Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

You are sick. I should put him in touch with you. You can see the video from 2 blocks away and explain to him what killed his wife. He's on the phone with her in the video.
My goodness, please don't. He's been through more than I can imagine, and the thought of Ace calling him a liar on top of this is just unthinkable. I see what kind of creature Ace is, offering money to someone for a tape like this. Un-frikkin-believable! Yeah, just full of compassion and understanding, aren't we? Of course, it's all just part of his "professional" investigation.
 
Honestly Ron, I know myna birds that repeat themselves less than you. "Ace Baker's insane". "Ace Baker's insane". "Squawk".


You are incapable of grasping my point. It is that you are seriously ill. Continuing to disparage you--something I am guilty of--creates an unpleasant spectacle that helps no one. You are reasonably articulate and you seem to prize civility. But, you display a severe cognitive disorder.

Possibly you are a megalomaniac who believes that he is able to compete on even terms with experts in any field. Your glaring ignorance of the technical subjects you attempt to discuss makes you a ridiculous figure, forever arguing bumptiously to promote nonsensical theories. You never display a scintilla of self-awareness. It never occurs to you that the people whose knowledge dwarfs your own REALLY DO know much more than you do. The reason they can pick apart your wild fantasies is that they actually understand the relevant material.

Here is the impasse we can't hope to get around, the central delusion that no amount of rational pleading can affect: You simply deny that the judgments of people who possess the professional expertise that you conspicuously lack are superior to your uninformed speculations. To you, such people are not your betters; they aren't even your peers. No, you will instruct them by pointing out errors they routinely commit that they can't discern, but--somehow--are crystal-clear to you.

NOTHING anybody has ever posted on this forum has dented your monumental ignorance. You have managed to learn NOTHING from being dressed-down repeatedly by engineers, physicists, architects, and pilots. You can't come to terms with the concept that your very best efforts to prove that no planes hit the Twin Towers MUST fail because planes really did hit the Twin Towers.

Yes, we all get the idea that you continue to deny the historicity of this event, but that's just it. To you, there is a controversy. To everyone else, your ravings demonstrate a severe mental illness. No matter what convoluted madness you fabricate, you cannot prove an assertion that is simply wrong.

But, you can never comprehend that, and I should not mock you for a disability that is not within your power to correct.
 
Last edited:
My goodness, please don't. He's been through more than I can imagine, and the thought of Ace calling him a liar on top of this is just unthinkable. I see what kind of creature Ace is, offering money to someone for a tape like this. Un-frikkin-believable! Yeah, just full of compassion and understanding, aren't we? Of course, it's all just part of his "professional" investigation.
I wouldn't worry about my friend. His "therapy" as he calls it is to go to GZ and get in truthers faces. He has a rather nice video of himself in Alex Jones face.
 
No comment on this Ace?

The plane is NOT moving perpendicular to the axis of the lens and this DOES make a difference ACE. First of all the plane was banking and turning pretty hard. that does two things. It presents a differeing profile to the camera in each frame. Second, it presents a varying reflection of the light, especially from the radically convex nose of the aircraft, in each frame and both of the previous items also are affected by the motion of the camera which is not only moving laterally and vertically but also the helicopter would be yawing which would change the angle at which the camera is pointed.

After all you are using the nose of the aircraft to determine velocity are you not?
 
I wouldn't worry about my friend. His "therapy" as he calls it is to go to GZ and get in truthers faces. He has a rather nice video of himself in Alex Jones face.
Now that is something I would like to see. Someone right in Ace's face over this nonsense. Not that it would make a lick of difference, but it would be emotionally satisfying!
 
All good scientific theories require duplication as part of the process of determining their veracity.

So, Ace, will you and Morgan be reproducing this fakery anytime soon? Sure , I know you cannot use the WTC towers but I am sure that any high rise will do.

Go out on a couple of clear days and on one shoot an aircraft lining up with your local airport, on the other , shoot a video of the high rise (better pick an office building, apartments have all manner of window coverings). Now edit the two together having the plane enter behind the building and then not show up on the other side in the time it would normally take for it to traverse the width of the building, instead delaying it by some 80%.

post the result and we will just have to trust you that you managed to do this manually.
 
heres a good one for you Corsair, can you tell me if the lightning effects (the one that was crawling up the "vines" where the pods were) were done in CGI or regular animation.
Uh, which movie is this? Sorry, my recall is far from total in most cases if I've seen the movie more than ten minutes ago and only once or twice. All effects sequences begin to blend into one giant mish-mash... :D

Women can't drive powerloaders?
Heh, I don't know, Ripley seemed to be good enough at it. She did toss that alien queen right into the airlock after all!
 
sorry corsair - it was in response to The Matrix - the lightning effects that were crawling up the "pod" vine. CGI or traditional?
 
No comment on this Ace?

After all you are using the nose of the aircraft to determine velocity are you not?

It's obvious you didn't read the paper. No, I am not using just the nose, I am using the whole aircraft.

The plane is very close to perpendicular to the line of sight, because the apparent size of the airplane does not change during the shot, not even by one pixel.

It doesn't matter. The plane banking would create the effect of an apparent acceleration, or deceleration (depending on whether it was banking toward or away from the perpendicular). The graph line would still be smooth.

Even if the plane were approaching at a 45 degree angle to the camera, its apparent velocity would be smooth. It would not speed up and slow down, speed up and slow down.

A real plane, on a stabilized video, cannot speed up and slow down frame by frame. It is physically impossible.

The only valid criticism to emerge is that measurement error might be greater than I allow for. The solution is to repeat the experiment on control cases, and I've said I will do that.

Thanks to a few of you for review.
 
you've failed to prove yoru point with one video (as has been pointed out to you numerous times)

tell us how you plan on debunking the 45 plus other videos that captured the south tower being hit by 175.
 
The only valid criticism to emerge is that measurement error might be greater than I allow for. The solution is to repeat the experiment on control cases, and I've said I will do that.

Ace, some criticism of you paper has been unfair, and I believe your method is roughly correct. However your stabilisation effort is very poor, and your tracking of the plane is very poor. Please take this from an expert in stabilisation and tracking. As I said, it's my job.

Get uncompressed video. This is very important. Compressed video is just a computer generated reconstruction of the original, with most of the original data lost.

Do not enlarge the footage by 200%. This merely adds useless data which will distort the results.

Edit: Also, do not tweak the contrast or brightness, or sharpen or otherwise 'enhance' the picture. All of these things destroy information, not recover it. There is NOTHING you can do to an image to make it more accurate.

Try different tracking strategies. I've done a fair amount of manual tracking and I can tell you simply stepping through the frames and placing the mark where it looks like it should go does not give a good track - not even good enough to fool a casual observer. As you're not a pro, get ten volunteers to track and stabilise the video. Eliminate all subjectivity. See if their results match, or if you get any correlation at all. Try averaging the tracks.

I did earlier suggest using an automatic tracking program, but having seen the footage I doubt it will provide any benefit. To get a good accurate track you need to be tracking something with a 2 dimensional shape, roughly an x shape (this applies to manual tracking too). A plane is perfect because the wings form an x with the fuselage. However, this x shape is only visible in about 8 frames of your video, thanks to the logo that's in the way. The nose of the plane, is almost 1 dimesional. It's easy to track it up and down, but left and right tracking will be innaccurate. Secondly there is a lot of jitter along the edges of the building. Just look at the black edge of the frame. It's supposed to be perfectly straight. To me some of those pixels look to be 4 or 5 pixels astray.

In conclusion Ace, the image itself is distorting, up to 5 pixels either way. Your stabilisation is easily 2 pixels out on some frames. Your track of the plane is easily two pixels out on good frames, and hard to judge on bad frames. In total that's a nine-pixel potential measurement error. Yet, you're convicting based on a claimed 4 pixel discrepancy.

I hope that helps.

Shrinks,
VFX Supervisors for Truth

PS, I've put many CGI planes into filmed shots. Evening winning awards for such acts. If you'd like to learn the truth about these processes fire away. If you'd prefer to continue guessing, then please carry on with watching those DVD extras.
 
Last edited:
Would again require that an operator control where the images are in real time, for every image that was being taken.
CNN,CBS,NBC,ABC,CBC, and many other live feeds and TPTB would also have to be prepared for ALL possiblities, that is all possible broadcasters and every conceivable angle.

Assuming the cameras weren't moving, of course.

Why are there hundreds of people who do report seeing and hearing the aircraft come in and saw it impact and why do you simply ignore them, or worse yet, accuse them of lieing Ace?

It was probably Bush on the megaphone... :rolleyes:

Why is it that you cannot see that your entire supposed conspiracy to fake two planes hitting two buildings is so vastly complicated, complex and unnecessary? It would be greatly easier to actually have two aircraft hit the towers than to fake it in the hopes that you can fool all onlookers and all but a handful of those watching it live accross that globe?

Yeah, but it isn't as exciting and troubling !
 
Assuming the cameras weren't moving, of course.

Right, make that every conceivable angle with a dynamic range of camera movement.



It was probably Bush on the megaphone... :rolleyes:

Nah, he's much too nasal to be confused with a 767



Yeah, but it isn't as exciting and troubling !

Which is the basis on which Ace grounds his concerns.
 
The plane is very close to perpendicular to the line of sight, because the apparent size of the airplane does not change during the shot, not even by one pixel.

Depending on the distance, it could just mean that it's not changing course.

A real plane, on a stabilized video, cannot speed up and slow down frame by frame. It is physically impossible.

Then your analysis is flawed, because there WAS a real plane.
 
I was just looking over Ace's web page. I don't recall anyone else here mentioning this, but I think it is relevant. (At least, relevant to type of analysis. Ace's interpretation is farking nuts anyway.)

I see no mention of deinterlacing in Ace's work. De-interlacing an NTSC (or PAL) video signal to display on progressive scan screen can cause the edge of the object to wiggle - depending on the de-interlace method used.

If you just mash the two 240 line fields into one frame, then you will get the most extreme problem. The two fields are taken 1/60 of second apart. Moving objects will therefore show position differences between the two fields. This will make the edges of the object look like the teeth of a comb. The faster the object moves, the longer the "teeth" will be.

At Ace's measured 20 pixels per frame for the airplane, that's going to give you "teeth" ten pixels long. When you then compress the video, those "teeth" will be smeared together. You will in effect have an indistinct outline of the plane, which may be anywhere up to 10 pixels from where it appears to be.

If a more sophisticated de-interlace method is used, things don't really improve for Ace. The more sophisticated methods eliminate the comb teeth, but they tend to move the objects a few pixels. Depending on just how each field pair lines up, the de-intelacer may decide to align the image to first the even field or to first the odd field.

In one frame, your object may align to the odd fields. The next frame may align to the even field. In this case, you would get a significant apparent slow down, namely a drop of half of the measured travel distance between the two frames. The other way is just as bad. If the de-interlacer aligns in one frame to the even and in the next frame to the odd, you will get an apparent speed up of the same magnitude.

So, de-interlacing in whatever form is going to be a problem for measurements. And that's ignoring the problems you can get into if the de-interlacer is started one field off. That is, if your video starts on an even frame and the de-interlacer doesn't compensate.

Even worse, the comments others have made about video compression are quite correct. MPEG compressed video stores only some frames completely. Others are stored as a sort of mathematical description of the differences. Typically, you might have one complete frame followed by four that will be calculated.

Part of that "mathematical description" is an approximation of the motion of the objects visible. This motion compensation is a further source of error in Ace's calculations that he has not bothered to account for.

The motion compensation in the compressed video will not be perfect. The objects don't all move at the same speed, and there is (as always) a tradeoff of accuracy against computation power. More accuracy takes more time for compression, and more space in the finished file. In heavily compressed videos from YouTube, the number of calculated frames will be higher, thus each frame will have even more potential for error.

It is, therefore, quite reasonable that only the full frames in the compressed video will show object in their correct positions. Reasonable and expected, except by Ace.


Anything else? Well, the thousands of witnesses, but Ace doesn't count them. He can't line them up on his monitor and make them lie the way he can torture a video into telling his Truth.
 
Snip...
A real plane, on a stabilized video, cannot speed up and slow down frame by frame. It is physically impossible.

The only valid criticism to emerge is that measurement error might be greater than I allow for. The solution is to repeat the experiment on control cases, and I've said I will do that.

Thanks to a few of you for review.
True, it would be physically impossible for an airplane to speed up and slow down at the rates you measured.

Due to errors and inaccuracies in video compression and de-interlacing, however, it is quite possible for an airplane to appear to speed up and slow down insanely on video.

Do you even know how the de-interlacing was done on that video? Heck, whoever converted it may have taken the easy way out and just doubled each scan line in every odd field. There's no way to tell, and no way to compensate without that knowledge - and even if you knew, it'd still be a devil of a job compensating.
 
Money awaits any who can provide uncompressed video of significant 9/11 events.


I suggest an ad in the NYT.

Most people here were not in NYC on 9/11(I for one have never been to NYC, ever) and those that were it seems, did not have a vid camera on them.

Let's see, you could also ask at every local TV station as well as the cable stations with hdqtrs in NYC.

It is suprising that you only think to do this AFTER making your pronouncement.

well no , not really
 
Anything else? Well, the thousands of witnesses, but Ace doesn't count them. He can't line them up on his monitor and make them lie the way he can torture a video into telling his Truth.

Oooh, it must be really annoying to him that so many people who know video technology better than he does are taking him apart.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom