Dorian Gray
Hypocrisy Detector
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2002
- Messages
- 20,366
1) If removing the clitoris/labia makes sex less pleasurable for women, then doesn't removing the foreskin make sex less pleasurable for men?
2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
First of all, then how do you justify circumcision for the hundreds of years BEFORE the 1970s (i.e., before AIDS existed to any appreciable degree)?
Secondly, there are FAR better ways to reduce your chances of getting HIV.
Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, and not many people contract it compared to numerous other diseases.
Fourth, why stop there? Shall we remove women's breasts after the onset of puberty to reduce their chances of getting breast cancer? How about preemptive bypass surgery on all people to reduce their chances of having a heart attack?
The argument that men won't get a circumcision later, so let's do it now while they are infants is pretty sick. Why don't we give everyone gastric bypass surgery as infants because fat people won't diet and exercise later?
Face it, it is societal pressure and not anything remotely resembling logic or reason that is leading people to perform this procedure. When you understand how 'shocking' it is for girls to have the equivalent procedure, then you will understand how shocking it should be for this as well.
2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
First of all, then how do you justify circumcision for the hundreds of years BEFORE the 1970s (i.e., before AIDS existed to any appreciable degree)?
Secondly, there are FAR better ways to reduce your chances of getting HIV.
Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, and not many people contract it compared to numerous other diseases.
Fourth, why stop there? Shall we remove women's breasts after the onset of puberty to reduce their chances of getting breast cancer? How about preemptive bypass surgery on all people to reduce their chances of having a heart attack?
The argument that men won't get a circumcision later, so let's do it now while they are infants is pretty sick. Why don't we give everyone gastric bypass surgery as infants because fat people won't diet and exercise later?
Face it, it is societal pressure and not anything remotely resembling logic or reason that is leading people to perform this procedure. When you understand how 'shocking' it is for girls to have the equivalent procedure, then you will understand how shocking it should be for this as well.