Nice dodge. It is not an appeal to emotion; it’s an appeal to logical (i.e. consistent) reasoning. Something you think you’re rather good at. All you’ve said above is that you're just following orders. That’s not very logical, Skeptigirl.
You can try, Ivor, but I'm not taking your bait. No one is "just following orders". If your physician or other health care provider isn't concerned with standards of care, I'd find another provider.
And more than one person in this thread is now resorting to such insults which I interpret as getting frustrated their arguments fail to sway my position.
Medical standards and professional organizations' position statements are an important resource for any provider. Perhaps you are not aware of efforts in the medical profession to standardize care and promote evidence based decisions. There is a wealth of research which any number of patients are not afforded the advantage of because the pace at which research is now acquired makes it is impossible to keep up on an individual basis alone. With justification, and hopefully supporting evidence, one can certainly choose not to follow a standard, but it needs to be done with great care.
Just to reiterate my position which is continually being distorted and demonized here,
- I agree with the position of the AAP and the AAFP, which also means I agree with what they believe is the appropriate standard of care.
- That position recognizes parents do not all assign the same weight to various components used to make their choice to circumcise their infant.
- The evidence based medical decision to circumcise (in low HIV prevalence countries) is equivocal.*
*I recognize not everyone in this thread agrees with that statement. But that comes as no surprise when you consider people here just like any parent have their own priorities which they are using to weigh the components of the decision.
Different values are assigned to such things as:
- Religion and beliefs about right and wrong.
- The child's self esteem in the grade school locker room.
- The child's right to choose.
- The child's right to 'body integrity'.
- Beliefs about the affects on sexual pleasure.
I may be leaving some out, but the point is the decision can vary depending on which of these factors are the most important to you and on how you view each of these.
I don't believe the components of this decision which are most important to me should be used to decide what is someone else's decision to make. Nor does it bother me everyone isn't making the same decision.
Let’s try again.
Is it your view that an infant does _not_ have the right to body integrity? I.e., that the parent’s rights to choose trump the child’s rights to not have an unnecessary medical procedure, based on the available* evidence, that will permanently alter their body.
Yes or No will do, but I’d prefer a reasoned, consistent argument, if you think one is possible for your position.
The answer is, no, not in this case.
Suppose the circumcision was medically necessary. The child has a kidney & urinary tract malformation and UTIs carry life threatening risk. What happens to your argument about right to body integrity? (I assume the people objecting to circumcision here would say, that's different.)
Now suppose the kidney defect is milder. Now the risk is less but a UTI in this child is still going to be riskier and/or more serious than a UTI in a healthy child. The evidence is that UTIs are potentially serious in any child but now you take the child with no anatomical issue making their UTI risk greater than any other child.
So you have a continuum of medical risk/benefit where each person is drawing the line between circumcision being justified with the benefit greater than the risk, and circumcision being unjustified.
So what is the justification for where
you draw that line? According to the medical evidence is there is a small medical benefit of UTI risk reduction with a circumcision.
Throw in another scenario. Suppose you have parents who have a healthy newborn but lost a previous child to an antibiotic resistant infection. Their priority is to take any action which decreases the risk of infection. Hearing there is evidence circumcisions decrease the risk of infection by a very small amount, they don't hear another word in the discussion. They opt for the circumcision. The previous child died from luck of the draw, not from any genetic contribution to risk. The parents, from previous experiences weigh the minor benefit of UTI risk reduction as extremely important. That is the only thing that differs here.
You say yourself, there is a threshold of risk reduction which you concede would make circumcision acceptable:
It seems I can change my position on circumcision for increased resistance to HIV infection in Africa, but you can’t do the same for unnecessary (based on the evidence) circumcisions in the US.
Who gets to draw that line, Ivor? Where do you draw it for UTI risk reduction? The kid with the major GU malformation, the moderate malformation, or no malformation but medical evidence still puts UTIs as potentially serious in any child?
Do the parents whose risk perception of infection is greater than your's get to use their value or yours or mine for that matter? These parents don't necessarily have false beliefs such as a parent refusing to vaccinate. These parents simply have had an experience which altered their value of infection prevention.
However, I doubt you’ll answer because the cognitive dissonance I think you have on this issue will make you dismiss my question as stupid or emotional.
You really doubt I'll answer? You've got to be kidding.
I have no cognitive dissonance here, Ivor. And I don't think the definition of cognitive dissonance even applies, unless there is a second definition I'm unaware of. I think you are looking for a word that describes a decision when there is more than one moral issue to compare. The parent's rights vs the child's rights, that isn't cognitive dissonance. CD is when you believe two things which are incompatible, such as believing in scientific evidence and believing in gods.
Ah well, I suppose no one can be sceptical all the time about all issues.
More insults because
you are frustrated you have failed to convince me?
*The available evidence includes an individual assessment by a professional of the child’s body. Seems a lot of people in the US currently tend to weight that bit of evidence rather lightly when it disagrees with their wishes.
I don't get what you mean here but if it has to do with more sarcasm and insults, that isn't very productive.