Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Good points, but not what I was aiming at, as I thought my link would show.
My point is that most countries in general, and America in particular, do not allow unchecked legal immigration from hordes of unskilled workers.
In order to get a green card, for example, you must either be sponsored by an American citizen, or have an offer of employment.
The claim that governments of any country have simply thrown open their borders to anyone who wants to come in is just not true. Applicants are assessed on their skills and qualifications, their grasp of the local language, their financial status, any criminal record they have, among other criteria, before being accepted.
The weird thing is, when I look at the immigrant dominated area near me.... we aren't talking about college professors, nuclear physicists and
accountants. There is begging there like in The Life of Brian - people faking the most terrible afflictions, until they have to dodge traffic.
 
The weird thing is, when I look at the immigrant dominated area near me.... we aren't talking about college professors, nuclear physicists and
accountants. There is begging there like in The Life of Brian - people faking the most terrible afflictions, until they have to dodge traffic.

Have you stopped beating your wife yet?
 
Too much straw to tackle without ending up with a conflagration - but tackling a couple of points.

Which racial groups would you apply that to? Bangladeshis perhaps? They seem to be one of the poorest performing immigrant groups in the UK. Would you agree that Bangladeshis are no good? If you dislike another brown immigrant group, by all means name them. Somalis perhaps?

I already said, I base my judgement on individuals, not racial groups. You're the one who keeps dragging this back to race all the time. Why do you do this ?


Why is the melanin level of the community important? Do all these old white communities look the same to you?

The melanin levels seem very important to you. The town I grew up in was, at the time, so insular that I was an exotic immigrant having come all the way from Middlesbrough


And there is something unique about people from the subcontinent that means they are uniquely able to do this and without them everybody would have just sat there and starved?

I don't know but the only two places that bothered to organise meals to be delivered to older, less well off, people; who put together food boxes for less well off families; who put together lunch boxes for kids being taught at home during lockdown were the Indian restaurant and a pub run by a Punjabi family. The town has another 15 or more pubs and a large number of cafes and restaurants but none of them bothered to offer this.

If they hadn't done this:

Would people have starved ? No

Would many families been even worse off ? Yes

Would some older people been less well fed and a little lonelier ? Yes
 
The weird thing is, when I look at the immigrant dominated area near me.... we aren't talking about college professors, nuclear physicists and
accountants. There is begging there like in The Life of Brian - people faking the most terrible afflictions, until they have to dodge traffic.

Come to the Valleys here in Wales and you'll notice a similar absence of college professors, nuclear physicists and accountants. "Immigrant dominated" areas tend to be more affordable which in turn tends to make them less attractive places to live - not least because the housing stock tends to be less desirable (older, smaller, less well situated geographically). The lack of professional classes in an area seems to be less driven by the proportion of immigrants, but rather the proportion of poorer people.

OTOH go to places like Sneyd Park in Bristol where we used to live and you'll find plenty of them, from all over the world and from a broad range of ethnic backgrounds.

edited to add....

Of course if people end up getting "stuck" in less desirable areas, that speaks more to the lack of economic, wealth and social mobility than it does to failings in large swathes of the population.
 
Last edited:
I already said, I base my judgement on individuals, not racial groups. You're the one who keeps dragging this back to race all the time. Why do you do this ?
I've explained already. It's a proxy for culture.

The melanin levels seem very important to you. The town I grew up in was, at the time, so insular that I was an exotic immigrant having come all the way from Middlesbrough
No they aren't. I have explained. I am interested in culture.

I don't know but the only two places that bothered to organise meals to be delivered to older, less well off, people; who put together food boxes for less well off families; who put together lunch boxes for kids being taught at home during lockdown were the Indian restaurant and a pub run by a Punjabi family. The town has another 15 or more pubs and a large number of cafes and restaurants but none of them bothered to offer this.
Well, lots of the old communities have been killed off. Religion is typically the way such things are organised, but nobody believes anymore.

If they hadn't done this:

Would people have starved ? No

Would many families been even worse off ? Yes

Would some older people been less well fed and a little lonelier ? Yes
Would more old people have been lonely because of this, than have felt similar isolation because the community they were born in to is now alien. These kind of things go both ways.
 
Come to the Valleys here in Wales and you'll notice a similar absence of college professors, nuclear physicists and accountants. "Immigrant dominated" areas tend to be more affordable which in turn tends to make them less attractive places to live - not least because the housing stock tends to be less desirable (older, smaller, less well situated geographically). The lack of professional classes in an area seems to be less driven by the proportion of immigrants, but rather the proportion of poorer people.
And? I was responding to your claim about how well qualified the immigrants are.

OTOH go to places like Sneyd Park in Bristol where we used to live and you'll find plenty of them, from all over the world and from a broad range of ethnic backgrounds.
Terrific. Good for them.

Of course if people end up getting "stuck" in less desirable areas, that speaks more to the lack of economic, wealth and social mobility than it does to failings in large swathes of the population.
Unlike the lack of "get up and go" in the native population? Maybe if these immigrants are languishing in poverty, we should import more dynamic immigrants? The strategy is afterall, not to fix the situation for the people who live here, but to just import new people.
 
I've explained already. It's a proxy for culture

Except it isn't. Culturally, I have more in common with Ian Wright than I do with Gerald Depardeu

No they aren't. I have explained. I am interested in culture.

And yet here you are obsessing about the colour of people's skin. :rolleyes:

Well, lots of the old communities have been killed off. Religion is typically the way such things are organised, but nobody believes anymore.

The community hasn't been killed off, a significant proportion of the people I grew up with are still there, it's just that the people who actually contributed to the community were some of its newest members.

Would more old people have been lonely because of this, than have felt similar isolation because the community they were born in to is now alien. These kind of things go both ways.

I'm not sure the arrival of maybe 20 families from different cultural backgrounds turned a town of 5,500 into an alien environment for Daddy Don and his pals. :rolleyes:
 
And? I was responding to your claim about how well qualified the immigrants are.

What was that claim ?

FWIW, on average in the UK, immigrants are better qualified than the "native" population and are net contributors financially.

Terrific. Good for them.

Yes, that's where the accountants, university lecturers and nuclear scientists who grew up in, or used to live in, your "immigrant dominated" area.

Unlike the lack of "get up and go" in the native population? Maybe if these immigrants are languishing in poverty, we should import more dynamic immigrants? The strategy is afterall, not to fix the situation for the people who live here, but to just import new people.

You can have plenty of "get up and go" and still be languishing in poverty.
 
I suppose we can credit the conservatives with a bold attempt to control immigration here. If you can't stop the masses from seeking opportunity, burn the opportunity. If you can't stop the mouthy minorities from yammering about democracy, burn the democracy. When America is a land to flee from and not to, the white majority can once again proudly rule the ruins.

MAGA, Make America Go Away.
 
Except it isn't. Culturally, I have more in common with Ian Wright than I do with Gerald Depardeu
Perhaps.... let's try this. A muslim who is sympathetic to Jihad, would like to live under Sharia and lives in Birmingham.... what race do you think this person is? Old Anglo-Saxon stock perhaps, maybe they re a blonde haired, blue eyed Swede? The experience of most people, most of the time is that culture and race are linked. I'm mentally going through all of my black colleagues at work. They are all English in a way that cultural identifies that as black, the only exception is one of the company directors who was public school educated. Race and culture are highly correlated.

And yet here you are obsessing about the colour of people's skin. :rolleyes:
Culture. This is the delusion of liberalism. You see it advocated by the people who set up what became the EU. The idea that you could just engineer away nations and peoples. You can't. What you do is you set up unresolvable ethno-cultural strife. This is a globalist, nowhere-people ideology.

The community hasn't been killed off, a significant proportion of the people I grew up with are still there, it's just that the people who actually contributed to the community were some of its newest members.
If that is the case, something is wrong with the community.

I'm not sure the arrival of maybe 20 families from different cultural backgrounds turned a town of 5,500 into an alien environment for Daddy Don and his pals. :rolleyes:
That isn't what is being complained about. It's certainly not the situation in the immigrant community near me. There you have elderly people who grew up there in the 50s and 60s who are now a small minority now in an immigrant community.
 
The thread title caught my eye, and I've only read the OP itself, that I'm responding to here. Haven't read any of the other posts here, so far, because I haven't the time: but I do intend to come back later on and give this thread a read.

I mean, it isn't every day that such an openly, nakedly, unashamedly white-supremacist POV is paraded around here at ISF.

Still, at least it is honest. Deeply despicable, but at least not dishonest about the despicable POV its pushing. That honesty I appreciate.


Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?


Can they? That's a sociological question, that needs to be answered objectively, basis current figures, trends, future extrapolation (based on a legal framework that operates both as-is, as well as a further liberalized immigration regime). I haven't those numbers, or those trends, but my off-the-cuff, and obvious, answer is: After a point, probably some will, while some won't.

Should they? Hell no. I mean, that "should" is, in the final analysis, something that the respective voters of those nations need to answer, and not so much a general faceless "us" sitting here. But since the question is being asked here, I suppose it's being asked on grounds of decency, equity, right-and-wrong, humanity, good-and-bad, despicable-and-not-despicable, that sort of thing. And the answer is a most emphatic No. No, they should not.


Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?


No, they don't. (Basis above. Legalistically speaking, obviously it is a question for the voters of the individual nations. If the voters so want, then sure they do have the right, legalistically speaking. But in general terms, most certainly not, they don't.)


I say they do.


Clearly. And I admire your courage and your honesty, in so nakedly parading your despicable views to the world at large, or at least the forum at large.


Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.


And all of the American continents, as well as Australia and NZ, are the lands of their indigenous populations.

Also, in the horror-fantasy land of your psychotic dreams, do you also plan to keep out whites of ethnicity other than Irish, and Germanic, and Russian, from those nations? Because you seem focused on the White-nonWhite question here. So that this thing about Ireland-is-for-the-Irish thing seems like a red herring, basically dishonest disingenuous pseudo-argument/pseudo-justification for your thesis. It falls flat, this latter argument, as it is: but I'm afraid it is not even honest. It is both despicable and dishonest, this latter argument, and I'm disappointed with it. It is so much better to be honest and despicable, than dishonest and despicable.


They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority.


(a) No they don't.

(b) Those are two separate arguments, and the first has nothing to do with the second.

(c) This is a dishonest line, this conflation of two separate arguments. Unlike your OP title and initial setting out of your thesis, which was despicable but honest.


I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.


What about all the nations in the American continents, and Australia, and NZ?


South Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, have all instituted immigration policies that for one thing, work to maintain their ethnic super-majority. There is only one Japan after all, and it has the right to exist.


Don't really know the details of their immigration policies. But the point is what they do isn't what defines what is right. This is a silly line of argument.

But again, legalistically speaking, absolutely, whatever the voters decide for some nation, is legalistically speaking "right", provided it doesn't violate broader constitutional provisions. I mean, obviously. But otherwise, if it turns out some Asian nation has laws and policies that are despicable, then that doesn't somehow make that right and moral and something the rest of the world should emulate.


I believe that Euro nations have the right enforce strict, tight immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic majorities.


Clearly, obviously, you believe that. And sure, you do have the right to your opinion, absolutely.


Do they have the right to remove non-citizen immigrants who are not white? I say its a little rude, but acceptable. Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.


Legalistically speaking, if their constitution allows it, and if their people vote in laws and policies to that effect, sure they have that legalistic right.

In terms of decency, right-and-wrong, equity, humanity, and so on and so forth, no they don't.

It isn't a question of being "rude". It is good to be rude and honest, than disingenuous and dishonest. It is better be despicable and honest, rather than despicable and dishonest. But obviously, it is despicable to be either.


What say you?


Admire your courage in so openly presenting your utterly despicable POV. Shows you have spine. Even if that spine wilts as you start making your case, and resort to dishonest and disingenuous argumentation, but overall I admire your courage and your honesty, in so openly proclaiming your utterly contemptible ideas.
 
What was that claim ?

FWIW, on average in the UK, immigrants are better qualified than the "native" population and are net contributors financially.
Yes.... but how is that distributed. You have a bunch of people coming in to do tech and financial work in the city... and you have a bunch of people who aren't like that. Does importing two Indian programmers mean one unskilled Somali should be let in?

You can have plenty of "get up and go" and still be languishing in poverty.
Clearly not enough. I am sold on your idea that we should import our way out of this. Time to get better immigrants. Maybe we can abandon the current ones to poverty and whatever problems they may have. To hell with them. Let's persuade a bunch of Taiwanese to come over?
 
Perhaps.... let's try this. A muslim who is sympathetic to Jihad, would like to live under Sharia and lives in Birmingham.... what race do you think this person is? Old Anglo-Saxon stock perhaps, maybe they re a blonde haired, blue eyed Swede? The experience of most people, most of the time is that culture and race are linked. I'm mentally going through all of my black colleagues at work. They are all English in a way that cultural identifies that as black, the only exception is one of the company directors who was public school educated. Race and culture are highly correlated.

I don't know, I'd have to see a picture. There are certainly examples of blonde/red-haired Muslims who have been jailed in the UK for terrorist offences.

Thinking about the people I interact with on a regular basis, they seem to have more in common with me culturally regardless of which country they were born and brought up in, the religion (or not) they adhere to and the colour of their skin than, say, the local farmer or the Brexiteer "Gammon" down the pub.

Culture. This is the delusion of liberalism. You see it advocated by the people who set up what became the EU. The idea that you could just engineer away nations and peoples. You can't. What you do is you set up unresolvable ethno-cultural strife. This is a globalist, nowhere-people ideology.

Yet another strawman. I'm not advocating doing away with countries or even "peoples" (whatever the **** that means). You, on the other hand want to perpetuate ethno-cultural strife by drawing hard lines based on skin colour and/or religion and by limiting the opportunities for exchange.

If that is the case, something is wrong with the community.

It's the same as most communities, a few people putting in the hard yards and many more passengers whose only contribution is to complain.

That isn't what is being complained about. It's certainly not the situation in the immigrant community near me. There you have elderly people who grew up there in the 50s and 60s who are now a small minority now in an immigrant community.

I thought we were talking about my home town and specifically the fact that the people who actually did something practical to help during Covid were recent additions to that community.
 
Yes.... but how is that distributed. You have a bunch of people coming in to do tech and financial work in the city... and you have a bunch of people who aren't like that. Does importing two Indian programmers mean one unskilled Somali should be let in?

It seems that your problem isn't so much with immigrants then - after all they are better qualified on average than the population at large. You seem to have a problem with "Untermenschen".

If you're going to go full Adolf then you're going to have to turn veggie and demonstrate a love for dogs. :rolleyes:

Clearly not enough. I am sold on your idea that we should import our way out of this. Time to get better immigrants. Maybe we can abandon the current ones to poverty and whatever problems they may have. To hell with them. Let's persuade a bunch of Taiwanese to come over?

Again with the straw. :rolleyes:

Social and economic mobility and wealth inequality are a huge, and growing, problem in the UK. Immigrants are invariably the scapegoats for this but they suffer just as badly (perhaps worse given the additional challenges that racists and racism give them) as the population at large.

Address the problems of Social and economic mobility and wealth inequality and suddenly immigrants won't be such a problem any more. ;)
 
Should they? Hell no. I mean, that "should" is, in the final analysis, something that the respective voters of those nations need to answer, and not so much a general faceless "us" sitting here.
Speaking purely with respect to the UK, that is absolutely false. Immigration policy has been in favour of immigration and contrary to public opinion since at least the 1960s. This is something that elite opinion has pretty uniformly favoured, an popular opinion has disfavoured.

Enoch Powell's famous Rivers of Blood speech was absolutely in line with public sentiment, but his political career was finished by it. The choice has been between party A who will keep immigration increasing and party B who want to keep immigration increasing. Immigration has happened against the will of the British people.

At the point where Blair came in and ramped up immigration to the current numbers, Gallup had 62% of respondents wanting immigration to decrease and 7% for it to increase. That's the period the famous quote about how they were going to "rub the Right's nose in diversity" came from. Only 7% of the public wanted anything like that.

This was something that was done intentionally, and against the will of the public.
 
Last edited:
Speaking purely with respect to the UK, that is absolutely false. Immigration policy has been in favour of immigration and contrary to public opinion since at least the 1960s. This is something that elite opinion has pretty uniformly favoured, an popular opinion has disfavoured.

Enoch Powell's famous Rivers of Blood speech was absolutely in line with public sentiment, but his political career was finished by it. The choice has been between party A who will keep immigration increasing and party B who want to keep immigration increasing. Immigration has happened against the will of the British people.
At the point where Blair came in and ramped up immigration to the current numbers, Gallup had 62% of respondents wanting immigration to decrease and 7% for it to increase.

This was something that was done intentionally, and against the will of the public.

Nah, the "immigration very bad" fraction has always been a small bunch of uneducated racists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom