I tend to think it has more to do with culture than the evidence of benefit. Being applied scientists, physicians should evaluate the evidence and recommend either (a) All infants should be circumcised or (b) Infants should be circumcised when it is medically indicated. This would be consistent with all other preventative treatments, including the examples you gave: vaccinations (a/b), braces (b) and tonsillectomies (b).
Isn't (b) the way it is now?
It is interesting to me because you are a physician and a parent in the US.
I've only lived here for a couple of years. I'm mostly Canadian. And Canadians are boring, dontcha know?
Do you think a study would show a risk reduction for the removal of infants’ toenails? From my limited research (and personal experience) it seems to be very effective at treating the problem.
I would suspect that a mass program would demonstrate that the complications would outweigh the benefit. Unless there was some background information to provide some guidelines, you couldn't ethically get this off the ground. The only reason there's been any study with circumcision is because information was available from its use as a cultural practice. There's no way you could have proposed it out-of-the-blue.
I think that the medical professions across the developed world should get their act together and inform parents that very few infant circumcisions are medically indicated and that the rare complications that occur in uncircumcised boys and men can usually be treated without removing the foreskin.
Isn't that already the case?
Clearly, if the number of medically performed circumcisions in Europe is 1-2% and in the US it is 10 to 20 times higher, then one group of medical professionals, to put it bluntly, have their heads in the sand. I believe that it is American physicians who are acting dumb, as they are effectively saying “don’t ask me, it’s up to you” to parents for an easier life.
It is my impression that Americans are much more reluctant to been seen as challenging religious practices, in addition to being much more religious than other developed countries.
I take issue with medical (or other scientific) professionals perpetuating cultural traditions without reasonable medical justification. Isn’t one of the virtues of EBM is that it allows doctors to use their resources effectively and in the best interests of the patient? I wonder if the UK’s EBM review board NICE would see neonatal circumcision as cost effective?
You seem to be straying into a paternalistic view of medicine. I thought we had worked really hard to get away from that?
I don't see medical professionals generally perpetuating this cultural tradition. It's seems to me that further changes would come from cultural change. You could argue that physicians should be more pro-active (which I suppose is the reason for the negative characterizations - "how can you just sit there when parents are mutilating their children in order to satisfy their god-complex!!!"), but maybe it's just a matter of priorities. I really don't know what the typical interaction is between the parents and the physician in the US. Or you're thinking that physicians should be refusing the practice? I think that you'd be on pretty shaky ground on an individual basis, and I'm not sure we can ask individual physicians to bear the risk of laying themselves open to legal attack.
I'll give you an example of my contribution to the "cultural change". I was chatting with my next-door-neighbour and he was wondering whether he should have his 9-year-old son circumcised. The child had been adopted from a country where circumcision rates are low, and his father was thinking that he might feel out of place around circumcised kids. I mentioned that my own son (who frequently would be naked in front of him as they changed into their bathing suits) was uncircumcised so he probably wouldn't feel that out of place. My neighbour was surprised to find out that in most places other than the US, most boys are uncircumcised. He seemed reassured by this information - more willing to consider it not a big deal. Now, I don't know whether or not I made a real difference, but I think I contributed my mote to what I suspect is something that is already changing in the US, similar to what happened decades ago in Canada.
Linda