Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

I'll cut to the chase.

Let's say that there are 4 possibilities. I believe the photo is real, but:

1) the photo is real: leave the woman alone

2) the photo is real but slightly enhanced: leave the woman alone

3) the photo is partly faked: leave the woman alone

4) the photo is completely faked: leave the woman alone

Nothing rides on the validity of the photo.

I agree. She should be left alone. If the photo is fake, the historical record should be changed.
 
Thanks for the video links Swing. But, is there a photograph from the website you gave a link to depicting airline crashes which shows a plume since you said it's where you started? Tks.
 
Interesting. That is the best way to find out the truth from American politicians. Expect the opposite of what they say and you won't be disappointed!;)

As far as Val photo, that looks nothing like smoke from an airline crash that I've ever seen. Also one of her neighbor's daughter's stated to Shure on the phone that it was a fake.
If I were a bettin' man, I would put money on it being a fake.
The plane exploded on impact. Do you need to see photos of clouds from explosions? I think you can picture those.
 
Swing: re-RUSH

I am not a fan of their music, but I admire them for their longevity. geddy lee was on "The Hour" last night, and it was a very entertaining interview.

TAM:)
 
Swing...now you have lost me again. Please tell me you are not flirting with Killtown territory...the man is mad...I mean if I interviewed him, I would wager money he is committable.

TAM:)
 
Swing...now you have lost me again. Please tell me you are not flirting with Killtown territory...the man is mad...I mean if I interviewed him, I would wager money he is committable.

TAM:)

I've heard him during an internet radio show interview. From a chronological standpoint, it may be a year or two before he's legally recognized as a man.
 
Swing...now you have lost me again. Please tell me you are not flirting with Killtown territory...the man is mad...I mean if I interviewed him, I would wager money he is committable.

TAM:)

Nope. Not yet. ;)
IMHO, I think a plane was shot down. You know the whole debris field measured in miles which would account for the lack of debris at the site itself.

I just do not think the Val photo is legit.

From a chronological standpoint, it may be a year or two before he's legally recognized as a man.
My wifes been saying the same thing the last 15 years! That is the key to longevity, refusing to grow old.
 
Yes, certainly a possibility. As the possibility exists that the intelligence was manipulated or outright manufactured. International examination of the issue was ignored of course as well as the Iraqi governments own statements.
Not only that the prior statements of Condi Rice and Colin Powell:





Relevant press confrences

History has shown that the assessments made then were truthful and factual.

IMHO, the amount and types of WMD's he supposedly had would have been very difficult to hide or move considering the intel we supposedly had on the country. The IAEA was ignored as well.


Taking all of those items into consideration along with the forged documents on the Republic of Niger and the yellow cake fiasco, the Rmackey plausibility of manipulated and manufactured evidence is substantially higher than the plausibility that they had 'em and moved 'em.
Just War theory for the public's consumption, and political realism as fact.



The forged documents, AS YOU KNOW, played no role whatever in the assessment by British intelligence alluded to by Bush in his infamous (but entirely accurate!) sixteen words.

Christopher Hitchens has written several essays on lyin' Joe Wilson that discuss this issue in depth (available on Slate.com).



I'm still waiting for you to back up your character attack again or please link to this lie you claim I made. Something you never are able to do. And you may want to examine the congressional examination I linked to in regards to the Tillman/ Lynch story.

Here is a timeline of the Lynch story, Pom. Get your facts straight. You can read more on the making of the myth here at Newsweek.
Or is that how you post here: find one statement, attack it with your own opinion, and then ignore the moderator's requests to attack the argument and not the person all the while ignoring everything else. All you have to do is examine her statements to the Congressional investigators as to who lied and who didn't and the purpose it served.


You're the only one who is waiting. People catch you lying all the time on SLC and you always try to squirm out. The spin on the Jessica Lynch story unraveled, AS YOU KNOW, very quickly. It is understandable that someone, whether a journalist or a representative of the military, would try to puff up the misfortunes of this young woman. That sort of myth-making is common to all wars. The truth became known very quickly. You are not making any point here.


So in other words, no you can't link or provide any immediate source to support your claim. And I'm surprised stills can't be offered from the video. I would have thought those would have been posted years ago to stifle criticism.

This statement of course ignores the historical reality of the Bush Administration.
Again why would you want Iran and the world to think you had WMD's by stating that you don't. By allowing IAEA and the UN to search for them? You


And sadly he did the political thing instead of the correct thing.


The notion that Bush promised to find weapons he KNEW he wouldn't find is insane. Pols try to win elections, not lose them.
 
Thanks for the video links Swing. But, is there a photograph from the website you gave a link to depicting airline crashes which shows a plume since you said it's where you started? Tks.



Perhaps this one.
 

Attachments

  • ukraine-crash.jpg
    ukraine-crash.jpg
    15.9 KB · Views: 0
Nope. Not yet. ;)
IMHO, I think a plane was shot down. You know the whole debris field measured in miles which would account for the lack of debris at the site itself.

I just do not think the Val photo is legit.


My wifes been saying the same thing the last 15 years! That is the key to longevity, refusing to grow old.


Oh dear God. Please no. Not again. I don't think I can take another one.

-Gumboot
 
As far as Val photo, that looks nothing like smoke from an airline crash that I've ever seen.
That's far from the only thing to look for. Take a look at how the cloud of smoke is integrated into the scene; does the lighting look about right? Is the perspective correct? Things of this sort are also important in judging the legitimacy of a photo if tampering is suspected for some reason.

IMHO, I think a plane was shot down. You know the whole debris field measured in miles which would account for the lack of debris at the site itself.
And the debris for the shuttle Columbia was in the hundreds of square miles; size of the debris field in and of itself does indicate whether the aircraft was shot down or not. You'll need more corroborating evidence than that.
 
You're the only one who is waiting. People catch you lying all the time on SLC and you always try to squirm out. The spin on the Jessica Lynch story unraveled, AS YOU KNOW, very quickly. It is understandable that someone, whether a journalist or a representative of the military, would try to puff up the misfortunes of this young woman. That sort of myth-making is common to all wars. The truth became known very quickly. You are not making any point here.

Well my gosh Pom, if I lie all the time, then you should have no problem posting proof, correct?

I posted the timeline, do you agree it was quickly?
Quick enough to prevent a movie in the making and a book? That is certainly very fast, isn't it.

I'm assuming this is the link you are referring to from Slate


Hmm lets look at a relevant passage from FactCheck.org
Wilson reported that he had met with Niger's former Prime Minister Ibrahim Mayaki, who said that in June 1999 he was asked to meet with a delegation from Iraq to discuss "expanding commercial relations" between the two countries. Based on what Wilson told them, CIA analysts wrote an intelligence report saying former Prime Minister Mayki "interpreted 'expanding commercial relations' to mean that the (Iraqi) delegation wanted to discuss uranium yellowcake sales."

I wish we knew exactly what Wilson told him.

Let me summarize: Wilson says so the CIA says that Mayki (whose country has had close and friendly relations with the U.S. since independence) say's he interpreted commercial relations meant uranium yellowcake sales.

Pom, why do you think it took hearsay based upon an interpretation about a an enemy from an ally to make the "16 words".
Throw on top of that "crack intel", the desire to invade Iraq, the forged Italian documents, the AL-Q links, and even you should be able to see a repeating pattern here for the bogus justifications for war.

Do you ever contemplate who would forge documents that might be used to lead our country to war?

When was Bush's press conference to the world retracting the "16 words" and explaining to the world why they were spoken and why they are being retracted? I may have missed that one. I've read Rice and Tenet's explanation but not the man who said it.

The notion that Bush promised to find weapons he KNEW he wouldn't find is insane.
Yes and so is lying to a city about its air quality which results in death is pretty crazy too, but darn it, POM, they did it anyway.

I don't know if I should interpret your response as defending this Administration or not. But I hope not. I'm going to appeal to emotion for a bit but when I see friends return home from Iraq maimed and some not return home at all, I find your position rather appalling and disgusting.
 
And the debris for the shuttle Columbia was in the hundreds of square miles; size of the debris field in and of itself does indicate whether the aircraft was shot down or not. You'll need more corroborating evidence than that.

Did Colombia break up in the air and scatter debris for miles or did it hit the ground and then scatter debris for miles? A bit of a difference don't you think?
Take a look at how the cloud of smoke is integrated into the scene
I did and the anomaly I find is the lack of continuity of dark burning jetfuelA especially to ignite the woods next to the impact site.

Based upon other plane crashes and the interview with the community member I'm still convinced the photo is fraudulent.

Sorry for the delay, DGM....The plane exploded on impact. Do you need to see photos of clouds from explosions? I think you can picture those.
I'm not aware of explosions that were suppose to be plane crashes. As I've stated, I think the plane was shot down as opposed to a full body impact into the ground.

It's funny that you insist to compare these completely unrelated accidents to the Shanksville crash when you so carelessly dismissed the picture I showed you of the WTC2 plane hit.
The comparison you offered was a plane hitting a tower. The comparisons I offered were of planes hitting the ground. Which is more relevant to the Val's photo?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom