Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

There wasn't thousands. I don't know which news agency claimed that, (I've never heard that claim) but there were clearly more than the 150-200 claimed here.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article2842.htm



Yes. I would consider a crowd of 1,000 civilians in a warzone quite sizable. Auckland couldn't even muster that many people to protest the invasion when the global protest day occurred. Needless to say we didn't have a war going on. At the very least one can conclude that the local Iraqi population supported the toppling of this statue considerably more than Aucklanders were against the war.

-Gumboot
 
So Pat Tillman's family wants the truth from media or the military?


You do realise that Tillman's family were told how he was killed (friendly fire) within weeks of the event occurring, yes?



Perhaps you should look into the Congressional Investigation surrounding those two persons. Let me help you get your facts correct.


With all due respect to Lynch, I've seen her interviewed. She's not very bright. Just because she says The Pentagon portrayed her as a "Rambo" doesn't make it true. She was, after all, in a hospital bed and most likely wasn't watching CNN. I was following the story. I have never seen the military portray her as a hero. I have never seen the military portray her rescue as some elaborate scene from a Tom Clancy film. What I have seen is the media criticise the military's rescue operation (BBC), and the military defend it. And I have seen the media go into a hero frenzy over the event (most notably ABC and FOX).

Within 24hrs of her rescue I had learned from the media (through CENTCOM press conferences, mainly):

1) That Lynch was rescued from a hospital
2) That an Iraqi civilian had attempted to deliver her to the US but had been shot at
3) That the Iraqi civilian provided substantial intel to the USA before any rescue attempt was made
4) That the hospital Lynch was recovered from was empty of Iraqi troops when the rescue occurred
5) That no shots were fired inside the hospital during the rescue
6) That there was a brief exchange of fire between perimeter defense forces outside the hospital and Iraqi forces during the rescue
7) That the ambush Lynch was captured in occurred because the US forces screwed up and got lost
8) That they were not prepared for any sort of combat action, were taken by surprise, and offered no real resistance

Why is it, if I knew all this in New Zealand by April 2, 2003, that the rest of the world was mysteriously oblivious to these facts until now?

-Gumboot
 
Swing:

you misunderstand. I have no doubt that the WMD info given to the administration was at the very least, grossly exaggerated, and perhaps even completely false.

1. should we really equate bad info on WMDs with not finding them? In other words, even if the intelligence concerning the presence of said weapons was top notch, it still does not guarantee we would have found them.

2. I will throw at you, the same argument that needs to be provided each and everytime a truther brings it up. If 9/11 was orchestrated by the USG admin as a pretext to the war in iraq then (A) Why were non of the patsy hijackers iraqi, and (B) why didnt they just plant the WMDs and some lab equipment...would have been fairly easy to do, for a superpowerful NWO evil Neocon Cabal.

TAM:)
 
The WMD thing certainly isn't clear cut. All we know for sure is:

1) Iraq had illegal WMD at some point
2) The USA claimed they still had them in 2003
3) The USA has not found any WMD in Iraq

One explanation is that Iraq never had WMD in 2003, the USA knew this, made up the intel anyway, and thus cannot find any.

But there's plenty of other possibilities:

A) The intel could all have been spot on, Iraq did have them, but the USA just can't find them.
B) The intel was all wrong, but Iraq did have WMD that the USA didn't know about, and the USA can't find them.
C) The intel was all wrong, but the USA genuinely thought it was correct, and now they have no WMD to find.
D) ...And so forth.

You get the idea.

-Gumboot
 
How about Iraq had them, but moved them or hid them...a possibility, correct?

TAM:)
 
How about Iraq had them, but moved them or hid them...a possibility, correct?

TAM:)



Yes. There's an endless number of possibilities. My personal opinion is that the actual situation was:

Iraq didn't have any substantial WMD by 2003, but wanted the world (Iran) to believe it did, so it pretended it did. It played a big game of bluff with the USA, just as it had in the decade previous with the UN. If the USA was convinced Iraq had WMD that would go a long way towards convincing Iran they had them. Of course it all backfired because Bush wasn't Clinton, and post 9/11 wasn't pre 9/11. Saddam's bluff failed and the USA invaded on the false information Saddam had offered up.

The fundamental question is, did the USA at all suspect that some of their intel was nothing more than Saddam pretending he had WMD? Did they know it was a sham and decided to act anyway? Or did Saddam's sham fool them?

I think it's a bit of both. I suspect US intelligence were undecided. Some thought he really did have WMD, some thought it was possible, some thought it was unlikely, some thought there was no way he had them.

The Administration wanted to invade, so it used the intel and people that supported its contention, and pushed aside the rest.

I think, for example, that Colin Powell genuinely thought Iraq had WMD. I think Bush and friends, looking at the intel, behaved much like Truthers watching YouTube videos. They saw what they wanted to see. They didn't deceive intentionally, but they didn't look critically. They looked with an agenda.

-Gumboot
 
yah, I agree. I doubt, when presented with the intel, that BUSH did any sort of double check on it.

As for Powell, he was interviewed recently on just this topic, and claims that the suspicions some had on the quality of the intel were not made known to him until the night before the UN address.

TAM:)
 
yah, I agree. I doubt, when presented with the intel, that BUSH did any sort of double check on it.

As for Powell, he was interviewed recently on just this topic, and claims that the suspicions some had on the quality of the intel were not made known to him until the night before the UN address.

TAM:)



Yup. And in 2004 he claimed he wasn't aware at the time that some in the intelligence community doubted the intel. That was when he called for a big shake up of the intelligence community and the creation of a National Intelligence adviser who would ensure whatever one knew, everyone knew.

-Gumboot
 
So your telling me fabricated information doesn't work? WMD's didn't work?? The incubator fabrication for Gulf War I didn't work?
Your kidding right?
It works perfectly almost every time! That is why public relations firms are hired to manufacture information for particular interests.
In era of non-accountability there is no harm to speak of.



As I have often observed, you are one of the more egregious liars in the fantasy movement. On SLC, you established a pattern of whining that people are always calling you a liar without providing evidence for the claim. People there found it amusing that you would invariably start bleating right after someone had exposed one of your lies.



Controlling news and creating news are a bit different of course. The Pat Tillman and Jessica Lynch stories worked for a few years. :busted


Yes, you are most certainly busted. The Jessica Lynch story attracted almost immediate attention and the truth came out in matter of weeks. Lynch herself disclaimed any heroic behavior on her part. The Tillman story came under scrutiny rather quickly, an investigation was announced, and the verdict on his tragic death was reached with no political pressure.



WMD worked!:busted

Yes, it worked extremely well for the Democrats. According to myth, Bush, sitting atop personal approval ratings in the high seventies, announced that he would find WMD that he KNEW he wouldn't find. Predictably, his polls melted like a snowfall in May and he was hammered 24/7 by his enemies. Had the Dems nominated an electable candidate in 2004, the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy's brilliant scheme would have cost them an election they stood to win in a landslide.
Most children figure out that liars expect to benefit from their lies and they don't expect to get caught. The left's Big Lie, an insult to everyone's intelligence, maintains that the evil Bushies crafted a lie that was certain to be exposed, thereby eliminating the possibility of deriving any benefits from it. You don't have to approve of Bush to reject blatant nonsense.




Incubator worked!

Sure it did. Most people never heard of the claim that Iraqis pulled Kuwaiti infants from their incubators. I suppose that Saddam's invasion of a sovereign state was actually quite gentle, and America was just being an imperialist bully in derailing his benevolent aims. You are a hopeless sap.



I always liked the statement, "Its not what they say, its what they don't say." The media certainly isn't the watchdog anymore and when there is only reporting and not true investigative journalism, the domestic or foreign policy gets what it needs: a complacent, entertained, half-informed populace that is no threat to bring harm to those responsible.


You don't begin to comprehend the truth in what you've just posted.
 
There is no tail number discernible in any of the links or pictures posted here thus far.
Considering that in most cases the tail numbers are not very large, and considering the distances involved, not being able to see them does not strike me as unusual or unexpected.
 
How about Iraq had them, but moved them or hid them...a possibility, correct?

TAM:)

Yes, certainly a possibility. As the possibility exists that the intelligence was manipulated or outright manufactured. International examination of the issue was ignored of course as well as the Iraqi governments own statements.
Not only that the prior statements of Condi Rice and Colin Powell:

Powells press conference on 24 February 2001 during Powell's visit to Cairo, Egypt. Answering a question about the US-led sanctions against Iraq, the Secretary of State said:
We had a good discussion, the Foreign Minister and I and the President and I, had a good discussion about the nature of the sanctions -- the fact that the sanctions exist -- not for the purpose of hurting the Iraqi people, but for the purpose of keeping in check Saddam Hussein's ambitions toward developing weapons of mass destruction. We should constantly be reviewing our policies, constantly be looking at those sanctions to make sure that they are directed toward that purpose. That purpose is every bit as important now as it was ten years ago when we began it. And frankly they have worked. He has not developed any significant capability with respect to weapons of mass destruction. He is unable to project conventional power against his neighbors. So in effect, our policies have strengthened the security of the neighbors of Iraq...

On 29 July 2001, Condoleezza Rice appeared on CNN Late Edition With Wolf Blitzer (an anonymous reader sent me the full transcript from Lexis-Nexis). Guest host John King asked Rice about the fact that Iraq had recently fired on US planes enforcing the "no-fly zones" in Iraq. Rice craftily responds:

Well, the president has made very clear that he considers Saddam Hussein to be a threat to his neighbors, a threat to security in the region, in fact a threat to international security more broadly.
Notice that she makes it clear that Bush is the one who considers Hussein a threat. She doesn't say, "I consider..." or even, "We consider..."
Then King asks her about the sanctions against Iraq. She replies:
But in terms of Saddam Hussein being there, let's remember that his country is divided, in effect. He does not control the northern part of his country. We are able to keep arms from him. His military forces have not been rebuilt.
King doesn't think to ask Rice, if Hussein hasn't been getting arms and his forces weren't rebuilt after the 1991 Gulf War, why Bush considers him a threat.

Relevant press confrences

History has shown that the assessments made then were truthful and factual.

IMHO, the amount and types of WMD's he supposedly had would have been very difficult to hide or move considering the intel we supposedly had on the country. The IAEA was ignored as well.

Taking all of those items into consideration along with the forged documents on the Republic of Niger and the yellow cake fiasco, the Rmackey plausibility of manipulated and manufactured evidence is substantially higher than the plausibility that they had 'em and moved 'em.
Just War theory for the public's consumption, and political realism as fact.


Pom-As I have often observed, you are one of the more egregious liars in the fantasy movement. On SLC, you established a pattern of whining that people are always calling you a liar without providing evidence for the claim. People there found it amusing that you would invariably start bleating right after someone had exposed one of your lies.
I'm still waiting for you to back up your character attack again or please link to this lie you claim I made. Something you never are able to do. And you may want to examine the congressional examination I linked to in regards to the Tillman/ Lynch story.

Here is a timeline of the Lynch story, Pom. Get your facts straight. You can read more on the making of the myth here at Newsweek.
Or is that how you post here: find one statement, attack it with your own opinion, and then ignore the moderator's requests to attack the argument and not the person all the while ignoring everything else. All you have to do is examine her statements to the Congressional investigators as to who lied and who didn't and the purpose it served.

Gumboot-
There's a piece in the documentary "Obsession: Radical Islam's War Against The West" towards the end. Otherwise I suppose you could do as we did and go buy some footage off CNN. It was quite expensive.
So in other words, no you can't link or provide any immediate source to support your claim. And I'm surprised stills can't be offered from the video. I would have thought those would have been posted years ago to stifle criticism.
They didn't deceive intentionally, but they didn't look critically.
This statement of course ignores the historical reality of the Bush Administration.
Again why would you want Iran and the world to think you had WMD's by stating that you don't. By allowing IAEA and the UN to search for them? You

Tam-As for Powell, he was interviewed recently on just this topic, and claims that the suspicions some had on the quality of the intel were not made known to him until the night before the UN address.
And sadly he did the political thing instead of the correct thing.
 
well if we were going to hang the BUSH Admin based on "Character", the Gallows would be full.

TAM:)
 
well if we were going to hang the BUSH Admin based on "Character", the Gallows would be full.

TAM:)

I agree, however, perhaps we should hang the Bush Admin based upon their record surrounding domestic and foreign policy.
 
in that case, the govt of almost every nation would have their leaders hung. Shall I make a list...lol

TAM:)
 
in that case, the govt of almost every nation would have their leaders hung. Shall I make a list...lol

TAM:)

:big: :lolsign:

I thought Canada's leader was ok. I haven't seen him in the news much.

WAAAY off topic, but are you a Rush fan and if so whats your latest thought on the album?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom