Does that make you qualified to generalize repeatedly about the differences between nurses and docs? My training emphasized patient-centered care and shared decision making, and my medical school was by no means unique. These principles are central to the care provided in my hospital, as well. Certainly, not every doc practices this way, but, by no means do all nurses behave in a manner that I would consider as advocates for patients. When you continually repeat the same claims about nurses being patient advocates and docs being paternalistic or controlling, you compromise your credibility with some of us.
Tell me, in the hospital(s) where you practice, do the physicians have a separate area from other staff in the cafeteria for meals? And if not, have you seen these areas in other hospitals? Have you observed a sufficient number of different nurse practitioner patient interactions to say you see no indication of any philosophical difference between patient-provider interactions?
You and Hawkeye both continue to misinterpret what I've said, regardless of the clarifications I keep posting. Surely you recognize the different roles of physicians and nurses are going to result in different reactions to patients' autonomy?
Nowhere in my posts have I said, bad doctors, good nurses. There is no reason for any defensiveness distorting perceptions of what I posted.
Of course doctors are compassionate! Just as some nurses aren't. That has absolutely nothing to do with my point.
I was pointing out the difference in the worlds of each profession. If you don't think such basic differences in the philosophy established in the educational and professional milieu have any affect on patient-physician and patient-nurse interactions, then what is your reasoning? I'll say it again, this is not about skills, compassion, clearly divided philosophies, patient respect in either profession. Think of it more like two overlapping bell curves with slightly shifted peaks (or maybe moderately shifted in some cases).
Changing face of medical curricula,
2001
The focus of health care has shifted from episodic care of individuals in hospitals to promotion of health in the community, and from paternalism and anecdotal care to negotiated management based on evidence of effectiveness and safety.
You can't exactly change from paternalistic training unless it was the status quo originally.
Here's an extreme version:
Pediatrician Refuses To Treat Patient Because of Mom’s Tattoos
Hoover 18 Feb, 2007 Physicians, Off Beat News
Sound crazy? It is. A pediatrician has refused to treat a patient because the patient’s mother has tattoos. In fact, Dr. Gary Merrill has the following sign in his office:
“This is a private office. Appearance and behavior standards apply.”...
........ Tasha Childress’ response after Dr. Merrill refused to treat her daughter’s ear infection?
I felt totally discriminated against, like I wasn’t good enough to talk to, Tasha Childress said, like he didn’t have to give me any reason for not wanting to see my daughter because I have tattoos and piercings.
You would think that this guy was the only pediatrician in town. If patients aren’t happy with the services rendered, simply go see another doc.
Problem solved.
The author's attitude says a lot as well.
Paternalism is addressed in any number of medical ethics classes. It is approached differently now than years passed and it is approached differently in different settings and countries. But the fact there are so many classes and articles that address the issue speaks to its existence.
Dissecting Room, Conduct and Compassion - Non-compliance
Non-compliance is a value laden term, heavily weighted against the patient who, by definition, refuses to yield or conform to the doctor's advice. Because of the nature of their diseases, chronically ill patients are most likely to be labeled non-compliant. Indeed, they are often considered “problem patients” simply by virtue of their diagnoses.1 Without attempting to understand why patients won't or can't make lifestyle and other changes critical to their care, the physician-patient relationship becomes more adversarial than collaborative. ...
Of course most doctors are not going to come anywhere close to this description.
Compare that to this article which fully explores nursing treatment of non-compliance.
Therapeutic Compliance Posttransplantation – A Nurse’s Perspective; Research Studies for Measurement and Prediction of Compliance. Rather than a discussion of the potential for non-compliance to be an issue, it's a nursing diagnosis. It's our job to deal with it. How would this not result in at least some different practice philosophies between doctors and nurse practitioners? I actively promote patient autonomy. I've not seen many doctors do that.
Until you are the one holding the scalpel, your perspective will be different. You have already admitted that the medical evidence for elective circumcisions is equivocal. Well, taking the knife in your hand in the face of that fact can be more or less uncomfortable to the responsible physician. One group of docs will feel that uncertainty more profoundly than others and may decide that that is enough to opt out and refer to another provider, but both groups of docs will likely be equally-comfortable doing the same procedure were it medically-necessary. However, what we are debating is, at the end of the day, an elective procedure.
If you are simply describing your personal feelings with a difficult medical dilemma in terms of performing circs, fine. But if you are trying to tell me
I can't possibly understand this unless I've done circ procedures, I don't accept that at all.
You have no idea what practice experiences I've had. And you are making the false assumption that somehow my evaluation and perception of this matter are naive. I might suggest to you that unless you've tried futilely to revive an infant that has just succumbed to a respiratory infection or taken care of a 3 year old that is about to have all four limbs amputated from a meningococcal infection, that you can't empathize with my position.
But that would be stupid because I don't know what your experiences have been. It wouldn't bother me to perform a circ because I have no dilemma over doing circumcisions. And lots of NPs perform circs, BTW.
There's one big glaring problem here. For whatever reason, I read a repeating theme in these posts that there is some unanimous perception of the infection risk. I gave the example of the hypothetical parent who had lost a previous child to infection unrelated to any underlying medical condition. Experience affects beliefs and values.
How is such a parent wrong who finds the risk reduction of UTI a compelling reason in favor of circumcision?
If there is any situation when a doc opting out of a procedure should be understandable, it would be in this one. I would not approve of that physician discouraging the procedure, and he/she should be willing to refer to another who is willing to do it, but simply opting out is acceptable.
I don't want to be judgmental toward the physician who opts out any more than the parents who opt in. That wasn't the point.
It was the underlying assumptions about 'not medically indicated' I object to. In addition, I disagreed with Dr Hawk's perception that providing another provider respected the parent's views.
We are interpreting "respect" differently in this discussion. I interpret respect as recognizing different people have different values and those values are just as valid as anyone else's in this case. Dr H is interpreting it to mean she doesn't recognize those values, doesn't recognize why the parents' decision is just as legitimate as hers. Dr H instead made the
non-evidence based declaration, "there is no medical indication for a circumcision in a healthy infant" so if the parents want one, they are wrong, but I won't interfere.
She doesn't say, the parents have different values and are valuing prevention of UTI while I (DrH) value something else so I don't personally want to do the circumcision.
My point in arguing this matter concerns what I see (and it's very clear in my view) as distortions of the empirical evidence.
I see a failure of people to recognize that more than one value is legitimate in weighing the risk and benefit.
I don't understand what you mean with this question, so I will go back to why I posted what I did.
You wrote:
Originally Posted by skeptigirl
Due care does not mean personal morals never apply. Providers who chose to opt out of any abortion procedures as long as another provider can step in, is usually considered an acceptable standard of care. But once again, we encounter a continuum. Is it an appropriate standard of care for a provider with fundamentalist religious beliefs to apply his/her morals to patient care decisions? One argument from fundamentalists for teaching abstinence only is that the use of condoms is facilitating a sin. Better for the sinner to get HIV than for the provider to contribute to facilitating the sin. I don't think that moral position would meet very many people's standards of care.
I was describing one end of the continuum, not saying, 'refusing circs', was on that end.
Physicians who opt out of abortion procedures do not always do so out of "fundamentalist religious beliefs". The reasons why someone may are often much more complicated than that. It is what that person does after that fact that separates the fundamentalists from the others. Would a fundamentalist make available another physician who could help his/her patient obtain the procedure in question? I think not.
Re-read what I said. I bolded it for you. I said nothing about anti-abortion beliefs being "fundamentalist religious beliefs". I do however think pushing abstinence only education is reaching the fundamentalist end of the continuum of beliefs.
Again, opting out when someone else is available is acceptable. However, blocking access to it or opting out of a medically-necessary procedure when no one else is available is not.
I said nothing about acceptable practice. I don't agree with the denial of the equivocal medical evidence regarding circumcisions. It is not respecting the parent's choice if you cannot recognize they have just as much justification deciding the lowered risk of infection is more important to them than the questionable significance of the foreskin.
If you are willing to perform a circumcision for medically indicated reasons, but you are unwilling to accept the fact that there is a legitimate argument any circumcision can be viewed as medically indicated, then you are not looking objectively at the empirical evidence. You are applying weight to the value of your perceptions about the foreskin. You are not applying weight to the value of infection risk reduction. That's fine until you say the person who does value infection risk reduction more than you do, is wrong based on empirical evidence.
This is a values difference, not an evidence based difference. And the lack of evidence that the circumcision is as damaging as the emotional appeals would have one believe speaks to that.