Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Again, around most of the developed world, yes. In the US, medical professionals appear to be either unwilling or scared to tell parents there is no medical reason to circumcise the vast majority of boys. Are they worried about repeat trade?


Upon what evidence do you base this assertion?
 
Around most of the developed world, yes. The fact that the US circumcises so many more infants indicates the reasons there are definitely not based on medical science.

But there's no reason to think that it's coming from physicians - i.e. physicians may be recommending that it only be done for medical reasons and people are choosing to ignore their advice in favour of other reasons.

We will never know about this potentially beneficial preventative treatment for ingrown toenails.

Just like we will never know about the potential benefits of ear-lobe or belly button removal.

Again, around most of the developed world, yes. In the US, medical professionals appear to be either unwilling or scared to tell parents there is no medical reason to circumcise the vast majority of boys. Are they worried about repeat trade?

What evidence do you have that medical professionals in the US are not telling parents that there is no medical reason to circumcise?

I don’t think it’s mainly religious. I think it’s become so routine that Americans don’t see how bizarre it is and because of the pressure to conform, as your recollection below hints at.

I agree. I'm just saying that a concerted, pro-active effort might be seen as an attack on a religious practice; something which people in the US seem sensitive to.

So parents deciding on unnecessary surgical procedures for their child is not paternalistic medicine? I’m all for empowering the patient, who in this case are currently unable to speak for themselves.

Paternalistic medicine usually refers to the physician acting as the decision-maker. Wouldn't the case of a father acting paternalistic be kind of a tautology?

However, I suppose you could argue that if the child is going to grow up in a pro-circumcision environment, then the choice of the parent is highly likely to reflect the choice of the child when it is older, just as children typically have the same faith as their parents.

With respect to the God complex, as a parent don’t you sometimes feel just a little bit pleased when your kids do as their told? Don’t you bask in the reflected glory from their successes?

I think this is one of those situations where first-hand experience is very enlightening. I gave up basking a long time ago. Now all I ask for is not to feel like a harpy every minute of every day. :)

The God complex comment was supposed to be provocative. However, as I said earlier I think the main reasons are down to social conformity and the belief that everyone else is doing it.

I also think that is a large component of it here (i.e. in the US).

Going back to my toenail analogy, do you think a physician would be open to legal attack for refusing to remove the toenail(s) of a young child because their parents requested it?

There isn't an established practice of providing the procedure or an established research base showing the benefit/harm of the procedure like there is for circumcision.

Now he probably just thinks Canadians are weird:D

Trust me. He had plenty of opportunity to come to that conclusion beforehand. ;)

Linda
 
Thanks Z.

Oh, and about those "tests" that have been performed, I feel quite suspicious about that research that says less HIV risks and no loss of sensitivity after circuncision. Since the emotional side of the issue is mostly on the part of the "pro-cut" guys, that research is more likely to have been done by them and to show the results they want to hear. "Anti-cut".-s usually don´t give a toss.

Also, this "evidence" is quite widely used by muslims and piled together with those really suspect "science" facts such as the supposed lack of intermediate evolutionary forms, the alleged tomb of Jesus and similarly wooish "science" that happens to confirm their views... and that too makes me suspicious...
 
There are scientific ways to test nerve sensitivity, skin sensitivity, etc. that are far less subjective than you apparently believe. I have to undergo a number of those tests regularly because of my psoriasis variation... my skin is steadily becoming less sensitive overall, for no apparent reason.

I don't know for certain what methods were used in the study, but I know that there are several methods that can be used, including reading nerve responses to stimuli, observing physical reaction to stimuli, etc.

....


And I usually do walk around with a hard-on from the stimulation of my underwear. Doesn't everyone?

Sensitivity is subjective, as is pain. What you have described are relative measurements for a single individual. Even then the results will be mixed up with a huge number of psychological factors. I.e. you don't "feel" anything until your brain interprets the input(*).

(*) This is not quite true. There is processing in the spinal cord that can initiate quite complicated motor responses. But you don't know about the sensation until the signals have reached you're brain and been processed.
 
But there's no reason to think that it's coming from physicians - i.e. physicians may be recommending that it only be done for medical reasons and people are choosing to ignore their advice in favour of other reasons.

<snip>

What evidence do you have that medical professionals in the US are not telling parents that there is no medical reason to circumcise?

Linda / Katana

I don't have evidence that medical professionals in the US are not telling parents that there is no reason to circumcise.

I have an inference that if they were consistently telling parents there was no medical reason to circumcise their child then the rate would not be so inflated compared to other developed countries.

However, I admit it is a bit of a leap and apologize if this is in fact incorrect:o

Paternalistic medicine usually refers to the physician acting as the decision-maker. Wouldn't the case of a father acting paternalistic be kind of a tautology?

Linda

It would. It sounded good at the time though.

I'm unclear on the ethical position of a doctor facing a request for unrequired surgery on a child from its parents. In my mind the doctor is obliged _not_ to operate on the child. Especially since it is reasonable to assume the patient will be able to decide in the future. I.e., the parents are not advocating for someone who is loosing or has lost the ability to understand or communicate, or making short term life or death decisions that the child cannot make for itself.

Again, the only way I can see around this is if the doctor assumes that the child will be brought up in an environment such that its "free" choice on the issue will likely match whatever the parents think. That just seems a bit back-to-front to me, though.

This doesn't apply for circumcisions performed for increased protection against HIV in regions of the world where HIV is prevalent, because there is a large risk reduction for a deadly disease and there are clear public health benefits.
 
Since the emotional side of the issue is mostly on the part of the "pro-cut" guys, that research is more likely to have been done by them and to show the results they want to hear. "Anti-cut".-s usually don´t give a toss.

Wait--what? Have you been reading this thread? I think you may want to re-evaluate the above claim.
 
Well...
Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin. Look at all the circumcised male porn stars? See much porn with non-curcumcised men? Doubt you could find much.
a) I think circumcised cocks are pretty funny-looking myself. Then again, I don't come from an area where the majority of men are circumcised. Whodathinkit??
b) An erect circumcised penis looks remarkably similar to a non-circumcised one, anyway... and nobody looks at the flaccid cock out of aesthetic interest, now do they.
c) Because we all know that porn stars are the epitome of beauty... especially male porn stars being the epitome of male beauty. Just look at Ron Jeremy!
d) The majority of porn is produced in the USA, which might explain your data - because you probably won't find many circumcised non-American porn stars.

All in all, tongue-in-cheek or not, your statement was just a whole load of bollocks in every way (no pun intended).


But in essence, the foreskin, like other evolutionary holdovers, is not necessary. It's like when people are born with tails, webbing, etc. Clothing makes having a foreskin superfluous.
This analogy is so wrong, I can't help but shake my head. A foreskin might not be essential but it's certainly not useless, and claiming otherwise and comparing it to a tail is sheer intellectual dishonesty.


One could argue forever about the science of it all, but the bottom line still stands. It is woo. It is based on Religion, not science.
Agreed.

And if you don't have a penis, shut the hell up about it.
Oh, sorry.
Well, okay - so long as the men stay out of abortion discussions. :D
 
Wait--what? Have you been reading this thread? I think you may want to re-evaluate the above claim.

Nope... It´s the circumcised posters (in general) who seem to have problems to admit that there might just be some loss of feeling there... Something quite reasonable, anyway, as "Z" himself admitted...
 
Nope... It´s the circumcised posters (in general) who seem to have problems to admit that there might just be some loss of feeling there... Something quite reasonable, anyway, as "Z" himself admitted...

And it's the "anti-cut" people who are trolling other threads (hence the necromancy of this one), accusing people of "barbaric" views, calling people a "sadistic butcher" who should be imprisoned for daring to say they plan on having their kids circumcised, and so forth.

The idea that the "pro-cut" posters are getting "emotional" while the "anti-cut" people don't give a toss is completely at odds with reality.
 
I have an inference that if they were consistently telling parents there was no medical reason to circumcise their child then the rate would not be so inflated compared to other developed countries.

However, I admit it is a bit of a leap and apologize if this is in fact incorrect:o


No prob. :)

I just wanted to assure you that there are a LOT of docs in this country who definitely inform parents that, unless there is a specific medical condition being treated, circumcision is an elective procedure. The vast majority of circs in this country fall into that category.

It is in the best interest of the doc to do this and to make sure that he/she documented that fact lest one of the fortunately-rare-but-very-real complications occurs. It's about informed consent. The consent form that my hospital uses says several times that, despite some studies showing potential future benefit from it, circumcision is at the end of the day an elective procedure with risks.

I doubt that we're unique in the information that we provide. Part of it is a sincere desire to inform parents as completely as possible to the potential risks/benefits of circumcision, but the other is, of course, an effort to address medico-legal concerns.
 
We had my son circumcised when he was born. I guess we just did it because I am circumcised and it is just what everyone does around here. I agree it is absurd and ridiculous. I did think about it a little. I guess part of the reason we had it done is because I read the ridiculous notion that it makes you less prone to certain infections - ridiculous because the risk of infection from the circumcision itself is not trivial. Also, I guess we wanted him not to be different in that respect from everyone else. It is a tremendously stupid custom, but nearly everybody in the US does it. Just another in a long, long list of cultural idiocies. I once saw on the internet that there is a device being marketed which is intended to stretch what is left of your foreskin so that it eventually is something of a foreskin. Well, my dick has had enough trauma for one lifetime.
 
Er, the infant shrieks in agony - a much higher pitched sound than a normal cry for attention - and then subsides, not because they have 'settled down' but because they have gone into shock!

Far from being less traumatic, infant tissue is considerably more sensitive to pain than adult tissue. Just because a new born baby can't regale you with endless stories about how much it hurt doesn't mean it didn't.

I also understand that any studies showing medical benefit from circumcision (eg less chance of urinary infection) have been rather questionable and that international medical organisations have found no conclusive evidence.

I'm astonished that the practice is so widespread in America...
In fairly recent times doctors used to perform major surgical procedures on awake infants using the argument that infants can't really feel pain. It's nauseating and horrifying to contemplate.
 
I'm unclear on the ethical position of a doctor facing a request for unrequired surgery on a child from its parents. In my mind the doctor is obliged _not_ to operate on the child. Especially since it is reasonable to assume the patient will be able to decide in the future. I.e., the parents are not advocating for someone who is loosing or has lost the ability to understand or communicate, or making short term life or death decisions that the child cannot make for itself.

Again, the only way I can see around this is if the doctor assumes that the child will be brought up in an environment such that its "free" choice on the issue will likely match whatever the parents think. That just seems a bit back-to-front to me, though.

What about this makes it unrequired in a way that doesn't make the majority of what we do for our children unrequired?

It is not a simple thing for a physician to refuse to provide service. The physician has to believe that it will not offer a net benefit to the patient, something that would be very difficult to support considering that the available information demonstrates 1) a net benefit to circumcision and 2) a net benefit to neonatal circumcision over and above that provided by circumcision later. This is particularly tricky in the US, and may be an additional contributor to the higher rate of circumcision.

Linda
 
The only actual reasoning that made any sense to me was that parents don't want to clean the boy's part properly. I guess they think hygiene can be considered kinky? But I think that's probably the root reason, others are just cover stories.
While I agree that anything having to do with genitalia in the US is fraught with hysteria (sort of a joke there) and certainly there may be some underlying puritanical cultural stupidity involved, I really doubt that really enters into the motives of individual parents. They have it done because that is what they know and that is what their culture tells them and in the back of their minds they assume there must be some benefit. It doesn't really occur to most folks that the practice is cruel and pointless and irrational.
 
I just realized something.

Are you circumcized, bignickel? Because men who aren't generally don't think the glans is the only part of the penis that gives pleasure. The most sensitive part of the penis, the frenulum, is removed in circumcision.
Oh great! Now you tell me!
 
Regarding infants and UTI's, I'm still waiting for someone to show me a study where they controlled for prematurely born infants who were both too young to be circumcised and who were also more prone to develop UTIs because they were so small and weak. I wouldn't be terribly surprised if there was some small effect there, but I think it's being overstated, at the least. I'm also pretty sure there's probably some genital modification that could be done on infant girls that would reduce their UTI's. That would be silly, though.

With the penile cancer thing...this one makes sense. More penis to get penis cancer--> higher rate of penile cancer. It wouldn't surprise me if HPV "likes" the foreskin. It's a weird reason to advocate RIC, though. I'm sure you could remove large areas of the vagina and get a reduction in vaginal cancer, too.

The HIV thing is "the best" reason to circ, I suppose. I don't think the Langerhans' cells theory is correct, though. In fact, the opposite is probably the case:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=17334373

Langerin is a natural barrier to HIV-1 transmission by Langerhans cells.

Human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) is primarily transmitted sexually. Dendritic cells (DCs) in the subepithelium transmit HIV-1 to T cells through the C-type lectin DC-specific intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-3-grabbing nonintegrin (DC-SIGN). However, the epithelial Langerhans cells (LCs) are the first DC subset to encounter HIV-1. It has generally been assumed that LCs mediate the transmission of HIV-1 to T cells through the C-type lectin Langerin, similarly to transmission by DC-SIGN on dendritic cells (DCs). Here we show that in stark contrast to DC-SIGN, Langerin prevents HIV-1 transmission by LCs. HIV-1 captured by Langerin was internalized into Birbeck granules and degraded. Langerin inhibited LC infection and this mechanism kept LCs refractory to HIV-1 transmission; inhibition of Langerin allowed LC infection and subsequent HIV-1 transmission. Notably, LCs also inhibited T-cell infection by viral clearance through Langerin. Thus Langerin is a natural barrier to HIV-1 infection, and strategies to combat infection must enhance, preserve or, at the very least, not interfere with Langerin expression and function.

But nevertheless, the effect of circumcision preventing HIV seems to be real. But I think the way it works is through herpes sores and other ulcerative genital sores that work in tandem with the HIV virus. That would also explain why female circumcision works to prevent AIDS, too. So if you're going to advocate infant circumcision for HIV prevention, you should really also advocate scientific inquiry into forms of FGM that might work the same way and have the same effect. But that would be silly, too, huh?
 
No prob. :)

I just wanted to assure you that there are a LOT of docs in this country who definitely inform parents that, unless there is a specific medical condition being treated, circumcision is an elective procedure. The vast majority of circs in this country fall into that category.

It is in the best interest of the doc to do this and to make sure that he/she documented that fact lest one of the fortunately-rare-but-very-real complications occurs. It's about informed consent. The consent form that my hospital uses says several times that, despite some studies showing potential future benefit from it, circumcision is at the end of the day an elective procedure with risks.

I doubt that we're unique in the information that we provide. Part of it is a sincere desire to inform parents as completely as possible to the potential risks/benefits of circumcision, but the other is, of course, an effort to address medico-legal concerns.

I think there might be a lot of variation in what happens in different areas of the country?
The OB who saw me though the first part of my delivery actually pressured me to circumcise, and then when it was "time", it was just a nurse who came in with paperwork and asked if I wanted it done. When my best friend gave birth, it was just a nurse with paperwork who spoke with her. She just rattled off the list of possible complications and my friend signed the consent form.
This is in the south, though.
 
I think there might be a lot of variation in what happens in different areas of the country?
The OB who saw me though the first part of my delivery actually pressured me to circumcise, and then when it was "time", it was just a nurse who came in with paperwork and asked if I wanted it done. When my best friend gave birth, it was just a nurse with paperwork who spoke with her. She just rattled off the list of possible complications and my friend signed the consent form.
This is in the south, though.

How long ago was that?

They asked me if we wanted the baby to be circumcised. I said no and that was that (my first boy was born 16 years ago in Minnesota). I think there is likely to be a lot of variation, but I wonder if there is a trend with time.

Linda
 
How long ago was that?

They asked me if we wanted the baby to be circumcised. I said no and that was that (my first boy was born 16 years ago in Minnesota). I think there is likely to be a lot of variation, but I wonder if there is a trend with time.

Linda

It was three years ago that I gave birth, and 8 years ago that my friend did.
I really think it's probably more of a regional thing? In my area, the overall circumcision rate is still around 80%, and I think it's much higher among caucasians.
There's probably a trend with time, as well, but the south is a decade or so behind the north and the west. There's still a very strong religious element to circumcision here in the Bible Belt, too, even if it's down to "God thought of it, so it can't actually be a bad thing."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom