Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Interestingly during the 60s photography experts did the same with the capitol monument. The government released a photo "proving" that the anti movement demostration was much smaller than claimed by the anti war movement. Experts were able to prove that judging from the length of the shadow, the photo was taken much later in the day, when the march was disapating.

Moral of the story? Both sides use the same lies.



Yup. One thing I think the American government has learned is that fabricating and distorting information doesn't actually work. They're not good enough at it, and it's quickly uncovered, which harms them.

The only effective way they have of controlling the media is by limiting the information they receive.

Hence why with the Iraq invasion we had the embedded journalist system. It's much easier, and safer, to simply control what gets reported, than it is to fabricate news or lie. After all, if a reporter is embedded with a unit, and you tell them they can't broadcast X because it will endanger the unit, they have a personal interest in complying.

-Gumboot
 
Yup. One thing I think the American government has learned is that fabricating and distorting information doesn't actually work. They're not good enough at it, and it's quickly uncovered, which harms them.
The only effective way they have of controlling the media is by limiting the information they receive.
Hence why with the Iraq invasion we had the embedded journalist system. It's much easier, and safer, to simply control what gets reported, than it is to fabricate news or lie. After all, if a reporter is embedded with a unit, and you tell them they can't broadcast X because it will endanger the unit, they have a personal interest in complying.
-Gumboot

So your telling me fabricated information doesn't work? WMD's didn't work?? The incubator fabrication for Gulf War I didn't work?
Your kidding right?
It works perfectly almost every time! That is why public relations firms are hired to manufacture information for particular interests.
In era of non-accountability there is no harm to speak of.

Controlling news and creating news are a bit different of course. The Pat Tillman and Jessica Lynch stories worked for a few years. :busted
WMD worked!:busted
Incubator worked!

I always liked the statement, "Its not what they say, its what they don't say." The media certainly isn't the watchdog anymore and when there is only reporting and not true investigative journalism, the domestic or foreign policy gets what it needs: a complacent, entertained, half-informed populace that is no threat to bring harm to those responsible.
 
Last edited:
I've just read through this thread and I have one question:

Ace, when are you going to the authorities with this information?

Like our other busibody, moral advisor, LYTE TRIP, I am sure ACE has already gone to the authorities, and just like Lyte (7.5 weeks now Lyte), he is patiently waiting for the authorities to conduct their investigation...cause these things take time ya know.

TAM;)
 
so the proof that the WMD information was actually FABRICATED, MADE UP, by anyone other than a faulty, or unreliable source, is what exactly? DO you think the USG had it made up? if so, who did it, or are you just speculating again.

TAM:)
 
Controlling news and creating news are a bit different of course. The Pat Tillman story worked for a few years.

and was relatively quickly found to be untrue.

WMD worked!

No it didn't, at least not past getting a short term goal of garnering Congressional support for war. At the present though the majority of Americans know that Bush at the very least stretched the truth and simply do not trust the man. This may well bode ill for the next sap who gets to run for Pres. on the Republican ticket. Yeah, it worked so well that Bush is sinking his own people.

Incubator worked!

No it didn't otherwise you'd still believe it.

I always liked the statement, "Its not what they say, its what they don't say." The media certainly isn't the watchdog anymore and when there is only reporting and not true investigative journalism, the domestic or foreign policy gets what it needs: a complacent, entertained, half-informed populace that is no threat to bring harm to those responsible.

Now that I agree with. Since the 80's the News dept's of major networks became just another part of the entertainment industry. 24 hour 'news' stations should have aken up the slack but also have to get advertising and to get advertising they must get ratings and to get ratings they must entertain the masses since the majority within those masses simply do not care to be educated or informed.

Prior to the 80's the news dept's did not have to produce profit and news gathering, investigative journalism in particular, was seen as a noble endevour.

'investigative journalism' now seems to include whether or not Britney Spears is wearing underwear or if Paris Hilton is crying because she was sent to jail.
 
Actually that's a myth.
People claiming it was faked or otherwise manipulated pulled together shots from two different time periods - when the statue was being pulled down and much later in the early evening after the civilian crowds had started to break up. This dishonesty is actually pretty obvious because the atmospheric lighting conditions are completely different. There are indeed wider shots earlier in the day that show a very large crowd present.
-Gumboot

Myth? LOL. Follow the series of photographs.

1. Statue still up
2. Statue still up close
3. Statue down more civilian vehicles than the statue up photos but not thousands of Iraqis in a mass showing.

Please link to the wide angle shot that shows a large crowd present during the toppling of the statue. Thanks.
 
and was relatively quickly found to be untrue.
No it didn't, at least not past getting a short term goal of garnering Congressional support for war. At the present though the majority of Americans know that Bush at the very least stretched the truth and simply do not trust the man. This may well bode ill for the next sap who gets to run for Pres. on the Republican ticket. Yeah, it worked so well that Bush is sinking his own people.
No it didn't otherwise you'd still believe it.
Now that I agree with. Since the 80's the News dept's of major networks became just another part of the entertainment industry. 24 hour 'news' stations should have aken up the slack but also have to get advertising and to get advertising they must get ratings and to get ratings they must entertain the masses since the majority within those masses simply do not care to be educated or informed.

Prior to the 80's the news dept's did not have to produce profit and news gathering, investigative journalism in particular, was seen as a noble endevour.

'investigative journalism' now seems to include whether or not Britney Spears is wearing underwear or if Paris Hilton is crying because she was sent to jail.

Manufactured information was used to sway public/ congressional opinion and you state it didn't work in the case of WMD's of the Iraq War? How can you logically state such a thing and expect us to take you seriously?

The incubator issue didn't work? You have got to be kidding me. I didn't state that the lies would remain truths forever, and therefore work forever.
If those two examples didn't work, we may have not been involved in 2 wars in Iraq! If they didn't work, it would have been investigated and shown to be false. Neither happened and the manufactured information served its purpose. If it served its purpose, then it, in fact, it did work.
 
So your telling me fabricated information doesn't work? WMD's didn't work?? The incubator fabrication for Gulf War I didn't work?
Your kidding right?
It works perfectly almost every time! That is why public relations firms are hired to manufacture information for particular interests.
In era of non-accountability there is no harm to speak of.


Ultimately? No, they don't work.



Controlling news and creating news are a bit different of course. The Pat Tillman and Jessica Lynch stories worked for a few years.



You're obviously not very familiar with either story. The "stories" were invented by the media, not the Government, and the appeared after the government had recounted what actually happened.

See this sort of CT bull[rule8] doesn't work on me because I was following these stories on six different news website AS THEY UNFOLDED. The BS "hero" story the media now claim was invented by the Government was never claimed by the government, and DID NOT EXIST when the events occurred. The media invented it themselves later.




WMD worked!:busted



Yeah WMD worked so well the US Invasion of Iraq met more public protest than any military action since the Vietnam War (and protests for that didn't kick in until well into the war, and were focused on conscription), and turned Bush into the least popular President in US history. A total success.



Incubator worked!


You may have missed it in the last decade and a half, but that little gem of a story was invented by Kuwait, not the US Government.

-Gumboot
 
so the proof that the WMD information was actually FABRICATED, MADE UP, by anyone other than a faulty, or unreliable source, is what exactly? DO you think the USG had it made up? if so, who did it, or are you just speculating again.
TAM:)

Based upon the following information, I think the WMD issue was mostly fabricated.
The Office of Special Plans (OSP), which existed from September 2002 to June 2003, was a Pentagon unit created by Paul Wolfowitz and Douglas Feith, and headed by Feith, as charged by then-U.S. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, to supply senior Bush administration officials with raw intelligence (unvetted by intelligence analysts, see Stovepiping) pertaining to Iraq.[1] An allegedly-similar unit, called the Iranian Directorate, was created several years later, in 2006, to deal with intelligence on Iran.[2]

In an interview with the Scottish Sunday Herald, former CIA officer Larry C. Johnson said the OSP was "dangerous for US national security and a threat to world peace. [The OSP] lied and manipulated intelligence to further its agenda of removing Saddam. It's a group of ideologues with pre-determined notions of truth and reality. They take bits of intelligence to support their agenda and ignore anything contrary. They should be eliminated." (Mackay, 2003)
Seymour Hersh writes that, according to an unnamed Pentagon adviser, "[OSP] was created in order to find evidence of what Wolfowitz and his boss, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, believed to be true—that Saddam Hussein had close ties to Al Qaeda, and that Iraq had an enormous arsenal of chemical, biological, and possibly even nuclear weapons (WMD) that threatened the region and, potentially, the United States. [...] 'The agency [CIA] was out to disprove linkage between Iraq and terrorism,' the Pentagon adviser told me. 'That’s what drove them. If you’ve ever worked with intelligence data, you can see the ingrained views at C.I.A. that color the way it sees data.' The goal of Special Plans, he said, was 'to put the data under the microscope to reveal what the intelligence community can’t see.'" (Hersh, 2003)
Source: Wiki

According to the British newspaper The Guardian, Feith's office had an unconventional relationship with Israel's intelligence services:
The OSP was an open and largely unfiltered conduit to the White House not only for the Iraqi opposition. It also forged close ties to a parallel, ad hoc intelligence operation inside Ariel Sharon's office in Israel specifically to bypass Mossad and provide the Bush administration with more alarmist reports on Saddam's Iraq than Mossad was prepared to authorise.

"None of the Israelis who came were cleared into the Pentagon through normal channels," said one source familiar with the visits. Instead, they were waved in on Mr Feith's authority without having to fill in the usual forms.

The exchange of information continued a long-standing relationship Mr Feith and other Washington neo-conservatives had with Israel's Likud party. [6]

Allegations have also been made that Pentagon employees in the Feith office have been involved in plans for overthrowing the governments of Iran and Syria.[5]

Key points: officials were searching for evidence for what they believed to be true. They didn't believe the truth because of the evidence which is what you would expect from the Sec. of Defense who is willing to support the intel and policy of involvement in Iraq. The OSP then took the evidence, comments from an Iraqi dissident group, among other things to the WH unfettered. Rather strange I would think to bypass the DCI.

"For bureaucratic reasons we settled on one issue, weapons of mass destruction, because it was the one reason everyone could agree on," Mr Wolfowitz tells the magazine.
Source: Independent/UK via Common Dreams
Makes you wonder what those bureaucratic reasons were.

I could throw out the Downing Street Memo as well but I don't have time.

I don't recall seeing much at all about the background of the WMD issues in the U.S. MSM. Bad for business I suppose.
 
A better point would be this, is it possible for a government to control the media, without the people working in the media being aware it? In Soviet Russia, and Nazi Germany it was obvious, party officals dictated what was said, not said, or outright ignored. Are you trying to tell me government could take control of media organisations without the staff being made aware? At what level do this controllers come in at? Who are they?

Ah, yes. Much better, actually. Thanks.
 
Myth? LOL. Follow the series of photographs.

1. Statue still up
2. Statue still up close
3. Statue down more civilian vehicles than the statue up photos but not thousands of Iraqis in a mass showing.

Please link to the wide angle shot that shows a large crowd present during the toppling of the statue. Thanks.



Yes that's the ones. (By the way those are terrible quality)

Notice in the first one (ELS, statue up) the US armoured vehicles are starting to establish a perimeter and there isn't much of a crowd. The colour temperature indicates it is late afternoon on a dusty day.

The second, (MLS, crowd at base of statue) shows a US armoured recovery vehicle approaching the statue. Note the colour temperature is the distinct golden light that in film circles is called "magic hour". It occurs in the last 2 - 3 hours of a day under certain conditions.

The third (ELS, statue down) shows the ARV still in the middle of the square with much more civilian activity and lighter US vehicles now present (Humvees). Note the colour temperature has changed dramatically; the light is now blue, indicating this footage was taken after sunset.

There is a minimum of 2 - 3 hours between the first images and the last.

In addition, I don't have to rely on a few crappy still images. I shot a feature film earlier this year and for whatever reason the Director wanted News footage of these events playing on a TV in the background of a scene (I think it was to establish the setting of the film in relation to date/year). The producer accquired two hours of footage of this event, which I then saw over and over again while we shot the scene for 10 hours.

Here are the facts of what happened:

1. US forces arrived
2. A sizable crowd gathered and spontaneously started to try pull down the statue
3. US forces moved in and assisted in pulling down the statue
4. The crowd celebrated this event and broke up the statue, eventually ripping the head off and dragging it away
5. US forces continued to maintain their perimeter

-Gumboot
 
swing:

so no proof then, just your opinion, formed by your reading of alleged suspicious meetings and committees, using sources such as wiki, etc...

ok...moving on.

TAM:)
 
Yes that's the ones. (By the way those are terrible quality)

Notice in the first one (ELS, statue up) the US armoured vehicles are starting to establish a perimeter and there isn't much of a crowd. The colour temperature indicates it is late afternoon on a dusty day.

The second, (MLS, crowd at base of statue) shows a US armoured recovery vehicle approaching the statue. Note the colour temperature is the distinct golden light that in film circles is called "magic hour". It occurs in the last 2 - 3 hours of a day under certain conditions.

The third (ELS, statue down) shows the ARV still in the middle of the square with much more civilian activity and lighter US vehicles now present (Humvees). Note the colour temperature has changed dramatically; the light is now blue, indicating this footage was taken after sunset.

There is a minimum of 2 - 3 hours between the first images and the last.

In addition, I don't have to rely on a few crappy still images. I shot a feature film earlier this year and for whatever reason the Director wanted News footage of these events playing on a TV in the background of a scene (I think it was to establish the setting of the film in relation to date/year). The producer accquired two hours of footage of this event, which I then saw over and over again while we shot the scene for 10 hours.

Here are the facts of what happened:

1. US forces arrived
2. A sizable crowd gathered and spontaneously started to try pull down the statue
3. US forces moved in and assisted in pulling down the statue
4. The crowd celebrated this event and broke up the statue, eventually ripping the head off and dragging it away
5. US forces continued to maintain their perimeter

-Gumboot

There wasn't thousands. I don't know which news agency claimed that, (I've never heard that claim) but there were clearly more than the 150-200 claimed here.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article2842.htm

I remember while working for a newspaper my boss thought the same thing. I showed him a few photos and some of the CNN footage. Yes they did pull back and show the croud. I can't find all of the photos and video right now, but here's one pic.
http://www.right-thinking.com/images/uploads/statue_debunk.jpg
If I remember correctly the true number was around 700-1000. I think it was closer to 1000. It also depends on how you want to count them. Inside the circle or outside.
 
Last edited:
Ultimately? No, they don't work.
You're obviously not very familiar with either story. The "stories" were invented by the media, not the Government, and the appeared after the government had recounted what actually happened.

See this sort of CT bull[rule8] doesn't work on me because I was following these stories on six different news website AS THEY UNFOLDED. The BS "hero" story the media now claim was invented by the Government was never claimed by the government, and DID NOT EXIST when the events occurred. The media invented it themselves later.
Yeah WMD worked so well the US Invasion of Iraq met more public protest than any military action since the Vietnam War (and protests for that didn't kick in until well into the war, and were focused on conscription), and turned Bush into the least popular President in US history. A total success.
You may have missed it in the last decade and a half, but that little gem of story was invented by Kuwait, not the US Government.

-Gumboot

WMD...did we end up in war? Yep. Success.

So Pat Tillman's family wants the truth from media or the military? Nevermind I know the answer, apparently you don't.
Perhaps you should look into the Congressional Investigation surrounding those two persons. Let me help you get your facts correct.

On April 24, 2007 Jessica Lynch gave congressional testimony before the United States House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform that the Pentagon had erroneously portrayed her as a "Rambo from West Virginia," when in fact, she never fired a shot after her truck was ambushed. (According to her authorized biography, her M-16 jammed.)

Earlier in the day, Pat Tillman's brother Kevin also testified; both he and Jessica Lynch talked about misinformation and hype relating to the battlefield and how the military lied and twisted reality for propaganda purposes. She also met with the Tillman family and compared her incident in Iraq to Pat Tillman's in Afghanistan saying that "Our stories are similar". [1] She began her testimony by noting for the record that her appearance was not politically motivated.

In a prepared statement she said:[24]

* "I believe this is not a time for finger pointing. It is time for the truth, the whole truth, versus hype and misinformation.

* "I am still confused as to why they chose to lie and tried to make me a legend when the real heroics of my fellow soldiers that day were, in fact, legendary....The bottom line is the American people are capable of determining their own ideals of heroes and they don't need to be told elaborate tales.

* "The truth of war is not always easy to hear but it is always more heroic than the hype."
Source: Wiki


As far as the incubator story, Kuwait paid for it and senior executives of Hill and Knowlton in Washington D.C., the biggest global PR firm at the time manufactured it. What is missing? A investigation into the event itself, the story, and the actors. Strange that a manufactured event wouldn't be investigated for its facts or lack thereof. Brent Snowcroft didn't know it was false at the time, but accepted it as fact. It sure helped to sway public opinion though didn't it?
I won't go into the satellite photographs of the Kuwait/Iraq border that is still classified but believed to be false.
Shortly before US strikes began in the Gulf War, for example, the St. Petersburg Times asked two experts to examine the satellite images of the Kuwait and Saudi Arabia border area taken in mid-September 1990, a month and a half after the Iraqi invasion. The experts, including a former Defense Intelligence Agency analyst who specialized in desert warfare, pointed out the US build-up – jet fighters standing wing-tip to wing-tip at Saudi bases – but were surprised to see almost no sign of the Iraqis.

"That [Iraqi buildup] was the whole justification for Bush sending troops in there, and it just didn't exist," Ms. Heller says. Three times Heller contacted the office of Secretary of Defense Dick Cheney (now vice president) for evidence refuting the Times photos or analysis – offering to hold the story if proven wrong.

The official response: "Trust us." To this day, the Pentagon's photographs of the Iraqi troop buildup remain classified.
Source: Christian Science Monitor

Now tell me again about how the media manufactured these stories???
Make sure you use that congressional investigation I presented to counter your statements.

Please stop stating truth as lies. That or update your research before you make comments that are supposedly facts, when they are not and finally stop wasting our time.
 
swing:
so no proof then, just your opinion, formed by your reading of alleged suspicious meetings and committees, using sources such as wiki, etc...
ok...moving on.
TAM:)

TAM, feel free to read up on the entire issue and come to your own conclusion. That or offer up some WMD's. Go ahead and move on.
I can only offer the statements provided by people involved with the issue.
 
Yes that's the ones. (By the way those are terrible quality)

Notice in the first one (ELS, statue up) the US armoured vehicles are starting to establish a perimeter and there isn't much of a crowd. The colour temperature indicates it is late afternoon on a dusty day.

The second, (MLS, crowd at base of statue) shows a US armoured recovery vehicle approaching the statue. Note the colour temperature is the distinct golden light that in film circles is called "magic hour". It occurs in the last 2 - 3 hours of a day under certain conditions.

The third (ELS, statue down) shows the ARV still in the middle of the square with much more civilian activity and lighter US vehicles now present (Humvees). Note the colour temperature has changed dramatically; the light is now blue, indicating this footage was taken after sunset.

There is a minimum of 2 - 3 hours between the first images and the last.

In addition, I don't have to rely on a few crappy still images. I shot a feature film earlier this year and for whatever reason the Director wanted News footage of these events playing on a TV in the background of a scene (I think it was to establish the setting of the film in relation to date/year). The producer accquired two hours of footage of this event, which I then saw over and over again while we shot the scene for 10 hours.

Here are the facts of what happened:

1. US forces arrived
2. A sizable crowd gathered and spontaneously started to try pull down the statue
3. US forces moved in and assisted in pulling down the statue
4. The crowd celebrated this event and broke up the statue, eventually ripping the head off and dragging it away
5. US forces continued to maintain their perimeter

-Gumboot

Please offer up the photographic record that presents 1000's of supporters or "sizable crowd" in the square.
Where is the proof big guy?
 
Swing said:
TAM, feel free to read up on the entire issue and come to your own conclusion. That or offer up some WMD's. Go ahead and move on.
I can only offer the statements provided by people involved with the issue.

So it's either there were WMDs in Iraq or it was fabricated ?

Aren't you missing one ?
 
Please offer up the photographic record that presents 1000's of supporters or "sizable crowd" in the square.
Where is the proof big guy?


There's a piece in the documentary "Obsession: Radical Islam's War Against The West" towards the end. Otherwise I suppose you could do as we did and go buy some footage off CNN. It was quite expensive.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom