Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

...
Is it your view that an infant does not have the right to body integrity?
Look, I am not the only one with my perspective. I am following the recommendations of The American Academy of Pediatrics, and The American Academy of Family Physicians, which I also happen to agree with. I posted their position statements. You want me to accede to your emotional appeal. It ain't gonna happen. When the evidence based medical consensus changes, I'll change.
 
I don't speak for all parents, of course, but it was a major deciding factor in my spouse's and my decision to not circumcise our son. Specifically, we wanted his to look like what his peers' will look like.
I think this is a compelling reason. You decided, and you state which of the deciding factors were most relevant to your decision.
 
... My viewpoint is ....
The position of the AAP and the AAFP is to give the parents the information in an unbiased way. If you can rationalize your viewpoint, then you should be able to convey it to any parent whose child you are caring for.

Why after having done that, would you not respect the values they then used to make their decision?
 
The position of the AAP and the AAFP is to give the parents the information in an unbiased way. If you can rationalize your viewpoint, then you should be able to convey it to any parent whose child you are caring for.

Why after having done that, would you not respect the values they then used to make their decision?

:jaw-dropp

If, after reading the last few posts I have made, you seriously think you can justify saying that I would not respect the values of parents...I don't think there is any point in continuing this discussion. That is far more judgmental than anything I have even implied and is, frankly, insulting.

I was willing to let the whole "alternate philosophies" idea slide, even though I very much disagree with any such notion. Nurses do not have a monopoly on 'teaching' and 'assisting' and 'helping'. If you honestly think that you can do any of that without conveying an opinion, without 'deciding', 'recommending' or 'knowing an answer', you are kidding yourself at best. 'Unbiased' does not mean the same thing as 'unknowledgable'.

Your viewpoint is clear. You think circumcision is a good thing. Fine. You will have to accept the fact that there are other medical professionals who disagree with you. And the reason that people keep responding to the idea that you are espousing the concept of circumcising American boys for the purpose of avoiding HIV infection is that you keep responding this way to those of us who are making the point that it does not apply in non-Third-World nations with posts like these.

I remember a previous thread where you took on a rather obvious troll about the parallel nature of the professions of medicine and nursing, and I also recall posting in your support. I am now inclined to reassess my support, because you are now sounding very much like the bad caricature of a nurse who wishes she were a doctor. And I would prefer not to think that of anybody, because I prefer not to think that such a creature exists.

Let me state for the record that, although I am only a fourth-year medical student, I am not a kid. I'm 39 years old and had a couple of careers prior to returning to school to become a doctor. I have the utmost respect for my patients and for those who make decisions for them. That is why I feel I should give them the benefit of the knowledge I have worked so hard to acquire. To suggest acquiescing to anything else in the name of "values" is to condescend to them. I have made it clear that I would never try to prevent a parent who, having heard my opinion, still wanted the procedure, from having it done.

Exactly where do you find an attack on a patient's parents values in that?
 
...
Skeptigirl's own analogy of the "no big deal" quality of the procedure compared to debridement or chemotherapy, which I just noticed, also strikes me as peculiarly inappropriate. These are horrible things to have to do, to see, or to undergo. But they are unequivocably necessary to try and save that patient's life. These examples are also, forgive me, an attempt at emotional appeal.
You are again taking two different things here and blurring them.

The point I was making was, on a scale of one to ten how tragic/traumatic did I view a circumcision because Ivor asked about how I perceived them.

You're blurring the point into something about decision making. There is no emotional appeal to anyone in my statement. I gave an example to illustrate how I viewed something.
 
Look, I am not the only one with my perspective. I am following the recommendations of The American Academy of Pediatrics, and The American Academy of Family Physicians, which I also happen to agree with. I posted their position statements. You want me to accede to your emotional appeal. It ain't gonna happen. When the evidence based medical consensus changes, I'll change.

Nice dodge. It is not an appeal to emotion; it’s an appeal to logical (i.e. consistent) reasoning. Something you think you’re rather good at. All you’ve said above is that you're just following orders. That’s not very logical, Skeptigirl.

Let’s try again.

Is it your view that an infant does _not_ have the right to body integrity? I.e., that the parent’s rights to choose trump the child’s rights to not have an unnecessary medical procedure, based on the available* evidence, that will permanently alter their body.

Yes or No will do, but I’d prefer a reasoned, consistent argument, if you think one is possible for your position. However, I doubt you’ll answer because the cognitive dissonance I think you have on this issue will make you dismiss my question as stupid or emotional.

It seems I can change my position on circumcision for increased resistance to HIV infection in Africa, but you can’t do the same for unnecessary (based on the evidence) circumcisions in the US. Ah well, I suppose no one can be sceptical all the time about all issues.

*The available evidence includes an individual assessment by a professional of the child’s body. Seems a lot of people in the US currently tend to weight that bit of evidence rather lightly when it disagrees with their wishes.
 
You are again taking two different things here and blurring them.

The point I was making was, on a scale of one to ten how tragic/traumatic did I view a circumcision because Ivor asked about how I perceived them.

You're blurring the point into something about decision making. There is no emotional appeal to anyone in my statement. I gave an example to illustrate how I viewed something.

Actually, I think your reaction to circumcision has been attenuated because you have seen children in even more pain and suffering. This is similar to my work colleague who commented it's amazing how quickly people get used to the kids begging for food while on their way back to a luxury villa. It's most likely a survival mechanism that keeps us able to function.

I had to do it while watching my father die over a period of 12 months. Many of the nurses at the hospice where he died appeared to do it to.

Empathy is fine so long as you can do something about it or get away, otherwise it just immobilises you.
 
Again, I agree, but what can you do except pick your battles? Ethical issues are always challenging. (I've been a student member of our hospital's ethics committee since first year; some of the cases have been doozies.) It wouldn't make me feel better to pass it off, but it would make me feel better to know that I've refused to do something I don't agree with.

The results of doctors disagreeing with putative caretakers came to its unbelievably ridiculous worst-case scenario in the Schiavo case, for example. There are topics I'd go to the mat for, but I just don't know that circumcision can be one of them. I am perfectly willing to argue with my colleagues on this subject, and I'm sure I will. At the end of the day, though, realistically speaking, my choices are to accept the parents' decision or to permanently alienate them. I suppose I could say that they need to find the alternate doctor themselves, but I don't think that's ethically justifiable either.

I'm sort of thinking of the opposite response - that you accept the parents' decision by performing the procedure yourself. I know it sounds weird, but I think it forces you to take a harder look at the issue than you would by otherwise taking the easier route. I'm not really advocating that you do this, I'm just bringing it up for consideration. I have this same argument with my colleagues - not about circumcision, but about refusing treatment, for example, of active smokers. Disagreement is the rule there, too. :)

To accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability. If you discover that your strong feelings against that decision interfere with your ability to provide the best care, then it is reasonable to pass part (or all) of that care on to a colleague.

I think we're just kind of talking at cross-purposes--I'm talking about an individual level, and you're talking about the profession's entire attitude. I do think that more and more doctors are coming around on this issue, but it's going to take time before everyone is convinced. In the aggregate, I think the rates are dipping, right?--just not as quickly as we might like. I'll be spreading the word, though.

I just wanted to bring up a different perspective about what it means to interfere with the care of an individual.

Linda

(This is also meant to be an answer to your second post to me.)
 
I think you're both relying rather heavily on appeals to emotion.

For my own part, no, I don't think infants have a right to bodily integrity - I think they have a right to reasonable levels of bodily integrity, meaning they have a right to have sufficient bodily integrity to function normally, but anything further is the right and responsibility of the parents to decide. For example, if a child is born with webbed feet, or an extra finger, or a deformed face, the parents should have the right to correct these errors without needing the child's permission - and I think most of us would agree, since these are deformities. But is it medically necessary to remove webbing or extra fingers? Is it medically necessary to restructure the face to more closely resemble everyone elses? Not necessarily. These cosmetic changes might make life easier for the child, but they aren't required (in every case) for preservation of life or prevention of disease or whatever.

The only real difference with the issue of foreskin, is that it's NORMAL to be born with the foreskin. But removing it clearly does NOT significantly impair either function or enjoyment (I will concede that it MAY impair enjoyment minimally). So removing a foreskin is akin to removing an extra finger or webbing between the toes - or removing the appendix or the tonsils or a vestigial tail, or excessive labia. To me, the parent has the right and responsibility in these cases. Just as the parent has the right to pierce ears, or in other cultures to tattoo their children. Just as the parent has the right to decide whether or not to cut a child's hair, or how the child will dress, or whether the child will wear contacts, glasses, or get corrective surgery, and so forth.

I suppose I would change the statement to read 'functional bodily integrity', allowing for the removal or alteration of non-vital portions. And evidence so far concerning the foreskin see-saws back and forth so much, based entirely on who is doing the research, that it's not clear that the foreskin is vital. Personal experience says it is not, and that in fact the foreskin is a burden, not a necessity.

But it's interesting that the UN statement says one thing, while the WHO statement says something entirely different, isn't it? You'd think they'd talk at least ONCE in a while... :D

(By the way, Beleth: I'm glad you've never had to interact with any child professionals. You're fortunate to have children that are free of the many problems that have plagued both my children and my stepchildren - autism, sensory integration, an abusive father [in the case of my stepkids], malformation of the feet [correctable, thank the Goddess], ear issues requiring tubes for three of our kids, delayed speech and walking [due to the same ear problems]... And if your kids DO have similar problems and you HAVEN'T dealt with those professionals - then I strongly question your parenting skills. But I hope that it's just that you've been blessed with genetically superior stock. I married into a genetic smorgasborg of flaws and errors, so my children's flaws are my own fault; and as to my stepkids, I strongly suspect that a few branches on their father's family tree connect at both ends to the trunk...)
 
The only real difference with the issue of foreskin, is that it's NORMAL to be born with the foreskin. But removing it clearly does NOT significantly impair either function or enjoyment (I will concede that it MAY impair enjoyment minimally). So removing a foreskin is akin to removing an extra finger or webbing between the toes - or removing the appendix or the tonsils or a vestigial tail, or excessive labia.


If having a foreskin is normal, as you concede then, by your own definition, removing it is an abnormal thing to do, especially as normal people would not say that it was in any way similar to having an extra finger or a tail.

It is nothing more than a medically unnecessary personal cosmetic choice of the parents. As such it no different to docking the tails of dogs, a barbaric practice which is now held in contempt by decent people.
 
Ok Linda, so you’re ignoring me again. I'm getting used to it:)

Here's what you said earlier in reply when I asked you:

Ivor said:
What I'm trying to understand is where your limit is. What act performed towards a child leads you to conclude that it should not be tolerated?

fls said:
...My personal threshold is quite low, but my public threshold is much higher. I tend to be someone that is reluctant to impose my opinions onto others, so I usually require a moderately strong reason to do so. Plus my ethical consideration of others is strongly influenced by medical ethics, which promotes more of a hands-off, self-autonomy attitude than is usually acceptable to the general public.

Then in reply to HawkeyeMD’s post (which she posted in reply to Skeptigirl):

HawkeyeMD replying to Skeptigirl said:
Your lecture in response to my final comment is not appreciated. I did not say that I would "judge" parents who chose circumcision. I will explain what I see to be the pros and cons of the procedure and, if they still want it done, refer them elsewhere. It is also not "practicing good medicine" to perform any procedure just because a patient or a parent desires it. At this time, my opinion is that for a child who will grow up in a country like the USA--which is where I will practice--there is not sufficient medical justification for circumcision. The evidence from the African studies is still very much being debated, but that is not really germane to the question of circumcision in the US. (I appreciate the argument about teenagers making poor decisions, but I can't really get behind the idea of permanently altering someone's body structure because of decisions you anticipate that they will make down the line, either.)

I have no problem with other doctors performing circumcisions, if that is what they feel to be correct. That is their decision.

You posted this:

fls said:
The problem I have with taking this stance, is that it essentially passes the buck so that one can make a show of advocating for one's patient or taking a moral position, without actually doing so. After all, no behaviour has been changed if it is simply someone else that does the procedure.

I think we have a duty to be willing to be more proactive than that.

Linda

So which is it Linda: Hands-off or proactive?
 
Z said:
For my own part, no, I don't think infants have a right to bodily integrity - I think they have a right to reasonable levels of bodily integrity, meaning they have a right to have sufficient bodily integrity to function normally, but anything further is the right and responsibility of the parents to decide. For example, if a child is born with webbed feet, or an extra finger, or a deformed face, the parents should have the right to correct these errors without needing the child's permission - and I think most of us would agree, since these are deformities. But is it medically necessary to remove webbing or extra fingers? Is it medically necessary to restructure the face to more closely resemble everyone elses? Not necessarily. These cosmetic changes might make life easier for the child, but they aren't required (in every case) for preservation of life or prevention of disease or whatever.

The only real difference with the issue of foreskin, is that it's NORMAL to be born with the foreskin. But removing it clearly does NOT significantly impair either function or enjoyment (I will concede that it MAY impair enjoyment minimally). So removing a foreskin is akin to removing an extra finger or webbing between the toes - or removing the appendix or the tonsils or a vestigial tail, or excessive labia.

You're contradicting yourself here. On one hand, you say that a foreskin is not a deformity, and on the other, you're saying it's removal is like correcting a deformity.
Can't have it both ways.

In the Wester world, we have Muslim immigrants who wish for their daughters to be circumcised. Do you think the removal of the clitoral prepuce and/or labia should be allowed for these cases when it's accepted and normal for their culture?
 
I'm sort of thinking of the opposite response - that you accept the parents' decision by performing the procedure yourself. I know it sounds weird, but I think it forces you to take a harder look at the issue than you would by otherwise taking the easier route. I'm not really advocating that you do this, I'm just bringing it up for consideration. I have this same argument with my colleagues - not about circumcision, but about refusing treatment, for example, of active smokers. Disagreement is the rule there, too. :)

To accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability. If you discover that your strong feelings against that decision interfere with your ability to provide the best care, then it is reasonable to pass part (or all) of that care on to a colleague.


Mmmm...interesting. :cool:

It's food for thought, but I have to disagree, ultimately, with the idea that "to accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability." I can accept their decision because ultimately, I don't think circumcision is particularly harmful. (I brought this up again with my husband last night and he agreed it's not something that's ever bothered him one way or another. That's the thing--I don't see it as a huge moral issue, I just see it as medically unnecessary, which is not the same thing as actively harmful.) But that doesn't mean I have to agree with the decision. Personally, I think if I don't agree with it, I shouldn't do it. As you say, reasonable people may come to different conclusions. ;)

I could postulate a decision that I would disagree with so vehemently that I would not even consider being involved with it, or even one so against what I see as the patient's best interests that I would be willing to take legal action to prevent its being acted on. (The ethics committee/legal department has had two of those since I've been in school--no one likes that.) But this just isn't that decision.

Somewhere backalong you said something about no behavior (pardon the American spelling) having been changed if I passed on the decision. Not quite true. I mean, mine has been, right? :D
 
You're contradicting yourself here. On one hand, you say that a foreskin is not a deformity, and on the other, you're saying it's removal is like correcting a deformity.
Can't have it both ways.

In the Wester world, we have Muslim immigrants who wish for their daughters to be circumcised. Do you think the removal of the clitoral prepuce and/or labia should be allowed for these cases when it's accepted and normal for their culture?

You can't compare most cases FGM with circumcision. That's like comparing an ear piercing to cutting off an ear. The only "operation" on the penis that compares to the most common forms of FGM is castration. As far as I know there are no cultures where castration is done to infants. Back in the days of the eunuch maybe...

So no, FGM should not be allowed despite it being part of their culture because we don't allow castration.

There is a rarer form of FGM where a small incision is made in the clitoral hood to expose the clitoris but neither it, nor the clitoris, is removed at all. This /might/ be considered equivalent to circumcision except that the clitoris is not an exact equivalent to the penis glans.
 
Last edited:
You can't compare most cases FGM with circumcision. That's like comparing an ear piercing to cutting off an ear. The only "operation" on the penis that compares to the most common forms of FGM is castration. As far as I know there are no cultures where castration is done to infants. Back in the days of the eunuch maybe...

So no, FGM should not be allowed despite it being part of their culture because we don't allow castration.

There is a rarer form of FGM where a small incision is made in the clitoral hood to expose the clitoris but neither it, nor the clitoris, is removed at all. This /might/ be considered equivalent to circumcision except that the clitoris is not an exact equivalent to the penis glans.

COME ON, DUDE.
All you responded with was a straw man. I'm not talking about cutting off ears or castration. I'm asking about removal of the clitoral prepuce and/or labia.
Would that or would that not be ok if the child was coming from and would remain actively involved in a culture where it was accepted, expected, and normal?
 
COME ON, DUDE.
All you responded with was a straw man. I'm not talking about cutting off ears or castration. I'm asking about removal of the clitoral prepuce and/or labia.
Would that or would that not be ok if the child was coming from and would remain actively involved in a culture where it was accepted, expected, and normal?

The problem here is the inclusion of labia and the word removal rather than pierce or trim.

Piercing or trimming the clitoral hood will not impede sexual functionality. Removal could as it is designed to protect the clitoris from excessive friction. Removal of the labia, which protect the vaginal and urethral openings, is also detrimental.

So you are trying to compare the complete removal of essential parts of the body (the female clitoral hood and labia) with a non-critical part of the body (the male foreskin). They just don't match up.

If you are against the removal of the foreskin (despite the arguments of circumcised males who are happy) that is your perrogative. Please do not try to compare it to FGM though as they are barely similar.
 
Last edited:
The problem here is the inclusion of labia and the word removal rather than pierce or trim.

Piercing or trimming the clitoral hood will not impede sexual functionality. Removal could as it is designed to protect the clitoris from excessive friction. Removal of the labia, which protect the vaginal and urethral openings, is also detrimental.

So you are trying to compare the complete removal of essential parts of the body (the female clitoral hood and labia) with a non-critical part of the body (the male foreskin). They just don't match up.

If you are against the removal of the foreskin (despite the arguments of circumcised males who are happy) that is your perrogative. Please do not try to compare it to FGM though as they are barely similar.

This is clearly a compelling delusion for you. Got any evidence that what you claim is actually true?
 
Mmmm...interesting. :cool:

It's food for thought, but I have to disagree, ultimately, with the idea that "to accept their decision means that you help them carry it out to the best of your ability." I can accept their decision because ultimately, I don't think circumcision is particularly harmful. (I brought this up again with my husband last night and he agreed it's not something that's ever bothered him one way or another. That's the thing--I don't see it as a huge moral issue, I just see it as medically unnecessary, which is not the same thing as actively harmful.) But that doesn't mean I have to agree with the decision. Personally, I think if I don't agree with it, I shouldn't do it. As you say, reasonable people may come to different conclusions. ;)

I could postulate a decision that I would disagree with so vehemently that I would not even consider being involved with it, or even one so against what I see as the patient's best interests that I would be willing to take legal action to prevent its being acted on. (The ethics committee/legal department has had two of those since I've been in school--no one likes that.) But this just isn't that decision.

Somewhere backalong you said something about no behavior (pardon the American spelling) having been changed if I passed on the decision. Not quite true. I mean, mine has been, right? :D

Did you watch the video of the circumcision being performed, apparently without pain relief?

If it was not a baby, but an adult, would it be "a huge moral issue" for you?

What if that pain was inflicted on you, but then you could be made to forget it, would you be up for that?

From my point of view infants make the perfect victims; they're small, can't speak and don't explicitly remember the pain that was inflicted upon them if it is done early enough in their existence.

I agree that the removal of foreskin is not a particularly big ethical issue in itself. The conditions under which it is removed are. Did you catch the earlier post that stated it looks like less than half of infant circumcisions in the US use anaesthetic?

Perhaps that was what Linda was talking about, if you did it, you would make sure the infant went through the minimum amount of suffering.
 
I'm with BlackKat here. The foreskin is a non-essential part of the male anatomy; the clitoral prepuce and labia are essential parts. Apples and antelopes, really.

It's like this: FGM, in most cases, causes harm to females. From personal experience, I know that circumcision causes no harm to males (or shouldn't, if done right), while being uncircumcised can lead to infections and hygeine issues, based on observing my kids vs. my stepkids, as well as the males in my various military units. Circumcised males have better longetivity than uncircumcised, my experience shows, and circumcised males have less potency problems than uncircumcised.

That's all anecdotal and all experiential; but the 'research' so far has always shown bias, one way or another, so it's hard to accept the word of clearly biased researchers over personal experience in these cases.

It's also interesting to observe how much emotional language creeps into the anti-circ rhetoric. Ivor refers to 'delusions' - an unnecessarily loaded term to describe BlackKat's understanding of the facts. EJ Armstrong makes an attempt to associate circumcision with indecency. Earlier on, Ivor questions the skepticism of other posters, essentially because they disagree with him.

Earlier still, and I forget who said this, someone claimed that you were somehow demented or messed up or something if you DIDN't get emotional over the issue of circumcision. Frankly, that tells me a lot about who is, and who is not, clearly seeing the issues for what they are.
 
This is clearly a compelling delusion for you. Got any evidence that what you claim is actually true?

That's what I was thinking. Specifically, evidence to back up this part:

Piercing or trimming the clitoral hood will not impede sexual functionality. Removal could as it is designed to protect the clitoris from excessive friction. Removal of the labia, which protect the vaginal and urethral openings, is also detrimental.
The foreskin also protects the penis from excessive friction. I'd like to see evidence that the effects would be different.
I'd also like to see evidence that removing the labia (major or minor) results in anything negative that removal of the foreskin doesn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom