Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Prove that the foreskin is 'useful'. Or, should I say, prove that the benefits of having a foreskin outweigh the benefits of not having one. So far, the benefits of having one appear minimal at best, while the benefits of not having one are somewhat greater (at least in our society).
Excuse me, but this thread has failed to convince me that the benefits are "greater". You're talking completely subjective bollocks here.
As for the foreskin being "useful" - um, it has been said over and over again what the uses of the foreskin are. Just because -you- don't agree these uses are significant doesn't mean they aren't, or don't exist.

Personally, I agree that parents ought to have the right (and, in fact, they DO have the right) to have surgery done on their children to improve their appearance. But then, I'm something of an extremist in this area, and my commentaries should be treated accordingly.
So if, in my "culture", earlobes are ugly, I can cut off my children's earlobes to make them look prettier, and hey, they won't suffer from potential pierced earlobe infection, so it's all good... right?
Same argument with the removal of the clitoral hood, actually. Or any other form of FMG, for that matter. Who are we to put the female's sexual pleasure over her acceptance into her community as someone with beautiful, healthy-looking, excised genitals, after all? Those women don't miss their intact genitals, in fact, they even make sure their daughters get the same treatment.
 
What the infant feels is a non-issue.

Wow! That's all the way up to Level 1, Pre-conventional morality (Right and wrong determined by rewards/punishment). Were you in the armed forces?

Most of the arguments here (including some of my own) are Level 2, Conventional morality (Views of others matter. Avoidance of blame; seeking approval).

Anyone care to try an argument based on Level 3, Post-conventional morality (Abstract notions of justice. Rights of others can override obedience to laws/rules)?
 
Last edited:
When you make a point of saying that you won't perform circumcisions for non-medical reasons, it could be taken as though you are allowing your beliefs to take priority over the beliefs of your patient's surrogate decision makers. What saves you is that the circumstances won't actually result in a denial of service, so it really just serves to somewhat quantify the strength of your disagreement. I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.

I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.

Linda

But you seem to be assuming that my 'belief' has something to do with something other than the medical necessity or value of the procedure. If another kind of 'belief' is involved, then the parents are free to seek out another provider.

I don't understand what you mean by "left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves." I've said several times that I would never try and stop parents who really wanted it done, for whatever reason. But there's no way I have to do something just because someone wants it. What if it's a parent of a child who absolutely wants their kid's cold to be treated with antibiotics, because they "know it will help"? Is their 'belief' supposed to trump my training and knowledge that antibiotics don't help colds, that they're overprescribed, and that they confer a risk of side effects including anaphylaxis?

And is the fact that the parent can probably talk some other overworked doctor into writing the script supposed to convince me to just go ahead and give it anyway, because that's what their belief is and my judgment shouldn't trump theirs?
 
Wow! That's all the way up to Level 1, Pre-conventional morality (Right and wrong determined by rewards/punishment). Were you in the armed forces?

Yes, as a matter of fact, for a decade.

Most of the arguments here (including some of my own) are Level 2, Conventional morality (Views of others matter. Avoidance of blame; seeking approval).

Yeah, I tend to reject that nonsense. Views of others: irrelevant. Acceptance of blame. Dismissal of approval.

Anyone care to try an argument based on Level 3, Post-conventional morality (Abstract notions of justice. Rights of others can override obedience to laws/rules)?

Pure crap... metaphorically speaking, of course.

Since the infant does not remember the pain, their pain is in this case irrelevant. Their pain is not life-threatening, nor disruptive to their growth and development, nor is it going to cause an issue in later life. Hence, it can be dismissed.

And Morri, the claimed uses of the foreskin are completely unconvincing. Having never had one, I've never had any problems from not having one; and I value my personal experience in this matter over these far-reaching attempts to justify keeping the foreskin.

As for the earlobes issue, sure. Earlobes are unnecessary. If your culture finds their removal to be more attractive, great.

As to the issue of the prepuce, I will say that IF its removal results in similar non-issues to the removal of the foreskin, then that's fine, too. However, I am aware that the clitoris is a far more sensitive member than the glans penis, and that removal of the clitoral prepuce can actually deter from the enjoyment of sex. Since removal of the foreskin does not deter from the enjoyment of sex - personal experience, again - it is not equivalent.

Personally, I think unless you've been circumcised, you have no place discussing circumcision.

:D
 
...Since the infant does not remember the pain, their pain is in this case irrelevant. Their pain is not life-threatening, nor disruptive to their growth and development, nor is it going to cause an issue in later life. Hence, it can be dismissed...

So if it was possible to erase adults' memories of specific events, you wouldn't mind if those events involved inflicting pain on the individual?

Do you find date rape (victim drugged, can't remember what happened, wakes up in bed) more acceptable than rape performed at knife-point?
 
So if it was possible to erase adults' memories of specific events, you wouldn't mind if those events involved inflicting pain on the individual?

As long as those events resulted in a positive effect for the individual, no. Hence, anesthesia for surgery.

Do you find date rape (victim drugged, can't remember what happened, wakes up in bed) more acceptable than rape performed at knife-point?

I find no form of rape acceptable, because rape does not result in a positive effect for the victim. Nor do I find drugging a person against their will acceptable.

How soon before you ask me if I've stopped beating my wife and raping my children? You anti-circers are big on making sweeping emotional pleas, aren't you?

Circumcision does result in positive effects for the individual, and the pain is forgotten if done in infancy. That pain is, therefore, irrelevant.
 
Ivor said:
So if it was possible to erase adults' memories of specific events, you wouldn't mind if those events involved inflicting pain on the individual?

Z said:
As long as those events resulted in a positive effect for the individual, no.

This is a very interesting insight into the mind of the circumcising parent.

I'm really thinking at this point that we need more laws in place to protect small children and others without a voice from needless suffering.
 
Since the infant does not remember the pain, their pain is in this case irrelevant. Their pain is not life-threatening, nor disruptive to their growth and development, nor is it going to cause an issue in later life. Hence, it can be dismissed.

:eek: What the ****. Suffering is only relevant if the subject always remembers it? But then, what makes you think that the infant can't remember it? I mean, by the time you are older, you will have forgotten. But do babies remember it the next day (This is last part is purely musing)?

As for the earlobes issue, sure. Earlobes are unnecessary. If your culture finds their removal to be more attractive, great.

:dl:

Really? I must refrain from asking questions that make you out to be a bastard, but you are really just begging for it with this stuff.

(Really?)

Personally, I think unless you've been circumcised, you have no place discussing circumcision.

:D

Naturally, lest the unbiased meander into the discussion :p .
 
I'm really fascinated by the idea that it's ok to do anything at all to another person (as long as there can be some small, obscure benefit theorized) so long as some anmesia over the trauma will set in at some point.

Patient has anterograde amnesia? No anaestesia for heart surgery. Just restrain him and try to ignore the pleas for mercy. He'll forget about the whole thing before too long.

:confused:
 
:eek: What the ****. Suffering is only relevant if the subject always remembers it? But then, what makes you think that the infant can't remember it? I mean, by the time you are older, you will have forgotten. But do babies remember it the next day (This is last part is purely musing)?

Even if they remember it a week, it's irrelevant. As it is, from what I can tell, the methods used by the doctors in my sons' circumcisions were painless, making it a moot point anyway.

:dl:

Really? I must refrain from asking questions that make you out to be a bastard, but you are really just begging for it with this stuff.

(Really?)

Really. As for what that makes me out to be, you're welcome to your opinions, but I'm pretty sure my parents were married.

And it's certainly better than waiting until they're old enough to RETAIN a memory of pain or discomfort, I'd say.

Naturally, lest the unbiased meander into the discussion :p .

:dl:

You're kidding, right? There ARE no unbiased men in a circumcision discussion. Only women could make that claim - possibly.

But what's become clear so far is that uncircumcised men (the ones posting here anyway) have this sick delusion that trimming off the foreskin results in lack of feeling, weaker sexual pleasure, and who know what else - when, in fact, it doesn't. It's not traumatic or harmful. And from my experience - anecdotal, yes - having a foreskin is more of a problem than not having one, what with infections, hygeine issues, the stench, etc. I might say that having been circumcised, I probably shouldn't discuss uncircumcised men, but I am stepfather to two uncircumcised boys and have been a friend to a scant few uncircumcised men.

Are the uncircumcised men here fathers to circumcised boys, or have close friends who have been circumcised? Then perhaps they might have a claim to less bias than otherwise. But that doesn't appear to be the case.
 
I'm really fascinated by the idea that it's ok to do anything at all to another person (as long as there can be some small, obscure benefit theorized)

There you go, trying to insert your erroneous opinion again. I'd say the benifits of circumcision are neither small, nor obscure, nor theoretical.

so long as some anmesia over the trauma will set in at some point.

A very short point, of course.

Patient has anterograde amnesia? No anaestesia for heart surgery.

Now you're just being silly. The shock involved could kill the patient. Of course you'd use anesthesia. Besides, restraining the patient would be too problematic.

No such problems with circumcision.

(Besides, amnesia can spontaneously reverse. An adult, on the other hand, isn't suddenly going to remember a slight pain shortly after birth.)

Is this the best you have? A few empty emotional appeals?
 
As long as those events resulted in a positive effect for the individual, no. Hence, anesthesia for surgery.

So you think the only reason a patient gets knocked out before having major surgery is so they don't remember it. You don't think that fear and pain come into it?

I find no form of rape acceptable, because rape does not result in a positive effect for the victim. Nor do I find drugging a person against their will acceptable.

Just remind me again, what out and out positive effects does circumcision provide for a boy in the developed world? Do you think American boys have a significant advantage to European ones?

How soon before you ask me if I've stopped beating my wife and raping my children? You anti-circers are big on making sweeping emotional pleas, aren't you?

I don't think you do those things so I'm not going to ask you. I was trying to understand how you came to the conclusion that just because pain and suffering have been forgotten, they are irrelevant.

By the way, I'm not anti-circumcision. I'm against circumcisions performed for no medical reason. If the circumcision is medically indicated and adequate pain relief is used, then I have no problem with circumcision at all.

Circumcision does result in positive effects for the individual, and the pain is forgotten if done in infancy. That pain is, therefore, irrelevant.

If it makes you feel better just keep on repeating that.
 
Doesn't circumcision stop masterbation?
I heard that it is so popular because people think it does, however I haven't seen any evidence for it.
 
This is a very interesting insight into the mind of the circumcising parent.

I'm really thinking at this point that we need more laws in place to protect small children and others without a voice from needless suffering.

I'm amazed after reading Linda's posts that the wishes of parents for unnecessary medical treatment of their children is such a difficult (and potentially risky) thing for a physician to say no to.

I wonder what the charge against a physician could actually be for refusing to perform a circumcision when it was not medically indicated?
 
So you think the only reason a patient gets knocked out before having major surgery is so they don't remember it. You don't think that fear and pain come into it?

Already addressed that.

Just remind me again, what out and out positive effects does circumcision provide for a boy in the developed world?

Already addressed that, too.

And do you honestly think that a risk of HIV doesn't exist in developed countries?

Do you think American boys have a significant advantage to European ones?

Do you really want me to go there?

By the way, I'm not anti-circumcision. I'm against circumcisions performed for no medical reason. If the circumcision is medically indicated and adequate pain relief is used, then I have no problem with circumcision at all.

Good. The first doctor to perform circumcision on one of my children advised that circumcision is an excellent preventative to infection, disease, and hygeine issues. Adequate pain relief was used. So no problem, right?

Then why all the drama?

If it makes you feel better just keep on repeating that.

Feelings have nothing to do with this.
 
Doesn't circumcision stop masterbation?
I heard that it is so popular because people think it does, however I haven't seen any evidence for it.

That's something else I'd never heard until this thread. Where have you heard that?

Of course, I was raised to believe that masturbation was just fine. And our school sex ed class praised masturbation as an alternative to intercourse.
 
Doesn't circumcision stop masterbation?
I heard that it is so popular because people think it does, however I haven't seen any evidence for it.

I can think of only one think that would stop a boy masturbating. It's not circumcision.

Anyhow, masturbation has positive effects, don't you know. I therefore think parents should insist their sons' are taught how to masturbate at the earliest age possible, so they gain the maximum benefit and don't remember the embarrassment of talking about sex to an adult when they're a teenager:D
 
Even if they remember it a week, it's irrelevant. As it is, from what I can tell, the methods used by the doctors in my sons' circumcisions were painless, making it a moot point anyway.

Well there's your problem. Was anesthesia used? What was the method? How often is anesthesia used? How often is that method used? Do you have any objective evidence that it was painless? And just for laughs, a calm baby looks similar to a baby in shock.

And it is not irrelevant. You made the ridiculous claim that suffering is irrelevant if the subject doesn't remember it later. What is your rationale?

Really. As for what that makes me out to be, you're welcome to your opinions, but I'm pretty sure my parents were married.

And it's certainly better than waiting until they're old enough to RETAIN a memory of pain or discomfort, I'd say.

But you can't know if they will choose to do the surgery later. And for me, the important part is the choice. I'd say it would be better to wait for the simple fact that it will then be their choice.

But again, that's just my crazy thinking. Kinda like your opinions that infantile suffering is irrelevant and that culturally accepted mutilation is fine as long as it doesn't take off anything too important.

:dl:

You're kidding, right?

Dur. That's why I used a smilie.

There ARE no unbiased men in a circumcision discussion. Only women could make that claim - possibly.

But what's become clear so far is that uncircumcised men (the ones posting here anyway) have this sick delusion that trimming off the foreskin results in lack of feeling, weaker sexual pleasure, and who know what else - when, in fact, it doesn't. It's not traumatic or harmful. And from my experience - anecdotal, yes - having a foreskin is more of a problem than not having one, what with infections, hygeine issues, the stench, etc. I might say that having been circumcised, I probably shouldn't discuss uncircumcised men, but I am stepfather to two uncircumcised boys and have been a friend to a scant few uncircumcised men.

Are the uncircumcised men here fathers to circumcised boys, or have close friends who have been circumcised? Then perhaps they might have a claim to less bias than otherwise. But that doesn't appear to be the case.

Congrats on admitting your bias :) . And, yes, I bolded the above just because you still say that infantile suffering is irrelevant.
 
...The first doctor to perform circumcision on one of my children advised that circumcision is an excellent preventative to infection, disease, and hygeine issues...

Then he was a fool or a lier. Alas, spending 5 or 6 years in medical school does not ensure a person is neither of these.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom