Yeah, that's my attitude...."you should be so lucky as to have me as your doctor."
That's the only attitude to have.
I wasn't really talking about singling out individuals in order to make a stand (when talking about doing more), but about taking the fight to a more productive area. I'm getting the impression that in the US, there is room for more effort on the part of physicians to discourage the practice, which includes getting more physicians to discourage the practice.
I agree with this wholeheartedly. FWIW, the one time I can remember it coming up in lecture, it was mentioned that the medical evidence was equivocal at best. That doesn't mean much, though, since not all lecturers are practicing physicians, and not all the lecturers who are talking about such things are actually dealing with them. I don't remember if it was a pediatrician speaking.
It is a very difficult situation when you cannot persuade others to what you (strongly) feel is the right course of action (or rather inaction). It does not make me feel any better to pass that decision off to someone else, though.
Again, I agree, but what can you do except pick your battles? Ethical issues are always challenging. (I've been a student member of our hospital's ethics committee since first year; some of the cases have been doozies.) It wouldn't make me feel better to pass it off, but it would make me feel better to know that I've refused to do something I don't agree with.
The results of doctors disagreeing with putative caretakers came to its unbelievably ridiculous worst-case scenario in the Schiavo case, for example. There are topics I'd go to the mat for, but I just don't know that circumcision can be one of them. I am perfectly willing to argue with my colleagues on this subject, and I'm sure I will. At the end of the day, though, realistically speaking, my choices are to accept the parents' decision or to permanently alienate them. I suppose I could say that they need to find the alternate doctor themselves, but I don't think that's ethically justifiable either.
And other than a salve to your conscience, what does that accomplish for your patient? I realize that I am picking on you unfairly (I think you are still in training?).
No, you're not, and yes, I am. I'll be a fourth year starting Monday (yay! Three hundred-odd days to go!). Now is a good time to be thinking these things through.
My desired area of specialty is actually pediatric neurology, so the likelihood is that for most of my career this will be an academic question--my experience is that most of the procedures are done by OB/GYNs anyway; I've never seen a pediatric resident or attending do one. Still and all.
As far as the US attitude goes: I happen to live in New York, and my school is in Brooklyn. That means, among other things, that there is a very large Jewish population there who are unlikely to be swayed on this issue, so that may color my views on how to handle the question. (Although I'm Jewish by heritage myself, so there's always hope.

) We also care for a largely underserved population and I see a lot of suspicion of doctors. So I'm sensitive, maybe overly so, to the idea that if I alienate the parent, the child may not get medical attention at all.
None of which means that I should support, or do, anything I am against. And I won't, but I think there is a difference between, say, whether or not a child should be circumcised and whether or not he should get an NG tube. I would prefer that the former not happen, but I can't honestly say I think it's damaging enough that I'd go into full-out challenge mode over it. Maybe I'll have to rethink that. I have already been asked by a new mother whether I thought she should have it done, and I said exactly what I've said here--that I don't think it's medically necessary and that there's no reason to do it. She didn't. But then, I didn't really have to convince her.
I think we're just kind of talking at cross-purposes--I'm talking about an individual level, and you're talking about the profession's entire attitude. I do think that more and more doctors are coming around on this issue, but it's going to take time before everyone is convinced. In the aggregate, I think the rates are dipping, right?--just not as quickly as we might like. I'll be spreading the word, though.