Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Media Matters is far left. I'm not familiar with The Daily Howler, but based on what I just read, praise for the rabid Paul Krugman, it's no different.

Your dismissal of those websites isn't any different from a truther dismissing NIST or Purdue because of "government funding."

It should be easy for you to dispute a page or two of each without resorting to emotional, prejudicial language (as in calling Paul Krugman rabid).
 
You're on about this, right?

No, I'm not sure why it looks darker at the opening, although since this is the exact plane we're looking at, tail number N612UA, I'd guess it's because the dark underbelly is banked toward the camera at first and then there's more glare on the plane (from the sun being more directly behind the camera) as it's closer to hitting. That's just a guess though.

The plane appears darker for a time because it flies into the shadow of the WTC1 smoke plume, and then out of it just before it hits. Example:
4miq7q1.jpg


UA175 can also be seen passing into the shadow here:
 
Care to share your story about your work with Al-J? Were you stationed in the Mid East or were you working from the States?

No I freelance in their london bureau. I was offered a post in Doha, but that would have involved living in a country with Sharia law and getting married to my long term girlfriend, who would have had to move over there, and do what? Besides it's June in london now, and I'm miserable in this heat, what the hell would I be like in a desert, I'm just a sweaty red faced Irishman.

Annoyingly, as the discuss about taking the job, continued with her, she asked "So why aren't we married?" I couldn't come up with an excuse fast enough, and six months later...*

But Al J english, is honestly an atonishing news organisation, they plundered the best out of every news organisation in the world when setting up, it's chock full of ex BBC. Its extremely together, hell they had the operating budget to spent months, rehearsing, a tv station working at full capacity and not broadcasting. One of my first days there Michael Stone decided to wage a one man war on the newly reopened Northern Ireland Assembly in Stormont, and hell this, Arabic language station tracked down and did a fifteen minute interview with his biographer, in New York. They have 19 bureaus in Africa, where most english language stations have at most three.




*Just kidding I love my wife dearly, and besides if she sees I'm repeating this stupid joke again, she will disembowl me.
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

And I'm crazy?

ROTFLMAO
Crazy? I'm not qualified to say. Immature though? Beyond measure.
 
No I freelance in their london bureau. I was offered a post in Doha, but that would have involved living in a country with Sharia law and getting married to my long term girlfriend, who would have had to move over there, and do what? Besides it's June in london now, and I'm miserable in this heat, what the hell would I be like in a desert, I'm just a sweaty red faced Irishman.

Annoyingly, as the discuss about taking the job, continued with her, she asked "So why aren't we married?" I couldn't come up with an excuse fast enough, and six months later...*

But Al J english, is honestly an atonishing news organisation, they plundered the best out of every news organisation in the world when setting up, it's chock full of ex BBC. Its extremely together, hell they had the operating budget to spent months, rehearsing, a tv station working at full capacity and not broadcasting. One of my first days there Michael Stone decided to wage a one man war on the newly reopened Northern Ireland Assembly in Stormont, and hell this, Arabic language station tracked down and did a fifteen minute interview with his biographer, in New York. They have 19 bureaus in Africa, where most english language stations have at most three.
*Just kidding I love my wife dearly, and besides if she sees I'm repeating this stupid joke again, she will disembowl me.


Would you have been paid more to work in Doha as a free lancer?
As a freelance video editor, would you agree that the press in general does things to manipulate public opinion on particular issues?

The classic current events example is the photo of the public square in Baghdad and the toppling of the statue of SH. The close ups and the write up made it sound like the entire city was there. In reality it was only a couple hundred of people.

BTW, Go Irish! I'll raise a glass of mead to that country any day! Off topic of course, but any dramatic experiences in Norther Ireland?
 
Your disagreement with assertions that are supported by overwhelming evidence strongly suggests that you are wrong.
If you are trying to pretend that the mainstream media in this country has not been outrageously partisan in its hostility to Bush, you have to argue with liberal critics such as Evan Thomas and Joe Klein. They don't like Bush, but they deplore the total abandonment of any pretense to neutrality by people who call themselves "journalists." You seem unaware of several academic studies showing the overwhelming preponderance of liberal Democrats in the media. Perhaps you'd care to explain this one: abortion is an issue that divides America into two warring halves (I am pro-choice, incidentally). The percentage of mainstream network news anchors and commentators who are anti-abortion is exactly ZERO. Ninety-two percent of the White House Press Corps supported John Kerry in 2004. Stop playing this silly game.
Does it tell you anything that Fox is a) not a major network and b) the only exception you can think of?
This has gotten off-topic. That being said, I will not be lectured about: being "wrong," nor playing a "silly game." It is you who are remarkably misinformed, no small irony considering the discussion central to this thread.
 
TamSo we have a VIDEO EDITOR who has worked for multiple media outlets, telling ACE his ideas are essentially hogwash, yet ACE, songwriter/entertainer extrordinaire, still feels he is right, and the expert is wrong.

With all do respect, I wouldn't consider a freelance video editor an expert on the inner workings of media outlets corporate boardrooms or senior editor's decisions . I would however consider him an experienced editor of digital media.
 
yes I agree, please drag it out to the politics pen.

As for the rest, well, what was the original focus of the discussion again?

TAM:)
 
swing:

the major premise of TS1234 claim concerns the digital imagery we saw on 9/11 and how he feels it was faked...hence, 8den is an expert for the OP.

TAM:)
 
Would you have been paid more to work in Doha as a free lancer?

You'll excuse me, if I don't go into the jist of my salary etc. I turned down a staff position before salary negotiations took place. But seeing as it was tax free, and accomadation was arranged and paid for, and salaries were being offered to woo people from established jobs, well, it was going to be a generous offer.

As a freelance video editor, would you agree that the press in general does things to manipulate public opinion on particular issues?

The classic current events example is the photo of the public square in Baghdad and the toppling of the statue of SH. The close ups and the write up made it sound like the entire city was there. In reality it was only a couple hundred of people.

Thats a loaded question, I know for example that certain papers when writing up that incident, were more than a little cynical at event, viewing it as a PR student, I remember the Guardian being one of those papers. Media organisations have different bias and slants and individual journalists, and cameraman and editors bring their own personal philosophy and opinion to a story and can add a futher spin to story.

BTW, Go Irish! I'll raise a glass of mead to that country any day! Off topic of course, but any dramatic experiences in Norther Ireland?

Before my time I'm afraid, I was still in college when the Good Friday agreement was signed. My Dad on the other hand was in Derry during Bloody Sunday, and UWC Strike. I'm an editor, mate, I'm for the comfy chair, and air con, and the cup of tea. Let the cameramen go out like hunter gathers and bring me the footage. The closest I got to action, was working as a cameraman on a low budget documentary, in Genoa, during the G8 riots in 2000. I ripped my knee up pretty badly when I crashed into a concrete bollard, while I was blinded by tear gas. I can remember lying on the ground whimpering to myself and thinking "Avoiding this kind of situation, is why you got into editing in the first place".
 
With all do respect, I wouldn't consider a freelance video editor an expert on the inner workings of media outlets corporate boardrooms or senior editor's decisions . I would however consider him an experienced editor of digital media.

On the contray major decisions and debates occur exactly there, in the edit suite. If I'm working on a significant or contraversal story, the lawyers, the producers, or even the head of the station will come in and the discussion will be had then and there.

Its 24 news mate, and theres no time to strike a beta or dvd, and bring it the exe's. They come to you, and they look at the footage, they may need to look at the orignal rushes and see if theres an alternative sound bite, or if the soundbite thats used is used in the correct context.

For an example I was in the room when a tv station found out about the relationship between the Fertilizer bomb plot members, and the July 7th London bombers was discovered. Within an hour every journalist and pretty much everyone working in news in london knew about it. This was nearly a full year before the press were allowed to report on it. Hell before they were convicted I wouldn't even dared type that sentence and publish it on a message board.
 
Yeah. That's what makes the lack of eyewitnesses so odd. I am not aware of very many humans at all who have gone on the record and said they saw a plane. There are some, and 95% of them work for news organizations.

Yeah, sure.

Then you have a number of people who said they saw the south tower explode. Then there's all the problems with the impact videos. They look distinctly "unphysical". No breaking, no crushing, no twisting, no bending, no slowing, no parts bouncing off.

They look unphysical to you because you know nothing of the physics involved.

The tail???? The tail of the airplane goes right through steel? The wingtips?

Perhaps, perhaps not.

You guys have got to be kidding me. Either you're lying, or you believe in impossible things.

There are other possibilities, that you seem unable or unwilling to consider.

Ron, you don't disagree that it is possible in theory for a government to control the news media, do you? The old Soviet Union controlled its media, right? The Nazis completely controlled their media, right?

It is possible in theory. You don't control what people see live, however.
 
Last edited:
As for the guy who survived the 175 impact, is he a liar. He states he watched the plane come toward the building, and hence the reason he was able to leap under his desk, which saved him. Is he a liar? A paid Shill?

This is someone who Ace should listen to. I remember his story but can't recall his name.
 
9:02
South Tower, 81st Floor, Fuji Bank, 57 minutes to collapse

Yes, Stanley Praimnath told the caller from Chicago, he was fine. He had actually evacuated to the lobby of the south tower, but a security guard told him to go back. Now, he was again at his desk at Fuji Bank. "I'm fine," he repeated.

As he would later tell his story, those were his final words before he spotted it.

A gray shape on the horizon. An airplane, flying past the Statue of Liberty. The body of the United Airlines jet grew larger until he could see a red stripe on the fuselage. Then it banked and headed directly toward him.

Another one.

"Lord, you take over!" he remembers yelling, dropping under his metal desk.

At 9:02:54, the nose of the jetliner smashed directly into Mr. Praimnath's floor, about 130 feet from his desk. A fireball ignited. Steel furnishings and aluminum plane parts were torn into white-hot shrapnel. A blast wave hurled computers and desks through windows, and ripped out bundles of arcing electrical cables. Then the south tower seemed to stoop, swinging gradually toward the Hudson River, ferociously testing the steel skeleton before snapping back.

Through most of both towers, the staircases were tightly clustered, and in the north tower, they were all immediately severed or blocked by the blast. Along the impact zone of the south tower, floors 78 to 84, however, the stairs had to divert around heavy elevator machinery. So instead of running close to the building core, two of the stairways serving those floors were built closer to the perimeter. One of them, on the northwest side, survived. A report in USA Today this month also suggested that the surviving stairway might have been shielded by the machinery.

However the stairway survived, it made all the difference to Stanley Praimnath, who, huddled under his desk, could see a shiny aluminum piece of the plane, lodged in the remains of his door.

found here, but can be found lots of other places...

http://www.theagitator.com/archives/001050.php

TAM:)
 
It is possible in theory. You don't control what people see live, however.

A better point would be this, is it possible for a government to control the media, without the people working in the media being aware it? In Soviet Russia, and Nazi Germany it was obvious, party officals dictated what was said, not said, or outright ignored. Are you trying to tell me government could take control of media organisations without the staff being made aware? At what level do this controllers come in at? Who are they?
 
The classic current events example is the photo of the public square in Baghdad and the toppling of the statue of SH. The close ups and the write up made it sound like the entire city was there. In reality it was only a couple hundred of people.



Actually that's a myth.

People claiming it was faked or otherwise manipulated pulled together shots from two different time periods - when the statue was being pulled down and much later in the early evening after the civilian crowds had started to break up. This dishonesty is actually pretty obvious because the atmospheric lighting conditions are completely different. There are indeed wider shots earlier in the day that show a very large crowd present.

-Gumboot
 
Actually that's a myth.

People claiming it was faked or otherwise manipulated pulled together shots from two different time periods - when the statue was being pulled down and much later in the early evening after the civilian crowds had started to break up. This dishonesty is actually pretty obvious because the atmospheric lighting conditions are completely different. There are indeed wider shots earlier in the day that show a very large crowd present.

-Gumboot

Interestingly during the 60s photography experts did the same with the capitol monument. The government released a photo "proving" that the anti movement demostration was much smaller than claimed by the anti war movement. Experts were able to prove that judging from the length of the shadow, the photo was taken much later in the day, when the march was disapating.

Moral of the story? Both sides use the same lies.
 
I've just read through this thread and I have one question:

Ace, when are you going to the authorities with this information?
 
On the contray major decisions and debates occur exactly there, in the edit suite. If I'm working on a significant or contraversal story, the lawyers, the producers, or even the head of the station will come in and the discussion will be had then and there.

Its 24 news mate, and theres no time to strike a beta or dvd, and bring it the exe's. They come to you, and they look at the footage, they may need to look at the orignal rushes and see if theres an alternative sound bite, or if the soundbite thats used is used in the correct context.

For an example I was in the room when a tv station found out about the relationship between the Fertilizer bomb plot members, and the July 7th London bombers was discovered. Within an hour every journalist and pretty much everyone working in news in london knew about it. This was nearly a full year before the press were allowed to report on it. Hell before they were convicted I wouldn't even dared type that sentence and publish it on a message board.



I was just about to say something along these lines, but you beat me to the punch, and your insight is more relevant.

In my experience in the film side of things, the central positions around which every single major decision is made are:

PRE-PRODUCTION - Production Manager
PRODUCTION - First Assistant Director
POST-PRODUCTION - Editor

In some cases these people will know of things that the Producer and Execs (and even Director!) never find out. In most other cases, they find out first.

And herein lies the thing... people who don't work in these fields often don't appreciate that the ground level, where the day to day action happens, is the stuff the Government would need to control in order to cover things up. The people at the top have very little (if any) influence over the ground level operations.

It's simply not possible to control the media without reporters and cameramen and presenters and technicians and editors and content directors knowing about it. Which means, in order to control the media, the government has to control literally thousands upon thousand upon thousands of people. Millions, if you want to include international media.

This simply can't be done. In an industry where many of those people are freelancers, not employees, it's absolutely impossible. In an industry where exactly that sort of thing is the story that journalists dream about, even attempting to exert that sort of control would be total suicide.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom