Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

There is something I don´t understand:

Most optimistic estimates give a protection rate of circumcision against AIDS of around 40% (correct me if I´m wrong.)

How can this be even considered to be a valuable, practical protection against AIDS? You´d still need to use condoms anyway... I wouldn´t have sex with a 60% risk of getting AIDS!

And it could even have negative consequences, badly informed people having more unprotected sex, with a false sense of security.

I´ve often seen these "studies" cited (and probably funded) by muslim apologists, and since we can´t expect much regard for science from these lkind of lobbies, I think it would be a good thing to look at them with a heavily skeptical attitude.

And were those studies about AIDS protection debunked or not? Please tell us! (I can´t be arse to read another of these threads, even though they are quite funny...)

The research is solid. The Risk Reduction is ~60% for the men in the study. The controversy is whether infants should be circumcised because it is a simpler and safer procedure, but violates their human rights.

ETA: The effect is best viewed at a population, rather than individual level.
 
There is something I don´t understand:

Most optimistic estimates give a protection rate of circumcision against AIDS of around 40% (correct me if I´m wrong.)

How can this be even considered to be a valuable, practical protection against AIDS? You´d still need to use condoms anyway... I wouldn´t have sex with a 60% risk of getting AIDS!

And it could even have negative consequences, badly informed people having more unprotected sex, with a false sense of security.

I´ve often seen these "studies" cited (and probably funded) by muslim apologists, and since we can´t expect much regard for science from these lkind of lobbies, I think it would be a good thing to look at them with a heavily skeptical attitude.

And were those studies about AIDS protection debunked or not? Please tell us! (I can´t be arse to read another of these threads, even though they are quite funny...)

The studies about decreased HIV risk are indeed valid. The only thing in question is the exact % of risk reduction. As to the false sense of security, that would indeed be a risk if you do not combine it with other safety education. Also, condoms are not a 100% fool-proof safety measure. They break sometimes, or fall off sometimes, or... Combine the two and you're even safer.

I don't know why you're bringing in "muslim apologists" though. Circumcision is (or was) most prevalent in North America, Europe, Oceanic (Aus, NZ).

Circumcision is almost universally a cosmetic surgery and the people giving and receiving the surgery are not trying to fool anyone. The only real question is whether it's fair to make a decision for a child that they are going to have a circumcised penis. So far in this thread the uncircumcised men who love their foreskins have said NO. And the circumcised men who love their circumcised penises have said YES.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Circumcision is almost universally a cosmetic surgery and the people giving and receiving the surgery are not trying to fool anyone. The only real question is whether it's fair to make a decision for a child that they are going to have a circumcised penis. So far in this thread the uncircumcised men who love their foreskins have said NO. And the circumcised men who love their circumcised penises have said YES.

So one could argue that circumcision does have a long term effect on a man's brain with respect to ethical decisions:)
 
There is something I don´t understand:

Most optimistic estimates give a protection rate of circumcision against AIDS of around 40% (correct me if I´m wrong.)

The most optimistic give a rate of 76%. Most of the results cluster around the 50-55% range.

How can this be even considered to be a valuable, practical protection against AIDS? You´d still need to use condoms anyway... I wouldn´t have sex with a 60% risk of getting AIDS!

Ummm....that's not what the number means.

The risk of getting HIV in the population in question is about 2 to 3 percent per year in those who are not circumcised and about 1 percent in those who are.

And it could even have negative consequences, badly informed people having more unprotected sex, with a false sense of security.

I´ve often seen these "studies" cited (and probably funded) by muslim apologists, and since we can´t expect much regard for science from these lkind of lobbies, I think it would be a good thing to look at them with a heavily skeptical attitude.

The studies have nothing to do with Muslim apologists - not the researchers (personal knowledge), nor the funding. The quality of the studies was very good and the conclusions drawn from the studies were supported by the results. My attitude was skeptical (it usually is anyway) as I am not in favour of circumcision.

And were those studies about AIDS protection debunked or not? Please tell us! (I can´t be arse to read another of these threads, even though they are quite funny...)

No.

Linda
 
Linda, do you know if the info. I posted earlier about Candian Physicians not having to perform routine infant circumcision is (still) correct?

I just noticed the website the document was from cirp.org - which has already been pointed out to have a biased view (anti-circ).

Also, do you know of any fMRI studies done on infants while being circumcised? It seems strange that there's only the one very dodgy been done (complete with conspiracy theory!), given the potential for the data from a study like this to help settle the argument over infant pain and distress.
 
Last edited:
Thankyou Linda, Ivor and BlackCat. I trust your criteria (for now).

The only thing that I´m still not sure about is the loss of sensitivity and other functions of our "beloved" foreskins... but this thread is becoming a bit repetitive so I won´t keep nagging about it.
 
Here's what some of the target population think:

Acceptability of male circumcision for prevention of HIV infection in Zambia.Lukobo MD, Bailey RC.
Chicago State University, USA.

Numerous observational studies and three clinical trials have shown male circumcision (MC) to be partially protective against HIV acquisition in heterosexual men. This has led to consideration of introducing circumcision as an HIV prevention strategy in parts of sub-Saharan Africa. This study assesses the acceptability of male circumcision as an intervention to improve male genital hygiene and reduce sexually transmitted infections, including HIV-1 in Zambia. Thirty-four focus group discussions were conducted - 17 with men and 17 with women - in four districts chosen to represent urban and rural communities where circumcision is and is not traditionally practiced. In communities where circumcision is little practiced, the main facilitators for acceptance were improved genital hygiene, HIV/STI prevention, and low cost. The main barriers were cultural tradition, high cost, pain, and concerns for safety. If MC is proven to reduce risk for HIV and STIs, most participants reported that they would seek circumcision for themselves or their partners or their sons if it was free or at a minimal cost. Acceptability of male circumcision for STI and HIV prevention appears to be high in Zambia.
 
Some new research on the effects of circumcision on sexuality:

The effect of male circumcision on sexuality.Kim D, Pang MG.
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea.

OBJECTIVE: To prospectively study, using a questionnaire, the sexuality of men circumcised as adults compared to uncircumcised men, and to compare their sex lives before and after circumcision. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: The study included 373 sexually active men, of whom 255 were circumcised and 118 were not. Of the 255 circumcised men, 138 had been sexually active before circumcision, and all were circumcised at >20 years of age. As the Brief Male Sexual Function Inventory does not specifically address the quality of sex life, questions were added to compare sexual and masturbatory pleasure before and after circumcision. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in sexual drive, erection, ejaculation, and ejaculation latency time between circumcised and uncircumcised men. Masturbatory pleasure decreased after circumcision in 48% of the respondents, while 8% reported increased pleasure. Masturbatory difficulty increased after circumcision in 63% of the respondents but was easier in 37%. About 6% answered that their sex lives improved, while 20% reported a worse sex life after circumcision. CONCLUSION: There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings.

PMID: 17155977 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
 
Some new research on the effects of circumcision on sexuality:

Now let´s see what the "emotionally unattached" pro-cut commentators have to say about this... because if that study is sound... there´s no way one can defend doing it to kids... I mean, "decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment"... If an adult wants to take that risk, ok, but newborns...

And they´ll say we´re being "emotional" about it... If maiming a newborn baby doesn´t get you emotional then the problem is yours matey...
 
Now let´s see what the "emotionally unattached" pro-cut commentators have to say about this... because if that study is sound... there´s no way one can defend doing it to kids... I mean, "decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment"... If an adult wants to take that risk, ok, but newborns...

And they´ll say we´re being "emotional" about it... If maiming a newborn baby doesn´t get you emotional then the problem is yours matey...

The problem with the study is it involved people who had it done after 20+ years. In essence they've had to get used to having a new penis. Psychology plays as much a role in sexual pleasure and ability as what parts you have.

There is no way to judge subjective sensations in the penis between someone who has a foreskin and someone who does not have one (virtually their whole life). This is because they are two different people. Best you can get in this case is self-reporting and this is not an accurate way to measure.

My penis is circumcised and I feel TONS of pleasure when I masturbate or have sex. I mean how are we going to compare my pleasure to yours? Time us? It's silly to try to compare.
 
...not to mention that you can find studies going the opposite direction, and no direction at all:
http://content.karger.com/ProdukteDB/produkte.asp?Doi=85930
Results: Fifty-nine percent of patients (88/150) responded. The total mean IIEF-5 score was 22.41 ± 0.94 and 21.13 ± 3.17 before and after circumcision, respectively (p = 0.4). Seventy-four percent of patients had no change in their libido levels, 69% noticed less pain during intercourse (p < 0.05), and 44% of the patients (p = 0.04) and 38% of the partners (p = 0.02) thought the penis appearance improved after circumcision. Penile sensation improved after circumcision in 38% (p = 0.01) but got worse in 18%, with the remainder having no change. Overall satisfaction was 61%. Conclusions: Penile sensitivity had variable outcomes after circumcision. The poor outcome of circumcision considered by overall satisfaction rates suggests that when we circumcise men, these outcome data should be discussed during the informed consent process.

In otherwords this study found that it didn't really matter if you're circumcised or not ... that some people liked it better (61% is a majority but not by much especially in a sample size less than millions of men) and some did not. It's inconclusive. Having a foreskin or not is really just a matter of looks.
 
Last edited:
"There is no way to judge subjective sensations in the penis between someone who has a foreskin and someone who does not"

The fact that a lot of nerve endings are lost together with with the poor little foreskin? Having no purely objective way to judge it, shouldn´t we take the side of caution?
 
And now, to lighten the mood:

A man shows up one morning at his local hospital, and speaks to a surgeon.

The surgeon says, "What can I do for you today, Mr. Longfellow?"

"Well," Longfellow replies, "I've decided to be castrated."

The doctor blinked and his jaw slightly dropped, but he quickly covered his professional aplomb. "Castrated? Are you sure?"

"I know what you're going to say, Doc... I've read all the arguments for and against it. I'm not doing this for religious grounds, but I'm doing it for my wife. She thinks it'll make things better for both of us, and I'll do anything for her. My own doc says the process is simple and painless, but he won't do it on ethical grounds. That leaves you..."

The doc considered for a moment, agreed, and made arrangements for the operation. A few days later, as Longfellow was resting in the recovery room, he turned to his neighbor.

"Hey, Manny Longfellow," he introduced to his neighbor. "What're you in for?"

"Pete Zimmer," the neighbor replied. "Circumcision."

Longfellow snapped his fingers and said, "Damn, I knew it started with a 'C'."
 
LOL Z. That's just what I needed to read before going to work (which is kind of like being castrated).
 
Circumcision is almost universally a cosmetic surgery and the people giving and receiving the surgery are not trying to fool anyone.
Which is why this whole thread has been about its so-called medical benefits, and you're the only one harping about aesthetics. :rolleyes:

The only real question is whether it's fair to make a decision for a child that they are going to have a circumcised penis. So far in this thread the uncircumcised men who love their foreskins have said NO. And the circumcised men who love their circumcised penises have said YES.
As was said earlier, female genital mutilation is perpetrated by women who have had it done, and think it normal and "right".

If you sincerely think that it's perfectly fine to remove a body part of an unconsenting infant just for a subjective, irrational cosmetic purpose (since, as you say yourself, it's all that there's left), you're not quite right in the head.
 
Which is why this whole thread has been about its so-called medical benefits, and you're the only one harping about aesthetics. :rolleyes:
The thread is about both. Because almost all circumcisions are done for aesthetics reasons the arguement is also whether it is fair or not to make aesthetics judgements for our children.

As was said earlier, female genital mutilation is perpetrated by women who have had it done, and think it normal and "right".

If you sincerely think that it's perfectly fine to remove a body part of an unconsenting infant just for a subjective, irrational cosmetic purpose (since, as you say yourself, it's all that there's left), you're not quite right in the head.

You can not compare the two. Castration would be an equivalent to female genital mutilation, not circumcision. Also female genital mutilation is almost never done for aesthetics. It is almost always done with the express purpose of making sure a woman can not enjoy sex or even have it at all. It does not matter if the person who thinks women should not enjoy sex is a man or a woman. It's still opression.
Female genital mutilation consists of excising the clitoris and or labia, and also can include sewing mostly shut the vagina.
 
Last edited:
BlackKat said:
You can not compare the two. Castration would be an equivalent to female genital mutilation, not circumcision. Also female genital mutilation is almost never done for aesthetics. It is almost always done with the express purpose of making sure a woman can not enjoy sex or even have it at all. It does not matter if the person who thinks women should not enjoy sex is a man or a woman. It's still opression.
Female genital mutilation consists of excising the clitoris and or labia, and also can include sewing mostly shut the vagina.
Aaaand again...repeating a false claim over and over and over again does not make it incrementally more true with each repetition.
It might appear to make it more true in the mind of the one repeating the claim, but in objective reality, it doesn't actually work like that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom