In answer to your question, Ivor, how can I say condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them, well access is a funny thing. It would be nice if you could just put those condoms with instructions on a boat and ship 'em where needed. But it isn't that simple.
Just look at the countries where access to these things are actually not too difficult to gage if the problem would be solved if only they had access:
The 25 states that track HIV cases are reporting an increase in new diagnoses, a striking change from the 1990s when the number of new infections remained stable at about 40,000 a year.
The HIV infection rate has doubled among blacks in the United States over a decade
A story in the Toronto Star reports that rates of new HIV infections in Candian young women have soared since 1996.
Then you can look at the real vs the ideal world beyond Western countries:
Global HIV rates at record high
Quote:
Around 14,000 people are infected with HIV every day
A record number of people were infected with HIV around the world this year, a report says.
Figures from UNAids and the World Health Organization put the number of new infections at five million.
The report also estimates that three million people died from the disease this year.
But it warns that the figures could rise sharply in the years ahead, with Eastern Europe and Central Asia on the verge of epidemics.
Africa hit hardest
The report, which is published ahead of World Aids Day on 1 December, estimates 40 million people around the world are infected with HIV/Aids. Of these, 2.5 million are children.
Russia's Aids timebomb
Around 14,000 people are infected with the disease every day.
Officials say the figures are more reliable than previous year's estimates, following improvements in the way the data is collected.
People living in sub-Saharan Africa continue to be most at risk. About 26.6m people are living with HIV/Aids are in this part of the world.
South Africa, alone, is home to 5.3 million people with HIV - more than any other country in the world. In Botswana, 39% of the population is HIV positive, the report says.
As to your assumptions about why circumcision is now going to be recommended, just who do you mean by "the US"? I'm curious who you think it is that has this power. Perhaps you envision some committee designated to come up with the cheapest way to treat HIV-AIDS in Africa. When you figure it out, let me know. I'd love to lobby them about the misguided ideas of the morality police.
The US donates like everyone else to the Global AIDS fund. Other countries and NGOs have done what they could to minimize the impact of the US AIDS fund donations since we have attached so many rules to the money. Particularly bad are the gag rules. If you take the money they want to see a ban on any discussion of anything to do with abortion. Because of that a couple of countries have even turned down US aid. It was earmarked for programs they felt were ineffective anyway.
So if you want to blame the US, you need to place the blame where it belongs, with the right wing Evangelicals who interfere with HIV-AIDS prevention programs to meet their own needs first.
I suggest you travel more if you get the chance. You might be surprised to know the US is not in control of the rest of the world in quite the way it seems you have pictured. It isn't up to the US to tell the countries on the African Continent how they should lower their HIV-AIDS risk. And for the moment, that's a good thing since we have those pesky church people in our government telling everyone sex is a sin and they should abstain or just suffer God's wrath.
You are correct in that money is an issue and we have enough of it we really should share more. The US pressures governments not to produce low cost anti-retrovirals that aren't off patents. That's another one of those dilemmas. If you wipe out drug company profits, you will have to find other ways to fund research. My assessment of the situation is the profits are currently obscene and the companies could stand to give up some in order to help so many desperate people.
So put pressure on the drug companies. They actually respond if they get enough pressure. When they smell the regulators coming or the frustrated third world governments threaten to make the drugs themselves, the drug companies start donating free drugs to poor countries. Write letters, send emails, make phone calls wherever you think some action might be useful. Don't just gripe about it. (Maybe you are an activist?) You can even donate time and money.
Keep something else in mind. If we spent a fraction of the money that's needed for HIV-AIDS just providing potable drinking water and basic vaccines to the third world, we be saving many more people than HIV will kill. Not that I suggest we only fund one of those, but if you think this whole circumcision thing is just about a cheaper treatment, you are quite misguided.
Hey, when those replaceable parts are ready to go, I'll be the first in line. I have no qualms taking advantage of the incredible medical discoveries we should be seeing in the next few decades.