Z
Variable Constant
I was present for the circumcisions of my sons. In the first two cases, a cream was applied before circumcision, and in the last three cases, a spray was used. There was a wait of a few minutes, and the plastibell procedure began.
The entire time, the infants were fairly calm and undisturbed by the process of circumcision (my oldest was only interested in sucking the pinky of a nurse who was with him). The procedure was very quick, and the results were clean and hygenic-looking.
Naturally, as a man, I wondered what it might actually feel like, sans pain relief; and I was grateful that they used the cream/spray on my child.
My feelings about the children at the point of the circumcision was relief and satisfaction, knowing I was saving them from infections, from the filthy stench of the foreskin, and from the hideous bestial appearance that an uncut penis has. At that time, I'd never heard of the HIV studies about foreskins, and had never heard of any complications later in life about circumcised men; my own experience was that it was UNcircumcised men who had problems. I was largely surrounded in the military by circumcised men (communal showers let you know a LITTLE too much about your comrades), and the scant few who hadn't been cut regularly spoke of problems as teens and young adults with infections and urinary difficulty. A few even got cut as adults, at the suggestion of the medical staff and the urging of their wives and/or girlfriends.
In all that time, it had never occured to me that there were those who thought circumcision was a BAD thing.
Of course, it also had never occured to me that getting a toddler's ears pierced, as we did with my daughter, would ever be seen as a bad thing, but I encounter people who tell me how horrible it is that my daughter has pierced ears. WTF?
I feel more empathy for the pain of my children when they get shots, when my second-born had to get an IV in his scalp, when they had to extract a piece of foam from my third-born's sinus that he had somehow managed to get in there at a year old... Compared to those pains, the circumcisions were quick, painless, and most importantly, rapidly forgotten.
I agree that some circumcisions are cruel and inhumane - those that don't use pain relief, those that use primitive methods (like teeth - ugh!), those that result in excessive bleeding and infections. But those done on my sons were none of that. They were quick, clean, and tidy. The results are beautiful (as penises go).
But I did have doubts, for a while, about whether it was really all that useful. Until I met our housemate, and her two uncut sons.
The two boys regularly suffer from infections, swelling, and stink. The younger of the two, a high-functioning autistic, so dislikes his penis that he's expressed a desire to have the entire thing removed (EEEK!), while being jealous of my sons' privates. The older boy mentions pain on those rare occasions when, for whatever reason, his penis becomes erect (I had no idea penises could get erect at five years old, but apparently they can).
And I sympathize greatly with the two of them, and wonder how their father can be so horrible as to not remove the terrible foreskin from his sons!
In fact, until I came to JREF, I'd never, EVER heard anyone claim that keeping the foreskin was a GOOD idea. Then again, I was rarely ever exposed to anyone who WASN'T from the U.S. (minus Koreans, who rarely ever discuss their genitals, and various hispanics, who seem to think that circumcisions are a good thing for hygiene reasons).
I have to admit, the argument has definitely made me think, long and hard, about the whole thing. But so far, I still remain unconvinced. I think the benefits - from health and hygiene to aesthetics and acceptance within culture - far outweigh any perceived drawbacks - including tiny chances of complications I'd never heard of or experienced, psychological damage that seems unlikely in a culture where circumcision is so common...
Then there's the whole 'human rights' aspect. Frankly, I think there are certain parental rights that trump individual human rights. And decisions about circumcision, piercing, tattoos, etc., IMO, fall firmly under the umbrella of parental rights, just as hair style (cutting vs. not cutting), clothing, makeup, who they hang with, etc. also fall under that umbrella.
When a child reaches the age of majority, they can make any decision they want for themselves. But until then, they are the responsibility of the parent, and that includes the parent deciding what's best for the child - braces, circumcisions, piercings, the removal of wisdom teeth, corrective eye surgery, and other forms fo cosmetic surgery included.
I've had moles removed from one of my sons before - a somewhat more painful and arguably less necessary procedure than circumcision - because I thought it would improve his appearance and acceptance. I've looked into treatment for my third-born's mongolian mark, a purplish mark covering one shoulder that is hot to the mark and unpleasant to look at. Unfortunately, those treatments are wildly painful, often leaving scars, and are not guaranteed to work - so we've decided against them.
And you can't even claim that my decisions were based on religion. I've never belonged to any formal religion until recently. My mother was raised Roman Catholic - where circumcisions aren't terribly common - and my father was Apache and a pragmatic theist. I was very eclectic, but never belonged to any group that required a cut tadger (in fact, as a religious practice, I find it abhorrent).
But I do belong to a society which accepts circumcision as normal, desirable, and attractive. That probably did color my earlier perceptions on circumcisions.
If you choose to see me as a horrible parent because I chose to circumcise my sons, that's your choice. I've gotten my kudos from professionals in several fields related to children - child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, teachers, pediatricians, behavioral specialists... I've been praised for being an exemplary parent many, many times. My children are healthy, active, intelligent, educated, extremely well behaved and polite, creative, energetic, sociable, and as close to perfect as any parent could want. My housemate is jealous at how good my kids tend to be, compared to her two sons (who have improved by vast leaps and bounds since coming to live with us).
But I've been insulted by people for: disciplining my children when they have tantrums or outbursts; letting them discover things for themselves, rather than rubber-padding their entire environment; taking them with me to go shopping, or out to dinner at fine restaurants (managers, on the other hand, thank us for our well-behaved children); feeding them a wide variety of foods that we ourselves eat (my roommate used to feed her kids pretty much nothing but chicken nuggets, ravioli, and PB&J sandwiches, 'cuz that's what kids eat, you know?'); speaking to my children as equals, rather than as children; explaining things as they are, rather than using sugar-coated euphamisms and lies; taking them off the bottle as soon as possible, and the pacifier as soon as the child shows no real need for it; letting my children eat spicy foods like Indian foods or Mexican foods at early ages; letting them have toys rated above their age limit; and many other perceived offenses.
Amazingly, not one of the people criticising me in these areas was qualified to judge! And those who ARE qualified, have praised me for many of these same things.
So if I'm a bad parent, fine. We need more bad parents, then, and maybe our world wouldn't be going to Nomandy in a hand-basket, like it currently is.
The entire time, the infants were fairly calm and undisturbed by the process of circumcision (my oldest was only interested in sucking the pinky of a nurse who was with him). The procedure was very quick, and the results were clean and hygenic-looking.
Naturally, as a man, I wondered what it might actually feel like, sans pain relief; and I was grateful that they used the cream/spray on my child.
My feelings about the children at the point of the circumcision was relief and satisfaction, knowing I was saving them from infections, from the filthy stench of the foreskin, and from the hideous bestial appearance that an uncut penis has. At that time, I'd never heard of the HIV studies about foreskins, and had never heard of any complications later in life about circumcised men; my own experience was that it was UNcircumcised men who had problems. I was largely surrounded in the military by circumcised men (communal showers let you know a LITTLE too much about your comrades), and the scant few who hadn't been cut regularly spoke of problems as teens and young adults with infections and urinary difficulty. A few even got cut as adults, at the suggestion of the medical staff and the urging of their wives and/or girlfriends.
In all that time, it had never occured to me that there were those who thought circumcision was a BAD thing.
Of course, it also had never occured to me that getting a toddler's ears pierced, as we did with my daughter, would ever be seen as a bad thing, but I encounter people who tell me how horrible it is that my daughter has pierced ears. WTF?
I feel more empathy for the pain of my children when they get shots, when my second-born had to get an IV in his scalp, when they had to extract a piece of foam from my third-born's sinus that he had somehow managed to get in there at a year old... Compared to those pains, the circumcisions were quick, painless, and most importantly, rapidly forgotten.
I agree that some circumcisions are cruel and inhumane - those that don't use pain relief, those that use primitive methods (like teeth - ugh!), those that result in excessive bleeding and infections. But those done on my sons were none of that. They were quick, clean, and tidy. The results are beautiful (as penises go).
But I did have doubts, for a while, about whether it was really all that useful. Until I met our housemate, and her two uncut sons.
The two boys regularly suffer from infections, swelling, and stink. The younger of the two, a high-functioning autistic, so dislikes his penis that he's expressed a desire to have the entire thing removed (EEEK!), while being jealous of my sons' privates. The older boy mentions pain on those rare occasions when, for whatever reason, his penis becomes erect (I had no idea penises could get erect at five years old, but apparently they can).
And I sympathize greatly with the two of them, and wonder how their father can be so horrible as to not remove the terrible foreskin from his sons!
In fact, until I came to JREF, I'd never, EVER heard anyone claim that keeping the foreskin was a GOOD idea. Then again, I was rarely ever exposed to anyone who WASN'T from the U.S. (minus Koreans, who rarely ever discuss their genitals, and various hispanics, who seem to think that circumcisions are a good thing for hygiene reasons).
I have to admit, the argument has definitely made me think, long and hard, about the whole thing. But so far, I still remain unconvinced. I think the benefits - from health and hygiene to aesthetics and acceptance within culture - far outweigh any perceived drawbacks - including tiny chances of complications I'd never heard of or experienced, psychological damage that seems unlikely in a culture where circumcision is so common...
Then there's the whole 'human rights' aspect. Frankly, I think there are certain parental rights that trump individual human rights. And decisions about circumcision, piercing, tattoos, etc., IMO, fall firmly under the umbrella of parental rights, just as hair style (cutting vs. not cutting), clothing, makeup, who they hang with, etc. also fall under that umbrella.
When a child reaches the age of majority, they can make any decision they want for themselves. But until then, they are the responsibility of the parent, and that includes the parent deciding what's best for the child - braces, circumcisions, piercings, the removal of wisdom teeth, corrective eye surgery, and other forms fo cosmetic surgery included.
I've had moles removed from one of my sons before - a somewhat more painful and arguably less necessary procedure than circumcision - because I thought it would improve his appearance and acceptance. I've looked into treatment for my third-born's mongolian mark, a purplish mark covering one shoulder that is hot to the mark and unpleasant to look at. Unfortunately, those treatments are wildly painful, often leaving scars, and are not guaranteed to work - so we've decided against them.
And you can't even claim that my decisions were based on religion. I've never belonged to any formal religion until recently. My mother was raised Roman Catholic - where circumcisions aren't terribly common - and my father was Apache and a pragmatic theist. I was very eclectic, but never belonged to any group that required a cut tadger (in fact, as a religious practice, I find it abhorrent).
But I do belong to a society which accepts circumcision as normal, desirable, and attractive. That probably did color my earlier perceptions on circumcisions.
If you choose to see me as a horrible parent because I chose to circumcise my sons, that's your choice. I've gotten my kudos from professionals in several fields related to children - child psychiatrists, social workers, OT/PT therapists, teachers, pediatricians, behavioral specialists... I've been praised for being an exemplary parent many, many times. My children are healthy, active, intelligent, educated, extremely well behaved and polite, creative, energetic, sociable, and as close to perfect as any parent could want. My housemate is jealous at how good my kids tend to be, compared to her two sons (who have improved by vast leaps and bounds since coming to live with us).
But I've been insulted by people for: disciplining my children when they have tantrums or outbursts; letting them discover things for themselves, rather than rubber-padding their entire environment; taking them with me to go shopping, or out to dinner at fine restaurants (managers, on the other hand, thank us for our well-behaved children); feeding them a wide variety of foods that we ourselves eat (my roommate used to feed her kids pretty much nothing but chicken nuggets, ravioli, and PB&J sandwiches, 'cuz that's what kids eat, you know?'); speaking to my children as equals, rather than as children; explaining things as they are, rather than using sugar-coated euphamisms and lies; taking them off the bottle as soon as possible, and the pacifier as soon as the child shows no real need for it; letting my children eat spicy foods like Indian foods or Mexican foods at early ages; letting them have toys rated above their age limit; and many other perceived offenses.
Amazingly, not one of the people criticising me in these areas was qualified to judge! And those who ARE qualified, have praised me for many of these same things.
So if I'm a bad parent, fine. We need more bad parents, then, and maybe our world wouldn't be going to Nomandy in a hand-basket, like it currently is.