Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I'm sort of thinking of the opposite response - that you accept the parents' decision by performing the procedure yourself. I know it sounds weird, but I think it forces you to take a harder look at the issue than you would by otherwise taking the easier route. I'm not really advocating that you do this, I'm just bringing it up for consideration. I have this same argument with my colleagues - not about circumcision, but about refusing treatment, for example, of active smokers. Disagreement is the rule there, too. :)

To accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability. If you discover that your strong feelings against that decision interfere with your ability to provide the best care, then it is reasonable to pass part (or all) of that care on to a colleague.

I just wanted to bring up a different perspective about what it means to interfere with the care of an individual.

Linda
This peds conference addresses this issue. Dr Marcuse, Seattle Children's Orthopedic Hospital, Chief of Staff has a brief segment which I admire in particular. I don't agree at all with refusing to treat patients who 'don't follow orders' which in some cases is what it amounts to. The doctor may rationalize it in a number of ways, and it isn't always the case, but often what it really amounts to is resentment of not being [believed, trusted, respected] (some combination of these issues.)

How Physicians View the Issue: Parents Who Refuse to Vaccinate a Child
This program focuses on a variety of issues related to parental rights regarding childhood vaccinations, including the origins of immunization hesitancy, and the medical community's response to the parent who refuses to vaccinate their child. Edgar Marcuse, professor at the University of Washington School of Medicine, discusses the nature and scope of immunization hesitancy and vaccine refusal in the United States. Dr. Marcuse identifies societal factors contributing to immunization hesitancy and discusses the tension between protecting the public's health and protecting the individual's right to choose. Joel Frader, professor at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, discusses the pediatricians' view of families who refuse vaccines and identifies the moral issues in responding to vaccine refusal. He also discusses options for physicians when parents refuse to vaccinate their children.
I can't say I've never experienced resentment at not being believed but I can say I recognize it and I think I deal with it well considering how I may have dealt with it in the past and considering how people in these forums react when their view is not accepted by someone they are discussing an issue with.

And that is the segway to my next two posts.
 
Ooooh...I see...
You're making it up. Okey dokey then. :)

Not only is that 100% wrong but it is a 100% rude thing to say.

Obviously in the black and white world you perceive circumcision is as horrid as FGM.
Sorry. You're just not convincing me that I am suffering as much as some poor woman in Africa with a carved up vagina. Until you can do that I will maintain my position.
 
BlackKat said:
Not only is that 100% wrong but it is a 100% rude thing to say.
My apologies for coming across rude. But seriously, you can't make claims and not provide evidence and expect to be taken seriously.

Obviously in the black and white world you perceive circumcision is as horrid as FGM.
I consider male circumcision quite comparable to removal of the clitoral prepuce.

Sorry. You're just not convincing me that I am suffering as much as some poor woman in Africa with a carved up vagina. Until you can do that I will maintain my position.
Of course you will. It would be very upsetting for you to acknowledge the similarities. When people hold irrational beliefs, there's usually a deep psychological need there.
 
Nice dodge. It is not an appeal to emotion; it’s an appeal to logical (i.e. consistent) reasoning. Something you think you’re rather good at. All you’ve said above is that you're just following orders. That’s not very logical, Skeptigirl.
You can try, Ivor, but I'm not taking your bait. No one is "just following orders". If your physician or other health care provider isn't concerned with standards of care, I'd find another provider. And more than one person in this thread is now resorting to such insults which I interpret as getting frustrated their arguments fail to sway my position.

Medical standards and professional organizations' position statements are an important resource for any provider. Perhaps you are not aware of efforts in the medical profession to standardize care and promote evidence based decisions. There is a wealth of research which any number of patients are not afforded the advantage of because the pace at which research is now acquired makes it is impossible to keep up on an individual basis alone. With justification, and hopefully supporting evidence, one can certainly choose not to follow a standard, but it needs to be done with great care.

Just to reiterate my position which is continually being distorted and demonized here,

  • I agree with the position of the AAP and the AAFP, which also means I agree with what they believe is the appropriate standard of care.
  • That position recognizes parents do not all assign the same weight to various components used to make their choice to circumcise their infant.
  • The evidence based medical decision to circumcise (in low HIV prevalence countries) is equivocal.*
*I recognize not everyone in this thread agrees with that statement. But that comes as no surprise when you consider people here just like any parent have their own priorities which they are using to weigh the components of the decision.

Different values are assigned to such things as:
  • Religion and beliefs about right and wrong.
  • The child's self esteem in the grade school locker room.
  • Health.
  • The child's right to choose.
  • The child's right to 'body integrity'.
  • Risk perception.
  • Beliefs about the affects on sexual pleasure.

I may be leaving some out, but the point is the decision can vary depending on which of these factors are the most important to you and on how you view each of these. I don't believe the components of this decision which are most important to me should be used to decide what is someone else's decision to make. Nor does it bother me everyone isn't making the same decision.

Let’s try again.

Is it your view that an infant does _not_ have the right to body integrity? I.e., that the parent’s rights to choose trump the child’s rights to not have an unnecessary medical procedure, based on the available* evidence, that will permanently alter their body.

Yes or No will do, but I’d prefer a reasoned, consistent argument, if you think one is possible for your position.
The answer is, no, not in this case.

Suppose the circumcision was medically necessary. The child has a kidney & urinary tract malformation and UTIs carry life threatening risk. What happens to your argument about right to body integrity? (I assume the people objecting to circumcision here would say, that's different.)

Now suppose the kidney defect is milder. Now the risk is less but a UTI in this child is still going to be riskier and/or more serious than a UTI in a healthy child. The evidence is that UTIs are potentially serious in any child but now you take the child with no anatomical issue making their UTI risk greater than any other child. So you have a continuum of medical risk/benefit where each person is drawing the line between circumcision being justified with the benefit greater than the risk, and circumcision being unjustified.

So what is the justification for where you draw that line? According to the medical evidence is there is a small medical benefit of UTI risk reduction with a circumcision.

Throw in another scenario. Suppose you have parents who have a healthy newborn but lost a previous child to an antibiotic resistant infection. Their priority is to take any action which decreases the risk of infection. Hearing there is evidence circumcisions decrease the risk of infection by a very small amount, they don't hear another word in the discussion. They opt for the circumcision. The previous child died from luck of the draw, not from any genetic contribution to risk. The parents, from previous experiences weigh the minor benefit of UTI risk reduction as extremely important. That is the only thing that differs here.

You say yourself, there is a threshold of risk reduction which you concede would make circumcision acceptable:
It seems I can change my position on circumcision for increased resistance to HIV infection in Africa, but you can’t do the same for unnecessary (based on the evidence) circumcisions in the US.
Who gets to draw that line, Ivor? Where do you draw it for UTI risk reduction? The kid with the major GU malformation, the moderate malformation, or no malformation but medical evidence still puts UTIs as potentially serious in any child?

Do the parents whose risk perception of infection is greater than your's get to use their value or yours or mine for that matter? These parents don't necessarily have false beliefs such as a parent refusing to vaccinate. These parents simply have had an experience which altered their value of infection prevention.

However, I doubt you’ll answer because the cognitive dissonance I think you have on this issue will make you dismiss my question as stupid or emotional.
You really doubt I'll answer? You've got to be kidding. :rolleyes:

I have no cognitive dissonance here, Ivor. And I don't think the definition of cognitive dissonance even applies, unless there is a second definition I'm unaware of. I think you are looking for a word that describes a decision when there is more than one moral issue to compare. The parent's rights vs the child's rights, that isn't cognitive dissonance. CD is when you believe two things which are incompatible, such as believing in scientific evidence and believing in gods.
Ah well, I suppose no one can be sceptical all the time about all issues.
More insults because you are frustrated you have failed to convince me?

*The available evidence includes an individual assessment by a professional of the child’s body. Seems a lot of people in the US currently tend to weight that bit of evidence rather lightly when it disagrees with their wishes.
I don't get what you mean here but if it has to do with more sarcasm and insults, that isn't very productive.
 
My apologies for coming across rude. But seriously, you can't make claims and not provide evidence and expect to be taken seriously.

Well I think I provided you with my evidence. I learned what the body parts do in Health and Sex Ed classes and from such Sex Ed books as were prevalent in the 1970s and early 1980s. I refined this knowledge by phyiscal relations with the opposite sex, testimonial though it may be. And before I posted I verified my facts as best as possible on the interweb (where there is as much fiction as fact) and provided you with one of the links I had visited.

I consider male circumcision quite comparable to removal of the clitoral prepuce.

And it could be argued to be comparable, except the revealed glans is just not analogous enough to the revealed clitoris. But my point to that has always been that removal of the clitoral hood is but one small aspect of FGM. And (with the exception of piercings which are if not infected essentially harmless) it does seem far less severe than removing the clitoris. But having an exposed clitoris can be extremely detrimental to sexual enjoyment.


Of course you will. It would be very upsetting for you to acknowledge the similarities. When people hold irrational beliefs, there's usually a deep psychological need there.

There are many more differences than similarities. I find nothing rational in believing penises are aestheticly better looking without a foreskin. You can not tie rational into aesthetic beliefs. People do not enjoy a painting or a penis or a song because it is rational to do so. They enjoy them because of the emotions those things evoke.

We can apply rational thinking to whether the emotions a circumcized penis evoke outweigh or not an infant's rights to body integrity versus a parent's right to request cosmetic body modifications. We must weigh a variety of factors when doing so, and one is "will these body modifications have a negative, positive, or no appreciable effect on this child". If the answer is positive or no appreciable effect then there is no reason to be opposed to them even if you do not promote them. If the answer is negative then there is reason to be opposed to them.

I thought it was fairly clear the FGM had enough evidence to say it was a negative modification. Maybe not for everyone, but I have seen enough evidence to convince me.
I just do not see any conclusive evidence showing negative effects to male circumcision, and I have seen some (a small amount) showing positive effects.

It definitely is something that merits more study. A large scale research project seems to be in order. I am pretty dismayed to see that both the pro-circumcision and anti-circumcision papers out there have such miniscule samples to use for making conclusions.

Really I don't see a single thing wrong with parents who choose to or who choose not to circumcise their children. So long as the circumcision is performed in a humane and medically sound manner and the baby does not suffer unduly. The same could be said of other debated neonatal procedures. for instance umbilical cord cutting vs. delayed cutting. If those parents are happy with a baby with a foreskin and are willing to risk the added infections and the way the penis looks, then they should not circumcise their child.
"To each their own" is a fitting statement for this. And that child is their own, entitling them to make decisions for the child until they are an adult so long as those decisions do not threaten the health or happiness of the child.
 
In other words, parents ought to have the right to remove useful but non-essential body parts of infants if they arbitrarily think it looks prettier.

Interesting.
 
In other words, parents ought to have the right to remove useful but non-essential body parts of infants if they arbitrarily think it looks prettier.

Interesting.

Prove that the foreskin is 'useful'. Or, should I say, prove that the benefits of having a foreskin outweigh the benefits of not having one. So far, the benefits of having one appear minimal at best, while the benefits of not having one are somewhat greater (at least in our society).

Personally, I agree that parents ought to have the right (and, in fact, they DO have the right) to have surgery done on their children to improve their appearance. But then, I'm something of an extremist in this area, and my commentaries should be treated accordingly.
 
If, after reading the last few posts I have made, you seriously think you can justify saying that I would not respect the values of parents...I don't think there is any point in continuing this discussion. That is far more judgmental than anything I have even implied and is, frankly, insulting.
And, I think becoming angry at a person who has a different perception of your 'planned response' to a parent opting for circumcision than you have of your response is the more insulting thing in this exchange so far.

We have a different perception of what your planned response means to the parent. You see it as respecting the parent's decision by offering them another physician to perform the circ. I perceive it as telling the parents you disapprove of their decision, and I don't equate that with respecting their opinion.

I realize you don't like the way I perceive your planned response. But if you choose to take that as an insult, I think you are short changing yourself.

I was willing to let the whole "alternate philosophies" idea slide, even though I very much disagree with any such notion. Nurses do not have a monopoly on 'teaching' and 'assisting' and 'helping'.
You are interpreting my discussion about an educational philosophy and its subtle effect on subsequent patient provider interactions and approaches on some level of concrete thinking. That may be why you disagree and it certainly seems to be making you confuse a discussion of 'patient approach' with 'provider's skills'. Skills have absolutely nothing to do with what I am talking about. I'll try once more but then think it best to drop it. Perhaps I am communicating the concept poorly, but regardless, we're just talking past each other.

Take a look at wiki's Nursing Model and Medical Model pages. They aren't the best descriptions but at least you can see that there is a distinctly different approach to the patient. I have one foot in each field. I have observed patient provider interactions for 30 years now. Not that it is the only way to understand, but if you spent a year in nursing school you might have a better understanding of the different philosophy that one comes out of their respective educations with.

Take the discussion about physicians refusing to take patients who refuse certain medical advice. That would be unheard of in nursing. Not because nurses are not autonomous and don't have the luxury, but because the role in nursing is to accept the patient and work with that. A patient refuses meds or to be compliant with a diabetic regimen, it is a nursing function to assess what the barriers are and find ways to accommodate. My role as a nurse would be to solve that problem, not reject the patient for it. Obviously not many physicians are rejecting patients, but the educational philosophy of the physician in charge allows it. The educational philosophy of nursing would not.

Your perception of what constitutes respect for the parent's decision and my perception of what constitutes respect are philosophically at odds. Perhaps we are merely arguing semantics. Respect in this case to me means, giving the parents the choice without bias. I believe you are defining it as, giving the parents the choice by accommodating it but with bias.

If you honestly think that you can do any of that without conveying an opinion, without 'deciding', 'recommending' or 'knowing an answer', you are kidding yourself at best. 'Unbiased' does not mean the same thing as 'unknowledgable'.
You are confusing 'facts' with 'values'. A medical opinion is based on facts. I am going to tell a patient, for example, what the risks and benefits are for a procedure or medication, and they are going to decide whether to go ahead. That's simply informed consent. Many if not most medical recommendations are guided by the evidence.

There's a difference in telling the patient that some men believe circumcision has affected their sexual pleasure and telling the patient that it is morally wrong to circumcise their infant. If I were advising parents today, I would find the latest statistics so that I could say, many parents are choosing not to circumcise, so they needed worry about their child being different. If the parent said it was important Jr look like daddy, I might be ready with studies on whether that impacts kids or some suggestion on how to approach that issue. There are countless ways to properly influence parent's decisions which do not involve rejecting their values or giving biased or even selective information.

The information you give the parent is in response to their decision making steps rather than cherry picked. If you left out the information about the medical benefits or downplayed them inappropriately, that would be unethical and you would not be presenting information in an unbiased way. You'd be denying the parents the right to decide by cherry picking facts in order to persuade.

Your viewpoint is clear. You think circumcision is a good thing. Fine. You will have to accept the fact that there are other medical professionals who disagree with you. And the reason that people keep responding to the idea that you are espousing the concept of circumcising American boys for the purpose of avoiding HIV infection is that you keep responding this way to those of us who are making the point that it does not apply in non-Third-World nations with posts like these.
I agree with the AAP and the AAFP position statements. Twisting that into a completely false claim that I must think circs are a good thing is an indication you're frustrated that you have not made your case. I don't care if I make my case to you. I'm confident that my position is supportable and I'm not invested in convincing any particular individuals. I find discussions like these actually help me refine my thoughts on the subject being discussed.

I remember a previous thread where you took on a rather obvious troll about the parallel nature of the professions of medicine and nursing, and I also recall posting in your support. I am now inclined to reassess my support, because you are now sounding very much like the bad caricature of a nurse who wishes she were a doctor. And I would prefer not to think that of anybody, because I prefer not to think that such a creature exists.
Now this, is absurd. Especially if you read even a quarter of the posts I wrote in that thread. Anyone who had would have no question how highly I regard the nursing profession, and how completely satisfied I am with my career. Nor should there be any doubt whatsoever if you read my posts in that thread, I do not view the nursing and medical professions as subordinate to either. Both are separate professions with equally important roles in health care. I could make an equally offensive statement that you are a med student miffed that a 'mere' nurse should dare challenge your superior position. But I would hope med school isn't still teaching that tripe.

Let me state for the record that, although I am only a fourth-year medical student, I am not a kid. I'm 39 years old and had a couple of careers prior to returning to school to become a doctor. I have the utmost respect for my patients and for those who make decisions for them. That is why I feel I should give them the benefit of the knowledge I have worked so hard to acquire. To suggest acquiescing to anything else in the name of "values" is to condescend to them. I have made it clear that I would never try to prevent a parent who, having heard my opinion, still wanted the procedure, from having it done.

Exactly where do you find an attack on a patient's parents values in that?
I think I have addressed this in this post and in my above post to Ivor. What I put in my reply to him I almost put in this post instead. So if you're sick of this exchange, at least read that post before wandering off.
 
In other words, parents ought to have the right to remove useful but non-essential body parts of infants if they arbitrarily think it looks prettier.

Interesting.
What if it is a cultural belief of aesthetics? Not something essential like in the FGM arguments it's cultural, but say ritual scarring some cultures perform?
 
I hope you are trying to claim the foreskin is more rather than the clitoris is less here.

Otherwise I might need to offer you some sympathy for what you've missed.

Do you know what the prepuce is, Skeptigirl?
Can you perhaps show me the logic behind the argument that the clitoral prepuce is an "essential part" whereas the foreskin of the penis is not?

I keep asking for evidence from BlackKat and Z, but they are staunchly refusing to provide it.
 
BlackKat said:
Well I think I provided you with my evidence. I learned what the body parts do in Health and Sex Ed classes and from such Sex Ed books as were prevalent in the 1970s and early 1980s. I refined this knowledge by phyiscal relations with the opposite sex, testimonial though it may be. And before I posted I verified my facts as best as possible on the interweb (where there is as much fiction as fact) and provided you with one of the links I had visited.
No, that's not evidence. That's you claiming to know what you're talking about. There's a difference there.

And it could be argued to be comparable, except the revealed glans is just not analogous enough to the revealed clitoris.
You keep saying that, but when I challenge you to prove it, you just keep on with the "I know what I'm talking about!" thing.

And that's an extremely uncompelling argument.

But my point to that has always been that removal of the clitoral hood is but one small aspect of FGM.
It's actually pretty darn common, but you're refusing to acknowledge that, because it makes you uncomfortable or something...

And (with the exception of piercings which are if not infected essentially harmless) it does seem far less severe than removing the clitoris.
Agreed.

But having an exposed clitoris can be extremely detrimental to sexual enjoyment.
"Extremely detrimental", huh? And you know this because...you know what you're talking about and don't need to provide evidence to back your claims, because you know what you're talking about?
Got it.

There are many more differences than similarities.
Actually you're wrong. LOTS of similarities going on, as I'm about to demonstrate:
BlackKat said:
I find nothing rational in believing penises are aestheticly better looking without a foreskin. You can not tie rational into aesthetic beliefs. People do not enjoy a painting or a penis or a song because it is rational to do so. They enjoy them because of the emotions those things evoke.


http://www.irinnews.org/InDepthMain.aspx?InDepthId=15&ReportId=62462
Other communities consider female genitalia to be ugly, offensive or dirty, and thus the removal of the external genitalia makes a woman more hygienic and aesthetically pleasing.


BlackKat said:
"To each their own" is a fitting statement for this. And that child is their own,
But it only works like that for boys, though, right?
If the baby is a girl, her genitalia do not belong to her parents for them to remove parts arbitrarily based on aesthetics?
 
Last edited:
Do you know what the prepuce is, Skeptigirl?
Can you perhaps show me the logic behind the argument that the clitoral prepuce is an "essential part" whereas the foreskin of the penis is not?

I keep asking for evidence from BlackKat and Z, but they are staunchly refusing to provide it.
OK, sorry, reread your post, I read it wrong. Seems easy to do. I wonder how often we all are doing it?
 
No, that's not evidence. That's you claiming to know what you're talking about. There's a difference there.

You keep saying that, but when I challenge you to prove it, you just keep on with the "I know what I'm talking about!" thing.

And that's an extremely uncompelling argument.

Like I said. Knowledge was confirmed as best it can be by the internet. And I provided you with a link. It's inane to argue this anyhow since you also know the exact same thing I know. If you don't believe I know what I'm talking about with circumcision then say THAT. You're trying to argue a completely separate point just to try to cast aspersion about some other point.

It's actually pretty darn common, but you're refusing to acknowledge that, because it makes you uncomfortable or something...
Never said it was uncommon. I said it was one of about 10 different FGM practices, and that is was rarely done in exclusion. You keep saying Type I is the most common. Type I is the excision of the clitoris and/or the labia.

"Extremely detrimental", huh? And you know this because...you know what you're talking about and don't need to provide evidence to back your claims, because you know what you're talking about?
Got it.
Again you know this is true but you are arguing not because you don't think I'm right because you are trying to cast aspersions on my statement that the foreskin is not important.


From that article:
"The function of this practice, whether mild or severe, is ultimately to reduce a woman's sexual desire, and so ensure her virginity until marriage. The more extensive procedure, involving stitching of the vagina, has the same aim, but reducing the size of the vagina is also intended to increase the husband's enjoyment of the sexual act."

That does not sound like aesthetics to me. Now keep reading below that in the article and it lists the short and long term effects of FGM. Guess what? Men who are circumcised do not suffer those effects.

But it only works like that for boys, though, right?
If the baby is a girl, her genitalia do not belong to her parents for them to remove parts arbitrarily based on aesthetics?

No if the parents wanted to perform on a female or male infant ritual scarring, most forms of piercing, tattooing... it's also their choice so long as it is done in as sterile and painless way as is medically viable. And so long as these things will not negatively impact the child's future.

You're trying to make equivalent two completely separate, and distinctly different, procedures and it is not working. That's like saying red is blue because they're both colors. Try arguing just about the merits or detriments of circumcision rather than trying to make circumcision into something that it's not.
 
Last edited:
You can try, Ivor, but I'm not taking your bait. No one is "just following orders". If your physician or other health care provider isn't concerned with standards of care, I'd find another provider. And more than one person in this thread is now resorting to such insults which I interpret as getting frustrated their arguments fail to sway my position.

Now come on skeptigirl, they weren't insults, just provocatitve statements:D

Medical standards and professional organizations' position statements are an important resource for any provider. Perhaps you are not aware of efforts in the medical profession to standardize care and promote evidence based decisions. There is a wealth of research which any number of patients are not afforded the advantage of because the pace at which research is now acquired makes it is impossible to keep up on an individual basis alone. With justification, and hopefully supporting evidence, one can certainly choose not to follow a standard, but it needs to be done with great care.

Circumcision of a healthy infant is not an evidence based decision. It’s a whim.

Just to reiterate my position which is continually being distorted and demonized here,

  • I agree with the position of the AAP and the AAFP, which also means I agree with what they believe is the appropriate standard of care.
  • That position recognizes parents do not all assign the same weight to various components used to make their choice to circumcise their infant.
  • The evidence based medical decision to circumcise (in low HIV prevalence countries) is equivocal.*
*I recognize not everyone in this thread agrees with that statement. But that comes as no surprise when you consider people here just like any parent have their own priorities which they are using to weigh the components of the decision.

Different values are assigned to such things as:
  • Religion and beliefs about right and wrong.
  • The child's self esteem in the grade school locker room.
  • Health.
  • The child's right to choose.
  • The child's right to 'body integrity'.
  • Risk perception.
  • Beliefs about the affects on sexual pleasure.

I may be leaving some out, but the point is the decision can vary depending on which of these factors are the most important to you and on how you view each of these. I don't believe the components of this decision which are most important to me should be used to decide what is someone else's decision to make. Nor does it bother me everyone isn't making the same decision.

What about putting yourself in the position of each person being affected by the decision. Can you put yourself in the position of the infant? Using your adult reasoning and knowledge that this procedure is not required and is going to hurt you (to a greater or lesser extent), would choose to have it performed on you?

The answer is, no, not in this case.

Thanks for your answer. The caveat of ‘not in this case’ implies there are situations where you think a child does have the right to body integrity. Could you give some examples where you think this right for the child should be supported over parent’s wishes?

Suppose the circumcision was medically necessary. The child has a kidney & urinary tract malformation and UTIs carry life threatening risk. What happens to your argument about right to body integrity? (I assume the people objecting to circumcision here would say, that's different.)

My reasoning (putting myself in each individual’s position) leads me to the conclusion that the procedure should be performed.

Now suppose the kidney defect is milder. Now the risk is less but a UTI in this child is still going to be riskier and/or more serious than a UTI in a healthy child. The evidence is that UTIs are potentially serious in any child but now you take the child with no anatomical issue making their UTI risk greater than any other child. So you have a continuum of medical risk/benefit where each person is drawing the line between circumcision being justified with the benefit greater than the risk, and circumcision being unjustified.

So what is the justification for where you draw that line? According to the medical evidence is there is a small medical benefit of UTI risk reduction with a circumcision.

Yes, pro-infant circumcision people do go on and on and on about the fact that circumcised boys have a lower incidence of UTI’s. If they also then take action to avoid all other similar magnitude risks for their child then at least they are being consistent. I bet they don’t though.

Again, put yourself in the position of the child. You know that studies have shown that being circumcised has a small benefit for contracting a UTI. You know that the risk is extremely small of you contracting a UTI in the first place. You know that circumcision is not 100% effective for preventing UTI. You know that a UTI can be treated with antibiotics successfully in the vast majority of cases. I think anyone who chose to have an irreversible medical procedure for that level of benefit would need serious psychological treatment (such as for OCD hand-washing) for their perception of risk, don’t you?

Throw in another scenario. Suppose you have parents who have a healthy newborn but lost a previous child to an antibiotic resistant infection. Their priority is to take any action which decreases the risk of infection. Hearing there is evidence circumcisions decrease the risk of infection by a very small amount, they don't hear another word in the discussion. They opt for the circumcision. The previous child died from luck of the draw, not from any genetic contribution to risk. The parents, from previous experiences weigh the minor benefit of UTI risk reduction as extremely important. That is the only thing that differs here.

You say yourself, there is a threshold of risk reduction which you concede would make circumcision acceptable:Who gets to draw that line, Ivor? Where do you draw it for UTI risk reduction? The kid with the major GU malformation, the moderate malformation, or no malformation but medical evidence still puts UTIs as potentially serious in any child?

Do the parents whose risk perception of infection is greater than your's get to use their value or yours or mine for that matter? These parents don't necessarily have false beliefs such as a parent refusing to vaccinate. These parents simply have had an experience which altered their value of infection prevention.

Stop with the parents! They and the physician should be advocating for the child, i.e. putting themselves in the position of the child.

You really doubt I'll answer? You've got to be kidding. :rolleyes:

Actually, I had only an incy-wincy bit of doubt. That’s why I put that (and other provocative statements) in. I know, I’m a pri*k:D

I have no cognitive dissonance here, Ivor. And I don't think the definition of cognitive dissonance even applies, unless there is a second definition I'm unaware of. I think you are looking for a word that describes a decision when there is more than one moral issue to compare. The parent's rights vs the child's rights, that isn't cognitive dissonance. CD is when you believe two things which are incompatible, such as believing in scientific evidence and believing in gods. More insults because you are frustrated you have failed to convince me?

The CD comes from you supporting the child’s rights in one situation and parent’s rights in another when they equivalent situations.

I don't get what you mean here but if it has to do with more sarcasm and insults, that isn't very productive.

No sarcasm or insult intended, just trying to clarify that the one piece of evidence that does not seem to get mentioned much (in this kind of debate) is what the assessment of an individual child’s condition is.
 
The child ultimately doesn't care, if the circumcision is done right. The pain - if any - is fleeting, and in the long term, the child doesn't remember the pain and doesn't suffer any side-effects. So that empathy plea isn't going to work, either.

If it was such a traumatic and life-damaging experience, it wouldn't be so common in the U.S. Men wouldn't be insisting such a painful and useless procedure be done on their male children - we're not inherently cruel, you know. And that goes for men from all walks of life (excepting the fundies of any given group), including men raised atheist. So you can't even claim that they were obeying their religious precepts over their latent memories of pain and fear.

What the infant feels is a non-issue.
 
Mmmm...interesting. :cool:

It's food for thought, but I have to disagree, ultimately, with the idea that "to accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability." I can accept their decision because ultimately, I don't think circumcision is particularly harmful. (I brought this up again with my husband last night and he agreed it's not something that's ever bothered him one way or another. That's the thing--I don't see it as a huge moral issue, I just see it as medically unnecessary, which is not the same thing as actively harmful.) But that doesn't mean I have to agree with the decision. Personally, I think if I don't agree with it, I shouldn't do it. As you say, reasonable people may come to different conclusions. ;)

I could postulate a decision that I would disagree with so vehemently that I would not even consider being involved with it, or even one so against what I see as the patient's best interests that I would be willing to take legal action to prevent its being acted on. (The ethics committee/legal department has had two of those since I've been in school--no one likes that.) But this just isn't that decision.

Somewhere backalong you said something about no behavior (pardon the American spelling) having been changed if I passed on the decision. Not quite true. I mean, mine has been, right? :D

I think that your behaviour is immaterial, except maybe to serve to emphasize your disagreement with the parents' choice. And this may be a good thing. I think ethical concerns can and should be a part of some discussions. But I am more interested in whether others understand and have given due consideration to the issues, than I am about whether we ultimately agree, because otherwise I worry that I am attempting to impose my own beliefs onto someone else. When you make a point of saying that you won't perform circumcisions for non-medical reasons, it could be taken as though you are allowing your beliefs to take priority over the beliefs of your patient's surrogate decision makers. What saves you is that the circumstances won't actually result in a denial of service, so it really just serves to somewhat quantify the strength of your disagreement. I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.

I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.

Linda
 
I think that your behaviour is immaterial, except maybe to serve to emphasize your disagreement with the parents' choice. And this may be a good thing. I think ethical concerns can and should be a part of some discussions. But I am more interested in whether others understand and have given due consideration to the issues, than I am about whether we ultimately agree, because otherwise I worry that I am attempting to impose my own beliefs onto someone else. When you make a point of saying that you won't perform circumcisions for non-medical reasons, it could be taken as though you are allowing your beliefs to take priority over the beliefs of your patient's surrogate decision makers. What saves you is that the circumstances won't actually result in a denial of service, so it really just serves to somewhat quantify the strength of your disagreement. I just think it should be made clear that what we are talking about is whether it is appropriate for you specifically and for physicians generally to make their judgment on this issue part of the discussion.

I don't have an answer, I just don't think it should be left up to individual physicians to take it upon themselves.

Linda


So you see no role for your own judgment in the care of your patients?
 
BlackKat said:
Never said it was uncommon. I said it was one of about 10 different FGM practices, and that is was rarely done in exclusion. You keep saying Type I is the most common. Type I is the excision of the clitoris and/or the labia.

Again: (the most recent survey done! )
http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/FGM-C_final_10_October.pdf

In the majority of countries that have included
questions regarding type of FGM/C, excision
of the prepuce
(Type 1) is found to be the most
common
. Only in Burkina Faso is excision of the
clitoris (Type 2) found to be most frequent.

BlackKat said:
Again you know this is true but you are arguing not because you don't think I'm right because you are trying to cast aspersions on my statement that the foreskin is not important.
I'm saying there's no reason to believe they are not THE SAME. Removing the clitoral prepuce or the penis's foreskin...it is extremely similar. There is no evidence that one is "worse" than the other.

That does not sound like aesthetics to me. Now keep reading below that in the article and it lists the short and long term effects of FGM. Guess what? Men who are circumcised do not suffer those effects.
You can not compare the medical complications that happen in the two thirds world with the complications that happen in industrialized nations. Male circumcision "over there" often results in all kinds of horrible things we don't see over here.

No if the parents wanted to perform on a female or male infant ritual scarring, most forms of piercing, tattooing... it's also their choice so long as it is done in as sterile and painless way as is medically viable. And so long as these things will not negatively impact the child's future.
You've provided no evidence that removing the clitoral prepuce from an infant girl does anything "bad" that removing the penile foreskin from an infant male does not. Yes, logically, it's removing nerves and will result in desensitization from friction. But guess what? That happens in boys, too.

You're trying to make equivalent two completely separate, and distinctly different, procedures and it is not working. That's like saying red is blue because they're both colors.

It's more like arguing the the differences between "blanco" and "white".

Try arguing just about the merits or detriments of circumcision rather than trying to make circumcision into something that it's not.
The merits of the milder forms of FGM are largely unknown because the practice is viewed as barbaric. We do have evidence that it decreases HIV, though. (that was discovered accidentally when researchers were attempting to prove the opposite). Logically, ulcerative genital sores from various STDs could be reduced by some forms, too.
So there are some parallels there with the benefits of male circumcision.
The "down sides" would be similar, as well. (desensitization, primarily).

Z said:
What the infant feels is a non-issue.
I have no idea how to respond to that other than to say I totally disagree.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom