Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

fls said:
There are two ways I am looking at this.

First of all, if preventative measures are to be undertaken, they should be done well before they are likely to be needed and when it is easiest to undertake that measure. If circumcision was going to be used as a preventative measure (and we are agreed that the absolute benefit would need to be much larger before we would consider the possibility), then the best time to do it would be as a neonate. Doing it later changes it into a more involved operation with a much longer recovery period and puts the child through much more stress.
Well, I disagree. When you circumcise a newborn, you have to rrrrrrrrrrriiiip the foreskin off the glans. This traumatizes the entire penis, and appears to be excruciatingly painful. Then you have poop and pee in diapers, bandages that require ointment, etc. Some of that is going to be very problematic in the two thirds world. Then there's the fact that circumcision can interfere with breastfeeding (I'll find that study if you haven't seen it) which is bad for health in a variety of ways. Then there's the unresolved issue of meatal stenosis. It looks to me like the research saying that's a very rare complication is from the 1970's when almost all boys were circumcised and it was thought that many boys "naturally" needed their pee holes surgically enlarged around potty training time. Skeptigirl's point in the last thread was that it's not life threatening, which is true...but it's extremely traumatic for a child to have it corrected. I know a few guys who say that's one of their earliest memories, and definitely is the earliest memory of a doctor.
Either way, it's something that happens, even if the true incidence is presently unknown. And it's something that only happens with infant circumcision.
Then there's the whole issue of anaesthesia. I'm getting the vibe that in Africa they're going to be going with "sugar water" and call it good. Is that ethical??? How can one really say what's more traumatic...circumcision without pain relief as a newborn vs. circumcision later when excellent pain relief can be given?
What are the rates of bacterial infections going to be after neonatal circumcision in areas without running water?
These factors, in my mind, at the very least make the newborn period the WORST time to circumcise. And that's not even getting into the issue of human rights and informed consent. Most of the benefits can still be gained if circumcision is performed around the age of 17 or 18. For all the good reasons to do it in infancy, there are as good or better reasons to wait.

The second way I am looking at this is whether or not we can prove to parents who want it done that it is harmful. And we can't when the information that we have shows a net benefit.

Linda

I'm seeing that net benefit melting away when meatal stenosis is added into the equation. And the fundamental right to have all your sex organs if you want them counts for something, too. Losing a sensitive sex organ that can provide it's owner with sexual pleasure is a significant loss, even if it's not one that translates into morbidity and mortality.
 
BlackKat said:
There are studies showing both circumcision making men and women happier and studies showing foreskins making men and women happier. Thus there is no firm conclusion either way. It's all subjective.
Have you found any studies saying women were twice as likely to orgasm with circumcised penises, though?

Just because women sometimes perform (and sadly sometimes willingly partake in) the operations does not make them any less of a human rights violation:
Even type one? The most common kind? You think that's a human rights violation?

But I am saying circumcision is not a hostile procedure as the foreskin is superfluous in terms of the functions of the penis as a reproductive organ. Men with them have functional and fun sex. Men without them have functional and fun sex.
Men with foreskins don't tend to find them superfluous. Sort of like how I like my labia and clitoral prepuce.
 
Have you found any studies saying women were twice as likely to orgasm with circumcised penises, though?


Even type one? The most common kind? You think that's a human rights violation?


Men with foreskins don't tend to find them superfluous. Sort of like how I like my labia and clitoral prepuce.

Orgasms are subjective from person to person just like tastes. Everyone's got something different that they like best. The sensations that will make me orgasm the quickest are not necessarily the same as those which will make others. Are women different in this regard? It was my understanding that the female genetalia also had some degree of uniqueness.

Again I will point you to:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
which states:
The most common type of female genital mutilation is excision of the clitoris and the labia minora, accounting for up to 80% of all cases

That means 80% of the time the clitoris is removed.

My point is not that men with foreskins find them superfluous. It's that men without foreskins don't miss them because they are superfluous to their activities of sex and urination. I think that many men with foreskins have somehow developed an emotional attachment to their foreskins and just can not comprehend people who have been circumcised not missing theirs in the slightest.
 
Last edited:
.... Then there's the fact that circumcision can interfere with breastfeeding (I'll find that study if you haven't seen it) which is bad for health in a variety of ways...

I believe you mean this:
http://www.cirp.org/library/birth/
and that is a real stretch if I ever saw one.

In any case babies do not remember, nor care that they had a flap of skin cut off. Nor do they even notice it much if at all. Not only do most hospitals use anesthesia but even in cases where it is performed outside of a hospital (such as by a mohel) there is frequently a doctor present. If people are claiming to be traumatized by something they in no way remember I will just lump them in with mass murderers who claimed they were given formula instead of breast milk as a child and that's why they killed eighteen large breasted women. It's not more traumatic for the child than the severing of the umbilical cord.
 
Last edited:
Well, I disagree. When you circumcise a newborn, you have to rrrrrrrrrrriiiip the foreskin off the glans. This traumatizes the entire penis, and appears to be excruciatingly painful. Then you have poop and pee in diapers, bandages that require ointment, etc. Some of that is going to be very problematic in the two thirds world. Then there's the fact that circumcision can interfere with breastfeeding (I'll find that study if you haven't seen it) which is bad for health in a variety of ways. Then there's the unresolved issue of meatal stenosis. It looks to me like the research saying that's a very rare complication is from the 1970's when almost all boys were circumcised and it was thought that many boys "naturally" needed their pee holes surgically enlarged around potty training time. Skeptigirl's point in the last thread was that it's not life threatening, which is true...but it's extremely traumatic for a child to have it corrected. I know a few guys who say that's one of their earliest memories, and definitely is the earliest memory of a doctor.
Either way, it's something that happens, even if the true incidence is presently unknown. And it's something that only happens with infant circumcision.
Then there's the whole issue of anaesthesia. I'm getting the vibe that in Africa they're going to be going with "sugar water" and call it good. Is that ethical??? How can one really say what's more traumatic...circumcision without pain relief as a newborn vs. circumcision later when excellent pain relief can be given?
What are the rates of bacterial infections going to be after neonatal circumcision in areas without running water?
These factors, in my mind, at the very least make the newborn period the WORST time to circumcise. And that's not even getting into the issue of human rights and informed consent. Most of the benefits can still be gained if circumcision is performed around the age of 17 or 18. For all the good reasons to do it in infancy, there are as good or better reasons to wait.



I'm seeing that net benefit melting away when meatal stenosis is added into the equation. And the fundamental right to have all your sex organs if you want them counts for something, too. Losing a sensitive sex organ that can provide it's owner with sexual pleasure is a significant loss, even if it's not one that translates into morbidity and mortality.

Sorry. I must have wandered into the wrong room.

Linda
 
Orgasms are subjective from person to person just like tastes. Everyone's got something different that they like best. The sensations that will make me orgasm the quickest are not necessarily the same as those which will make others. Are women different in this regard? It was my understanding that the female genetalia also had some degree of uniqueness.

Again I will point you to:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
which states:
The most common type of female genital mutilation is excision of the clitoris and the labia minora, accounting for up to 80% of all cases

That means 80% of the time the clitoris is removed.

My point is not that men with foreskins find them superfluous. It's that men without foreskins don't miss them because they are superfluous to their activities of sex and urination. I think that many men with foreskins have somehow developed an emotional attachment to their foreskins and just can not comprehend people who have been circumcised not missing theirs in the slightest.

I think you might have nailed it right on the head... and I think I can empathize.

See, I had my wisdom teeth for a very long time - up until I was 22, in fact. Then the military dentist gave me a long song-and-dance about possible future complications for wisdom teeth, etc... MY teeth were perfect, placed well, fully formed and expressed, etc. But the army pulled them anyway.

And even though I certainly didn't NEED those teeth, I still sometimes feel regret at not HAVING those teeth anymore.

I can only imagine that this is what the owner or recent loser of a foreskin feels - and, of course, goes to great lengths to attempt to justify his feelings.

I have to say, though, that having read everything presented by everyone on this thread, and more, the issue is still contraversial in both directions. I still feel that the foreskin is an evolutionary dead-end for humans, and its removal is nothing but recognition of its unclean and unpleasant nature. The reduction of HIV risks alone, IMO, is sufficient to make circumcision mandatory everywhere - since condoms aren't always readily available, but sex is. And all the crap about how 'traumatized' the babies are is just pure B.S. Modern facilities, at least, use (or can use, if asked) local anaesthesia (as each doctor did for each of my boys). And the pain, if any, is QUICKLY forgotten. In fact, with the plastibell method, after-surgery care is simple and painless, too. You do more work and cause more pain cleaning up the umbilical area than you do after circumcision.

And babies don't remember the pain. Certainly, in the aftermath of the trauma of birth itself, a little sharp tug isn't going to compare. This is opposed to attempting to convince a teenage or adult male that first, we're going to rip the foreskin off your penis, and second, you're not going to be able to use it for a week or more, and third, you'll clearly remember the trauma of this event.

Sorry, I'm not at all convinced. I've never in my life heard any male complain about the pain of his neonatal circumcision, or any memory of it, or anything else; but I've heard more than a few regretting waiting so long to have it done to themselves (and cursing their parents for not doing it sooner). And a few who needed it done, who instead chose to live with infections and secondary urine tubes rather than get a medically prescribed treatment done.

But neither side of this debate is going to convince the other side, and the global situation isn't likely going to change due to our debate, either.

So at this point, I'll snip off my own useless comments and let this discussion stand erect and beautiful free of my foreposts.
 
Last edited:
Orgasms are subjective from person to person just like tastes. Everyone's got something different that they like best. The sensations that will make me orgasm the quickest are not necessarily the same as those which will make others. Are women different in this regard? It was my understanding that the female genetalia also had some degree of uniqueness.

Seems as good a point as any to derail over (sorry, my forepost is longer than I thought)...

I had a girlfriend whose genitals didn't form quite correctly. The sensitive nerve bundles normally found in the clitoris were instead to the left, in the labia, about a half-inch from her clitoris. Massaging her clitoris only annoyed her. (She was also only about four inches in depth, which made our couplings very difficult on both of us.)

Another girlfriend I had could only orgasm through vaginal penetration in female-dominant position, and had a VERY sensitive G-spot - but an almost insensitive clitoris.

So just from what I can tell, women are VERY different.

(And guys, take this as a hint - actually LEARN what your women enjoy INDIVIDUALLY, and remember what goes to whom. You'll be amply rewarded for it.)
 
BlackKat said:
Orgasms are subjective from person to person just like tastes. Everyone's got something different that they like best. The sensations that will make me orgasm the quickest are not necessarily the same as those which will make others. Are women different in this regard? It was my understanding that the female genetalia also had some degree of uniqueness.
So I take it the answer to this question:
me said:
Have you found any studies saying women were twice as likely to orgasm with circumcised penises, though?
..is "No"?


Again I will point you to:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
which states:
The most common type of female genital mutilation is excision of the clitoris and the labia minora, accounting for up to 80% of all cases

That means 80% of the time the clitoris is removed.
Do I need to point you to the more recent 2005 survey again?

I believe you mean this:
http://www.cirp.org/library/birth/
and that is a real stretch if I ever saw one.

Perhaps you should take it up with the AAP?

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/93/4/641

Results. Neonates in both groups showed significant increases in heart rate, respiratory rate, and crying during circumcision with no clinically significant differences observed between the groups. Postoperative comfort scores showed no significant differences between the groups until the 360-minute postoperative assessment, at which time the acetaminophen group had significantly improved scores (P < .05). Feeding behavior deteriorated in breast- and bottle-fed neonates in both groups, and acetaminophen did not seem to influence this deterioration.


http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/108/3/793.pdf

Local anesthetics and strategies to soothe and minimize
distress should be considered even for simple
procedures, such as venipuncture. Some common
painful minor procedures, such as circumcision, do
not always receive the warranted attention to comfort
issues. Available research indicates that newborn
circumcisions are a significant source of pain
during the procedure and are associated with irritability
and feeding disturbances during the days afterward.

9–11



http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/100/6/1035

Breastfeeding should begin as soon as possible after birth, usually within the first hour.80-82 Except under special circumstances, the newborn infant should remain with the mother throughout the recovery period.80,83,84 Procedures that may interfere with breastfeeding or traumatize the infant should be avoided or minimized.

BlackKat said:
In any case babies do not remember, nor care that they had a flap of skin cut off. Nor do they even notice it much if at all.
Some do when they grow up, some don't.

Not only do most hospitals use anesthesia
You haven't been following the thread very closely, have you?

It's not more traumatic for the child than the severing of the umbilical cord.
Again I'm going to have to ask you to substantiate that claim with evidence.
 
Last edited:
While I've been stunned or rather, confused into silence with Linda, I'll just say that the effects of early childhood trauma are unknown. Just because you don't remember something explicitly does not mean your central nervous system has not been effected by it for an extended period of time after the event.

The brain of a circumcised man may compensate for the lack of sensory input from a foreskin by "remapping" input from other nerves to the area of the brain that would have been used to interpret sensation from the foreskin.
 
Last edited:
So I take it the answer to this question:
Originally Posted by me
Have you found any studies saying women were twice as likely to orgasm with circumcised penises, though?

..is "No"?
My point is that you can not quantify pleasure or extrapolate results of such studies to larger groups of people beyond the participants because each person is unique in their response to different sexual stimulus. I will gladly point out that all the same anectedotes Z gave us about his different partners can be evenly matched by my own. In fact I have never had any two sexual partners that could achieve orgasm the same way.

Some do when they grow up, some don't.
No some THINK they do when they grow up. But they are wrong.
However if I had circumcision performed on me last week instead of 36 years ago you can damn well bet I would remember the discomfort (because the procedure would have been much more complex and difficult).

Quote:
It's not more traumatic for the child than the severing of the umbilical cord.

Again I'm going to have to ask you to substantiate that claim with evidence.
Do you know how both procedures are performed? Clamps and scissors/scalpel. Clamp. Snip. Done. No tears.
 
Last edited:
BlackKat said:
My point is that you can not quantify pleasure or extrapolate results of such studies to larger groups of people beyond the participants because each person is unique in their response to different sexual stimulus. I will gladly point out that all the same anectedotes Z gave us about his different partners can be evenly matched by my own. In fact I have never had any two sexual partners that could achieve orgasm the same way.
So the answer is "no". Ok.

No some THINK they do when they grow up. But they are wrong.
You were misunderstanding me. I meant "some care" when they grow up.

Do you know how both procedures are performed? Clamps and scissors/scalpel. Clamp. Snip. Done. No tears.

It appears that you're just making things up now, so I'm not sure what the point is.
But I'll give it a go anyway.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6584757516627632617&q=circumcision&hl=en
 
While I've been stunned or rather, confused into silence with Linda, I'll just say that the effects of early childhood trauma are unknown. Just because you don't remember something explicitly does not mean your central nervous system has not been effected by it for an extended period of time after the event.

The brain of a circumcised man may compensate for the lack of sensory input from a foreskin by "remapping" input from other nerves to the area of the brain that would have been used to interpret sensation from the foreskin.

Well, feel free to jump on in with me and BlackKat over here. :)

Circumcision does appear to have effects on the nervous system that extend beyond the actual procedure:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=9057731&dopt=Citation

BACKGROUND: Preliminary studies suggested that pain experienced by infants in the neonatal period may have long-lasting effects on future infant behaviour. The objectives of this study were to find out whether neonatal circumcision altered pain response at 4-month or 6-month vaccination compared with the response in uncircumcised infants, and whether pretreatment of circumcision pain with lidocaine-prilocaine cream (Emla) affects the subsequent vaccination response. METHODS: We used a prospective cohort design to study 87 infants. The infants formed three groups--uncircumcised infants, and infants who had been randomly assigned Emla or placebo in a previous clinical trial to assess the efficacy of Emla cream as pretreatment for pain in neonatal circumcision. Infants were videotaped during vaccination done at the primary care physician's clinic. Videotapes were scored without knowledge of circumcision or treatment status by a research assistant who had been trained to measure infant facial action, cry duration, and visual analogue scale pain scores. FINDINGS: Birth characteristics and infant characteristics at the time of vaccination, including age and temperament scores, did not differ significantly among groups. Multivariate ANOVA revealed a significant group effect (p < 0.001) in difference (vaccination minus baseline) values for percentage facial action, percentage cry time, and visual analogue scale pain scores. Univariate ANOVAs were significant for all outcome measures (p < 0.05): infants circumcised with placebo had higher difference scores than uncircumcised infants for percentage facial action (136.9 vs 77.5%), percentage cry duration (53.8 vs 24.7%), and visual analogue scale pain scores (5.1 vs 3.1 cm). There was a significant linear trend on all outcome measures, showing increasing pain scores from uncircumcised infants, to those circumcised with Emla, to those circumcised with placebo. INTERPRETATION: Circumcised infants showed a stronger pain response to subsequent routine vaccination than uncircumcised infants. Among the circumcised group, preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination. We recommend treatment to prevent neonatal circumcision pain.
 
It appears that you're just making things up now, so I'm not sure what the point is.
But I'll give it a go anyway.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6584757516627632617&q=circumcision&hl=en

The baby in that video was either anesthetized (and was crying for other reasons) or that video was not made in the U.S. (at least recently). In U.S. hospitals babies are anesthetized when circumcised. Even in the olden skool days when mohel's did all the circumcisions they gave the baby a mouth full of sugar or wine to dull or distract him from the pain.

And like I said... in that video it was: clamp. snip. done.
 
The baby in that video was either anesthetized (and was crying for other reasons) or that video was not made in the U.S. (at least recently). In U.S. hospitals babies are anesthetized when circumcised. Even in the olden skool days when mohel's did all the circumcisions they gave the baby a mouth full of sugar or wine to dull or distract him from the pain.

And like I said... in that video it was: clamp. snip. done.

You know, repeating an incorrect statement over and over and over again doesn't actually end up making it correct.

Since I have already once in this thread gone to the trouble of looking up the percentage of OBs in the US who provide pain relief, could you perhaps make some small token gesture to give the appearance of at least attempting to substantiating your claims with evidence?
Please?
 
Kelly, are you reading your own posts?


"...preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination."

Now, in the case of my own boys, born between 1995 and 2002, each was treated with pain-killers just prior to circumcision; each failed to cry or react to the procedure whatsoever; and each has had minimal - almost non-existent - reaction to vaccinations. In fact, my 8-year-old is completely impassive to the needle, only complaining of soreness in intramuscular (is that the right word?) shots. We didn't even need to request anything beyond the circumcision itself - anesthesia was given as routine.

This was in two Army hospitals and one local Catholic hospital, in three different states. Not a LARGE sample size, but not restricted to any unusual area.


...


Damn, I keep clipping that forepost, and it keeps growing back. Shoulda had it done as a neoposter.
 
Kelly, are you reading your own posts?


"...preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination."

Now, in the case of my own boys, born between 1995 and 2002, each was treated with pain-killers just prior to circumcision; each failed to cry or react to the procedure whatsoever; and each has had minimal - almost non-existent - reaction to vaccinations. In fact, my 8-year-old is completely impassive to the needle, only complaining of soreness in intramuscular (is that the right word?) shots. We didn't even need to request anything beyond the circumcision itself - anesthesia was given as routine.

This was in two Army hospitals and one local Catholic hospital, in three different states. Not a LARGE sample size, but not restricted to any unusual area.


...


Damn, I keep clipping that forepost, and it keeps growing back. Shoulda had it done as a neoposter.

I guess I just need to accept having to repost the same links several times in this thread.
:confused:

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/101/6/e5.pdf
 
No, I am not. As a matter of fact, I have several friends in such nations, and am probably more in touch with the situation in the field than you are. So please grab your rigteous indignation and store it away from sunlight...
You suggested people were recommending circumcision in areas with low rates of HIV. And the following 2 comments reveal you are not well informed or in touch. Sorry to make a pissing contest of it but I'm trying to stay with what the fact reveal.

Quoting the old adage, two wrongs don't make a right. Additionally, I would think that the infection rates in women will soar if most men are circumcised. Afterall, without the foreskin, there will be an increase in friction and abrasions, which will maximize the potential of infection.
This is not only illogical, but also a baseless hypothesis. Anything which lowers the incidence of HIV is going to lower the risk of HIV. And there is no evidence women have a higher risk of contracting HIV from circumcised as opposed to uncircumcised males. I also doubt you could find any medical research showing circumcision caused vaginal abrasions. You are just making up emotional tripe here.

Maybe increasing education about ways of infection, respect for your partners health and condom use could actually acomplish something useful?
Condom promotion is an extremely effective means of lowering HIV risk. Uganda was a model showing it could be every effective (until Bush allowed the religious police to interfere by pushing their failed abstinence only garbage, but that is a separate issue). Again, and where my complaint comes in about your position, facing the HIV risk, even where condom promotion has been effective is still so high in many parts of the world, it is absurd to have some Westerner who enjoys a low risk of HIV judging a parent in the third world who would choose to add the protection of a circumcision to their struggle to keep their infant alive.
 
I've only skimmed this thread, but I have to say I have found it very informative.

First, thanks to skeptigirl for that tsunami of pro-circumcision evidence. Were I a neutral observer, I'd probably end up on the pro-circumcision side.

But I am not a neutral observer; I have cast my die, and it has come up anti-circumcision. At the current time, there is only one foreskin I have had any say in removing, and that is my son's. My spouse and I had had many discussions about this before he was born in 2000. We talked to the OB-GYN, and our first pediatrician, and they were not much help at all. The health issues, they said, were fairly balanced out, and his peers in school were going to be split about 50/50 cut/uncut.

So we decided to leave him with what he was born with.

If we ever have another boy, he'll also be uncut, despite the studies, because I'm not going to have one with and one without.

If my son(s) ever want to become circumcised, they will be able to make that choice themselves, and I will fully support them in it. As it stands, my now-6-year-old son has never had trouble keeping it clean and uninfected. At the risk of giving TMI, he rather enjoys keeping it clean...


And not to end this post with a controversial bomb or anything, but the rate at which women achieve orgasm with circumcised vs. uncircumcised men should never be a consideration -- not even a little bit.
 
...
The benefit of increased resistance to HIV does not kick in until long after the child is able to make that choice for themselves.

Let's say you're right and the lots of 15 year old boys are having unprotected sex. Why can't the decision be put off until they are 12, 13 or 14? I.e. the doctor knows that the benefit she is providing by operating on the infant could be provided later with fewer ethical problems....
You are missing something here which any parent of a teenager knows. A 12 yr old, and even an 18 yr old can probably make many informed decisions. However, they are still immature in many ways and some decisions they are not so good at making. One that is well documented is poor judgment of risk. That's why so many teenage drivers are killed in vehicle accidents. That's why kids experiment with drugs. That's why cigarette manufacturers know they have to addict kids to cigarettes before they are young adults because young adults rarely decide to start smoking now that the dangers have been revealed. So risk perception is an issue.

The second type of decision which teens are often not mature enough make is that of choosing something they know will hurt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom