Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I have no problem with other doctors performing circumcisions, if that is what they feel to be correct. That is their decision.

From where I sit, it appears you're sidestepping the real issue, that is the right of a human not to be mutilated without consent or medical necessity.

You're saying, hey, if you want to cut pieces off your newborn infant for whatever reason, that's your decision. But does the infant get no say in the matter? The infant CANNOT protest or understand what is happening.

I just don't see how someone can support that, or even adopt a que sera sera attitude towards such an obvious breach of human rights.
 
Did you watch the video of the circumcision being performed, apparently without pain relief?

If it was not a baby, but an adult, would it be "a huge moral issue" for you?

What if that pain was inflicted on you, but then you could be made to forget it, would you be up for that?

From my point of view infants make the perfect victims; they're small, can't speak and don't explicitly remember the pain that was inflicted upon them if it is done early enough in their existence.

I agree that the removal of foreskin is not a particularly big ethical issue in itself. The conditions under which it is removed are. Did you catch the earlier post that stated it looks like less than half of infant circumcisions in the US use anaesthetic?

Perhaps that was what Linda was talking about, if you did it, you would make sure the infant went through the minimum amount of suffering.

Easy there, cowboy. I agree with you, remember?

I don't need to watch the video or read the stats. I just finished both my pediatric and OB/GYN rotations. I've seen them done, live. (I happened to do both rotations at the same hospital and all of the doctors I observed used EMLA cream.)

Simple fact is, we do have to do some very unpleasant things to kids, and once you have gone through this training, it does change your viewpoint somewhat. That's not to say that I minimize the pain involved. That's a major issue I have with the procedure--why on earth do an unnecessary invasive procedure, and doing it without anaesthsia is simply unethical, as far as I'm concerned. However, the main issue I have with it is not with the pain itself, because that can be minimized. My main issue with it is the permanent alteration, for no good medical reason that I can see. There it sounds like we disagree. Are you saying you wouldn't have a problem with it if there was sufficient pain relief?

Don't get the idea that I'm not empathetic about the trauma. I am. I hate listening to kids scream, and I hate when we have to hurt them. We try not to. It's hard to explain this without resorting to the sort of emotional appeal I was arguing against earlier. It's just that I *have* seen circumcisions, and honestly, they are much less upsetting that some other things we have to do. I still cringe every time I see an attending trying to thread an IV into a premie's arm or leg. But let's be careful about calling the baby a 'victim'.

Once more--I *agree* with your position. I'm not sure why you're responding so personally to what I said.
 
You're saying, hey, if you want to cut pieces off your newborn infant for whatever reason, that's your decision. But does the infant get no say in the matter? The infant CANNOT protest or understand what is happening.

No, that's a silly reductio ad absurdum rephrasing of what I'm saying. I'm saying I don't intend to perform them, at all, for any non-medical purpose. For much the reason you state--I feel that it is a decision that should only be made by someone who is old enough to understand what is being done and request it for themselves.

However, that is my opinion and I do not presume to speak for all medical professionals. I'm not even a full-fledged medical professional yet. Maybe some of them might know more than I do. Maybe all of them who do it are wrong. I just don't think I know everything. I'm willing to argue the point to my colleagues. What I'm not willing to do is to paint everything black and white. I don't think that parents or doctor or mohels or whoever wants it done are intrinsically evil.
 
Easy there, cowboy. I agree with you, remember?

I obviously didn’t express myself very well. Must try harder:(

I don't need to watch the video or read the stats. I just finished both my pediatric and OB/GYN rotations. I've seen them done, live. (I happened to do both rotations at the same hospital and all of the doctors I observed used EMLA cream.)

If what other people have said is still the case, it seems to be a very mixed situation across the US. This is the biggest issue for me. Except for emergency situations, I can think of virtually no reason to perform surgery without some kind of pain relief.

Simple fact is, we do have to do some very unpleasant things to kids, and once you have gone through this training, it does change your viewpoint somewhat. That's not to say that I minimize the pain involved. That's a major issue I have with the procedure--why on earth do an unnecessary invasive procedure, and doing it without anaesthsia is simply unethical, as far as I'm concerned. However, the main issue I have with it is not with the pain itself, because that can be minimized. My main issue with it is the permanent alteration, for no good medical reason that I can see. There it sounds like we disagree. Are you saying you wouldn't have a problem with it if there was sufficient pain relief?

No, I’m saying that without pain relief I see no difference between circumcision of infants and torture. Without pain relief, I wouldn’t care if it offered 100% protection against HIV.

However, if significant pain relief is used, then I can see a role for it, as the research in Africa has demonstrated. I can accept that most men in the situation they find themselves there would choose to be circumcised, as my earlier post with the report from the focus group in Zambia appeared to indicate. Thus I could accept Linda’s argument that the parent’s in that situation would likely be expressing what the child would want when it’s an adult.

In the developed world I still see significant ethical problems for doctors operating on healthy patients for no valid medical reason just because the parents request it.

I too can watch or make other people suffer if I know the actions being taken by others or myself are going to provide them with a significant benefit. I hope you understand what I mean when I say this.

Don't get the idea that I'm not empathetic about the trauma. I am. I hate listening to kids scream, and I hate when we have to hurt them. We try not to. It's hard to explain this without resorting to the sort of emotional appeal I was arguing against earlier. It's just that I *have* seen circumcisions, and honestly, they are much less upsetting that some other things we have to do. I still cringe every time I see an attending trying to thread an IV into a premie's arm or leg. But let's be careful about calling the baby a 'victim'.

I used the word victim because I was referring to the child in the video (or another in the same situation), where (I assumed) the child was healthy (i.e. the circumcision was not required), had been given no pain relief and was screaming as hard as it could when the doctor was operating.

As an aside, I showed my mother the video and she nearly passed out. It didn’t make me feel faint, just angry.

Once more--I *agree* with your position. I'm not sure why you're responding so personally to what I said.

Again, sorry if the way I phrased my reply sounded like I was having a go at you. I’m not. Actually, your situation interests me. I may be sending you a PM asking you a few questions… (Nice ones, I promise) :)
 
EMLA cream isn't all that effective, is it?
I mean, it's better than nothing, but only by a very small percentage compared to a dorsal penile nerve block?
 
Evidence?

This is clearly a compelling delusion for you. Got any evidence that what you claim is actually true?

So... are we "deluded" for stating that the clitoris and labia are essential body parts which ought not to be removed? It really sounds like kellyb does not think they are essential even though the "Evidence?" was probably not intended that way.

Or is it that the "foreskin" is not necessary. Like I've said dozens of times already in this thread. I have no foreskin. My penis is perfect. You have a foreskin. Your penis is perfect. The best evidence anyone here can provide about circumcision is all anecdotes on both sides. The only purpose for the foreskin which has been clearly stated here is to lessen friction during intercourse. Have not had any chaffing myself, nor had a partner complain.

The medical studies on foreskins or lack thereof are all inconclusive (and should be because they sample a whopping 100 or 200 people in one hospital which does not guarantee any sort of accuracy.). The studies go both ways but with very small majorities in very small sample groups. Nobody here can show me a comprehensive study that shows men with foreskins are better off, nor can I show you a comprehensive study that shows men without foreskins are better off.

If someone performs a worldwide study with millions of participants from all over the globe which points one direction or the other... then maybe one of us will have "Evidence". Until then I'm pretty happy with our current "to each his or her own" practice of providing parents with all the pros and cons and letting them decide.

Maybe it would be better for everyone to wait until puberty to decide... but I personally am glad that a quick snip snip was performed on me as a baby when it was still an easy procedure over having my penis in a cast for a week at 13. An anecdote I know... but it's all we've got here.
 
Last edited:
EMLA cream isn't all that effective, is it?
I mean, it's better than nothing, but only by a very small percentage compared to a dorsal penile nerve block?

No, it's not, based totally unscientifically on my own experimental methodology (meaning that I put it on the back of my hand). It does numb you, but I could still tell the difference between a needle and a dull touch (I didn't use that much and I didn't wait twenty minutes, though). I do know that a lot of residents or attendings have said that they don't use it for procedures like IVs and blood draws because they say it also dilates the capillaries in the area and can make it harder overall. I know a couple who use it for LPs. Not sure how effective it is there either.

I've never seen anyone use a nerve block on an infant. Frankly, I don't know a thing about them as regards this issue.
 
BlackKat said:
So... are we "deluded" for stating that the clitoris and labia are essential body parts which ought not to be removed?
You said the clitoral prepuce was essential. I want to know where you're getting that idea from. Same thing for the labia, both major and minor. You obviously are holding this as some kind of fact in your mind while being either unable or unwilling to support it with evidence.
If your opinion is not based on evidence of any kind, what is it based on, other than wish?

It really sounds like kellyb does not think they are essential even though the "Evidence?" was probably not intended that way.
I have no reason to believe they're any more essential than the foreskin of the penis. And neither do you, apparently.
 
You said the clitoral prepuce was essential. I want to know where you're getting that idea from. Same thing for the labia, both major and minor. You obviously are holding this as some kind of fact in your mind while being either unable or unwilling to support it with evidence.
If your opinion is not based on evidence of any kind, what is it based on, other than wish?


I have no reason to believe they're any more essential than the foreskin of the penis. And neither do you, apparently.

There are women who have surgery because they are not happy with their labia. Take a read of this.
 
Last edited:
You said the clitoral prepuce was essential. I want to know where you're getting that idea from. Same thing for the labia, both major and minor. You obviously are holding this as some kind of fact in your mind while being either unable or unwilling to support it with evidence.
If your opinion is not based on evidence of any kind, what is it based on, other than wish?


I have no reason to believe they're any more essential than the foreskin of the penis. And neither do you, apparently.


Well... do I need to provide reference material as to what the various parts of the vulva do or are you just playing devil's advocate?

Do a google search for female anatomy will provide you with countless sources of information if you do not already know what the different parts are for. Most of us have known them since Sex Ed class or book or since our mom told us or from relations with our significant others.
Here ya go... you can even watch the movie (no it's not one of /those/ movies):
http://www.dermlectures.com/LecturesWMV.cfm?lectureID=78

The purposes of the foreskin, as we've learned in this thread, have been listed as follows:
1. To keep the penis glans warm and protected from cold weather
2. To aid in intercourse by providing an extra layer of lubrication and flexible skin
3. To aid in intercourse by providing more nerve endings

These have been countered repeatedly in this thread by the following points:
1. Wear pants when you go outside unless it's hot! (sorry nudists)
2. Men without foreskins have found that arousing the female prior to intercourse (foreplay) creates adequate levels of lubrication.
3. Men without foreskins have not been shown to require additional time or stimulation in order to achieve orgasms, and are just as likely or not likely to prematurely ejaculate (thus we think dull or repulsive thoughts during intercourse to prolong it)


As I understand it from a combination of Sex Ed, reading, girlfriends:
If I was female and had my clitoris and labia removed I would be losing my primary source of sexual satisfaction and constantly have issues with infections by bacteria and foreign matter. Having my clitoral hood removed would likely (but not necessarily) result in overstimulus of the clitoris to the point where it did not create pleasurable sensations. This is why trimming or removing the clitoral hood is not quite an exact compliment to male circumcision.

I am male and had my foreskin removed and I do not have a cold penis, nor is it chaffed, nor is it numb.
 
BlackKat said:
Well... do I need to provide reference material as to what the various parts of the vulva do or are you just playing devil's advocate?
I seriously want to know if you have any evidence that bad things happen when the prepuce or labia are removed in part or in whole.
You said it was all "essential" and I'm challenging you to back your claim.


BlackKat said:
Having my clitoral hood removed would likely (but not necessarily) result in overstimulus of the clitoris to the point where it did not create pleasurable sensations.

Where are you getting that from?
(I don't have sound on my computer at the moment so I can't watch videos.)
 
Last edited:
OK, I didn't want to participate in this, but BlackKat: FGM is not comparable to male castration, as FGM doesn't remove the reproductive capabilities of women.

/just wanted to point that out.
 
OK, I didn't want to participate in this, but BlackKat: FGM is not comparable to male castration, as FGM doesn't remove the reproductive capabilities of women.

/just wanted to point that out.

Understood. But FGM is a helluva lot closer to castration than it is to circumcision.
 
Understood. But FGM is a helluva lot closer to castration than it is to circumcision.

Only some types. Type 1 (by the WHO classification) is very much equivalent to a male circumcision.

By the way anyone got some good statistics of the percentage of each type of FGM?
 
I seriously want to know if you have any evidence that bad things happen when the prepuce or labia are removed in part or in whole.
You said it was all "essential" and I'm challenging you to back your claim.




Where are you getting that from?
(I don't have sound on my computer at the moment so I can't watch videos.)

I thought I was pretty clear where I am getting that from. A combination of Sex Ed Class, Sex Ed books, females I have known, and the internet. But if you demand a precise source site, if you go to the site I linked the full text of the narrator is right below the video pane. It is not where I got the information from, but does coincide with what I already knew.

So I am a little confused by all these accusations of essentiality...
Are you saying that parts of the female genitals are not essential and that some forms of FGM are ok?
This is not a black and white issue. One thing can be WRONG while another separate thing can be INCONCLUSIVE. Nobody in this post ever claimed circumcision to be the BEST thing to do to a penis. Even those of us who said we like circumcisions have not said they should be done without forethought. Some people claimed it might be wise to in areas with high levels of HIV infections. But even those claims were offered with caveats.
 
Only some types. Type 1 (by the WHO classification) is very much equivalent to a male circumcision.

By the way anyone got some good statistics of the percentage of each type of FGM?

Well Type 1 on the WHO site (http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/):
* Type I - excision of the prepuce, with or without excision of part or all of the clitoris;

Sounds rather broad...
If it's just the prepuce maybe... but the clitoris is a lot more sensitive than the glans. Exposing one does not equate to exposing the other.

And according to the same page:
The most common type of female genital mutilation is excision of the clitoris and the labia minora, accounting for up to 80% of all cases; the most extreme form is infibulation, which constitutes about 15% of all procedures.
 
BlackKat said:
I thought I was pretty clear where I am getting that from. A combination of Sex Ed Class, Sex Ed books, females I have known, and the internet.

Ooooh...I see...
You're making it up. Okey dokey then. :)

Are you saying that parts of the female genitals are not essential and that some forms of FGM are ok?
No, but I don't think MGM is ok, either.
It also depends on how you define "essential", I guess, though.

Darat said:
By the way anyone got some good statistics of the percentage of each type of FGM?

This is a 2005 survey...the most recent I've been able to find:
http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/FGM-C_final_10_October.pdf

In the majority of countries that have included
questions regarding type of FGM/C, excision
of the prepuce (Type 1) is found to be the most
common.
Only in Burkina Faso is excision of the
clitoris (Type 2) found to be most frequent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom