Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Nah, the "immigration very bad" fraction has always been a small bunch of uneducated racists.
The data shows that going back to the 60s, the majority of the public wanted immigration to be reduced. Mass immigration has happened against the wishes of the public.
 
I am trying to imagine any scenario in which the idea of removing citizens who are non-white is anything but outright, blatant racism bordering on genocide. Of course to begin with, it would render those persons homeless, stateless and devoid of the most basic protections that citizenship might be considered to entail. Even if you were on board with the unsavory idea of racial standards for immigration, and racial standards for the granting of citizenship, I think almost anyone with a shred of decency left would reject that level of ethnic cleansing. I certainly would be ashamed to remain a citizen of any such country.

Of course I speak here only as an American, from a country that has its own problems along with a history of diversity, but I think the notion that any citizen should be expelled from the country of their birth or adoption on the basis of race is loathsome in the extreme.

It is hard even to imagine the moral depravity of someone who could think that this is a worthwhile notion.
 
I am trying to imagine any scenario in which the idea of removing citizens who are non-white is anything but outright, blatant racism bordering on genocide. Of course to begin with, it would render those persons homeless, stateless and devoid of the most basic protections that citizenship might be considered to entail. Even if you were on board with the unsavory idea of racial standards for immigration, and racial standards for the granting of citizenship, I think almost anyone with a shred of decency left would reject that level of ethnic cleansing. I certainly would be ashamed to remain a citizen of any such country.

Of course I speak here only as an American, from a country that has its own problems along with a history of diversity, but I think the notion that any citizen should be expelled from the country of their birth or adoption on the basis of race is loathsome in the extreme.

It is hard even to imagine the moral depravity of someone who could think that this is a worthwhile notion.

I agree, but where did this come from?
 
I am trying to imagine any scenario in which the idea of removing citizens who are non-white is anything but outright, blatant racism bordering on genocide. Of course to begin with, it would render those persons homeless, stateless and devoid of the most basic protections that citizenship might be considered to entail. Even if you were on board with the unsavory idea of racial standards for immigration, and racial standards for the granting of citizenship, I think almost anyone with a shred of decency left would reject that level of ethnic cleansing. I certainly would be ashamed to remain a citizen of any such country.
I'm not advocating anything. I think the situation is non-fixable, and in any case nobody in power is interested in fixing it which amounts to the same thing. Honestly though, if you want strife.... import millions and millions of people from other cultures against the wishes of the existing population. Then tell the native population that the new people you've imported are better than them - more "get up and go".

Of course I speak here only as an American, from a country that has its own problems along with a history of diversity, but I think the notion that any citizen should be expelled from the country of their birth or adoption on the basis of race is loathsome in the extreme.
Sure. This is partly why importing millions of immigrants against the wishes of the local population is such a wicked thing to do. There really is no pleasant fix for it once it's done.

It is hard even to imagine the moral depravity of someone who could think that this is a worthwhile notion.
De Tocqueville claims that that is pretty much what the North did when they phased out slavery. Lots of the slaves were sold to the South and you have Lincoln supporting assisting others to leave for Liberia. Is somebody in this thread advocating doing this?
 
Last edited:
The data shows that going back to the 60s, the majority of the public wanted immigration to be reduced. Mass immigration has happened against the wishes of the public.
:rolleyes:
The majority of the population of the USA want legal, safe, abortion to remain. I assume you condemn the current efforts by certain politicians to end this?
 
:rolleyes:
The majority of the population of the USA want legal, safe, abortion to remain. I assume you condemn the current efforts by certain politicians to end this?
I was replying to a claim that immigration was up to the voters, which it manifestly isn't.
 
As a mildly left-leaning white, nominally Christian (though actually atheist), middle-class, middle-aged, straight, cis-male I worry that I'm becoming too much like Daddy Don and will inevitably turn out to be the reactionary anti-immigration, anti-science racist that he eventually became - and which was so at odds with his views earlier in his life.

My responses in this thread, and the posts I'm responding to, give me some scope for optimism. For sure my views are coloured by my life experiences and in particular that it wasn't until I went to university in Bristol that I encountered people with a different cultural background than myself but while I'm not as uncritically pro-immigration as some people are, I'm still not that bad of a reactionary dinosaur as I could be. :)
 
As a mildly left-leaning white, nominally Christian (though actually atheist), middle-class, middle-aged, straight, cis-male I worry that I'm becoming too much like Daddy Don and will inevitably turn out to be the reactionary anti-immigration, anti-science racist that he eventually became - and which was so at odds with his views earlier in his life.

My responses in this thread, and the posts I'm responding to, give me some scope for optimism. For sure my views are coloured by my life experiences and in particular that it wasn't until I went to university in Bristol that I encountered people with a different cultural background than myself but while I'm not as uncritically pro-immigration as some people are, I'm still not that bad of a reactionary dinosaur as I could be. :)
Your dads path and mine may be somewhat similar. 20 years ago, I was a normie soft left liberal.
 
I was replying to a claim that immigration was up to the voters, which it manifestly isn't.

Maybe in the US, but most EU countries do not have the two-party system of the US (barring the UK of course, but well, Brexit and all that)

Here in the Netherlands there are also parties claiming immigration is against the 'will of the silent majority'. And it's their main (and frankly only) political focus to bar foreigners and even make Muslims second class citizens.
Yet at every election they do not go above 15% of the voters.
So while these people are very vocal they are actually a minority, no matter how much they scream to be a majority.
 
How long has that been true for? You can hollow out your country so long as the money keeps coming in. Rome imported barbarians for quite a while and got them to fight its wars before things really fell apart. What would happen to Kuwait if the oil stopped flowing, the US military stopped backing them and the culture actually had to function and be productive?

That wasn't the point you were making- don't move the goalposts. Your claim was that countries with high levels of immigration had their local culture suffer because of it. It you want to refute my point, you need to show how Kuwait's culture, and the culture of the other Gulf states, has suffered because of immigration.

Importing foreign vitality is not a new thing. The Romans did it with the Germanic barbarian tribes. After the Romans left, the Britons did it with the Angles, Saxons and Jutes. There were significant migrations of people throughout European history. There are also many examples of civilizations losing their vitality.

Are you actually claiming that the Angles &c were asked to come by the Britons? Your grasp of history is faulty, there, old bean.
Furthermore, as white British people identify as Anglo-Saxon, i.e. descended from immigrant stock, and these Anglo-Saxons went on to build one of the largest empires the world has ever seen, in what way would you say their culture was weakened by immigration?
 
The weird thing is, when I look at the immigrant dominated area near me.... we aren't talking about college professors, nuclear physicists and
accountants. There is begging there like in The Life of Brian - people faking the most terrible afflictions, until they have to dodge traffic.

The even more weird thing is, when I look at London, one of the most culturally diverse cities in the world, I see any number of college professors, nuclear physicists and accountants.
Have you considered that systemic racism is one of the causes of deprivation in some areas with high proportions of non-whites? Also, when you say 'immigrant-dominated', how are you defining that? Do you mean recently-arrived in the country, or just non-white? Because those non-whites could be second or third-generation native-born.
 
I was watching the BBC Masterchef series and it reminded me how much modern British food owes to different groups of immigrants. The finalists were two people of British/Subcontinental background and third person from Thailand.

I too watched that series. One of the finalists, Radha, as well as drawing from her sub-continental background, also mentioned a love of soft-boiled eggs with buttered toast soldiers, which she charmingly called 'dippy eggs'. She and her family had clearly absorbed British culture, as well as contributing to it.
 
Speaking purely with respect to the UK, that is absolutely false. Immigration policy has been in favour of immigration and contrary to public opinion since at least the 1960s. This is something that elite opinion has pretty uniformly favoured, an popular opinion has disfavoured.

Enoch Powell's famous Rivers of Blood speech was absolutely in line with public sentiment, but his political career was finished by it. The choice has been between party A who will keep immigration increasing and party B who want to keep immigration increasing. Immigration has happened against the will of the British people.

Was Enoch Powell right? Have there been rivers of blood?

At the point where Blair came in and ramped up immigration to the current numbers, Gallup had 62% of respondents wanting immigration to decrease and 7% for it to increase. That's the period the famous quote about how they were going to "rub the Right's nose in diversity" came from. Only 7% of the public wanted anything like that.

This was something that was done intentionally, and against the will of the public.

Your information about the wishes of the public is incorrect.
Please educate yourself:
https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac....ation-overall-attitudes-and-level-of-concern/

tl;dr: Opposition to immigration has declined markedly over the years. People are more interested in the skills of the immigrants than their skin colour.
In other words, we are not as racist as we used to be, and are more interested in importing people with the skills we need to help our country than whining about 'Pakis'.
 
That wasn't the point you were making- don't move the goalposts. Your claim was that countries with high levels of immigration had their local culture suffer because of it. It you want to refute my point, you need to show how Kuwait's culture, and the culture of the other Gulf states, has suffered because of immigration.
I'm not moving goalposts. There are different types if immigration. For thousands of years prisoners have been taken as slaves. They aren't really an issue for the culture who takes them. In the West at the moment, you have an integrationist elite culture that is pretty well insulated from everybody else. Their culture isn't harmed by immigration. I don't know Kuwait well enough, but I've had a look:

Kuwait 31.3%
other Arab 27.9%
South Asian 37.8%
African 1.9%
other 1.1%
https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/kuwait-population

Are the other Arabs from a radically different culture? I don't know. I'd be guessing a lot of Saudis. The South Asians are their servants? If all this immigration was of servants with no rights, I think that would have a negative impact on the culture.... but it is a very different thing to what we are discussing. I also really don't know enough about the culture of Kuwait to have an opinion about whether it had been improved or harmed.

Are you actually claiming that the Angles &c were asked to come by the Britons? Your grasp of history is faulty, there, old bean.
Yes. They were paid to come by Vortigern, King of the Britons and given the Isle of Thanet.

Furthermore, as white British people identify as Anglo-Saxon, i.e. descended from immigrant stock, and these Anglo-Saxons went on to build one of the largest empires the world has ever seen, in what way would you say their culture was weakened by immigration?
The pre-Saxon British culture certainly was. They were driven back to Wales and many had to flee to northern France.
 
Why do racists think what happened in Europe a thousand years ago should ******* matter to anyone today?
 
Last edited:
Maybe in the US, but most EU countries do not have the two-party system of the US (barring the UK of course, but well, Brexit and all that)

Here in the Netherlands there are also parties claiming immigration is against the 'will of the silent majority'. And it's their main (and frankly only) political focus to bar foreigners and even make Muslims second class citizens.
Yet at every election they do not go above 15% of the voters.
So while these people are very vocal they are actually a minority, no matter how much they scream to be a majority.
Do you have opinion polling from the Netherlands on the actual question of immigration? My gut is that they are rather more in favour of immigration than the UK, but I'm genuinely curious.

I found it really difficult to find data outside the UK. I found this
https://www.dw.com/en/many-europeans-worry-about-refugee-terrorists-poll-says/a-19468591
Showing Germany between 2011 and 2016 with about 50% of the population thinking there was too much immigration and 20% thinking immigration had had a generally positive impact.
 
Do you have opinion polling from the Netherlands on the actual question of immigration? My gut is that they are rather more in favour of immigration than the UK, but I'm genuinely curious.

I found it really difficult to find data outside the UK. I found this
https://www.dw.com/en/many-europeans-worry-about-refugee-terrorists-poll-says/a-19468591
Showing Germany between 2011 and 2016 with about 50% of the population thinking there was too much immigration and 20% thinking immigration had had a generally positive impact.

I have no clue, opinion polling isn't that much a thing as far as I know.
What I do know is that the political parties that make it their political focus do not do particularly well. So most people care about other things more.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom