I also wonder whether this is a pattern that would emerge any time you finish the job of removing something that is on its way to becoming vestigial - a small benefit that would not have been sustained if the process of evolution had led to the disappearance. For example, if men had evolved to lack a foreskin, the rate of HIV acquisition would be the same as it is now for uncircumcised men.

But I think we should do it on mice, first.

Linda

But is it random?:D

ETA: Do you have any evidence that the foreskin is "on its way to becoming vestigal"? Or is everything that a human can survive without to be considered vestigal? E.g., a kidney, a lung, etc.
 
Last edited:
Tell me, in the hospital(s) where you practice, do the physicians have a separate area from other staff in the cafeteria for meals? And if not, have you seen these areas in other hospitals? Have you observed a sufficient number of different nurse practitioner patient interactions to say you see no indication of any philosophical difference between patient-provider interactions?


No. There is no separate area for physicians. I have seen them in other hospitals.

My take on it is that there is an argument to be made for having a separate clinical staff cafeteria so nurse practitioners, nurses, docs, etc could talk a bit more freely over lunch about tough cases or the like. I don't think that docs need to have an area separate from other clinical staff, but it is awkward to have a patient or patients' family members corner me in the sandwich line to discuss sensitive issues.

You and Hawkeye both continue to misinterpret what I've said, regardless of the clarifications I keep posting. Surely you recognize the different roles of physicians and nurses are going to result in different reactions to patients' autonomy?

Nowhere in my posts have I said, bad doctors, good nurses. There is no reason for any defensiveness distorting perceptions of what I posted. Of course doctors are compassionate! Just as some nurses aren't. That has absolutely nothing to do with my point.

I was pointing out the difference in the worlds of each profession. If you don't think such basic differences in the philosophy established in the educational and professional milieu have any affect on patient-physician and patient-nurse interactions, then what is your reasoning? I'll say it again, this is not about skills, compassion, clearly divided philosophies, patient respect in either profession. Think of it more like two overlapping bell curves with slightly shifted peaks (or maybe moderately shifted in some cases).


I have thought about what I said and your response to it, skeptigirl, and I should apologize for the tone of my post. You are right in that I took offense, responded in defense, and my reaction is likely due more to experiences that I have had on the job with nurses throwing the "I'm the patient advocate" accusation at docs, including me (obviously), when they clearly weren't.

More often than not, I am impressed by your posts and your efforts to support your positions with evidence.

My frustration is that, yes, docs and nurses will ultimately have different roles and with those differences comes some differences in philosophy (? is that the right word even - I don't know).

However, I think that the greatest disservice to all of us in the healthcare field is perpetuating this idea that these differences are so vast. I'm not saying that that's what you're doing. I'm just venting.

It never fails to amaze me that docs and nurses always have different patient sign-outs at the end of the day. When I sit in on nurses' sign-outs, I learn so much, and I have always found that they feel the same when they participate in ours. We have much more to learn from each other than not.

For that matter, why does the ob/gyn department in my hospital have a meeting that includes nurses, midwives, nurse practitioners, and docs only once a year? It's ridiculous.

Anyway, I digress a bit...

Changing face of medical curricula, 2001 You can't exactly change from paternalistic training unless it was the status quo originally.

{snip}

Paternalism is addressed in any number of medical ethics classes. It is approached differently now than years passed and it is approached differently in different settings and countries. But the fact there are so many classes and articles that address the issue speaks to its existence.


You're right. I just seek to point out that it's changing, and you have acknowledged that. I just think that when young docs hear generalizations lodged at them (or think that they are hearing them ;)) based on conclusions formed from exposure to people trained using old-fashioned models, they will become defensive. Most of us really do strive for better and believe in a different approach.


Compare that to this article which fully explores nursing treatment of non-compliance. Therapeutic Compliance Posttransplantation – A Nurse’s Perspective; Research Studies for Measurement and Prediction of Compliance. Rather than a discussion of the potential for non-compliance to be an issue, it's a nursing diagnosis. It's our job to deal with it. How would this not result in at least some different practice philosophies between doctors and nurse practitioners? I actively promote patient autonomy. I've not seen many doctors do that.


How do you see yourself as doing that? And how do you contrast that with what doctors do? That's a distinction that you are making that I wish to understand. What does it mean to you to promote patient autonomy? How are docs not doing that? What do you wish they would do instead?

If you are simply describing your personal feelings with a difficult medical dilemma in terms of performing circs, fine. But if you are trying to tell me I can't possibly understand this unless I've done circ procedures, I don't accept that at all. You have no idea what practice experiences I've had. And you are making the false assumption that somehow my evaluation and perception of this matter are naive. I might suggest to you that unless you've tried futilely to revive an infant that has just succumbed to a respiratory infection or taken care of a 3 year old that is about to have all four limbs amputated from a meningococcal infection, that you can't empathize with my position. But that would be stupid because I don't know what your experiences have been. It wouldn't bother me to perform a circ because I have no dilemma over doing circumcisions. And lots of NPs perform circs, BTW.


I am not suggesting that, because someone does not do circs, that he/she cannot speak to the matter, though I can understand why the general tone of my post may have conveyed that.

I was putting forth the fact that, in the face of equivocal medical evidence for its value, being the one actively doing an elective procedure puts things in a different light. I don't mean to demean anyone's opinions. I meant only to point out that this level of uncertainty in the "evidence" so to speak can cause varying amounts of discomfort in the one yielding the scalpel. Yes. I learned that first-hand.

It was the underlying assumptions about 'not medically indicated' I object to. In addition, I disagreed with Dr Hawk's perception that providing another provider respected the parent's views.

We are interpreting "respect" differently in this discussion. I interpret respect as recognizing different people have different values and those values are just as valid as anyone else's in this case. Dr H is interpreting it to mean she doesn't recognize those values, doesn't recognize why the parents' decision is just as legitimate as hers. Dr H instead made the non-evidence based declaration, "there is no medical indication for a circumcision in a healthy infant" so if the parents want one, they are wrong, but I won't interfere.

She doesn't say, the parents have different values and are valuing prevention of UTI while I (DrH) value something else so I don't personally want to do the circumcision.

My point in arguing this matter concerns what I see (and it's very clear in my view) as distortions of the empirical evidence. I see a failure of people to recognize that more than one value is legitimate in weighing the risk and benefit.

I guess I don't see HawkeyeMD's actions in the same light at all. As I said, in a situation with equivocal evidence, as the one doing the procedure, the simple desires of the parents may not be enough. In this instance, that's ok. She hasn't obstructed their ability to obtain this procedure. She just is not willing to do it herself. I guess I understand.

Re-read what I said. I bolded it for you. I said nothing about anti-abortion beliefs being "fundamentalist religious beliefs". I do however think pushing abstinence only education is reaching the fundamentalist end of the continuum of beliefs.

I won't disagree there. The way the posts read, it came across differently.

I said nothing about acceptable practice. I don't agree with the denial of the equivocal medical evidence regarding circumcisions. It is not respecting the parent's choice if you cannot recognize they have just as much justification deciding the lowered risk of infection is more important to them than the questionable significance of the foreskin.

In the same vein, I don't see how, in the face of equivocal evidence, opting out of an elective procedure and referring the parents to someone else compromises their ability to choose.

Having said all of that, we clearly will not agree on all things, but I do respect your opinion, what I learn from your posts (even in threads in which I am not a participant), and your obvious passion for your work.
 
fls said:
How many bits and pieces are there that could be easily lopped off in an infant that wouldn't be immediately harmful, though?

Not a lot, but some parts of the female anatomy could go, ear lobes, probably other parts of the ear, some toes, parts of the lips?

I also wonder whether this is a pattern that would emerge any time you finish the job of removing something that is on its way to becoming vestigial

How can you say the foreskin is on it's way to becoming vestigial? The foreskin of the human penis is more developed than what you see in other primates.

a small benefit that would not have been sustained if the process of evolution had led to the disappearance. For example, if men had evolved to lack a foreskin, the rate of HIV acquisition would be the same as it is now for uncircumcised men.

I would be interesting to know what would have happened with HIV in a hypothetical world where men were born without foreskins. But since biology will always throw you for a loop, it's equally plausible that different negatives would have popped up over time instead....epidemics that didn't take off because of the foreskin. My impression of how pathogens evolve leads me to think that we would have entirely different STDs, or that the STDs we have right now would behave very differently, if humans were born with a different sexual anatomy. Change the selective pressures and the pathogens will be different.
 
Not a lot, but some parts of the female anatomy could go, ear lobes, probably other parts of the ear, some toes, parts of the lips?



How can you say the foreskin is on it's way to becoming vestigial? The foreskin of the human penis is more developed than what you see in other primates.



I would be interesting to know what would have happened with HIV in a hypothetical world where men were born without foreskins. But since biology will always throw you for a loop, it's equally plausible that different negatives would have popped up over time instead....epidemics that didn't take off because of the foreskin. My impression of how pathogens evolve leads me to think that we would have entirely different STDs, or that the STDs we have right now would behave very differently, if humans were born with a different sexual anatomy. Change the selective pressures and the pathogens will be different.

Yep. The best you can do is play with the hand you've been dealt. However, I think the idea Linda was getting at was that if you can remove a body part that is only a minor change for you, but a step change for the pathogen, then you can have a net benefit if the pathogen's reproductive success is significantly reduced.
 
Not a lot, but some parts of the female anatomy could go, ear lobes, probably other parts of the ear, some toes, parts of the lips?

I agree with the female anatomy and the ear lobes. I suspect that once you involve bones, the risk of serious infection becomes an issue. And that lips would interfere with breastfeeding. So the latter two might end up immediately harmful. We've got the female genitalia covered. Surely there's some culture somewhere that lops off the ear lobes? Or maybe piercing counts.

How can you say the foreskin is on it's way to becoming vestigial? The foreskin of the human penis is more developed than what you see in other primates.

That would support my supposition, though. The selection pressures are likely to be higher in other primates, so they are further along the path that we are following. Just saying that it's an obvious possibility.

I would be interesting to know what would have happened with HIV in a hypothetical world where men were born without foreskins. But since biology will always throw you for a loop, it's equally plausible that different negatives would have popped up over time instead....epidemics that didn't take off because of the foreskin. My impression of how pathogens evolve leads me to think that we would have entirely different STDs, or that the STDs we have right now would behave very differently, if humans were born with a different sexual anatomy. Change the selective pressures and the pathogens will be different.

Yeah, I'm thinking similar equilibriums would be reached regardless of the details.

Linda
 
Yep. The best you can do is play with the hand you've been dealt. However, I think the idea Linda was getting at was that if you can remove a body part that is only a minor change for you, but a step change for the pathogen, then you can have a net benefit if the pathogen's reproductive success is significantly reduced.

Right. I agree. And that's why I can see how people in Africa might want circumcision. Since HIV is an epidemic of quasi-Armageddon proportions, desperate measures do seem to be called for.

But in complete seriousness (honestly not an "emotional appeal") I really do think removing some of the female labia and some other forms of FGC would disrupt the transmission cycles of both herpes and HIV, as well, especially as the two viruses work together. But we all know that kind of "desperate measure" would be unethical to even explore as an option or potential area of scientific research.
How do you resolve that logical disconnect?
 
Right. I agree. And that's why I can see how people in Africa might want circumcision. Since HIV is an epidemic of quasi-Armageddon proportions, desperate measures do seem to be called for.

But in complete seriousness (honestly not an "emotional appeal") I really do think removing some of the female labia and some other forms of FGC would disrupt the transmission cycles of both herpes and HIV, as well, especially as the two viruses work together. But we all know that kind of "desperate measure" would be unethical to even explore as an option or potential area of scientific research.
How do you resolve that logical disconnect?

That's what I can't get with the likes of the pro-circumcision people and skeptigirl. They're fast enough to defend parents rights to choose circumcision for their boys, but balk at the idea of doing a clinical trial of a very specific form of FGM with consenting adult volunteers. I don't see how you can have an issue with one but not the other.:confused:
 
I agree with the female anatomy and the ear lobes. I suspect that once you involve bones, the risk of serious infection becomes an issue. And that lips would interfere with breastfeeding.
Regarding breastfeeding, just like the tribes that practiced religious circumcision figured out that the 8th day was best (probably because of vitamin K), "god" would probably command a culture to remove lip parts after the local age of weaning. I can even see it being a cultural symbol of transition into middle childhood or something.

That would support my supposition, though. The selection pressures are likely to be higher in other primates, so they are further along the path that we are following. Just saying that it's an obvious possibility.

Huh. I guess you're right. It could have gone either way.
Of course, if the "sperm competition" theory relating to the penis size to testical size ratio is correct, the the male anatomy is in the process of changing quite a bit, probably. And not in a way that many men would find appealing. :)
 
Last edited:
Of course, if the "sperm competition" theory relating to the penis size to testical size ratio is correct, the the male anatomy is in the process of changing quite a bit, probably. And not in a way that many men would find appealing. :)

But at least I have an excuse now. Thanks.;)
 
That's what I can't get with the likes of the pro-circumcision people and skeptigirl. They're fast enough to defend parents rights to choose circumcision for their boys, but balk at the idea of doing a clinical trial of a very specific form of FGM with consenting adult volunteers. I don't see how you can have an issue with one but not the other.:confused:

Uh, yeah. I still don't get what gives the parents the right to perform unnecessary and unreversable surgery on their children. I also personally think it's unethical for medical profressionals to participate in this.
 
That's what I can't get with the likes of the pro-circumcision people and skeptigirl. They're fast enough to defend parents rights to choose circumcision for their boys, but balk at the idea of doing a clinical trial of a very specific form of FGM with consenting adult volunteers. I don't see how you can have an issue with one but not the other.:confused:

Well I'm not sure that there is a basis for such a test so far. Nobody has put forward any particular theories nor have then been any noticable trends that would lead to such theories. But it seems unlikely they will find anything positive.

And here's something I think you'll enjoy. Aparently circumcision is not alone...
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/health/2002246171_healthhelmet20.html
 
Uh, yeah. I still don't get what gives the parents the right to perform unnecessary and unreversable surgery on their children. I also personally think it's unethical for medical profressionals to participate in this.

And I still don't get what makes people think foreskins are a good thing...

I guess that makes us even.
 
Well I'm not sure that there is a basis for such a test so far. Nobody has put forward any particular theories nor have then been any noticable trends that would lead to such theories. But it seems unlikely they will find anything positive.

And here's something I think you'll enjoy. Aparently circumcision is not alone...
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/health/2002246171_healthhelmet20.html

When I read mis-shaped heads I got worried...:jaw-dropp

The difference between that procedure and circumcision is that it is a cosmetic procedure that can only be performed at that age.

I have far more sympathy for parents of kids with mild deformities like that than ones who select circumcision for a healthy child, since the latter can be performed at any age.
 
And I still don't get what makes people think foreskins are a good thing...

I guess that makes us even.

I'm not sure that's how debate works.

It's certainly a rational opinion to believe that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the costs-- it's a subjective judgement based on the applicable evidence, but it can be done in a rational manner. I agree with the recent posters in that I don't see how you could deny it on a rational basis and then categorically say all types of FGM are morally unjust; that's not rational at all; though it might be the case that FGM doesn't have the same cost-benefit ratio as male circumcision, presently there isn't really a lot of research done in this area. If you support research for male circumcision to fight AIDS, then it logically follows you should support research determining whether the cost of FGM in some form is worth the potential benefits.

Well I'm not sure that there is a basis for such a test so far. Nobody has put forward any particular theories nor have then been any noticable trends that would lead to such theories. But it seems unlikely they will find anything positive.
It seems like there is plenty of basis, in that male circumcision slightly reduces chance of an UTI and signifigantly reduces the contraction of AIDS. It seems like a fair bet that in toughening and reducing sensitive tissues you would get a similar effect regardless of gender, at least to my admittedly non-medically trained eyes.

In my opinion the right of integrity of body and the loss of sensation are heavy weights, but it would be foolish to say there is no point at which medical concerns do not weigh even heavier, or even that those concerns are not based strongly in the contemporary and surrounding medical landscape.
 
Well I'm not sure that there is a basis for such a test so far. Nobody has put forward any particular theories nor have then been any noticable trends that would lead to such theories. But it seems unlikely they will find anything positive.



http://www.aegis.com/conferences/IASHIVPT/2005/TuOa0401.html

INTRODUCTION: It has been postulated that female circumcision might increase the risk of HIV infection either directly, through the use of unsterile equipment, or indirectly, through an increase in genital lacerations or the substitution of anal intercourse. The authors sought to explain an unanticipated significant crude association of lower HIV risk among circumcised women [RR=0.51; 95% CI 0.38,0.70] in a recent survey by examining other factors which might confound this crude association.

METHODS: Capillary blood was collected onto filter paper cards from a nationally representative sample of women age 15 to 49 during the 2004 Tanzania Health Information Survey. Eighty-four percent of eligible women gave consent for their blood to be anonymously tested for HIV antibody. Interview data was linked via barcodes to final test results for 5753 women. The chi-square test of association was used to examine the bivariate relationships between potential HIV risk factors with both circumcision and HIV status. Restricting further analyses to the 5297 women who had ever had sexual intercourse, logistic regression models were then used to adjust circumcision status for other factors found to be significant.

RESULTS: By self-report, 17.7 percent of women were circumcised. Circumcision status varied significantly by region, household wealth, age, education, years resident, religion, years sexually active, union status, polygamy, number of recent and lifetime sex partners, recent injection or abnormal discharge, use of alcohol and ability to say no to sex. In the final logistic model, circumcision remained highly significant [OR=0.60; 95% CI 0.41,0.88] while adjusted for region, household wealth, age, lifetime partners, union status, and recent ulcer.

CONCLUSIONS: A lowered risk of HIV infection among circumcised women was not attributable to confounding with another risk factor in these data. Anthropological insights on female circumcision as practiced in Tanzania may shed light on this conundrum.

So, who's going to volunteer to follow up on this?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom