Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

The HIV arguments have not been defused.
But it does not matter since as the vast majority of circumcised males are quite happy with their elective, cosmetic surgery even if we did not choose it. We are so happy with it we choose it for our children in turn. This is because foreskins are considered ugly and dirty by most Americans. To most of us it would be like keeping most of the umbilical cord attached and dragging it along with you. Or like not having warts removed with liquid nitrogen.

The lack of a foreskin has little to no effect on sexual lubrication because most sexual lubricants come from the female genitals or a jar. In any case you should wear condoms when you have sex so even if your foreskin is unwashed and lubricating it won't matter.

Also foreskins or circumcised penises can not be proven or dis proven to make sex any more or less pleasurable and whether your partner prefers them is also subjective so it is all moot.


No you are wrong...are you old?!:p My friends are in California But MOST boys are not circumcised there! My nephews are 6 and 8 and only one each of their friends are circumcised...it is a practice that is dying out...admit it...there is NO reason for it!;)


Ok plus:o Now i am a little embarrassed! But lack of foreskin had a BIG effect on sexual lubrication...honestly. Sex with a circumcised person vs with an normal one is SOOOO different. The circumcised can be better to start , maybe.
, but it just pounds away and is really unpleasant when you (eventually!) get to the end. The "glide thing" doesnt work!!! rofl...this is my first post's on this forum...I never thought they would all be about dicks!!!!LOL
 
They can get it done as infants as adults?

No, you don't honestly think that was what I meant, do you?

I agree with you that the regret over not having been circumcised as an infant is irreparable. You can't wish it into having been so - but what you can do is get circumcised as an adult if you think it's important.

Which is just not possible the other way around.

What I'm saying is simply that this regret (however common it is) is the lesser of two evils. Whether you do circumcise the majority or not, you're going to get a group of people who are unhappy with it. Fact of life.

There have been effects that change based on when it is done, and the question was how many would want it done as infants not how many would want it done as adults. Between the pain and temporary sexual dysfunction that is enough to discourage people.

Like I said, whatever you do there's going to be regrets. Is it a problem, in your view, that the majority of uncircumcised adults don't get it done when they can?

But which side is the side of caution? If someone said "well the link between autism and vaccination is questionable best err on the side of caution" but the side of caution in both cases involves an irreversible treatment that the person can never go back to a "natural" condition.

That, to me, is the central point we're debating here. And my position hinges upon the observation that as long as we don't know more about the function of the foreskin, better leave it be. So that, in my opinion, is the side of caution.

Of course, you can (and apparently do) disagree.

The strong opinions seem to be entirely emotion based.

Yes, I'm tired as well of the appeals to emotion. I know where my sensitivities and cultural background (Europe, as stated) place me on the scale of emotional responses. But that won't get us anywhere, so I try to disregard it and not get too emotional, at least in the way I write it.

ThatSoundAgain said:
- If it ain't broken, don't fix it.
- If you want to fix it, despite the data being unclear, the benefits of doing so small, the drawbacks of doing so not well examined, the procedure a risk (albeit small), be sure it's your own foreskin you fix, not someone else's.

So you are for the practice of circumcision because as a common practice if that is "broken" is the basis of your argument or an appeal to "natural" being the preferred state.

Let me just clarify my original position. Maybe it would have been clearer if I'd said "If the foreskin ain't broken..." (but it just hasn't the same ring to it). So I'm not talking about the common, default practice across the population (which would be different depending on which side of the Atlantic you're on, anyway). I'm talking about the specific, individual foreskin. If there's not a problem with it (like phimosis), leave it be unless you know very specifically what foreskins do and don't do.

I hope that makes it clear(er). That's my position, take it as you will.

The if it ain't broke don't fix is just as much an appeal to maintain the status quo as it is to preserve the natural state of man. Most people here do not automatically assume "natural"=Better very much but that seems to be at the heart of these debates.

Which is wise (acknowledging that "natural" and "better" are independent variables). But to me there's a hint in that most healthy males are born with foreskins. It may be vestigial or not - the level of confidence in that has to me not been reached to the point of advocating routine removal.

Not even in the same league as "herbal medicine is better beacuse its natural".
 
Have to strongly disagree here as the foreskin is vestigal. A holdover from pre-underpants cultures. Removal of the foreskin does not (we can argue this all day but in the end circumcized men feel plenty of pleasure) detract from sex nor is it removed for that express purpose.

The clitoris is not vestigal. It's removal (and other types of femal genital mutilation) in cultures (primarily in Africa) is specifically to prevent women from enjoying sex as much or at all.

I think it's disingenuous to the women who suffer from such abuse to even try to put foreskin removal anywhere near the subject of female genital mutilation.

You're assuming total clitoral removal is the the most common form of FGM, and it's not. Removal of the clitoral hood and other forms of cutting are more common. But I agree that total clitoral removal is not the same as male circumcision.
You're also assuming that the main reason cultures who practice FGM do it is to oppress women, and that's also incorrect. They really think it's "healthier"and "more attractive" . They could have a point on the "healthier" thing. The more I think about it, the more I think removing the labia at birth might actually have some obscure health benefits that could be found if someone were to look hard enough.

Vestigial organs serve no purpose and have no function. The foreskin does not qualify. Foreskins do all kinds of things. Saying the things the foreskin does don't matter very much in your opinion doesn't make the foreskin a vestigial organ.
Saying "circumcised men feel plenty of pleasure" doesn't mean that circumcision doesn't detract from sex.
 
Equivalent to women finding your sexual organ distasteful? Sorry, I couldn't resist.

I cannot say whether she'd like the taste or not.

Education is clearly required.

I can't tell how I'm supposed to judge that.

By the time a child needs a brace they're old enough to start having a say in what happens to them and can remove the brace at will. Plus healthy but crooked teeth are the norm in the UK, don't you know that:rolleyes:

Some of the reduction of suffering is minimal or non-existent. I don't know what Calpol is.

Calpol is paracetamol for kids.

I now have a vision of your kids saying "Mummy! It hurts!" and you replying "Life is pain kid. Get used to it.":D

Seriously, which is worse as a kid: having a pain and being alone or having a pain and having your mum there?

At least equivalently required.

Yes.

So this relates to whether or not education is "required".

No, that was just the example I attached to it. Playing catch with the other kids is pretty hard if you can't see the ball clearly.

Less required.

It should really be classed as hair care, which is required. You know, like washing.

Presumably not required, yet I don't recall seeing a single anti-child-piercing thread here.

I very rarely visit the Current Events forum. If you like I'll start a thread.

They can be performed for screening or case-finding where the benefit may be non-existent (therefore not required).

The benefit is in the information gained, which if I'm correct has to be disclosed to the patient or a guardian. Knowing you don't have something can be useful too.

So at least some of what we do seems to be as unrequired as circumcision, so I'm not sure that can be used as a criterion.

Linda

The only one I see in the same league as circumcision is piercing/tattoos of infants. I would argue against that too on ethical grounds.

Going to bed. Catch you later.
 
You're assuming total clitoral removal is the the most common form of FGM, and it's not. Removal of the clitoral hood and other forms of cutting are more common. But I agree that total clitoral removal is not the same as male circumcision.
You're also assuming that the main reason cultures who practice FGM do it is to oppress women, and that's also incorrect. They really think it's "healthier"and "more attractive" . They could have a point on the "healthier" thing. The more I think about it, the more I think removing the labia at birth might actually have some obscure health benefits that could be found if someone were to look hard enough.

Sorry but there are almost no cases where female genital mutilation is not performed with the express purpose of preventing women from enjoying sex.
And in most cases it does involve deliberate removal or sabotage of the clitoris:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/

Vestigial organs serve no purpose and have no function. The foreskin does not qualify. Foreskins do all kinds of things. Saying the things the foreskin does don't matter very much in your opinion doesn't make the foreskin a vestigial organ.

I didn't say they don't matter much in my opinion. I said they don't matter much at all. No opinion, just a cold hard fact. The ONLY purpose of the foreskin (that is not served equally well by other parts of the penis) is to keep it warm and tucked away like a dog's penis sheathe (or horse, or bull, or hippopotomus).
Because we are such advanced cultures that developed PANTS we don't need this sheathe anymore. We have PANTS. Now if we were all Scots this would be another issue as we would need to have foreskins to wear under our kilts (provided we could get a license to wear a kilt as apparently Scot imposters are quite common so they're licensing kilts now). I suppose you could argue that the foreskin does prevent chaffing from said pants. But I would counter that arguement with a bottle of fabric softener.

Saying "circumcised men feel plenty of pleasure" doesn't mean that circumcision doesn't detract from sex.
Yes it does. I hate to sound cocky, but I would gladly challenge any foreskinned male on this board to a pleasure competition and am sure I could at least tie the best of them. ;)
 
Last edited:
Education is clearly required.

I remember that you have some sort of standing offer....

Calpol is paracetamol for kids.

I now have a vision of your kids saying "Mummy! It hurts!" and you replying "Life is pain kid. Get used to it.":D

Puhleeze. I have the Amazing Magic Mommy Kisses on my side.

Actually, I'm dumping the rest of the examples in favour of the definition you provided:

First thoughts would be an act is required if in-action could reasonably be expected to have negative consequences for the child in the foreseeable future, based on your list (Death, Disability, etc.). The amount of foresight would vary depending on the act being considered.

Putting aside our bias for physical integrity, could not the small (tiny) absolute benefit in infant UTI and penile cancer, and variable (depending upon the prevalence wherever the child lives when they become sexually active) absolute benefit in reducing the risk of acquiring HIV be considered as consequences worth avoiding through inaction? (Focusing on those issues in which some or all of the benefit is lost by waiting until the child is an adult.)

Linda
 
rofl...this is my first post's on this forum...I never thought they would all be about dicks!!!!LOL

I'd like to say you've got nowhere to go but up from here.

I'd like to say that. But...well, this place is like a gutter with a basement. There's always a way to go lower.

Welcome to the forums. :D

Athon
 
BlackKat said:
Sorry but there are almost no cases where female genital mutilation is not performed with the express purpose of preventing women from enjoying sex.
That's not true.
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/102/1/153
FGM has been documented in individuals from many religions, including Christians, Muslims, and Jews. Some proponents of the practice claim that it is required by the Islamic faith. However, scholars and theologians of Islam state that female circumcision is not prescribed by their religious doctrine, emphasizing that the procedure is almost never performed in many major Muslim countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Pakistan.17

Kopelman18 has summarized four additional reasons proposed to explain the custom of FGM: 1) to preserve group identity; 2) to help maintain cleanliness and health; 3) to preserve virginity and family honor and prevent immorality; and 4) to further marriage goals, including enhancement of sexual pleasure for men. Preservation of cultural identity has been noted by Toubia19 to be of particular importance for groups who have previously faced colonialism and for immigrants threatened by a dominant culture. FGM is endemic in poor societies where marriage is essential to the social and economic security for women. FGM becomes a physical sign of a woman's marriageability, with social control exercised over her sexual pleasure by clitorectomy and over reproduction by infibulation.


BlackKat said:
And in most cases it does involve deliberate removal or sabotage of the clitoris:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
If you want to call removing the prepuce "sabotage".
(ETA: notice that my link is from 2005 and yours from 2000. That WHO media release is pretty old now.)

http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/FGM-C_final_10_October.pdf

In the majority of countries that have included
questions regarding type of FGM/C, excision
of the prepuce (Type 1) is found to be the most
common. Only in Burkina Faso is excision of the
clitoris (Type 2) found to be most frequent.


BlackKat said:
I didn't say they don't matter much in my opinion. I said they don't matter much at all. No opinion, just a cold hard fact.
What fact? You haven't provided any facts at all so far.
The ONLY purpose of the foreskin (that is not served equally well by other parts of the penis) is to keep it warm and tucked away like a dog's penis sheathe (or horse, or bull, or hippopotomus).
Can you provide some evidence to back that claim?
Because we are such advanced cultures that developed PANTS we don't need this sheathe anymore. We have PANTS. Now if we were all Scots this would be another issue as we would need to have foreskins to wear under our kilts (provided we could get a license to wear a kilt as apparently Scot imposters are quite common so they're licensing kilts now). I suppose you could argue that the foreskin does prevent chaffing from said pants. But I would counter that arguement with a bottle of fabric softener.
See above.
Yes it does. I hate to sound cocky, but I would gladly challenge any foreskinned male on this board to a pleasure competition and am sure I could at least tie the best of them.
I bet you'd cheat. This would have to rely on "self-reporting", right?
:)
In all seriousness, I'll dig up the studies that have looked into sexual satisfaction after circumcision if you want. Circumcision generally reduces sexual pleasure.
 
Last edited:
fls said:
Putting aside our bias for physical integrity, could not the small (tiny) absolute benefit in infant UTI and penile cancer, and variable (depending upon the prevalence wherever the child lives when they become sexually active) absolute benefit in reducing the risk of acquiring HIV be considered as consequences worth avoiding through inaction? (Focusing on those issues in which some or all of the benefit is lost by waiting until the child is an adult.)

Linda

Are you sure the penis cancer thing only "works" if a male is circumcised in infancy?
And the choice to use circumcision as an HIV preventive could be made around the time of puberty, as well. Realistically, most of the benefits there could still be gained if circumcision was performed around age 18. (I'm going out on a limb here and guessing that an overwhelming majority of HIV infected men picked up the virus after age 18, although I haven't looked it up.)
 
Have to strongly disagree here as the foreskin is vestigal. A holdover from pre-underpants cultures. Removal of the foreskin does not (we can argue this all day but in the end circumcized men feel plenty of pleasure) detract from sex nor is it removed for that express purpose.
You keep repeating that claim, without any evidence. And you claim it's all fact, while ignoring the evidence showing that the foreskin does have a use. Hmm, sounds iffy, even disingenuous.

The clitoris is not vestigal. It's removal (and other types of femal genital mutilation) in cultures (primarily in Africa) is specifically to prevent women from enjoying sex as much or at all.
That is not the reason they give, actually. Preventing women from enjoying sex is a result, not necessarily the primary, or even secondary objective.

I think it's disingenuous
Oh the irony.
 
Id feel more comfortable with circumsision of they gave the baby anesthesia


That's fairly standard practice these days.

Feel better?

ETA: Didn't mean for that to sound so confrontational, so I'll add: :p
 
That's fairly standard practice these days.

Feel better?

ETA: Didn't mean for that to sound so confrontational, so I'll add: :p

This is the most recent thing I could find on it:

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/101/6/e5.pdf

Anesthesia or analgesia is
used by 45% of circumcisers and is more likely to be
used by PEDs (71%) than by either FPs (56%; P ,
.001) or OBs (25%; P , .001)
An overall average of less than half, and only one out of four OBs doing it in the hospital use it.

:(
 
No you are wrong...are you old?!:p My friends are in California But MOST boys are not circumcised there! My nephews are 6 and 8 and only one each of their friends are circumcised...it is a practice that is dying out...admit it...there is NO reason for it!;)


Ok plus:o Now i am a little embarrassed! But lack of foreskin had a BIG effect on sexual lubrication...honestly. Sex with a circumcised person vs with an normal one is SOOOO different. The circumcised can be better to start , maybe.
, but it just pounds away and is really unpleasant when you (eventually!) get to the end. The "glide thing" doesnt work!!! rofl...this is my first post's on this forum...I never thought they would all be about dicks!!!!LOL


Ok, tabitha.

First of all, excellent first post.

Second of all, welcome! :D

This is the most recent thing I could find on it:

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/101/6/e5.pdf


An overall average of less than half, and only one out of four OBs doing it in the hospital use it.

:(


:seerrrr:

Damn. Jerks.

Thanks, kellyb.

I'm a bit too inebriated to the research that I should have done before, so I thank you. If this really is reflective of the majority of docs, it's pathetic. My only hope is that, because it's from 1998, it doesn't reflect current practice.

I can only hope...

I'll try to look into it more tomorrow.

:viking1
 
I bet you'd cheat. This would have to rely on "self-reporting", right?
:)
In all seriousness, I'll dig up the studies that have looked into sexual satisfaction after circumcision if you want. Circumcision generally reduces sexual pleasure.

That's my point. Claims on this post go both ways from men and women for and against the circumcised penis for satisfaction. The same is true for more organized studies. Since sexual satisfaction is subjective and dependent on so many factors it's almost silly to bring sexual satisfaction into debate. If people are enjoying sex who are both circumcised or not, or whose partner(s) are/have been circumcised and/or not.... Can you quantify this enjoyment in terms of levels? Pretty difficult if not impossible.

Sorry but there are almost no cases where female genital mutilation is not performed with the express purpose of preventing women from enjoying sex.
And in most cases it does involve deliberate removal or sabotage of the clitoris:
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
I suppose we could all call up conflicting studies but I'm going to believe the World Health Organization's claim that 80% of female genital mutilation procedures are designed to remove the clitoris, labia, or both for the purpose of as your own source stated:
1) to preserve group identity; 2) to help maintain cleanliness and health; 3) to preserve virginity and family honor and prevent immorality; and 4) to further marriage goals, including enhancement of sexual pleasure for men.

Now it's perfectly ok to call into question the medical studies which are stating 2) for circumcision. But the HIV studies done are fairly conclusive. More so are the ones about wearing condoms, which would make the HIV transmission studies about having a foreskin or not moot.

As far as 1) goes. I'd agree this probably is the reason most Americans are circumcised. But you know what? We like our circumcised penises. We (those of us who are circumcised) think our penises are less ugly. I am SOOOOOOO glad I was circumcised as an infant. I would almost certainly have made the same choice as an older person, but am spared the thought and discomfort of having the procedure done because it occurred when I was too young to remember a thing, let alone probably notice it. I am calling my mother right now to thank her for having me circumcised. Just because a child is too young to appreciate getting a less unattractive penis does not mean they won't love you for it later.
 
Last edited:
Hopefully it's changed since 1998.

Hey Katana...since you're drunk, you'll like this. I was trying to find the purpose of the female prepuce earlier (I was going to make the point that it's not a vestigial organ) and ran across a bunch of pictures of diseased vulvas.

Is the one on the bottom right...scroll all the way down....does that look like the face of James Randi to you??? The one for a mysterious condition called "Vulvar vestibulitis"?
(Warning! Graphic pictures!!!!)
http://www.brooksidepress.org/Products/Military_OBGYN/Textbook/Vulva/VulvaAtlas.htm
I had a moment of pareidolia when I saw that.
 
BlackKat said:
That's my point. Claims on this post go both ways from men and women for and against the circumcised penis for satisfaction. The same is true for more organized studies. Since sexual satisfaction is subjective and dependent on so many factors it's almost silly to bring sexual satisfaction into debate.
But there's hard biology that explains the how's and why's of the loss of sensitivity that comes with circumcision, though. You'd only have a case if self-reports were the only thing we had to work with.
If people are enjoying sex who are both circumcised or not, or whose partner(s) are/have been circumcised and/or not.... Can you quantify this enjoyment in terms of levels? Pretty difficult if not impossible.
But the general experience is that men report a loss of sensation and pleasure after being circumcised. And this makes sense since we know there are millions of nerves lost and whole erogenous zones removed.

I suppose we could all call up conflicting studies but I'm going to believe the World Health Organization's claim that 80% of female genital mutilation procedures are designed to remove the clitoris, labia, or both for the purpose of as your own source stated:
1) to preserve group identity; 2) to help maintain cleanliness and health; 3) to preserve virginity and family honor and prevent immorality; and 4) to further marriage goals, including enhancement of sexual pleasure for men.
First of all, none of those say "to make sex less enjoyable for women"...and even if you can squeeze that out of number 3, it's one out of 5 reasons given. That doesn't mean ALL cultures use ALL five reasons. You just want it to mean that so FGM can stay firmly planted on the "evil" side, so it maintains a stark contrast with male circumcision.
 
Are you sure the penis cancer thing only "works" if a male is circumcised in infancy?

"Neonatal circumcision confers some protection from penile cancer; however, circumcision at a later age does not seem to confer the same level of protection."

And the choice to use circumcision as an HIV preventive could be made around the time of puberty, as well. Realistically, most of the benefits there could still be gained if circumcision was performed around age 18. (I'm going out on a limb here and guessing that an overwhelming majority of HIV infected men picked up the virus after age 18, although I haven't looked it up.)

It seems to me that kids start having sex long before they are capable of making responsible decisions. Having two teenagers myself, I'd be happy if you could find evidence to the contrary, so I could rest easy. :)

Linda
 
But there's hard biology that explains the how's and why's of the loss of sensitivity that comes with circumcision, though. You'd only have a case if self-reports were the only thing we had to work with.

But the general experience is that men report a loss of sensation and pleasure after being circumcised. And this makes sense since we know there are millions of nerves lost and whole erogenous zones removed.

If you look at a penis diagram most of the nerves (erogenous zones) are on the underside of the shaft and on the glans. I can only relate my personal satisfaction (or Z's since he also expressed the same earlier this thread). There's a reason American men recite baseball stats in their heads during sex you know... it's to keep going longer.

First of all, none of those say "to make sex less enjoyable for women"...and even if you can squeeze that out of number 3, it's one out of 5 reasons given. That doesn't mean ALL cultures use ALL five reasons. You just want it to mean that so FGM can stay firmly planted on the "evil" side, so it maintains a stark contrast with male circumcision.

Well ... I may be wrong because I am not female. But I would think removing the clitoris and/or labia would make sex (including masturbation) a lot less pleasurable. I don't think I was making a huge intellectual leap of faith to add that with the patriarchal societies and second class treatment of women to conclude that female genital mutilation is an act of deliberate sabotage.
 
Last edited:
"Neonatal circumcision confers some protection from penile cancer; however, circumcision at a later age does not seem to confer the same level of protection."



It seems to me that kids start having sex long before they are capable of making responsible decisions. Having two teenagers myself, I'd be happy if you could find evidence to the contrary, so I could rest easy. :)

Linda
Ok...I just looked through some of the research making that claim, and it looks to me like circumcision's effectiveness for penis cancer has to do with whether or not it's performed before men become sexually active. It's not very good research, though. It's hard to say for sure what's going on there.

Regarding teens making good decisions, I'm just not seeing this as an argument for infant circumcision. You just can't go around whacking off other people's sex organs when they're babies because you think they're going to maybe make bad choices later. Penile cancer is somewhat avoidable by means other than circumcision, as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom