Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

1) If removing the clitoris/labia makes sex less pleasurable for women, then doesn't removing the foreskin make sex less pleasurable for men?

2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
First of all, then how do you justify circumcision for the hundreds of years BEFORE the 1970s (i.e., before AIDS existed to any appreciable degree)?
Secondly, there are FAR better ways to reduce your chances of getting HIV.
Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, and not many people contract it compared to numerous other diseases.
Fourth, why stop there? Shall we remove women's breasts after the onset of puberty to reduce their chances of getting breast cancer? How about preemptive bypass surgery on all people to reduce their chances of having a heart attack?


The argument that men won't get a circumcision later, so let's do it now while they are infants is pretty sick. Why don't we give everyone gastric bypass surgery as infants because fat people won't diet and exercise later?

Face it, it is societal pressure and not anything remotely resembling logic or reason that is leading people to perform this procedure. When you understand how 'shocking' it is for girls to have the equivalent procedure, then you will understand how shocking it should be for this as well.
 
BlackKat said:
If you look at a penis diagram most of the nerves (erogenous zones) are on the underside of the shaft and on the glans. I can only relate my personal satisfaction (or Z's since he also expressed the same earlier this thread). There's a reason American men recite baseball stats in their heads during sex you know... it's to keep going longer.

Well, maybe foreskins could help with timing between men and women?

http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/116-1181/595/
While vaginal dryness is considered an indicator for female sexual arousal disorder,1,2 male circumcision may exacerbate female vaginal dryness during intercourse.3 O’Hara and O’Hara reported that women who had experienced coitus with both intact and circumcised men preferred intact partners by a ratio of 8.6 to one.4 Most women (85.5%) in that survey reported that they were more likely to experience orgasm with a genitally intact partner: ‘They [surveyed women] were also more likely to report that vaginal secretions lessened as coitus progressed with their circumcised partners (16.75, 6.88–40.77).’4

Presence of the movable foreskin makes a difference in foreplay, being more arousing to the female.4 Women reported they were about twice as likely to experience orgasm if the male partner had a foreskin.4 The impact of male circumcision on vaginal dryness during coitus required further investigation.

We conducted a survey of 35 female sexual partners aged 18 to 69 years who had experienced sexual intercourse with both circumcised and genitally intact men.

Participants completed a 35-item sexual awareness survey. Women reported they were significantly more likely to have experienced vaginal dryness during intercourse with circumcised than with genitally intact men χ2 (df = 1, n = 20) = 5.0, p <0.05.5

Well ... I may be wrong because I am not female. But I would think removing the clitoris and/or labia would make sex (including masturbation) a lot less pleasurable.
I would think so, too. I'd also think removing the clitoral prepuce at birth would negatively effect pleasure. Then again, I have all my parts, so of course I think that. Women circumcised with the other various, lesser degrees of circumcision would probably diasagree, though.
I don't think I was making a huge intellectual leap of faith to add that with the patriarchal societies and second class treatment of women to conclude that female genital mutilation is an act of deliberate sabotage.

It is the women themselves who primarily perpetuate the practice, though. It's their culture. They think it's healthier. It was done to them so they have it done to their daughters. They don't think there's anything wrong with it.
 
1) If removing the clitoris/labia makes sex less pleasurable for women, then doesn't removing the foreskin make sex less pleasurable for men?

Not sure if this was an accidental mistake or not, but the clitorus is the equivalent of the glans on the penis, and is full of nerves. The equivalent of the foreskin is the clitoral hood.

2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
First of all, then how do you justify circumcision for the hundreds of years BEFORE the 1970s (i.e., before AIDS existed to any appreciable degree)?
Secondly, there are FAR better ways to reduce your chances of getting HIV.
Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, and not many people contract it compared to numerous other diseases.

The argument is a small risk for a small gain. Sure, condoms work better, but HIV isn't just for Xmas - it's for life. That tiny added bit of protection for some is argued as being beneficial for a tiny compensation (removing the foreskin).

I also question the risk-benefit, to be honest. Which is why I think this decision is personal, and not to be imposed by the parent.

Fourth, why stop there? Shall we remove women's breasts after the onset of puberty to reduce their chances of getting breast cancer? How about preemptive bypass surgery on all people to reduce their chances of having a heart attack?

Because removing the breasts are a large loss for small potential of gain, therefore not equivalent. I would argue that removing the appendix is more similar.

Athon
 
Well, maybe foreskins could help with timing between men and women?

http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/116-1181/595/



I would think so, too. I'd also think removing the clitoral prepuce at birth would negatively effect pleasure. Then again, I have all my parts, so of course I think that. Women circumcised with the other various, lesser degrees of circumcision would probably diasagree, though.


It is the women themselves who primarily perpetuate the practice, though. It's their culture. They think it's healthier. It was done to them so they have it done to their daughters. They don't think there's anything wrong with it.

There are studies showing both circumcision making men and women happier and studies showing foreskins making men and women happier. Thus there is no firm conclusion either way. It's all subjective. Some people like blue cars better, some people like red cars better. If your circumcised penis works just fine why would you want a foreskin and if you always have had a foreskin why would you not want one? Thus no matter what kind of penis you have, you like that kind the best.

Just because women sometimes perform (and sadly sometimes willingly partake in) the operations does not make them any less of a human rights violation:
http://www.4woman.gov/faq/fgc.htm

I'm not trying to say that male children SHOULD be automatically circumcised. I'm not trying to say that male children should NOT be automatically circumcised. But I am saying circumcision is not a hostile procedure as the foreskin is superfluous in terms of the functions of the penis as a reproductive organ. Men with them have functional and fun sex. Men without them have functional and fun sex.

The difference between male circumcision and female mutilation is because after circumcision the penis functions perfectly well. In 80% of the cases of female genital excision... it's broken. The only way you could lump the two together is if nearly 75% of the male organ was removed. This is because almost all of the nerves in the penis are in the shaft and glans.
 
Last edited:
...But lack of foreskin had a BIG effect on sexual lubrication...honestly. Sex with a circumcised person vs with an normal one is SOOOO different. The circumcised can be better to start , maybe.
, but it just pounds away and is really unpleasant when you (eventually!) get to the end. The "glide thing" doesnt work!!! rofl...this is my first post's on this forum...I never thought they would all be about dicks!!!!LOL
But did you have a large enough sample size to rule out other variables? ;)
 
This is the most recent thing I could find on it:

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/101/6/e5.pdf


An overall average of less than half, and only one out of four OBs doing it in the hospital use it.

:(
Recently trained PEDs and FPs were more likely to use anesthetics than were their older colleagues, but OB use of pain relief was independent of their practice longevity. Physicians in the western states were significantly more likely to use anesthesia than were other physicians from the rest of the United States.
Hooray for NPs and the western states, ahead of the crowd.

I have seen this in other areas of medicine. You have to wait for the old guys to die out for old practices to change.
 
...
2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
...Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, ...l.
You are rehashing. Your examples are false analogies. And if you were paying attention, not a single person here (that I saw) is advocating the HIV prevention EXCEPT where there are high rates of HIV and in those countries, other measures are used as well. They need them all.

You also need to update your pandemic knowledge. I'm afraid HIV has spread much much further than Africa. India, Asia, and Eastern Europe have considerable numbers of HIV infected individuals now.
 
I remember that you have some sort of standing offer....

Only in my dreams:(

Puhleeze. I have the Amazing Magic Mommy Kisses on my side.

Hey, a debate with TV / Film quotes!

Actually, I'm dumping the rest of the examples in favour of the definition you provided:

Ok.

Putting aside our bias for physical integrity, could not the small (tiny) absolute benefit in infant UTI and penile cancer, and variable (depending upon the prevalence wherever the child lives when they become sexually active) absolute benefit in reducing the risk of acquiring HIV be considered as consequences worth avoiding through inaction? (Focusing on those issues in which some or all of the benefit is lost by waiting until the child is an adult.)

Linda

So reducing a lifetime risk of 1 in 600 of penile cancer is worth raising the ethical problems by operating on a non-consenting patient? What other surgery is justified for such a low risk? I think I'm correct in saying HPV vaccinations would help with this as well? Any idea on the NNT?

The benefit of increased resistance to HIV does not kick in until long after the child is able to make that choice for themselves.

Let's say you're right and the lots of 15 year old boys are having unprotected sex. Why can't the decision be put off until they are 12, 13 or 14? I.e. the doctor knows that the benefit she is providing by operating on the infant could be provided later with fewer ethical problems.

The money parents spend on a circumcision would probably have a better return by putting it in a bank account and buying a stash of condoms for their son when he's 15.

As for UTI's it still raises the ethical problem that there are alternative and much less severe ways to deal with the problem if it arises in the first place.

In summary, circumcision of infants in the developed world (with relatively low incidence of HIV) raises the big ethical problem of performing surgery on a non-consenting patient, for which the outcome of the various benefits it provides can be attained or surpassed by alternative measures.
 
Last edited:
Ok...I just looked through some of the research making that claim, and it looks to me like circumcision's effectiveness for penis cancer has to do with whether or not it's performed before men become sexually active. It's not very good research, though. It's hard to say for sure what's going on there.

Regarding teens making good decisions, I'm just not seeing this as an argument for infant circumcision. You just can't go around whacking off other people's sex organs when they're babies because you think they're going to maybe make bad choices later. Penile cancer is somewhat avoidable by means other than circumcision, as well.

There are two ways I am looking at this.

First of all, if preventative measures are to be undertaken, they should be done well before they are likely to be needed and when it is easiest to undertake that measure. If circumcision was going to be used as a preventative measure (and we are agreed that the absolute benefit would need to be much larger before we would consider the possibility), then the best time to do it would be as a neonate. Doing it later changes it into a more involved operation with a much longer recovery period and puts the child through much more stress.

The second way I am looking at this is whether or not we can prove to parents who want it done that it is harmful. And we can't when the information that we have shows a net benefit.

Linda
 
Are you that oblivious to the plight of the nations experiencing the full force of the HIV pandemic?

No, I am not. As a matter of fact, I have several friends in such nations, and am probably more in touch with the situation in the field than you are. So please grab your rigteous indignation and store it away from sunlight...

Quoting the old adage, two wrongs don't make a right. Additionally, I would think that the infection rates in women will soar if most men are circumcized. Afterall, without the foreskin, there will be an increase in friction and abrasions, which will maximize the potential of infection.

Maybe increasing education about ways of infection, respect for your partners health and condom use could actually acomplish something useful?
 
These are false analogies. They may sound good to a non-skeptic, but a good skeptic can see right through them.

My dear, you wouldn't know a good skeptic if one fell on you playing tuba.
The only problem with my analogy is that you can't, AFAIK, do a mastectomy to a new born (maybe you can remove the tissue that will originate the breasts, I don't know).
Other than that, according to some of the arguments presented, there is no objective use for the breast that could justify the increased risk of death by cancer.
The only objections would be that it is a secondary sexual feature and that lactation is good. And, of course, that parents have no business mutilating their children.

But that would be my point from the beginning...

Here's my analogy: You are comparing trimming fingernails to a finger amputation.

How do you tie your shoelaces in the morning?

Here's a clue: You cannot grow back a removed foreskin!
 
1) If removing the clitoris/labia makes sex less pleasurable for women, then doesn't removing the foreskin make sex less pleasurable for men?

Your analogy is incorrect. Removing the clitoris/labia would be equivalent to removing the penis and scrotum of the male.

2) Justifying circumcision by arguing that it can reduce the chances of getting HIV is utterly ridiculous.
First of all, then how do you justify circumcision for the hundreds of years BEFORE the 1970s (i.e., before AIDS existed to any appreciable degree)?

Is anybody attempting to do so?

Secondly, there are FAR better ways to reduce your chances of getting HIV.

In the population for which circumcision is now recommended for a preventative measure, the research consistently shows that circumcision provides a marked benefit in addition to the concerted promotion of other methods.

Third, AIDS is not a prevalent disease outside of Africa, and not many people contract it compared to numerous other diseases.

Which is why the recommendations mostly focus on Africa and other developing nations where the prevalence is high.

Fourth, why stop there? Shall we remove women's breasts after the onset of puberty to reduce their chances of getting breast cancer? How about preemptive bypass surgery on all people to reduce their chances of having a heart attack?

Because none of those measures are remotely comparable and cannot provide any hope of net benefit. And it is possible to make that distinction using reason, without recourse to hyperbole, emotional appeals, false analogies, and name-calling.

The argument that men won't get a circumcision later, so let's do it now while they are infants is pretty sick.

You've missed the point. The argument is that men would get a circumcision as adults anyway and would prefer to have the procedure done at a point in time when it is quick and easy.

Why don't we give everyone gastric bypass surgery as infants because fat people won't diet and exercise later?

Probably because one can tell a priori that that would lead to excessive deaths in infants.

Face it, it is societal pressure and not anything remotely resembling logic or reason that is leading people to perform this procedure.

Isn't that what we've all been saying for at least the last 10 pages?

When you understand how 'shocking' it is for girls to have the equivalent procedure, then you will understand how shocking it should be for this as well.

You did not compare it to an equivalent procedure, though.

I don't know if you are usually a reasonable person, but this is yet another example of how the topic seems to generate diatribes consisting of false analogies and scathingly presented suggestions that we are not considering the obvious (despite explicit statements otherwise) or that we are providing justification for the bizarre, in order to generate an emotional response. Is it really necessary? (Serious question)

Linda
 
So reducing a lifetime risk of 1 in 600 of penile cancer is worth raising the ethical problems by operating on a non-consenting patient? What other surgery is justified for such a low risk? I think I'm correct in saying HPV vaccinations would help with this as well? Any idea on the NNT?

How many times do I have to say this? Reducing a lifetime risk of 1 in 600 of penile cancer is not justification for circumcision. Who do you think is using that as justification for circumcision?

The benefit of increased resistance to HIV does not kick in until long after the child is able to make that choice for themselves.

I disagree. A 12-year-old boy will make different decisions than an adult. Specifically, they will heavily discount future benefit, making them poor judges in this kind of situation. And you are intentionally increasing the suffering by changing it from a simple operation that will not be remembered, to a more involved operation that takes several weeks to recover from.

In summary, circumcision of infants in the developed world (with relatively low incidence of HIV) raises the big ethical problem of performing surgery on a non-consenting patient, for which the outcome of the various benefits it provides can be attained or surpassed by alternative measures.

You have made this point over and over and over again. And I got it the first time. Since you have not addressed the points I brought up in my responses I don't think continued attempts on my part are likely to be successful. I am willing to concede the fault may be mine, since this is a recurring theme with you and me.

Linda
 
How many times do I have to say this? Reducing a lifetime risk of 1 in 600 of penile cancer is not justification for circumcision. Who do you think is using that as justification for circumcision?

You put it in your post as a small absolute benefit.

I disagree. A 12-year-old boy will make different decisions than an adult. Specifically, they will heavily discount future benefit, making them poor judges in this kind of situation.

Now who's advocating paternalistic medicine?

(I'll add that I'm _not_ talking about regions of the world with high incidence of HIV, just the US).

And you are intentionally increasing the suffering by changing it from a simple operation that will not be remembered, to a more involved operation that takes several weeks to recover from.

That is one way to look at it. You missed out the part about this being performed for a small benefit that can easily be surpassed by the correct use of condoms.

You have made this point over and over and over again. And I got it the first time. Since you have not addressed the points I brought up in my responses I don't think continued attempts on my part are likely to be successful. I am willing to concede the fault may be mine, since this is a recurring theme with you and me.

Linda

Linda,

I assure you I am not doing this on purpose. I thought I was replying to the point(s) you made about the small absolute benefits for the conditions you listed vs. the ethical considerations of action or in-action, given my definition.

Clearly this is not the question you asked or thought you asked. What do you want me to reply to?

Are there benefits to (infant) circumcision? Yes.

Are there ethical issues with operating on non-consenting individuals? Yes.

Are there alternative courses of action that raise fewer ethical issues while providing similar or better benefits compared to infant circumcision? Yes.

Are there alternative courses of action that raise more ethical issues while providing fewer or no benefits compared to infant circumcision? Yes.

Please pick the question-answer pair that fits the reply you wanted OR ask your question in a simple enough fashion that I stand a chance of answering it appropriately, even if not to your liking.
 
"Congratulations on the birth of your baby boy. I've looked at his chart, and all seems well. You should be able to take him home in twenty-four hours, right after the nostrilectomy."

"Thanks, we're so happy! All I - Wait, what? Nostilwhodemy?"

"Nostrilectomy. It's a routine procedure."

"We informed the nurses that we didn't want that procedure done."

"Oh, I see. I am of course here to advise you of all the benefits and risks associated with the procedure."

"We do want what's best for our son, and you are a doctor. . .go on."

"It's a relatively simple operation. We just remove the outermost portion of the nostril, under anesthesia, of course. Some other hosptials forgo that, saying that infant don't remember pain, but that's. . .unsound."

"Why would we want to remove the nostrils from our son?"

"It's the norm! Almost every boy has it done!"

"That's not a very convincing arguement."

"Well, I imagine his girlfriend is going to lose interest in him if he's got a funny looking nose with extra skin on it."

"I imagine that if his girlfriend, or boyfriend, prioritizes nostrils above everything else, she's not good enough for our son. Besides, if he grows up and wants it done, he can have it done then. There's nothing special about the procedure that prevents it from being done in adults, is there?"

"No, but it's extremely uncommon."

"I'm sure."

"Er...There's also some very small, but statistically significant health benefits. Your son will slightly less likely to catch influenza. Influenza's contagious, you know. If your son doesn't catch it, he can't spread it. It's your obligation to have the nostrilectomy done."

"I've seen those studies, and not only is the benfit quite small, ordinary hygine's much more important, as are simple precautions."

"True, but there are other benefits. Skin cancer, in all its forms, is quite dangerous. If you remove the nostril, you remove the possiblity of skin cancer of the nostril."

"Skin cancers on the scalp are many times more dangerous than skin cancers of the nostril, and yet you're not recomending that I have his scalp removed. Besides, aren't there risks of complications?"

"Yes, about 1% of patients have complications that result in some damage to the rest of the nose."

"So, even though the risk of dangerous nostril cancer is smaller than one percent, you want me to take a one percent risk of complications with this procedure?"

"I see your point. But, it's a routine procedure. Will you give your consent?"

"I don't think so."
 
Last edited:
Hopefully it's changed since 1998.

Hey Katana...since you're drunk, you'll like this. I was trying to find the purpose of the female prepuce earlier (I was going to make the point that it's not a vestigial organ) and ran across a bunch of pictures of diseased vulvas.

Is the one on the bottom right...scroll all the way down....does that look like the face of James Randi to you??? The one for a mysterious condition called "Vulvar vestibulitis"?
(Warning! Graphic pictures!!!!)
http://www.brooksidepress.org/Products/Military_OBGYN/Textbook/Vulva/VulvaAtlas.htm
I had a moment of pareidolia when I saw that.


Thanks for thinking of me, kellyb. ;)

Pretty awful, isn't it? It's a hideous condition and very difficult to treat.

And people think ob/gyns only deliver babies.
 
You put it in your post as a small absolute benefit.

I thought that we had agreed that benefit alone may not be sufficient reason, especially in this situation.

Now who's advocating paternalistic medicine?

(I'll add that I'm _not_ talking about regions of the world with high incidence of HIV, just the US).[/QUOTE]

That's not an example of paternalism, but there does not seem to be much point in repeating my explanation yet again.

That is one way to look at it. You missed out the part about this being performed for a small benefit that can easily be surpassed by the correct use of condoms.

That comment is not relevant to what came before.

I assure you I am not doing this on purpose. I thought I was replying to the point(s) you made about the small absolute benefits for the conditions you listed vs. the ethical considerations of action or in-action, given my definition.

I don't think you are doing it on purpose.

Clearly this is not the question you asked or thought you asked. What do you want me to reply to?

Are there benefits to (infant) circumcision? Yes.

Are there ethical issues with operating on non-consenting individuals? Yes.

Are there alternative courses of action that raise fewer ethical issues while providing similar or better benefits compared to infant circumcision? Yes.

Are there alternative courses of action that raise more ethical issues while providing fewer or no benefits compared to infant circumcision? Yes.

Please pick the question-answer pair that fits the reply you wanted OR ask your question in a simple enough fashion that I stand a chance of answering it appropriately, even if not to your liking.

Is there any way that you could consider a person who disagrees with you on this issue reasonable (please note that I am not one of them)?

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom