Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Actually here are some statistics broken down by year and region in the U.S.
http://www.cirp.org/library/statistics/USA/
I still have not been able to determine if this is a pro / con / neutral site but their numbers seem to have come from the NHDS so they're probably accurate.

Morrigan said:
Quote:
But in essence, the foreskin, like other evolutionary holdovers, is not necessary. It's like when people are born with tails, webbing, etc. Clothing makes having a foreskin superfluous.
This analogy is so wrong, I can't help but shake my head. A foreskin might not be essential but it's certainly not useless, and claiming otherwise and comparing it to a tail is sheer intellectual dishonesty.

This is hardly a faulty analogy. The foreskin is the human equivalent to other animals having furred sheathes which their penis withdraws into when not erect (like land mammals) or body cavities (like birds or fish or whales). Since the invention of pants (some thousands of years ago) the foreskin has just been an evolutionary holdover from when we needed to hide our penis to keep it safe and warm.
 
http://www.cirp.org/library/statistics/USA/
I still have not been able to determine if this is a pro / con / neutral site but their numbers seem to have come from the NHDS so they're probably accurate.

Based on the direction of the misleading and misrepresentative information provided in the articles and FAQ's, it's a con site. I agree that it's hard to tell if you don't have independent knowledge.

Linda
 
This is hardly a faulty analogy. The foreskin is the human equivalent to other animals having furred sheathes which their penis withdraws into when not erect (like land mammals) or body cavities (like birds or fish or whales). Since the invention of pants (some thousands of years ago) the foreskin has just been an evolutionary holdover from when we needed to hide our penis to keep it safe and warm.
No, in the human, the foreskin does more than that.
The prepuce keeps the glans soft and protects it from abrasions and drying out (keratinized), releases pheromones, assists in lubrication during intercourse, etc. In lower primates, the glans penis is actually more sensitive than the foreskin. In humans it's reversed, making it impossible for it to be a simple vestigial organ.
 
What about this makes it unrequired in a way that doesn't make the majority of what we do for our children unrequired?

I think in the case of circumcision the benefit really is in the eye of the beholder. The only other unrequired things we do for our children that I can think of is vaccinate them. Typically these are for unpleasant and sometimes deadly diseases, which there is few treatments for (since they are viral) except support for the body while it is healing itself.

However, we don't vaccinate children (or anybody else for that matter) until just before they are likely to be at risk. Standard vaccinations have extremely low risk and large benefits. They also do not affect the individual at a level they can perceive for a significant length of time. I.e. the administration of them is quick and the after effects are minor.

I really can't think of any other medical treatments that are not indicated first before treatment commences. Were you just thinking about medical interventions? Give me some examples of other things parents do for their children that are not required.

It is not a simple thing for a physician to refuse to provide service. The physician has to believe that it will not offer a net benefit to the patient, something that would be very difficult to support considering that the available information demonstrates 1) a net benefit to circumcision and 2) a net benefit to neonatal circumcision over and above that provided by circumcision later. This is particularly tricky in the US, and may be an additional contributor to the higher rate of circumcision.

Linda

Again, it comes down to who's viewing the benefit.

Claiming circumcising an infant to avoid problems associated with tight foreskin is a benefit for most children is ridiculous. Most of the (non-US) research concludes that this 'problem' cures itself for the vast majority of boys by the time they're 15. If it does occur there are techniques other than circumcision to try first.

It reduces infections of the foreskin/glans. I can only talk from personal experience*, but I would certainly not have chosen to be circumcised to avoid the 1-2 days of discomfort caused by one of these. (I didn't even have a day of work). Plus it's something to talk about in the pub:)

It provides protection against HIV. No one in their right mind would think circumcision is going to be a significant advantage for the control of HIV in the US.

That leaves UTI's, which presumably in women are treated with antibiotics. Why raise the ethical problems of operating on a healthy, non-consenting patient when there exists effective treatment for the problem if it occurs in the first place?

Circumcision does have a role, but it should be much closer to the 0.6% figure quoted in the paper I linked to earlier if it is being used when it is an appropriate treatment.

*This was caused by not washing my hands before going for a pee after using mineral oil on a lathe.
 
I think in the case of circumcision the benefit really is in the eye of the beholder.

Haven't we all agreed on that?

The only other unrequired things we do for our children that I can think of is vaccinate them. Typically these are for unpleasant and sometimes deadly diseases, which there is few treatments for (since they are viral) except support for the body while it is healing itself.

However, we don't vaccinate children (or anybody else for that matter) until just before they are likely to be at risk. Standard vaccinations have extremely low risk and large benefits. They also do not affect the individual at a level they can perceive for a significant length of time. I.e. the administration of them is quick and the after effects are minor.

I really can't think of any other medical treatments that are not indicated first before treatment commences. Were you just thinking about medical interventions? Give me some examples of other things parents do for their children that are not required.

Education, braces, treatment of most ailments, sunscreen, glasses, haircuts, piercings, tatoos, diagnostic tests.

Again, it comes down to who's viewing the benefit.

Claiming circumcising an infant to avoid problems associated with tight foreskin is a benefit for most children is ridiculous. Most of the (non-US) research concludes that this 'problem' cures itself for the vast majority of boys by the time they're 15. If it does occur there are techniques other than circumcision to try first.

It reduces infections of the foreskin/glans. I can only talk from personal experience*, but I would certainly not have chosen to be circumcised to avoid the 1-2 days of discomfort caused by one of these. (I didn't even have a day of work). Plus it's something to talk about in the pub:)

It provides protection against HIV. No one in their right mind would think circumcision is going to be a significant advantage for the control of HIV in the US.

That leaves UTI's, which presumably in women are treated with antibiotics. Why raise the ethical problems of operating on a healthy, non-consenting patient when there exists effective treatment for the problem if it occurs in the first place?

Circumcision does have a role, but it should be much closer to the 0.6% figure quoted in the paper I linked to earlier if it is being used when it is an appropriate treatment.

We've gone over all this already. Nobody's disagreeing with you on these issues.

*This was caused by not washing my hands before going for a pee after using mineral oil on a lathe.

TMI!!!

Linda
 
Ivor said:
I really can't think of any other medical treatments that are not indicated first before treatment commences. Were you just thinking about medical interventions? Give me some examples of other things parents do for their children that are not required.

fls said:
Education, braces, treatment of most ailments, sunscreen, glasses, haircuts, piercings, tatoos, diagnostic tests.
I'm not really seeing the parallel between circumcision and the application of sunscreen.:confused: Glasses, medications, and diagnostic tests tend to be done after there's already a problem, so I'm not seeing that, either.
Circumcision appears to be rather unique.
 
Quote:
This is hardly a faulty analogy. The foreskin is the human equivalent to other animals having furred sheathes which their penis withdraws into when not erect (like land mammals) or body cavities (like birds or fish or whales). Since the invention of pants (some thousands of years ago) the foreskin has just been an evolutionary holdover from when we needed to hide our penis to keep it safe and warm.
No, in the human, the foreskin does more than that.
The prepuce keeps the glans soft and protects it from abrasions and drying out (keratinized).
I am circumcised and have never had abrasions or kerantization. I would think this a symptom of too much of a good thing. Precum is emitted by the ureathra anyhow, not by the foreskin. If you're refering to smegma as was already addressed earlier this is a sign of a penis that is not washed enough. All pores on humans emit oils and other liquids over time. But since we bathe at least daily unless we are hobos we do not keep them there.

, releases pheromones,
How many do you need? Are you going to complain if I give you 1,234,345,227 instead of 1,234,345,230 ? Human phermones are still unproven anyhow although there is some evidence they may exist.


assists in lubrication during intercourse, etc.
see above.

In lower primates, the glans penis is actually more sensitive than the foreskin. In humans it's reversed, making it impossible for it to be a simple vestigial organ.
Circumcised men (as Z has said) are having no problems with lack of sensation in their de-foreskinned members. I'll testify to this as well.
But again comparing sensations (which are subjective and could be as much psychological as physical anyhow) is pointless. But in case it's not pointless the most nerves in the penis (circumcised or not) are in the tip and along the bottom length. Not in the foreskin.
 
Last edited:
I'm not really seeing the parallel between circumcision and the application of sunscreen.:confused: Glasses, medications, and diagnostic tests tend to be done after there's already a problem, so I'm not seeing that, either.
Circumcision appears to be rather unique.

They are examples of things that we force upon our children that are not required (to force a clarification of what is meant by "required").

Linda
 
I think there might be a lot of variation in what happens in different areas of the country?
The OB who saw me though the first part of my delivery actually pressured me to circumcise, and then when it was "time", it was just a nurse who came in with paperwork and asked if I wanted it done. When my best friend gave birth, it was just a nurse with paperwork who spoke with her. She just rattled off the list of possible complications and my friend signed the consent form.
This is in the south, though.


That was pretty irresponsible. A nurse is no more qualified to consent you for your son's circumcision than he/she is for any other surgical procedure. That is not meant to cause offense. It's a matter of the physician taking the responsibility to ensure that patients are adequately-informed since he/she is the one actually doing the procedure and who is, therefore, best-qualified to do so. It's the same reason that medical students don't consent patients. What happened to you and your friend put the nurses in a bad position in that they were asked to do the docs' work for them.

Having said that, you might be right about there being some geographic differences in even in the way that physicians approach the matter. However, going on my experiences in a variety of settings and the opinions of many docs expressed at conferences that I have attended, I know that my hospital is not alone. That much I can say, but, admittedly, that is anecdotal. :con2:
 
Circumcision is pretty horrible. I fortunately live in the UK where it is not the norm. No medical body on the world recommends it, The HIV arguments have been pretty much defused to my knowledge. (I have links but I can't post them as I am new!).

I don't know why anyone would put a newborn through cosmetic surgery though (that is what it is). It's pretty hard to understand for us on this side of the pond! Why would you want to decrise the sexual capacity of your baby??? Foreskins have functions!!! Honestly, they do!;)

Two of my friends are now married to circumcised americans and both of them are finding it hard. Foreskins glide up and down when you make love...it can be pretty harsh to make love with a circumcised guy sometimes, for the woman. "Lasting longer" is NOT always a good thing iykim;) :p
 
Circumcision is pretty horrible. I fortunately live in the UK where it is not the norm. No medical body on the world recommends it, The HIV arguments have been pretty much defused to my knowledge. (I have links but I can't post them as I am new!).

I don't know why anyone would put a newborn through cosmetic surgery though (that is what it is). It's pretty hard to understand for us on this side of the pond! Why would you want to decrise the sexual capacity of your baby??? Foreskins have functions!!! Honestly, they do!;)

Two of my friends are now married to circumcised americans and both of them are finding it hard. Foreskins glide up and down when you make love...it can be pretty harsh to make love with a circumcised guy sometimes, for the woman. "Lasting longer" is NOT always a good thing iykim;) :p

The HIV arguments have not been defused.
But it does not matter since as the vast majority of circumcised males are quite happy with their elective, cosmetic surgery even if we did not choose it. We are so happy with it we choose it for our children in turn. This is because foreskins are considered ugly and dirty by most Americans. To most of us it would be like keeping most of the umbilical cord attached and dragging it along with you. Or like not having warts removed with liquid nitrogen.

The lack of a foreskin has little to no effect on sexual lubrication because most sexual lubricants come from the female genitals or a jar. In any case you should wear condoms when you have sex so even if your foreskin is unwashed and lubricating it won't matter.

Also foreskins or circumcised penises can not be proven or disproven to make sex any more or less pleasurable and wether your partner prefers them is also subjective so it is all moot.
 
Last edited:
Education, braces, treatment of most ailments, sunscreen, glasses, haircuts, piercings, tatoos, diagnostic tests.

Education: Huge disadvantage if not provided.

Braces: I think it would make an interesting court case if a child really did not want to wear braces, against the parents will.

Treatment of most ailments: To reduce suffering that is occurring at the time of treatment. E.g., Calpol

Sunscreen: Interesting one. Does work but encourages more time in sun so benefit is reduced. Then there's the whole vitamin D thing...

Glasses: Not being able to see clearly is a significant disadvantage for most children. E.g., they can't read the blackboard in school or learn to write properly unless they can see.

Haircuts: Not essential, but handy if the school has an outbreak of head lice. Also rather trivial until you start noticing the opposite sex.

Piercings/Tattoos: Hey, the region of England I come from even the women have L-O-V-E H-A-T-E on their knuckles! If either of these procedures were performed on a non-consenting child it would raise similar ethical problems for the person performing them.

Diagnostic Tests: Apart from aliens and Greg House, who performs diagnostic tests without some medical problem in the first place?

TMI!!!

Linda

What's TMI? Is it rude?:D

ETA: Got TMI. Sorry if you were eating...
 
Last edited:
BlackKat said:
I am circumcised and have never had abrasions or kerantization.
Uuh...maybe you're some rare exception, but I've never....seen...the glans of a circumcised adult male that weren't keratinized. I don't know if it's allowed on this forum, but there are compare/contrast pictures available on the web from non-pornographic sources that show the difference.
I would think this a symptom of too much of a good thing.
What do you mean?
Having shiny, smooth pink parts isn't an issue in a negative way for intact men. Or for uncircumcised women, either.
Precum is emitted by the ureathra anyhow, not by the foreskin.
It has to do with the way the penis "behaves" with lubrication produced by the female. I'm not sure how to describe it without being vulgar.
If you're refering to smegma as was already addressed earlier this is a sign of a penis that is not washed enough.
I wasn't talking about that, either, but it's not like only "dirty" penises can produce it. It's something that's produced and that washes away. Just like with females.
All pores on humans emit oils and other liquids over time. But since we bathe at least daily unless we are hobos we do not keep them there.
Ok. Either way, the foreskin contains apocrine glands. It's part of our pheromonal signalling system.

How many do you need? Are you going to complain if I give you 1,234,345,227 instead of 1,234,345,230 ? Human phermones are still unproven anyhow although there is some evidence they may exist.

I was unaware that pheromones in humans were unproven. I'd be very surprised if they didn't exist. Perhaps that would be a subject for another thread, though. I read some interesting research on pheromones and the MHC a while back, and I'm personally convinced.
Regarding the relevance to circumcision, I guess it's unknown at this time, since it hasn't been studied.
Circumcised men (as Z has said) are having no problems with lack of sensation in their de-foreskinned members. I'll testify to this as well.
There are similar testimonials from women who've undergone various forms of female circumcision. It's hard to know what it "means" as far as which is really "better", though.
But again comparing sensations (which are subjective and could be as much psychological as physical anyhow) is pointless. But in case it's not pointless the most nerves in the penis (circumcised or not) are in the tip and along the bottom length. Not in the foreskin.
Have you seen this?

http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1464-410X.2006.06685.x

OBJECTIVE

To map the fine-touch pressure thresholds of the adult penis in circumcised and uncircumcised men, and to compare the two populations.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Adult male volunteers with no history of penile pathology or diabetes were evaluated with a Semmes-Weinstein monofilament touch-test to map the fine-touch pressure thresholds of the penis. Circumcised and uncircumcised men were compared using mixed models for repeated data, controlling for age, type of underwear worn, time since last ejaculation, ethnicity, country of birth, and level of education.

RESULTS
The glans of the uncircumcised men had significantly lower mean (sem) pressure thresholds than that of the circumcised men, at 0.161 (0.078) g (P = 0.040) when controlled for age, location of measurement, type of underwear worn, and ethnicity. There were significant differences in pressure thresholds by location on the penis (P < 0.001). The most sensitive location on the circumcised penis was the circumcision scar on the ventral surface. Five locations on the uncircumcised penis that are routinely removed at circumcision had lower pressure thresholds than the ventral scar of the circumcised penis.

CONCLUSIONS
The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis. The transitional region from the external to the internal prepuce is the most sensitive region of the uncircumcised penis and more sensitive than the most sensitive region of the circumcised penis. Circumcision ablates the most sensitive parts of the penis.
 
Last edited:
BlackKat said:
But it does not matter since as the vast majority of circumcised males are quite happy with their elective, cosmetic surgery even if we did not choose it. We are so happy with it we choose it for our children in turn. This is because foreskins are considered ugly and dirty by most Americans. To most of us it would be like keeping most of the umbilical cord attached and dragging it along with you. Or like not having warts removed with liquid nitrogen.
That sounds a lot like what women in Africa think about FGM.
It's a totally illogical cultural bias.
 
They are examples of things that we force upon our children that are not required (to force a clarification of what is meant by "required").

Linda

First thoughts would be an act is required if in-action could reasonably be expected to have negative consequences for the child in the foreseeable future, based on your list (Death, Disability, etc.). The amount of foresight would vary depending on the act being considered.
 
Well this hardy perennial has come around again!

I still say what I did at the start: If adults want to cut bits off themselves, fine. Doing it to children is at best unfair and at worst, I can't see how it differs from abuse. The fact that it's common custom in certain areas is no argument at all. Clitoral circumcision is common practice some places. Doesn't make it right.
If this makes me anti-semitic or anti-whoever the hell cuts girls' clitorises off, I think I can live with it.
 
That sounds a lot like what women in Africa think about FGM.
It's a totally illogical cultural bias.

Have to strongly disagree here as the foreskin is vestigal. A holdover from pre-underpants cultures. Removal of the foreskin does not (we can argue this all day but in the end circumcized men feel plenty of pleasure) detract from sex nor is it removed for that express purpose.

The clitoris is not vestigal. It's removal (and other types of femal genital mutilation) in cultures (primarily in Africa) is specifically to prevent women from enjoying sex as much or at all.

I think it's disingenuous to the women who suffer from such abuse to even try to put foreskin removal anywhere near the subject of female genital mutilation.
 
Education: Huge disadvantage if not provided.

Equivalent to women finding your sexual organ distasteful? Sorry, I couldn't resist.

Braces: I think it would make an interesting court case if a child really did not want to wear braces, against the parents will.

I can't tell how I'm supposed to judge that.

Treatment of most ailments: To reduce suffering that is occurring at the time of treatment. E.g., Calpol

Some of the reduction of suffering is minimal or non-existent. I don't know what Calpol is.

Sunscreen: Interesting one. Does work but encourages more time in sun so benefit is reduced. Then there's the whole vitamin D thing...

At least equivalently required.

Glasses: Not being able to see clearly is a significant disadvantage for most children. E.g., they can't read the blackboard in school or learn to write properly unless they can see.

So this relates to whether or not education is "required".

Haircuts: Not essential, but handy if the school has an outbreak of head lice. Also rather trivial until you start noticing the opposite sex.

Less required.

Piercings/Tattoos: Hey, the region of England I come from even the women have L-O-V-E H-A-T-E on their knuckles! If either of these procedures were performed on a non-consenting child it would raise similar ethical problems for the person performing them.

Presumably not required, yet I don't recall seeing a single anti-child-piercing thread here.

Diagnostic Tests: Apart from aliens and Greg House, who performs diagnostic tests without some medical problem in the first place?

They can be performed for screening or case-finding where the benefit may be non-existent (therefore not required).

So at least some of what we do seems to be as unrequired as circumcision, so I'm not sure that can be used as a criterion.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom