Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Still can't find any evidence of men who've been left intact being 'socially harmed'.

A related question is how many men wish to change their status from intact to circumcised?

This relates to Linda's point about the parents trying to figure out what the child would want when it is older. They should be informed that most intact men do not opt to be circumcised.

Here's how I seen the future of infant circumcision:

When a vaccine becomes available for HIV, that reason will be gone.

When a preventative treatment for UTI's in girls (which will most likely be applicable to boys as well) is developed, that reason will disappear.

And when penile cancer is curable in most men, that won't be a significant advantage.

But I have a feeling that even when all these treatments have been developed, Americans will still be circumcising their boys.

Let's just hope they learn to insist on and use effective pain relief.

NB: I must say as a person who stutters, I think I know a thing or two about being 'socially harmed'. I find the idea of someone being 'socially harmed' because of an organ they themselves can elect to change at any time rather insulting:rolleyes:
 
I haven't read any of this looooong discussion, but:

Can anyone summarize the medical reasons that would require a circumcision, and their statistical prevalence among males?

Please also consider whether this said medical condition actually requires a full-scale circumcision. Perhaps an alternative operation would solve the problem and restore the body into its most natural and healthy state?

I somehow like the original design of nature. It's cool.
 
I haven't read any of this looooong discussion, but:

Can anyone summarize the medical reasons that would require a circumcision, and their statistical prevalence among males?

Tight foreskin (phimosis) is the most common reason. 0.6% of boys are medically indicated by the age of 15 for this.

There is evidence to suggest that circumcision reduces the incidence of Urinary Tract Infections (UTI's) in the developed world from 1% to 0.1%.

There is evidence that circumcision protects against penile cancer, which in the developed world has a lifetime risk of 1 in 600.

There is strong evidence to suggest that circumcision provides ~60% risk reduction of contracting HIV in areas of the world with high incidence of the disease.

Please also consider whether this said medical condition actually requires a full-scale circumcision. Perhaps an alternative operation would solve the problem and restore the body into its most natural and healthy state?

I somehow like the original design of nature. It's cool.

I don't think that's feasible. The only reason we know about the above is from looking at the incidence of disease in circumcised boys and/or men. How would you determine the optimal amount to cut off ethically?
 
I haven't read any of this looooong discussion, but:

Can anyone summarize the medical reasons that would require a circumcision, and their statistical prevalence among males?

Please also consider whether this said medical condition actually requires a full-scale circumcision. Perhaps an alternative operation would solve the problem and restore the body into its most natural and healthy state?

I somehow like the original design of nature. It's cool.

Circumcision is used to treat phimosis (foreskin doesn't retract fully) and paraphimosis (retracted foreskin cannot be returned to natural position) and to prevent balanitis (infection/inflammation of the head of the penis) - prevalence varies depending upon your criteria and which condition you are talking about, but a ballpark figure is less than 5%. Whether circumcision is required depends upon whether serious complications (urinary obstruction, problems with intercourse, recurrent infection) have developed from any of these conditions. Even then, if you are determined to save your foreskin, you probably can as there are alternative treatments. It depends upon how much discomfort/inconvenience you're willing to tolerate, too.

Linda
 
there are alternative treatments.
It just occurred to me that if I were a medical doctor, I probably would try to heal people's bodies, instead of amputating everything that does not seem to function properly.

Just an idea.
 
It just occurred to me that if I were a medical doctor, I probably would try to heal people's bodies, instead of amputating everything that does not seem to function properly.

Just an idea.

Yeah. I think if I were a concert pianist I would wear an evening dress instead of a tube top and shorts.

Linda
 
"There is strong evidence to suggest that circumcision provides ~60% risk reduction of contracting HIV in areas of the world with high incidence of the disease."
There's MORE evidence that proper condom use provides MUCH higher risk reduction....

I can't believe the hoops people are jumping through, trying to justify mutilating their male children.
 
"There is strong evidence to suggest that circumcision provides ~60% risk reduction of contracting HIV in areas of the world with high incidence of the disease."
There's MORE evidence that proper condom use provides MUCH higher risk reduction....

I can't believe the hoops people are jumping through, trying to justify mutilating their male children.

Yep, they do. Now all you have to do is get them to the men and women (only 1 in 5 couples have access to condoms in Africa) and get them to use them.
 
Last edited:
"There is strong evidence to suggest that circumcision provides ~60% risk reduction of contracting HIV in areas of the world with high incidence of the disease."
There's MORE evidence that proper condom use provides MUCH higher risk reduction....

I can't believe the hoops people are jumping through, trying to justify mutilating their male children.

It's my impression that most people in North America don't consider circumcision because of medical reasons, like reducing the risk of acquiring HIV. I've looked at a number of surveys and the most common reason seems to be "hygiene" followed by "tradition" and "father is circumcised". Medical reasons usually seem to be lower on the list.

Linda
 
"only 1 in 5 couples have access to condoms in Africa"
I'm not in charge of shipping.... I'm not even sure who is. Maybe ask "The Pope".... He seems to have an opinion on condom usage...

"the most common reason seems to be "hygiene"
Which has already been shot down as a very good reason in posts above....

"followed by "tradition" and "father is circumcised"
Traditions change... Hopefully for the better.... Because one person was mutilated sure is a DUMB reason to mutilate anyone else. It's a damn good thing we don't do the same when it comes to "Eat By Alligators"...
 
Last edited:
"only 1 in 5 couples have access to condoms in Africa"
I'm not in charge of shipping.... I'm not even sure who is. Maybe ask "The Pope".... He seems to have an opinion on condom usage...

"the most common reason seems to be "hygiene"
Which has already been shot down as a very good reason in posts above....

I suspect the vast majority of parents do not read the JREF forum, though. :)

I'm not sure how useful it is to re-iterate all these points here.

Linda
 
"I suspect the vast majority of parents do not read the JREF forum"
That aughta be classified as Child Neglect! ,-)
 
It's my impression that most people in North America don't consider circumcision because of medical reasons, like reducing the risk of acquiring HIV. I've looked at a number of surveys and the most common reason seems to be "hygiene" followed by "tradition" and "father is circumcised". Medical reasons usually seem to be lower on the list.

Linda

Or in the case of my father, his Jewish grandmother insisted.
 
"his Jewish grandmother insisted"
Now that's a spectacularly STUPID reason... if she wants someones penis chopped up, let her start with hers.
 
Most people in North America vaguely think that if you don't circumcise, there's a pretty good chance the penis will turn gangrenous and rot off. Upon hearing several times that it's not true, it turns to a vague notion of "lots of problems, then." I had to meet a lot of intact guys myself before I was able to shake those fuzzy ideas off. It's just an impression we form in childhood that's seen as a "fact"...like "the earth is round".

"Boys are cirumcised because, otherwise, their penises get lots of infections and it's really gross. So it has to be done."

All of the other "reasons" flow from that initial impression, in my opinion and experience.
 
It used to be same over in the UK but for some reason it rather quickly died away. My father was circumcised in the 1940s when it was apparently just routine, yet by the time I was born in the 60s it was no longer routine (but still not uncommon if not common).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom