Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

As long as you aren't in a country with a soaring HIV pandemic, Beleth, your decision does not go against any of the research I posted.
 
You are missing something here which any parent of a teenager knows. A 12 yr old, and even an 18 yr old can probably make many informed decisions. However, they are still immature in many ways and some decisions they are not so good at making. One that is well documented is poor judgment of risk. That's why so many teenage drivers are killed in vehicle accidents. That's why kids experiment with drugs. That's why cigarette manufacturers know they have to addict kids to cigarettes before they are young adults because young adults rarely decide to start smoking now that the dangers have been revealed. So risk perception is an issue.

The second type of decision which teens are often not mature enough make is that of choosing something they know will hurt.

Not in my experience. I chose to have surgery on two ingrown toenails (both sides of each one) when I was 12. I knew it was going to hurt - I'd had several procedures to remove the sides of the nails temporarily about once every month for a year before. I even went to one guy who just put the scalpel straight in, causing a fair amount of blood to be let. When they got infected from time to time just having the covers on in bed would make them ache.

And yet, even that I knew how much it was likely to hurt (and they DID hurt like hell for a day after and were very sore for about a week) I chose to have it done. Are you claiming my choice as a 12-year old is unique?

Having said all that, what that kid went through in the video (you have watched it, haven't you?) was much worse. Did you choose to put your son through that because you prefer the look of a circumcised penis? Or did you come up with an elaborate delusion to make yourself feel better?

My once high level of respect for you has plummeted, as it has for all parents (and medical "professionals" who tolerate it to go on) who have had that done to their child(ren) when it was not required, for what boils down to cosmetic or ritualistic reasons no matter how much they pretend otherwise.
 
...Having said all that, what that kid went through in the video (you have watched it, haven't you?) was much worse. Did you choose to put your son through that because you prefer the look of a circumcised penis? Or did you come up with an elaborate delusion to make yourself feel better?

My once high level of respect for you has plummeted, as it has for all parents (and medical "professionals" who tolerate it to go on) who have had that done to their child(ren) when it was not required, for what boils down to cosmetic or ritualistic reasons no matter how much they pretend otherwise.

I think most of us pro-circumcision posters have been pretty open about prefering circumcised penises for cosmetic reasons. The other potential benefits are just that, potential and largely secondary. But what that kid "went through" in the video was not any more horrific to me than the snipping of the umbilical cord, the removal of a vestigal tail, or the clipping of ingrown toenails is to me.
 
Last edited:
Come on Ivor, you are using your personal single anecdote as evidence that all or even a majority of twelve year olds would be the same, and that cutting a toenail was equal to cutting on one's genitals, something a 12 year old would clearly have emotions interfering in the thought process about.

I know you know better than to draw that conclusion based on that evidence.:rolleyes:
 
I think most of us pro-circumcision posters have been pretty open about prefering circumcised penises for cosmetic reasons. The other potential benefits are just that, potential and largely secondary. But what that kid "went through" in the video was not any more horrific to me than the snipping of the umbilical cord, the removal of a vestigal tail, or the clipping of ingrown toenails is to me.

All your examples are either required for normal functioning or extremely rare. I.e. they are medically indicated. Hopefully they are carried out quickly (matter of seconds) or with appropriate and significant pain relief.

The pro-circumcision parents and medical professionals on this thread are not skeptical; they are True Believers. They can close their eyes and block their ears to the sight and sound of torture performed and perpetuated because of their delusions and whims.
 
Come on Ivor, you are using your personal single anecdote as evidence that all or even a majority of twelve year olds would be the same, and that cutting a toenail was equal to cutting on one's genitals, something a 12 year old would clearly have emotions interfering in the thought process about.

I know you know better than to draw that conclusion based on that evidence.:rolleyes:

I think you're getting confused with my point of view about regions of the world with high incidence of HIV (infant circumcision is, on balance, indicated), and the US, where the effects of torture are being researched to see if it has any advantages.

ETA: In the regions of the world it is indicated it better be performed with a hell of a lot more pain relief that the child in the video got.
 
Last edited:
It has nothing to do with real risk or real pain, Ivor. It is what a 12 year old perceives the risk and pain to be.

I give thousands of shots to people. You cannot feel that needle going in. Yet some people are unable to sit still because they anticipate pain which is not going to happen. You have to tell adults, "no I'm not waiting", otherwise they want you to wait while they just get more freaked out.

I didn't watch the video, BTW. I've seen hundreds of circumcision procedures including my son's.
 
Ivor said:
I think you're getting confused with my point of view about regions of the world with high incidence of HIV (infant circumcision is, on balance, indicated)
I'm still not seeing it really being indicated even there. It comes closer, but still not worth it. People could still be allowed to make the choice for themselves around the age of 17 or 18.
 
I am going by my extensive review of the medical literature. There is unequivocal evidence HIV risk is decreased considerably. The other medical benefits are small but favor circumcision.

Nope, sorry, this was thoroughly debunked the last time it was brought up. I'm not going to bother digging up all the citations again, since they're easily available by going to the previous thread.

The gist of the thing was:

1) The data was not unequivocal, it was, in fact, in dire need of some serious tightening of methodology with some sampling issues; particularly as it conflated several different modifications of sexual behaviour along with the circumcision. One of the biggest problems was simply self-reporting, and the cultural tendency to not report certain types of sexual activity. It also didn't account for high-risk sexual practices such as "dry sex".

2) The only effect noted was on Female to Male transmission, focusing on vaginal intercourse. Statistically the lowest rate of transmission. Data on FTM and rMTiM transmission through anal intercourse, the second and third lowest rates of transmission, was inadequate due to reporting issues. Compared to MTF and iMTrM transmission, the rate of FTM transmission is statistically insigificant.

3) Even the best, most generous estimate of the reduction of FTM HIV transmission is less than half the reduction accomplished by proper use of a condom. More reasonable estimates put it at about a quarter of the reduction created by proper condom use.

4) Circumcision does not have a statistically signifcant impact on any other problem where adequate personal hygiene is practiced. That includes penile cancer and HPV transmission, where the measured differences were equal to or lower than the margin for error.

The only situation were circumcision was shown to have any significant benefit at all was in condition of inadequate personal hygiene.
 
The argument is a small risk for a small gain. Sure, condoms work better, but HIV isn't just for Xmas - it's for life. That tiny added bit of protection for some is argued as being beneficial for a tiny compensation (removing the foreskin).
Except that it isn't added. The effect isn't cumulative in any statistically significant way. The difference between transmission rates with condom use vs. non-condom use is orders of magnitude higher than the difference between circumcized vs. non-circumcized. It's the equivalent of wearing a scuba-diving wetsuit inside a submarine. Yes, it does provide some additional protection against getting wet if the submarine happens to leak, but not that much, since with enough time the water and will soak through anyway.
 
it is absurd to have some Westerner who enjoys a low risk of HIV judging a parent in the third world who would choose to add the protection of a circumcision to their struggle to keep their infant alive.[/B]

Since I can't find any information, do you have any data on HIV transmissibility through infant sexual activity? How many uncircumcised neonates aquire HIV through unprotected sex, vs. the number of circumcised neonates who aquire HIV through unprotected sex? You seem to have all the answers here, so I'm sure you can find a study on this somewhere.

Or perhaps this is something that adults are capable of deciding for themselves.
 
Nope, sorry, this was thoroughly debunked the last time it was brought up. I'm not going to bother digging up all the citations again, since they're easily available by going to the previous thread.

The gist of the thing was:

1) The data was not unequivocal, it was, in fact, in dire need of some serious tightening of methodology with some sampling issues; particularly as it conflated several different modifications of sexual behaviour along with the circumcision. One of the biggest problems was simply self-reporting, and the cultural tendency to not report certain types of sexual activity. It also didn't account for high-risk sexual practices such as "dry sex".

I'm trying to understand what you are getting at with your criticisms. How would not accounting for high-risk sexual practices influence the results, given that these other practices should be evenly distributed among both groups (by the process of randomization)? Or are you talking about the speculation that circumcised men had less sex (while recovering from the procedure) and that accounts for the lowered risk - an idea that was not born out once the results were published?

2) The only effect noted was on Female to Male transmission, focusing on vaginal intercourse. Statistically the lowest rate of transmission. Data on FTM and rMTiM transmission through anal intercourse, the second and third lowest rates of transmission, was inadequate due to reporting issues. Compared to MTF and iMTrM transmission, the rate of FTM transmission is statistically insigificant.

Focusing on rates is misleading. For example, a low rate in a high frequency activity can have much larger absolute effect than a higher rate in a low frequency activity. The penile cancer issue is a good example. If we wished to make circumcision look fabulous, we could announce the 20-fold reduction in penile cancer in big letters (combining careful selection of which research to quote with the withholding of crucial information about frequency). Using all of the information to look at the size of the effect (for HIV) does show that it would be substantial/desirable under the specific circumstances for which it is recommended.

3) Even the best, most generous estimate of the reduction of FTM HIV transmission is less than half the reduction accomplished by proper use of a condom. More reasonable estimates put it at about a quarter of the reduction created by proper condom use.

The best information we have puts the reduction at 50% (generous estimates are 75%). Regular condom use is estimated to reduce it by 85%. Programs to promote regular condom use have variable success. In the trials (which included an educational program promoting safe sex practices including condom use and the provision of free condoms), the best results were up to 41% regular condom use. So while regular condom use has a higher rate of success (although it would require serious fudging to come up with some way to make it four times better), the end result depends upon how many people participate in either activity. Circumcision showed a substantial benefit in addition to the promotion of regular condom use.

Linda
 
Luchog, what you claim to be, "thoroughly debunked the last time it was brought up", is nothing more than your unsupported opinion. Support it with some research refuting the conclusions that have now become an evidence based recommendation for countries with high rates of HIV by the leading public health authorities in the world.
 
It has nothing to do with real risk or real pain, Ivor. It is what a 12 year old perceives the risk and pain to be.

What has that got to do with anything in the developed world? Any studies done of circumcision on an infant, with their brain being monitored with fMRI?

There's this, but it's a biased site.

The baby was kept in the machine for several minutes to generate baseline data of the normal metabolic activity in the brain. This was used to compare to the data gathered during and after the surgery. Analysis of the MRI data indicated that the surgery subjected the infant to significant trauma. The greatest changes occurred in the limbic system concentrating in the amygdala and in the frontal and temporal lobes.

A neurologist who saw the results to postulated that the data indicated that circumcision affected most intensely the portions of the victim’s brain associated with reasoning, perception and emotions. Follow up
tests on the infant one day, one week and one month after the surgery indicated that the child’s brain never returned to its baseline configuration. In other words, the evidence generated by this research indicated that the brain of the circumcised infant was permanently changed by the surgery.

The latter part is not surprising, or to me relavent, since an infants' brain is changing very quickly anyway.

IMO this research should be made a priority in the US to make sure the minimum trauma is being caused by this procedure.

I give thousands of shots to people. You cannot feel that needle going in. Yet some people are unable to sit still because they anticipate pain which is not going to happen. You have to tell adults, "no I'm not waiting", otherwise they want you to wait while they just get more freaked out.

So? I'm still not getting how this relates the issue I have with circumcision of infants in the developed world.

I didn't watch the video, BTW. I've seen hundreds of circumcision procedures including my son's.

And no doubt grandma will be recommending that her grandson is circumcised because it looks good.
 
Have you totally lost track of this discussion, Ivor? I don't have a clue what you are on about in half your post.

You suggested parents wait and let kid decide.
Problem: Kids are sexually active and thus at risk for HIV before they are mature enough to decide.
You suggested because you volunteered to have an ingrown toenail removed at age 12 that all kids were mature enough by age 12 to decide if they want to be circumcised.
Problem: That isn't evidence, and a toenail and a foreskin have different emotional issues especially for a 12 yr old.
The parent has to make the decision because the kid will be at risk of HIV before the kid is mature enough to have the responsibility to decide.
If they decide to circumcise to protect the baby from HIV (which is valid in some countries), then the best time is as an infant.

The example of the shots shows people have irrational fears so just considering the amount of pain in a 12 yr old will have getting a circumcision does not tell you when they would be mature enough to weigh actual risk of HIV or pain. They would be weighing perceived risk.

And grandma, if you are referring to me in the future, has no concerns what my son chooses for his son. It isn't that big of a deal to me one way or the other. I have not been convinced that the loss of sexual pleasure is as great as people make it out to be. The only people who really know the degree are those men circumcised as adults. I am convinced there is a very small medical benefit except the HIV risk, that is a huge medical benefit. That makes the decision for a child born in the USA today pretty neutral.
 
Last edited:
Have you totally lost track of this discussion, Ivor? I don't have a clue what you are on about in half your post.

You suggested parents wait and let kid decide.
Problem: Kids are sexually active and thus at risk for HIV before they are mature enough to decide.
You suggested because you volunteered to have an ingrown toenail removed at age 12 that all kids were mature enough by age 12 to decide if they want to be circumcised.
Problem: That isn't evidence, and a toenail and a foreskin have different emotional issues especially for a 12 yr old.
The parent has to make the decision because the kid will be at risk of HIV before the kid is mature enough to have the responsibility to decide.
If they decide to circumcise to protect the baby from HIV (which is valid in some countries), then the best time is as an infant.

The example of the shots shows people have irrational fears so just considering the amount of pain in a 12 yr old will have getting a circumcision does not tell you when they would be mature enough to weigh actual risk of HIV or pain. They would be weighing perceived risk.

Er, no. READ WHAT I SAID:

I think you're getting confused with my point of view about regions of the world with high incidence of HIV (infant circumcision is, on balance, indicated), and the US, where the effects of torture are being researched to see if it has any advantages.
 
Some people may find this interesting:

Human Rights Considerations

The matter of infant male circumcision is particularly difficult in regards to human rights, as it involves consideration of the rights of the infant as well as the rights of the parents.

Under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, an infant has rights that include security of person, life, freedom and bodily integrity. Routine infant male circumcision is an unnecessary and irreversible procedure. Therefore, many consider it to be "unwarranted mutilating surgery".

Many adult men are increasingly concerned about whether their parents had the right to give consent for infant male circumcision. They claim that an infant's rights should take priority over any parental rights to make such a decision. This procedure should be delayed to a later date when the child can make his own informed decision. Parental preference alone does not justify a non-therapeutic procedure.

Others argue that this stance violates the parents' right to religious or cultural expression, and that adherence to their religious and cultural practices would be in the best interests of the infant.

Ethical Considerations

Ethical considerations regarding infant male circumcision centre on the welfare (or "best interests") of the infant and the potential benefit and harm associated with the procedure. Ethics points us to corrective vision, i.e. to question practices that have become routine, or which we take for granted.

<snip>

You are not obliged to act upon a request to circumcise an infant, but you must discuss the medical evidence and the current thoughts in bioethics that dissuade you from performing this procedure. You must also inform the parents that they have the right to see another doctor.

Looks like Canada is leading the way with the ethics of this procedure.
 
There is something I don´t understand:

Most optimistic estimates give a protection rate of circumcision against AIDS of around 40% (correct me if I´m wrong.)

How can this be even considered to be a valuable, practical protection against AIDS? You´d still need to use condoms anyway... I wouldn´t have sex with a 60% risk of getting AIDS!

And it could even have negative consequences, badly informed people having more unprotected sex, with a false sense of security.

I´ve often seen these "studies" cited (and probably funded) by muslim apologists, and since we can´t expect much regard for science from these lkind of lobbies, I think it would be a good thing to look at them with a heavily skeptical attitude.

And were those studies about AIDS protection debunked or not? Please tell us! (I can´t be arse to read another of these threads, even though they are quite funny...)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom