Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

There are women who choose to have cosmetic surgery on their genitals. Apparently, some want to feel like a virgin again after having had a baby or two, while others just want to 'tidy' their vulva up.

What do the pro-circumcision people think about the parents of a baby girl judge the aesthetic quality of their child's vulva and have it made more similar to the concept of a "normal" one?
 
...snip...

You can not compare the two. Castration would be an equivalent to female genital mutilation, not circumcision. Also female genital mutilation is almost never done for aesthetics. It is almost always done with the express purpose of making sure a woman can not enjoy sex or even have it at all. It does not matter if the person who thinks women should not enjoy sex is a man or a woman. It's still opression.
Female genital mutilation consists of excising the clitoris and or labia, and also can include sewing mostly shut the vagina.


FGM covers a huge range of mutilation, from just the removal of some tissue to as you rightly say complete excision of most of the tissues of the vagina.

As for the reasons why FGM is carried out - it is for the same reasons as male circumcisions are carried out e.g. hygiene, aesthetics, not wanting to be different and so on.

See: http://www.siue.edu/~jfarley/nicho490.htm

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/

...snip...

The reasons given by families for having FGM performed include:
psychosexual reasons:
  • reduction or elimination of the sensitive tissue of the outer genitalia, particularly the clitoris, in order to attenuate sexual desire in the female, maintain chastity and virginity before marriage and fidelity during marriage, and increase male sexual pleasure;
  • sociological reasons: identification with the cultural heritage, initiation of girls into womanhood, social integration and the maintenance of social cohesion;
  • hygiene and aesthetic reasons: the external female genitalia are considered dirty and unsightly and are to be removed to promote hygiene and provide aesthetic appeal;
  • myths: enhancement of fertility and promotion of child survival;
  • religious reasons: Some Muslim communities, however, practise FGM in the belief that it is demanded by the Islamic faith. The practice, however, predates Islam.


...snip...

Supporters of male circumcision should logically also be supporters of at least Type 1 female genital mutilation.
 
Last edited:
FGM covers a huge range of mutilation, from just the removal of some tissue to as you rightly say complete excision of most of the tissues of the vagina.

As for the reasons why FGM is carried out - it is for the same reasons as male circumcisions are carried out e.g. hygiene, aesthetics, not wanting to be different and so on.

See: http://www.siue.edu/~jfarley/nicho490.htm

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/

Supporters of male circumcision should logically also be supporters of at least Type 1 female genital mutilation.

You're right. But in 80% or more cases (at least according to the WHO's survey linked earlier in the thread) it's excision of the clitoris or worse. If those numbers have changed then that's good. And I don't have a problem with FGM that does not involve removal of some body part. But it's hard to draw parallells between circumcision and any form of female genital mutilation because females don't have much that is extraneous the way the foreskin is. There are a number of piercings I would not have an issue with. But anytime you're cutting something off it's going to be something vital.
 
Last edited:
reduction or elimination of the sensitive tissue of the outer genitalia, particularly the clitoris, in order to attenuate sexual desire in the female, maintain chastity and virginity before marriage and fidelity during marriage, and increase male sexual pleasure;
Similarly, many Christians to this day "believe in" circumcision to prevent masturbation and sexual immorality.
But not ALL or necessarily even most parents who have their kids circumcised do it for that reason.
 
BlackKat said:
You're right. But in 80% or more cases (at least according to the WHO's survey linked earlier in the thread) it's excision of the clitoris or worse.
Why would a 2000 survey be more accurate in 2007 than a 2005 survey?

It's hard to draw parallells between circumcision and any form of female genital mutilation because females don't have much that is extraneous the way the foreskin is. There are a number of piercings I would not have an issue with. But anytime you're cutting something off it's going to be something vital.
Why would the female prepuce or labia be "vital"?
 
Similarly, many Christians to this day "believe in" circumcision to prevent masturbation and sexual immorality.
But not ALL or necessarily even most parents who have their kids circumcised do it for that reason.

I find that hard to believe that any people believe in "circumcision to prevent masturbation and sexual immorality."
It's just for looks. Parents want their children's penises to look like what they think penises should look like.
 
I find that hard to believe that any people believe in "circumcision to prevent masturbation and sexual immorality."
It's just for looks. Parents want their children's penises to look like what they think penises should look like.
How many fundamentalist Christians do you know who really, really don't want their kids ever masturbating?
 
Something else that's crossed my mind is how do people see their children? As property to do with as they wish (within the law) or something else? At what age does this change?
 
So what does circumcision have to do with that?


http://www.giveshare.org/BibleStudy/134.circumcision.html

Left uncleansed this [smegma in an uncircumcised male] may cause inflammation and trouble. It is, therefore, necessary, in the case of an uncircumcised male baby, for the mother to regularly push the prepuce [foreskin] back behind the glans penis, and wash it; and as he grows old enough, the boy must be taught to do this regularly. This very need for sanitation causes irritation of the very seat of voluptuous sensation. It is very likely to stimulate sex arousal, and lead to masturbation [which is wrong]. This has been the chief cause of a serious ‘sex problem’ in the lives of countless young men prior to marriage.
The prepuce forms a protective covering over the easily aroused sensation-producing glans — yet, instead of actually ‘protecting’ it, the cleansing need produces just the opposite [effect]. The glans of the uncircumcised boy or man is exceedingly tender and sensitive. After circumcision, the glans gradually loses much of its sensitiveness, until the touch or rubbing of underclothing over it produces no more sensitiveness than clothing does to any other part of the body. Still, the circumcised enjoy all the voluptuous pleasure God made possible in marital coitus.
Parents are advised not to let a doctor perform circumcision of their baby at the time of birth. Insist that it be done when the baby is eight days old. Finally, Armstrong advises parents to insist that a little of the foreskin be left, for if all of the foreskin is cut off, "the skin is drawn back from the point of joining with the glans on erection, and this causes undue arousal and temptation" (page 228). Proper circumcision, Armstrong notes, will greatly lessen the danger of masturbation
 
Last edited:

Fringe groups do not mean much though. I could also point to a buch of white supremecist sites. But if I said:
White people hate black people

You'd of course want a quantifier, at the least for me to say:
A few white people hate black people.

So there's a handful of people who think circumcised penises are less easy to arouse. Won't they be in for a big surprise.
 
Last edited:
Fringe groups do not mean much though. I could also point to a buch of white supremecist sites. But if I said:
White people hate black people

You'd of course want a quantifier, at the least for me to say:
A few white people hate black people.

So there's a handful of people who think circumcised penises are less easy to arouse. Won't they be in for a big surprise.

Interesting analogy.
I'd say it's more than "a few" white people who hate blacks, and having spent most of my life as a Christian, I'd say that that's more than a fringe opinion in Christianity that having to clean under the foreskin will tempt a boy to masturbate.

But on both points I'm not sure I can actually prove I'm right.
 
Interesting analogy.
I'd say it's more than "a few" white people who hate blacks, and having spent most of my life as a Christian, I'd say that that's more than a fringe opinion in Christianity that having to clean under the foreskin will tempt a boy to masturbate.

But on both points I'm not sure I can actually prove I'm right.

Hey, more than two shakes at the urinal and your likely to get a funny look.

Bad design by God, really. You'd have thought it would have made a man's penis so it required the chemicals from a woman's vagina on it to allow a man to reach orgasm.

That is unless it's testing us. (I failed very early:D)
 
Most of the stuff brought up here, ie. cosmetics, tradition, functionality, etc. are, in my view, essentially moot. There is one issue that trumps all other issues.

For me the crux of the issue is really simple. It's called basic human rights. Absent medical necessity, people should not be altered or mutilated in ANY way without their educated consent. To do so is criminal.

The question of medical necessity is probably best left to doctors.
 
Ok, looks like the thread is coming to a close, but I'll ask anyway.

My reasoning while watching (and importantly I think, listening to) the video clip of the routine circumcision was two-fold. Firstly, I felt empathy for the child's suffering. I thought (felt?) the child was in significant pain and distress, and the pain and distress was caused by the procedure. Secondly, I assumed the child would be no worse off with his foreskin intact. Thus I perceived someone hurting a child for no valid reason which made me angry and I wanted to stop it.

If you haven't watched and listened to the video, but have been in the room while another child or your own has been circumcised (not for a medical reason), I want to know what you were thinking and feeling then instead.

So my questions are these:

Did everyone who was ok with it feel some empathy for the child? Or did you not feel anything? Was it just a sequence of actions to you?

What thoughts or assumptions made the difference for those who were ok with it? E.g., do you think (feel?) about foreskin in a negative sense?

I want to know the reasoning you used to come to the conclusion that it was worth it.
 
Ok, looks like the thread is coming to a close, but I'll ask anyway.

My reasoning while watching (and importantly I think, listening to) the video clip of the routine circumcision was two-fold. Firstly, I felt empathy for the child's suffering. I thought (felt?) the child was in significant pain and distress, and the pain and distress was caused by the procedure. Secondly, I assumed the child would be no worse off with his foreskin intact. Thus I perceived someone hurting a child for no valid reason which made me angry and I wanted to stop it.

If you haven't watched and listened to the video, but have been in the room while another child or your own has been circumcised (not for a medical reason), I want to know what you were thinking and feeling then instead.

So my questions are these:

Did everyone who was ok with it feel some empathy for the child? Or did you not feel anything? Was it just a sequence of actions to you?

What thoughts or assumptions made the difference for those who were ok with it? E.g., do you think (feel?) about foreskin in a negative sense?

I want to know the reasoning you used to come to the conclusion that it was worth it.

The answer's probably going to depend on if pain relief was used, and if so, what type. From what I understand, using EMLA cream, then waiting an hour or so, and then using local, and then using a nerve block works pretty well.
In hospitals this is almost never done, and that's also the place where mothers are the least likely to be there to see what actually happens.
 
Ok, looks like the thread is coming to a close, but I'll ask anyway.

My reasoning while watching (and importantly I think, listening to) the video clip of the routine circumcision was two-fold. Firstly, I felt empathy for the child's suffering. I thought (felt?) the child was in significant pain and distress, and the pain and distress was caused by the procedure. Secondly, I assumed the child would be no worse off with his foreskin intact. Thus I perceived someone hurting a child for no valid reason which made me angry and I wanted to stop it.

If you haven't watched and listened to the video, but have been in the room while another child or your own has been circumcised (not for a medical reason), I want to know what you were thinking and feeling then instead.

So my questions are these:

Did everyone who was ok with it feel some empathy for the child? Or did you not feel anything? Was it just a sequence of actions to you?

What thoughts or assumptions made the difference for those who were ok with it? E.g., do you think (feel?) about foreskin in a negative sense?

I want to know the reasoning you used to come to the conclusion that it was worth it.

I watched the video mentioned (and a few others) of circumcision, and been in the room during circumcisions (bike courier picking up just removed foreskins for delivery to testing facility - and no that's not the oddest cargo I ever had). I do feel sorry for the child but in the same sense I feel sorry for them when they get a rectal thermometer, or get their bath, or... Anything beyond cuddling up to mommy's breast or a bottle or sleeping when you're a newborn is going to be uncomfortable. Now if I had seen a circumcision where I /knew/ there were no anesthetics involved I would feel badly for the child. But even still... the procedure is generally done quickly and as painlessly as possible, and at that age there's just not much going through your mind beyond eat, poop, sleep.

For me the HIV tests, the easier cleaning, etc... are all just bonuses to having the foreskin removed. Although I myself love not having a foreskin, and would seriously consider having any son of mine circumcised, it is for aesthetic reasons first and foremost. I just don't like the way foreskins look (and I am well aware this is a case of not being used to penises with foreskins as much as anything else.). But I'm ok with that.

Perhaps it's because I've always been circumcised and nigh everyone I know as well.

Perhaps it's because I have spent most of my life in social circles and cliques where body modification is not frowned upon, almost required, in the form of tattoos, body piercing, and more... just for aesthetics.

Perhaps it is because I view the foreskin in the same light as other animals similar penis mechanics but know that those mechanics are designed to warm and protect the penis. The advent of clothing negates a lot of necessities and in fact many men end up with impotency problems as their testicles get too warm to produce enough sperm. Just as we no longer have hairy, calloused, hobbit-like feet as the norm because we wear shoes.

I would never want anyone to have to get their children circumcised if they were not comfortable with the procedure. But I would also never condemn anyone for having their children circumcised (or for that matter - such as in many Latino families - ears pierced). If I thought there was extreme pain involved or that the child would be missing out on something I would feel differently. But as a sexually satisfied circumcised male surrounded by other sexually satisfied circumcised males it's hard to feel left out.
 
I know several men who say that they wish they hadn't have been circumcised as infants, and now think their penises are numb to some degree as a result.
Well this is a bit late to be asking since you posted this a while back but, how do they know their penises wouldn't be numb to some degree even if they were not circumcised?
 
If anyone wants to look at the research that led to the recommendation circumcision prevented HIV, I posted a lot of sources for circumcision preventing HIV in this thread on Skepchick.

Here they are as is from that discussion so the discussion on these posts will be out of context, and some of the sources may have already been posted here. You can go to the thread to see comments and responses. There is more than just circumcision being discussed in the thread.

Posts don't have numbers, this one is on page 2.
writerdd said:
skeptigirl said:
A good example is HIV. The cells in the foreskin allow a direct portal of entry for HIV. Circumcised men in Africa have been shown to have a lower rate of HIV than circumcised males.

Do you have a source for this information? Another group I'm in is having a feud about circumcision and I'd like to post this info. There's one guy in particular who keep crying about how circumcision is child abuse. (I've actually bailed from the group until the penis frenzy is over, but this would be worth adding to the conversation.)
The penis frenzy? That's cute.

Randomized, controlled intervention trial of male circumcision for reduction of HIV infection risk: the ANRS 1265 Trial.
...A total of 3,274 uncircumcised men, aged 18-24 y, were randomized to a control or an intervention group with follow-up visits at months 3, 12, and 21. Male circumcision was offered to the intervention group immediately after randomization and to the control group at the end of the follow-up....There were 20 HIV infections (incidence rate = 0.85 per 100 person-years) in the intervention group and 49 (2.1 per 100 person-years) in the control group, corresponding to an RR of 0.40 (95% CI: 0.24%-0.68%; p < 0.001). This RR corresponds to a protection of 60% (95% CI: 32%-76%)....

But hold on a minute folks. I brought this up in response to the, 'foreskin evolved therefore it must be good' post. I certainly never meant circumcised men were safe from HIV. It was observed in some African countries with high rates of HIV that tribes which practiced circumcision had lower rates of HIV than tribes which did not practice it. This study followed and it was conclusive enough that the trial was stopped so the rest of the men could be circumcised. In addition, the cells in the foreskin have been shown to be the portal of entry for the HIV.

Circumcision is of benefit in countries such as those in Africa with high rates of HIV. All possible measures to control HIV need to be implemented in those countries. (Bush of course has his head up his ass and is spending all our money on teaching abstinence there while spending very little on other measures. He'd rather please his base than actually slow the spread of HIV.) But I digress...

I will repeat what I posted earlier. Circumcision has been shown to offer a small health benefit. The chance of the foreskin getting stuck in the retracted position and cutting off circulation to the tip, the chance the foreskin will not properly retract due to the size of the opening, and the collection of bacteria under the foreskin which can be a risk in itself and adds a slightly increased risk of urethra or urinary tract infection are the risks of not circumcising. These are rare, and manageable risks. Infection post-op or reaction to the anesthetic are risks with circumcision, also very rare, but to be fair need mention.

The benefit is not big enough that it should be the only deciding factor in the choice to circumcise your child. If you were poor and lived in Africa, India, or a few other places in Asia and Eastern Europe, the HIV protection, while not complete, would be a very good reason to circumcise your infant. Ysabella doesn't live in one of those countries. (Hey you're in my state. :D ) But if she did I would have said, without a doubt she should get the thing done. For everyone else, there is a slight health benefit but not a big health benefit.

-

[page 5]
I am not invested in the outcome here. I am not campaigning for nor against circumcision in Western countries or in Africa or any other third world countries. It's annoying to be pegged as pro-circumcision here just for posting current research and responding to an inaccurate conclusion the relationship between HIV and circumcision had been ruled out.

I have read sufficient research to conclude the relationship between circumcision and HIV is supported. No studies to date, regardless of the quality of the studies that have been done, have found data contradicting the relationship. But that is a completely different statement from proposing or supporting the use of circumcision as a means of controlling HIV in Africa or elsewhere. It suggests there are benefits in countries with such high rates of HIV that everything possible should be utilized in the effort to combat the disease.

The UNAIDS statement on South African trial findings regarding male circumcision and HIV:
Although UNAIDS believes that it is premature to recommend male circumcision services as part of HIV prevention programmes, there is heightened interest from governments and the general public in male circumcision in a number of African countries. News of the trial results presented today may increase demand for male circumcision services. Governments should take steps now to ensure that male circumcision is conducted by trained practitioners in safe and equipped settings in order to reduce the rate of post-operative complications.

I looked at the first 40 returns from a Pub Med search for HIV and circumcision. Unfortunately many of these links did not have abstracts so I didn't really look at 40 citations. Sometimes you can find the citations without fees if you Google them. I didn't have time. But the point of posting the following was just to give the thread readers some idea where the research is on this matter.

This 2005 review, Male circumcision and the risk of HIV infection, supports a similar conclusion as the 1999 review posted above.
These studies' systematic lack of control of important confounding factors makes the assessment of the association between male circumcision and HIV transmission very difficult and raises doubt about the validity of the current findings. Randomized trials are needed to determine the true strength of the association. Until then, a decision to recommend mass male circumcision to prevent HIV transmission in sub-Saharan Africa is premature and risky.

But this one, HIV and male circumcision--a systematic review with assessment of the quality of studies, objects to the validity of any of the meta-analyses.
Study quality was very variable and no studies measured the same set of potential confounding variables. Therefore, conducting a meta-analysis was inappropriate. Detailed quality assessment of observational studies can provide a useful visual aid to interpreting findings. Although most studies show an association between male circumcision and prevention of HIV, these results may be limited by confounding, which is unlikely to be adjusted for.

Many well done individual studies support the link regardless of the meta-analyses, including the randomized study I first linked to. Here is another. Female-to-male infectivity of HIV-1 among circumcised and uncircumcised Kenyan men.
CONCLUSIONS: After accounting for sexual behavior, we found that uncircumcised men were at a >2-fold increased risk of acquiring HIV-1 per sex act, compared with circumcised men.

This one, HIV infection and circumcision: cutting through the hyperbole, discusses some other factors which must be considered besides merely a single clinical outcome.
Our results show that the medical literature supporting mass circumcision for the prevention of HIV infection is inconsistent and based on observation studies. Even if the two ongoing randomised controlled trials in Africa show a protective benefit of circumcision, factors such as the unknown complication rate of the procedure, the permanent injury to the penis, human rights violations and the potential for veiled colonialism need to be taken into account. Based on the best estimates, mass circumcision would not be as cost-effective as other interventions that have been demonstrated to be effective. Even if effective, mass circumcision as a preventive measure for HIV in developed countries is difficult to justify.

Which some studies are now trying to address such as this one, Adult male circumcision: results of a standardized procedure in Kisumu District, Kenya.
CONCLUSION: Safe and acceptable adult male circumcision services can be delivered in developing countries should male circumcision ultimately be advocated as a public-health measure.

Here's an example of the controversy, which sadly should be based on science, not emotion, but clearly isn't. news article: nternational AIDS Society conference update. Male circumcision as a prevention method? Study was controversial from day one.
Investigators presented evidence at the July International AIDS Society conference in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, in that male circumcision helps reduce the risk of HIV infection among men who have sex with women. The study showed that circumcised men were more than 60% less likely than uncircumcised men to be infected with HIV when having sex with infected female partners. The news was not welcomed by all quarters. Anti-circumcision activists quickly called on the United Nations to classify circumcision of children younger than age 18 as a human rights crime.

There was one study addressing risk in the USA. Sexual risk, nitrite inhalant use, and lack of circumcision associated with HIV seroconversion in men who have sex with men in the United States.
factors for HIV seroconversion were increased number of reported HIV-negative male sex partners (adjusted odds ratio (AOR) = 1.14 per partner, population attributable risk (PAR) = 28%), nitrite inhalant use (AOR = 2.2, PAR = 28%), unprotected receptive anal sex with an HIV unknown serostatus partner (AOR = 2.7, PAR = 15%) or HIV-positive partner (AOR = 3.4, PAR = 12%), protected receptive anal sex with an HIV-positive partner (AOR = 2.2, PAR = 11%), lack of circumcision (AOR = 2.0, PAR = 10%), and receptive oral sex to ejaculation with an HIV-positive partner (AOR = 3.8, PAR = 7%). Having a large number of male sex partners, nitrite inhalant use, and engaging in receptive anal sex explained the majority of infections in this cohort and should be targeted in prevention strategies for MSM.
Note they cut off their measure of "most" at 11% and did not list circs, 10% nor oral sex with an infected partner, 7% in their conclusion.

And this one looked at cost benefit analysis regardless of HIV transmission. Cost analysis of neonatal circumcision in a large health maintenance organization.
Cost benefits of circumcision resulted from prevention of infant urinary tract infection, balanoposthitis, phimosis, HIV infection and penile cancer. Assuming initial neonatal circumcision cost to be 200 dollars, the future health care cost offset (avoided) was calculated as 183 dollars (range 93 dollars to 303 dollars in 95% of simulations). CONCLUSIONS: Multiple lifetime medical benefits of neonatal circumcision can be achieved at little or no cost. Because postneonatal circumcision is so expensive, its rate is the most important factor determining future cost savings from newborn circumcision.

-

[page 6]
SZABO, R. and SHORT, R. How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? Bristish Medical Journal 320: 1592-1594. Jun. 10, 2000. (Available: http://www.bmj.com/cgi/reprint/320/7249/1592.pdf , Accessed Jun. 27, 2001)

How does male circumcision protect against HIV infection? (non pdf link)

To summarize, the foreskin is susceptible to small scratches and tears during intercourse and contains a high density of Langerhans cells - primary target cells for HIV.

I had no idea this was such a hot topic for you boys. Mind you I'm not complaining. I have my personal preference but really don't care that many prefer intact foreskins or object to removing them from infants.

-

[page 9]
Circumcision could prevent millions of AIDS cases in Africa: report

It's a WHO sponsored report. I haven't had time to read it yet but it sounds like one study I already cited..
The study, coordinated by Brian Williams of the World Health Organization (WHO) and published in the US review PLoS Medicine, is based on results of a trial conducted in South Africa, in which men were offered the chance to be circumcised. Those who chose to be circumcised had a lower HIV infection rate 18 months later.

-

[page 9]
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20061129/hl_nm/aids_africa_circumcision_dc_1

Seems the research is now strong enough to start promoting circumcision as an HIV prevention tactic.

Mind you we are talking Africa here and not the USA.

-
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom