Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Please, Functions of the Foreskin (The last ones are pretty funny).

The foreskin is just as functional as female parts. And your "unattractive" comment just reveals more cultural bias.
I admit to the cultural bias and as I said, it would never be a deal breaker.

Re the other benefits of the foreskin on your link, a lot of them were close enough to redundancy to be redundant. But as far as these go:
Stores pheromones and releases them on arousal

In infancy, protects the urethra against contamination, meatal stenosis, (and UTIs?)

Provides lysosomes for bacteriostatic action around the glans

Provides skin for grafts to burnt eyelids, reconstructive surgery, etc.Provides skin for grafts to burnt eyelids, reconstructive surgery, etc.
Show me the evidence of pheromones and lysosomes and evidence those chemicals are not produced elsewhere in the body. The protection against UTIs is contradicted by the evidence. The source of eyelid replacement is interesting. But it couldn't possibly be more important than HIV prevention in areas with high rates of HIV.
 

[to alternative treatments]

How can you seriously say that there are no alternatives to circumcision for the risks it reduces?

The relatively tiny amount of men circumcised in the UK and Europe are evidence that the medical professions here have figured out ways to deal with these problems effectively.
 
Here are my posts from the last thread we had on this discussion which had sources cited in them. Many of the people posting here have already addresses these posts. Go to the original thread to see those replies and my subsequent replies. And, I did not edit my replies in these so they are likely to not be following the direction of this thread. The posts are to provide sources for the above statements.

Post #137

CDC: Male Circumcision and Risk for HIV Transmission: Implications for the United States
After adjusting for confounding factors in the population-based studies, the relative risk for HIV infection was 44% lower in circumcised men. The strongest association was seen in high-risk men, such as patients at sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinics, for whom the adjusted relative risk was 71% lower for circumcised men.
In an ideal world you would have never had this pandemic in the first place. We can't even educate the population in this country that evolution theory is not in doubt and you would solve the HIV pandemic by adding more resources to addressing education access? Do you not think this is also being addressed? Think if all the resources available were put into other measures then circs wouldn't need to be added to the repertoire? You'd be wrong. To take from kelly's posts, "the world just doesn't work that way".


Post #138

Well, I started off looking at the meatal stenosis issue from kelly's posts. I'm not one to defend a position when the evidence supports otherwise, (about the complication rate, not about the recommendation to circ boys in high HIV-AIDS prevalence areas which has clear support.) The Emed link from kellyb had the following supporting citations. Keep in mind, the Emed article was for meatal stenosis, not circumcision in general.

Incidence of meatal stenosis following neonatal circumcision in a primary care setting; Clin Pediatr (Phila). 2006
The diagnosis was made in 24 of 329 circumcised boys who were Tanner I development and older than 3 years of age (7.29%, 95%CI=4.48-10.10%). Nearly all required meatotomy to resolve their symptoms. All of the boys with meatal stenosis were circumcised neonatally (exact OR=3.54, 95%CI=0.62-infinity). The ratio of circumcised boys to noncircumcised boys in this study provided 80% power to demonstrate a 21.4% difference in the incidence of meatal stenosis between circumcised and noncircumcised Tanner I boys 3 years and older. Meatal stenosis may be the most common complication following neonatal circumcision. The frequency of this complication and the need for surgical correction need to be disclosed as part of the informed consent for neonatal circumcision. A careful meatal examination is indicted in any circumcised boy with abdominal or urinary complaints.
Circumcision for phimosis: a follow-up study; Scand J Urol Nephrol. 1986
It is concluded that circumcision for phimosis in young boys is complicated by meatal stenosis in a certain frequency (13/117) but not loaded with serious complications. There seems to be no reason to fear psychological disturbances due to circumcision.
Both of those articles have pretty small sample sizes. It isn't clear but it looks like the populations are self selected in both cases since that's typical for a small sample and no mention of randomization is made which is normally mentioned in the abstract when it is done. And the CDC data differed so I soldiered on looking for more data.

Risks Associated with Male Circumcision from the CDC
Reported complication rates depend on the type of study (e.g., chart review vs. prospective study), setting (medical vs. nonmedical facility), person operating (traditional vs. medical practitioner), patient age (infant vs. adult), and surgical technique or instrument used. The most common complications are minor bleeding and local infection. In large studies of infant circumcision in the U.S., complications rates range from 0.2 to 2.0% [2]. In the recently completed South African study of adult circumcision by general medical practitioners in their surgical offices, the overall complication rate was 3.8%. The most commonly reported complications were pain (0.8%), followed by swelling or hematoma, bleeding, and problems with appearance (each 0.6%). Damage to the penis (0.3%), infection (0.2%), and delayed wound healing (0.1%) were uncommon. There were no reported deaths or problems with urination [10].

[2]Alanis MC, Lucidi RS. Neonatal circumcision: a review of the world’s oldest and most controversial operation. Obstet Gynecol Surv. 2004 May;59(5):379-95.

[10]Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, Puren A. Randomized, Controlled Intervention Trial of Male Circumcision for Reduction of HIV Infection Risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial. PLoS Med. 2005 Nov;2(11):e298.
That wasn't sufficient so I looked for the source of the figures and found Report of the Task Force on Circumcision; American Academy of Pediatrics
The exact incidence of postoperative complications is unknown,(50) but large series indicate that the rate is low, approximately 0.2% to 0.6%.(44,45,51,52) The most common complications are local infection and bleeding. Deaths attributable to newborn circumcision are rare; there were no deaths in 500 000 circumcisions in New York City (52) or in 175,000 circumcisions in US Army hospitals.(51) A communication published in 1979 reported one death in the United States due to circumcision in 1973, and the authors’ review of the literature during the previous 25 years documented two previous deaths due to this procedure.(53)

Complications due to local anesthesia are rare and consist mainly of hematomas and local skin necrosis.(41,46-49,54) However, even a small dose of lidocaine can result in blood levels high enough to produce measurable systemic responses in neonates.(55,56) Local anesthesia adds an element of risk and data regarding its use have not been reported in large numbers of cases. Circumferential anesthesia may be hazardous. It would be prudent to
obtain more data from large controlled series before advocating local anesthesia as an integral part of newborn circumcision. When considering circumcision of their infant son, parents should be fully informed of the possible benefits and potential risks of newborn circumcision, both with and without local anesthesia.
But that wasn't full of original data either and the citations didn't offer a lot so I went looking for more. So now I have to admit maybe I was wrong. ;) Circs for HIV prevention benefit might be worthwhile in areas with low HIV-AIDS prevalence after all. And, they should be considered as well to prevent cancer and serious complications from urinary tract infections.

Benefits of newborn circumcision: is Europe ignoring medical evidence? Edgar J Schoen
When properly done, newborn circumcision is a quick, simple procedure with a low complication rate. Morbidity and costs of circumcision are much lower for newborns than they are for older patients.6,7

Moreover, about 70 million circumcised US males currently attest to the lack of effect of circumcision on either emotional health or sexual performance, and no objective studies indicate otherwise. As a matter of fact, evidence indicates that women in Middle America have a sexual preference for circumcised men, mainly from the standpoint of aesthetics and hygiene.33

The multiple benefits of newborn circumcision are additive over a lifetime and include prevention of cancer of the penis, of balanoposthitis, and protection against the effects of phimosis and poor hygiene as well as prevention of UTI and STD, particularly of HIV. Protection against these diseases constitutes a substantial public health advantage and provides a strong argument in favour of instituting universal newborn circumcision in Europe. With AIDS spreading rapidly in developed Western countries in persons who practice heterosexual behaviour as well as in men who practice homosexual behaviour, implementation of universal circumcision beginning with Europe is prudent and timely.
There are scores of additional citations including this very large study, Risks From Circumcision During the First Month of Life Compared With Those for Uncircumcised Boys; Thomas E. Wiswell MC, USA1 and Dietrich W. Geschke MC, USA1; 1 The Medical Research Fellowship, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Washington, DC
The records of 136,086 boys born in US Army hospitals from 1980 to 1985 were reviewed for indexed complications related to circumcision status during the first month of life. For 100,157 circumcised boys, there were 193 complications (0.19%). These included 62 local infections, eight cases of bacteremia, 83 incidences of hemorrhage (31 requiring ligature and three requiring transfusion), 25 instances of surgical trauma, and 20 urinary tract infections. There were no deaths or reported losses of the glans or entire penis. By contrast, the complications in the 35,929 uncircumcised infants were all related to urinary tract infections. Of the 88 boys with such infections (0.24%), 32 had concomitant bacteremia, three had meningitis, two had renal failure, and two died. The frequencies of urinary tract infection (P < .0001) and bacteremia (P < .0002) were significantly higher in the uncircumcised boys. Serious complications from routine prepuce removal are rare and relatively minor. Circumcision may be beneficial in reducing the occurrence of urinary tract infections and their associated sequelae.
So while there were 3 deaths possibly (we don't have the information to decide) related to circs in 25 years, there were none resulting from circs and 2 clearly associated with not getting circs in 5 years in the very large study here. And penile cancer is an additional risk not included in the time frame of the study.

You have to wonder why there are so few male physicians writing about the loss of sexual sensation and almost no mention of the complication in the research. With the expected number of men physicians and researchers, it is very curious. I'm beginning to think the evidence for this loss of pleasure is slimmer than one would think given the activism surrounding the issue.

Prepuce presence portends prevalence of potentially perilous periurethral pathogens.This link is to a MetaAnalysis with no abstract, PubMed. I just posted it for the cute name.

And this one was in the bib. of the Shoen article. I didn't look for a link but I couldn't resist:
33. Williamson ML, Williamson PS. Women's preferences for penile circumcision in sexual partners. Journal of Sex Education and Therapy 1988 Fall/Winter;14(2):9-12.

Sorry boys, what can I say.


Post #143

In answer to your question, Ivor, how can I say condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them, well access is a funny thing. It would be nice if you could just put those condoms with instructions on a boat and ship 'em where needed. But it isn't that simple.

Just look at the countries where access to these things are actually not too difficult to gage if the problem would be solved if only they had access:

The 25 states that track HIV cases are reporting an increase in new diagnoses, a striking change from the 1990s when the number of new infections remained stable at about 40,000 a year.

The HIV infection rate has doubled among blacks in the United States over a decade

A story in the Toronto Star reports that rates of new HIV infections in Candian young women have soared since 1996.

Then you can look at the real vs the ideal world beyond Western countries:

Global HIV rates at record high
Quote:
Around 14,000 people are infected with HIV every day
A record number of people were infected with HIV around the world this year, a report says.

Figures from UNAids and the World Health Organization put the number of new infections at five million.

The report also estimates that three million people died from the disease this year.

But it warns that the figures could rise sharply in the years ahead, with Eastern Europe and Central Asia on the verge of epidemics.

Africa hit hardest

The report, which is published ahead of World Aids Day on 1 December, estimates 40 million people around the world are infected with HIV/Aids. Of these, 2.5 million are children.

Russia's Aids timebomb
Around 14,000 people are infected with the disease every day.

Officials say the figures are more reliable than previous year's estimates, following improvements in the way the data is collected.

People living in sub-Saharan Africa continue to be most at risk. About 26.6m people are living with HIV/Aids are in this part of the world.

South Africa, alone, is home to 5.3 million people with HIV - more than any other country in the world. In Botswana, 39% of the population is HIV positive, the report says.

As to your assumptions about why circumcision is now going to be recommended, just who do you mean by "the US"? I'm curious who you think it is that has this power. Perhaps you envision some committee designated to come up with the cheapest way to treat HIV-AIDS in Africa. When you figure it out, let me know. I'd love to lobby them about the misguided ideas of the morality police.

The US donates like everyone else to the Global AIDS fund. Other countries and NGOs have done what they could to minimize the impact of the US AIDS fund donations since we have attached so many rules to the money. Particularly bad are the gag rules. If you take the money they want to see a ban on any discussion of anything to do with abortion. Because of that a couple of countries have even turned down US aid. It was earmarked for programs they felt were ineffective anyway.

So if you want to blame the US, you need to place the blame where it belongs, with the right wing Evangelicals who interfere with HIV-AIDS prevention programs to meet their own needs first.

I suggest you travel more if you get the chance. You might be surprised to know the US is not in control of the rest of the world in quite the way it seems you have pictured. It isn't up to the US to tell the countries on the African Continent how they should lower their HIV-AIDS risk. And for the moment, that's a good thing since we have those pesky church people in our government telling everyone sex is a sin and they should abstain or just suffer God's wrath.

You are correct in that money is an issue and we have enough of it we really should share more. The US pressures governments not to produce low cost anti-retrovirals that aren't off patents. That's another one of those dilemmas. If you wipe out drug company profits, you will have to find other ways to fund research. My assessment of the situation is the profits are currently obscene and the companies could stand to give up some in order to help so many desperate people.

So put pressure on the drug companies. They actually respond if they get enough pressure. When they smell the regulators coming or the frustrated third world governments threaten to make the drugs themselves, the drug companies start donating free drugs to poor countries. Write letters, send emails, make phone calls wherever you think some action might be useful. Don't just gripe about it. (Maybe you are an activist?) You can even donate time and money.

Keep something else in mind. If we spent a fraction of the money that's needed for HIV-AIDS just providing potable drinking water and basic vaccines to the third world, we be saving many more people than HIV will kill. Not that I suggest we only fund one of those, but if you think this whole circumcision thing is just about a cheaper treatment, you are quite misguided.

Hey, when those replaceable parts are ready to go, I'll be the first in line. I have no qualms taking advantage of the incredible medical discoveries we should be seeing in the next few decades.


Post #254

This evidence has a glaring problem, there is no comparison with women in a more sexually permissive society to establish if the "the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse" is sufficient to detect a difference between "cut and uncut" women in the study.

Here's the actual abstract:

The association between female genital cutting and correlates of sexual and gynaecological morbidity in Edo State, Nigeria.
Quote:
POPULATION: 1836 healthy premenopausal women [attending family planning and antenatal clinics at three hospitals in Edo State, South-south Nigeria.]

RESULTS:Forty-five percent were circumcised and 71% had type 1, while 24% had type 2 female genital cutting. No significant differences between cut and uncut women were observed in the frequency of reports of sexual intercourse in the preceding week or month, the frequency of reports of early arousal during intercourse and the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse.

In contrast, cut women were 1.25 times more likely to get pregnant at a given age than uncut women. Uncut women were significantly more likely to report that the clitoris is the most sexually sensitive part of their body (OR = 0.35, 95% CI = 0.26-0.47), while cut women were more likely to report that their breasts are their most sexually sensitive body parts (OR = 1.91; 95% CI = 1.51-2.42).

CONCLUSION: Female genital cutting in this group of women did not attenuate sexual feelings
You have no mention of what percentage of women reported orgasm at all. You have women with complete removal of the clitoris stating their breasts were the site of most sexual stimulation.

If the claim is being made here that women can achieve orgasm equally from nipple stimulation as from clitoral stimulation I'd say that's doubtful. This study certainly doesn't provide evidence of that fact without some documentation of how many of the women in the sample achieve orgasm, cut or not. Many adult women have not experienced orgasm at all. In sexually repressive societies, who knows what the experience of women commonly is. Perhaps there is additional research on the matter.

Diagram from Wiki showing type 1 & 2 cutting

I did a brief search for rates of female orgasm by age and culture but it looks like it will take more time to find appropriate research addressing the question I posed. I did find the following but as an abstract the sources cited supporting the conclusions aren't available.

Medical dangers of female circumcision
Quote:
Psychosexual complications [of fgm] include a feeling of reduced feminity; diminished desire for coitus; diminished coital frequency; dyspareunia, apareunia or vaginismus; lack of orgasm; anal intercourse; depression and psychotic states; and, social problems.
-
 
Last edited:
[to alternative treatments]

How can you seriously say that there are no alternatives to circumcision for the risks it reduces?

The relatively tiny amount of men circumcised in the UK and Europe are evidence that the medical professions here have figured out ways to deal with these problems effectively.
Without data, "effectively" becomes relative. I'm sure in the UK, it is reasonable to recommend to a parent who is opposed to circumcision that they use alternative measures and indeed they should have a similar result as with a circumcised child.

But this is the problem. It is common to assume all parents are equal, capable and willing. It is easy to assume all kids have the same health and all environments those children will be living are similar. It's the same assumptions those judgmental parents who believe we should teach abstinence only to every child make. It's the same assumption many people in this thread are making about the means of preventing HIV. It's an egocentric view.

So while there are alternatives available to some children, it would be stupid to think those alternatives are realistic in every child's situation.
 
I'm wondering if the risk-benefit for appendix removal these days is of similar scale to that of circumcision. Keyhole surgery today is much less risky, and balanced against the chances of serious effects from ruptured appendices seems to be a good thing.

Why don't those who circumcise their boys - who claim its inspired on the grounds of health reasons also get their sons' appendices removed?

Athon
 
I'm wondering if the risk-benefit for appendix removal these days is of similar scale to that of circumcision. Keyhole surgery today is much less risky, and balanced against the chances of serious effects from ruptured appendices seems to be a good thing.

Why don't those who circumcise their boys - who claim its inspired on the grounds of health reasons also get their sons' appendices removed?

Athon
Because the risk benefit analysis is not the same.
 
Circumcision is much less traumatic and much easier when performed on an infant than with an adult.

Er, the infant shrieks in agony - a much higher pitched sound than a normal cry for attention - and then subsides, not because they have 'settled down' but because they have gone into shock!

Far from being less traumatic, infant tissue is considerably more sensitive to pain than adult tissue. Just because a new born baby can't regale you with endless stories about how much it hurt doesn't mean it didn't.

I also understand that any studies showing medical benefit from circumcision (eg less chance of urinary infection) have been rather questionable and that international medical organisations have found no conclusive evidence.

I'm astonished that the practice is so widespread in America...
 
Because the risk benefit analysis is not the same.

How's that? There is a slightly increased risk of penile cancer (extremely rare to begin with) and UTI (hardly life threatening, but still unpleasant) matched with a slight risk of complications and pain from the circumcision.

With appendectomy, the risk of complications is slightly higher, but so is the relative risk of appendicitus (matched against the much lower risk of penile cancer).

HIV risk doesn't count here as that's something the child can determine for themselves when they reach an age of sexual maturity (which by then they should have learned how to use a damn condom).

Therefore, if the parents are really worried about their child's health so they remove a 'useless' bit of skin, they might as well match the greater odds of getting appendicitus by having the appendix removed as well.

Athon
 
This citation is out of date. It cites the That indicates the conclusions are also out of date.I do believe all the "may result"s are now confirmed though I'll have to recheck on the cancer risk. The last statement, "there is no absolute medical indication", is flat wrong.

You also make a lot of false statements.

Not all the may results have been confirmed.

Also the HIV-prevention is not as clear cut as you and other make it out to be.

http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/HIV/ is an update-to-date and seemingly unbiased report on the research done on HIV and circumcision.

While indeed all studies in Africa between circumsized and uncircumsized men show a positive correlation between circumcision and preventing HIV infection, the research done in Europe and America has been THE OTHER WAY AROUND.

STDs and HIV in the western world are more prevalent amongst circumsized men than uncircumsized men.

America is the western country where circumcision is most common, it's also the western country with the highest HIV-infection rate. However correlation is not causation (if that makes sense, not native speaker, sorry). Still it gives some indication that mass circumcision is not really a solution.

Something that has been shown BOTH in Africa and in the western studies is the fact that HIV-transfer for male-to-female is higher for circumsized men.

Something that's also often ignored is that circumcision in Africa is a cultural thing, those different cultures may also have distinctly different sexual morale etc.. All in all there is simply not enough evidence to say circumcision prevents HIV-transfer, in fact, the opposite seems to be the case in those countries with a high degree of personal hygiene. But there's also not enough evidence to state the latter with a degree of certainty.

-=-=-=-
Back to the point of wether it's relevant that the conclusions about circumcision and health benefits are post-hoc.

Yes it's very important, the difference are extremely small, and if you look generally for effects, you're datamining.

This means that you will always find something, you should NEVER draw conclusions from that, this kind of research is only useful for determining what to test.

As far as I can tell the penial cancer claims have not been followed up by actual research TESTING the effect.

It's much the same with the other claims...

Hey here we find UTI rates are down... let's claim that as an advantage...

Here the penial cancer is down, let's claim that as an advantage etc...

These are at best starting points, at worst the effects dissappear completely when all the tests are added up...
 
I remember Howard Stern going off against circumcision. With him being Jewish, it was interesting radio. His own Dad was on the air ranting at him about it.

http://www.sexuallymutilatedchild.org/stern.htm

It is about religion, nothing else. Circumcision is woo. I can't imagine anyone with a clue defending such a barbaric ritual.
 
I am going by my extensive review of the medical literature. There is unequivocal evidence HIV risk is decreased considerably. The other medical benefits are small but favor circumcision. Look over the sources I cited.

If you have current sources that come to different conclusions, post them. I am an evidence based health care provider. Evidence is always subject to mount in wavering directions. The most current research (not opinions now, but research) favors circumcision in terms of pure medical outcome.

When the risk of HIV is low, the benefit of circumcision is not large enough to mean one should recommend it over the parent's wishes. OTOH, for a completely neutral parent, you tell them what the medical research shows and discuss what some people believe about the negative effects on sexual pleasure. From there it is a individual choice.

If the child is at high risk of HIV exposure then I would highly recommend circumcision to the parents. Kids have sex before they become responsible decision makers. It's simply a fact of life.
 
Male circumcision overstated as prevention tool against AIDS

In new academic research published today in the online, open-access, peer-reviewed scientific journal PLoS ONE, male circumcision is found to be much less important as a deterrent to the global AIDS pandemic than previously thought. The author, John R. Talbott, has conducted statistical empirical research across 77 countries of the world and has uncovered some surprising results.

http://www.physorg.com/news101559563.html

Circumcision does away with the most sensitive parts of the penis

June 16 : A new study has found that what boys lose in the process of circumcision turns out to be the most sensitive parts of the penis.

The long-term-health impact of neo-natal circumcision has received little study, while the consequences of circumcision on sexual function in the adult male have received even less attention.

(more at link)

http://www.ebiologynews.com/2154.html

One could argue forever about the science of it all, but the bottom line still stands. It is woo. It is based on Religion, not science.

And if you don't have a penis, shut the hell up about it.






heh
 
I guess it depends upon how strongly physicians feel about their role in shaping cultural traditions? Or maybe it reflects the fact that we all tend to be products of our environment? The idea that physicians can refuse requests for treatment is relatively recent. I'm trying to think of something relatively equivalent....maybe growth hormone supplementation?

I tend to think it has more to do with culture than the evidence of benefit. Being applied scientists, physicians should evaluate the evidence and recommend either (a) All infants should be circumcised or (b) Infants should be circumcised when it is medically indicated. This would be consistent with all other preventative treatments, including the examples you gave: vaccinations (a/b), braces (b) and tonsillectomies (b).

Why is this of interest to you? My personal threshold is quite low, but my public threshold is much higher. I tend to be someone that is reluctant to impose my opinions onto others, so I usually require a moderately strong reason to do so. Plus my ethical consideration of others is strongly influenced by medical ethics, which promotes more of a hands-off, self-autonomy attitude than is usually acceptable to the general public.

It is interesting to me because you are a physician and a parent in the US.

Not if it's life or seriously health-threatening.

Maybe. It really depends upon the nature of the harm. I use a hierarchy of death, disability, disease, discomfort, dissatisfaction. I think that in most cases, I would find the first three adequate reasons to interfere. The last two would depend upon the details.

If this were a general practice, there should be research performed to look at the overall benefit (i.e. advantages and disadvantages).

Do you think a study would show a risk reduction for the removal of infants’ toenails? From my limited research (and personal experience) it seems to be very effective at treating the problem.

I don't know why you'd be interested in my limit except to show that it's unreasonable. I'm perfectly willing to concede that you think I'm unreasonable to save you the trouble.

You are one of the most reasonable people I converse with. I was more interested to find out if I was being unreasonable. I'm perfectly willing to concede that you think I'm unreasonable to save you the trouble:)

So the state should intervene? Or at the very least, we should be able to brand the parents with a scarlet M (for Mutilator)?

Linda

We don’t need to do that: We know who they are by looking at their child’s penis:D

I think that the medical professions across the developed world should get their act together and inform parents that very few infant circumcisions are medically indicated and that the rare complications that occur in uncircumcised boys and men can usually be treated without removing the foreskin.

Clearly, if the number of medically performed circumcisions in Europe is 1-2% and in the US it is 10 to 20 times higher, then one group of medical professionals, to put it bluntly, have their heads in the sand. I believe that it is American physicians who are acting dumb, as they are effectively saying “don’t ask me, it’s up to you” to parents for an easier life.

I take issue with medical (or other scientific) professionals perpetuating cultural traditions without reasonable medical justification. Isn’t one of the virtues of EBM is that it allows doctors to use their resources effectively and in the best interests of the patient? I wonder if the UK’s EBM review board NICE would see neonatal circumcision as cost effective?
 
Someguy, if you expect to convince a skeptic and a health care provider, this kind of crap is not helpful. This kind of crap pisses me off. I am more than willing to look at evidence but not woo type distortions of what the evidence actually says. The following conclusion citing the following evidence is absurd. Here is the very first research they cite.

It is documented that circumcised adult males exhibit a greater tendency to engage in risky sexual behavior. Hooykaas and colleagues reported that circumcised men in the Netherlands engage in more risky sexual behavior and have markedly higher rates of STDs.

RESULTS: Besides STD-related complaints, ethnicity was an important independent predictor of one or more diagnosed genital STDs. STD-prevalence was higher among men born in Turkey (47%, OR = 3.4) and men born in Surinam (36%, OR = 2.1), compared with Dutch men (21%). While Turkish men had mainly riskful sexual behaviour with prostitutes, Surinam men had more often riskful sexual contact with private partners. Among women, STD prevalence was higher among West-European (38%, OR = 2.3) and Latin-American women (30%, OR = 1.6), compared with Dutch women (21%). Latin American women had more often riskful sexual contact with clients; sexual behaviour of West-European women was riskful with both clients and private partners.

CIRP says
[CIRP Note: This study is significant because Dutch men are usually non-circumcised intact males, but immigrant men from Turkey and Surinam are Muslims, who are usually circumcised for religious reasons.
This is a clear attempt to find evidence supporting a cause rather than looking at the evidence and concluding what it means. Why should we expect two completely different cultures to only differ by their circumcisions?

I'll keep looking but your source had already proven itself to be BS.
 
Last edited:
CIRCUMCISION IN THE UNITED STATES
Objective. - To assess the prevalence of circumcision across various social groups and examine the health and sexual outcomes of circumcision.

Main Outcome Measures. - The contraction of sexually transmitted diseases, the experience of sexual dysfunction, and experience with a series of sexual practices.

Results. - We find no significant differences between circumcised and uncircumcised men in their likelihood of contracting sexually transmitted diseases. However uncircumcised men appear slightly more likely to to experience sexual dysfunctions, especially later in life. Finally, we find that circumcised men engage in a more elaborated set of sexual practices. This pattern differs across ethnic groups, suggesting the influence of social factors.
Why on Earth would circumcision determine the "set of sexual practices" one engaged in? It is very likely any differences in sexual behaviors are going to be related to culture, with circumcision being much more coincidental than causal. Without an alternate explanation it is hard to believe their interpretation of the evidence.

Conclusions. - The National Health and Social Life Survey evidence indicates a slight benefit of circumcision but a negligible association with most outcomes. These findings inform existing debates on the utility of circumcision. The considerable impact of circumcision status on sexual practice represents a new finding that should further enrich such discussion. Our results support the view that physicians and parents be informed of the potential benefits and risks before circumcising newborns.
A benefit in circumcision?

Differences in circumcision levels across racial and ethnic groups are more revealing. In particular, whites are considerably more likely to be circumcised than are blacks or Hispanics (81% vs 65% or 54%). These differences remain significant when other variables are controlled. Net of these factors, the odds of a black being circumcised are roughly half (95% confidence interval[CI], 0.40-0.85) that of whites; the odds for Hispanics are about one third (95% CI, 0.26-0.44) that of whites. There has been some convergence in circumcision rates for the 3 groups across cohorts, though differences among groups have persisted (Table 1).
So culture differs along with rates of circumcision. Then you have to distinguish between culture and circumcision. You cannot assume circumcision causes any specific behaviors without controlling for cultural differences.

Table 2 compares the incidence of various STDs reported by circumcised and uncircumcised respondents. I'm not convinced by the data given the previous interpretations, but assuming the data is correct, they are claiming all STDs are lower in uncircumcised men. But they fail to mention the glaring difference in HIV infection in their own data: All men, rate per 1,000, circumcised 1.0; uncircumcised, 5.4. Instead they point out the non-statistically different results:
Several instructive features of the data presented in Table 2 deserve attention. First, circumcision status does not appear to lower the likelihood of contracting an STD. Rather, the opposite pattern holds. Circumcised men were slightly more likely to have had both a bacterial and a viral STD in their lifetime. While these differences are not statistically significant,
If they aren't statistically significant, why are they reporting them as if they were?

But the following conclusion is even more biased.
Table 2 shows a marked decrease in the experience of STDs as the number of partners increases. The small, nonsignificant tendency for circumcised men to contract STDs at greater rates appeared for each category of sexual experience. In addition, contraction of bacterial STDs occurred at a significantly greater rate for men who have had more than 20 sex partners in their lifetimes. Among circumcised men with such a sexual background, the odds of contracting a bacterial STD are estimated at 2.88 that for uncircumcised men. While significant, the exact size of the difference is difficult to establish as indicated by the wide confidence interval (95% CI, 1.03-9.03). Note as well that this difference is driven largely by differential contraction of gonorrhea.
So their data supposedly shows the more partners the less STDS? I would say then they either need to explain this bizarre outcome or they need to assess the accuracy of their data.

I am getting tired, so if I have overlooked something here, let me know. I'll look at the rest of the evidence tomorrow. Needless to say I am not impressed. It should be clear, don't take people's word for things without checking their sources for yourself.
 
You also make a lot of false statements.

Not all the may results have been confirmed.

Also the HIV-prevention is not as clear cut as you and other make it out to be.

Since I am one of the others, I am going to address this post.

http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/HIV/ is an update-to-date and seemingly unbiased report on the research done on HIV and circumcision.

Unfortunately, that is a biased source of information. I know that it is sometimes difficult to assess how reliable a source of information is when you do not have independent knowledge and experience in the area. And that is a whole 'nother topic. But in my read through the page that you linked and then through parts of the rest of the site I found multiple examples where incomplete information was given (i.e. the research that contradicted the author's conclusions was not mentioned) and summaries of research papers misrepresented the actual contents of the papers.

While indeed all studies in Africa between circumcized and uncircumcized men show a positive correlation between circumcision and preventing HIV infection, the research done in Europe and America has been THE OTHER WAY AROUND.

STDs and HIV in the western world are more prevalent among circumcized men than uncircumsized men.

America is the western country where circumcision is most common, it's also the western country with the highest HIV-infection rate. However correlation is not causation (if that makes sense, not native speaker, sorry). Still it gives some indication that mass circumcision is not really a solution.

Something that has been shown BOTH in Africa and in the western studies is the fact that HIV-transfer for male-to-female is higher for circumsized men.

Something that's also often ignored is that circumcision in Africa is a cultural thing, those different cultures may also have distinctly different sexual morale etc.. All in all there is simply not enough evidence to say circumcision prevents HIV-transfer, in fact, the opposite seems to be the case in those countries with a high degree of personal hygiene. But there's also not enough evidence to state the latter with a degree of certainty.

It turns out that none of this information is relevant when you have much better quality information to look at. As you mention, all kinds of things can influence the prevalence of HIV in any population. So information that comes from a study that is designed to eliminate all these influences except the influence of circumcision is really the only relevant information to look at when it is available. And there have now been three large randomized controlled trials looking at this. The author glosses over this fact. He dismisses one of the trials as "controversial" solely because letters criticizing the study were published. However, most studies will generate letters of criticism (especially when the research is important). Rather, the question should be, "does the study hold up to the criticism?" And in this case, the criticisms were addressed by the authors and none of them were sufficient to alter the main conclusions drawn from the study. The other two RCT's have been published, and all three show a consistent, large and robust effect. In addition, information was collected looking at the influence on male-to-female transmission, and preliminary reports show a reduction in transmission from circumcised men.

This is one example of the dishonesty exhibited by the author. When the bulk of the article should be spent on looking at the best available information, he chooses instead to devote 3 dismissive paragraphs to that information and to focus on low quality information. Most of his subsequent criticisms aren't even relevant. He brings up "contradictory" studies, yet none of them are remotely comparable as none of them are randomized controlled trials. He mentions ethical concerns about violating the rights of children by performing these trials, yet the trials themselves were conducted on adults giving informed consent.

Back to the point of wether it's relevant that the conclusions about circumcision and health benefits are post-hoc.

Yes it's very important, the difference are extremely small, and if you look generally for effects, you're datamining.

This means that you will always find something, you should NEVER draw conclusions from that, this kind of research is only useful for determining what to test.

There is a difference between starting with a particular bias and looking only for information to confirm that bias, and starting from a neutral position and looking at all the information in order to see what conclusions can reasonably be drawn from that information. I am talking about the latter situation.

As far as I can tell the penial cancer claims have not been followed up by actual research TESTING the effect.

It's much the same with the other claims...

Hey here we find UTI rates are down... let's claim that as an advantage...

Here the penial cancer is down, let's claim that as an advantage etc...

I think this simply demonstrates your unfamiliarity with the actual research, and with the conclusions that can reasonably be drawn from that research. Did you read papers where these associations were demonstrated?

These are at best starting points, at worst the effects dissappear completely when all the tests are added up...

At this point you're just making stuff up. You have no idea what happens when "all the tests are added up".

Linda
 
Does anyone else hear the ghost of Jack Dean Tyler cackling in the background?

What IS the dorsal side, anyway?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom