Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

While I appreciate that I have a choice, parents shouldn't be allowed* to act as surrogate-decision-makers for their children unless their choices coincide with mine?

Linda

*whatever form that takes

Any idiot can become a parent. Look at the parents insisting WiFi is removed from schools. Sometimes you have to legislate to protect children from the lowest common denominator.

What's the point in training physicians, dentists, etc. if their advice is going to be ignored because of parents who wish to "pimp their child" so they look cool in the locker room?

If the child does feel embarrassed because he is not circumcised, it can be rectified quickly and safely if he wants. If only all "afflictions" were so easily remedied:rolleyes:

What anybody has done to their body should be their choice. It does not have to be a free choice (if there exists such a thing in the first place), but they should believe they had a say in what happened to them. The only exceptions I see are if it is unlikely they will ever be able to make the choice themselves because of life-threatening illness, an illness that is likely to cause significant disability and the patient cannot be communicated with before treatment begins, prior brain damage / metal illness that means they cannot understand or communicate, or where treatment has such clear benefits and low risk that it would be considered unreasonable not to proceed. Otherwise, hands-off until you've asked them.

I am amazed that intelligent people here think this approach of maximizing patient input to the decision making process is paternalistic. I view it as the exact opposite.
 
Last edited:
That is as much a strawman as if I tried to say to you that your view is

"As a parent I can do anything I wish to my child since it is my property".

I was trying to understand the reason for the parade of "well, I wouldn't circumcise my child" posts, since after all, no one is saying you must.

Do you disagree with this statement:

"Parent's shouldn't be allowed to abuse their children"

Isn't it obvious that there is tremendous variation as to whether or not circumcision is considered abuse? And that parents who consider it abuse do not choose it for their child, making your statement a tautology?

Linda
 
Last edited:
So lets cut bits off them then in a non-colonial way. We do know what's best for the natives don't we?

If you take that argument to it's logical conclusion you would cut off other body parts that could get diseased, such as fingers.

After all a finger is not essential and it is the parents right to tidy up such untidy looking appendages, especially as the child will not remember the pain when it is grown up.

N'est ce pas?

There is no way around it I am afraid. Circumcision of male babies amounts to docking the child for the parents' convenience. Something many rational people have stopped doing to dogs.

If it's about convenience, then I'll get all their teeth pulled so I don't have to worry about nagging them to brush their teeth. That's turning into a pain in the a**, I tell ya. I have a blender (wedding present), after all.

And all this laundry is pretty inconvenient, so I'm thinking of getting "clothes" tattooed on all my kids. I won't circumcise them, though, cuz it's probably easier to tattoo a foreskin than it is to tattoo a glans.

And if we're making Africans do what we want them to do, I say make them send more chocolate my way.

Linda
 
parents who consider it abuse do not choose it for their child
Kinda forgotten that it is the body of the child we're talkin about? The decision cannot possibly belong to anyone else, if any sense of justice be respected.

Not that it really would matter much. As far as I can see, people are having a life on both sides of the hedge.
 
...snip...


Isn't it obvious that there is tremendous variation as to whether or not circumcision is considered abuse? And that parents who consider it abuse do not choose it for their child, making your statement a tautology?

Linda

It is only a tautology if you believe the first statement I made is correct.
 
It is only a tautology if you believe the first statement I made is correct.

How so? It is my impression that parents think they are benefiting the child, not themselves.

Linda
 
Kinda forgotten that it is the body of the child we're talkin about? The decision cannot possibly belong to anyone else, if any sense of justice be respected.

This discussion has taken that into consideration.

Linda
 
Are you able to have penetrative sex with your partner sans lubrication, natural or otherwise?

Well there is always the natural "lube" that comes out when you get excited that works quite well for regular sex. I think regular sexual function is probably less affected by circumcision because the foreskin naturally gets pulled back during regular sex.

This "lube" also plays a role in masturbation although it isn't actually needed when you have a foreskin. Basically the foreskin itself because it can kind of "roll" is almost like having a vagina built into your penis. I honestly have a hard time picturing how it would work without it.
 
And what a first post it is...
I'm also somewhat surprised you are not circumcised yourself considering where and when you were born... but if you enjoy your foreskin then that's your right. It's kind of silly to presume that people without them are missing much (besides smelling their penis--yuck). The primary penile nerve is in the dorsal area of the penis with many nerve endings in the glans. Circumcision has little to no effect on these areas.

The incidence of it is a lot less in Canada than in the US. My dad (born in Canada in the 40's) is also uncircumcised so I'm guessing he had something to do with it as well.

I live in the states and both my first wife and my current girlfriend were surprised but don't think it's a big deal.
 
The quality of an erotic experience is related to the quality of sensory input on your skin, what you see with your eyes, etc.

The worst possible sensory input on your skin would be too cold, too boiling hot or too violent injuring touch. Under such circumstances it might be impossible to have an erotic experience of high quality.


While it is possible to experience something erotic in circumstances less than best possible, there is a difference between good quality, better quality and best possible quality.

Interestingly enough there is a pretty large amount of the population that really enjoys more intense sensory play. At the end of the day though most people do want a softer touch. I don't want to get too crazy in this thread, but I've seen some stuff that would absolutely blow the average persons mind.
 
How so? It is my impression that parents think they are benefiting the child, not themselves.

Linda

How could they think that when the physician will have told them that the procedure is not medically required for their child?

Does any parent elect to have their child's wisdom teeth removed unless a dentist advises it?

A parent could make all sorts of judicious changes to their child's anatomy to give it an 'advantage'.

It is ironic that a country that has inflicted its culture on so many others round the globe needs to resort the the concept of cultural relativism to defend its own practices.
 
How could they think that when the physician will have told them that the procedure is not medically required for their child?

Does any parent elect to have their child's wisdom teeth removed unless a dentist advises it?

A parent could make all sorts of judicious changes to their child's anatomy to give it an 'advantage'.

It is ironic that a country that has inflicted its culture on so many others round the globe needs to resort the the concept of cultural relativism to defend its own practices.

Why does this surprise you, Ivor? Consider the weirdness we get from the Fundamentalists. When you think about it, it's right in synch.
 
I think I just became an anti-circumcisionist.

Never been clearly for or against the practice before, but today I have seen the Great Light of Truth.

From now on I shall think that circumcising a person younger than 21 years is primitive, soo primitive. (Googleing for photos of Australian aborigines, to get into the right mood...) Soo primitive.
 
How so? It is my impression that parents think they are benefiting the child, not themselves.

Linda

Because for it to be a tautology you must be saying that it is up to the parents to decide what is abuse or not for their child which means that you are in fact saying "As a parent I can do anything I wish to my child since it is my property".
 
Because for it to be a tautology you must be saying that it is up to the parents to decide what is abuse or not for their child which means that you are in fact saying "As a parent I can do anything I wish to my child since it is my property".

There is a minimal consideration of "abuse" which would be respresented in the legal system by the "reasonable person", and there is individual opinion. So I think it would more accurately be stated "as a parent I can do anything a reasonable person would do to my child". The "since it is my property" doesn't follow though. There are many reasons that people take action - use of property is just one of many. "Since I am entrusted with the care of this person" could just as easily be inserted, especially since children are not legally considered property in the US (I don't know where you are).

ETA: D'oh! I should have looked at your info.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Nah. And there's no health benefits, either.

Considering the direction your initial post took, shouldn't that be...

"But the health benefits are."

(Otherwise someone will be tempted to use it against you. ;))

Linda
 
Last edited:
Concerning alleged "medical benefits" of circumcision:

How could natural selection create, and preserve, an anatomical feature that is actually harmful to the organism (as the foreskin is alleged to be)? If that were true, nature would select for men with smaller foreskins, and then eventually with none at all.

And it's not just the human male we're talking about. All male mammals possess a foreskin. That's an awful lot of natural selection weighing in there. Kind of makes it very difficult to believe the line about "having a foreskin may be hazardous to your health."

Genital modifications or "mutilations" (except to correct actual medical problems) carried out on either male or female unconsenting victims, are remnants of primitive savagery and have no place in the modern world.

Robert
 
There is a minimal consideration of "abuse" which would be respresented in the legal system by the "reasonable person", and there is individual opinion. So I think it would more accurately be stated "as a parent I can do anything a reasonable person would do to my child". The "since it is my property" doesn't follow though. There are many reasons that people take action - use of property is just one of many. "Since I am entrusted with the care of this person" could just as easily be inserted, especially since children are not legally considered property in the US (I don't know where you are).

ETA: D'oh! I should have looked at your info.

Linda

Given that 80% of the world's men are not circumcised, then American parents are being unreasonable if significantly more that 20% of their boys are circumcised.

By the way, how "local"* do you go to judge what's reasonable? How many people does it take to form a culture?

Cultural relativism is all fine and dandy if your culture does not intend on interacting with any other. It tends to go tits up when two or more cultures meet though. From what I can tell, the US is not exactly isolating itself from the rest of the world.

For large numbers of people from different cultures to live closely together in peace, idiosyncratic practices of different cultures have to disappear or be assimilated by all. Circumcision is definitely an idiosyncratic cultural practice.

*British readers will get this I hope:D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom