ThatSoundAgain
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2006
- Messages
- 1,305
The issue is how many would wish that they had had it done as infants, not those who get it done as adults.
True, but I'm arguing that this is inconsequiential, seeing as one state (uncircumcised) is 100% reversible and the other is not. So, the (my guess) relatively few adults that wish they'd had it done as infants can still get it done at the expense of some discomfort, while the already circumcised adults who wish they weren't can never get full functionality back.
From everything I can tell there are marginal costs and benefits on both sides, and it is just that the anti circ side makes massive appeals to emotion and often refuses to look at science since this is not about real risks and benefits but a PRINCIPLE.
I see the appeals to emotion on both sides. And yes, principle, the one about being allowed to choose, plays a part in my stance on this, but there's also the very pragmatic wish to err on the side of caution - in the case of my (hypothetical) newborn son, he'll hopefully have much better data in 18 years, and can make a more informed decision.
So for everyone who argues that there are huge costs, well then think this, if you reversed the costs vs benefits of the procedure would it make sense to make everyone uncircumcised?(if the procedure produced an uncircumcised state), if people argue yes then they simply do not seem have an evidence based decision.
I don't quite follow this. But I think I can try for a more clear statement of my own position:
- If it ain't broken, don't fix it.
- If you want to fix it, despite the data being unclear, the benefits of doing so small, the drawbacks of doing so not well examined, the procedure a risk (albeit small), be sure it's your own foreskin you fix, not someone else's.