Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

I thought Canada's leader was ok. I haven't seen him in the news much.
You mean Stephen Harper? Well, at the moment his government is slowing imploding and is beset with problems. The latest polls have the Conservatives in a dead heat with the Liberals, so their dream of a Conservative majority in the next election is unlikely at best right now.

Of course, the opposition isn't doing much better, so there'll likely be another minority parliament whenever the next election rolls around.
 
You mean Stephen Harper? Well, at the moment his government is slowing imploding and is beset with problems. The latest polls have the Conservatives in a dead heat with the Liberals, so their dream of a Conservative majority in the next election is unlikely at best right now.

Of course, the opposition isn't doing much better, so there'll likely be another minority parliament whenever the next election rolls around.

I must apologize for not being informed of Canadian politics,but what exactly is his administration imploding from?
Domestic policy? Foreign policy? Exposed corruption?

Thanks again for any information.
 
I must apologize for not being informed of Canadian politics,but what exactly is his administration imploding from?
Domestic policy? Foreign policy? Exposed corruption?

Their inadequacy (and almost denialist attitude) to deal with the global warming problem and other environmental issues for one thing.
 
I must apologize for not being informed of Canadian politics,but what exactly is his administration imploding from?
Domestic policy? Foreign policy? Exposed corruption?
Domestic policy mostly. They've flip-flopped on a number of issues, saying one thing during the election campaign and while early in office, then doing the opposite. The decision on income trusts was one such example; the budget that recently passed Parliament violates an agreement signed earlier with Atlantic provinces over equalization payments would be another.

The major dissatisfaction with foreign policy is over Canada's military participation in Afghanistan; much of the public is not that supportive of it but for the moment there is no large opposition to it.
 
You do realize that many individuals when in that exact situation would forget that they have a camera and their EYES, not the CAMERA, would be pointed towards the jet.

Ever watch videos on youtube when someone crashes or some other unexpected event occurs. In many of those videos the camera falls to the videographers side and the video sucks because the camera man is watching the event with his EYES at that point. Not the video camera.

Actually the instinctive action of capturing a sudden event on camera is exceedingly rare because, as you pointed out, most people want to see for themselves what is going on, and a camera does not offer very good situational awareness.

The best news cameramen succeed specifically because they possess that rare trait that makes them get the right shot.

-Gumboot

It's funny, because oddly enough this is one of Killtown's core arguments for Val's photo being fake.
 
Domestic policy mostly. They've flip-flopped on a number of issues, saying one thing during the election campaign and while early in office, then doing the opposite.

Interesting. That is the best way to find out the truth from American politicians. Expect the opposite of what they say and you won't be disappointed!;)

As far as Val photo, that looks nothing like smoke from an airline crash that I've ever seen. Also one of her neighbor's daughter's stated to Shure on the phone that it was a fake.
If I were a bettin' man, I would put money on it being a fake.
 
Last edited:
As far as Val photo, that looks nothing like smoke from an airline crash that I've ever seen. Also one of her neighbor's daughter's stated to Shure on the phone that it was a fake.
If I were a bettin' man, I would put money on it being a fake.

implied argument from incredulity, and all that.

How many times have you seen smoke from airline crashes, especially ones that were reported to have involved the plane going nearly straight down?

Then, if the photo were fake, what would that prove?

Where are you going with this?
 
As far as Val photo, that looks nothing like smoke from an airline crash that I've ever seen.

8886467308eb21d0d.jpg


88864673083a494b2.jpg
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/8886467308eb21d0d.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/88864673083a494b2.jpg[/qimg]
I'm missing that tower looking object in the Shanksville area.
How many times have you seen smoke from airline crashes, especially ones that were reported to have involved the plane going nearly straight down?

You might start here...I did.Aviation Accident Photos


Then, if the photo were fake, what would that prove?
\
What would it prove? Excellent question. What would it prove?
 
I'm missing that tower looking object in the Shanksville area.


You might start here...I did.Aviation Accident Photos


\
What would it prove? Excellent question. What would it prove?

all right, now that the link works, I see tons of photos. Do you have a photo that you know to be of a similar case--similar plane and trajectory, or do you want us to look at lots and lots of pictures?
 
Swinger,

After opening nearly 100 of the images on that website I could not find one of a crash smoke plume. Can you point one out to me that is on that site, or is that site irrelevent to the discussion?
 
I'll cut to the chase.

Let's say that there are 4 possibilities. I believe the photo is real, but:

1) the photo is real: leave the woman alone

2) the photo is real but slightly enhanced: leave the woman alone

3) the photo is partly faked: leave the woman alone

4) the photo is completely faked: leave the woman alone

Nothing rides on the validity of the photo.

On the other hand, there is a long, rich tradition of amateur sleuths and crackpots thinking that they can do expert analysis of photos, etc. They are almost always wrong.

If you can point me to a single historical instance where something truly important was discovered by amateur analysis of a photo, it might be somewhat interesting, but it would still not go anywhere in this case.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom