Ivor the Engineer
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 11,103
While I appreciate that I have a choice, parents shouldn't be allowed* to act as surrogate-decision-makers for their children unless their choices coincide with mine?
Linda
*whatever form that takes
Any idiot can become a parent. Look at the parents insisting WiFi is removed from schools. Sometimes you have to legislate to protect children from the lowest common denominator.
What's the point in training physicians, dentists, etc. if their advice is going to be ignored because of parents who wish to "pimp their child" so they look cool in the locker room?
If the child does feel embarrassed because he is not circumcised, it can be rectified quickly and safely if he wants. If only all "afflictions" were so easily remedied
What anybody has done to their body should be their choice. It does not have to be a free choice (if there exists such a thing in the first place), but they should believe they had a say in what happened to them. The only exceptions I see are if it is unlikely they will ever be able to make the choice themselves because of life-threatening illness, an illness that is likely to cause significant disability and the patient cannot be communicated with before treatment begins, prior brain damage / metal illness that means they cannot understand or communicate, or where treatment has such clear benefits and low risk that it would be considered unreasonable not to proceed. Otherwise, hands-off until you've asked them.
I am amazed that intelligent people here think this approach of maximizing patient input to the decision making process is paternalistic. I view it as the exact opposite.
Last edited: