Ivor the Engineer
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 11,103
There is something I don´t understand:
Most optimistic estimates give a protection rate of circumcision against AIDS of around 40% (correct me if I´m wrong.)
How can this be even considered to be a valuable, practical protection against AIDS? You´d still need to use condoms anyway... I wouldn´t have sex with a 60% risk of getting AIDS!
And it could even have negative consequences, badly informed people having more unprotected sex, with a false sense of security.
I´ve often seen these "studies" cited (and probably funded) by muslim apologists, and since we can´t expect much regard for science from these lkind of lobbies, I think it would be a good thing to look at them with a heavily skeptical attitude.
And were those studies about AIDS protection debunked or not? Please tell us! (I can´t be arse to read another of these threads, even though they are quite funny...)
The research is solid. The Risk Reduction is ~60% for the men in the study. The controversy is whether infants should be circumcised because it is a simpler and safer procedure, but violates their human rights.
ETA: The effect is best viewed at a population, rather than individual level.