Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Oh stop it 8den. I think the airplane shot was prepared in advance, and was laid into the Chopper 5 shot in real time, as explained.

There seems to be a consensus that a lack of bystander reaction to an incoming jet at low altitude is a dead giveaway to fakery. I agree. Hold this thought.

Corsair has also discussed what she feels is expected behavior for camera operators in an unexpected situation. If you were filming firefighters talking in the street, and all of a sudden you heard an incoming jet above you, where would you point the camera?

What color was UA175, and what color would it appear in full sunlight? Hypothetically suppose it is viewed from the east, looking west. The plane is flying north, banking left, the sun is in the east, behind us, 9 a.m., the buildings facing us in the picture are lit up brightly. Describe how you think UA175 ought to appear in that situation.
 
Oh stop it 8den. I think the airplane shot was prepared in advance, and was laid into the Chopper 5 shot in real time, as explained.
.

How, please explain, better yet please do this, and show us how you did it in real time, and what kit you used.
 
I don't have the article in front of me, but I think it was IEEE Spectrum within the last year or so, that had a fascinating article on how Sportvision works.

What exactly do you mean by real time? Sportvision, although it appears to work in real time, introduces a delay (0.5-1.5 sec?) into the live feed. It would appear correlation with TS' "non CGI" events would be extremely difficult, if not impossible.
 
Oh stop it 8den. I think the airplane shot was prepared in advance, and was laid into the Chopper 5 shot in real time, as explained.


Why would they do this?

In order for the shots to match, the helicopter shot had to have been planned precisely to match the angle of the pre-recorded aircraft plate. So why not just record both plates in advance and broadcast the composited VT? There is simply no logical explanation whatsoever for doing this live - something which adds enormous unnecessary complications, and something which I am not convinced was even possible in 2001.

-Gumboot
 
What color was UA175, and what color would it appear in full sunlight? Hypothetically suppose it is viewed from the east, looking west. The plane is flying north, banking left, the sun is in the east, behind us, 9 a.m., the buildings facing us in the picture are lit up brightly. Describe how you think UA175 ought to appear in that situation.


Black or very dark.

-Gumboot
 
My understanding of the flame software is that the footage needs to be predigitized onto the flame before this could be done.

Absolutely, the Flame example was just to demonstrate that 2D tracking in realtime was technically possible and that its not necessarily some kind of computationally expensive process. As I said, it didn't (and won't) fit into a live pipeline, and, as I also said, the result would not be perfect.
 
Absolutely, the Flame example was just to demonstrate that 2D tracking in realtime was technically possible and that its not necessarily some kind of computationally expensive process. As I said, it didn't (and won't) fit into a live pipeline, and, as I also said, the result would not be perfect.

Grand so, interesting as well. I didnt know it could do that, however I'm rarly in a flame suite, though I once worked on a feature length documentary that was graded entirely in two flame suites. That was hellish.
 
As an aside, I saw an ad for the forthcoming Live Free or Die Hard (a.k.a. Die Hard 4) on TV earlier tonight. And as I watched some of the various car action sequences shown in the ad, I said, "That's a CGI car, that's a CGI car, and that's a CGI car." Can't movies do stunts anymore with real vehicles? I personally am beginning to find this reliance on CGI to pump up action sequences rather annoying. The stunts done with real vehicles and real drivers way back in 1981's The Road Warrior are far more impressive and dramatic to me than all this ridiculously over-the-top CGI-enhanced stuff...


I agree.

As for the DH4 trailer, the most obvious CG car is the one that flies through the air sideways, narrowly missing our heros who are standing between two other cars and the falling car impacts the parked cars rather than Bruce Willis. Every car in that scene is CG.

I believe that the car that hits the helicopter is CG as well but the copter might have been real.
 
I agree.

As for the DH4 trailer, the most obvious CG car is the one that flies through the air sideways, narrowly missing our heros who are standing between two other cars and the falling car impacts the parked cars rather than Bruce Willis. Every car in that scene is CG.

I believe that the car that hits the helicopter is CG as well but the copter might have been real.

Thats honestly the least appealing film trailer I've ever seen, it's almost a parody of an action movie trailer, with an absurd budget, it just looks beyond ricidulously, and amazingly isn't the craziest thing on this thread by a country mile.

Oh and this is the film I'm looking forward this year.
 
Newcomers wading through your gibberish are curious to know how much of it may be attributed to your manifest mental illness and how much to your dishonesty. I would argue that your dishonesty is forced upon you by your illness. What people here don't understand is where you're coming from.

The question in most minds is the obvious one: Why would media outlets, overwhelmingly liberal and implacably hostile to the Bush administration, participate in a fantastic crime to line the pockets of Dick Cheney, a man they despise? For almost all of us, your imaginary conspiracy collapses at this point. I have met other anarcho-libertarians and I understand that you are incapable of distinguishing George Bush from Barack Obama. To you, both are evil statists (a term you are clueless about). The man who responded belatedly to the jihadist threat is no different from the man who believes that the threat is bogus.

Those of us who inhabit the real world understand perfectly well that the networks hate Bush and do everything in their power to undermine "his" war on terror. The idea that they faked video of planes crashing into the Twin Towers is preposterous nonsense on several levels. Your often-demonstrated technical incompetence masks your fundamental inability to comprehend basic political realities. For your imaginary, mathematically-impossible conspiracy to exist, all that we know about the world must be an illusion. Republicans and Democrats who seem to loathe each other must secretly be allies in a gigantic imperialist venture that, oddly enough, comes to an abrupt halt whenever a Democrat enters the White House.

Mindless fantasists have even tried to enlist John Kerry, of all people, into the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy, citing his confused and uninformed comments on WTC 7. Like you, they are not inconvenienced by the fact that by blowing the whistle, he could have gotten himself elected Presdient of the United States.

Seek help, Ace. Seriously. You are ill.
Bolding mine.

I disagree with those premises wholeheartedly.
 
...The sad but inescapable truth is that a significant minority of people have entrenched themselves, greedily slurping off the government nozzle. They support the global domination project. They are all for it. They know where their bread is buttered. They are willing to do what it takes to keep the gravy train rolling down the tracks. That includes looking the other way when the big boys blow up the World Trade Center and cook up a ludicrous fairy tale about 19 party-animal-kamikazee-fundamentalist-hijackers who hate our freedom.
A masturbatory fantasy par excellence!
 
ace why have you ignored for the last 5 pages about how the thousands of witnesses and the thousands of people who saw the planes hit, LIVE, in person!?

have you even offered an answer to this question?


remember
thousands of people saw the two planes hit the buildings from various angles, from right in front of the WTC towers, up to miles away...
Considering NYC's five boroughs alone comprise over 8 million people, and that the twins were easily visible to those along the Jersey shore, I'd suggest it likely many more than thousands watched the second plane hit. Tens, if not hundreds of thousands. Maybe more.
 
I know a few people who saw the plane hit live.

I guess they are part of the conspiracy too.

What a load of crap.
It's amazing isn't it?

Think about it for just a second: someone is seriously proposing that no airplanes impacted the Twin Towers on 9/11.

No airplanes.

pomeroo has many times suggested the term "insane" applies to Mr. Baker. Normally I'd shy away from such name-calling, never mind it's tempting to agree. However, I think our friend simply has his little agenda, facts and coherence be damned.
 
Thats honestly the least appealing film trailer I've ever seen, it's almost a parody of an action movie trailer, with an absurd budget, it just looks beyond ricidulously, and amazingly isn't the craziest thing on this thread by a country mile.

Oh and this is the film I'm looking forward this year.

The DH4 trailer looks like it was a competition to see how many scene clips could be cut in during one commercial break.:D

Wicker Man was probably the most disappointing movie I have watched ever!

Did Nick Cage not read the script before signing up for it?
Was this a favor he was doing for a 12 year old relative and aspiring writer?
When it ended, the wife and I looked at each other and asked "that's it?!"

Worst of all , I watched it on pay-per-view and paid $4.99.
 
What color was UA175, and what color would it appear in full sunlight? Hypothetically suppose it is viewed from the east, looking west. The plane is flying north, banking left, the sun is in the east, behind us, 9 a.m., the buildings facing us in the picture are lit up brightly. Describe how you think UA175 ought to appear in that situation.


Um, Ace? New Jersey is west of Manhattan, not east. The High 5 helicopter was a few miles northwest of the WTC, pointing its camera to the southeast.
 
It's amazing isn't it?

Think about it for just a second: someone is seriously proposing that no airplanes impacted the Twin Towers on 9/11.

No airplanes.

pomeroo has many times suggested the term "insane" applies to Mr. Baker. Normally I'd shy away from such name-calling, never mind it's tempting to agree. However, I think our friend simply has his little agenda, facts and coherence be damned.
Exactly. Ace is not insane, at least not in a clinical, asylum sort of way. He is an attention whore, desperately out to find his 15 minutes of fame. His ego feeds on the endless responses he gets to his trolling. His ideas are outlandish by design and the design is to generate responses, so the more outrageous the better.
 
To add a bit of precision, at 9:02 a.m. local time in New York on September 11, 2001, the sun had an altitude of 37.4 degrees and rising and an azimuth of 122.0 degrees east of true north and increasing, according to this calculator. So the sunlight would have been coming from the ESE.
 
Originally Posted by TruthSeeker1234
As for "thousands" of eyewitnesses. . .Evidence please.

I'm not aware of any evidence that supports any number remotely like "thousands" or "one thousand" or even "one hundred".

Evidence please.
are you serious?
In the event of an building fire on a busy downtown street you easily get 100 onlookers. But run of the mill buildng fires are fairly common.

In this case though we not only have THE tallest office building in the world on fire but it was hit by an aircraft. It would be visible to tens of , if not hundreds of, thousands of people. While they are looking at the first tower, its twin , right next door, is also hit by an airliner and there is an explosion and fire.

You honestly believe that there were not thousands of people looking up at the north tower's south side when the south side of the south tower was hit?

You do know how many people inhabit lower Manhattan and Jersey don't you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom