Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

I've heard back from Eric Salter. Yes, the frames were de-interlaced as I said, every other field was discarded, interpolation between scan lines.

It is not reasonable to think that odd and even fields were discarded at random. De-interlacing algorithms do not do this. Rather, it will pick either the odds, or the evens, to discard.
The challenge to produce a similar fake video with a real time overlay is a good one, but I don't have the gear. My point is that they didn't do a perfect job, it appears that they used old school technology. However, do bear in mind that the SportVision software was operational in 1998.

The control case is the way to go. If legitimate videos show the same kinds of anomalies that Chopper 5 shows, you will have made your point, and I will admit that my graphs show only measurement error. Is that fair enough?
Wrong, Ace. Deinterlacers can handle different areas of the picture differently. It is NOT at random. They use motion detection to determine the best method to apply to a particular part of the picture.

So, you've confirmed that your video was made by using only even frames and line doubling.

Very good. Now all you have to do is eliminate the compression and motion detection errors, and all of the error sources that others have pointed out. And you need to do a comparative test against a video of an airplane in flight, said video to have been prepared (deinterlaced and compressed in exactly the same way) as the one you were using.

All that, and reconcile your results with the witness statements.


Oh, and remember, Ace, if an airplane didn't cause the destruction of the tower you will then have to explain how the demolition was rigged in an occupied building with no one noticing.
 
I think the camera was tripod mounted, not handheld.
Possibly, but my first bet would be to say no. The camera zooms out at the start, and a wide angle view reduces the normal handheld shakiness quite a bit. A camera on a tripod has a slightly different look to the way the frame moves if it's a jerky camera move than the way the frame movement looks in a handheld shot. Depends too on the type of tripod.

I'm not sure, but I think that might be real video of a real jet at an airshow, with background removed and laid on top of the video of the buildings.
I doubt it, the jet doesn't look sufficiently real nor does the smoke trail. I would think both were created in Microsoft Flight Simulator or similar program and then composited with the pre-recorded footage of the buildings.

Again though, the caveat applies that the video quality and resolution is poor, so the details one needs to be more definitive just aren't there.

What color was UA175? And what color should it appear in full sunlight?
Depends entirely on the camera angle and where the light is coming from. An object with light falling on it from the front can look quite a bit different if it is backlit. The perceived colour depends a great deal on the kind of light falling on it as well as the colours around it.


As an aside, I saw an ad for the forthcoming Live Free or Die Hard (a.k.a. Die Hard 4) on TV earlier tonight. And as I watched some of the various car action sequences shown in the ad, I said, "That's a CGI car, that's a CGI car, and that's a CGI car." Can't movies do stunts anymore with real vehicles? I personally am beginning to find this reliance on CGI to pump up action sequences rather annoying. The stunts done with real vehicles and real drivers way back in 1981's The Road Warrior are far more impressive and dramatic to me than all this ridiculously over-the-top CGI-enhanced stuff...
 
I would expect the explosion at impact to be much more than a small dust cloud. And the explosion coming out from the opposite side doesn't look like it lines up with the direction of the impact, though it's hard to tell exactly.

Also, it seems that the Jet slows down significantly, or rather doesn't speed up proportionately as it comes closer in view towards the camera. It just looks to me like it's going way too slow in its approach.
 
Corsair, some nice observations,like the plane disappearing. I think the camera was tripod mounted, not handheld.


It's handheld.



I think this fake video might make a nice study, to see if stabilizing it smooths out the velocity line, or makes it more jagged. I'm not sure, but I think that might be real video of a real jet at an airshow, with background removed and laid on top of the video of the buildings. I'm not sure.


The jet is fake. It is not footage of a real jet.

-Gumboot
 
I would expect the explosion at impact to be much more than a small dust cloud. And the explosion coming out from the opposite side doesn't look like it lines up with the direction of the impact, though it's hard to tell exactly.

Also, it seems that the Jet slows down significantly, or rather doesn't speed up proportionately as it comes closer in view towards the camera. It just looks to me like it's going way too slow in its approach.



The most obvious give away is scale...

The aircraft has a wingspan of about one floor of the building. It looks to be a MiG-29 or similar Russian fighter.

Here's some comparative wingspans:

MiG-29 - 37ft
MiG-35 - 49ft
Su-27 - 48ft
Su-30 - 48ft

In contrast a typical office building floor is about 12ft.

-Gumboot
 
I've heard back from Eric Salter. Yes, the frames were de-interlaced as I said, every other field was discarded, interpolation between scan lines.

It is not reasonable to think that odd and even fields were discarded at random. De-interlacing algorithms do not do this. Rather, it will pick either the odds, or the evens, to discard.

The challenge to produce a similar fake video with a real time overlay is a good one, but I don't have the gear. My point is that they didn't do a perfect job, it appears that they used old school technology. However, do bear in mind that the SportVision software was operational in 1998.

The control case is the way to go. If legitimate videos show the same kinds of anomalies that Chopper 5 shows, you will have made your point, and I will admit that my graphs show only measurement error. Is that fair enough?


No it's not. If you feel that it is possible to create the kind of effects you claim they used on 911 using sportvision hardware feel free to actually go out get the kit and demonstrate that.

I know the kit you're talking about and it is far more limited than what you claim. Perhaps you've contacted "sportsvision" and asked them, if this was possible in 1998 or 2001? No?

Theres the gaunlet for you Ace, if this footage was easy to fake, please demostrate it by faking it, a second time. Put up or shut up.
 
Corsair, some nice observations,like the plane disappearing. I think the camera was tripod mounted, not handheld.
I think this fake video might make a nice study, to see if stabilizing it smooths out the velocity line, or makes it more jagged. I'm not sure, but I think that might be real video of a real jet at an airshow, with background removed and laid on top of the video of the buildings. I'm not sure.

You mentioned lighting not quite being right. Hmmmmm. . . .

What color was UA175? And what color should it appear in full sunlight?

I have a few moment to make a point or two. IMO the action was deliberately filmed by an amateur (or pro in his spare time) for the purposes of adding the fake plane. The shot was most probably created either as a student project or just to show off on an online CG forum.

The shot is handheld - there is some roll of the camera about the lens axis which is unlikely on a tripod. But, there is practically no parallax, which means the operator is holding the camera in a fixed spot. Having no parallax makes the shot significantly easier for the artist, but such a camera move rarely happens by accident. That leads me to beleive the artist shot the footage himself.

The wrongness of the smoke, lighting on the plane, and its movement etc. are all quite subjective, especially given the compression. I wouldn't say any was proof of fakery but it all adds up. I couldn't select the frame where the plane disappears but I doubt that this happens. There's no practical reason why a half competent FX artist would make such a mistake and so it's probably just an illusion caused by the compression and the plane colour matching the building.

For me the biggest giveaway is the lack of reaction. That's one thing out of the control of FX artists. Also of note, one of the explosions at the front of the building is quite elongated. This could happen for real, but looks to me like either deliberate distortion by the artist, or it's an explosion shot in controlled conditions elsewhere and added in (you can buy these online for a few dollars). Also the smoke and debris behind the building seems to have a slightly mismatched black level (in english - it's too dark).

It's a good effort though.

Now Ace, you're guessing that the plane was taken from real footage. You making the same guess for the WTC shot too. This is really not a wise move for the artists.

First up. Planes are easy to make as computer generated elements. Nowadays you can buy useable models for peanuts (some examples)

Second. Real footage of planes will probably have a moving camera. This movement would have to be removed via stabilisation. Stabilisation is not perfect and can introduce blurring, severe blurring in some cases. On interlaced footage you must halve the resolution of the clip before even starting so the problems are compounded. Using a CG plane the artist can use any camera movement or none at all, to create the element he/she needs.

Third. Real footage of a plane comes with lighting already on the plane. It cannot be changed once the photograph has been taken. Correct lighting is not just a matter of correctly aligned shadows. An artist needs to match shadow density, sharpness, bounce light, environmental light, colour temperature as well as a whole stack of camera specific attributes. These things rarely match in two totally seperate shots. For CG planes however, the artist can light the subject however he or she desires.

Fourth. Real footage has a fixed motion and a fixed start and end. CG planes can be animated to do anything for as long as the artist needs it.

Fifth. A real plane would need to be extracted cleanly from its background. Although chromakeying has been around for decades this is sill not a trivial process if perfect results are needed. There are some excellent intelligent solutions for keying but they all require good quality blue/green/magenta screens. It IS possible to pluck something out of a blue sky but the result can be messy, especially if that object has a tendency to aquire the same colour as the sky (shiny or white objects). CG planes can be rendered without a background at all, so this process is unecessary.

Sixth. The footage of the real plane would have to roughly match the expected action in the completed scene, with a roughly similar camera move. (Stabilisation would fix the small differences). This might not be a problem, but if you don't know what the background footage will be in advance, or how many cameras will capture the scene, you have a big problem knowing exactly what to film beforehand. CG has the same problem, but the action or camera move can be edited in minutes in order to match the incoming footage.

If you think 2001 was too early for fully CG planes, look at this homemade movie from 2000/2001: http://www.ifilm.com/video/204155 (The page says 2001, but I'm pretty sure I first saw it in 2000).

In 1996, a largish Hollywood movie featured a shot of a military plane that had been cut out of stock footage and digially inserted into the production's background. I'll let you figure out which film it was. Despite ideal conditions, the effect is not particularly successful, even when viewed on TV, IMO mainly because of the third point above.

So, to conclude all that. Any sensible evil CGI artist would have chosen a computer generated plane, not a real one. Therefore what you claim are rotoscoping artifacts around the plane (inaccurate cutting & pasting) would never exist. Let's ignore for now the fact that your pink halo looks nothing like any roto error that I've ever seen yet looks exactly like JPEG artifacts.

Also your explanation for the jerky movement you have found makes little sense. The fake plane would likely have been rendered performing a perfectly accurate, smooth flight (since that's what computer animation does by default). The smoothly moving plane would have been tracked into the shot by computer.

Now, contrary to some debunking, tracking can be done live, and this technology did exist in 2001. It is however imperfect.

This is where I have to give you a little credit, Ace. Stabilising a shot and looking for anomalies in the movement does work. I've used it myself to show that a UFO video was fake. As great as an artist's tracking software may be, it can still slip up and can be fooled into making mistakes. Therefore the jitter you claim to have found, might really exist in fake footage.

However, as has been stated many times, you can 'find' this jitter by simply not measuring accurately enough. Humans in my experience are not accurate enough, so no conclusion can be reached.

Working against your theory, amongst many other things, is the very tight integration bewteen plane debris, fireballs and the building, which are very very difficult to fake in CG, even with ample time.

I don't expect this to be the end of the matter, (since, 'it don't look right to me' can't be debunked) but I can't have people trampling all over my turf without saying something.
 
No, Dave. The point is to analyze the velocities, and reconstruct the most likely method by which the video was created. Whether the camera shake was intended, or unintended, or more than what was planned, is all interesting, but somewhat beside the point.

No, it's not beside the point. It's trivially simple to record a video of an airliner flying by with a fixed camera, so that there's no camera shake. The variation in apparent airliner velocity is a crucial point in your argument, yet you have advanced no hypothesis as to how it arose. You're therefore saying that the velocity variation proves compositing, but that you have no idea how it arose. Can you come up with any hypothesis as to why the velocity variation would have been present in the original video that doesn't require ignorance of the behaviour of random noise on the part of the conspirators? If not, it's a serious hole in your argument.

She's the one who said she was north of the towers, not me.

False. Strawman. I never said any such thing. Dave, you're smarter than this. When you resort to this tactic, you make us think you're not confident on the science.

You're carefully missing the point here. You've stated that many people didn't see an airliner hit WTC2, therefore it's plausible that no airliner hit WTC2. That must imply that the testimony of the witnesses who didn't see an airliner contradicts that of those who did. That is not the case, and your accusation against Alt+F4 demonstrates that you are aware that it is not the case. You're being dishonest, then, if you argue that the hypothesis that no airliner hit the tower is supported by the fact that some witnesses didn't see an airliner hit the tower - an implication you clearly made.

False. I have so constructed a line of argument. If the video was not composited, we would see a straighter graph line after stabilizing than before.

OK, conceded that that's your line of argument. The whole point is that you haven't justified that assertion.

Dave
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

And you accuse me of creating strawmen. I think the crows are much more scared when you're around.

Dave
 
Shrinker said:
Now, contrary to some debunking, tracking can be done live, and this technology did exist in 2001. It is however imperfect.

Hey I'll bow down completely to your opinion on this matter Shrinker. Out of curiousity what real time tracking software/hardware existed in 2001?
 
To get it to blend with the background. Anyone who has done any picture manipulation runs into this problem. You don't want a razor sharp cutout, instead you want a blend. Best to have the blend on the sky, not the plane.

Best ? So you have no idea how it was done.

No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .

But how exactly did they composite that real-time ?

You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight, rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles, disappearing major parts of other buildings, drilling round vertical holes, throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions, expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano, pushing up a giant mushroom cloud, leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

Yes, no such thing, wrong again, nope, they weren't anywhere near round, yes indeed, it didn't look anything like a volcano, what mushroom, yeah flaming debris will do that. Your incredible incredulity is amazing.
 
Hey I'll bow down completely to your opinion on this matter Shrinker. Out of curiousity what real time tracking software/hardware existed in 2001?

I concede you'd be hard pressed to find an off-the-shelf-solution to track and composite live, but all the technology was there.

Flame, a software + SGI Hardware solution could do a 2D track in realtime back then although it wasn't directly built into a live TV pipeline. Customizing it to do so should be easy for anyone qualified and suitably funded.

We also had a virtual studio setup around 2000 (I forget then name of the kit) which could composite TV presenters into a CGI background generated in realtime. It could accomodate 3D tracking, panning and zooming cameras, although the matchmoving if I remember correctly was achieved using sensors on the camera rather than image analysis.

The sportvision thing that somebody referred to (maybe I got the name wrong) is not something I'm familiar with, although I remember seeing the technology to add CG billboards into live sporting events demonstrated many years ago. If I understand it correctly, it does a kind of 2.5D track (tries to match perspective distortion) which would be overkill for Ace's WTC plane.

Also, I believe the military have been using pattern tracking for a long while in their weapons systems. If we have an Apache pilot on the board (I wouldn't be surprised!) maybe they could confirm that.

Finally I know it's a cliche that technology exists long before its publicly available but I've experienced the truth behind of that. For example this 3D laptop screen (that doesn't require special glasses) was announced 2 or 3 years ago. I was lucky enough to see it in action 10 years before that. At the same time (around 1994) I also saw some other things, which incidentally also required tracking live 2D images, which I think I'm still not allowed to talk about! It was cool though.
 
Finally I know it's a cliche that technology exists long before its publicly available but I've experienced the truth behind of that. For example this 3D laptop screen (that doesn't require special glasses) was announced 2 or 3 years ago. I was lucky enough to see it in action 10 years before that. At the same time (around 1994) I also saw some other things, which incidentally also required tracking live 2D images, which I think I'm still not allowed to talk about! It was cool though.

The point Ace is missing though, is all the technology in the world doesn't hide the fact that it was seen by thousands of people.
 
No. For the 47th time. Plane layer not done in real time. Plane layer done ahead of time, i.e. before, i.e. in advance of, i.e. previous to, i.e. in anticipation of, i.e. prior to, i.e. pre-dating, . . .

. . .9/11.

Please just read the paper and learn how I think it was done. Then come and criticize it. But at least learn how I think it was done.


Yes, I know you said that the plane layer was produced before the event BUT it would have to have been inserted LIVE, on every live feed, with very little delay and in each case done well enough that no one would notice any oddities. There would have to be contingencies for every POSSIBLE video feed and every possible transmission technique(some satellite feeds, some microwave and still others may have been via physical cables).

Furthermore you have to allow for all possible locations of the camera , especially one mounted on a helicopter. That requires a live person at the controls who must have slowed the helicopter layer by 80% so that the exiting debris is not travelling at 500MPH.

You also keep refering to the exiting piece as the 'nose' when you know very well that hundreds of people saw this come through the north wall of the building and crash to the street. You know that indeed the remains of a jet engine were on the street and that people witnessed it hit and roll. Yet your position seems to be that nothing actually exited the north wall so once again you are willing to pretend that there were no witnesses OR that, somehow a jet engine was mounted within the building and then ejected as part of this idioticly convoluted plot to fake an aircraft impact.

,,,, and then you also have to , somehow, manage to alter all taped videos of the events including those of the impact,,,,, and then you have to alter all still shots of the event including any of the impact.
 
You guys think a building can crush itself into fine powder under its own weight
,

didn't happen. Some of the concrete used was crushed and some of it to powder and of course, pretty much all of the hundreds of tons of drywall was powdered fairly completely.

rusting, melting and warping thousands of motor vehicles
,

Cars on fire from debris that rained down over a large area and cars that had the misfortune of being parked next to other vehicles on fire. BTW, oxidation is oxidation, whether it occurs as a result of water and oxygen reacting with iron or due to oxygen and high heat on iron.


disappearing major parts of other buildings,

Riiight! Did not occur Ace, it only looks like it if you squnit real hard and try to make it so due to a preconcieved notion that an idiotically convoluted plot was afoot

drilling round vertical holes,

Again requires that one squint real hard and ignore the facts.

throwing what little is left hundreds of feet in all directions,

Gee, and it only started from 1000 feet up too.

expanding dust clouds in a way the mimics a volcano
,

Again, only in the most simplistic way is it a mimic of volcanic dust flow.

pushing up a giant mushroom cloud,

Visible only in stills that do not show the dynamic way this image was produced. There was no "mushroom cloud"

leaving behind a flattened and well-named ground zero

Could you supply a picture of this "flat" landscape.

that gives off clouds of mystery dust for months, despite rainstorms and constant watering!

Smoke Ace, smoke. You are aware that there are underground coal seams that have been burning for decades right?

So now its gonna be beam weapons and nukes is it?


And I'm crazy?

That seems to be the concensus here and among many "truthers" as well.
 
Last edited:
I concede you'd be hard pressed to find an off-the-shelf-solution to track and composite live, but all the technology was there.

Flame, a software + SGI Hardware solution could do a 2D track in realtime back then although it wasn't directly built into a live TV pipeline. Customizing it to do so should be easy for anyone qualified and suitably funded.

My understanding of the flame software is that the footage needs to be predigitized onto the flame before this could be done.

In any case this is mostly academic as Ace flicks between "it was done live" and "it was prerecorded" daily.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom