Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Wait for it...

Five...

Four...

Three...

420kitten.jpg
 
Um what? Sorry what? Finally I can truly grasp how baffling and bizarre the 911 truth movement is to engineers and architects when truthers try and speak in their language.

Teh stupid burnz, it does.
 
You need to read their posts again for comprehension. The actual compositing itself takes time, and cannot be done "real time".

-Gumboot

Compositing video in real time has been done since the 1960's. For you all to suggest that video compositing is "impossible" in real time is just silly.
 
Compositing video in real time has been done since the 1960's. For you all to suggest that video compositing is "impossible" in real time is just silly.
Well, sure, if you mean stuff like the weatherman standing in front of his weather map. But that stuff is not exactly photorealistic is it? I mean, it's pretty easy to spot that kind of effect.

For what you're talking about, you need special effects of a quality like you'd find in a feature film. Think ILM and you'll get the idea. Those aren't done in real-time. And, as I alluded to earlier, a good eye can spot even those effects. Which is why I asked you the movie-related questions I did earlier, to try and gauge how good your eye might be at detecting motion picture quality visual effects. I note you did not see fit to try and answer those questions.
 
Compositing video in real time has been done since the 1960's. For you all to suggest that video compositing is "impossible" in real time is just silly.

For you to suggest that a composited video looks anything like what was seen on 911 is what is silly.

I'll ask you again if you or anyone else has tried to reproduce the kind of effect you imagine was used in 2001. Do you have any idea of the complexity? The man hours it would take? The sheer impossibility of fooling anyone with such techniques?
 
I've heard back from Eric Salter. Yes, the frames were de-interlaced as I said, every other field was discarded, interpolation between scan lines.

It is not reasonable to think that odd and even fields were discarded at random. De-interlacing algorithms do not do this. Rather, it will pick either the odds, or the evens, to discard.

The challenge to produce a similar fake video with a real time overlay is a good one, but I don't have the gear. My point is that they didn't do a perfect job, it appears that they used old school technology. However, do bear in mind that the SportVision software was operational in 1998.

The control case is the way to go. If legitimate videos show the same kinds of anomalies that Chopper 5 shows, you will have made your point, and I will admit that my graphs show only measurement error. Is that fair enough?
 
lol, if it was real it would be the size of a model airplane. Obviously fake.

Now Ace, explain how the second 9/11 WTC crash was videotaped by dozens (at the very least) of people with their camcorders from all over NYC if it was fake... you really have no idea how batguano crazy your theory is, do you? You really should get professional help.
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

And I'm crazy?

ROTFLMAO
 
lol, if it was real it would be the size of a model airplane. Obviously fake.

Now Ace, explain how the second 9/11 WTC crash was videotaped by dozens (at the very least) of people with their camcorders from all over NYC if it was fake... you really have no idea how batguano crazy your theory is, do you? You really should get professional help.



He really doesn't understand that he's ill. All these technicians cooperating with their ideological opposites to hide a monstrous and fantastic crime, and Ace sees nothing strange.

All those eyewitnesses are lying.

You are terribly disturbed, Ace.
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

And I'm crazy?

ROTFLMAO


Yes, that the exposure of your preposterous lies reduces you to fits of deranged laughter is a sure indication that you are crazy.
Your imaginary "dustified" steel was, in reality, tons of steel that required months to haul away. Your nonsensical garbling of common scientific terms shows your incompetence to discuss these matters. Now it's "thousands of motor vehicles"? Seek help, Ace: you are ill.
 
It's a little hard to be definitive since the video is a low-resolution, grainy YouTube video which makes many of the normal cues harder to see - it'd be much easier with a high-resolution, TV broadcast-quality image.

That said, I noticed the following:

First, the smoke trail from the jet just looks, well, wrong somehow. The lighting doesn't seem right on it for one thing. Second, the way the jet maneuvers is little odd also, it doesn't quite look like the way a real jet would move. An addendum to that fact is that the pilot doesn't even try to avoid the building, indeed, it looks like he made a beeline for it. A real pilot would do everything in his power to miss a building.

Third, and a most telling clue, is that the moment the jet begins to cross in front of the building, it disappears! You can still see its wing silhouetted against the sky but the body of the jet is not visible in front of the building. If you pause the video right at that point this becomes apparent. Fourth, and another telling clue, is that when you can still people in frame none of them are reacting at all to the jet. An aircraft flying that low and close is most unusual and people would naturally look towards the sound.

And lastly, in spite of the camera being handheld, the camera does not shake or otherwise do any of the expected shaking or shuddering one would expect an amateur cameraman to do when confronted with a crash and explosion right in front of them. Indeed, the operator stands quite still and holds the camera quite steadily all things considered.

Final verdict (based on the low-quality YouTube version): not real. The explosions are nicely done though.
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!
And your explanation would be...?
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

And I'm crazy?

ROTFLMAO


Does this mean you are ready to continue the discussion regarding steel estimates?
 
It's a little hard to be definitive since the video is a low-resolution, grainy YouTube video which makes many of the normal cues harder to see - it'd be much easier with a high-resolution, TV broadcast-quality image.

That said, I noticed the following:

First, the smoke trail from the jet just looks, well, wrong somehow. The lighting doesn't seem right on it for one thing. Second, the way the jet maneuvers is little odd also, it doesn't quite look like the way a real jet would move. An addendum to that fact is that the pilot doesn't even try to avoid the building, indeed, it looks like he made a beeline for it. A real pilot would do everything in his power to miss a building.

Third, and a most telling clue, is that the moment the jet begins to cross in front of the building, it disappears! You can still see its wing silhouetted against the sky but the body of the jet is not visible in front of the building. If you pause the video right at that point this becomes apparent. Fourth, and another telling clue, is that when you can still people in frame none of them are reacting at all to the jet. An aircraft flying that low and close is most unusual and people would naturally look towards the sound.

And lastly, in spite of the camera being handheld, the camera does not shake or otherwise do any of the expected shaking or shuddering one would expect an amateur cameraman to do when confronted with a crash and explosion right in front of them. Indeed, the operator stands quite still and holds the camera quite steadily all things considered.

Final verdict (based on the low-quality YouTube version): not real. The explosions are nicely done though.

Corsair, some nice observations,like the plane disappearing. I think the camera was tripod mounted, not handheld.
I think this fake video might make a nice study, to see if stabilizing it smooths out the velocity line, or makes it more jagged. I'm not sure, but I think that might be real video of a real jet at an airshow, with background removed and laid on top of the video of the buildings. I'm not sure.

You mentioned lighting not quite being right. Hmmmmm. . . .

What color was UA175? And what color should it appear in full sunlight?
 
Last edited:
I Fourth, and another telling clue, is that when you can still people in frame none of them are reacting at all to the jet. An aircraft flying that low and close is most unusual and people would naturally look towards the sound.

Yes! Corsair, excellent point! People would look up and react to the sound! Keep this in mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom