Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Doesn't circumcision stop masterbation?
I heard that it is so popular because people think it does, however I haven't seen any evidence for it.

Well, it was once thought that:

And Yet Another Reason?

It was once believed that circumcision would prevent masturbation, as stated earlier, that was in the 1800s when masturbation was not looked upon as a healthy thing to be doing. Circumcision does not prevent masturbation or increase fertility. The belief that circumcision enhances the sexual experience for men or for their sexual partners may not necessarily be true, either. I can't confirm or deny this as I wasn't born with a penis, but many men have written in to say that they believe they are more 'sensitive' because of having a foreskin.

Source
 
Luckily, Australia is reconsidering circumcision, thanks to the HIV studies. And thanks to the plastibell method, circumcision is painless and almost error-free.

(BTW, yeah, masturbation should be taught to young children (in a purely textbook, hands-off approach) fairly early on, around puberty. It is quite beneficial, actually.)
 
Oh, I forgot to post this from my link :p . It is actually very interesting:

Cancer Risk?

It is widely and falsely believed that uncircumcised men stand a greater risk of penile cancer. A big surprise to many in the medical community.

In March of 1999, the American Academy of Pediatrics revised its circumcision policy statement and concluded that there is not sufficient data to support the supposed potential health benefits of circumcision. The organization no longer advocates routine neonatal circumcision.

Here is part of that press release from March 1, 1999, 5 p.m. (ET) Below is a highlight of the policy published in the March issue of Pediatrics, the peer-reviewed, scientific journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), if you care to see what they determined.

CHICAGO - After analysis of almost 40 years of available medical research on circumcision, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) issued new recommendations today stating that the benefits are not significant enough for the AAP to recommend circumcision as a routine procedure.

The new policy statement was published in this month's issue of Pediatrics, the journal of the AAP. “Circumcision is not essential to a child's well-being at birth, even though it does have some potential medical benefits. These benefits are not compelling enough to warrant the AAP to recommend routine newborn circumcision. Instead, we encourage parents to discuss the benefits and risks of circumcision with their pediatrician, and then make an informed decision about what is in the best interest of their child,” says Carole Lannon, M.D., MPH, FAAP, chair of the AAP's Task Force on Circumcision. The policy concluded, however, that it is legitimate for parents to take into account cultural, religious and ethnic traditions, in addition to medical factors, when making this decision. It states that to make an informed choice, parents of all male infants should be given accurate information and be provided the opportunity to discuss this decision with their pediatrician.”

I agree with the bolded.

However, I personally disagree with doing it for cultural, religious, or ethnic reasons. Damn culture *shakes fist* :mad: .
 
I'm amazed after reading Linda's posts that the wishes of parents for unnecessary medical treatment of their children is such a difficult (and potentially risky) thing for a physician to say no to.

I wonder what the charge against a physician could actually be for refusing to perform a circumcision when it was not medically indicated?

Charge? Did I miss something?

I didn't see anywhere that she implied the physician could be charged with anything. :confused: She's been talking about an ethical obligation, as far as I can tell, not a legal one.
 
I don't think you can be charged, per se, for refusing treatment. Some nurses have been (IMHO) wrongly fired for giving their opinions to the parents, or refusing to take part in the process... but I don't think refusing treatment is considered a criminal or civil offense.

But these days, who knows? People sue each other over their own stupidity.

ETA: If there's anyone that needs to have charges brought up, it's the pharmacists who are refusing to sell birth control to their customers.
 
And Morri, the claimed uses of the foreskin are completely unconvincing. Having never had one, I've never had any problems from not having one; and I value my personal experience in this matter over these far-reaching attempts to justify keeping the foreskin.
Personal experience trumps the big picture. Interesting.

As for the earlobes issue, sure. Earlobes are unnecessary. If your culture finds their removal to be more attractive, great.
I see. What if I'm actually living in North America, where no one else has cut off earlobes. My child will look funny to the others. But it's part of my culture where I was born or some crap like that. Still think it's a good idea?

Personally, I think unless you've been circumcised, you have no place discussing circumcision.

:D
How convenient... eliminate different viewpoints. But will you stay out of any abortion topic, then?

There you go, trying to insert your erroneous opinion again. I'd say the benifits of circumcision are neither small, nor obscure, nor theoretical.
:newlol Genius!
Why is his opinion erroneous? We can say the same thing about yours.

And do you honestly think that a risk of HIV doesn't exist in developed countries?
Oh please, do you honestly think that circumcision will prevent AIDS for a North American? Do you really think that American males as a whle would have more HIV infections if it weren't for circumcision? (If so, provide evidence please, kthxbye)
The only way it can "help", is if the man is having unprotected sex with an HIV-positive partner. Yeah, good plan of action right there.

Good. The first doctor to perform circumcision on one of my children advised that circumcision is an excellent preventative to infection, disease, and hygeine issues.
But that's not even true! :newlol
 
There you go, trying to insert your erroneous opinion again. I'd say the benifits of circumcision are neither small, nor obscure, nor theoretical.

What exactly are the benefits of circumcision? I know there is a small reduction in UTI's in circ'd boys but really, boys don't really suffer from UTI's, girls do more usually. UTI's are very easily treated with antibiotics. Surely this is not held up as a "benefit" of circumcision:confused:

Why do people think circumcised penis are "cleaner"? If you wash, you are clean. It isn't hard to wash a penis in the shower. This seems a silly argument to me?

There seems to be so many complications that can arise from circumcision...adhesions seem to be very common, with most circ'd infants suffering. Also phimosis, metal stenosis, dead penis, missing frenulum.and a lot more. There are pictures here. (ww w.circu mcisionquotes.com/complic ations.html) (You have to c+p, I can't post links yet)

I just don't get why a parent would put an otherwise healthy infant at risk of any of this. I am not seeing any benefits to being circumcised? What are they? Can't the child decide for themselfs as an adult if they want to be?

If the circ rate is only around 40-60% in the US right now (dpending on state, far as I can tell from googling) then the "look like daddy/same as boys at school argument doesn't work either. Actually the "look like daddy" argument makes me lol...no child's penis is going to "look like daddys", circ'd or not..you'd have to cut off all the hair first!:p

It is cosmetic surgery. Why do people put day old babies through that? I have seen the aftermath of circumcision once. It was a jewish baby.( which I can understand the reasoning for) Three days after it was done it was stil raw...he cried every time he peed. It looked so painful. I can't even imagine what it was like being done:(
 
Last edited:
.....I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.

I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.

Linda
Clearly you understand what I am talking about.

If our position is justifiable, then unbiased information we give the parents should support our position. If on the other hand we don't recognize where evidence based medicine ends and personal moral decisions begin, then we won't recognize and therefore cannot respect the parents' moral decisions. What one person views as important, another may view as unimportant. And evidence based medicine cannot empirically determine the value of importance to assign decision criteria. And here is where a health care provider, I think, has a duty to maintain due care in applying personal morals to determine the importance of various criteria when drawing conclusions.

(Again, this differs from taking a position against a parent/patient decision based in ignorance or misinterpretation of facts and evidence. That is where one does not compromise and one's expertise applies.)

Due care does not mean personal morals never apply. Providers who chose to opt out of any abortion procedures as long as another provider can step in, is usually considered an acceptable standard of care. But once again, we encounter a continuum. Is it an appropriate standard of care for a provider with fundamentalist religious beliefs to apply his/her morals to patient care decisions? One argument from fundamentalists for teaching abstinence only is that the use of condoms is facilitating a sin. Better for the sinner to get HIV than for the provider to contribute to facilitating the sin. I don't think that moral position would meet very many people's standards of care.

A circumcision decision is not a black and white decision. It is a continuum decision. That is getting lost in this discussion. On this continuum people are drawing the line in different places where risk/cost and benefit intersect.

I listed a number of values which affect where one draws the line. Different values are assigned, but not limited to, such things as:

* Religion and beliefs about right and wrong.

* The child's self esteem in the grade school locker room.

* Health.

* The child's right to choose.

* The child's right to 'body integrity'.

* Risk perception.

* Beliefs about the affects on sexual pleasure.


If a parent were having the child circumcised because of religious beliefs, I don't think they'd have the same reaction to a provider referring them to someone else as in other situations. That meets an acceptable standard of care.

Right to choose and body integrity is another matter. This is a gray area of provider's moral beliefs vs parent's moral beliefs including the moral belief of whose decision and whose morals apply. This is the area where I feel the strongest about leaving my moral beliefs out of the decision. You could argue you were advocating for the patient, but then you are saying you have the right to apply your beliefs and the parents do not have the right to apply theirs.

However, it has been stated that the argument of body integrity and right to choose don't override medical necessity. This at the same time one is claiming the right of the parents to apply their beliefs regarding right to choose and body integrity does not override the right of the provider to apply his/her beliefs about body integrity and right to choose. So what is the provider's actual moral belief resting on here? I suggest it is resting on the provider's personal values being applied to risk/cost vs benefit, and not directly on body integrity and right to choose. It isn't the infant's right to choose if the decision is made for 'medical reasons'.

But the provider's personal values are affecting the conclusions from evidence based medicine about where the line is drawn in favor of medical benefit over risk/cost. The reason for the position of the AAP and the AAFP is that the medical benefit of circumcision is not zero, and opinions differ as to when the cost/risk clearly overrides that benefit.

If the value assigned to the affect on sexual pleasure is exaggerated above the evidence due to emotional factors, that could be a problem.

If the benefit of UTI prevention is being discounted without a neutral evaluation of the evidence, that could be a problem.

If the parent's risk perception of UTIs differs from the provider for legitimate reasons then whose risk perception applies to the decision?

As an evidence based provider, I need more than emotional testimony the sexual pleasure is affected as greatly as is being claimed. If such evidence exists and I provide that to the parents, I should be able to support my position. If I am acting on that emotional reaction, then I'm deciding my moral opinion overrides the parent's and that, IMO, is overstepping my role as a provider.
 
Now come on skeptigirl, they weren't insults, just provocatitve statements:D
It's my mission to point out fallacious debate tactics. ;)

Circumcision of a healthy infant is not an evidence based decision. It’s a whim.
According to Dr Ivor, who has the expertise to evaluate and has read extensively all the medical literature in this area. I did read extensively on this topic, BTW, gathering information to discuss the issues in these three very long debates. If you go back through my posts in this thread, I believe I cited ~80% of what I read. I have not seen anything supporting "it's a whim". Care to point me in that direction with something besides blogs on an activist web site. I'll take cited research from the cites, but not emotional appeal.

What about putting yourself in the position of each person being affected by the decision. Can you put yourself in the position of the infant? Using your adult reasoning and knowledge that this procedure is not required and is going to hurt you (to a greater or lesser extent), would choose to have it performed on you?...

Thanks for your answer. The caveat of ‘not in this case’ implies there are situations where you think a child does have the right to body integrity. Could you give some examples where you think this right for the child should be supported over parent’s wishes?...

My reasoning (putting myself in each individual’s position) leads me to the conclusion that the procedure should be performed....
I've thoroughly addresses all of this. Could you read my last 3 longer posts again and see if you don't understand the risk-benefit decision making continuum a little better?

Yes, pro-infant circumcision people do go on and on and on about the fact that circumcised boys have a lower incidence of UTI’s. If they also then take action to avoid all other similar magnitude risks for their child then at least they are being consistent. I bet they don’t though.
I don't think the medical literature agrees with you.

Again, put yourself in the position of the child. You know that studies have shown that being circumcised has a small benefit for contracting a UTI. You know that the risk is extremely small of you contracting a UTI in the first place. You know that circumcision is not 100% effective for preventing UTI. You know that a UTI can be treated with antibiotics successfully in the vast majority of cases. I think anyone who chose to have an irreversible medical procedure for that level of benefit would need serious psychological treatment (such as for OCD hand-washing) for their perception of risk, don’t you?
Have you shown that the loss of sexual pleasure is as great as is emotionally claimed? Have you filtered out all the emotional chafe that is mixed in with the evidence?

Stop with the parents! They and the physician should be advocating for the child, i.e. putting themselves in the position of the child.
It's called parental rights, Ivor. It is after all one of our cultural values.

Actually, I had only an incy-wincy bit of doubt. That’s why I put that (and other provocative statements) in. I know, I’m a pri*k:D
It's called risk/cost - benefit analysis. Trouble is there is no magic marker saying "the line is here".

The CD comes from you supporting the child’s rights in one situation and parent’s rights in another when they equivalent situations.
You are referring to a moral dilemma, not cognitive dissonance. Cognitive refers to 'thinking' whereas morals are more tied to emotions or 'feelings'.

No sarcasm or insult intended, just trying to clarify that the one piece of evidence that does not seem to get mentioned much (in this kind of debate) is what the assessment of an individual child’s condition is.
Not true.
 
I don't think you can be charged, per se, for refusing treatment. Some nurses have been (IMHO) wrongly fired for giving their opinions to the parents, or refusing to take part in the process... but I don't think refusing treatment is considered a criminal or civil offense.

But these days, who knows? People sue each other over their own stupidity.

ETA: If there's anyone that needs to have charges brought up, it's the pharmacists who are refusing to sell birth control to their customers.
Actually, there is a law against abandoning the patient. It applies to nursing. And laws have been enacted that if you are going to refuse certain care related to abortions, another provider must be available. That came up recently with pharmacists who refused to fill prescriptions for "the morning after" type birth control pills.

No physician is obligated to provide particular services, you can't discriminate against certain patients but no one says you have to provide circumcisions. That makes no sense.
 
So, about that evidence. From the activist web sites (not that activists sites are never valid sources of information) one finds mostly citations of studies on the nerve supply to the foreskin. These are cited as strong evidence the removal of the foreskin is a travesty.

You have to take such evidence a step further. The outcome you want to look at is the effect on the person, not the evidence for the mechanism of action. So showing loss of sensitive tissue is one thing, whether it matters is another.

here is the PubMed search for, "effect of circumcision on sexual function". These were all the relevant studies the search gave, not cherry picked studies, except those without abstracts and those were mostly correspondence re these papers. The search returned 13 citations. I also left out a couple that were related to HIV rather than sexual effects.

Sensation and sexual arousal in circumcised and uncircumcised men.
METHODS: Twenty uncircumcised men and an equal number of age-matched circumcised participants underwent genital and nongenital sensory testing at baseline and in response to erotic and control stimulus films. Touch and pain thresholds were assessed on the penile shaft, the glans penis, and the volar surface of the forearm. Sexual arousal was assessed via thermal imaging of the penis. RESULTS: In response to the erotic stimulus, both groups evidenced a significant increase in penile temperature, which correlated highly with subjective reports of sexual arousal. Uncircumcised men had significantly lower penile temperature than circumcised men, and evidenced a larger increase in penile temperature with sexual arousal. No differences in genital sensitivity were found between the uncircumcised and circumcised groups. Uncircumcised men were less sensitive to touch on the forearm than circumcised men. A decrease in overall touch sensitivity was observed in both groups with exposure to the erotic film as compared with either baseline or control stimulus film conditions. No significant effect was found for pain sensitivity. CONCLUSION: These results do not support the hypothesized penile sensory differences associated with circumcision. However, group differences in penile temperature and sexual response were found.

The effect of male circumcision on sexuality
OBJECTIVE: To prospectively study, using a questionnaire, the sexuality of men circumcised as adults compared to uncircumcised men, and to compare their sex lives before and after circumcision. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: The study included 373 sexually active men, of whom 255 were circumcised and 118 were not. Of the 255 circumcised men, 138 had been sexually active before circumcision, and all were circumcised at >20 years of age. As the Brief Male Sexual Function Inventory does not specifically address the quality of sex life, questions were added to compare sexual and masturbatory pleasure before and after circumcision. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in sexual drive, erection, ejaculation, and ejaculation latency time between circumcised and uncircumcised men. Masturbatory pleasure decreased after circumcision in 48% of the respondents, while 8% reported increased pleasure. Masturbatory difficulty increased after circumcision in 63% of the respondents but was easier in 37%. About 6% answered that their sex lives improved, while 20% reported a worse sex life after circumcision. CONCLUSION: There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings.
So here you have the conclusion leaving out the results of what didn't happen and emphasizing only the negative. In addition, if 20% reported their sex life worse and only 6% reported it improved, then the vast majority reported it unchanged or they didn't comment. So tell me where in this abstract is the conclusion sexual enjoyment decreased! Half said masturbating was less fun. I find the conclusion as stated in this abstract to be biased. But judge for yourselves. I do think it reinforces the conclusion emotions are affecting evaluation of the effects.

Penile sensitivity and sexual satisfaction after circumcision: are we informing men correctly?
OBJECTIVES: Currently no consensus exists about the role of the foreskin or the effect circumcision has on penile sensitivity and overall sexual satisfaction. Our study assesses the effect of circumcision on sexually active men and the relative impact this may have on informed consent prior to surgery. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred and fifty men between the ages of 18 and 60 years were identified as being circumcised for benign disease between 1999 and 2002. Patients with erectile dysfunction were excluded from the study. The data was assessed using the abridged, 5-item version of the International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF-5). Questions were also asked about libido, penile sensitivity, premature ejaculation, pain during intercourse and appearance before and after circumcision. IIEF-5 data was analysed using two-tailed paired t test to compare pre-operative and post-operative score changes across the study group. For the rest of the questions, data was analysed using 'Sign Test', calculating two-sided p values and 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: Fifty-nine percent of patients (88/150) responded. The total mean IIEF-5 score was 22.41 +/- 0.94 and 21.13 +/- 3.17 before and after circumcision, respectively (p = 0.4). Seventy-four percent of patients had no change in their libido levels, 69% noticed less pain during intercourse (p < 0.05), and 44% of the patients (p = 0.04) and 38% of the partners (p = 0.02) thought the penis appearance improved after circumcision. Penile sensation improved after circumcision in 38% (p = 0.01) but got worse in 18%, with the remainder having no change. Overall satisfaction was 61%. CONCLUSIONS: Penile sensitivity had variable outcomes after circumcision. The poor outcome of circumcision considered by overall satisfaction rates suggests that when we circumcise men, these outcome data should be discussed during the informed consent process. 2005 S. Karger AG, Basel
Here where 61% were satisfied overall they call that a 'poor outcome'. Obviously accurate informed consent is valid. I think you have to look at what "overall satisfaction" meant to the respondents since the results in the abstract do not clearly support the overall satisfaction rates support a "poor outcome" In this report you need the rest of the results to assess the validity of the author's conclusions.

Circumcision in adults: effect on sexual function.
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effects of adult circumcision on sexual function in men circumcised only for religious or cosmetic reasons. METHODS: The study group consisted of 42 male patients with a median age of 22.3 years (range 19 to 28) referred for circumcision from June 2002 to January 2003. Of the 42 men, 39 desired circumcision for religious reasons. Before circumcision, their sexual performance was evaluated using the Brief Male Sexual Function Inventory (BMSFI) and ejaculatory latency time. The BMSFI evaluation and ejaculatory latency time measurements were repeated after a postoperative interval of at least 12 weeks. The scores in the five main sections of the BMSFI and the ejaculatory latency times before and after circumcision were analyzed. RESULTS: The differences in the mean BMSFI scores were not statistically significant in any of the five sections. However, the mean ejaculatory latency time was significantly longer after circumcision (P = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Adult circumcision does not adversely affect sexual function. The increase in the ejaculatory latency time can be considered an advantage rather than a complication

Adult circumcision outcomes study: effect on erectile function, penile sensitivity, sexual activity and satisfaction.
PURPOSE: Evidence concerning the effect of circumcision on sexual function is lacking. Men circumcised as adults are potentially in a unique position to comment on the effect of a prepuce on sexual intercourse. We examine sexual function outcomes in men who have experienced sexual intercourse in the uncircumcised and circumcised states. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Men 18 years old or older when circumcised were identified by billing records during a 5-year period at an academic medical center. Medical charts were reviewed for confirmation of the procedure and to identify the indication(s). These men were surveyed to assess erectile function, penile sensitivity, sexual activity and overall satisfaction. Data were analyzed using paired t tests to compare category scores before and after circumcision. RESULTS: A total of 123 men were circumcised as adults. Indications for circumcision included phimosis in 64% of cases, balanitis in 17%, condyloma in 10%, redundant foreskin in 9% and elective in 7%. The response rate was 44% among potential responders. Mean age of responders was 42 years at circumcision and 46 years at survey. Adult circumcision appears to result in worsened erectile function (p = 0.01), decreased penile sensitivity (p = 0.08), no change in sexual activity (p = 0.22) and improved satisfaction (p = 0.04). Of the men 50% reported benefits and 38% reported harm. Overall, 62% of men were satisfied with having been circumcised. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings may help urologists better counsel men undergoing circumcision as adults. Prospective studies are needed to better understand the relationship between circumcision and sexual function.

Effects of circumcision on male sexual function: debunking a myth?
PURPOSE: Claims of superior sexual sensitivity and satisfaction for uncircumcised males have never been substantiated in a prospective fashion in the medical literature. We performed such a study to investigate these assertions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The Brief Male Sexual Function Inventory (BMSFI) was administered to sexually active males older than 18 years before undergoing circumcision. After a minimum interval of 12 weeks after the operation, the survey was again administered. The 5 domains of the BMSFI (sexual drive, erections, ejaculation, problem assessment overall satisfaction) were each given a summed composite score. These scores before and after circumcision were then analyzed by Wilcoxon signed-rank testing. RESULTS: All 15 men who participated in the study between September 1999 and October 2000 were available for followup. Mean patient age plus or minus standard deviation was 36.9 +/- 12.0 years. There was no statistically significant difference in the BMFSI composite scores of reported sexual drive (p >0.68), erection (p >0.96), ejaculation (p >0.48), problem assessment (p >0.53) or overall satisfaction (p >0.72). CONCLUSIONS: Circumcision does not appear to have adverse, clinically important effects on male sexual function in sexually active adults who undergo the procedure.

As I said, there's a lot of emotion on this topic that is detracting from the actual evidence. Were I practicing in general pediatrics, I'd most certainly read these studies in full.
 
Last edited:
Being uncomfortable doing something does not make one a fundamentalist.

Evidence is not always clear-cut - a responsible provider must use his/her judgment in evaluating the quality of available evidence.

It is very easy to judge when one is not the person doing the procedure in question.
 
Skeptigirl, most of those studies are using men who were circumcised because of medical reasons.

Skeptigirl said:
So here you have the conclusion leaving out the results of what didn't happen and emphasizing only the negative. In addition, if 20% reported their sex life worse and only 6% reported it improved, then the vast majority reported it unchanged or they didn't comment. So tell me where in this abstract is the conclusion sexual enjoyment decreased! Half said masturbating was less fun. I find the conclusion as stated in this abstract to be biased. But judge for yourselves. I do think it reinforces the conclusion emotions are affecting evaluation of the effects.

If they were circumcised because of problems with their foreskins/penises...wouldn't you expect a lot more to report an improvement...not a worsening?
 
Z said:
There you go, trying to insert your erroneous opinion again. I'd say the benifits of circumcision are neither small, nor obscure, nor theoretical.
UTI's are:
1) Rare in boys, period. Circumcised or intact.
2)Easily treated

Penis cancer is:
A rather obscure form of cancer

FACT:
For an overwhelming majority of males, circumcision will provide no medical benefit.

I can back all this up with links and figures if you insist on calling it nothing more than an opinion. Just make the request an I'll happily prove it.

Me said:
Patient has anterograde amnesia? No anaestesia for heart surgery.
Z said:
Now you're just being silly. The shock involved could kill the patient. Of course you'd use anesthesia.
I'm actually a little unclear on this. I'd think if performing heart surgery without anaesthesia would kill an adult from the shock, circumcision without pain relief could kill an infant in the same way. Can one of the resident doctors here give us the facts of the matter?
 
Well, unless you folks can bring some logical and practical arguments to the table, instead of going for emotional punch, continuing to refer to botched, old-technique circumcision (I notice that not one of you dare refer to the painless plastibell method), and continue to compare circumcision to heart surgery or clitorectomies, I'll bow out. I don't see any valid refutation to any of the points I've raised, only emotional outcries.

Just a couple of responses though: No, I would never dare to get involved in an abortion thread (at this point in my life). Although I'm generally against abortion on principle, I'm torn at the moment between seeing embryos as living beings with rights, and seeing them as an unwanted biological infection in some cases. I'm pro-abortion in terms of rape or deformity, I feel that my position on abortion is inconsistant and unfounded. And since I've never been in a position to have to deal directly with the choice of abortion, I don't feel I'm in any position to discuss it.

Of course, this is a fairly recent decision on my part.

To Tabitha, it's obvious your only exposure to circumcisions are botched jobs and jobs done using outdated techniques. Personally, I'd require the plastibell method for all circumcision, as well as pain relief, and criminalize other forms of circumcision. This would eliminate nearly all of the problems you cite, while providing protection from UTI's, infections of the foreskin, smegma, HIV, HPA, and impotency.

To KellyB, your ploys are entirely emotion-based and meant to conflate one type of issue with another. I feel no impetus to further respond to your outbursts.

To Ivor, you've actually been arguing fairly logically, though I feel you're again arguing against outdated methods and botched procedures. I respect your opinion, and can only say I agree to disagree with you.

To the rest, well, you're entitled to your opinions, and until the U.S. outlaws circumcision, I'll rest comfortably knowing that it is still an option.

But I have a bad feeling that continuing to post in this thread is only going to result in me becoming inappropriately emotional, and emotion is a detriment to proper discussion.

Good evening, all.
 
Being uncomfortable doing something does not make one a fundamentalist.

Evidence is not always clear-cut - a responsible provider must use his/her judgment in evaluating the quality of available evidence.

It is very easy to judge when one is not the person doing the procedure in question.
I've been a nurse practitioner for >20 years. While I haven't done circs, I think I think I'm qualified judge. So I'm really not sure what you mean.

And what does defining fundamentalism have to do with a fundamentalist imposing radical moral beliefs on others?

As to clear cut evidence, ???????????

Provide some you think contradicts what I posted. I am always interested in the best evidence based decisions. I have no qualms whatsoever in changing outdated medical recommendations to new ones.
 
Skeptigirl, most of those studies are using men who were circumcised because of medical reasons.



If they were circumcised because of problems with their foreskins/penises...wouldn't you expect a lot more to report an improvement...not a worsening?
Come on, kelly. Did you read the studies to see what the reasons for the circs were? I was under the impression the most common reason was adoption of the Jewish faith.

Regardless, what evidence do you want? Got any large surveys of circumcised and uncircumcised men's sex lives? You have to go by the evidence you have, not unfounded conclusions. I made no effort to cherry pick those studies, unlike what you find on the activists web sites.

Show me the evidence. In the meantime, see my next post!
 
UTI's are:
1) Rare in boys, period. Circumcised or intact.
2)Easily treated

Penis cancer is:
A rather obscure form of cancer

FACT:
For an overwhelming majority of males, circumcision will provide no medical benefit.

I can back all this up with links and figures if you insist on calling it nothing more than an opinion. Just make the request an I'll happily prove it.

I'm actually a little unclear on this. I'd think if performing heart surgery without anaesthesia would kill an adult from the shock, circumcision without pain relief could kill an infant in the same way. Can one of the resident doctors here give us the facts of the matter?
Resident doctors? I know you are not incapable of a medical literature review. Back up your claims then because I'm not sure you can.

I have now gone through the second half of my evidence based review for today and remember now why the evaluation for circumcisions considered the prevention of UTIs as a benefit worth the cost.

As is so common with people not working in a particular medical field, it is very easy to underestimate risk. Anti-vaxers do it and you are doing it with your assumptions that pediatric UTIs are minor, rare and easily treated. While you are at it looking for the rate of complications for local nerve block take a look at the risks associated with all the medical interventions discussed in the following studies, IV meds, IVPs, hospitalizations, ED visits, multiple phlebotomies, and missed & difficult diagnoses, to name a few. And do go to the links because I didn't copy the lengthy abstracts discussing all the interventions they were evaluating. Of course, that would be the risks associated with interventions. I didn't get to the risks associated with UTIs. Also, I highly recommend you all do your own pubmed searches because there were hundreds of studies and I didn't bother going past the first page.

Urinary tract infection in febrile infants younger than eight weeks of Age.
RESULTS: There were 22 positive urine culture results of at least 100 colony-forming unit/mL. Eighteen of these 22 patients were males, and all were uncircumcised. There were significant differences for pyuria >/=5 WBCs/hpf, pyuria >/=10 WBC/microL, CRP >20 mg/L, and ESR >30 mm/hour between culture-positive and culture-negative groups (P <.05). The ROC area for hemocytometer WBC count, standard UA, peripheral WBC count, ESR, and CRP concentration were.909 +/-.045,.791 +/-.065,.544 +/-.074,. 787 +/-.060, and.822 +/-.036, respectively. The ROC curve analysis indicates that the CRP, ESR, and standard UA were powerful but imperfect tools with which to discriminate for UTI in potentially infected neonates. Hemocytometer WBC counts had the highest sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and likelihood ratios for identifying very young infants with positive urine culture results. For all assessments, hemocytometer WBC counts were significantly different, compared with the standard urinalysis. ESR, CRP, and peripheral WBC counts were not helpful in identifying UTI in febrile infants. CONCLUSION: UTI had a prevalence of 13.6% in febrile infants <8 weeks of age. The CRP, ESR, and standard UA were imperfect tools in discriminating for UTI, and the sensitivity of these laboratory parameters was relatively low. Hemocytometer WBC count was a significantly better predictor of UTI in febrile infants.

Primary urinary tract infection in infants: prophylaxis for uncomplicated pyelonephritis.
BACKGROUND: Urinary tract infection (UTI) is one of the most common causes of unexplained fever in infants with a reported prevalence range of 5-11%. The clinical and laboratory findings were reviewed, and diagnosis and treatment for 95 infants with primary UTI were evaluated in this study. METHODS: All patients underwent renal ultrasonography, voiding cystourethrogram and 99mTc dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) scan during hospitalization before treatment, with treatment consisting of 2- or 4-week appropriated antibiotic therapy for the patients associated upper UTI, followed by a second DMSA scan 6 months after therapy. RESULTS: In the present study the main symptom of UTI in infants was fever. High white blood cell count was not necessarily present, and urinalysis was also an imperfect diagnostic tool for discriminating UTI. In addition, colony count from urine culture and kidney ultrasonography was not efficacious in terms of predicting the occurrence of pyelonephritis. Intravenous antibiotic for 1 week followed by 3 weeks of the same oral antibiotic provided good prophylaxis for uncomplicated pyelonephritis. CONCLUSION: Four weeks of antibiotic treatment resulted in good recovery from pyelonephritis in the present sample of infant primary UTI cases. voiding cystourethrogram, DMSA and ultrasonography scanning should be performed in primary infant UTI.

Urinary tract infections in young febrile children.
UTI is a common and important clinical problem in infants and young children, with a prevalence of 5.3% among febrile infants seen in our Emergency Department. White females with rectal temperature > or = 39 degrees C are at particularly high risk (prevalence, 17%). [Meaning there were plenty of male patients as well]

Treatment of urinary tract infections among febrile young children with daily intravenous antibiotic therapy at a day treatment center.
We aimed to describe the feasibility and complications of outpatient management with IV antibiotics of UTI among febrile children, at the day treatment center (DTC) of a tertiary-care pediatric hospital. METHODS: Between April 1, 2002, and March 31, 2003, a prospective cohort of patients 3 months to 5 years of age who were examined in the emergency department (ED) and diagnosed as having presumed febrile UTI were treated according to a clinical protocol. Patients were treated at the DTC unless they met exclusion criteria, in which case they were hospitalized. The DTC was open 7 days per week, including holidays, from 8:30 am to 4:30 pm. At the DTC, patients were initially treated with a daily dose of IV gentamicin, until the child had been afebrile for at least 24 hours, and with oral amoxicillin, until preliminary urine culture results were available. Children allergic to penicillin received gentamicin only. IV antibiotics were administered through peripheral IV access; the IV catheter's patency was maintained with injection of 50 U of heparin once daily throughout the treatment period. Parental satisfaction with the DTC experience was assessed with an anonymous, self-administered questionnaire. RESULTS: Two hundred ninety-one episodes of presumed febrile UTI were diagnosed in the ED, of which 212 (72.9%) were sent to the DTC. There were 71 hospital admissions (24.4%);.....Four patients with UTI treated in the DTC had positive blood cultures, 2 with Escherichia coli (both successfully treated at the DTC) and 2 with contaminants. For 4 children treated at the DTC, UTI was caused by gentamicin-resistant E coli. One patient became afebrile within 24 hours after treatment initiation with IV gentamicin; he was then treated with oral cefixime. A second patient was treated with IV ceftriaxone, administered at the DTC once culture results were available, and remained febrile for <72 hours. The last 2 patients were hospitalized; one, who was also allergic to cephalosporins, had been febrile for 72 hours at the time of hospitalization (once hospitalized, he was treated with IV amikacin), and the other was admitted to the hospital for an unrelated problem, namely, scalp cellulitis.

Nonresponders: prolonged fever among infants with urinary tract infections.
BACKGROUND: The majority of young children with fever and urinary tract infections (UTIs) have evidence of pyelonephritis based on renal scans. Resolution of fever during treatment is 1 clinical marker of adequate treatment. Theoretically, prolonged fever may be a clue to complications, such as urinary obstruction or renal abscess.

[First urinary tract infection in healthy infants: epidemiology, diagnosis and treatment]
RESULTS: We studied 131 patients (median age: 90 days). In infants younger than 30 days, UTI was more prevalent in males. The most frequent symptom was fever (73.3 %). Seventy-one patients fulfilled the criteria for acute pyelonephritis. The presence of nitrituria was low. Escherichia coli was isolated in 90.1 % of the patients. Voiding cystourethrogram detected vesicoureteric reflux in 18.4 % of the patients. Scintigraphy revealed renal scarring in 15.1 %. No significant correlations were found between renal scarring in late scintigraphy and a diagnosis of acute pyelonephritis and/or alterations in the cystourethrogram. CONCLUSIONS: Fever was the main symptom. E. coli was the most commonly isolated microorganism. Nitrituria had low sensitivity in infants. Ultrasonography had low specificity. Scintigraphy showed the highest sensitivity and specificity in the detection of renal scarring. Predictability improved when scintigraphy was performed a few months after acute infection.

Does this really sound like no big deal? (Oh yeah, and be careful, it's easy to read febrile as female when you think mostly girls get UTIs.)
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl said:
Come on, kelly. Did you read the studies to see what the reasons for the circs were? I was under the impression the most common reason was adoption of the Jewish faith.
#1- n/a
#2- doesn't say what the reason was.
#3- circumcised for "benign diseases"
#4- religion and cosmetic
#5- circumcised for foreskin problems
#6- doesn't say

What makes you think the "unknowns" were all adopting Judaism?

Show me the evidence. In the meantime, see my next post!
The evidence is all over the place. Do you want to count studies or something?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom