Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I could, as a provider, feel personally that the medical benefit outweighed the cost, because the case has not been made that the cost is as high as "believers" (don't know what else to call them) are claiming. So should I then advocate for the infant by recommending circumcision?

Regardless of how I would decide, given the fact in this case, there are two equally supportable evidence based decisions (there is a medical benefit and there are costs associated with that benefit) the parents are the rightful decision makers for that infant. Just as the parents are the rightful decision makers for many other medical choices involving weighing risk and benefit.


BTW, I never felt you were overly hostile or out of line or whatever it is you are referring to in you previous post.

You forget that the most important evidence is in front of your face when you look at the individual child's penis. It either needs to be circumcised or it does not need to be circumcised.

Future benefits provided by reducing risk, unless they are likely to occur AND there is no less invasive or effective alternative treatment available if they do occur, are not applicable to the judgement. They are excuses to justify the choice after it has been taken.

You still haven't answered how you can have the idea that the infant has the right to body integrity and that circumcision is the parent's choice in your brain at the same time. Please could you do this?

Logically, you must believe one is correct and the other is wrong. Up to this point you have advocated the parent's rights to choose. Logically, therefore, you do not believe the infant has the right to body integrity.

Is it your view that an infant does not have the right to body integrity?
 
I appreciate your clarification.



No, it sounds like exactly what I said: that I don't plan to perform circumcisions routinely, on a medical-evidence basis. The judgement, if any, is in your interpretation. I'm not obliged to perform a procedure if I don't think it's in my patient's best interest.

I'm all for patient's rights, and I want to be careful here because this is email and I know things tend to come off harsher than they sound (I think part of my initial response to your post came from the fact that you chose to boldface your comments--which I'm sure you did just to set them off from the flurry of quotations, but they gave me a sense of being lectured). Still--please be careful with the innate assumption that all doctors are out there trampling patients' rights and being paternalistic. Maybe some of them are. I've seen nurses behaving exactly the same way, and I'm sure, so have you. My training--and my inclination, I assure you--is very much the opposite.

In answer to your question "Whose decision is it?"--What I want is for parents to understand that there *are* two sides to this issue. Being a pediatrician means there has to be a balance--taking the best interest of the patient--the child--into account along with the wishes of the parent or guardian. Based on medical evidence, I do not feel that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks for my patient population, unless there is a separate medical issue. If the evidence changes, so may my opinion. It's not like I'm going to go to court to keep people from doing it, but again, it is not good medicine not to give my opinion.

If I were practicing medicine in Africa, my opinion might also be different. But--as I pointed out previously--I will be practicing medicine in the US. Here, the best defense against HIV is the use of a condom. It does not require the permanent alteration of the human being. I don't think that's "blurring the lines"--I think that's pointing out the very great difference between the two situations.

And in answer to the other poster--not that I consider it to be an analogous situation--my age cutoff for doing ear piercings on children is a child who is old enough to ask for the procedure and to understand basic instructions on how to care for it. That doesn't make me judgmental of parents who may choose to have it done earlier. It just means I'll be a pediatrician who doesn't do piercings on infants. Not everyone has to perform every possible procedure.

You give me hope:)
 
'Round and 'round the cobbler's bench
eleven pages repeating,
as if it makes another point
but it's just more emotion appealing'


Sorry, not a valid analogy. I believe it's been addressed.

Why? It's an elective procedure. If it can't be demonstrated to have a significant benefit, why perform it?
 
Evidence?
I don't speak for all parents, of course, but it was a major deciding factor in my spouse's and my decision to not circumcise our son. Specifically, we wanted his to look like what his peers' will look like.
 
You give me hope.

Thanks, Ivor. ;) But I think we're all just here tryin' to save a few lives.

Why? It's an elective procedure. If it can't be demonstrated to have a significant benefit, why perform it?

It's a poor analogy because the risks are not the same, and while there can be a permanent effect (holes in the earlobes), these can often close up on their own, and they are made in a portion of the anatomy that is much less personal and sensitive than the one under discussion. Additionally, there is absolutely no medical argument to be made in favor of the procedure.

However, the basis of the comparison--if there is no significant benefit, why perform it--is the crux of the disagreement about circumcision, which is why I addressed it. Insofar as that goes, I'll take it as an analogy. All analogies break down eventually. :D

Here is what I think is a more apt comparison: suppose, instead of a neonate, the patient brought to my office is a 16-year old boy. His parents say "We know he's sexually active, we want him to be protected against HIV, so we want a circumcision." The kid says "No way, get away from me with that scalpel."

You think any physician in his/her right mind would perform that procedure? The risk of HIV infection is not a sufficient reason to perform a circumcision. It is not protective enough, even if I accept the current evidence on its face (and I am not entirely comfortable with that evidence as yet). And yet these are parents, with the 'right' to make medical decisions for a minor child.

The ethics of pediatric medicine are complex, and they get exponentially more so as the child approaches maturity. An infant can't speak for himself, and so my feeling is that before any procedure is performed that can't be undone, I need to feel that there is a medical necessity for it. Both ear piercing and circumcision do have this in common--they can always be done later on if the patient desires it. I can't justify making that decision many years before the potential danger even occurs.

When I referenced the fact that my husband was the one who made me reconsider this subject, I was being a little flippant, but in all seriousness, it was his comment that he wouldn't have had it done if he'd had a choice that made me look into the medical evidence. And what I found was that there didn't seem to be enough in favor of circumcision to recommend it. Therefore, I changed my mind. It happens. :cool: But his opinion, even not buttressed by any medical evidence, has weight because he's the one with the penis. It's not like he's particularly concerned about it one way or the other at this late date. But he'd have made a different decision, had he been able to make it for himself. That matters to me.

Skeptigirl's own analogy of the "no big deal" quality of the procedure compared to debridement or chemotherapy, which I just noticed, also strikes me as peculiarly inappropriate. These are horrible things to have to do, to see, or to undergo. But they are unequivocably necessary to try and save that patient's life. These examples are also, forgive me, an attempt at emotional appeal.
 
If you choose to see me as a horrible parent because I chose to circumcise my sons, that's your choice. I've gotten my kudos from professionals in several fields related to children - child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, teachers, pediatricians, behavioral specialists... I've been praised for being an exemplary parent many, many times.


That's interesting. I and my child-rearing abilities, on the other hand, have never been praised by child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, or behavioral specialists -- mainly because I've never had the need to visit with child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, or behavioral specialists.

But I've been insulted by people for: disciplining my children when they have tantrums or outbursts; letting them discover things for themselves, rather than rubber-padding their entire environment; taking them with me to go shopping, or out to dinner at fine restaurants (managers, on the other hand, thank us for our well-behaved children); feeding them a wide variety of foods that we ourselves eat (my roommate used to feed her kids pretty much nothing but chicken nuggets, ravioli, and PB&J sandwiches, 'cuz that's what kids eat, you know?'); speaking to my children as equals, rather than as children; explaining things as they are, rather than using sugar-coated euphamisms and lies; taking them off the bottle as soon as possible, and the pacifier as soon as the child shows no real need for it; letting my children eat spicy foods like Indian foods or Mexican foods at early ages; letting them have toys rated above their age limit; and many other perceived offenses.
Likewise here. Looks like the only difference we have is our choice regarding circumcision. (Well, that, and the aforementioned dealing with behavioral therapists et al.) Perhaps the choice of whether or not to circumcise has very little, if anything, to do with how good a parent one is.
 
Your lecture in response to my final comment is not appreciated. I did not say that I would "judge" parents who chose circumcision. I will explain what I see to be the pros and cons of the procedure and, if they still want it done, refer them elsewhere. It is also not "practicing good medicine" to perform any procedure just because a patient or a parent desires it. At this time, my opinion is that for a child who will grow up in a country like the USA--which is where I will practice--there is not sufficient medical justification for circumcision. The evidence from the African studies is still very much being debated, but that is not really germane to the question of circumcision in the US. (I appreciate the argument about teenagers making poor decisions, but I can't really get behind the idea of permanently altering someone's body structure because of decisions you anticipate that they will make down the line, either.)

I have no problem with other doctors performing circumcisions, if that is what they feel to be correct. That is their decision.

The problem I have with taking this stance, is that it essentially passes the buck so that one can make a show of advocating for one's patient or taking a moral position, without actually doing so. After all, no behaviour has been changed if it is simply someone else that does the procedure.

I think we have a duty to be willing to be more proactive than that.

Linda
 
The problem I have with taking this stance, is that it essentially passes the buck so that one can make a show of advocating for one's patient or taking a moral position, without actually doing so. After all, no behaviour has been changed if it is simply someone else that does the procedure.

I think we have a duty to be willing to be more proactive than that.

Linda

Actually, (this is anecdotal, so you're just going to have to take my word for it) seeing physicians refuse to do it has made many a parent think more deeply about the issue.
 
Thanks, Hawk. I'd been wanting to jump in this thread for a while but I couldn't figure out how to express my position without simplifying the issue too much; your analogy works and I think it demonstrates the clear ethical reasoning I couldn't synthesize into coherence.

I'd like to add that another basis on which I find myself against the idea of circumcision is the issue of sensation. It's been briefly touched on-- no pun intended (ok, maybe a little intended), but the trouble is it quickly turns into a comparison with FGM which muddles the issue signifigantly. I'd like to propose another analogy, hopefully one which is not too biased: Let's say the chance of some airborne illness can be reduced by the neonatal or adult application of some chemical which has the unfortunate side effect of permanently dulling the sense of smell. Not by any great amount - the nose is still perfectly functional, and those who have had the procedure in no way find themselves unable to appreciate the smell of a rose, for example(though some, curiously, claim it enables them to last longer in smelly environments).

To me --and of course, an ethical position can only be an opinion-- the idea of reducing the senses, our "window to the world," so to speak, seems abhorrent, minor loss or no. Considering the importance of the sense of touch to the pleasure of sex, I would think this would magnify the issue. It's difficult to weigh something like this against potential illness, and ends up being fairly subjective and greatly dependent on 1) the amount and quality of sensation lost and 2) the prevalance and severity of the illnesses in question, and the amount in which the chance can be reduced. Obviously then, you can say that in a epidemic situation, you have a lot more leeway. Personally I don't feel in developed nations the benefit outweighs the cost.

I suppose a counter argument would be to say, if you never know the intensity of smell you're missing, who's to say your actual experience is any worse? It's hard to argue against something like that, as the argument devolves into issues of "contrast" and "qualia." Still, I DO think it's safe to say, loss of nerve endings = loss of sensation, and I think I'll use that to prop up my assertion.
 
The problem I have with taking this stance, is that it essentially passes the buck so that one can make a show of advocating for one's patient or taking a moral position, without actually doing so. After all, no behaviour has been changed if it is simply someone else that does the procedure.

I think we have a duty to be willing to be more proactive than that.

Linda

Short of taking a parent to court, there is very little more than that I can do. My viewpoint is that it will probably not be worth the potential alienation of the parents to pick, you should forgive the metaphor, that hill to die on. And I don't mean solely from the point of view of my future income, I mean from the POV that I would undoubtedly not get to be that child's physician in the future. Which I personally think would be to the child's detriment. :cool:

You see above the reaction to my purported infringement of the parents' right to choose? Imagine if that was actually the parent of a patient. You have to find a way to work with the parents. At some point, that may mean saying, "Well, you understand my point of view. If you still want it done, I can give you some names of doctors who do perform the procedure." I don't think that's making a show of advocacy. It's just that in the course of a career, you are not going to win every fight. If they listen to me, and they still want it done, well...it's not illegal and I can't say that I think it's hugely harmful. I just don't think it's necessary. If I go into this thinking I personally can change everyone's behavior overnight, I won't last long.

But I disagree that I would not be taking my own stance. I will not do the procedure, after all.

Actually, (this is anecdotal, so you're just going to have to take my word for it) seeing physicians refuse to do it has made many a parent think more deeply about the issue.

That would be my great hope. And isn't that what we're all supposed to be in favor of? Getting people to think?

FWIW, I haven't yet thought much about future activity as regards medical policy or public health advocacy. I would be much more likely to be proactive in that arena.
 
Oh, and if anyone is a fan of the TV show Arrested Development, I think the strongest case is Lindsay Bluth's anti-circumcision quote for HOOP (Hands-Off Our Penises): "It's a Doberman. Let it have its ears." ;)
 
Actually, (this is anecdotal, so you're just going to have to take my word for it) seeing physicians refuse to do it has made many a parent think more deeply about the issue.

Yeah, when I was thinking about ways that refusal could have an influence on the behaviour, I thought that would be a possibility. I just have no real idea as to the extent.

Linda
 
The problem I have with taking this stance, is that it essentially passes the buck so that one can make a show of advocating for one's patient or taking a moral position, without actually doing so. After all, no behaviour has been changed if it is simply someone else that does the procedure.

I think we have a duty to be willing to be more proactive than that.

Linda

Does this mean you've changed your mind from when you were conversing with me? I remember you mentioning something along the lines of 'not intervening'. It's late, so I'm going to bed. I'll re-read the thread tomorrow and see if I've just imagined or misunderstood what you said earlier.
 
Yeah, when I was thinking about ways that refusal could have an influence on the behaviour, I thought that would be a possibility. I just have no real idea as to the extent.

Linda

Linda, I was just reading some of the middle parts of this thread, and I had not realized that you are in fact a doctor. Apologies if I should have known that from before this thread, too--I don't get around here all that much any more.

That being said, regarding my last post, what would you as a practicing physician do differently in that situation? I was phrasing my answer as to a non-medical-professional, but not meaning any challenge or disrespect, what else could one do?

Clearly, this subject is going to come up for me in the future. :confused:
 
Short of taking a parent to court, there is very little more than that I can do. My viewpoint is that it will probably not be worth the potential alienation of the parents to pick, you should forgive the metaphor, that hill to die on. And I don't mean solely from the point of view of my future income, I mean from the POV that I would undoubtedly not get to be that child's physician in the future. Which I personally think would be to the child's detriment. :cool:

Yeah, that's my attitude...."you should be so lucky as to have me as your doctor." :)

I wasn't really talking about singling out individuals in order to make a stand (when talking about doing more), but about taking the fight to a more productive area. I'm getting the impression that in the US, there is room for more effort on the part of physicians to discourage the practice, which includes getting more physicians to discourage the practice. I don't have a good feel for the nature of the discussion in the US, since the part of my training that had anything to do with circumcision was in Canada.

My specialty is internal medicine, so the analogous situation I am more likely to deal with is children making decisions for their incompetent parents - something like the insertion of a gastric feeding tube. It is a very difficult situation when you cannot persuade others to what you (strongly) feel is the right course of action (or rather inaction). It does not make me feel any better to pass that decision off to someone else, though.

You see above the reaction to my purported infringement of the parents' right to choose? Imagine if that was actually the parent of a patient. You have to find a way to work with the parents. At some point, that may mean saying, "Well, you understand my point of view. If you still want it done, I can give you some names of doctors who do perform the procedure." I don't think that's making a show of advocacy. It's just that in the course of a career, you are not going to win every fight. If they listen to me, and they still want it done, well...it's not illegal and I can't say that I think it's hugely harmful. I just don't think it's necessary. If I go into this thinking I personally can change everyone's behavior overnight, I won't last long.

But I disagree that I would not be taking my own stance. I will not do the procedure, after all.

And other than a salve to your conscience, what does that accomplish for your patient? I realize that I am picking on you unfairly (I think you are still in training?). It is though I am asking you to compel physicians to a particular course of action at a point where attending physicians are inclined to dismiss your opinions (not me of course ;)). And I am open to the possibility that your action is seen as compelling by others. But the graphs presented earlier about rates of circumcision in the US (and I could not confirm their accuracy as the NCHS data that I could easily find only went to 1999) does not yet show a definite downward trend comparable to the other developed countries. This suggests that it may take more than just the AAP position paper (which essentially hasn't changed since the 70's) and some conscientious objectors to really effect change. I am totally out of the loop on this, though.

Linda
 
Yeah, that's my attitude...."you should be so lucky as to have me as your doctor." :)

That's the only attitude to have. ;)

I wasn't really talking about singling out individuals in order to make a stand (when talking about doing more), but about taking the fight to a more productive area. I'm getting the impression that in the US, there is room for more effort on the part of physicians to discourage the practice, which includes getting more physicians to discourage the practice.

I agree with this wholeheartedly. FWIW, the one time I can remember it coming up in lecture, it was mentioned that the medical evidence was equivocal at best. That doesn't mean much, though, since not all lecturers are practicing physicians, and not all the lecturers who are talking about such things are actually dealing with them. I don't remember if it was a pediatrician speaking.

It is a very difficult situation when you cannot persuade others to what you (strongly) feel is the right course of action (or rather inaction). It does not make me feel any better to pass that decision off to someone else, though.

Again, I agree, but what can you do except pick your battles? Ethical issues are always challenging. (I've been a student member of our hospital's ethics committee since first year; some of the cases have been doozies.) It wouldn't make me feel better to pass it off, but it would make me feel better to know that I've refused to do something I don't agree with.

The results of doctors disagreeing with putative caretakers came to its unbelievably ridiculous worst-case scenario in the Schiavo case, for example. There are topics I'd go to the mat for, but I just don't know that circumcision can be one of them. I am perfectly willing to argue with my colleagues on this subject, and I'm sure I will. At the end of the day, though, realistically speaking, my choices are to accept the parents' decision or to permanently alienate them. I suppose I could say that they need to find the alternate doctor themselves, but I don't think that's ethically justifiable either.

And other than a salve to your conscience, what does that accomplish for your patient? I realize that I am picking on you unfairly (I think you are still in training?).

No, you're not, and yes, I am. I'll be a fourth year starting Monday (yay! Three hundred-odd days to go!). Now is a good time to be thinking these things through.

My desired area of specialty is actually pediatric neurology, so the likelihood is that for most of my career this will be an academic question--my experience is that most of the procedures are done by OB/GYNs anyway; I've never seen a pediatric resident or attending do one. Still and all.

As far as the US attitude goes: I happen to live in New York, and my school is in Brooklyn. That means, among other things, that there is a very large Jewish population there who are unlikely to be swayed on this issue, so that may color my views on how to handle the question. (Although I'm Jewish by heritage myself, so there's always hope. ;)) We also care for a largely underserved population and I see a lot of suspicion of doctors. So I'm sensitive, maybe overly so, to the idea that if I alienate the parent, the child may not get medical attention at all.

None of which means that I should support, or do, anything I am against. And I won't, but I think there is a difference between, say, whether or not a child should be circumcised and whether or not he should get an NG tube. I would prefer that the former not happen, but I can't honestly say I think it's damaging enough that I'd go into full-out challenge mode over it. Maybe I'll have to rethink that. I have already been asked by a new mother whether I thought she should have it done, and I said exactly what I've said here--that I don't think it's medically necessary and that there's no reason to do it. She didn't. But then, I didn't really have to convince her.

I think we're just kind of talking at cross-purposes--I'm talking about an individual level, and you're talking about the profession's entire attitude. I do think that more and more doctors are coming around on this issue, but it's going to take time before everyone is convinced. In the aggregate, I think the rates are dipping, right?--just not as quickly as we might like. I'll be spreading the word, though.
 
Is it your view that an infant does not have the right to body integrity?

The problem with rights-based moral talk is that there is no simple way to figure out what happens when rights clash.

Infants have the right to bodily integrity, parents have the right to decide what elective medical procedures their infants undergo, now what?

Attempts to solve this kind of problem always seem to end up with complicated hierarchies of rights, but no one story about how to rank rights has gained popular acceptance. Probably because it all gets too messy.
 
Personally I think it should be illegal; it's rather irrational that it isn't actually illegal in countries like the UK or the USA where it is already illegal for parents to cause their child to be mutilated.

Interesting point.

In the past, have there been other medical surgeries, procedures, operations, whatever, performed on people without their consent, that were found to be irrational, dangerous, and are now considered stupid, harmful, or illegal?

I thought of tonsils. I remember when tonsils were removed, and considered dangerous to leave, and it was believed they caused disease. That surgery to remove them (it always seemed to be on kids), was common.

Does anybody still believe that? Could a rational thinker defend removing a kids tonsils?
 
Infants have the right to bodily integrity, parents have the right to decide what elective medical procedures their infants undergo, now what?

At the risk of returning to a lighthearted tone, if every infant is given two parents so as to ensure a second opinion, perhaps a pediatrician's role is to provide the tiebreaker. ;)

Well, it may be only a matter of time before this 'elective medical procedure' is considered differently. Things change, you see.

I thought of tonsils. I remember when tonsils were removed, and considered dangerous to leave, and it was believed they caused disease. That surgery to remove them (it always seemed to be on kids), was common.

Does anybody still believe that? Could a rational thinker defend removing a kids (sic) tonsils?

Yes! When medically necessary. This might be a pretty good analogy (though I am unaware of any cultural, religious or aesthetic issues involved in tonsillectomy). Tonsillar tissue can become problematic if it is chronically inflamed or becomes infected so many times that its integrity is compromised. But tonsils are a very good example of an 'elective' surgery that has become largely extinct because of awareness by both parents and physicians that it did not do what it was intended to do.
 
...(I think part of my initial response to your post came from the fact that you chose to boldface your comments--which I'm sure you did just to set them off from the flurry of quotations,
Sorry, it was purely for ease of reading. I know when I post long discussions that many people do not want to read all that stuff. I have taken to highlighting what I hope someone skimming the post will read if they don't read anything else. I also put incorporated quotes in italics because it is easier to see that someone else said something in my post.

I was lecturing a little. People who have been around for ever can't help themselves when around someone new. But there is nothing to be defensive about. As a nurse, I am specifically tasked to advocate for the patient. It's part of the collaborating roles of nursing and medicine. I think if we were in a face to face discussion, you'd find I have a completely different tone than you are reading into my posts.

...-please be careful with the innate assumption that all doctors are out there trampling patients' rights and being paternalistic.
As should you be careful making this erroneous assumption about me. I made a point of the non-exclusivity and the over-generalization of my statement. It was easy to miss.
... Maybe some of them are. I've seen nurses behaving exactly the same way, and I'm sure, so have you.
Nothing used to annoy me more than ICU nurses kicking family members out of a room of a dying patient so the nurse didn't have to accommodate the visitors in some minor way when providing care. When necessary, sure, but a lot of ICU nurses are all about the technical care and not so much about the other side of nursing care.

I have worked both sides of the isle. I was educated as a nurse before becoming a family nurse practitioner. Now I have a private practice that is more medical than nursing. I do see a big difference in medical vs nursing philosophies. It doesn't mean physicians aren't equally compassionate. What it does mean however, is your education has been to "decide", to recommend, to know the answers. Nursing education is all about teaching, assisting, helping, and so on. It doesn't make nurses any less knowledgeable. We have a parallel profession with medicine. PhDs are granted in Nursing Science. But the whole focus really is different.

..If I were practicing medicine in Africa, my opinion might also be different. But--as I pointed out previously--I will be practicing medicine in the US. Here, the best defense against HIV is the use of a condom. It does not require the permanent alteration of the human being. I don't think that's "blurring the lines"--I think that's pointing out the very great difference between the two situations.
It's blurring the line of the discussion. No one in this thread is saying HIV prevention is a factor in the decision to circumcise an infant in the US.*

*Emphasized because it's at least the third time I have said it in this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom