Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

The simple reality is there only needs to be a margin of error of +/- 1.5 pixels for TS1234's entire conclusion to totally collapse, and as many experts in the field of film/video/effects have repeatedly demonstrated, there are ample opportunities for this degree of error in the analysis.

-Gumboot
 
OK, maybe there is a little more to discuss.

Dave, when you resort to putting words in my mouth, you expose the weakness of your own position. I say the halo and artifacts are more pink in all the frames. In the case of frame 7, it's also that very obvious swatch of "digital paintbrush".

So you're suggesting that, as if the halo left round the plane wasn't enough, the conspirators added a bit more pink in frame 7 to make things even more obvious? And that it never occurred to them that sky colour varies? Why did they leave the halo in the first place?

The camera shake in the live shot would not be known, thus it would not be "trivial to reproduce" in the overlay shot. Random errors in this case can either accumulate or cancel out, on a frame-by-frame basis. They were betting that any instability measured in the velocity could just be dismissed as measurement error.

Now you're mis-stating both my position and yours. The amplitude of the camera shake in the live shot would, indeed, be trivial to reproduce; just take a live shot from the same camera and helicopter a few days before. I suspect nobody would have noticed a news helicopter over New York on an average day. Specific errors in a particular frame would, indeed, be impossible to predict - that's exactly my point. However, your statement that "they were betting that any instability measured in the velocity could just be dismissed as measurement error" is in direct contradiction to your entire hypothesis - that the conspirators deliberately introduced camera shake to the plane video to cancel out the camera shake on the live shot, but overdid it.

The problem with this idea that the conspirators introduced shake to the plane video to match the shake in the live video is that nobody with the slightest rudimentary understanding of the statistics of random errors would think for one moment that such a procedure could possibly do anything but increase the variation in airplane position from frame to frame. Your hypothesis is therefore flawed in that it supposes that nobody involved in this plan had as much as a first-year college level science education. I'd try to explain more clearly, but since you've already failed to pick up on the statement that random errors accumulate, I suspect there's too great a gap in your science education to bridge here.

Planes certainly do not agree with all the eyewitnesses, e.g. we have a number of first responders who said the south tower exploded and did not hear or see a plane. We also have at least one on-scene news reporter.

You yourself have called Alt+F4 a liar for saying she saw the plane hit the tower, because you say she was on the wrong side of the tower to see it hit. Therefore, by your own assertion, one would expect at least half the witnesses not to see a plane, because half were on the wrong side of the tower and at least some of the rest would have been looking in another direction and would only have looked round at the sound of the impact. You're bright enough to figure this out for yourself; what other option than dishonesty is left, when you still say that because some people didn't see the plane, there wasn't one?

The video composite theory has the advantage of actually fitting the data.

Not in any meaningful form, i.e. it isn't predictive. You haven't constructed a line of argument of the form "If the video was not composited, we would see A (or not see B); we do not see A (or do see B) therefore the video was composited." You have simply advanced a hypothesis which you claim is compatible with your preferred interpretation, yet on further analysis your hypothesis has some serious flaws.

The issue of possible measurement error is valid. I propose that version 2 of the paper will include control studies of both a legitimate video, and also a known composite video, each with similar resolution and compression as the Chopper 5.

I propose that version 1 of the paper should have included those features.

Dave
 
A real plane, on a stabilized video, cannot speed up and slow down frame by frame. It is physically impossible.

It should be fairly easy to test that assumption. Try getting some footage of random planes flying through the air, process the footage by saving it in various different formats, and see if it is indeed impossible for this to happen.

This is called testing the null hypothesis, and is a very important step for any investigation. The above-described test represents the MINIMUM you should do before making bold pronouncements that something is impossible.
 
It should be fairly easy to test that assumption. Try getting some footage of random planes flying through the air, process the footage by saving it in various different formats, and see if it is indeed impossible for this to happen.

This is called testing the null hypothesis, and is a very important step for any investigation. The above-described test represents the MINIMUM you should do before making bold pronouncements that something is impossible.

Not only should one check the raw video in several formats by also re-recorded video from one format to another.

In fact of course, one could only get such video of slower moving aircraft but if the pixel change is still consistent with what Ace found it proves the point I would think, that it is the analysis that is incorrect.
 
Oooh, it must be really annoying to him that so many people who know video technology better than he does are taking him apart.
I think so!

And even those of us who know SQUAT about video technology are taking him apart qucker'n a 4-year-old can stomp a sand castle.
 
Money awaits any who can provide uncompressed video of significant 9/11 events.

Ring APTN, CNN, Reuters, Sky, any tv news company, and ask for their archive department, they should be able to provide a copy of the footage on Beta SX, or even on another tape format. For a fee.

Ace working as a tv news editor, and I've worked with the archived news feeds of the tower being hit. NONE of what you claim you can see on your blurry Youtube nonsense is on these copies.
 
PS, I've put many CGI planes into filmed shots. Evening winning awards for such acts. If you'd like to learn the truth about these processes fire away.
Well, if TS doesn't ask, then I will. Can you give us a rundown of the basics involved in performing that task of inserting a CGI element into a pre-existing filmed or videotaped scene?
 
Well, if TS doesn't ask, then I will. Can you give us a rundown of the basics involved in performing that task of inserting a CGI element into a pre-existing filmed or videotaped scene?

Shrinker is way way way way more qualifed than I to answer this. But I'll give you the general jist.

it's impossible to do real time. Not only does the software to do this not exist, if you're planning on adding a composite to a shot at a later date, it's generally a good idea to plan this during the shoot. In terms of lighting etc.

Essentially you need to create an alpha channel matte of the object you want to insert

image_1.jpg


This is done to blend the pixels to along the two images you want to composite. This creates a still matte, which you insert between the two images, to merge them. But it's a still, a static image which means as the object you're inserting (in the above case a motorcylist) moves, you need to track the matte, to match the objects new position.

Which is to say, pick a point on the matte, generally of high contrast, for the matte to follow, using a process called tracking. It's a slow labourious process. Oh and when you've done it all, you need to render it, a process that is not real time. And certainly wasn't real time in any professional software available in 2001.

Cosair if you want to read about the maths, go here it's where I nicked that image from, I freely admit to still be going through my copy of "adobe aftereffects classroom in a book", and the maths is well beyond me.
 
I was just looking over Ace's web page. I don't recall anyone else here mentioning this, but I think it is relevant. (At least, relevant to type of analysis. Ace's interpretation is farking nuts anyway.)

I see no mention of deinterlacing in Ace's work. De-interlacing an NTSC (or PAL) video signal to display on progressive scan screen can cause the edge of the object to wiggle - depending on the de-interlace method used.

If you just mash the two 240 line fields into one frame, then you will get the most extreme problem. The two fields are taken 1/60 of second apart. Moving objects will therefore show position differences between the two fields. This will make the edges of the object look like the teeth of a comb. The faster the object moves, the longer the "teeth" will be.

At Ace's measured 20 pixels per frame for the airplane, that's going to give you "teeth" ten pixels long. When you then compress the video, those "teeth" will be smeared together. You will in effect have an indistinct outline of the plane, which may be anywhere up to 10 pixels from where it appears to be.

If a more sophisticated de-interlace method is used, things don't really improve for Ace. The more sophisticated methods eliminate the comb teeth, but they tend to move the objects a few pixels. Depending on just how each field pair lines up, the de-intelacer may decide to align the image to first the even field or to first the odd field.

In one frame, your object may align to the odd fields. The next frame may align to the even field. In this case, you would get a significant apparent slow down, namely a drop of half of the measured travel distance between the two frames. The other way is just as bad. If the de-interlacer aligns in one frame to the even and in the next frame to the odd, you will get an apparent speed up of the same magnitude.

So, de-interlacing in whatever form is going to be a problem for measurements. And that's ignoring the problems you can get into if the de-interlacer is started one field off. That is, if your video starts on an even frame and the de-interlacer doesn't compensate.

Even worse, the comments others have made about video compression are quite correct. MPEG compressed video stores only some frames completely. Others are stored as a sort of mathematical description of the differences. Typically, you might have one complete frame followed by four that will be calculated.

Part of that "mathematical description" is an approximation of the motion of the objects visible. This motion compensation is a further source of error in Ace's calculations that he has not bothered to account for.

The motion compensation in the compressed video will not be perfect. The objects don't all move at the same speed, and there is (as always) a tradeoff of accuracy against computation power. More accuracy takes more time for compression, and more space in the finished file. In heavily compressed videos from YouTube, the number of calculated frames will be higher, thus each frame will have even more potential for error.

It is, therefore, quite reasonable that only the full frames in the compressed video will show object in their correct positions. Reasonable and expected, except by Ace.


Anything else? Well, the thousands of witnesses, but Ace doesn't count them. He can't line them up on his monitor and make them lie the way he can torture a video into telling his Truth.


Ace:
I had to read this post three times to be sure that I comprehended the main points MortFurd makes. It appears as though he knows vastly more about the subject than you do. Tell us what obvious errors he is committing.
 
What 8den wrote applies only to stills or individual frames of video each of which would have to be composited and rendered. This would be laborious today and very much more so in 2001 and as pointed out, pretty much impossible to manage real time in a digital world.

In the analog world of 3/4 inch tape and analog video feeds Ace suggests that using the background sky as the chroma to key in the aircraft layer but a sky, especially near the horizen is most certainly not monochromatic. Ok there are key systems that allow a range of color phase to be selected in chroma key but now you have the problem of having any area on the foreground building containing a window (for eg.) with a chroma component that is within that wider phase 'window'. If that occurs then the plane would show up in that window.

Next there is the problem of having to slow the plane down so that what exits the other side is not travelling at 500 MPH and once again this has to be done in real time, on every single video simultaneously and then also done , perhaps later, on every other video of the event, and, then you have to alter all videos of the south face as well and insert a plane hitting the building.

Is this what you expect us to swallow Ace?
 
OK, maybe there is a little more to discuss.



So you're suggesting that, as if the halo left round the plane wasn't enough, the conspirators added a bit more pink in frame 7 to make things even more obvious? And that it never occurred to them that sky colour varies? Why did they leave the halo in the first place?
To get it to blend with the background. Anyone who has done any picture manipulation runs into this problem. You don't want a razor sharp cutout, instead you want a blend. Best to have the blend on the sky, not the plane.


Now you're mis-stating both my position and yours. The amplitude of the camera shake in the live shot would, indeed, be trivial to reproduce; just take a live shot from the same camera and helicopter a few days before. I suspect nobody would have noticed a news helicopter over New York on an average day. Specific errors in a particular frame would, indeed, be impossible to predict - that's exactly my point. However, your statement that "they were betting that any instability measured in the velocity could just be dismissed as measurement error" is in direct contradiction to your entire hypothesis - that the conspirators deliberately introduced camera shake to the plane video to cancel out the camera shake on the live shot, but overdid it.
No, Dave. The point is to analyze the velocities, and reconstruct the most likely method by which the video was created. Whether the camera shake was intended, or unintended, or more than what was planned, is all interesting, but somewhat beside the point.

The problem with this idea that the conspirators introduced shake to the plane video to match the shake in the live video is that nobody with the slightest rudimentary understanding of the statistics of random errors would think for one moment that such a procedure could possibly do anything but increase the variation in airplane position from frame to frame.
Again Dave, you're putting words in my mouth. I never said they were trying to "match the shake in the live video".

Your hypothesis is therefore flawed in that it supposes that nobody involved in this plan had as much as a first-year college level science education. I'd try to explain more clearly, but since you've already failed to pick up on the statement that random errors accumulate, I suspect there's too great a gap in your science education to bridge here.
Strawman. My hypothesis does not suppose any such thing. I explained how I think they put that video together, and it fits the data. I explained how the data do not support it being a legit video. Your complaint here is based on the words you put in my mouth.

You yourself have called Alt+F4 a liar for saying she saw the plane hit the tower, because you say she was on the wrong side of the tower to see it hit.
She's the one who said she was north of the towers, not me.

Therefore, by your own assertion, one would expect at least half the witnesses not to see a plane, because half were on the wrong side of the tower and at least some of the rest would have been looking in another direction and would only have looked round at the sound of the impact. You're bright enough to figure this out for yourself; what other option than dishonesty is left, when you still say that because some people didn't see the plane, there wasn't one?
False. Strawman. I never said any such thing. Dave, you're smarter than this. When you resort to this tactic, you make us think you're not confident on the science.

Not in any meaningful form, i.e. it isn't predictive. You haven't constructed a line of argument of the form "If the video was not composited, we would see A (or not see B); we do not see A (or do see B) therefore the video was composited." You have simply advanced a hypothesis which you claim is compatible with your preferred interpretation, yet on further analysis your hypothesis has some serious flaws.
False. I have so constructed a line of argument. If the video was not composited, we would see a straighter graph line after stabilizing than before.

I propose that version 1 of the paper should have included those features.
We'll call this "version 0.5" then. Thank you for peer review. You have made points that are well taken, and require further work on my part. If control videos of similar quality graph as I think they should, it will support my thesis. If they don't, it won't. Take your strawmen and go try to scare crows.
 
Last edited:
What 8den wrote applies only to stills or individual frames of video each of which would have to be composited and rendered. This would be laborious today and very much more so in 2001 and as pointed out, pretty much impossible to manage real time in a digital world.

In the analog world of 3/4 inch tape and analog video feeds Ace suggests that using the background sky as the chroma to key in the aircraft layer but a sky, especially near the horizen is most certainly not monochromatic. Ok there are key systems that allow a range of color phase to be selected in chroma key but now you have the problem of having any area on the foreground building containing a window (for eg.) with a chroma component that is within that wider phase 'window'. If that occurs then the plane would show up in that window.

Next there is the problem of having to slow the plane down so that what exits the other side is not travelling at 500 MPH and once again this has to be done in real time, on every single video simultaneously and then also done , perhaps later, on every other video of the event, and, then you have to alter all videos of the south face as well and insert a plane hitting the building.

Is this what you expect us to swallow Ace?

No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .

. . .9/11.

Please just read the paper and learn how I think it was done. Then come and criticize it. But at least learn how I think it was done.
 
No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .

. . .9/11.

Please just read the paper and learn how I think it was done. Then come and criticize it. But at least learn how I think it was done.


And the Bush-hating liberal Democrats in the media are willing accomplices in this insanely convoluted scheme?

They created videos to promote a war they oppose?

And the people who SAW the plane crash into the building are liars?

And you can still out-shout the experts in the field even though you know next to nothing?
 
No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .



You need to read their posts again for comprehension. The actual compositing itself takes time, and cannot be done "real time".

-Gumboot
 
On Mortfurd:

I do discuss interlacing in the paper, maybe Mortfurd missed it. I don't discuss how it was de-interlaced, because I don't know. I've sent a mail to Eric Salter, to see if he knows how this particular video was de-interlaced.

I believe the video was de-interlaced by discarding even numbered fields, and interpolating between scan lines, because there is no "double vision" effect, and very little motion-blur. The apparent horizontal position of the plane then would not be affected, because the interpolation runs vertically, between horizontal scan lines.

Whatever method was used, the same method was used for the whole video. Thus whatever it does, it does consistently. Thus with de-interlacing, we don't really have a mechanism to explain destabilizing the motion of the plane.

The test of this, again, is control cases. If similar quality videos graph as I expect, it will support my thesis. If they don't, it won't.

I'll monitor this thread to see if any new information comes, otherwise I'll report back when I have control cases, and perhaps some other 9/11 videos as well.
 
I think so!

And even those of us who know SQUAT about video technology are taking him apart qucker'n a 4-year-old can stomp a sand castle.
How did our music expert video man get the original tape of the video?

How did he get the original version? You have to have the original version to do any useful work. The first cut, original not copied version has to be used. If not he is fired from this work.
 
The test of this, again, is control cases. If similar quality videos graph as I expect, it will support my thesis. If they don't, it won't.

One would assume that before all the work was done, even a simple thesis would be inappropriate.

You say thesis, we say irrational, preconceived opinion. Tomayto, Tomahto, huh?
 
On Mortfurd:

I do discuss interlacing in the paper, maybe Mortfurd missed it. I don't discuss how it was de-interlaced, because I don't know. I've sent a mail to Eric Salter, to see if he knows how this particular video was de-interlaced.

I believe the video was de-interlaced by discarding even numbered fields, and interpolating between scan lines, because there is no "double vision" effect, and very little motion-blur. The apparent horizontal position of the plane then would not be affected, because the interpolation runs vertically, between horizontal scan lines.

Um what? Sorry what? Finally I can truly grasp how baffling and bizarre the 911 truth movement is to engineers and architects when truthers try and speak in their language. On what possible basis do you suggest that the delacing occured in the manner you suggest.

Whatever method was used, the same method was used for the whole video. Thus whatever it does, it does consistently. Thus with de-interlacing, we don't really have a mechanism to explain destabilizing the motion of the plane.

The test of this, again, is control cases. If similar quality videos graph as I expect, it will support my thesis. If they don't, it won't.

I'll monitor this thread to see if any new information comes, otherwise I'll report back when I have control cases, and perhaps some other 9/11 videos as well.


i really don't see how it's possible to look at a mpeg compressed video
and guess whether it was interlaced.

No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .

. . .9/11.

Please just read the paper and learn how I think it was done. Then come and criticize it. But at least learn how I think it was done.

But ace again this defies all rational knowledge of what occured on 911 for your situation to exist it means all 41 cameras played out prerecorded vt. It also means all live feeds were frame accurately synch'd which means you're preincluding dozens of technicans in tv stations into the conspiracy theory.

Ace could you explain how this occured? A top notch visual effects company is hired to design the VFX of a plane crashing into the twin towers. The dozens of people involved in the project keep stum. Then on the day, helicopter pilots manage to hover at the exact specific location so the switch to pre recorded material isn't seen as odd. And then at the preplanned moment, they switch to pre planned vt, assured that the missile (or maybe there wasn't a missile) crashes into the building. And the dozens of VT engineers in these tv stations don't notice this insane redesign of how feeds come in? Or don't comment on them?

WHY. ARE. WE. EVEN. ENTERTAINING. THIS. NONSENSE? Theres a conspiracy theorist on an irish forum I'm on who thinks Aleister Crowley is George W Bush's grandfather that makes more sense than this.
 
WHY. ARE. WE. EVEN. ENTERTAINING. THIS. NONSENSE? Theres a conspiracy theorist on an irish forum I'm on who thinks Aleister Crowley is George W Bush's grandfather that makes more sense than this.

Wait for it...

Five...

Four...

Three...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom