Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Eyewitnesses are outside the scope of this paper, but I'll touch on some points.

Logically, if even one person really saw a 767 crash into the south tower, that would invalidate the no plane theory. But there are reasons that eyewitness testimony is less valued than physical evidence. People lie. People are mistaken. People are suggestible. Etc.

Ningen has posted some interesting research tonight. We seem to have a number of firefighters saying they saw the south tower explode, and did not see or hear a plane.

http://911researchers.com/node/570


Ace, THOUSANDS of eyewitnesses watched the crash of Flight 175 from the street and their office windows. You can't wish them away. No matter what nonsense is fabricated by some crackpot, those witnesses saw a plane hit a building. For many, it remains the most vivid memory of their lives. I know three people who would be happy to tell any tinfoil-hatted loon what to do with his fantasies. There is no "research" that can invalidate a reality shared by so many independent observers. No, they are not shills; they are not liars; they do not work for the gubmint. The planes existed, Ace. They were flown into buildings by the jihadists who hijacked them.
 
Ace, THOUSANDS of eyewitnesses watched the crash of Flight 175 from the street and their office windows. You can't wish them away. No matter what nonsense is fabricated by some crackpot, those witnesses saw a plane hit a building. For many, it remains the most vivid memory of their lives. I know three people who would be happy to tell any tinfoil-hatted loon what to do with his fantasies. There is no "research" that can invalidate a reality shared by so many independent observers. No, they are not shills; they are not liars; they do not work for the gubmint. The planes existed, Ace. They were flown into buildings by the jihadists who hijacked them.

Please have your 3 people contact me and be happy.

[email protected]
 
Please have your 3 people contact me and be happy.

[email protected]


No one is going to contact you because you aren't an honest researcher. That is a matter-of-fact assertion, not an insult. An honest researcher is attempting to determine the truth: the truth holds no interest for you.

One of my former girlfriends loves to argue politics with me. She's one of those quintessentially far-left, upper-Westside creatures. She loathes Republicans and takes a fiendish delight in pushing my buttons by citing Michael Ruppert and Webster Tarpley. She still thinks Bush and Cheney might have allowed the 9/11 attacks to happen.

You won't sell her on your no-planes fantasy, however, for a compelling
reason. She was working in downtown Manhattan on that terrible day and returned home covered in soot and dust. The image of that plane crashing into the tower continues to haunt her. She suffered severe emotional distress that persisted for almost a year from the experience.

She asked me to convey the following message: She saw a plane fly into a building. It was not a bird or a hologram. She saw the plane HIT the building with a thunderous explosion. NOTHING will ever persuade her that she did not see a plane hit that building. She hates Bush at least as much as you do, but you could not be more mistaken in your mad delusion that there were no planes crashing into the Twin Towers.
 
this last video as posted by gravy, proves TS claims as 100% BS. Why? because of all the different angles that need to be "done" if it were faked. including those captured by private individuals.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThPTduiA5jI

that video contains most of the damning evidence against TS claims. 44 different clips of the planes hitting the towers; does he realize that to do a 30 second piece of animation by ANYONE takes nearly 2-3 weeks of modeling and animating and by a team of at least 10-15 people? And we have 44 clips here. various angles, various distances.
 
The videos do a good job a discrediting themselves. We have a black plane in full sunlight in one video, light-colored in another, contradictory approach angles, all sorts of stuff.
Uh, you've offered an in-depth attempt at proving one particular video was a fake. Now continue to the other forty-plus.

Let's do a quick check to assess your special effects spotting abilities: in the movie The Matrix Reloaded, were there any CGI-generated cars in the highway chase sequence? If so, can you spot which ones were digital creations? In the film The Terminator, can you tell me which shots featured stop-motion animation? In the film Aliens, can you describe what, if anything, looked odd about the first shots of Ripley driving the powerloader?
 
Uh, you've offered an in-depth attempt at proving one particular video was a fake. Now continue to the other forty-plus.

Let's do a quick check to assess your special effects spotting abilities: in the movie The Matrix Reloaded, were there any CGI-generated cars in the highway chase sequence? If so, can you spot which ones were digital creations?

Ooh! Ooh! I can I can....pick me!!!!


In the film The Terminator, can you tell me which shots featured stop-motion animation? In the film Aliens, can you describe what, if anything, looked odd about the first shots of Ripley driving the powerloader?
ah jeez....why an easy questions?
 
Ooh! Ooh! I can I can....pick me!!!!
Now, now, let's give our old friend TS a chance first, okay? :)

ah jeez....why an easy questions?
Well, let's start with the easy questions and work our way up to the hard ones. I just wish I could've picked more recent examples, but those older movies are ones I've seen many times and thus examples from them have stuck in my mind more readily. I could give an example from Blade II since that was on TV the other night and thus is still relatively fresh in my mind.
 
haha. blade II the sfx was so bad....eegh.


heres a good one for you Corsair, can you tell me if the lightning effects (the one that was crawling up the "vines" where the pods were) were done in CGI or regular animation.
 
Eyewitnesses are outside the scope of this paper, but I'll touch on some points.

Logically, if even one person really saw a 767 crash into the south tower, that would invalidate the no plane theory. But there are reasons that eyewitness testimony is less valued than physical evidence. People lie. People are mistaken. People are suggestible. Etc.

Ningen has posted some interesting research tonight. We seem to have a number of firefighters saying they saw the south tower explode, and did not see or hear a plane.

http://911researchers.com/node/570

Oh, come on! Enough of this nonsense! Add me to Pomeroo's 3 friends and to the other poster(s) who said they witnessed the event. I'd also be happy to tell you what I think of your theories, but I'd be off to AAH again and have to sit in the corner for a few days.

Ace, I saw the plane fly into the South Tower. I heard its roaring approach from over my right shoulder and behind, meaning I was looking out of the bow-shaped picture windows on the front of 10 Exchange Place in Jersey City.

Do you want me to repeat that?

I saw the plane hit the tower. I was elevated, and there were no screaming people, noisy sirens, or other distractions like the firefighters had to deal with. This is once again the problem with you recreational researchers. You hear of people who did not hear or see something that everyone else saw, and you assume they are correct rather than saying to yourself, "Self, what is it about those people that made them not see/hear what everyone else saw/heard?" Maybe it had to do with the fact that they, like the CNN reporter who only saw the explosion and not the plane, were surrounded by NOISE? D'ya Think?

Nice to have three options, though. Which are you going to accuse me of?

A) Lying?
B) Being mistaken?
C) Being suggestible?

I think I know which one you're going to take.... "Uh, can I buy a vowel, Pat?" (In short, you'll just dodge the issue as you do so many others.)
 
Congratulations. Of 41 United 175 impact video clips you have successfully not proven that this one clip is faked. Only 41 more to go.

Go get 'em tiger!
 
If there was nothing incoming, no missile, no anything, then it's not so risky for the perps. How can someone take a picture of nothing?

If there was, say, a missile, that's riskier. What if a citizen happens to get a video of it coming in?

That's why the safest way to do it is to RAM ACTUAL PLANES into the WTC.

The top of the perpetrator pyramid is the international banking cartel, and the executive branch of the U.S. government. Who could possibly rule the world besides those with the monopoly privilege to create unlimited money?

That's all, of course, assuming all this is true...

That includes looking the other way when the big boys blow up the World Trade Center and cook up a ludicrous fairy tale about 19 party-animal-kamikazee-fundamentalist-hijackers who hate our freedom.

If you hadn't heard of those freedom-haters before, I'm sorry for you.

Irrelevant. This could not possibly cause the apparent velocity to increase and decrease repeatedly.

Oh, yes it could.

Logically, if even one person really saw a 767 crash into the south tower, that would invalidate the no plane theory. But there are reasons that eyewitness testimony is less valued than physical evidence. People lie. People are mistaken. People are suggestible. Etc.

THOUSANDS ???

As for "thousands" of eyewitnesses. . .Evidence please.

:jaw-dropp

Seriously, Ace. You're completely out of touch with reality.
 
You won't sell her on your no-planes fantasy, however, for a compelling
reason. She was working in downtown Manhattan on that terrible day and returned home covered in soot and dust. The image of that plane crashing into the tower continues to haunt her. She suffered severe emotional distress that persisted for almost a year from the experience.

I hope she's okay, now. Please convey my best wishes to her.
 
OK, so summarising so far, we have two pieces of evidence claimed by Ace: (1) artefacts from digital manipulation of the airliner image, most clearly visible in frame 7, and (2) variations in the airliner speed due to camera shake in the hypothetical airliner video. I would argue that neither of these pieces of evidence points the way Ace claims they do.

Firstly, Ace claims that the "halo" in frame 7 is due to the sky colour in this frame being different to the sky colour on 9/11, although the sky colour in all the other frames matches the sky colour on 9/11. This requires that either the sky colour in one frame of the hypothetical airliner-only video was deliberately altered to be different to the sky colour in every other frame, for which there is no sane reason; or that the actual sky colour on 9/11 was varying over a 1/25 second timescale, which is absurd. Therefore, the fact that this halo is visible more in frame 7 than in any other frame strongly suggests that it must be an artefact of video compression.

Secondly, the supposed camera shake in the hypothetical airliner video is required by Ace's theory to be four times the intensity of the actual camera shake in the crash video - this is clear from Ace's data. This requires that the conspirators were intelligent and foresighted enough to realise that investigators would analyse the videos in sufficient detail to reveal discrepancies in the camera shake, that they inexplicably overestimated the camera shake (in a situation it would have been trivial to reproduce before the fact) by a factor of four, and finally that they were so staggeringly ignorant as to be unaware that random errors accumulate rather than cancelling out - something that would be obvious to a first year physics student.

The alternative hypothesis, that these supposed discrepancies are the effects of measurement error, camera frame rate error in the original source video, and digital compression artefacts, has the advantages of requiring no self-contradictory assumptions about motivation of unknown persons, and agrees with all the eyewitness, video and physical evidence of two airliners having hit the WTC towers.

I think it's time for me to leave this discussion, as there's really nothing here to discuss.

Dave
 
Uh, you've offered an in-depth attempt at proving one particular video was a fake. Now continue to the other forty-plus.

Let's do a quick check to assess your special effects spotting abilities: in the movie The Matrix Reloaded, were there any CGI-generated cars in the highway chase sequence? If so, can you spot which ones were digital creations? In the film The Terminator, can you tell me which shots featured stop-motion animation? In the film Aliens, can you describe what, if anything, looked odd about the first shots of Ripley driving the powerloader?
Women can't drive powerloaders?

I'M KIDDING!
 
OK, so summarising so far, we have two pieces of evidence claimed by Ace: (1) artefacts from digital manipulation of the airliner image, most clearly visible in frame 7, and (2) variations in the airliner speed due to camera shake in the hypothetical airliner video. I would argue that neither of these pieces of evidence points the way Ace claims they do.

Firstly, Ace claims that the "halo" in frame 7 is due to the sky colour in this frame being different to the sky colour on 9/11, although the sky colour in all the other frames matches the sky colour on 9/11.

Dave, when you resort to putting words in my mouth, you expose the weakness of your own position. I say the halo and artifacts are more pink in all the frames. In the case of frame 7, it's also that very obvious swatch of "digital paintbrush".

This requires that either the sky colour in one frame of the hypothetical airliner-only video was deliberately altered to be different to the sky colour in every other frame, for which there is no sane reason; or that the actual sky colour on 9/11 was varying over a 1/25 second timescale, which is absurd. Therefore, the fact that this halo is visible more in frame 7 than in any other frame strongly suggests that it must be an artefact of video compression.
Disregard above as complete strawman attack. Repeat, the artifacts are present on all frames.

Secondly, the supposed camera shake in the hypothetical airliner video is required by Ace's theory to be four times the intensity of the actual camera shake in the crash video - this is clear from Ace's data.
That's true.

This requires that the conspirators were intelligent and foresighted enough to realise that investigators would analyse the videos in sufficient detail to reveal discrepancies in the camera shake, that they inexplicably overestimated the camera shake (in a situation it would have been trivial to reproduce before the fact) by a factor of four, and finally that they were so staggeringly ignorant as to be unaware that random errors accumulate rather than cancelling out - something that would be obvious to a first year physics student.
The camera shake in the live shot would not be known, thus it would not be "trivial to reproduce" in the overlay shot. Random errors in this case can either accumulate or cancel out, on a frame-by-frame basis. They were betting that any instability measured in the velocity could just be dismissed as measurement error.

The alternative hypothesis, that these supposed discrepancies are the effects of measurement error, camera frame rate error in the original source video, and digital compression artefacts, has the advantages of requiring no self-contradictory assumptions about motivation of unknown persons, and agrees with all the eyewitness, video and physical evidence of two airliners having hit the WTC towers.

Frame rate error is a non-starter. Even consumer recorders are stable at 29.97 fps. Compression artifacts are a non-starter for velocity information, as explained in the article. They are a valid concern for showing "cut-and-paste", but compression wants to make backgrounds the same color, thus making the pink area behind the engines quite anomalous.

Planes certainly do not agree with all the eyewitnesses, e.g. we have a number of first responders who said the south tower exploded and did not hear or see a plane. We also have at least one on-scene news reporter.

The video composite theory has the advantage of actually fitting the data.

I think it's time for me to leave this discussion, as there's really nothing here to discuss.
Dave was the only one actually making a pretense to scientific rigor. In the end, he resorted to strawman arguments, apparently confident that readers would not take the time to go through the paper.

The issue of possible measurement error is valid. I propose that version 2 of the paper will include control studies of both a legitimate video, and also a known composite video, each with similar resolution and compression as the Chopper 5.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom