Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Well my gosh Pom, if I lie all the time, then you should have no problem posting proof, correct?

I posted the timeline, do you agree it was quickly?
Quick enough to prevent a movie in the making and a book? That is certainly very fast, isn't it.




Yes, it was very quick. Those of us who inhabit reality remember the year 2003 pretty well. It wasn't too long ago. Initially, we heard about the feisty little girl from West Virginia who, although badly injured, fought like a tiger. Soon after, we found out about the Iraqi who saved her life. We then learned that Lynch wasn't a female Rambo.
To repeat, you are not making any point. There was no conspiracy--merely a typical bit of wartime myth-making.



I'm assuming this is the link you are referring to from Slate


Hmm lets look at a relevant passage from FactCheck.org


HeadlineAuthorDateDept.Liberal Hawks Reconsider the Iraq War
Final words. Paul Berman, Thomas Friedman, Christopher Hitchens, Fred Kaplan, George Packer, Kenneth M. Pollack, Jacob Weisberg and Fareed Zakaria Jan 12, 2004 Politics Liberal Hawks Reconsider the Iraq War
A Slate dialogue. Paul Berman, Thomas Friedman, Christopher Hitchens, Fred Kaplan, George Packer, Kenneth M. Pollack, Jacob Weisberg and Fareed Zakaria Jun 23, 2006 Slate's 10th Anniversary


Into the Fray
Christopher Hitchens Sep 26, 2006 Hey, Wait a Minute

Christopher Hitchens responds to a former Iraqi official's missive.


Christopher Hitchens Jun 19, 2006 Fighting Words Hello, Zahawie, My Old Friend
I've come to talk with you again.

Christopher Hitchens Sep 05, 2006 Fighting Words Sorry, Hitch—You're Wrong About Niger
Plus: Christopher Hitchens responds.

David Corn Sep 26, 2006 Hey, Wait a Minute Christopher Hitchens Responds
There's only one reason to
go to Niger






Here is a suggestion that is guaranteed to be ignored by you: why not read what Hitchens has reported?




I wish we knew exactly what Wilson told him.

Let me summarize: Wilson says so the CIA says that Mayki (whose country has had close and friendly relations with the U.S. since independence) say's he interpreted commercial relations meant uranium yellowcake sales.

Pom, why do you think it took hearsay based upon an interpretation about a an enemy from an ally to make the "16 words".
Throw on top of that "crack intel", the desire to invade Iraq, the forged Italian documents, the AL-Q links, and even you should be able to see a repeating pattern here for the bogus justifications for war.

Do you ever contemplate who would forge documents that might be used to lead our country to war?

When was Bush's press conference to the world retracting the "16 words" and explaining to the world why they were spoken and why they are being retracted? I may have missed that one. I've read Rice and Tenet's explanation but not the man who said it.



You demonstrate that you know nothing about the subject, yet you pontificate about it and propose false interpretations.


Yes and so is lying to a city about its air quality which results in death is pretty crazy too, but darn it, POM, they did it anyway.


Gee, Swingie, the damage to the city's economy was so great that it contributed mightily to a national recession that, predictably, was blamed on Bush. It almost makes you wonder why your imaginary conspiracy blew up the buildings in the first place. Oh, I forgot: they caused a recession in order to make a few bucks for Dick Cheney's cronies. And that explains why all the Democrats in the military and in the intelligence services signed off on the plan. Why do people regard you as a fool and a crackpot?

That the EPA encouraged people to believe that the air was safe is a real scandal. Why would that concern you?



I don't know if I should interpret your response as defending this Administration or not. But I hope not. I'm going to appeal to emotion for a bit but when I see friends return home from Iraq maimed and some not return home at all, I find your position rather appalling and disgusting.


I find your repeated falsehoods quite disgusting, but not nearly as disgusting as your pernicious and dishonest attempts to absolve the jihadists who attacked America of all wrongdoing and your baseless slanders of innocent government officials.
 
Last edited:
I find your repeated falsehoods quite disgusting, but not nearly as disgusting as your pernicious and dishonest attempts to absolve the jihadists who attacked America of all wrongdoing and your baseless slanders of innocent government officials.

I also find it disturbing that these falsehoods represent a tacit support to these jihadists.

It is one of the ramifications of accusing the "Man" of perpetrating 911; if NOT true, it suggests support of those who most of us know are REALLY responsible.
 
Last edited:
Did Colombia break up in the air and scatter debris for miles or did it hit the ground and then scatter debris for miles? A bit of a difference don't you think?
You might be surprised just how far a ground-based explosion can hurl debris.
 
Did Colombia break up in the air and scatter debris for miles or did it hit the ground and then scatter debris for miles? A bit of a difference don't you think?



I assume you are aware that all substantial debris from UA93 was found in the immediate vicinity of the impact site, yes? I assume you aware that the furthest debris was found from the crash site was lightweight debris such as scraps of paper and clothing which was found downwind of the crash site on Indian Lake, between 1.5 and 2.8 miles from impact. Yes? you knew that already?

-Gumboot
 
I assume you are aware that all substantial debris from UA93 was found in the immediate vicinity of the impact site, yes? I assume you aware that the furthest debris was found from the crash site was lightweight debris such as scraps of paper and clothing which was found downwind of the crash site on Indian Lake, between 1.5 and 2.8 miles from impact. Yes? you knew that already?

-Gumboot

Well, there was some paper and insulation scraps found at New Baltimore, which was eight miles away. No metal, nothing heavy at all, and New Baltimore was downwind as well.
 

well, I read maybe 10 pages out of 73. One lunatic post of KT among many:

#2906: killtown:
"If her photo is real, funny she hasn't reached out to me to try to clear things up, huh?"


That Malcolm and Swing Dangler are quoting Killtown (even though he's a total loon) supports the idea that a falsehood will get repeated and repeated, until a large number of people have heard it and vaguely believe it.
 
es, it was very quick. Those of us who inhabit reality remember the year 2003 pretty well. It wasn't too long ago. Initially, we heard about the feisty little girl from West Virginia who, although badly injured, fought like a tiger. Soon after, we found out about the Iraqi who saved her life. We then learned that Lynch wasn't a female Rambo.
To repeat, you are not making any point. There was no conspiracy--merely a typical bit of wartime myth-making
.

Well first off those of us that inhabit reality examine documented time lines from press outlets that I linked to earlier. Those in fantasy land apparently refuse to examine the documented time lines and use vague generalizations to support their point. Soon...soon...soon...Pom, I gave you a link to the time line, no need to use the term soon when you could use the term weeks and months. Indeed the story was busted so soon that a movie was in the works and a book to boot? That is certainly fast debunking by the media and persons involved isn't it.

Second, I never contended there was a "conspiracy", you did with your above statement. I stated as fact according to Lynch's testimony to the Congressional investigation of the issue and Newsweek magazine's article that at least one member of the military lied to the press and thus started the "Myth" as Newsweek so succinctly stated.


HeadlineAuthorDateDept.Liberal Hawks Reconsider the Iraq War
Final words. Paul Berman, Thomas Friedman, Christopher Hitchens, Fred Kaplan, George Packer, Kenneth M. Pollack, Jacob Weisberg and Fareed Zakaria Jan 12, 2004 Politics Liberal Hawks Reconsider the Iraq War
A Slate dialogue. Paul Berman, Thomas Friedman, Christopher Hitchens, Fred Kaplan, George Packer, Kenneth M. Pollack, Jacob Weisberg and Fareed Zakaria Jun 23, 2006 Slate's 10th Anniversary


Into the Fray
Christopher Hitchens Sep 26, 2006 Hey, Wait a Minute

Christopher Hitchens responds to a former Iraqi official's missive.


Christopher Hitchens Jun 19, 2006 Fighting Words Hello, Zahawie, My Old Friend
I've come to talk with you again.

Christopher Hitchens Sep 05, 2006 Fighting Words Sorry, Hitch—You're Wrong About Niger
Plus: Christopher Hitchens responds.
David Corn Sep 26, 2006 Hey, Wait a Minute Christopher Hitchens Responds
There's only one reason to
go to Niger
Here is a suggestion that is guaranteed to be ignored by you: why not read what Hitchens has reported?
Quote:
I wish we knew exactly what Wilson told him.

Let me summarize: Wilson says so the CIA says that Mayki (whose country has had close and friendly relations with the U.S. since independence) say's he interpreted commercial relations meant uranium yellowcake sales.

Pom, why do you think it took hearsay based upon an interpretation about a an enemy from an ally to make the "16 words".
Throw on top of that "crack intel", the desire to invade Iraq, the forged Italian documents, the AL-Q links, and even you should be able to see a repeating pattern here for the bogus justifications for war.

Do you ever contemplate who would forge documents that might be used to lead our country to war?

When was Bush's press conference to the world retracting the "16 words" and explaining to the world why they were spoken and why they are being retracted? I may have missed that one. I've read Rice and Tenet's explanation but not the man who said it.



You demonstrate that you know nothing about the subject, yet you pontificate about it and propose false interpretations.

ROFLMAO! Please offer proof for your claim. What did you offer? A bunch of links to a slanted biased media outlet who has no problem spinning the story in favor of their biased. This apparently is your prerogative as I suspect you have voted for right wing Republicans most of your adult life.
Pom, do as I do and go directly to Primary Source documents instead of relying on someone else to interpret the story for you. You can start with the press statments by the DCI:
CIA
You might just be able to find other primary source documents unless you enjoy being told what to think by biased media outlets.


Do you ever contemplate who would forge documents that might be used to lead our country to war? Is there a reason why you avoided this question or does it challenge your belief system?

Quote:
Yes and so is lying to a city about its air quality which results in death is pretty crazy too, but darn it, POM, they did it anyway.

Gee, Swingie, the damage to the city's economy was so great that it contributed mightily to a national recession that, predictably, was blamed on Bush. It almost makes you wonder why your imaginary conspiracy blew up the buildings in the first place. Oh, I forgot: they caused a recession in order to make a few bucks for Dick Cheney's cronies. And that explains why all the Democrats in the military and in the intelligence services signed off on the plan. Why do people regard you as a fool and a crackpot?

That the EPA encouraged people to believe that the air was safe is a real scandal. Why would that concern you?

You left out the pressure put on the EPA by the White house.
Source: EPA Report

Why is that Pom? Defending this Administration's scandals yet again?
Why does it concern me? It is another example of the Federal Government misleading and lying to Americans and it appears this might just be leading to the deaths of many people. And the last time I checked, the Federal Government represents me. And again where is the accountability and punishment for the individuals who perpetrate these misleading statements and outright lies? Or do you defend this type of behavior?


I don't know if I should interpret your response as defending this Administration or not. But I hope not. I'm going to appeal to emotion for a bit but when I see friends return home from Iraq maimed and some not return home at all, I find your position rather appalling and disgusting.

I find your repeated falsehoods quite disgusting, but not nearly as disgusting as your pernicious and dishonest attempts to absolve the jihadists who attacked America of all wrongdoing and your baseless slanders of innocent government officials.
Huh? This tidbit of discussion was about Iraq, not 9/11. Or are you pulling a Bush on me and trying to link Iraq to 9/11? ;)

Can you please source those baseless slanders again and please point out where I'm trying to absolve the jihadists?
Or are you once again stating mis-truths to support your position?
Never mind, it seems you have taken a page out of the Bush Administration handbook when dealing with facts.
Gumboot-
I assume you are aware that all substantial debris from UA93 was found in the immediate vicinity of the impact site, yes? I assume you aware that the furthest debris was found from the crash site was lightweight debris such as scraps of paper and clothing which was found downwind of the crash site on Indian Lake, between 1.5 and 2.8 miles from impact. Yes? you knew that already?

Lets examine your question. How do you define substantial debris?
Are lightweight debris limited to scraps of paper and clothing only or does that include books and possible body parts after witnesses heard a plane fly over?
And that engine bouncing thing. That is a bit troublesome. Engine remains are found in the crater and most of the plane in the crater. The other engine remains "bounced" off of that soft stripped mine dirt and landed how far away again?

Or do you actually believe the wind blew the debris that far away as opposed to the high ranking Rmackey plausibility factor which favors that either a bomb went off on board or it was shot down?


Arkan-
This thread lays to rest any accusations of fakery
I could not disagree more. Based upon the following information.
1. The plume seems disconnected from continually burning jet fuel. The same jet fuel I assume ignited the forested area.
2. The size of the plume in relation to the surroundings.
3. And IMO, the statements of Kelly Leverknight about the event and about what her mom saw.

But it is ok, officials manufacture fantasy based stories for public consumption quite frequently.
 
.
Lets examine your question. How do you define substantial debris?
Are lightweight debris limited to scraps of paper and clothing only or does that include books and possible body parts after witnesses heard a plane fly over?
And that engine bouncing thing. That is a bit troublesome. Engine remains are found in the crater and most of the plane in the crater. The other engine remains "bounced" off of that soft stripped mine dirt and landed how far away again?
There were no real points in the entire post.

Yes, one engine could dig in, and one engine can roll off. The plane was turning, you can see it on the data from the FDR, the turn would help one engine dig in, and one fall off. Next time you get a few million dollars take a plane and hit the ground at 600 mph and see what happens, you will be surprised what happens. Parts are hundreds of yards away, small stuff and big stuff. The bodies are mashed into the plane parts, there is some stuff carried by the wind. I am not sure what your point was, but it seems to be wrong. You can go and pay, and learn accident investigation of aircraft, I bet USC would take your money. You would also learn it is not an accident when it is done on purpose.

Too bad you can not grasp the engine thing. If you have problems with the engine, you will not have the ability to do any rational or logical research and never understand 9/11. It is an education thing, some are able to do great with minimal education I needed lots, your education has failed you based on your post all over the internet. Go back to school.

You do not really use Killtown as a source do you? Back to school, quick.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Not yet. ;)
IMHO, I think a plane was shot down. You know the whole debris field measured in miles which would account for the lack of debris at the site itself.

I just do not think the Val photo is legit.
So where was the explosive residue from the plane supposedly being shot down? You know they searched for explosive residue because of the hijackers threat of having a bomb on board correct?
 
Last edited:
I could not disagree more. Based upon the following information.
1. The plume seems disconnected from continually burning jet fuel. The same jet fuel I assume ignited the forested area.
2. The size of the plume in relation to the surroundings.
3. And IMO, the statements of Kelly Leverknight about the event and about what her mom saw.

But it is ok, officials manufacture fantasy based stories for public consumption quite frequently.
Revisiting Flight 93, are we?

You're totally wrong. We do not expect "continually burning jet fuel," and there is no reason to expect connection to the ground. The forested area was scorched, but not set ablaze.

The size and position of the plume are as expected.

Statements of the whole damn town, including the Mayor of Shanksville, say that her picture matches what they saw.

I summarized this here if you don't want to read the whole 73 page catastrophe.

Don't make stupid claims, like your three above, without backing them up. We've beat this one to death and the burden of proof on you is extremely high.
 
did you have a point?

Again, it cuts way before the plume can form. Val's picture was taken as the plume was starting to disperse into the atmosphere.

As Calebprime said, is there a point to all this?

Thanks for the video links Swing. But, is there a photograph from the website you gave a link to depicting airline crashes which shows a plume since you said it's where you started? Tks.

:s2:
 
.

Well first off those of us that inhabit reality examine documented time lines from press outlets that I linked to earlier. Those in fantasy land apparently refuse to examine the documented time lines and use vague generalizations to support their point. Soon...soon...soon...Pom, I gave you a link to the time line, no need to use the term soon when you could use the term weeks and months. Indeed the story was busted so soon that a movie was in the works and a book to boot? That is certainly fast debunking by the media and persons involved isn't it.



Yes, the debunking was fast. The only time I heard anything about a movie was within days of Lynch's release. The corrected version of the story followed soon after. You are, as usual, flogging a dead horse. Some people, whether journalists or representatives of the militarty, decided to invent a female warrior to match the template rammed down our throats by the sensitivity folks. The truth came out rather quickly.


Second, I never contended there was a "conspiracy", you did with your above statement. I stated as fact according to Lynch's testimony to the Congressional investigation of the issue and Newsweek magazine's article that at least one member of the military lied to the press and thus started the "Myth" as Newsweek so succinctly stated.

So, you have no point to make. In every war, heroes are created to supply a perceived need for them. So what?


ROFLMAO! Please offer proof for your claim. What did you offer? A bunch of links to a slanted biased media outlet who has no problem spinning the story in favor of their biased. This apparently is your prerogative as I suspect you have voted for right wing Republicans most of your adult life.
Pom, do as I do and go directly to Primary Source documents instead of relying on someone else to interpret the story for you. You can start with the press statments by the DCI:



When your spasm of deranged hysteria subsides, you might want to consider the FACT that Slate.com leans LEFT, not right.

I linked to essays written by Christopher Hitchens because he has investigated Zahawie's trip to Niger comprehensively. His findings are inconvenient to your lies.





https://www.cia.gov/news-informatio...ts/press-release-archive-2003/pr07112003.html


The Italian forgeries had nothing to do with either British or American intelligence--AS YOU KNOW.


Quote:


You left out the pressure put on the EPA by the White house.
Source: EPA Report

Why is that Pom? Defending this Administration's scandals yet again?
Why does it concern me? It is another example of the Federal Government misleading and lying to Americans and it appears this might just be leading to the deaths of many people. And the last time I checked, the Federal Government represents me. And again where is the accountability and punishment for the individuals who perpetrate these misleading statements and outright lies? Or do you defend this type of behavior?


Gee, it appears as though you believe that crippling the economy of NYC and midwifing a national recession was bad for this administration. Kinda makes you wonder why they did it.





Huh? This tidbit of discussion was about Iraq, not 9/11. Or are you pulling a Bush on me and trying to link Iraq to 9/11? ;)


Many liars have been asked to provide a quote by Bush linking Iraq to 9/11. You will not be the first one to succeed.



Can you please source those baseless slanders again and please point out where I'm trying to absolve the jihadists?
Or are you once again stating mis-truths to support your position?
Never mind, it seems you have taken a page out of the Bush Administration handbook when dealing with facts.


Your imaginary conspiracy is a pernicious and baseless falsehood. You promote it to absolve the true perpetrators of this monstrous act of any wrongdoing.



Lets examine your question. How do you define substantial debris?
Are lightweight debris limited to scraps of paper and clothing only or does that include books and possible body parts after witnesses heard a plane fly over?
And that engine bouncing thing. That is a bit troublesome. Engine remains are found in the crater and most of the plane in the crater. The other engine remains "bounced" off of that soft stripped mine dirt and landed how far away again?

Or do you actually believe the wind blew the debris that far away as opposed to the high ranking Rmackey plausibility factor which favors that either a bomb went off on board or it was shot down?


Your knowledge of the crash of Flight 93 is comparable to your knowledge of every other 9/11-related subject.


I could not disagree more. Based upon the following information.
1. The plume seems disconnected from continually burning jet fuel. The same jet fuel I assume ignited the forested area.
2. The size of the plume in relation to the surroundings.
3. And IMO, the statements of Kelly Leverknight about the event and about what her mom saw.

But it is ok, officials manufacture fantasy based stories for public consumption quite frequently.


Conspiracy liars manufacture pure fantasies constantly. They do it to promote their evil myths.
 
Lets examine your question. How do you define substantial debris?


Pieces large and heavy enough they cannot be carried by the wind. Pieces of the aircraft, in other words.




And that engine bouncing thing. That is a bit troublesome. Engine remains are found in the crater and most of the plane in the crater. The other engine remains "bounced" off of that soft stripped mine dirt and landed how far away again?


It landed in a pond 250m from the impact site, in the direction of travel. 250m, or about 1 second, at UA93's impact speed of 500KT.



Or do you actually believe the wind blew the debris that far away as opposed to the high ranking Rmackey plausibility factor which favors that either a bomb went off on board or it was shot down?


Here's the FDR data from UA93 at the moment of impact:

1. Cabin pressure - NORMAL
2. Hydraulics - NORMAL
3. Cargo fire - NORMAL
4. Smoke - NORMAL
5. Engines - RUNNING
6. Engine RPM (N1) 70%
7. Fuel pressure - NORMAL
8. Engine vibration - LO

9. Wind direction - WEST
10. Wind speed - 25 kts

11. Pitch angle - 40 deg down
12. Airspeed - 500 kts
13. Heading - 180 deg
14. Roll angle - 150 deg right
15. AoA - 20 deg negative

The aircraft did not break up before impact.



I could not disagree more. Based upon the following information.
1. The plume seems disconnected from continually burning jet fuel. The same jet fuel I assume ignited the forested area.
2. The size of the plume in relation to the surroundings.
3. And IMO, the statements of Kelly Leverknight about the event and about what her mom saw.

But it is ok, officials manufacture fantasy based stories for public consumption quite frequently.


Her photo has been examined to death. What we see in that photo is entirely in keeping with the events alleged to have occurred. Continually burning jet fuel would only be a product of a slow speed impact which spread jet fuel across the ground. In a high speed impact one would expect the collision to spray virtually all of the jet fuel into the air in a fine enough mist to allow combustion. I would imagine virtually all of UA93's fuel burned off in the initial fireball.

-Gumboot
 
Revisiting Flight 93, are we?

Nope. Not the flight, just the photo.

You're totally wrong. We do not expect "continually burning jet fuel," and there is no reason to expect connection to the ground. The forested area was scorched, but not set ablaze.

And how did that forest get scorched? Burning jet fuel, correct?
And the opposite side of the crater? Should we expect similar scorches on the other side considering the angle of impact?


The size and position of the plume are as expected.
Statements of the whole damn town, including the Mayor of Shanksville, say that her picture matches what they saw.

Out of curiosity, what would be the expected size and position of the plume?
Apparently not every dam person. Have you not listened to Lee Purbaugh's wife and that conversation?
The Levernkight conversation? A man's wife who saw the impact state that the photo is fraudulent and is "BS" and it is just for money. Lervernkights daughter states that it is a fraud as well. So not every dam person thinks the photo is real.

I summarized this here if you don't want to read the whole 73 page catastrophe.

Don't make stupid claims, like your three above, without backing them up. We've beat this one to death and the burden of proof on you is extremely high.[/QUOTE]

I don't consider them "stupid" when primary sources state the photo is a fraud. And primary sources of other impacts do not match the plume

As far as the picture is concerned:
1. The plume appears to be a one time event, as I've never seen an airline impact on the ground that "poofs" into a virtually unconnected plume. In the history of aviation, I would expect to see similarities and this photo appears to not be similar. If you could provide a photo or two of a similar type of plume from an airline impact with the ground I would greatly appreciate it. I haven't been able to find one.

Killtown's assertions about the extent of burned and unburned vegetation are based on incomplete evidence cobbled together from TV news screencaptures, and fail to take into accout the litany of airplane crashes that left similar effects on vegetation

Your own debunking of Killtown calls into account the litany of airplane crashes that left similar effects on vegetation and we should then expect similar smoke plume effects. Empirical evidence should be other plane impacts that show similar smoke plumes.
While Val McClatchey may have had access to photo-editing software, so does virtually everyone else in the world, and there is no evidence that she altered anything

This of course is opinion as none of us have access to the original graphic file from Val to check for authenticity. That empirical evidence issue again.
Val is not profiting by this venture, but donates all money sent to Heroic Choices, a charity organization honoring Mr. Todd Beamer, a victim of Flight 93
This of course is an opinion, as none of us to my knowledge have access to her financial records. And not ALL money goes to the charities as she keeps some to cover postage.

2. Two relatives of people who were first on the scene and one which saw the plane crash state the photo is a fraud and that Val is doing it for money.
Does this prove anything about Flight 93? Not in my opinion. Does it prove the photo is a fraud? I believe so.
And until the original digital photo file is obtained and examined by experts, the fraudulent photo explanation has a greater RMackey plausibility than the photo being original.

I would be convinced the photo is not fraudulent if:
1. You can show me pictures of other plane impacts with the ground that produce similar plumes.
2. The individuals mentioned above recanted their statements about the photo being a fraud.

Beachnut-
Too bad you can not grasp the engine thing. If you have problems with the engine, you will not have the ability to do any rational or logical research and never understand 9/11.
If you could offer up the physics behind the engine roll or bounce I would greatly appreciate it?
 
Swing, like we have said to many others here, take the photo to a photo analysis expert, or just drop it. You are not an expert, so why are you making comment on it.

As for the crash analysis, likewise, take it to a plane crash investigator, or be done with it. I am really sick and tired of these would be investigooglers, who also think they are experts in every field of science, law inforcement, and criminology.

TAM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom