kellyb
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2006
- Messages
- 12,632
Well, I disagree. When you circumcise a newborn, you have to rrrrrrrrrrriiiip the foreskin off the glans. This traumatizes the entire penis, and appears to be excruciatingly painful. Then you have poop and pee in diapers, bandages that require ointment, etc. Some of that is going to be very problematic in the two thirds world. Then there's the fact that circumcision can interfere with breastfeeding (I'll find that study if you haven't seen it) which is bad for health in a variety of ways. Then there's the unresolved issue of meatal stenosis. It looks to me like the research saying that's a very rare complication is from the 1970's when almost all boys were circumcised and it was thought that many boys "naturally" needed their pee holes surgically enlarged around potty training time. Skeptigirl's point in the last thread was that it's not life threatening, which is true...but it's extremely traumatic for a child to have it corrected. I know a few guys who say that's one of their earliest memories, and definitely is the earliest memory of a doctor.fls said:There are two ways I am looking at this.
First of all, if preventative measures are to be undertaken, they should be done well before they are likely to be needed and when it is easiest to undertake that measure. If circumcision was going to be used as a preventative measure (and we are agreed that the absolute benefit would need to be much larger before we would consider the possibility), then the best time to do it would be as a neonate. Doing it later changes it into a more involved operation with a much longer recovery period and puts the child through much more stress.
Either way, it's something that happens, even if the true incidence is presently unknown. And it's something that only happens with infant circumcision.
Then there's the whole issue of anaesthesia. I'm getting the vibe that in Africa they're going to be going with "sugar water" and call it good. Is that ethical??? How can one really say what's more traumatic...circumcision without pain relief as a newborn vs. circumcision later when excellent pain relief can be given?
What are the rates of bacterial infections going to be after neonatal circumcision in areas without running water?
These factors, in my mind, at the very least make the newborn period the WORST time to circumcise. And that's not even getting into the issue of human rights and informed consent. Most of the benefits can still be gained if circumcision is performed around the age of 17 or 18. For all the good reasons to do it in infancy, there are as good or better reasons to wait.
The second way I am looking at this is whether or not we can prove to parents who want it done that it is harmful. And we can't when the information that we have shows a net benefit.
Linda
I'm seeing that net benefit melting away when meatal stenosis is added into the equation. And the fundamental right to have all your sex organs if you want them counts for something, too. Losing a sensitive sex organ that can provide it's owner with sexual pleasure is a significant loss, even if it's not one that translates into morbidity and mortality.