Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I tend to think it has more to do with culture than the evidence of benefit. Being applied scientists, physicians should evaluate the evidence and recommend either (a) All infants should be circumcised or (b) Infants should be circumcised when it is medically indicated. This would be consistent with all other preventative treatments, including the examples you gave: vaccinations (a/b), braces (b) and tonsillectomies (b).

Isn't (b) the way it is now?

It is interesting to me because you are a physician and a parent in the US.

I've only lived here for a couple of years. I'm mostly Canadian. And Canadians are boring, dontcha know?

Do you think a study would show a risk reduction for the removal of infants’ toenails? From my limited research (and personal experience) it seems to be very effective at treating the problem.

I would suspect that a mass program would demonstrate that the complications would outweigh the benefit. Unless there was some background information to provide some guidelines, you couldn't ethically get this off the ground. The only reason there's been any study with circumcision is because information was available from its use as a cultural practice. There's no way you could have proposed it out-of-the-blue.

I think that the medical professions across the developed world should get their act together and inform parents that very few infant circumcisions are medically indicated and that the rare complications that occur in uncircumcised boys and men can usually be treated without removing the foreskin.

Isn't that already the case?

Clearly, if the number of medically performed circumcisions in Europe is 1-2% and in the US it is 10 to 20 times higher, then one group of medical professionals, to put it bluntly, have their heads in the sand. I believe that it is American physicians who are acting dumb, as they are effectively saying “don’t ask me, it’s up to you” to parents for an easier life.

It is my impression that Americans are much more reluctant to been seen as challenging religious practices, in addition to being much more religious than other developed countries.

I take issue with medical (or other scientific) professionals perpetuating cultural traditions without reasonable medical justification. Isn’t one of the virtues of EBM is that it allows doctors to use their resources effectively and in the best interests of the patient? I wonder if the UK’s EBM review board NICE would see neonatal circumcision as cost effective?

You seem to be straying into a paternalistic view of medicine. I thought we had worked really hard to get away from that?

I don't see medical professionals generally perpetuating this cultural tradition. It's seems to me that further changes would come from cultural change. You could argue that physicians should be more pro-active (which I suppose is the reason for the negative characterizations - "how can you just sit there when parents are mutilating their children in order to satisfy their god-complex!!!"), but maybe it's just a matter of priorities. I really don't know what the typical interaction is between the parents and the physician in the US. Or you're thinking that physicians should be refusing the practice? I think that you'd be on pretty shaky ground on an individual basis, and I'm not sure we can ask individual physicians to bear the risk of laying themselves open to legal attack.

I'll give you an example of my contribution to the "cultural change". I was chatting with my next-door-neighbour and he was wondering whether he should have his 9-year-old son circumcised. The child had been adopted from a country where circumcision rates are low, and his father was thinking that he might feel out of place around circumcised kids. I mentioned that my own son (who frequently would be naked in front of him as they changed into their bathing suits) was uncircumcised so he probably wouldn't feel that out of place. My neighbour was surprised to find out that in most places other than the US, most boys are uncircumcised. He seemed reassured by this information - more willing to consider it not a big deal. Now, I don't know whether or not I made a real difference, but I think I contributed my mote to what I suspect is something that is already changing in the US, similar to what happened decades ago in Canada.

Linda
 
What IS the dorsal side, anyway?

I always wondered about this as well, since depending upon the position, either side can be facing toward the back. I was generally too embarrassed to ask for clarification during class, though.

Linda
 
One question:

Losing nerve endings can make you lose sensitivity?

Or, a man with half a d*ck would feel THE SAME as a man with a whole one? ("The same" as in quantity or quality of the feeling they´d get from stimulation etc.)

Cut guys usually will say that they lose no feeling but I´m rather skeptic about it. Most likely, if they do lose some nerve endings, they do lose SOME sensitivity. And the foreskin is a very sensitive area... Taking the slippery slope, if you take off chunks of d*ck little by little won´t you end up not feeling anything? Would you have different degrees of sensitivity as you keep chopping away? If so, it seems that circuncision alone would result in SOME loss of sensitivity.

But as you try explaining them this (cut guys), they go into a state of denial (it´s understandable, losing a chunk of functional d*ck is quite a tragedy). But guys, react, be brave and admit your wang MIGHT have been slightly insensitized by that unnecessary mutilation! Then we might be able to help those poor l ittle jewish kids!
 
And my son was circumcised because I thought it was better according to the medical evidence, and I've not met a circumcised man that wasn't sexually satisfied and I have no moral qualms whatsoever about my decision. As it turns out, I had not heard of this controversy before I made that decision. However, after an extremely thorough review of the medical literature, I have no regrets about my decision.

That's it! I'm getting snipped! :D
 
Er, the infant shrieks in agony - a much higher pitched sound than a normal cry for attention - and then subsides, not because they have 'settled down' but because they have gone into shock!

Far from being less traumatic, infant tissue is considerably more sensitive to pain than adult tissue. Just because a new born baby can't regale you with endless stories about how much it hurt doesn't mean it didn't.

I also understand that any studies showing medical benefit from circumcision (eg less chance of urinary infection) have been rather questionable and that international medical organisations have found no conclusive evidence.

I'm astonished that the practice is so widespread in America...


I'm wondering what barbaric method you use that causes the baby to shriek so? My boys were all circumcised using the plastibell method, and not one made a single sound for the duration of the application (other than normal infant-related noises). I even watched the procedure in one case, and was absolutely amazed at how calmly he took it (of course, they also used localized anaesthesia, which I fully support).

But much better to inflict such minor pains upon someone who will quickly forget it, than the much greater pain (which will be remembered) of performing the process as an adult.

As for the appendectomy issue, personally I'd remove those neonatally as well, if they served as little function as the foreskin does. As for tonsils, apparently tonsilectomies are vastly overstated; some doctors don't even remove the tonsils now even in cases of tonsilitis, because it can be treated effectively.

The myth about sexual enjoyment is just that. There is no difference in sensitivity and no difference in sexual enjoyment between circumcised and uncircumcised men; the only recognized difference is that a circumcised man has more staying power, generally, than an uncircumcised man. And we could certainly count that as a benefit.

This thread stuns me, though, to see people normally intelligent and skeptical instead reacting like common woos, trying to poo-poo off the benefits of circumcision, while making up indefensible fictions about the risks of the procedure and the importance of the foreskin.

What also stuns me, is the one person who did claim that he was mutilated by doctors, offers absolutely no evidence to support his claim, and appears unwilling to consider the idea that it might not be the surgery in general that mutilated him, but the incompetance of a single doctor. Yet I see the exact same behavior many times in unsatisfied circumcised men - they mention being ruined, yet refuse to say how; they often have wives and children (so they're functional), and aren't seeing any specialists for urinary concerns; and to a man, every one I've ever talked to has refused uncategorically to consider that the problem might be a botched surgery, rather than the nature of the surgery itself!

It's very strange how the penis can so affect the minds of men...
 
Isn't (b) the way it is now?

Around most of the developed world, yes. The fact that the US circumcises so many more infants indicates the reasons there are definitely not based on medical science.

I've only lived here for a couple of years. I'm mostly Canadian. And Canadians are boring, dontcha know?

I like to think of you as polite, intelligent Americans:)

I would suspect that a mass program would demonstrate that the complications would outweigh the benefit. Unless there was some background information to provide some guidelines, you couldn't ethically get this off the ground. The only reason there's been any study with circumcision is because information was available from its use as a cultural practice. There's no way you could have proposed it out-of-the-blue.

We will never know about this potentially beneficial preventative treatment for ingrown toenails.

Isn't that already the case?

Again, around most of the developed world, yes. In the US, medical professionals appear to be either unwilling or scared to tell parents there is no medical reason to circumcise the vast majority of boys. Are they worried about repeat trade?

It is my impression that Americans are much more reluctant to been seen as challenging religious practices, in addition to being much more religious than other developed countries.

I don’t think it’s mainly religious. I think it’s become so routine that Americans don’t see how bizarre it is and because of the pressure to conform, as your recollection below hints at.

You seem to be straying into a paternalistic view of medicine. I thought we had worked really hard to get away from that?

So parents deciding on unnecessary surgical procedures for their child is not paternalistic medicine? I’m all for empowering the patient, who in this case are currently unable to speak for themselves.

However, I suppose you could argue that if the child is going to grow up in a pro-circumcision environment, then the choice of the parent is highly likely to reflect the choice of the child when it is older, just as children typically have the same faith as their parents.

I don't see medical professionals generally perpetuating this cultural tradition. It's seems to me that further changes would come from cultural change. You could argue that physicians should be more pro-active (which I suppose is the reason for the negative characterizations - "how can you just sit there when parents are mutilating their children in order to satisfy their god-complex!!!"), but maybe it's just a matter of priorities. I really don't know what the typical interaction is between the parents and the physician in the US. Or you're thinking that physicians should be refusing the practice? I think that you'd be on pretty shaky ground on an individual basis, and I'm not sure we can ask individual physicians to bear the risk of laying themselves open to legal attack.

With respect to the God complex, as a parent don’t you sometimes feel just a little bit pleased when your kids do as their told? Don’t you bask in the reflected glory from their successes? The God complex comment was supposed to be provocative. However, as I said earlier I think the main reasons are down to social conformity and the belief that everyone else is doing it.

Going back to my toenail analogy, do you think a physician would be open to legal attack for refusing to remove the toenail(s) of a young child because their parents requested it?

I'll give you an example of my contribution to the "cultural change". I was chatting with my next-door-neighbour and he was wondering whether he should have his 9-year-old son circumcised. The child had been adopted from a country where circumcision rates are low, and his father was thinking that he might feel out of place around circumcised kids. I mentioned that my own son (who frequently would be naked in front of him as they changed into their bathing suits) was uncircumcised so he probably wouldn't feel that out of place. My neighbour was surprised to find out that in most places other than the US, most boys are uncircumcised. He seemed reassured by this information - more willing to consider it not a big deal. Now, I don't know whether or not I made a real difference, but I think I contributed my mote to what I suspect is something that is already changing in the US, similar to what happened decades ago in Canada.

Linda

Now he probably just thinks Canadians are weird:D
 
One question:

Losing nerve endings can make you lose sensitivity?

Or, a man with half a d*ck would feel THE SAME as a man with a whole one? ("The same" as in quantity or quality of the feeling they´d get from stimulation etc.)

Cut guys usually will say that they lose no feeling but I´m rather skeptic about it. Most likely, if they do lose some nerve endings, they do lose SOME sensitivity. And the foreskin is a very sensitive area... Taking the slippery slope, if you take off chunks of d*ck little by little won´t you end up not feeling anything? Would you have different degrees of sensitivity as you keep chopping away? If so, it seems that circuncision alone would result in SOME loss of sensitivity.

But as you try explaining them this (cut guys), they go into a state of denial (it´s understandable, losing a chunk of functional d*ck is quite a tragedy). But guys, react, be brave and admit your wang MIGHT have been slightly insensitized by that unnecessary mutilation! Then we might be able to help those poor l ittle jewish kids!


Apparently not. Tests have been conducted, and there's no loss in sensitivity. I know that seems to go against logic, but so does so much science these days.

Most American men are circumcised, and given all the babies born every year in the U.S., I'm guessing circumcised men are plenty enough sensitive to do their duty... :D I've been cut my whole life and never had any problems with sensitivity (above and beyond my own skin condition). I've also never had any problems with infections in that region, or bad odor, or any other foreskin-related problem. And I've never, ever had an unsatisfied sexual partner - indeed, in three cases, they discovered that they preferred, strongly, a cut man to an uncut man - though I personally like to think my techniques won them over, rather than the appearance of the tool.
 
I'm wondering what barbaric method you use that causes the baby to shriek so? My boys were all circumcised using the plastibell method, and not one made a single sound for the duration of the application (other than normal infant-related noises). I even watched the procedure in one case, and was absolutely amazed at how calmly he took it (of course, they also used localized anaesthesia, which I fully support).

But much better to inflict such minor pains upon someone who will quickly forget it, than the much greater pain (which will be remembered) of performing the process as an adult.

As for the appendectomy issue, personally I'd remove those neonatally as well, if they served as little function as the foreskin does. As for tonsils, apparently tonsilectomies are vastly overstated; some doctors don't even remove the tonsils now even in cases of tonsilitis, because it can be treated effectively.

The myth about sexual enjoyment is just that. There is no difference in sensitivity and no difference in sexual enjoyment between circumcised and uncircumcised men; the only recognized difference is that a circumcised man has more staying power, generally, than an uncircumcised man. And we could certainly count that as a benefit.

This thread stuns me, though, to see people normally intelligent and skeptical instead reacting like common woos, trying to poo-poo off the benefits of circumcision, while making up indefensible fictions about the risks of the procedure and the importance of the foreskin.

What also stuns me, is the one person who did claim that he was mutilated by doctors, offers absolutely no evidence to support his claim, and appears unwilling to consider the idea that it might not be the surgery in general that mutilated him, but the incompetance of a single doctor. Yet I see the exact same behavior many times in unsatisfied circumcised men - they mention being ruined, yet refuse to say how; they often have wives and children (so they're functional), and aren't seeing any specialists for urinary concerns; and to a man, every one I've ever talked to has refused uncategorically to consider that the problem might be a botched surgery, rather than the nature of the surgery itself!

It's very strange how the penis can so affect the minds of men...

Would you say you're risk adverse?:D
 
Thought I'd check in to see where this discussion was going and I find no one challenging these claims. You cannot support those false claims. I looked at volumes of research on this.

You are wrong. These claims are not only supportable, they are tautological. If there is at least one circumcision that has complications, and at least one death that results, then my statements are true.

What is the rate of death due to circumcision in circumcised males? What is the rate of death due to circumcision in uncircumcised males? I don't know the former, but the latter is zero.

Notice I never made any claims based on those rate differences. It was only an exercise to demonstrate why using disease rates between circumcised and non-circumcised is not necessarily useful.

Again, how do you compare a 4 fold increase in the rate of penile cancer to an infinite fold in circumcision related deaths? The answer is, you don't. When talking about such small numbers, rate differences aren't the baseline you use. My comment is mostly in response's to Z's statement that it doesn't matter if it is small numbers, wouldn't you do whatever to improve the chances?
 
Apparently not. Tests have been conducted, and there's no loss in sensitivity. I know that seems to go against logic, but so does so much science these days.

Most American men are circumcised, and given all the babies born every year in the U.S., I'm guessing circumcised men are plenty enough sensitive to do their duty... :D I've been cut my whole life and never had any problems with sensitivity (above and beyond my own skin condition). I've also never had any problems with infections in that region, or bad odor, or any other foreskin-related problem. And I've never, ever had an unsatisfied sexual partner - indeed, in three cases, they discovered that they preferred, strongly, a cut man to an uncut man - though I personally like to think my techniques won them over, rather than the appearance of the tool.

How can science look into something as subjective as "sensitivity"? Clearly there is a HUGE psychological component, or men would be walking around with hard-ons from the stimulation of their underwear.
 
Last edited:
How can science look into something as subjective as "sensitivity"? Clearly there is a HUGE psychological component, or men would be walking around with hard-ons from the stimulation of their underware.

There are scientific ways to test nerve sensitivity, skin sensitivity, etc. that are far less subjective than you apparently believe. I have to undergo a number of those tests regularly because of my psoriasis variation... my skin is steadily becoming less sensitive overall, for no apparent reason.

I don't know for certain what methods were used in the study, but I know that there are several methods that can be used, including reading nerve responses to stimuli, observing physical reaction to stimuli, etc.

....


And I usually do walk around with a hard-on from the stimulation of my underwear. Doesn't everyone?
 
This thread stuns me, though, to see people normally intelligent and skeptical instead reacting like common woos, trying to poo-poo off the benefits of circumcision, while making up indefensible fictions about the risks of the procedure and the importance of the foreskin.

It's not the first time in this thread I've seen this accusation, and to be honest it gets old real fast. Being critical of your position does not equate to woo. If you look closer, my position, and that of several others here, are arrived at in a rational fashion - we're not claiming the foreskin is magic.

Regarding "poo-pooing off" the benefits, that's not at all what I am doing (can only speak for myself). I'm just saying that circumcision doesn't prevent any problems that aren't trivial to treat, except for phimosis and the like, where the surgical correction is either - you guessed it - circumcision or closely resembling it. Is there any other minor, easily corrected condition affecting ~1% of the population you would advocate preventive surgery for? With HIV, would you argue that (in a developed nation), the only preventive measure that should be taken is circumcising all males?

Regarding the "indefensible fictions", it's easy to declare opposing arguments as such. Care to list a couple, and why they're indefensible?

As you note, this is a hot button topic. It's hard to speak out against circumcision in a culture where it's common, because you're criticising something directly applicable to your audience's sexuality, and by extension their parents.

I don't know about the others here, but I'm not doing this to claim superiority. I'm not doing it to say there's something wrong with anyone who's circumcised. I'm not saying circumcision is crippling, sexually. I'm not even saying it's a big deal.

What I am saying is that some data indicates that the foreskin is functional, and that it's generally not well understood. From this information I argue that one should think twice before removing it, since it can't be reattached.
 
This thread moves too fast.

Z, Disregard my request that you address the "indifensible fictions" above - I see you've engaged them in the mean time.

I might have a reply for the sensitivity issue later.
 
Last edited:
True, but I'm arguing that this is inconsequiential, seeing as one state (uncircumcised) is 100% reversible and the other is not. So, the (my guess) relatively few adults that wish they'd had it done as infants can still get it done at the expense of some discomfort, while the already circumcised adults who wish they weren't can never get full functionality back.

They can get it done as infants as adults? There have been effects that change based on when it is done, and the question was how many would want it done as infants not how many would want it done as adults. Between the pain and temporary sexual dysfunction that is enough to discourage people.

I see the appeals to emotion on both sides. And yes, principle, the one about being allowed to choose, plays a part in my stance on this, but there's also the very pragmatic wish to err on the side of caution - in the case of my (hypothetical) newborn son, he'll hopefully have much better data in 18 years, and can make a more informed decision.
But which side is the side of caution? If someone said "well the link between autism and vaccination is questionable best err on the side of caution" but the side of caution in both cases involves an irreversible treatment that the person can never go back to a "natural" condition.

The strong opinions seem to be entirely emotion based.


I don't quite follow this. But I think I can try for a more clear statement of my own position:

- If it ain't broken, don't fix it.
- If you want to fix it, despite the data being unclear, the benefits of doing so small, the drawbacks of doing so not well examined, the procedure a risk (albeit small), be sure it's your own foreskin you fix, not someone else's.

So you are for the practice of circumcision because as a common practice if that is "broken" is the basis of your argument or an appeal to "natural" being the preferred state.

The if it ain't broke don't fix is just as much an appeal to maintain the status quo as it is to preserve the natural state of man. Most people here do not automatically assume "natural"=Better very much but that seems to be at the heart of these debates.
 
Z: [ I'm guessing circumcised men are plenty enough sensitive to do their duty... :D QUOTE]

Yes, you could manage even with half a d*ck, but don´t you get the nagging doubt that perhaps us with the beatleneck are getting (a bit) more satisfaction out of our willies? :p

And thanks for admitting there is some logic to what I said...

(what did I do wrong with the quoting thingy?)
 
Last edited:
Indeed it can, to some degree.



What / how do you propose we use this in research?


I meant, for personal research, of course... studying the available literature, analysing the pros and cons...

The Wiki article suggests to me that it's more cosmetic/psychological, though from what I can tell, that's about the same extent of the damage caused by circumcision, so it would be functionally equivalent.

However, it also appears inadequate at best, so at this point I certainly wouldn't use it to support the idea that adults have the choice of 'uncircumcising'.

Still, this is merely a Wiki article. So more (personal) research is indicated.
 
Yes, you could manage even with half a d*ck, but don´t you get the nagging doubt that perhaps us with the beatleneck are getting (a bit) more satisfaction out of our willies? :p

Absolutely not. I'm quite satisfied with the satisfaction I get with my trouser snake. In fact, I'm rather alarmed at the idea that it might have been larger with the foreskin, since it's already rather larger than some women like or can endure. (I'm probably the only non-abnormal-sized male who has considered penile reduction surgery...) And I'm quite please in that, living in a culture that considers foreskins ugly, my John Thomas has a higher chance of being considered desirable - and therefore, a better chance of scoring. Plus, no unpleasant Smegma aroma or taste.

So no nagging doubts there. My ONLY complaint about my Monkey is that it's slightly too large for the comfort and complete pleasure of those I regularly use it with.

And thanks for admitting there is some logic to what I said...

Well, there is, it just happens to run counter to evidence.

(what did I do wrong with the quoting thingy?)

Somehow you erased part of the first quote box, I think.
 
Z: [ I'm guessing circumcised men are plenty enough sensitive to do their duty... :D QUOTE] <snip>
(what did I do wrong with the quoting thingy?)

OK, the opening code should look like this: [quote=Z]
The closing code is simply: [/quote]

See?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom