Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

Venezuela should not be immune to criticism. If I start daily threads like Oliver does against America then you might have a point. As it is I'm simply voicing an opinion.

I think it is good for you to criticize Chavez, but in the right terms.
You can say that you greatly disagree with his views, that he is behaving badly in many ways, etc. etc.
But, you can not saying that he is a dictator, aspiring or not, so far.
Also, I disagree with Bush` s vision in many ways too, but, I have never dreamt to say that he is a dictator, nor did Oliver ( did he? ).
We all know that Bush was elected with fair elections.
Almost ( eh! eh! - just joking )
 

- Rule by decree, that does not prevent him to undergo elections;
- Chavez called for an end to presidential term limits, that does not prevent him to undergo elections, it just means that he can be re-elected indefinitely;
- eliminating central bank autonomy, strengthening state expropriation powers and giving himself control over international reserves, that is called, centralization of the decision making process, which can be a good thing or a bad thing, not necessarily an anti-democratic thing..

About the " useful idiot " thing, I reply to you that, at least, I am useful..
 
I think it is good for you to criticize Chavez, but in the right terms.
You can say that you greatly disagree with his views, that he is behaving badly in many ways, etc. etc.
Thank you.

But, you can not saying that he is a dictator, aspiring or not, so far.
Hmmm.... Chaves is acting like a dictator.

Also, I disagree with Bush` s vision in many ways too, but, I have never dreamt to say that he is a dictator, nor did Oliver ( did he? ).
We all know that Bush was elected with fair elections.
Almost ( eh! eh! - just joking )
Matteo, you are a fair and honest person and for that I am grateful.

If Bush did what Chavez did I would accuse Bush of acting like a dictator.
 
Thank you.

Hmmm.... Chaves is acting like a dictator.

Matteo, you are a fair and honest person and for that I am grateful.

If Bush did what Chavez did I would accuse Bush of acting like a dictator.

It seems that is ( also ) a word problem.
In my opinion, a dictator is a ruler who, among other things, abolishes free elections.
We agree that this is not be the case for Chavez, at the moment.
But, that basically depends on the meaning we want to give to that word
 
It seems that is ( also ) a word problem.
In my opinion, a dictator is a ruler who, among other things, abolishes free elections.
We agree that this is not be the case for Chavez, at the moment.
But, that basically depends on the meaning we want to give to that word
I'll concede that. That said,
  • Let's wait to see if there is an election.
  • Let's wait to see if Chavez is behind in the polls.
  • Let's wait to see if the election is fair.
Saddam Husein had elections. He always won by a very high margin.
 
This is why I was speaking about free elections.
Anyway, let` s see.. Just, let` s give him a chance..
Oh, sure, you bet. In the mean time I wish he wouldn't act like a... :)

Then again I wish it were 2008 and our elections were held.
 
I am naturally obtuse.

Chavez wins Venezuela re-election
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6205128.stm

With most of the ballots counted, Mr Chavez had taken more than 60% of the vote, officials said.
[..]
Sunday's election saw a high turnout and the poll was monitored by hundreds of international observers.
[..]

And was this election held before or after the conditions I indicated?
 
Sorry. I went on vacation for a week with no internet access.

post 33
I find it funny that people complain that America is ignorant of the world, but when they show an interest in the world, people wonder why we should bother.

post 35
people are afraid [i.e., not complaining that America is ignorant ], is [ about ] which kind of " interest " is America having torwards poor countries
So your response was a non sequitur?

So, the economy is improving?
When did I deny that? (Hint: I didn't.) However, it is improving more slowly than the rest of Latin America, which shouldn't be the case since, unlike Latin America as a whole, Venezuela's economy is based on oil, which has been doing a booming business recently.

Me: And once again, when did I say the people of Venezuela should be denied the vote? (Hint: I did not.)
You: OK, so, since they have chosen Chavez, accept this.
Matteo, did you even read what I wrote? I never denied the people of Venezuela voted for Chavez. So what is there for me to accept? You seem to persist in thinking I think Chavez seized power, when I never claimed that.

It is called the clean-your-own-back-yard-first thing
Says the man from Italy?! Let me know when Italy's politics have been cleaned up and then you can criticize an American for criticizing Venezuelan politics. Sheesh, talk about hypocrisy.

This website does not state that the lives of the poor are improving compare to the rest of Latin America. I know you think it does, but it's clear you didn't read it, or you don't understand it. According to the UN, Venezuela is lagging behind the rest of Latin America, even though Venezuela's main industry -- pretroleum -- is sporting record profits.
 
Mind you, just as an afterthought, to several people such as Marksman and Rob Lister, I would gently suggest nationals from a country managing to comprehensively screw itself through the smoke-and-mirrors economics of the sub-prime market should be a hell of a lot more reticent before they start jumping up and down in forced outrage over the economic mismanagment shown by Chavez.
I didn't bring up the Venezuelan economy. Matteo was making an argument that essentially sounded like "Even if Chavez is curbing freedoms, it's okay, because Chavez is delivering on his promise to help the Venezuelan poor."

Notwithstanding that the argument would be fallacious even if factually accurate, I was pointing out that it was not in fact factually accurate. I am not criticizing Chavez for failing to help the poor as much as his neighbors appear to be helping the poor. I am merely rebutting one of Matteo's factual assumptions.
 
Should we take Chavez seriously?

I appologize if this has already been posted. I might have missed it.

 
So your response was a non sequitur?

Just making my point, about what poor people around the world may be scared about.

When did I deny that? (Hint: I didn't.) However, it is improving more slowly than the rest of Latin America, which shouldn't be the case since, unlike Latin America as a whole, Venezuela's economy is based on oil, which has been doing a booming business recently.

Me: And once again, when did I say the people of Venezuela should be denied the vote? (Hint: I did not.)
You: OK, so, since they have chosen Chavez, accept this.
Matteo, did you even read what I wrote? I never denied the people of Venezuela voted for Chavez. So what is there for me to accept? You seem to persist in thinking I think Chavez seized power, when I never claimed that.

So, we agree that Chavez has ( almost ) all the rights to stay where he is.
Then, you can criticize him, for being an " demagogue ", among other things, even if he never said he wants to take away free elections, and other people can criticize you, asking you to look at what Bush has done ( and Chavez not, so far ), that is starting a war which has led to some tens or hundreds of thousands of civilian casualties.
Yes, we can criticize each other..

Says the man from Italy?! Let me know when Italy's politics have been cleaned up and then you can criticize an American for criticizing Venezuelan politics. Sheesh, talk about hypocrisy.

I have not criticize America or Venezuela.
I have criticized you for criticizing Venezuela in an improper way, that is different.
It was you who said that Chavez was an " demagogue".
I have never called neither Bush nor Chavez as " demagogues "

This website does not state that the lives of the poor are improving compare to the rest of Latin America. I know you think it does, but it's clear you didn't read it, or you don't understand it. According to the UN, Venezuela is lagging behind the rest of Latin America, even though Venezuela's main industry -- pretroleum -- is sporting record profits.

The website stated that, from 2003 to 2005:
- the GDP has grown from 35 to 45 trillion VEB;
- GDP pro-capita from 1400 to 1800 thousand VEB
- inflation down from 30 to less than 20%;
- unemployment down from 16 to 12%
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Chávez#Economic_policy

Beware, I notice from the graphs that the year 2003 was a particularly bad year, so, maybe, it was easy to recover from that year.
But, many comparison stand, even if you compare the indicators of 2005, with the situation in 2001 or 1999, ..
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom