Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Dave was the only one actually making a pretense to scientific rigor.
Then why don't you follow his example and make a pretense of addressing a valid subject in your paper.

By your standards, no source of information can be trusted, which means that everything that you believe to be fact must also be suspect. You are in error and must sterilize.
 
3?4 inch tape?? Who uses that anymore?
Most large and medium sized TV stations have gone to digital format even on ENG reports. Some have maintained a professional analog Beta format though.


At any rate there has been a recording, a playback and re-recording of this clip. That much is patently obvious.

If it was recorded on a professional VTR with stable frame rate there would still be a small error from 29.97 fps. Now this clip was played back and re-recorded. The playback would also have a small error from 29.97 fps and so would the next recording. Each of these errors are not necessarily the same nor constant. The error multiplies each time you do this. However, the error is not constant in each case, ie. the flyback time between frame a and frame b might be off by +0.05% whereas the the flyback time between frame b and frame c is only off by -0.05% however that would mean that the difference between frame a and frame c is 0.1%.


But that is not all. Once again I point out that the video went through a CG to insert the banner graphics and that processing also introduces errors even before it gets recorded.


Then there is the problem with compression of the digital formats. If the clip has been digitized in one format then rendered again in another format or even in the same format you have just compressed the file twice and compounded the compression atifacts.

In order to even aproach any meaningful examination of this video clip one absolutly must have the rawest video there is. Without that this is a meaningless exercise Ace. That's the long and short of it, you simply cannot create a silk purse from a sow's ear(even if the actors on CSI do it routinely).

The plane is NOT moving perpendicular to the axis of the lens and this DOES make a difference ACE. First of all the plane was banking and turning pretty hard. that does two things. It presents a differeing profile to the camera in each frame. Second, it presents a varying reflection of the light, especially from the radically convex nose of the aircraft, in each frame and both of the previous items also are affected by the motion of the camera which is not only moving laterally and vertically but also the helicopter would be yawing which would change the angle at which the camera is pointed.

But it does not end there since you have not come up with any technical explanation of how this trickery was accomplished live and without significant delay. Nor have you explained how it was accomplished on the other 40 or so live shots of the impact of the aircraft as well. With 40 live feeds then you must have 40 CG artists all doing their own magic on each feed and getting it right each time. That's 40 more people 'in on it" Ace. Given the randomness of the placement of each of these cameras you simply could not program a machine to do it for you. It would have to have an operator do it live.

You also neglect the eyewitnesses , not just those who you have been told saw the impact but the thousands of people in the vicinity who would be looking towards tower 1 when tower 2 gets hit. Many, I daresay most, would also have then seen tower 2 get hit given they would be attuned to the sound of a jet, and were watching the towers already. If these people were looking towards the south face of tower 2 and tower 1 when without warning tower 2 blows up they would later be telling people that they did not see the impact. I know of no one, no one Ace, who says that the south face of the tower just exploded for no descernable reason. Do you?
 
http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/Chopper5Velocity.html




Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 6 removed.


Several of your other posts have just been deleted since they were nothing but spamming this Forum with your own material.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
It's not sloppy photoshoping, its sloppy work stabilizing the video. The red lines hide the edges of the towers in the stabilized video. Therefore there is no accurate reference point in these videos to confirm that the video has been properly stabilized. This will account for the changing speeds of the plane seen in the (poorly stabilized) video. When this video is redone without the red lines, I'll make a reexamination.
 
No one is ever going to convice Ace. It doesn't matter how hard you try or how much evidence you provide.

Crazy people don't know they're crazy.

Let the thread die.
 
3?4 inch tape?? Who uses that anymore?
Most large and medium sized TV stations have gone to digital format even on ENG reports. Some have maintained a professional analog Beta format though.

This was 2001, WNYW probably recorded onto 3/4 in tape, but who knows. I'll write and ask for a copy.

At any rate there has been a recording, a playback and re-recording of this clip. That much is patently obvious.

If it was recorded on a professional VTR with stable frame rate there would still be a small error from 29.97 fps.

It depends what you mean by small. From frame to frame, I doubt the variance is much greater than 1/1000 second, if that. Frame lock must be very accurate to work at all.

Now this clip was played back and re-recorded. The playback would also have a small error from 29.97 fps and so would the next recording. Each of these errors are not necessarily the same nor constant. The error multiplies each time you do this. However, the error is not constant in each case, ie. the flyback time between frame a and frame b might be off by +0.05% whereas the the flyback time between frame b and frame c is only off by -0.05% however that would mean that the difference between frame a and frame c is 0.1%.

You don't understand. Once you have recorded the video, it exists as a series of frames, each frame being comprised of two interlaced fields. Making a new recording from that can only copy those frames. Fidelity loss from the picture can occur, but it cannot displace those frames in time. As far as frame rate is concerned, the only issue is whether there are any frames missing.

If the original recording had 32,457 frames in it, a copy would also have 32,457 frames in it, assuming there is no frame rate conversion.

But that is not all. Once again I point out that the video went through a CG to insert the banner graphics and that processing also introduces errors even before it gets recorded.

It does not change the frame rate, it does not discard frames.

Then there is the problem with compression of the digital formats. If the clip has been digitized in one format then rendered again in another format or even in the same format you have just compressed the file twice and compounded the compression atifacts.

Won't affect frame rate, won't affect apparent position. Will affect colors and resolution, dealt with in article.

In order to even aproach any meaningful examination of this video clip one absolutly must have the rawest video there is. Without that this is a meaningless exercise Ace. That's the long and short of it, you simply cannot create a silk purse from a sow's ear(even if the actors on CSI do it routinely).

The plane is NOT moving perpendicular to the axis of the lens and this DOES make a difference ACE. First of all the plane was banking and turning pretty hard. that does two things. It presents a differeing profile to the camera in each frame. Second, it presents a varying reflection of the light, especially from the radically convex nose of the aircraft, in each frame and both of the previous items also are affected by the motion of the camera which is not only moving laterally and vertically but also the helicopter would be yawing which would change the angle at which the camera is pointed.

This can be answered, one way or another, with control cases. I'll do that, but it will take me a few weeks.

But it does not end there since you have not come up with any technical explanation of how this trickery was accomplished live and without significant delay.

False.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/Chopper5Velocity.html#Hypothesis_1


Nor have you explained how it was accomplished on the other 40 or so live shots of the impact of the aircraft as well. With 40 live feeds then you must have 40 CG artists all doing their own magic on each feed and getting it right each time. That's 40 more people 'in on it" Ace. Given the randomness of the placement of each of these cameras you simply could not program a machine to do it for you. It would have to have an operator do it live.

There aren't anything like 40 live shots. I think there are 2 or 3. The rest surfaced much later. Remember, none of the live shots actually shows a plane hitting a tower. None. As in zero.

You also neglect the eyewitnesses , not just those who you have been told saw the impact but the thousands of people in the vicinity who would be looking towards tower 1 when tower 2 gets hit. Many, I daresay most, would also have then seen tower 2 get hit given they would be attuned to the sound of a jet, and were watching the towers already. If these people were looking towards the south face of tower 2 and tower 1 when without warning tower 2 blows up they would later be telling people that they did not see the impact. I know of no one, no one Ace, who says that the south face of the tower just exploded for no descernable reason. Do you?

Yes. How about these firefighters:

http://911researchers.com/node/570
 
What's your point with that last post truth. Do you honestly think that negates the THOUSANDS of people who saw an actual plane strike the second tower? Do you know how tall the towers were? That's right, 110 stories. Do you know where the planes struck the towers? That's right, about the 94th and 78th floors respectively. Know what a plane striking a building at those heights looks like from the ground? That's what I thought.

How can you sit there and actually make yourself believe planes didn't strike the towers? How can you call all the people who live and work nearby the site of the tragidy, who saw that horrific event LIVE , liars. How can you disrespect the dead this way?

Fortunately I'll never understand your psyche as I'm rooted in sanity.
 
This was 2001, WNYW probably recorded onto 3/4 in tape, but who knows. I'll write and ask for a copy.



Give up this madness and seek psychiatric help.




It depends what you mean by small. From frame to frame, I doubt the variance is much greater than 1/1000 second, if that. Frame lock must be very accurate to work at all.



You don't understand. Once you have recorded the video, it exists as a series of frames, each frame being comprised of two interlaced fields. Making a new recording from that can only copy those frames. Fidelity loss from the picture can occur, but it cannot displace those frames in time. As far as frame rate is concerned, the only issue is whether there are any frames missing.


No, YOU don't understand. Once again, you are debating a technical subject that you know nothing about. The people with whom you are debating know vastly more than you.

You are ill, Ace: seek treatment.




If the original recording had 32,457 frames in it, a copy would also have 32,457 frames in it, assuming there is no frame rate conversion.



It does not change the frame rate, it does not discard frames.



Won't affect frame rate, won't affect apparent position. Will affect colors and resolution, dealt with in article.



Stop posting uninformed drivel and get medical attention.


This can be answered, one way or another, with control cases. I'll do that, but it will take me a few weeks.



False.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/Chopper5Velocity.html#Hypothesis_1


Your thoroughly debunked gibberish reveals you to be insane. Get help, Ace.


There aren't anything like 40 live shots. I think there are 2 or 3. The rest surfaced much later. Remember, none of the live shots actually shows a plane hitting a tower. None. As in zero.



Stop making up fantastic lies, Ace. THOUSANDS of people saw a plane fly into a building.

You require medical help.


Yes. How about these firefighters:

http://911researchers.com/node/570


Appropriately, a psychotic links to one of the most deranged groups of maniacs on the net.
 
There aren't anything like 40 live shots. I think there are 2 or 3. The rest surfaced much later. Remember, none of the live shots actually shows a plane hitting a tower. None. As in zero.

I know of and have seen 2 that have never been released. These people have no interest in putting them on ytube or google. They're a private reminder of the day. One is a friend that lost his wife.
 
I know of and have seen 2 that have never been released. These people have no interest in putting them on ytube or google. They're a private reminder of the day. One is a friend that lost his wife.

If that's true, I will pay money for copies of them. Money can be donated to the charity of your choice, or kept.

Please, describe what they show, location, distance, etc.
 
DGM,

That's what these freaks don't get! How many other hundreds of individuals are in situations just like yourself? Once the first tower was truck could anyone fathom the number of cell phone cameras, movie cameras and eyes were on the towers before and as the second tower was hit?

It's utterly mind boggling to me that anyone might actually believe no planes hit the towers. It's already been stated, but I do believe if someone is that delusional they should seek help and should probably not be loose in society. (I'm not making a joke with that last sentence.)

Part of me is just hoping they're only doing it for attention even though my mind tells me otherwise.
 
DGM,

That's what these freaks don't get! How many other hundreds of individuals are in situations just like yourself? Once the first tower was truck could anyone fathom the number of cell phone cameras, movie cameras and eyes were on the towers before and as the second tower was hit?

It's utterly mind boggling to me that anyone might actually believe no planes hit the towers. It's already been stated, but I do believe if someone is that delusional they should seek help and should probably not be loose in society. (I'm not making a joke with that last sentence.)

Part of me is just hoping they're only doing it for attention even though my mind tells me otherwise.


Ace is not a charlatan who craves attention: He is seriously ill.
 
Honestly Ron, I know myna birds that repeat themselves less than you. "Ace Baker's insane". "Ace Baker's insane". "Squawk".
 
peteweaver,

Unfortunately Ace is correct for once. It's Myna or Mina or mynah.

However, spelling prowess does not a sane mind make.
 
This was 2001, WNYW probably recorded onto 3/4 in tape, but who knows. I'll write and ask for a copy.

Perhaps, but Beta was better and is still used while 3/4 has gone the way of the dinosaurs.


It depends what you mean by small. From frame to frame, I doubt the variance is much greater than 1/1000 second, if that. Frame lock must be very accurate to work at all.

That would make an error of about 1 foot

If there is any variance at all would you not at least have to include it in your positional error?




You don't understand. Once you have recorded the video, it exists as a series of frames, each frame being comprised of two interlaced fields. Making a new recording from that can only copy those frames. Fidelity loss from the picture can occur, but it cannot displace those frames in time. As far as frame rate is concerned, the only issue is whether there are any frames missing


If the original recording had 32,457 frames in it, a copy would also have 32,457 frames in it, assuming there is no frame rate conversion.



It does not change the frame rate, it does not discard frames. .

A discarded frame would result in a difference of 733 feet. See anything in your digital video that represents a skip of 733 feet more than expected? If so then a frame indeed was dropped by a conversion somewhere.

Well, and that fidelity loss which I and others have also addressed and you ignore.


Won't affect frame rate, won't affect apparent position. Will affect colors and resolution, dealt with in article

Actually it will affect position given that you are measuring position by locateing the pixels you designate as the nose of the aircraft which is a sharp edged object which will suffer bleeding into the background which when rendered digitally will either be displayed as the background OR the plane but it will be a crap shoot as to which. Recompressing the video will do this again to the new edge of the aircraft thus generating the distinct possiblity of several pixels error.



This can be answered, one way or another, with control cases. I'll do that, but it will take me a few weeks.

Which, as has been pointed out, you should have done before publishing. It only serves to illustrate your rush to judgement based on your desire to prove a preconceived notion, no matter how many other questions it begs.




Would again require that an operator control where the images are in real time, for every image that was being taken.
CNN,CBS,NBC,ABC,CBC, and many other live feeds and TPTB would also have to be prepared for ALL possiblities, that is all possible broadcasters and every conceivable angle.




There aren't anything like 40 live shots. I think there are 2 or 3. The rest surfaced much later. Remember, none of the live shots actually shows a plane hitting a tower. None. As in zero.

Even if you are correct then pray tell , how did TPTB arange for there to be no live feed from the south side of the towers? How did they then also arrange to manipulate the recorded shots that did show the plane hit?



Yes. How about these firefighters:

http://911researchers.com/node/570


Perhaps you missed what I said. I want someone who was watching the tower's south side while having an unobstructed view of the sky, and reporting that the tower just exploded for no discernable reason. I do not want someone who was driving, eyes on the road, I do not want someone who was in a vehicles that had a loud and powerful deisel engine and sirens blaring. You cannot produce that person. In every case in that article the biggest question you can ask is why did they not hear the aircraft roar overhead and look up. But in each case there is a ready answer, road noise, vehicle noise, sheilding by the roof of the vehicle and sirens.


Where are the pedestrians and on lookers doing nothing else but watch the burning tower while they stood in the open to the south of both buildings who state that the tower just exploded for no reason, ACE?

Why are there hundreds of people who do report seeing and hearing the aircraft come in and saw it impact and why do you simply ignore them, or worse yet, accuse them of lieing Ace?

Why is it that you cannot see that your entire supposed conspiracy to fake two planes hitting two buildings is so vastly complicated, complex and unnecessary? It would be greatly easier to actually have two aircraft hit the towers than to fake it in the hopes that you can fool all onlookers and all but a handful of those watching it live accross that globe?

You no-planers are the laughing stock of both sides of the debate.
 
If that's true, I will pay money for copies of them. Money can be donated to the charity of your choice, or kept.

Please, describe what they show, location, distance, etc.

You are sick. I should put him in touch with you. You can see the video from 2 blocks away and explain to him what killed his wife. He's on the phone with her in the video.
 
Actually Ace I don't think you would be able to use chroma key on the sky. the chroma phase would have to be too wide and you'd end up with the plane being seen through the windows to the building or worse yet parts of the plane entering and exiting the scene before the impact.

There is very good reason why blue and green screens are strict mono-color.

Maybe I'll try it tomorrow. I'll tape a seagull in the distance against a cloud and then try to layer it on top of a clear sky using the chroma key magic that Ace claims is possible. there are no high rises nearby though so I don't know if I can make it disappear behind one.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom