.....I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.
I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.
Linda
Clearly you understand what I am talking about.
If our position is justifiable, then unbiased information we give the parents should support our position. If on the other hand we don't recognize where evidence based medicine ends and personal moral decisions begin, then we won't recognize and therefore cannot respect the parents' moral decisions. What one person views as important, another may view as unimportant. And evidence based medicine cannot empirically determine the value of importance to assign decision criteria. And here is where a health care provider, I think, has a duty to maintain due care in applying personal morals to determine the importance of various criteria when drawing conclusions.
(Again, this differs from taking a position against a parent/patient decision based in ignorance or misinterpretation of facts and evidence. That is where one does not compromise and one's expertise applies.)
Due care does not mean personal morals never apply. Providers who chose to opt out of any abortion procedures as long as another provider can step in, is usually considered an acceptable standard of care. But once again, we encounter a continuum. Is it an appropriate standard of care for a provider with fundamentalist religious beliefs to apply his/her morals to patient care decisions? One argument from fundamentalists for teaching abstinence only is that the use of condoms is facilitating a sin. Better for the sinner to get HIV than for the provider to contribute to facilitating the sin. I don't think that moral position would meet very many people's standards of care.
A circumcision decision is not a black and white decision. It is a continuum decision. That is getting lost in this discussion. On this continuum people are drawing the line in different places where risk/cost and benefit intersect.
I listed a number of values which affect where one draws the line. Different values are assigned, but not limited to, such things as:
* Religion and beliefs about right and wrong.
* The child's self esteem in the grade school locker room.
* Health.
* The child's right to choose.
* The child's right to 'body integrity'.
* Risk perception.
* Beliefs about the affects on sexual pleasure.
If a parent were having the child circumcised because of religious beliefs, I don't think they'd have the same reaction to a provider referring them to someone else as in other situations. That meets an acceptable standard of care.
Right to choose and body integrity is another matter. This is a gray area of provider's moral beliefs vs parent's moral beliefs including the moral belief of whose decision and whose morals apply. This is the area where I feel the strongest about leaving my moral beliefs out of the decision. You could argue you were advocating for the patient, but then you are saying you have the right to apply your beliefs and the parents do not have the right to apply theirs.
However, it has been stated that the argument of body integrity and right to choose don't override medical necessity. This at the same time one is claiming the right of the parents to apply their beliefs regarding right to choose and body integrity does not override the right of the provider to apply his/her beliefs about body integrity and right to choose. So what is the provider's actual moral belief resting on here? I suggest it is resting on the provider's personal values being applied to risk/cost vs benefit, and not directly on body integrity and right to choose. It isn't the infant's right to choose if the decision is made for 'medical reasons'.
But the provider's personal values are affecting the conclusions from evidence based medicine about where the line is drawn in favor of medical benefit over risk/cost. The reason for the position of the AAP and the AAFP is that the medical benefit of circumcision is not zero, and opinions differ as to when the cost/risk clearly overrides that benefit.
If the value assigned to the affect on sexual pleasure is exaggerated above the evidence due to emotional factors, that could be a problem.
If the benefit of UTI prevention is being discounted without a neutral evaluation of the evidence, that could be a problem.
If the parent's risk perception of UTIs differs from the provider for legitimate reasons then whose risk perception applies to the decision?
As an evidence based provider, I need more than emotional testimony the sexual pleasure is affected as greatly as is being claimed. If such evidence exists and I provide that to the parents, I should be able to support my position. If I am acting on that emotional reaction, then I'm deciding my moral opinion overrides the parent's and that, IMO, is overstepping my role as a provider.