Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I was present for the circumcisions of my sons. In the first two cases, a cream was applied before circumcision, and in the last three cases, a spray was used. There was a wait of a few minutes, and the plastibell procedure began.

The entire time, the infants were fairly calm and undisturbed by the process of circumcision (my oldest was only interested in sucking the pinky of a nurse who was with him). The procedure was very quick, and the results were clean and hygenic-looking.

Naturally, as a man, I wondered what it might actually feel like, sans pain relief; and I was grateful that they used the cream/spray on my child.

My feelings about the children at the point of the circumcision was relief and satisfaction, knowing I was saving them from infections, from the filthy stench of the foreskin, and from the hideous bestial appearance that an uncut penis has. At that time, I'd never heard of the HIV studies about foreskins, and had never heard of any complications later in life about circumcised men; my own experience was that it was UNcircumcised men who had problems. I was largely surrounded in the military by circumcised men (communal showers let you know a LITTLE too much about your comrades), and the scant few who hadn't been cut regularly spoke of problems as teens and young adults with infections and urinary difficulty. A few even got cut as adults, at the suggestion of the medical staff and the urging of their wives and/or girlfriends.

In all that time, it had never occured to me that there were those who thought circumcision was a BAD thing.

Of course, it also had never occured to me that getting a toddler's ears pierced, as we did with my daughter, would ever be seen as a bad thing, but I encounter people who tell me how horrible it is that my daughter has pierced ears. WTF?

I feel more empathy for the pain of my children when they get shots, when my second-born had to get an IV in his scalp, when they had to extract a piece of foam from my third-born's sinus that he had somehow managed to get in there at a year old... Compared to those pains, the circumcisions were quick, painless, and most importantly, rapidly forgotten.

I agree that some circumcisions are cruel and inhumane - those that don't use pain relief, those that use primitive methods (like teeth - ugh!), those that result in excessive bleeding and infections. But those done on my sons were none of that. They were quick, clean, and tidy. The results are beautiful (as penises go).

But I did have doubts, for a while, about whether it was really all that useful. Until I met our housemate, and her two uncut sons.

The two boys regularly suffer from infections, swelling, and stink. The younger of the two, a high-functioning autistic, so dislikes his penis that he's expressed a desire to have the entire thing removed (EEEK!), while being jealous of my sons' privates. The older boy mentions pain on those rare occasions when, for whatever reason, his penis becomes erect (I had no idea penises could get erect at five years old, but apparently they can).

And I sympathize greatly with the two of them, and wonder how their father can be so horrible as to not remove the terrible foreskin from his sons!

In fact, until I came to JREF, I'd never, EVER heard anyone claim that keeping the foreskin was a GOOD idea. Then again, I was rarely ever exposed to anyone who WASN'T from the U.S. (minus Koreans, who rarely ever discuss their genitals, and various hispanics, who seem to think that circumcisions are a good thing for hygiene reasons).

I have to admit, the argument has definitely made me think, long and hard, about the whole thing. But so far, I still remain unconvinced. I think the benefits - from health and hygiene to aesthetics and acceptance within culture - far outweigh any perceived drawbacks - including tiny chances of complications I'd never heard of or experienced, psychological damage that seems unlikely in a culture where circumcision is so common...

Then there's the whole 'human rights' aspect. Frankly, I think there are certain parental rights that trump individual human rights. And decisions about circumcision, piercing, tattoos, etc., IMO, fall firmly under the umbrella of parental rights, just as hair style (cutting vs. not cutting), clothing, makeup, who they hang with, etc. also fall under that umbrella.

When a child reaches the age of majority, they can make any decision they want for themselves. But until then, they are the responsibility of the parent, and that includes the parent deciding what's best for the child - braces, circumcisions, piercings, the removal of wisdom teeth, corrective eye surgery, and other forms fo cosmetic surgery included.

I've had moles removed from one of my sons before - a somewhat more painful and arguably less necessary procedure than circumcision - because I thought it would improve his appearance and acceptance. I've looked into treatment for my third-born's mongolian mark, a purplish mark covering one shoulder that is hot to the mark and unpleasant to look at. Unfortunately, those treatments are wildly painful, often leaving scars, and are not guaranteed to work - so we've decided against them.

And you can't even claim that my decisions were based on religion. I've never belonged to any formal religion until recently. My mother was raised Roman Catholic - where circumcisions aren't terribly common - and my father was Apache and a pragmatic theist. I was very eclectic, but never belonged to any group that required a cut tadger (in fact, as a religious practice, I find it abhorrent).

But I do belong to a society which accepts circumcision as normal, desirable, and attractive. That probably did color my earlier perceptions on circumcisions.

If you choose to see me as a horrible parent because I chose to circumcise my sons, that's your choice. I've gotten my kudos from professionals in several fields related to children - child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, teachers, pediatricians, behavioral specialists... I've been praised for being an exemplary parent many, many times. My children are healthy, active, intelligent, educated, extremely well behaved and polite, creative, energetic, sociable, and as close to perfect as any parent could want. My housemate is jealous at how good my kids tend to be, compared to her two sons (who have improved by vast leaps and bounds since coming to live with us).

But I've been insulted by people for: disciplining my children when they have tantrums or outbursts; letting them discover things for themselves, rather than rubber-padding their entire environment; taking them with me to go shopping, or out to dinner at fine restaurants (managers, on the other hand, thank us for our well-behaved children); feeding them a wide variety of foods that we ourselves eat (my roommate used to feed her kids pretty much nothing but chicken nuggets, ravioli, and PB&J sandwiches, 'cuz that's what kids eat, you know?'); speaking to my children as equals, rather than as children; explaining things as they are, rather than using sugar-coated euphamisms and lies; taking them off the bottle as soon as possible, and the pacifier as soon as the child shows no real need for it; letting my children eat spicy foods like Indian foods or Mexican foods at early ages; letting them have toys rated above their age limit; and many other perceived offenses.

Amazingly, not one of the people criticising me in these areas was qualified to judge! And those who ARE qualified, have praised me for many of these same things.

So if I'm a bad parent, fine. We need more bad parents, then, and maybe our world wouldn't be going to Nomandy in a hand-basket, like it currently is.
 
Wow, go off the boards for a while and look at the sort of thing you miss.

I don't have much to add, but I wanted to thank you all for showing me what I'm likely to come up against during the pediatric portion of my upsoming residency. :cool: FWIW, I tend towards the "it's medically unnecessary in most cases" viewpoint. I understand that there will be parents who want it done for a variety of reasons; I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it.

In addition, the cells in the foreskin have been shown to be the portal of entry for the HIV.

How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? (non pdf link)

To summarize, the foreskin is susceptible to small scratches and tears during intercourse and contains a high density of Langerhans cells - primary target cells for HIV.

-

Just a word here--I'm not sure this is entirely correct. Langerhans cells are *not* the primary target cells for HIV. This paper presumes that because they have some of the same target receptors as CD4+ T-cells that HIV will use them as a port of entry. However, this hasn't been conclusively proven. From what I recall from lecture, there are also a lot of people who think that the Langerhans cells--a type of dendritic cell that is prevalent in the mucosal tissue--may actually be protective against HIV, because its job is to take up the virus before it gets to the lymph nodes and HIV can't multiply in these cells.

On the other hand, no one knows for sure. What I do agree with is that I think this is something a man should decide for himself. My husband convinced me of that. :D
 
If you were trolling, Z, that was pretty good.

I thought about rewriting your post to justify female genital mutilation ("saving them from infections, from the filthy stench of the labia, and from the hideous bestial appearance that an uncut vulva has.... what? I'm an awesome parent, everyone says so, how could I be wrong about FGM? The world needs more parents like me!") but in the end I decided it would be too icky.

I'm in favour of circumcision in areas with high rates of AIDS for the same reasons that I'm in favour of immunisation against deadly diseases. Saving lives justifies the lesser risks of circumcision in my mind. None of the other proposed justifications put forward for circumcision that I have seen make circumcision a clear net win for the subject, and a clear net win is what I think should be required for irreversible surgical alterations to infants.
 
Thanks to the people who've explained their thoughts while watching the video or another circumcision. Any more?

Skeptigirl, what goes through your mind while watching a circumcision of an infant?
 
Last edited:
... FWIW, I tend towards the "it's medically unnecessary in most cases" viewpoint. I understand that there will be parents who want it done for a variety of reasons; I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it.
The AAFP and the AAP have a different position on the matter. Their position is to give parents the risks and benefits without prejudice and accept the parents decision.

AAFP Position Paper on circumcisions.
Summary
Considerable controversy surrounds neonatal circumcision. Putative indications for neonatal circumcision have included preventing UTIs and their sequelae, preventing the contraction of STDs including HIV, and preventing penile cancer as well as other reasons for adult circumcision. Circumcision is not without risks. Bleeding, infection, and failure to remove enough foreskin occur in less than 1% of circumcisions. Evidence-based complications from circumcision include pain, bruising, and meatitis. More serious complications have also occurred. Although numerous studies have been conducted to evaluate these postulates, only a few used the quality of methodology necessary to consider the results as high level evidence.

The evidence indicates that neonatal circumcision prevents UTIs in the first year of life with an absolute risk reduction of about 1% and prevents the development of penile cancer with an absolute risk reduction of less than 0.2%. The evidence suggests that circumcision reduces the rate of acquiring an STD, but careful sexual practices and hygiene may be as effective. Circumcision appears to decrease the transmission of HIV in underdeveloped areas where the virus is highly prevalent. No study has systematically evaluated the utility of routine neonatal circumcision for preventing all medically-indicated circumcisions in later life. Evidence regarding the association between cervical cancer and a woman’s partner being circumcised or uncircumcised, and evidence regarding the effect of circumcision on sexual functioning is inconclusive. If the decision is made to circumcise, anesthesia should be used.

The American Academy of Family Physicians recommends physicians discuss the potential harms and benefits of circumcision with all parents or legal guardians considering this procedure for their newborn son. (2001)
AAP Policy Paper on Circumcision
Over the past several decades, the American Academy of Pediatrics has published several policy statements on neonatal circumcision of the male infant.1-3 Beginning in its 1971 manual, Standards and Recommendations of Hospital Care of Newborn Infants, and reiterated in the 1975 and 1983 revisions, the Academy concluded that there was no absolute medical indication for routine circumcision.

In 1989, because of new research on circumcision status and urinary tract infection (UTI) and sexually transmitted disease (STD)/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, the Academy concluded that newborn male circumcision has potential medical benefits and advantages as well as disadvantages and risks.4 This statement also recommended that when circumcision is considered, the benefits and risks should be explained to the parents and informed consent obtained. Subsequently, a number of medical societies in the developed world have published statements that do not recommend routine circumcision of male newborns.5-7 In its position statement, the Australian College of Paediatrics emphasized that in all cases, the medical attendant should avoid exaggeration of either risks or benefits of this procedure.5

Because of the ongoing debate, as well as the publication of new research, it was appropriate to reevaluate the issue of routine neonatal circumcision. This Task Force adopted an evidence-based approach to analyzing the medical literature concerning circumcision. The studies reviewed were obtained through a search of the English language medical literature from 1960 to the present and, additionally, through a search of the bibliographies of the published studies.

-

Just a word here--I'm not sure this is entirely correct. Langerhans cells are *not* the primary target cells for HIV. This paper presumes that because they have some of the same target receptors as CD4+ T-cells that HIV will use them as a port of entry. However, this hasn't been conclusively proven. From what I recall from lecture, there are also a lot of people who think that the Langerhans cells--a type of dendritic cell that is prevalent in the mucosal tissue--may actually be protective against HIV, because its job is to take up the virus before it gets to the lymph nodes and HIV can't multiply in these cells.

On the other hand, no one knows for sure.
I'd be interested in alternative research, but I believe the rebuttals have not borne fruit.

Expression of DC-SIGN in human foreskin may facilitate sexual transmission of HIV
ABSTRACT
This study demonstrates that the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) binding C-type lectin DC-SIGN is coexpressed with CD4 and CCR5 on dendritic cells/macrophages in human foreskin. It is hypothesised that DC-SIGN may contribute to the sexual transmission of HIV in the foreskin, by enabling infection of permissive cells in cis and/or in trans.
Facilitation of HIV transmission in the foreskin
A study of nine normal human foreskin specimens may explain at a molecular level why circumcised men are less frequently infected with HIV than those who are not circumcised.

The C-type lectin DC-SIGN (dendritic cell specific intercellular cell adhesion molecule grabbing non-integrin) binds human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) avidly, and has been shown to facilitate HIV infection of permissive cells both in trans and in cis. This study shows that DC-SIGN may also contribute to HIV transmission in the foreskin.

Cells such as maternal and alveolar macrophages and fetal Hofbauer cells at the placental interface, facilitate HIV infection where DC-SIGN and the HIV entry receptors CD4 and CCR5 are coexpressed. This study of dendritic cells and macrophages in foreskin specimens showed that all the DC-SIGN+ cells expressed both CD4 and CCR5 suggesting that DC-SIGN may potentiate HIV infection of these cells in cis. Most CD4+DC-SIGN- cells also expressed CCR5 and could . . .

-

Here is a pretty decent Power Point presentation discussing the mechanism of circumcision in preventing HIV transmission:

Biological Rationale
��Biological plausibilityBiological plausibility
��Inner mucosa of foreskin is rich in HIV target cells (9x)
��External foreskin/ shaft keratinized and not vulnerableExternal vulnerable
��After circumcision, only vulnerable mucosa is meatusmeatus
��Foreskin is retracted over shaft during intercourseForeskin intercourse
��Large inner mucosal surface exposureLarge exposure
��MicroMicro-tears, especially of frenulum
��Intact foreskin associated with infectionsIntact infections
��GUDGUD
��Balanitis/phimosisBalanitis/phimosis
��Possible increase HIV entry or sheddingPossible shedding

-

The following are letters and the author's reply regarding the Szabo article. I take it with a grain of salt when I see, "Nature has not made a design error; Cruz, Rio (International Coalition for Genital Integrity), as the source of the objections. Not that I won't look at the evidence regardless but still, there's a lot of chafe on this topic.

Male circumcision and HIV prevention; Some science would not have gone amiss
Editor—While a number of studies suggest an association between the foreskin and HIV infection, a simple tallying of studies, such as performed by Szabo and Short,1 is unscientific and misleading. Meta-analysis suggests that men engaging in high risk behaviours may be placed at further risk by having a foreskin, but in the general population circumcision status is not a significant factor. It also showed an important degree of heterogeneity between studies, calling into question the validity of the summary results.2 The multiple confounding factors influencing sexual behaviour and HIV susceptibility make it irresponsible to place blame on normal anatomy.

Langerhans' cells in the preputial mucosa are nothing new: all mucosal tissues have Langerhans' cells. Szabo and Short did not report Langerhans' cell concentrations in comparison with other mucosal tissues, their concentration in the glans, foreskin remnant, and circumcision scar in circumcised men, the presence of associated T cell infiltration (which may be necessary for viral transmission), or how findings in elderly cadavers correlate to sexually active young men. Szabo and Short state that the inner surface of the foreskin and the frenulum must be regarded as the most probable sites for viral entry of primary HIV infections in men; but without quantitative comparative data their statements are pure speculation.

The only reports of preputial Langerhans' cells have been in specimens from neonates3 and elderly cadavers. If normal genital mucosa is at risk, we need to know the concentration of Langerhans' cells in healthy men, men with multiple sexual partners, men with genital infections, men with HIV, and men of differing races and ages before any recommendations can be made.

Szabo and Short dismiss the complications of circumcision as having a low incidence; but the rate of immediate complications in the United States is between 3.1% and 9%,4 and another 5% will later develop meatal stenosis.5 A higher rate of complications is believed to follow circumcisions performed in the developing world, where circumcision has been linked to tuberculosis, tetanus, penile amputation, and death.

HIV transmission is heavily dependent on certain sexual behaviours, not anatomy. The authors have not provided any new information to alter this fact but have taken the discussion off on a needless tangent. Indiscriminate mass circumcision, which is currently popularised by some Western researchers, is unproved and does not address the core behavioural issues that have fuelled this pandemic. Therefore, it will not alter the course of AIDS in Africa.
Nature has not made a design error

Cruz, Rio (International Coalition for Genital Integrity, Box 8462, Santa Cruz, CA 95061, USA [email protected]).

Editor—Szabo and Short's article on male circumcision and HIV places them in splendid solidarity with Victorian notions of sex and hygiene, together with tribal initiation rituals.1-11-2 They are completely isolated from their major peer medical organisations, not one of which endorses routine infant circumcision as a prophylactic measure despite over 100 years of pressure brought to bear by circumcisers.

To accept that circumcision is a really good idea, we first have to believe that nature made some huge design error in human anatomy that requires removal by force. This is a great leap of faith given the fact that not just humans but all mammals, both male and female, have evolved over millions of years to end up with a prepuce. But for some reason known only to religious types and medicalised capitalism the only mammal to be benefited by summarily removing this omnipresent organ through surgery is the human male.

The history of medicalised circumcision is a fascinating study in Victorian medicine and anti-sexuality.1-4 Amputating the normal prepuce of human beings started in the English speaking countries as a measure to prevent masturbation. It did not work, but circumcisers have learnt that the pretexts for penile pruning are inexhaustible. Simply by playing on the fears of the culture they can keep the practice going—and the income flowing. At the turn of the 20th century better hygiene was the big issue, followed by penile cancer in the 1930s,1-3 cervical cancer in the '50s, sexually transmitted diseases in the '60s, urinary tract infections in the '80s,1-4 and, perhaps the most dreaded of all, AIDS in the '90s. If it looks as if routine infant circumcision is an operation in search of a disease, that's because it is. Every single claim for legitimate medical benefit justifying this routine has been discredited.1-5

But still the amputations go on. Every 26 seconds another penis is reduced in the United States. This is in sharp contrast with the rest of the world, where over 80% of the male population are left whole and intact—including all of Europe, most of non-Muslim Asia and Latin America—their genitals as nature designed them before the collective wisdom of Szabo and Short and other pro-circumcision proponents had a “better” idea.
1-1.
Szabo R, Short RV. How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? BMJ. 2000;320:1592–1594. . (10 June.). [PubMed]
1-2.
Moscucci, O. Clitoridectomy, circumcision, and the politics of sexual pleasure. In: Miller AH, Adams JE. , editors. Sexualities in Victorian Britain. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press; 1996. pp. 63–65.
1-3.
Fleiss PM, Hodges F. Neonatal circumcision does not protect against cancer. BMJ. 1996;312:779–780. [PubMed]
1-4.
Wiswell TE, Smith FR, Bass JW. Decreased incidence of urinary tract infections in circumcised male infants. Pediatrics. 1985;75:901–903. [PubMed]
1-5.
Fleiss P, Hodges F, Van Howe RS. Immunological functions of the human prepuce. Sex Trans Inf. 1998;74:364–367. [PubMed]
No case was made for circumcising unconsenting children

Dalton, John D (Howgate Farm, Linglabank, Frizington, Cumbria CA26 3SU).

Editor—Szabo and Short have concluded that circumcision of male children should be seriously considered as an additional means of preventing HIV.2-1 Whether they have a valid argument for the circumcision of consenting adults, they have certainly not made a case for circumcising unconsenting children who are not sexually active. Furthermore, there are certain failings of the article that should not have escaped the attention of the peer reviewer.

Szabo and Short conducted a Medline search for relevant literature, but they present no full listing of the search results. An objective review of the literature would have shown that there was no consensus that male circumcision protects against HIV.2-2 One meta-analysis showed circumcised men to be more at risk of HIV than those with the normal, intact penis.2-3

No evidence is presented by Szabo and Short to confirm their claim that HIV enters the body through CD4 and CCR5 receptors on Langerhans' cells located in the penis. As such their proposed mechanism for prevention of HIV by male circumcision is little more than supposition.

It is unacceptable for Szabo and Short to claim that circumcision has a low incidence of complications on the basis of a booklet favouring circumcision that has had no peer review.2-4 Although a complication rate as low as 0.06% has been claimed for circumcision, rates as high as 55% have also been reported.2-5 A detailed literature review of the complication rate for circumcision concluded that a realistic rate of significant complications is 2-10%.2-6 It seems possible that any programme of child circumcision would cause more serious complications than it would prevent cases of HIV.

We believe that we live in an enlightened age. What is most surprising is that we still believe that we should ward off disease by cutting children's genitals. Publishing the opinion of Szabo and Short will do more to perpetuate non-therapeutic circumcisions of unconsenting children in North America and Australia than it will for the prevention of HIV in Africa.
2-1.
Szabo R, Short RV. How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? BMJ. 2000;320:1592–1594. . (10 June.). [PubMed]
2-2.
De Vincenzi I, Mertens T. Male circumcision: a role in HIV prevention? AIDS. 1994;8:153–160. [PubMed]
2-3.
Van Howe RS. Circumcision and HIV infection: review of the literature and meta-analysis. Int J STD AIDS. 1999;10:8–16. [PubMed]
2-4.
Morris, B. In favour of circumcision. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press; 1999.
2-5.
Patel H. The problem of routine infant circumcision. Can Med Assoc J. 1996;95:576–581. [PubMed]
2-6.
Williams N, Kapila L. Complications of circumcision. Br J Surg. 1993;80:1231–1236. [PubMed]
More studies need to be done before widespread circumcision is implemented

Oliver, R T D (St Bartholomew's Hospital, London EC1A 7BE [email protected]). Oliver, Josephine (University of Birmingham medical School, Birmingham B15 2TT). Ballard, Ron C (National Reference Centre for Sexually Transmitted Diseases, South African Institute for Medical Research, Johannesburg, South Africa).

Editor—Szabo and Short suggest that the increased number of Langerhans' cells on the surface of the foreskin explains why circumcised men are less likely to become infected with HIV.3-1 They did not mention an issue that has long dogged debate on the protective effect of circumcision on the incidence of cervical cancer and now increasingly prostate cancer3-13-2—that is, the extent to which improved hygiene and affluence are confounding variables to the benefits of circumcision. This is exemplified by the lower incidence of cervical cancer in educated high caste women in India whose husbands were not circumcised than in less educated Muslim women with circumcised husbands.3-3 Undoubtedly the increased numbers of Langerhans' cells with HIV receptors in the foreskin may well contribute to an increased susceptibility to HIV.

Evidence that nutritional state and other sexually transmitted diseases also play a part in acquiring HIV infection prompted us to examine the role of the foreskin in the occurrence of HIV infection in a series of 83 new patients (40 positive for HIV) attending a urethritis clinic at East and West Drakefontein Gold Mines Carltonville, Gauteng, South Africa, as part of a study of the impact of HIV and sexually transmitted diseases on serum concentrations of prostate specific antigen.3-3 After giving their signed informed consent the miners received a questionnaire and were examined to ascertain whether they were circumcised (including whether the glans penis was visible) and the retractability of the foreskin. In addition, a limited history of sexual activity was recorded.

As expected, the frequency of HIV infection was significantly lower in those who were circumcised (table). The small subgroup who had been circumcised after puberty seemed to show some benefit in reducing the incidence of HIV infection. Even more interesting in the light of Szabo and Short's hypothesis about the increased numbers of Langerhans' cells in the foreskin, we found, contrary to what might be expected if their hypothesis was correct, that the frequency of HIV infection was less in men with long foreskins that were difficult to retract than in those with short easily retractable short foreskins.

Clearly this observation is based on too small a sample size for us to be totally confident in the results. However, these observations, added to those on the role of hygiene versus circumcision in reducing cervix cancer from India,3-4 suggest that further studies would help to clarify Szabo and Short's hypothesis and need to be done before widespread use of circumcision is implemented to try to reduce the spread of HIV infection. Furthermore, work needs to be done on the influence of circumcision after puberty because performing such a procedure after the first infection of a sexually transmitted disease could be more effective than circumcision based on the total population.
3-1.
Szabo R, Short RV. How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? BMJ. 2000;320:1592–1594. . (10 June.). [PubMed]
3-2.
Ross R, Shimizi H, Paganini-Hill A, Honda G, Henderson B. Case-control studies of prostate cancer in blacks and whites in southern California. J Natl Cancer Inst. 1987;78:869–874. [PubMed]
3-3.
Oliver J, Oliver R, Ballard R. Influence of circumcision and sexual behaviour on PSA levels in patients attending a sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinic. Prostate Cancer and Prostate Diseases (in press).
3-4.
Gajalakshmi C, Shanta V. Association between cervical and penile cancers in Madras, India. Acta Oncologica. 1993;32:617–620. [PubMed]
Authors' reply

Szabo, Robert (Mildura Base Hospital, Mildura, Victoria, Australia). Short, Roger V ([email protected] Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Melbourne, Royal Women's Hospital, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia).

Editor—Our review article was primarily concerned with exploring the mechanisms by which male circumcision protects against heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men. We concluded that it is the inner aspect of the foreskin, which is poorly keratinised but well supplied with Langerhans' cells, that is likely to be one of the principal sites of HIV entry into the penis.

We have now developed an active research programme on this topic, and, together with our collaborators, we hope to publish a number of papers in the near future on the distribution of Langerhans cells in the foreskins of young men with and without balanitis, the degree of keratinisation of the various penile epithelia, and the uptake of live HIV virus applied to the inner and outer aspects of adult human foreskins in vitro. Some of our histological findings were shown on the BBC Horizon/Discovery television programme “The Valley of Life or Death” on 16 November.4-1

The claim by Van Howe et al that a meta-analysis of the many papers that show a significant correlation between lack of male circumcision and HIV infection is unscientific and misleading makes little sense, since most of the 40 studies that show such an association have incorporated multivariate analysis to correct for confounding variables such as different sexual practices. Furthermore, Van Howe's own meta-analysis has been invalidated because of several major methodological errors.4-24-3

Male circumcision, like all minor surgical procedures, carries a small risk of postoperative complications. But this should not detract from the twofold to eightfold protective effect that circumcision provides against HIV infection, which, unlike the surgical complications, is almost invariably fatal. Other than recommending that male circumcision should be seriously considered as an additional means of preventing HIV in all countries with a high prevalence of infection, we have avoided all discussion about the relative advantages and disadvantages of neonatal male circumcision as a routine procedure in developed countries, where the prevalence of HIV infection is low. We do not intend to enter that debate, where objectivity is hard to find.

It is pleasing to note that organisations are now beginning to give serious consideration to the policy implications arising from the protective effect of male circumcision against HIV infection. In June 2000 the Horizons Project of the Population Council published a report of an international discussion meeting entitled “Male Circumcision and HIV Prevention: Directions for Future Research,”4-4 and in July the World Health Organization held a similar consultation in Durban at the time of the international AIDS conference, although its findings have yet to be published.

It would be unfortunate if the zealous opponents of neonatal male circumcision in developed countries, however well meaning, distracted attention from the glaring fact that in central and southern Africa, where 24.5 million people are infected with HIV,4-5 circumcision could offer some immediate protection against spread of the disease until such time as effective vaccines become available.
4-1.
Jackson T. No news is bad news. BMJ. 2000;321:1419. . (2 December.).
4-2.
Van Howe RS. Circumcision and HIV infection: review of the literature and meta-analysis. Int J STD AIDS. 1999;10:8–16. [PubMed]
4-3.
Moses S, Nagelkerke NJD, Blanchard J. Analysis of the scientific literature on male circumcision and risk of HIV infection. Int J STD AIDS. 1999;10:626–628. [PubMed]
4-4.
Van Dam, J.; Anastasi, MC. Male circumcision and HIV prevention: directions for future research. Horizons Project. The Population Council; 2000. p. 28.
4-5.
The Durban Declaration. Nature. 2000;406:15–16. [PubMed]

References
1.
Szabo R, Short RV. How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? BMJ. 2000;320:1592–1594. . (10 June.). [PubMed]
2.
O'Farrell N, Egger M. Circumcision in men and the prevention of HIV infection: a “meta-analysis” revisited. Int J STD AIDS. 2000;11:137–142. [PubMed]
3.
Hussain LA, Lehner T. Comparative investigation of Langerhans' cells and potential receptors for HIV in oral, genitourinary and rectal epithelia. Immunology. 1995;85:475–484. [PubMed]
4.
Sutherland JM, Glueck HI, Gleser G. Hemorrhagic disease of the newborn: breast feeding as a necessary factor in the pathogenesis. Am J Dis Child. 1967;113:524–533. [PubMed]
5.
Van Howe RS. Variability in penile appearance and penile findings: a prospective study. Br J Urol. 1997;80:776–782. [PubMed]

-

What I do agree with is that I think this is something a man should decide for himself. My husband convinced me of that. :D
On the one hand we learn from people and our experiences, on the other hand, your husband is not the father of the babies you will be treating. Just as I wouldn't tell any parent who chose to not circumcise their child that I believed he/she had made the wrong choice, neither would I try to influence another parent not to circumcise the child. In spite of people such as some in this thread who have strong feelings about what other parents should do, the medical evidence is equivocal. It should remain a personal choice. It wouldn't be practicing good medicine, in my opinion, to judge this particular decision. Good medicine is giving patients complete, correct information to make their own informed decision. That means discussing the issues claimed by some rather adamant men about circumcision, but it doesn't mean allowing the loudest voices to cloud one's perception of the evidence.
 
Last edited:
...Skeptigirl, what goes through your mind while watching a circumcision of an infant?
As a young nurse watching a male doctor performing them without anesthesia, I complained more than once that it was absurd not to use anesthesia.

But other than that, it takes less than a minute, it just doesn't seem like that big of a deal.

In the scheme of things, try debriding extensive 3rd degree burns on a child day after day, or taking care of a 17 year old quadriplegic from an accidental gunshot wound to the neck by his friend playing with a gun. Spend a month taking care of a single child getting a bone marrow transplant (because there is so much to do you can't take care of 2 patients) knowing some of them aren't going to make it. After the radiation, all the cells from the mouth thru to the other end die and slough off. Infections can set in anywhere and they usually do.

No, Ivor, I just don't think circumcisions are that big of a deal. Sorry.
 
As a young nurse watching a male doctor performing them without anesthesia, I complained more than once that it was absurd not to use anesthesia.

But other than that, it takes less than a minute, it just doesn't seem like that big of a deal.

In the scheme of things, try debriding extensive 3rd degree burns on a child day after day, or taking care of a 17 year old quadriplegic from an accidental gunshot wound to the neck by his friend playing with a gun. Spend a month taking care of a single child getting a bone marrow transplant (because there is so much to do you can't take care of 2 patients) knowing some of them aren't going to make it. After the radiation, all the cells from the mouth thru to the other end die and slough off. Infections can set in anywhere and they usually do.

No, Ivor, I just don't think circumcisions are that big of a deal. Sorry.

Thanks for your thoughts. And I appologise for my earlier outburst towards you (and others here who took any offense). You were just in the wrong place at the wrong time.

What prompted the question was another thread where Milgram's experiment was brought up (again), something a co-worker who travels to the less pleasant areas of the world said to me and our discussion somewhere else about empathy.

It appears that not only do we have the ability to experience another individuals suffering, but we also have the ability to ignore it or give it much less weight in our calculation of appropriate behaviour when there are other things to consider, or when we have become habituated to the stimulus that triggered it initially.

This is why I replied to Linda's question that I thought a reasonable person could come to a different conclusion than my own with respect to infant circumcision; they are applying different weights to the (ethical and physical) costs, benefits and risks. I think the answers provided to my question by the pro routine-circumcision people and yourself demonstrate this to be the case.

If someone is using incorrect data in their decision making process then that can and should be corrected. But if they just don't empathize the same amount or way, or they disagree with the UN statement on human rights, what can be done about that?
 
My feelings about the children at the point of the circumcision was relief and satisfaction, knowing I was saving them from infections, from the filthy stench of the foreskin, and from the hideous bestial appearance that an uncut penis has.
I believe the word you are looking for is believing, not knowing.

In fact, until I came to JREF, I'd never, EVER heard anyone claim that keeping the foreskin was a GOOD idea.

This really creeps me out.
 
Skeptigirl...
Here's some research that contradicts the Langerhans cells theory...

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=17334373

Langerin is a natural barrier to HIV-1 transmission by Langerhans cells.

Human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) is primarily transmitted sexually. Dendritic cells (DCs) in the subepithelium transmit HIV-1 to T cells through the C-type lectin DC-specific intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-3-grabbing nonintegrin (DC-SIGN). However, the epithelial Langerhans cells (LCs) are the first DC subset to encounter HIV-1. It has generally been assumed that LCs mediate the transmission of HIV-1 to T cells through the C-type lectin Langerin, similarly to transmission by DC-SIGN on dendritic cells (DCs). Here we show that in stark contrast to DC-SIGN, Langerin prevents HIV-1 transmission by LCs. HIV-1 captured by Langerin was internalized into Birbeck granules and degraded. Langerin inhibited LC infection and this mechanism kept LCs refractory to HIV-1 transmission; inhibition of Langerin allowed LC infection and subsequent HIV-1 transmission. Notably, LCs also inhibited T-cell infection by viral clearance through Langerin. Thus Langerin is a natural barrier to HIV-1 infection, and strategies to combat infection must enhance, preserve or, at the very least, not interfere with Langerin expression and function.

I still think the "circumcision effect" with HIV is "real", but I think it has to do with ulcerative genital sores like herpes....pathogens that work in tandem with the HIV virus, where HIV causes immunosupression, which helps the other virus make more sores, and the sores spread the HIV virus, too. Circumcision reduces the amount of skin there to have the sores (the pathogens probably evolved to propogate through intact genitals). Cutting off exterior sex organs that the ulcerative pathogens are adapted to throws a wrench in their transmission cycle. That would explain why some types of FGM "work" to prevent HIV, too.
 
I am aware that there are alternate opinions on circumcision from the major professional organizations in pediatrics.

The studies you cite are interesting, but my point is the same--no one is sure yet of the role of Langerhans cells in the transmission of HIV.

Your lecture in response to my final comment is not appreciated. I did not say that I would "judge" parents who chose circumcision. I will explain what I see to be the pros and cons of the procedure and, if they still want it done, refer them elsewhere. It is also not "practicing good medicine" to perform any procedure just because a patient or a parent desires it. At this time, my opinion is that for a child who will grow up in a country like the USA--which is where I will practice--there is not sufficient medical justification for circumcision. The evidence from the African studies is still very much being debated, but that is not really germane to the question of circumcision in the US. (I appreciate the argument about teenagers making poor decisions, but I can't really get behind the idea of permanently altering someone's body structure because of decisions you anticipate that they will make down the line, either.)

I have no problem with other doctors performing circumcisions, if that is what they feel to be correct. That is their decision.
 
It will take more research to sort out. While that study is intriguing, the fact these cells fail to overcome whatever is the factor making circumcision lower the HIV infection rate suggests they may be missing something. HIV might overwhelm such a cellular mechanism by a dose related function. Macrophages may be involved or some other binding sites.

I probably should revise my comments, however, and say possible mechanisms have been hypothesized rather than the mechanism is known. I should know better than to think cellular physiology is ever something simple. :)
 
Then I misunderstood your comments, Hawk, when you said, "I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it." That sounds to me like you plan to be fairly judgmental.

Obviously one doesn't ignore evidence based medicine in favor of a patient's desires. But two academies found there was not medical evidence suggesting ending the practice of circumcisions. That leaves a statement such as yours above based on personal biases affecting judgment rather than medical evidence.

I am an advocate of patient's rights. If you found my comments offensive I'm sorry. I should also add that while it is far from absolute, and somewhat oversimplifying things, the nursing model does lean more toward patient advocacy while the medical model is more paternalistic. That doesn't meant there aren't times when one may be better suited to a situation than the other. They both have their advantages. I merely state this as something which I have often observed in the underlying philosophies of health care practitioners. While subtle, it nonetheless observably affects decision making, and how information is relayed to patients.
 
Last edited:
Then I misunderstood your comments, Hawk, when you said, "I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it." That sounds to me like you plan to be fairly judgmental.

Obviously one doesn't ignore evidence based medicine in favor of a patient's desires. But two academies found there was not medical evidence suggesting ending the practice of circumcisions. That leaves a statement such as yours above based on personal biases affecting judgment rather than medical evidence.

I am an advocate of patient's rights. If you found my comments offensive I'm sorry. I should also add that while it is far from absolute, and somewhat oversimplifying things, the nursing model does lean more toward patient advocacy while the medical model is more paternalistic. That doesn't meant there aren't times when one may be better suited to a situation than the other. They both have their advantages. I merely state this as something which I have often observed in the underlying philosophies of health care practitioners. While subtle, it nonetheless observably affects decision making, and how information is relayed to patients.

Skeptigirl, I'd say you are more an advocate of parent's rights as far as circumcision is concerned:rolleyes:

How do you get round the UN human rights statement that an infant has the right to body integrity? Ignore it? Think it's wrong? I.e. You would change the document to state that an infant does _not_ have the right to body integrity.

I'm still finding it hard to understand how you can have the two concepts in one brain at the same time. How do you do it?
 
...I appreciate the argument about teenagers making poor decisions, but I can't really get behind the idea of permanently altering someone's body structure because of decisions you anticipate that they will make down the line, either....
There are two things here.

One, whose decision is it? That we seem to disagree, though I await your comments re my above post.

The second is the continual blurring of situations being discussed in this thread.

If you have the luxury of not having to weigh the "decisions they might make later" and the devastation of HIV in the society one is functioning in, then your position is logical and reasonable.

But if you are in a society that is literally being destroyed by HIV, such a position is naive.
 
Obviously one doesn't ignore evidence based medicine in favor of a patient's desires. But two academies found there was not medical evidence suggesting ending the practice of circumcisions. That leaves a statement such as yours above based on personal biases affecting judgment rather than medical evidence.

Is there medical evidence suggesting ending the practice of piercing the ears of infant girls? Even assuming that circumcision is harmless, which I disagree with, that isn't a reason to perform the procedure.
 
A good source of information (not Woo) on circumcision, policy, research, scientific/medical type stuff.

http://www.cirp.org/library/statements/

Medical organizations in the various English speaking nations have found it appropriate to issue policy statements for the information of the medical community and the public. The Circumcision Reference Library has collected these official policy statements, both old and new, from the various English speaking nations. The medical societies of non-English speaking nations do not issue circumcision policy statements because neonatal male circumcision is not a practice of those countries. The older statements may not reflect current policy but are presented for reference purposes.

Conflict of interest. Medical organizations are political associations of doctors that have a duty to represent the interests of their doctor members, of whom some may profit by performing circumcision. The protection of the income and estates of the members may be given high priority. This duty to the members may in some instances prevent complete candor about the effects of non-therapeutic circumcision. The content of circumcision policy statements may also be influenced by political considerations.

(File revised 20 February 2007)
 
Skeptigirl, I'd say you are more an advocate of parent's rights as far as circumcision is concerned:rolleyes:

How do you get round the UN human rights statement that an infant has the right to body integrity? Ignore it? Think it's wrong? I.e. You would change the document to state that an infant does _not_ have the right to body integrity.

I'm still finding it hard to understand how you can have the two concepts in one brain at the same time. How do you do it?
I could, as a provider, feel personally that the medical benefit outweighed the cost, because the case has not been made that the cost is as high as "believers" (don't know what else to call them) are claiming. So should I then advocate for the infant by recommending circumcision?

Regardless of how I would decide, given the fact in this case, there are two equally supportable evidence based decisions (there is a medical benefit and there are costs associated with that benefit) the parents are the rightful decision makers for that infant. Just as the parents are the rightful decision makers for many other medical choices involving weighing risk and benefit.


BTW, I never felt you were overly hostile or out of line or whatever it is you are referring to in you previous post.
 
A good source of information (not Woo) on circumcision, policy, research, scientific/medical type stuff.

http://www.cirp.org/library/statements/



(File revised 20 February 2007)
Yeah, right, robinson, this isn't woo. :rolleyes:

"The medical societies of non-English speaking nations do not issue circumcision policy statements because neonatal male circumcision is not a practice of those countries."

"Medical organizations are political associations of doctors that have a duty to represent the interests of their doctor members, of whom some may profit by performing circumcision. The protection of the income and estates of the members may be given high priority."

That's bu!!$h!+.
 
Last edited:
Is there medical evidence suggesting ending the practice of piercing the ears of infant girls? Even assuming that circumcision is harmless, which I disagree with, that isn't a reason to perform the procedure.
'Round and 'round the cobbler's bench
eleven pages repeating,
as if it makes another point
but it's just more emotion appealing'


Sorry, not a valid analogy. I believe it's been addressed.
 
I appreciate your clarification.

Then I misunderstood your comments, Hawk, when you said, "I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it." That sounds to me like you plan to be fairly judgmental.

No, it sounds like exactly what I said: that I don't plan to perform circumcisions routinely, on a medical-evidence basis. The judgement, if any, is in your interpretation. I'm not obliged to perform a procedure if I don't think it's in my patient's best interest.

I'm all for patient's rights, and I want to be careful here because this is email and I know things tend to come off harsher than they sound (I think part of my initial response to your post came from the fact that you chose to boldface your comments--which I'm sure you did just to set them off from the flurry of quotations, but they gave me a sense of being lectured). Still--please be careful with the innate assumption that all doctors are out there trampling patients' rights and being paternalistic. Maybe some of them are. I've seen nurses behaving exactly the same way, and I'm sure, so have you. My training--and my inclination, I assure you--is very much the opposite.

In answer to your question "Whose decision is it?"--What I want is for parents to understand that there *are* two sides to this issue. Being a pediatrician means there has to be a balance--taking the best interest of the patient--the child--into account along with the wishes of the parent or guardian. Based on medical evidence, I do not feel that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks for my patient population, unless there is a separate medical issue. If the evidence changes, so may my opinion. It's not like I'm going to go to court to keep people from doing it, but again, it is not good medicine not to give my opinion.

If I were practicing medicine in Africa, my opinion might also be different. But--as I pointed out previously--I will be practicing medicine in the US. Here, the best defense against HIV is the use of a condom. It does not require the permanent alteration of the human being. I don't think that's "blurring the lines"--I think that's pointing out the very great difference between the two situations.

And in answer to the other poster--not that I consider it to be an analogous situation--my age cutoff for doing ear piercings on children is a child who is old enough to ask for the procedure and to understand basic instructions on how to care for it. That doesn't make me judgmental of parents who may choose to have it done earlier. It just means I'll be a pediatrician who doesn't do piercings on infants. Not everyone has to perform every possible procedure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom