Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

The point I made, which I think needs re-stating because you've clearly completely failed to appreciate it, is that nobody with a freshman college level education or better would think that what you've suggested could do anything but increase the shakiness of the shot.

Dave

Correct. Bingo. Hallelujah. Bravo.

It did increase the shakiness of the shot. Hence the whole paper.
 
Not quite. The perps knew that if they inserted a perfectly stable shot into a shaky shot, that would be a dead giveaway. So that's out. Best bet is to lay a shaky shot into another shaky shot, try to keep the shake down to a minimum, and blame the resulting errors on measurement imprecision, as Dave is now doing.

On a frame by frame basis, the random errors in the live shot can either add to or subtract from the random errors already present in the overlay.

In general, we can say that the Chopper 5 shot was more smooth and stable than the overlay shot. Around frames 8,16,18,22, and 41, the Chopper 5 motion was such that it added to the error. Around frames 9,21, and 39 the motion was such that it subtracted from the error.

The cumulative error predicted by Dave is indeed evident.
This is the sad effect of bias. Not a thing you have said, not a video you have studied make sense. Even a kid would listen to the eyewitnesses and even a kid knows your analysis of the video motion is out to lunch due to helicopter motion and the gyro stabilize camera algorithm to compensate for vibration and motion. You essential have nothing. Zip. Nil. I do not understand why you ignore all and continue to make up what amounts to a lie.

Since you do not know the motion of the helo, or the algorithm that stabilized the camera, you have nothing. You are missing so much data!
 
Not quite. The perps knew that if they inserted a perfectly stable shot into a shaky shot, that would be a dead giveaway.
I've put two motion detecting challenges out there for you. Are you going to take them up? Because until you do, I place my eyes' ability to detect special effects far, far above yours.
 
I've put two motion detecting challenges out there for you. Are you going to take them up? Because until you do, I place my eyes' ability to detect special effects far, far above yours.

No I'm not going to study Aliens. I have however discovered another 9/11 plane video that appears to have worse motion problems than Chopper 5.
 
lets see 2 videos and thousands more to go.. not to mention the eyewitness which you ahve shown to completely ignore.

you're nothing more than a lying sack of.....
 
No I'm not going to study Aliens.
Translation: you're afraid to do so because you know you will not be able to spot the problem, thereby supporting my assertion that you have no reasonable abilty to detect special effects or problems in motion which betray a special effect.

And I was even willing to help you out by giving you the exact times on the DVD so you could go straight to the shots and not have to watch any unneeded scenes.
 
Bad news, Ace.Your original video is compressed.[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/10976468c933dc866e.png[/qimg]

Sorenson three is a variant of H.264. http://www.nuntius.com/technology3.html H.264 uses motion compensation and motion prediction in its compression, as well as using DCT. Your samples were uncompressed video, Ace.

Comparison invalid. Try again, and see if you can do it right.

Great find MordFurd. It's like taking a YouTube version of the Zapruder Film in order to prove the original film must have been manipulated due to these "strange" compression artifacts.

Case closed.
 
No I'm not going to study Aliens. I have however discovered another 9/11 plane video that appears to have worse motion problems than Chopper 5.

Will you explain to me first why there is a "strange" halo on the right edge of the left tower (I circled it for you), which appears on a cropped screenshot I took from your "original" Fox video?

wtc.jpg


What do you think? Is it due to the camera equipment/lens/recording device not coping with the high color contrast, and the ensuing cropping/changing brightness amplifying this effect, or is it because someone pasted pre-recorded footage of the North Tower in realtime onto the actual footage of the North Tower on 9/11?
 
William Seger is playing semantics. Increasing the size of a picture does not create any more data, but it does allow greater precision in stabilizing, and greater precision in placing wireframes, thus greater precision in measurement. Essentially it allows us to move things by what would have been 1/2 pixel at the original size. Increasing the image size does indeed serve to reduce margin of measurement error.

Well, I have to ask you, Ace: Do you understand the difference between precision and accuracy? (It's a rhetorical question, since you've already revealed that you do not.) No, the difference is not just semantics.
 
The error in my controls is <6%, in Chopper 5 it is>35%.

If Seger is correct, how does he explain the stability of my control cases?

That's an interesting question, Ace -- but not for the reason you probably imagine.

I did screen grabs from the animated gif you posted of your unstabilized "control" and used approximately the same method I used to measure the Chopper 5 video: I enlarged the images enough to clearly see individual pixels and measured the number of pixels between the inside of your red plane outline to my best guess of the edge of the building. Working backwards from the frame just before the one where the plane's nose passed behind the building and going for 8 frames, I get per-frame displacements of 20, 19, 21, 21, 17, 21, and 19.

Despite the fact that your "control" is not nearly so much like the Chopper 5 video as you claim (e.g. your video obviously used a different deinterlacing technique, your plane and building are much closer, etc.), those measurements have one characteristic that's very much like the Chopper 5 video: Other than the 17 anomaly, the measurements are about plus or minus one pixel from the mean of about 20 pixels.

Isn't that odd?

No, it isn't odd at all; again, it's about what one should expect. (And, btw, expressing that error as a percentage of the pixel distances when your control involves distances of almost twice as many pixels is just silly.)

So, here's my answer to your request to explain your results: Through a combination of apparent experimenter bias and not really understanding the nature of what you were trying to do (i.e. not understanding the real source and scale of the measurement errors -- the difficulty of locating the plane and building accurately when there are imaging and compression flaws that are a minimum of one pixel in the original -- and also not understanding the difference between precision and accuracy), the relative smoothness of the motion of your control versus the Chopper 5 video is really just a figment of your imagination.

Are you really sure you want to go to a "scientific truther" conference that would have you as a speaker?
:dl:
 
And I was even willing to help you out by giving you the exact times on the DVD so you could go straight to the shots and not have to watch any unneeded scenes.

Unneeded scenes! Unneeded scenes! Unneeded scenes in Aliens! Woman which scenes are unneeded! They're all fricking cool. How can you watch Aliens, ands not do the Bishop knife scene? Or the "lets take off and nuke the site from orbit" Or Ripley rescuing Newt!

True story I met an actor once, whose claim to fame is that he was cut from Aliens, and Star Wars IV. The two biggest films he's ever worked on and he ended up on the cutting room floor. He was a X wing pilot in Star Wars, and Newt's dad in Aliens (turns up in that pointless directors cut mind you).

Anywho Ace I asked this question on another thread and I'll ask it here as well.

Oh Ace satisfy my curiousity on something. At what stage in production are you generally brought in? The shoot? Post? After the Online? And what do you like getting your cuts on split track dvds with BITC? Music on two dial and SFX on one? Or quicktimes? with a similar audio and BITC? Just curious I think your answer will help go along way in figuring you out.
 
Unneeded scenes! Unneeded scenes! Unneeded scenes in Aliens! Woman which scenes are unneeded! They're all fricking cool. How can you watch Aliens, ands not do the Bishop knife scene? Or the "lets take off and nuke the site from orbit" Or Ripley rescuing Newt!
Clarification: I meant unneeded in the sense of not having to be watched in order to get to the powerloader shots. It was not a reference to the quality of the other scenes themselves. :)

True story I met an actor once, whose claim to fame is that he was cut from Aliens, and Star Wars IV. The two biggest films he's ever worked on and he ended up on the cutting room floor. He was a X wing pilot in Star Wars, and Newt's dad in Aliens (turns up in that pointless directors cut mind you).
That does happen from time to time with minor characters. At least the actor/actress got paid for their work even if we don't see it onscreen...
 
I'm bumping this thread for mrwonggt13 before he starts any more hysterical nonsense threads about being censored. Here's his OP from a thread that was moved to AAH.

FOX 5 WNYW Provably Guilty of Treason, Murder

The FOX 5 WNYW "Chopper 5" footage is the smoking gun.

Here is Ace Baker's frame viewer for Chopper 5.

1. There is no plane in the wide shot.
2. The plane enters 1 frame after a dramatic zoom.
3. The motion of the plane becomes less stable as the background is stabilized.
4. The nose of the plane appears to pop out from behind the tower.
5. There is a quick fade to black.
6. The footage was never replayed.
7. The footage was cleansed from the official archive.

If there was a real plane: 1 is impossible, 2 is extremely unlikely, 3 is impossible, 4 is impossible, 5 is extremely suspicious, 6 is extremely suspicious, and 7 is extremely suspicious.
And here is part of the mod box explaining why the thread was moved to AAH:

If you wish to discuss this topic, please use one of the many threads already open on it
So, if anyone wants to continue to discuss this, here is the place to do it. Not in a new thread.

Personally, I think these ludicrous claims have already been comprehensively rebutted in this thread. Furthermore, the underlying hypothesis (that there were no planes) is self-evidently nonsense.

So, I won't be contributing further. But, carry on if you feel it's worth it...
 
Last edited:
You put a stake through its heart, chop its head off, fill its mouth with garlic and bury it at the crossroads, but still someone's going to dig it up and reanimate the thing. Just a couple of comments here, though.

2. The plane enters 1 frame after a dramatic zoom.

Texas Sharpshooter fallacy. If the plane had entered the frame later, that would have been no less consistent with video compositing.

4. The nose of the plane appears to pop out from behind the tower.

It's extremely dishonest of Ace to continue claiming this is due to video compositing, after he's seen the proof that it could not possibly have been. When he claims that the object emerging from the left of the tower is the nose of the plane, he's being deliberately dishonest. This claim was tested in every way Ace could think of on this forum, and it failed every test. I quite enjoyed some aspects of arguing with Ace, but since he's not a member now, I can say this: it's clear to me that he's either insane or a liar.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom