Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

The major networks are heavily-biased in favor of the Democrats, the party that OPPOSES Bush and his policies. I understand that you are incapable of discerning a difference between the Bush Administration and its critics, but you, it must be remembered, are insane.
Except for Fox of course.
 
Taco, my hypothetical question was about viewing UA175 from the other side. I did not make a mistake. Hypothetically, if viewed from the east, looking west, at around 9:00 am, in full sunlight, with buildings facing us lit up brightly, what color would UA175 appear?

Would you care to answer?


You're on about this, right?

No, I'm not sure why it looks darker at the opening, although since this is the exact plane we're looking at, tail number N612UA, I'd guess it's because the dark underbelly is banked toward the camera at first and then there's more glare on the plane (from the sun being more directly behind the camera) as it's closer to hitting. That's just a guess though.
 
Corsair has also discussed what she feels is expected behavior for camera operators in an unexpected situation. If you were filming firefighters talking in the street, and all of a sudden you heard an incoming jet above you, where would you point the camera?
How quickly and how accurately a camera would track in on something unusual depends on the ability of the operator. I would expect a professional news cameraman to do so much more capably than an amateur.

Black or very dark.
You want to hear something really weird in the whole "how visible is an object in the sky" train of thought? Try this on for size: during WWII, one of the ways U-boat hunting aircraft were camouflaged to help prevent the U-boat crews from spotting them was by hanging lights on the aircraft.

Sounds completely counter-intuitive doesn't it? Putting lights on the aircraft should make it easier to spot not harder, right?

Any guesses as to why lights actually made the aircraft harder to see rather than easier?

The tail???? The tail of the airplane goes right through steel? The wingtips?
Did you know there are these things called waterjet saws which use an extremely fast-moving jet of liquid water which can cut through steel? Water - water! - can cut through steel if it's moving fast enough. Given this, why is it surprising that something much harder than liquid water can also penetrate steel if it's also moving fast enough?

Ron, you don't disagree that it is possible in theory for a government to control the news media, do you? ...Can you at least agree that it is possible for a central government to control the news media and use it as a propaganda machine?
Except, of course, that the United States is not the only country in the world with news media.

In Canada there are three national broadcast networks, each with their own news divisions: Global, CTV, and CBC. Then there are two 24-hour news networks, CBC Newsworld and CTV Newsnet. In Ontario, there's the regional pseudo-network City-tv with its own news department (admittedly, covering mostly its own region but nonetheless they have their own news division). It also runs its own 24-hour channel version called CP24. The there's the provincial TVOntario (it's sort of like PBS) which, while not doing daily news, does have current affairs programs (check out The Agenda, a very fine program and a great example of how a current affairs and discussion program should be done).

Then in the newspaper department, you've got The Globe & Mail, The National Post, The Toronto Star, and The Toronto Sun all competing for readers in the Toronto market. That's not to mention all the dailies in other cities.

And that's not to mention all the news media in other countries (I'll let the citizens of those countries post the relevant lists).

I couldn't select the frame where the plane disappears but I doubt that this happens. There's no practical reason why a half competent FX artist would make such a mistake and so it's probably just an illusion caused by the compression and the plane colour matching the building.
That's what I thought too at first, but every time I paused the video at the right point it sure looked like the body of the jet had disappeared though the wing was still visible against the sky. The colouration and tonal qualities of the building looked unchanged, and I would have expected some sort of change where the aircraft body overlapped it. And I couldn't see any change.

Also, after seeing what I thought was the jet disappearing as it passed in front of the building it hit in single frames, when I played the video at normal speed I swear I could then see the jet disappearing in real-time also. But it happens very quickly, and the jet is in front of the building for only a few frames at most.

Thank heavens, I'm not the only one after all!

As for the DH4 trailer, the most obvious CG car is the one that flies through the air sideways, narrowly missing our heros who are standing between two other cars and the falling car impacts the parked cars rather than Bruce Willis. Every car in that scene is CG.
The thing that got me was the big tractor-trailer truck which smashes into a car causing it to go spinning through the air and yet there wasn't so much as a scratch on the front of the truck. I'm guessing CGI cars weigh a whole lot less than real cars. :D
 
Last edited:
That would be completely aweful. I cant even imagine it. Each time I see the footage I get a horrible chill down my spine and to this day its still something I still shake my head in utter disbelief at. Its a scale of terror unimaginable.

But I imagine in bakers world, she is either a shill, never saw it/lying or something else.

You wonder why there is violence in society....

Very well put. Can you imagine putting this person in contact with a deranged, agenda-driven psycho who wants to intensify this unimaginably horrible experience by calling her a liar?

You could line up hundreds of eyewitnesses and Ace would attempt to discredit each of their accounts. It's the tactic used by Holocaust-deniers: two aged camp-survivors talk about a particularly sadistic guard. One remembers the guard being right-handed; the other thinks he was left-handed. Aha! That proves they are lying and the Holocaust is a myth.

Civility is a virtue to be prized, but sometimes the sheer rockheaded evil of these bastards is just too much to take.
 


Well for one, the underside of UA175 was painted dark blue. And secondly, if you're looking at it with the sky in the background, the sky is going to raise the overall exposure level for the camera, so it will close down the aperture to compensate, thus making the aircraft appear dark.

This can (and usually is) compensated by use of a polarising filter which prevents polarised light from reaching the CCD.

The sky consists entirely of polarised light; with a polarising filter that cuts out ALL polarising light the sky will appear black, even on a sunny day.

With the sky significantly darkened by the polarising filter, the camera will open the aperture to compensate, and the aircraft will appear brighter.

I have never seen a news cameraman use a polarising filter.

Also, for what it's worth, polarisation is more noticeable when the camera has the sun behind it.

-Gumboot
 
so when are we going to see Ace's paper on the other 43 shots? Since he failed with his first one....


btw, my aunt and uncle are reitrees (my uncle being a mechanic). My aunt teaches japanese privately in her spare time. My cousin is perpetual student
 
Can someone explain to me why so much time is wasted on the mad ravings of a truly deluded individual?
I can't speak for anyone else, but I would say there is value in getting accurate information out there. There is value in combatting incorrect versions of events. It's a service for all the lurkers out reading the threads, for those still able to be persuaded by evidence, facts, and well-reasoned points.
 
Personally, although really stupid, I actually enjoy these sorts of arguments much more, because they relate directly to my field. Most 9/11 specific topics are outside my field.

-Gumboot
 
Truthseeker1234 said:
Ron, you don't disagree that it is possible in theory for a government to control the news media, do you? ...Can you at least agree that it is possible for a central government to control the news media and use it as a propaganda machine?

Ace would you care to explain how the central government controls the news media?

Keep in mind you'll be talking to someone whose worked for Bloomberg, Sky News, CNN, the BBC, and Al Jazeera.* So I'm more than aware of the structures and organisation of several different news stations.

gumboot said:
Personally, although really stupid, I actually enjoy these sorts of arguments much more, because they relate directly to my field. Most 9/11 specific topics are outside my field.

Yeah, me too, personally after all this discussion about dynamic loads, stress levels, and net force equaling 0! It's just a pleasure to discuss something that I can speak about with a degree of authority**. Its nice knowing that my liberal arts education wasn't a complete waste

*that someone would be, er, me.

**I pretty much bow out to veterans like gumboot and shrinker though.
 
Corsair has also discussed what she feels is expected behavior for camera operators in an unexpected situation. If you were filming firefighters talking in the street, and all of a sudden you heard an incoming jet above you, where would you point the camera?

You do realize that many individuals when in that exact situation would forget that they have a camera and their EYES, not the CAMERA, would be pointed towards the jet.

Ever watch videos on youtube when someone crashes or some other unexpected event occurs. In many of those videos the camera falls to the videographers side and the video sucks because the camera man is watching the event with his EYES at that point. Not the video camera.
 
Why would they do this?

In order for the shots to match, the helicopter shot had to have been planned precisely to match the angle of the pre-recorded aircraft plate. So why not just record both plates in advance and broadcast the composited VT? There is simply no logical explanation whatsoever for doing this live - something which adds enormous unnecessary complications

That would be in line with the NWO M.O., wouldn't it ?
 
Ace would you care to explain how the central government controls the news media?

Keep in mind you'll be talking to someone whose worked for Bloomberg, Sky News, CNN, the BBC, and Al Jazeera.* So I'm more than aware of the structures and organisation of several different news stations.

In what capacity? Reporter, senior editor, cameraman, corporate board member, president, owner? I'm curious as I've never met someone who claimed to work somewhere to prove a point of expertise but not state what job they performed.
 
Ever watch videos on youtube when someone crashes or some other unexpected event occurs. In many of those videos the camera falls to the videographers side and the video sucks because the camera man is watching the event with his EYES at that point. Not the video camera.



Actually the instinctive action of capturing a sudden event on camera is exceedingly rare because, as you pointed out, most people want to see for themselves what is going on, and a camera does not offer very good situational awareness.

The best news cameramen succeed specifically because they possess that rare trait that makes them get the right shot.

-Gumboot
 
In what capacity? Reporter, senior editor, cameraman, corporate board member, president, owner? I'm curious as I've never met someone who claimed to work somewhere to prove a point of expertise but not state what job they performed.

My bad, sorry, video editor.
 
You're on about this, right?

No, I'm not sure why it looks darker at the opening, although since this is the exact plane we're looking at, tail number N612UA, I'd guess it's because the dark underbelly is banked toward the camera at first and then there's more glare on the plane (from the sun being more directly behind the camera) as it's closer to hitting. That's just a guess though.

There is no tail number discernible in any of the links or pictures posted here thus far.
 
So we have a VIDEO EDITOR who has worked for multiple media outlets, telling ACE his ideas are essentially hogwash, yet ACE, songwriter/entertainer extrordinaire, still feels he is right, and the expert is wrong.

And the moral of this story is?

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom