Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

It's all coming back to me now, how the other two threads went and why I didn't come away convinced.
 
I don't know the reasons for adult circs were for religious conversions. I said that was the most common reason I was aware of.

Adult Circumcision; AFP
Medical indications for this procedure include phimosis, paraphimosis, recurrent balanitis and posthitis (inflammation of the prepuce). Nonmedical reasons may be social, cultural, personal or religious....Circumcision is performed on an estimated one out of six male newborns worldwide.1 Over 60 percent of male newborns were circumcised in the United States in 1992.2 Circumcision in adults is performed much less often; however, accurate statistics are not available. Adult patients often have a medical indication for the procedure, but circumcision may also be done for social or purely personal reasons.
 
Last edited:
Circumcision for Sexual Reasons
In Dr. Sharlip's experience, less than 5% of men who undergo circumcision do so for non-medical reasons. Some of these men are prompted by the request of their sexual partners or by expectations that being circumcised will provide enhanced feeling during sex. One 1997 study found that in comparison to circumcised men, uncircumcised men over 45 years of age are significantly more likely to lack enjoyment of sex, be anxious about their performance, and have difficulty maintaining erection. These differences were not present in younger men. No studies have compared mens’ sexual functioning before and after circumcision.
Since the statement, no studies compare function before and after, isn't correct, it's hard to say if the 5% is correct. Interesting though that men >45 are reported as having more trouble if uncircumcised. But again, hard to say if this is reliable. It must be something anecdotally reported by this treating physician.

I'm going to go walk my dogs. Back later.
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl said:
Resident doctors?
Didn't mean to offend you, Skeptigirl. Can you answer the question? If you performed an extremely painful surgery on an adult without pain relief, would the pain put them into shock and possible kill them? Would this be more likely to happen with an adult than an infant for some reason? I was under the impression that not that long ago, all kinds of surgeries were performed on infants without pain relief of any kind. The little I know about shock leads me to suspect that pain doesn't usually actually induce the state as a general rule, but honestly, I don't know much about it. I know when I was giving birth the thought crossed my mind that the pain should really have rendered me unconscious somehow. :)

I know you are not incapable of a medical literature review. Back up your claims then because I'm not sure you can.
Which ones?

As is so common with people not working in a particular medical field, it is very easy to underestimate risk. Anti-vaxers do it and you are doing it with your assumptions that pediatric UTIs are minor, rare and easily treated.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15890696

CONCLUSIONS: Circumcision reduces the risk of UTI. Given a risk in normal boys of about 1%, the number-needed-to-treat to prevent one UTI is 111. In boys with recurrent UTI or high grade vesicoureteric reflux, the risk of UTI recurrence is 10% and 30% and the numbers-needed-to-treat are 11 and 4, respectively. Haemorrhage and infection are the commonest complications of circumcision, occurring at rate of about 2%. Assuming equal utility of benefits and harms, net clinical benefit is likely only in boys at high risk of UTI.

Over 100 circumcisions to prevent ONE UTI??? Circumcision having no UTI benefit in the other 99-109 babies?
That's not me underestimating risk. That's realism to say that circumcision provides no medical benefit in an overwhelming majority of circumcised males.
Would you like to move onto the penis cancer stats now?


Skeptigirl said:
Does this really sound like no big deal? (Oh yeah, and be careful, it's easy to read febrile as female when you think mostly girls get UTIs.)

Mostly girls DO get UTIs.
http://www.emedicine.com/ped/topic2366.htm

During the first few months of life, the incidence of UTI in boys exceeds that in girls. By the end of the first year and thereafter, both first-time and recurrent UTIs are most common in girls.
 
Last edited:
#1- n/a
#2- doesn't say what the reason was.
#3- circumcised for "benign diseases"
#4- religion and cosmetic
#5- circumcised for foreskin problems
#6- doesn't say

What makes you think the "unknowns" were all adopting Judaism?


The evidence is all over the place. Do you want to count studies or something?
So having now looked at the reasons for the circs in the studies, it would seem that not all of the men had medical problems. And if you still think the studies are not relevant, then on what evidence are you basing the claim circs have such a great impact on men's (and women's for that matter) sexual pleasure?


I'll settle for a couple citations to start with:

Evidence UTIs are minor, rare, and easily treated?
Evidence that the studies of nerve tissue in the foreskin translates into significant impact on sexual function/pleasure when removed?

Oh, the resident DR thing didn't offend me. Expecting an appeal to authority was going to be convincing was the issue.
 
Last edited:
So, looking at that analysis
Circumcision was associated with a significantly reduced risk of UTI (OR = 0.13; 95% CI, 0.08 to 0.20; p<0.001) with the same odds ratio (0.13) for all three types of study design. CONCLUSIONS: Circumcision reduces the risk of UTI. Given a risk in normal boys of about 1%, the number-needed-to-treat to prevent one UTI is 111.
how did they determine the value of 111 circs to one UTI?

For example, one could measure deaths from UTIs. How many circs to prevent one death are reasonable?

While UTI was counted, did they include rates of complications and risks from procedures? Risks from just being hospitalized are significant. How many bleeding circs led to deaths? How many UTIs led to eventual kidney failure?

And do you think 1 of every 100 kids getting a UTI is rare? And, are those infants with "In boys with recurrent UTI or high grade vesicoureteric reflux" supposed to have a couple UTIs before circs are considered? How else would you know that was going to occur? That would make the kids with those problems likely to be self selected uncircumcised infants. How did they control for self selection in the analysis?
 
Last edited:
So, looking at that analysis how did they determine the value of 111 circs to one UTI?

For example, one could measure deaths from UTIs. How many circs to prevent one death are reasonable?

While UTI was counted, did they include rates of complications and risks from procedures? Risks from just being hospitalized are significant. How many bleeding circs led to deaths? How many UTIs led to eventual kidney failure?

http://www.emedicine.com/ped/topic2366.htm

Neonatal circumcision decreases the risk of UTI by about 90% in male infants during the first year of life. The risk of UTI in a circumcised infant is about 1 in 1000 during the first year, whereas an uncircumcised male infant has a 1 in 100 risk of developing a UTI. Given this risk, 111 healthy male infants must be circumcised to prevent 1 UTI. The risk and long-term effect of scarring due to 1 preventable UTI in a male infant are not known.

What percentage of UTI's lead to death? One in 10,000?

I wonder if "death by foreskin" affects child mortality in Europe in any calculable way?

And do you think 1 of every 100 kids getting a UTI is rare?
Yes.

And, are those infants with "In boys with recurrent UTI or high grade vesicoureteric reflux" supposed to have a couple UTIs before circs are considered?
Yes. I mean, you can't go around removing the sex organs of thousands of infants in an attempt to preventatively help the one or two with structural abnormalities, can you?

Skeptigirl said:
That would make the kids with those problems likely to be self selected uncircumcised infants. How did they control for self selection in the analysis?
The fulltext is free:

Data extraction
Randomised studies were assessed using the guidelines provided by the CONSORT statement.17 Aspects of study design including allocation concealment, blinding, follow up, outcome measurement, and analysis by intention to treat were assessed.

Quality assessment for observational studies was carried out using the guidelines provided by the MOOSE statement.18 The quality of studies identified was assessed according to the study setting, completeness and duration of follow up, validity and completeness of exposure and outcome ascertainment, comparability of the control group, and adjustment for known confounding variables.

ETA:

Skeptigirl said:
I'll settle for a couple citations to start with:

Evidence UTIs are minor, rare, and easily treated?

Minor:
http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/000521.htm

Expectations (prognosis)

Cystitis is uncomfortable, but usually responds well to treatment.

http://www.emedicine.com/ped/topic2366.htm

Mortality/Morbidity:

Mortality related to UTI is exceedingly rare for otherwise healthy children in developed countries.

Easily treated:

http://www.emedicine.com/ped/topic2366.htm

Antibiotics are used to treat urinary tract infection (UTI) and to prevent recurrences.

"Rare" is apparently in the eye of the beholder.

Skeptigirl said:
Oh, the resident DR thing didn't offend me. Expecting an appeal to authority was going to be convincing was the issue.
I was asking a question. I don't know if you've noticed, but you're the only pro-circer in this discussion providing any evidence at all and who's not just making things up. I honestly know nothing about shock, so if you'd answer the question, it would be nice. :)

(If it makes you feel better, I did attempt to look up the answer myself, but was unable to find it.)
 
Last edited:
Let me put this back in perspective. The first one is to keep in mind what we are talking about here. We are talking about risk/cost vs benefit of circumcisions. We are also talking about whether there is or is not overwhelming evidence one way or the other. My position has been throughout this thread, that the decision based on medical evidence is equivocal.

I have seen no overwhelming evidence that circumcisions are as devastating as is being made out here. The activists sites are even worse calling them amputations. While patient choice vs parent choice has some legitimacy, body integrity is a little more of a stretch since the only outcry one hears from adult circumcised males is from a vocal minority. (Prove otherwise and I'll correct that conclusion.)

At the same time that risk/cost is IMO being exaggerated (again, prove otherwise, I've posted my sources and reason innervation studies of the foreskin are not sufficient), the benefit is being understated.

Take kellyb in post #575 (I can't believe I'm still arguing this)
UTI's are:
1) Rare in boys, period. Circumcised or intact.
2)Easily treated

Penis cancer is:
A rather obscure form of cancer

FACT:
For an overwhelming majority of males, circumcision will provide no medical benefit.
Talking about "being in the eye of the beholder" is exactly what I have been.

The point here isn't if kellyb thinks a 1% prevalence of UTIs is rare, the point is can a parent not make that assessment on their terms? Does kellyb or Ivor or Dr Hawk get to say, "that's 'nothing'" to a parent who disagrees? Do they get to decide for the parent that circumcision is horrendous if the parent doesn't agree? You are going to tell a father who has never thought twice about his own circumcision that he should believe his son will be forever harmed by it? That would be reasonable if you had evidence and not merely anecdotal opinion to back that claim up.

I don't consider a 1% prevalence rare. In fact, it's darn common. 1 in 100,000 is rare. Measles kills one in a 1,000 cases. That's frightening. So there is an issue here of relative risk.

Mortality being rare is not the same as morbidity being rare. Death from complications which develop over years are not going to be included in death from UTI. Death from a nosocomial hospital acquired infection or a medical error are not doing to be recorded as a UTI death.

In addition, we have few new antibiotics in the pipeline and each new one developed is untested for serious risk. And they are never tested on kids until they've been on the market a while. No infection should be viewed as a minor issue as drug resistant bacteria out pace new antibiotics or if new antibiotics are not affordable to low income patients. Two recent pediatric patients in Seattle almost died from rapidly invasive strep after a minor injury, one lost a leg and the other is on his last of umpteenth facial reconstruction surgeries. More than one healthy child has died from community acquired antibiotic resistant infections. I do not view infection as a minor issue.

Urinary tract infections in children younger than 5 years of age: epidemiology, diagnosis, treatment, outcomes and prevention; 2001
Although the true incidence of urinary tract infections (UTIs) in children is difficult to estimate, they are one of the most common bacterial infections seen by clinicians who care for young children. Except for the first 8 to 12 weeks of life, when infection of the urinary tact may be secondary to a haematogenous source, UTI is believed to arise by the ascending route after entry of bacteria via the urethra. Enterobacteriaceae are the most common organisms isolated from uncomplicated UTI. Infection with Staphylococcus aureus is rare in children without in-dwelling catheters or other sources of infection, and coagulase-negative staphylococci and Candida spp. are associated with infections after instrumentation of the urinary tract. The diagnosis of UTI in young children is important as it is a marker for urinary tract abnormalities and, in the newborn, may be associated with bacteraemia. Early diagnosis is critical to preserve renal function of the growing kidney. A urine specimen for culture is necessary to document a UTI in a young child. Prior to culture, urinalysis may be useful to detect findings supporting a presumptive diagnosis of UTI. The goals of the management of UTI in a young child are: (i) prompt diagnosis of concomitant bacteraemia or meningitis, particularly in the infant; (ii) prevention of progressive renal disease by prompt eradication of the bacterial pathogen, identification of abnormalities of the urinary tract and prevention of recurrent infections; and (iii) resolution of the acute symptoms of the infection. Delay in initiation of the antibacterial therapy is associated with an increased risk of renal scarring. The initial choice of antibacterial therapy is based on the knowledge of the predominant pathogens in the patient's age group, antibacterial sensitivity patterns in the practice area, the clinical status of the patient and the opportunity for close follow-up. Imaging studies to detect congenital or acquired abnormalities are recommended following the first UTI in all children aged <6 years. Patients with significant urinary tract abnormalities and/or frequent symptomatic UTI may benefit from prophylactic antibacterials. The main long term consequence of UTI is renal scarring which may lead to hypertension and end-stage renal disease. Prevention of recurrent UTI focuses on detection, and correction if possible, of urinary tract abnormalities. Interventions that have been associated with a decrease in symptomatic UTI in children with a history of recurrent UTI include relief of constipation and voiding dysfunction.
Does that sound like no big deal to you kelly? Uncommon, no risk, as minor as a runny nose? Every first UTI is followed up with an invasive exam. EVERY ONE.

Here are the AAP practice recommendations for UTI in kids 2 months to 2 years. Practice parameter: the diagnosis, treatment, and evaluation of the initial urinary tract infection in febrile infants and young children. American Academy of Pediatrics. Committee on Quality Improvement. Subcommittee on Urinary Tract Infection.
Recommendation 1
The presence of UTI should be considered in infants and young children 2 months to 2 years of age with unexplained fever (strength of evidence: strong).

The prevalence of UTI in infants and young children 2 months to 2 years of age who have no fever source evident from history or physical examination is high, ;5%.4–8 The genders are not affected equally, however. The prevalence of UTI in febrile girls age 2 months to 2 years is more than twice that in boys (relative risk, 2.27).

The prevalence of UTI in girls younger than 1 year of age is 6.5%; in boys, it is 3.3%. The prevalence of UTI in girls between 1 and 2 years of age is 8.1%; in boys it is 1.9%. The rate in circumcised boys is low, 0.2% to 0.4%.9–13 The literature suggests that the rate in uncircumcised boys is 5 to 20 times higher than in circumcised boys.

Infants and young children are at higher risk than are older children for incurring acute renal injury with UTI. The incidence of vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) is higher in this age group than in older children (Fig 1), and the severity of VUR is greater, with the most severe form (with intrarenal reflux or pyelotubular backflow) virtually limited to infants. Infants and young children with UTI warrant special attention because of the opportunity to prevent kidney damage. Infants and young children with UTI warrant special attention because of the opportunity to prevent kidney damage. First, the UTI may bring to attention a child with an obstructive anomaly or severe VUR.

Second, because infants and young children with UTI may have a febrile illness and no localizing findings, there may be a delay in diagnosis and treatment of the UTI. Clinical and experimental data support the concept that delay in instituting appropriate treatment of acute pyelonephritis increases the risk of kidney damage.14,15 Third, the risk of renal damage increases as the number of recurrences increases16 (Fig 2).

Recommendation 3
If an infant or young child 2 months to 2 years of age with unexplained fever is assessed as being sufficiently ill to warrant immediate antimicrobial therapy, a urine specimen should be obtained by SPA or transurethral bladder catheterization; the diagnosis of UTI cannot be established by a culture of urine collected in a bag (strength of evidence: good). [A low risk procedure but cathing the kid can introduce organisms and sticking a needle in a kid's belly for a urine spec is never totally risk free.]

Recommendation 6
If the infant or young child 2 months to 2 years of age with suspected UTI is assessed as toxic, dehydrated, or unable to retain oral intake, initial antimicrobial therapy should be administered parenterally and hospitalization should be considered (strength of evidence: opinion/consensus).

Recommendation 7
In the infant or young child 2 months to 2 years of age who may not appear ill but who has a culture confirming the presence of UTI, antimicrobial therapy should be initiated, parenterally or orally (strength of evidence: good).

Recommendation 9
Infants and young children 2 months to 2 years of age, including those whose treatment initially was administered parenterally, should complete a 7- to 14-day antimicrobial course orally (strength of evidence: strong).

Recommendation 10
After a 7- to 14-day course of antimicrobial therapy and sterilization of the urine, infants and young children 2 months to 2 years of age with UTI should receive antimicrobials in therapeutic or prophylactic dosages until the imaging studies are completed (strength of evidence: good).

Recommendation 11
Infants and young children 2 months to 2 years of age with UTI who do not demonstrate the expected clinical response within 2 days of antimicrobial therapy should undergo ultrasonography promptly, and either voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) or radionuclide cystography (RNC) should be performed at the earliest convenient time. Infants and young children who have the expected response to antimicrobials should have a sonogram and either VCUG or RNC performed at the earliest convenient time (strength of evidence: fair).

VCUG; RNC
Either traditional contrast VCUG or RNC is recommended for detecting reflux. Although children may have pyelonephritis without reflux, the child with reflux is at increased risk of pyelonephritis and of scarring from UTI. With VCUG and RNC, a voiding phase is important because some reflux occurs only during voiding. If the predicted bladder capacity is not reached, the study may underestimate the presence or degree of reflux. VCUG with fluoroscopy characterizes reflux better than does RNC. In addition, RNC does not show
urethral or bladder abnormalities; for this reason, boys, whose urethra must be examined for posterior urethral valves, or girls, who have symptoms of voiding dysfunction when not infected, should have a standard fluoroscopic contrast VCUG as part of their initial studies.RNC has a lower radiation dose and therefore may be preferred in follow-up examinations of children with reflux. However, the introduction of low-dose radiographic equipment has narrowed the gap in radiation between the VCUG and RNC.50

There is no benefit in delaying performance of these studies as long as the child is free of infection and bladder irritability is absent. While waiting for reflux study results, the child should be receiving an antimicrobial, either as part of the initial treatment or as posttreatment prophylaxis (Table 5).

Radionuclide Renal Scans
Renal cortical scintigraphy (with 99 m Tc-DMSA or 99 m Tc-glucoheptonate) and enhanced computed tomography are very sensitive means of identifying acute changes from pyelonephritis or renal scarring. However, the role of these imaging modalities in the clinical management of the child with UTI still is unclear.
So here's a better description of that no big deal UTI.

If the parents don't bring the kid in soon enough he is likely to need IV antibiotics. He is going to be on oral antibiotics for another 1-2 weeks, but after that he is going to be on antibiotics until the radionuclide or a contrast [injected dye] and fluoroscopic exam are completed. And that is on every single first UTI in an infant to toddler.

So to add this up you have to add up the risk of those invasive procedures. I've worked in the bone marrow transplant units with kids with leukemia. I'm terribly concerned about radiation exposure to infants. I was upset my son had an unnecessary chest X-ray after delivery. If I were told a UTI would mean a certain fluoroscope or nuke med study on my infant if he got a UTI, I would need a lot of evidence that circ was such a big deal. And I would be disgusted with any physician who felt they had a right to judge those risks and benefits for my child.

I can also imagine a parent who had strong feelings about not circumcising their child might be offended by any provider who had strong feelings about the medical risks of not circumcising and made the parent feel they were putting their child at risk by not circumcising.

This is the parent's decision and respect means accepting that. There is not sufficient evidence one way or the other to say either decision is wrong. The committees of experienced physicians at both the AAP and the AAFP weighed this research and came to the same conclusion.
 
Last edited:
Charge? Did I miss something?

I didn't see anywhere that she implied the physician could be charged with anything. :confused: She's been talking about an ethical obligation, as far as I can tell, not a legal one.

Yep. When Linda was still talking to me, she mentioned she thought refusing this kind of treatment would open a physician to legal attack. I'll find the post if you want me to.
 
AAP said:
The prevalence of UTI in girls younger than 1 year of age is 6.5%; in boys, it is 3.3%. The prevalence of UTI in girls between 1 and 2 years of age is 8.1%; in boys it is 1.9%. The rate in circumcised boys is low, 0.2% to 0.4%.9–13 The literature suggests that the rate in uncircumcised boys is 5 to 20 times higher than in circumcised boys.

So:

a) Girls have a higher incidence of UTI than boys and they get treated with antibiotics.

b) Circumcision does not eliminate the risk in boys.

c) The number of children (male or female) who have serious complications if they get a UTI is small.

And from these facts, the learned physicians at the AAP deduced that this procedure is worth while doing if the parents want it done? What next, will they be recommending children’s hands are washed every 5 minutes?

Skeptigirl, I thought someone like you would be politically aware enough to see through this crap. It is blindingly obvious to me that they came to a conclusion that would not offend the American public. A rational evaluation of the evidence does not lead to the conclusion that circumcision provides a clinically significant benefit for the vast majority of patients. An NNT of ~100 for a rare, non life-threatening condition in the vast majority of people who contract it is ridiculous. Some people aren’t convinced a NNT of ~50 is good enough to fight HIV in Africa.

In the vast majority of patients all it raises are ethical problems for the physicians performing the procedure and society at large. By all means, keep on ignoring the ethical issues of parents physically modifying their children for such insignificant benefits. By the way, parents not only have rights, they also have responsibilities, which include respecting the child’s human rights.

European doctors must be laughing their socks off at their American colleagues.

You crazy Americans!

ETA: Check out this

ETA2: And what treatment is being considered to reduce the rate of UTI's in girls and can it be applied to boys?
 
Last edited:
Ivor, you are judging for everyone. What gives you the right to?

See through the crap of my hours of literature review? Excuse me?

ETA, that meta-a is no different than the Cochrane kelly cited. They probably reviewed some if not all of the same research.

I think I can say I made a more thorough evaluation of all aspects of this matter than anyone else here. Some of you have presented very little except anecdotally based beliefs and exaggerated risk over understated benefit. Not to mention continually mis-stating my position as pro circ when in reality it is pro-parental right to chose as no compelling medical evidence points one way or the other. The decision rests on risk perception and personal values and beliefs. If it rested on medical evidence, some of the arguments about provider choosing over parental choice would be reasonable. But no one here has proved one side outweighs the other. All you have is each of your personal opinions about which decision is correct. The tie breaker goes to the parents and I accept their choice with no qualms.

ETA, not everyone has been stating anecdotally supported opinions, some have been much more reasoned. And I don't claim to know what research anyone has reviewed that they haven't posted here.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by fls
I think that your behaviour is immaterial, except maybe to serve to emphasize your disagreement with the parents' choice. And this may be a good thing. I think ethical concerns can and should be a part of some discussions. But I am more interested in whether others understand and have given due consideration to the issues, than I am about whether we ultimately agree, because otherwise I worry that I am attempting to impose my own beliefs onto someone else. When you make a point of saying that you won't perform circumcisions for non-medical reasons, it could be taken as though you are allowing your beliefs to take priority over the beliefs of your patient's surrogate decision makers. What saves you is that the circumstances won't actually result in a denial of service, so it really just serves to somewhat quantify the strength of your disagreement. I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.

I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.

So you see no role for your own judgment in the care of your patients?

I was attempting to describe (obviously quite unsuccessfully :)) how I saw the role for my own judgment. I think it should be made clear to the patient and myself when my opinion is the result of personal bias rather than my medical judgment. And I think we should resist introducing our personal bias into medical decisions - that we give thoughtful consideration as to whether its appropriate, first.

I realize that the code of ethics of professional organizations in different countries differ in some interesting ways on the details. You're a physician, right? Where do you practice?

Linda
 
Charge? Did I miss something?

I didn't see anywhere that she implied the physician could be charged with anything. :confused: She's been talking about an ethical obligation, as far as I can tell, not a legal one.

I'm not going to look for it, but I did bring up the issue of the consequences of refusing treatment. It would rarely be criminal, though - more likely civil or professional. I just wanted to make the point that physicians don't generally have the right to refuse service without qualification. The details are relevant.

Linda
 
But you seem to be assuming that my 'belief' has something to do with something other than the medical necessity or value of the procedure. If another kind of 'belief' is involved, then the parents are free to seek out another provider.

It is my impression that if the same degree of benefit was conferred by an inoculation (some routine vaccinations confer less benefit than that of circumcision), you would not quibble over medical necessity - that it is the nature of the procedure that leads to the benefit that is the problem. And while the parents have decided that inaction will, on balance, lead to some harm to their infant (taking into consideration the list of factors that Skeptigirl outlined earlier), you disagree. I think we all agree that the majority of the reasons for perceived harm (in the parents) are cultural/religious, rather than medical. While there may be situations where the parents are persuaded by the presentation of the medical benefits, I suspect that most of the time, the parents are weighing harm (and both medical and social harms weigh the scale in favour of circumcision). And I think that you are considering medical harm, but not social/cultural harm. So I agree that your belief is based on medical necessity. I think the conflict with the parents comes about because their belief is based on more than that.

I don't understand what you mean by "left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves." I've said several times that I would never try and stop parents who really wanted it done, for whatever reason.

I understand that. My statement was meant to apply to the preceding statement "I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion."

Stated more directly - Is it appropriate for physicians to dismiss considerations of social harm in this situation specifically or generally?

But there's no way I have to do something just because someone wants it. What if it's a parent of a child who absolutely wants their kid's cold to be treated with antibiotics, because they "know it will help"? Is their 'belief' supposed to trump my training and knowledge that antibiotics don't help colds, that they're overprescribed, and that they confer a risk of side effects including anaphylaxis?

And is the fact that the parent can probably talk some other overworked doctor into writing the script supposed to convince me to just go ahead and give it anyway, because that's what their belief is and my judgment shouldn't trump theirs?

The difference with this situation is that this is essentially just a medical decision and they are basing their request on a misunderstanding. It is considered good medical practice to not provide antibiotics in this situation.

The standard of care with regards to circumcision in the US, is that physicians have recognized that cultural/religious issues are relevant when considering possible harm. Of course there is variation in the extent to which physicians agree with this practice. But in this case, to completely dismiss the relevance of social harm goes against standard medical practice. That is how I distinguish the two situations.

Linda
 
Ivor, you are judging for everyone. What gives you the right to?

80% of men world-wide? 90%+ of neonatal boys in European countries? The UN charter on human rights?

See through the crap of my hours of literature review? Excuse me?

No, through the politically sensitive statement that the AAP came out with.

ETA, that meta-a is no different than the Cochrane kelly cited. They probably reviewed some if not all of the same research.

And what was wrong with it? Over 400000 patients in the Cohort study, which determined the rates of UTI to be 1.1% in uncircumcised boys and 0.13% in circumcised boys.

Except for a randomized controlled trial, what is better than a Cohort study?

So, ignoring the totally ridiculous risk reduction of penile cancer (NNT > 600), this gives a NNT of 99. So you are ok with 99 children having their human rights violated for 1 of them to avoid a highly treatable condition?

That is some bias you have there, skeptigirl!

I think I can say I made a more thorough evaluation of all aspects of this matter than anyone else here. Some of you have presented very little except anecdotally based beliefs and exaggerated risk over understated benefit. Not to mention continually mis-stating my position as pro circ when in reality it is pro-parental right to chose as no compelling medical evidence points one way or the other. The decision rests on risk perception and personal values and beliefs. If it rested on medical evidence, some of the arguments about provider choosing over parental choice would be reasonable. But no one here has proved one side outweighs the other. All you have is each of your personal opinions about which decision is correct. The tie breaker goes to the parents and I accept their choice with no qualms.

The argument is that all people are afforded the same human rights, whether they can speak or understand them. In the case of parents and physicians, they should be made aware of or already know what the child's rights are.

A non-reversible physical alteration is a violation of those rights, unless not performing the circumcision is likely to violate the child's right to life or health. The evidence from the cohort study suggests that circumcision is only appropriate if the estimated risk of the child contracting a UTI (~1% for normal children) is greater than the risk of complications from the circumcision (~2%). It is not.

But if there is a history of UTI for the child then circumcision would probably be indicated. Even here, some physicians who specialize in UTI disagree, since the causes of the particular UTI might not be caused by bacteria entering the urinary tract via the opening of the urethra.

The decision to circumcise should be made on a case-by-case basis, with the child protected from unsupportable whims of its parents.

ETA, not everyone has been stating anecdotally supported opinions, some have been much more reasoned. And I don't claim to know what research anyone has reviewed that they haven't posted here.

No, I have not. You either believe every individual has human rights or you don't. As I said earlier, if a person believes that parents’ choice is supreme then it is pointless arguing with them about this.
 
I've been a nurse practitioner for >20 years. While I haven't done circs, I think I think I'm qualified judge. So I'm really not sure what you mean.


Does that make you qualified to generalize repeatedly about the differences between nurses and docs? My training emphasized patient-centered care and shared decision making, and my medical school was by no means unique. These principles are central to the care provided in my hospital, as well. Certainly, not every doc practices this way, but, by no means do all nurses behave in a manner that I would consider as advocates for patients. When you continually repeat the same claims about nurses being patient advocates and docs being paternalistic or controlling, you compromise your credibility with some of us.

Until you are the one holding the scalpel, your perspective will be different. You have already admitted that the medical evidence for elective circumcisions is equivocal. Well, taking the knife in your hand in the face of that fact can be more or less uncomfortable to the responsible physician. One group of docs will feel that uncertainty more profoundly than others and may decide that that is enough to opt out and refer to another provider, but both groups of docs will likely be equally-comfortable doing the same procedure were it medically-necessary. However, what we are debating is, at the end of the day, an elective procedure.

If there is any situation when a doc opting out of a procedure should be understandable, it would be in this one. I would not approve of that physician discouraging the procedure, and he/she should be willing to refer to another who is willing to do it, but simply opting out is acceptable.

And what does defining fundamentalism have to do with a fundamentalist imposing radical moral beliefs on others?

I don't understand what you mean with this question, so I will go back to why I posted what I did.

You wrote:

Due care does not mean personal morals never apply. Providers who chose to opt out of any abortion procedures as long as another provider can step in, is usually considered an acceptable standard of care. But once again, we encounter a continuum. Is it an appropriate standard of care for a provider with fundamentalist religious beliefs to apply his/her morals to patient care decisions? One argument from fundamentalists for teaching abstinence only is that the use of condoms is facilitating a sin. Better for the sinner to get HIV than for the provider to contribute to facilitating the sin. I don't think that moral position would meet very many people's standards of care.


Physicians who opt out of abortion procedures do not always do so out of "fundamentalist religious beliefs". The reasons why someone may are often much more complicated than that. It is what that person does after that fact that separates the fundamentalists from the others. Would a fundamentalist make available another physician who could help his/her patient obtain the procedure in question? I think not.

Again, opting out when someone else is available is acceptable. However, blocking access to it or opting out of a medically-necessary procedure when no one else is available is not.

I was attempting to describe (obviously quite unsuccessfully :)) how I saw the role for my own judgment. I think it should be made clear to the patient and myself when my opinion is the result of personal bias rather than my medical judgment. And I think we should resist introducing our personal bias into medical decisions - that we give thoughtful consideration as to whether its appropriate, first.

I realize that the code of ethics of professional organizations in different countries differ in some interesting ways on the details. You're a physician, right? Where do you practice?

Linda


I understand. :)

You're right. We ALL need to be vigilant about avoiding inserting bias, but, if we cannot in certain situations, we need to be honest with ourselves and our patients when our advice may be colored by personal beliefs or experiences. That's when it is appropriate to get someone else involved. That is being human, but that is also being a responsible physician, one who ensures that your patients' needs are being met even if you may not be able to meet them personally.

There is a difference between using one's judgment in the care of one's patients and judging one's patients and their decisions and imposing one's own agenda on them.

If the evidence that we use in medicine, or the literature, as it were, were so black and white, our jobs would be far easier. When there is overwhelming support for something, that's ideal, but not everything is so clear-cut. The issue is that any study has its strengths and weaknesses, contradictory findings in the literature abound, and it is often up to us to interpret the evidence and apply it as best we can.

I practice in New England. How 'bout you?
 
Stated more directly - Is it appropriate for physicians to dismiss considerations of social harm in this situation specifically or generally?

Linda

If there was a significant number of uncircumcised men in the culture who were "socially harmed" (the mind boggles) by being left intact, then no, it would not be.

Is there a web site for these men? I can't find one.
 
Last edited:
You're right. We ALL need to be vigilant about avoiding inserting bias, but, if we cannot in certain situations, we need to be honest with ourselves and our patients when our advice may be colored by personal beliefs or experiences. That's when it is appropriate to get someone else involved. That is being human, but that is also being a responsible physician, one who ensures that your patients' needs are being met even if you may not be able to meet them personally.

Yes. And I alluded to this earlier - if your own bias will impair your ability to provide the best care, it is better to involve a different physician.

There is a difference between using one's judgment in the care of one's patients and judging one's patients and their decisions and imposing one's own agenda on them.

If the evidence that we use in medicine, or the literature, as it were, were so black and white, our jobs would be far easier. When there is overwhelming support for something, that's ideal, but not everything is so clear-cut. The issue is that any study has its strengths and weaknesses, contradictory findings in the literature abound, and it is often up to us to interpret the evidence and apply it as best we can.

And I think that is where even just making our biases explicit helps keep interpretations as objective as possible.

I practice in New England. How 'bout you?

I have practiced in the US and Canada, but mostly in Canada. And my ethics have been most strongly influenced by the five principles of the Canada Health Act and the Canadian Medical Association's Code of Ethics, which promote a greater responsibility to the patient and includes recognition of the contribution of the community and society to health. And I do see subtle differences in physician attitudes, although of course I have no idea how representative my observations are.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom