They can get it done as infants as adults?
No, you don't honestly think that was what I meant, do you?
I agree with you that the regret over not having been circumcised as an infant is irreparable. You can't wish it into having been so - but what you
can do is get circumcised as an adult if you think it's important.
Which is just not possible the other way around.
What I'm saying is simply that this regret (however common it is) is the lesser of two evils. Whether you do circumcise the majority or not, you're going to get a group of people who are unhappy with it. Fact of life.
There have been effects that change based on when it is done, and the question was how many would want it done as infants not how many would want it done as adults. Between the pain and temporary sexual dysfunction that is enough to discourage people.
Like I said, whatever you do there's going to be regrets. Is it a problem, in your view, that the majority of uncircumcised adults don't get it done when they can?
But which side is the side of caution? If someone said "well the link between autism and vaccination is questionable best err on the side of caution" but the side of caution in both cases involves an irreversible treatment that the person can never go back to a "natural" condition.
That, to me, is the central point we're debating here. And my position hinges upon the observation that as long as we don't know more about the function of the foreskin, better leave it be. So that, in my opinion, is the side of caution.
Of course, you can (and apparently do) disagree.
The strong opinions seem to be entirely emotion based.
Yes, I'm tired as well of the appeals to emotion. I know where my sensitivities and cultural background (Europe, as stated) place me on the scale of emotional responses. But that won't get us anywhere, so I try to disregard it and not get too emotional, at least in the way I write it.
ThatSoundAgain said:
- If it ain't broken, don't fix it.
- If you want to fix it, despite the data being unclear, the benefits of doing so small, the drawbacks of doing so not well examined, the procedure a risk (albeit small), be sure it's your own foreskin you fix, not someone else's.
So you are for the practice of circumcision because as a common practice if that is "broken" is the basis of your argument or an appeal to "natural" being the preferred state.
Let me just clarify my original position. Maybe it would have been clearer if I'd said "If
the foreskin ain't broken..." (but it just hasn't the same ring to it). So I'm not talking about the common, default practice across the population (which would be different depending on which side of the Atlantic you're on, anyway). I'm talking about the specific, individual foreskin. If there's not a problem with it (like phimosis), leave it be unless you know very specifically what foreskins do and don't do.
I hope that makes it clear(er). That's my position, take it as you will.
The if it ain't broke don't fix is just as much an appeal to maintain the status quo as it is to preserve the natural state of man. Most people here do not automatically assume "natural"=Better very much but that seems to be at the heart of these debates.
Which is wise (acknowledging that "natural" and "better" are independent variables). But to me there's a hint in that most healthy males are born with foreskins. It may be vestigial or not - the level of confidence in that has to me not been reached to the point of advocating routine removal.
Not even in the same league as "herbal medicine is better beacuse its
natural".