Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Suppose that conservative beliefs and attitudes force some groups of immigrants into those ghettoes I mentioned. You can come to a country for the benefits of its laws and discover that its culture denies them to you.
 
Anyone who thinks that Ian Wright isn't proudly English because he's black needs to take a long hard look at themselves.

Exactly; the national sports teams, particularly the England cricket and football teams, and GB Olympic teams, have people with a great diversity of backgrounds. Mo Farah, Raheem Sterling, Katarina Johnson-Thompson, Tessa Sanderson, Monty Panesar, Frank Bruno, are all British despite not being 'white'.
 
I do not, as a general rule, agree with the political views, cultural preferences or societal norms that my great-grandparents held.
I say this with confidence, despite not having known even just my grandparents.

Would it be fair, just and right if my legal status, my rights, were determined by what these long dead people were?

Culture is an ever changing thing. New cultural traits arise in some locality and spread unevenly across already existing geo-cultural areas.

People in Southern Bavaria are far more culturally similar to people in Austria than people in Southern Schleswig, who in turn have a great deal in common with the Danes. And yet either are "Germans".
So we see: There are cultural gradients as you move in any direction throughout a continent, or the landmasses of planet earth. Just as there are gradients of physical traits formerly associated with "races" - and there is at best a lose connection between both.
And both exhibit gradients through the progress of time.

Where do you draw the line?
Why should the borders of today remain cultural or racial borders - they are themselves usually just the result of a snapshot of political circumstances that happened to arise with some degree of randomness at some point in the past. Why should we desire to preserve that particular random state of the past, rather than any other?

Language as determinator of cultures = ethnicities = nations? Well, explain Switzerland - or France, or the United Kingdom, or Ireland, or Spain, or Russia, or Ukraine, or Poland, or Bulgaria, or Turkey, ... or China even! -> Language doesn't work.

It appears to me that Hercules really advocated for all of Europe ("Western Eurasia") becoming one nation. Is that right?
 
I'm not advocating anything. I think the situation is non-fixable, and in any case nobody in power is interested in fixing it which amounts to the same thing. Honestly though, if you want strife.... import millions and millions of people from other cultures against the wishes of the existing population. Then tell the native population that the new people you've imported are better than them - more "get up and go".


Sure. This is partly why importing millions of immigrants against the wishes of the local population is such a wicked thing to do. There really is no pleasant fix for it once it's done.


De Tocqueville claims that that is pretty much what the North did when they phased out slavery. Lots of the slaves were sold to the South and you have Lincoln supporting assisting others to leave for Liberia. Is somebody in this thread advocating doing this?

I can barely believe that I’m reading this. Governments around the world make unpopular decisions all the time about taxes, defence, welfare and, yes, immigration. In Australia’s case (and I’m certain the UK) immigration policy has been driven by a non-discrimination ethos and a desire to meet labour market needs. The halt in immigration due to covid has had a devastating impact on many industry sectors, hospitality and construction in particular.

If there was an opinion poll today I reckon most Australians would want immigration reduced. Government would rightly ignore that poll. And as I said earlier, the nation is objectively better off.
 
I can barely believe that I’m reading this. Governments around the world make unpopular decisions all the time about taxes, defence, welfare and, yes, immigration. In Australia’s case (and I’m certain the UK) immigration policy has been driven by a non-discrimination ethos and a desire to meet labour market needs. The halt in immigration due to covid has had a devastating impact on many industry sectors, hospitality and construction in particular.

If there was an opinion poll today I reckon most Australians would want immigration reduced. Government would rightly ignore that poll. And as I said earlier, the nation is objectively better off.

Yeah, the White Australia policy worked so well.
And then of course there is the treatment of the Aborigines (I understand this term is perfectly acceptable since the people in question use is it themselves)
Back to the Picket fence.
 
Yeah, the White Australia policy worked so well.
And then of course there is the treatment of the Aborigines (I understand this term is perfectly acceptable since the people in question use is it themselves)
Back to the Picket fence.

Read my earlier posts in this thread. I have only been talking about post WW2 immigration.

Can I now dismiss your posts because of slavery?
 
I can barely believe that I’m reading this. Governments around the world make unpopular decisions all the time about taxes, defence, welfare and, yes, immigration. In Australia’s case (and I’m certain the UK) immigration policy has been driven by a non-discrimination ethos and a desire to meet labour market needs. The halt in immigration due to covid has had a devastating impact on many industry sectors, hospitality and construction in particular.

If there was an opinion poll today I reckon most Australians would want immigration reduced. Government would rightly ignore that poll. And as I said earlier, the nation is objectively better off.
Yes. I am aware of many of the motivations for wanting immigration. The ironic thing if we are looking at the UK is that pre-war eugenic arguments morphed into malthusian-environmentalist arguments about how we should stop having babies. This is quite widely supported amongst UK liberals.

Further, the huge levels of immigration didn't come in in the UK until the late 1990s. It had been at around 300,000 for decades and from the late 1990s it goes up in a straight line to 700,000 per year. The economy was being sustained at far lower levels of immigration, and the reduction in the birth rate that partly necessitated the immigration has been a more or less explicit elite policy goal my whole life. It's been one of those assumed goods, like the NHS.
 
If you don't ghettoize immigrants, they assimilate quickly and effectively vanish. Most of their remaining culture seems to be culinary, oddly enough.
Maybe there is a way of doing mass immigration where this happens. The issue is that it isn't happening in the UK and it's too late to do it now. Immigrants gather together in communities and retain their culture. Two London boroughs are now majority Muslim. Going back to the immigration after the end of the second world war, immigrants have taken over areas of cities. I remember Southall in the 1980s being an Indian/Pakistani area of London and 40 years later this is still the case.
 
Was there a time during that early period of America when the majority of US citizens wanted immigration to stop? I thought there was a constant labour shortage as people moved west. I'm not sure what the argument is here. Are we agreeing?


I'm from the UK and the problems here are somewhat different, though I think equally unlikely to be solved. Many problems have no pleasant fix, and yet they are fixed all the same. It just depends on how much pressure builds for a solution. The Civil War wasn't a pleasant solution, but it resolved the tensions that had built up in the 50 years leading up to it.

Of course in the earliest part of America there was no US. It was colonies, and they were nationalistic with regard to their parent countries. Later they were nationalistic on their own. I think there has always been a time when the majority of US citizens (or their colonial forebears) wanted immigration of people not like themselves to stop - except, of course, for slaves. The residents of various places sure as hell did not want the Dutch to keep coming, or the French, or the Spanish, or the Acadians. They fought wars about it and burned down each other's houses and stuff.

Our own national hero Ethan Allen, before he was a lush orator and revolutionary firebrand was the leader of what might well be called a terrorist gang dedicated to burning out the Dutch cultural settlers of Vermont who claimed New York authority, in favor of the English cultural settlers who claimed New Hampshire authority (and whose land developers paid his way).
 
Last edited:
Of course in the earliest part of America there was no US. It was colonies, and they were nationalistic with regard to their parent countries. Later they were nationalistic on their own. I think there has always been a time when the majority of US citizens wanted immigration of people not like themselves to stop - except, of course, for slaves. The residents of various places sure as hell did not want the Dutch to keep coming, or the French, or the Spanish, or the Acadians. They fought wars about it and burned down each other's houses and stuff.
Not wanting the French to come is not the same as not wanting immigration. I talked about US citizens because I was talking about that period. I guess that would be post Louisiana Purchase. As far as I'm aware, through the 19th century there was a labour shortage as people moved west and the conquest of the country required immigrants. Was there ever a time when the majority of US citizens wanted that process to stop?
 
1. We should legally discriminate based on culture.
2. We can infer culture based on skin color.
C. We should legally discriminate based on skin color.

This is just racism with extra (and false) steps.
 
Stick a new feather in racism's hat, and assume no-one will notice that it's the same old tired ****.

Nice try, but no. Everyone can see what you're up to.

ETA: On reflection, I retract the 'nice try'. It's a piss-poor, and very tranparent attempt.
 
Last edited:
Not wanting the French to come is not the same as not wanting immigration. I talked about US citizens because I was talking about that period. I guess that would be post Louisiana Purchase. As far as I'm aware, through the 19th century there was a labour shortage as people moved west and the conquest of the country required immigrants. Was there ever a time when the majority of US citizens wanted that process to stop?
I don't know if many of the migrants heading west wanted immigrants to go with them. Many were fleeing the influx of population where they came from. The growing industrial economy needed immigrants, but I think they preferred any of the less desirable (read not British or Scottish) immigrants to be disenfranchised laborers, coolies, slaves and sharecroppers. Like the starter of the thread, they wanted to maintain their white majority. Immigration in the true sense of the word is something else, I think. The United States has a long history of racist, exclusionary immigration policy, and a society that worked pretty hard to keep them poor and segregated if they got in.
 
Last edited:
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?
Simple answer: no, they don't.

I say they do.
You can say they do, but you would be wrong.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.
That may be your belief, but the laws of most nations say otherwise - for good reason.

Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world...

Article 1

All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.

Article 2

Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status. Furthermore, no distinction shall be made on the basis of the political, jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty...

Article 15

Everyone has the right to a nationality.
No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his nationality nor denied the right to change his nationality.


Hercules56 said:
Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.
You'd be wrong to say that, because they don't have that right.
 
Alls I know is that if we don't start mixing Chinese and American cultures fast, we're not gonna be in Firefly any time soon!
 
When I compare the "get up and go" of immigrants who have come half way around the world to try and improve their lives despite all the challenges they face to the multi-generational unemployed in the Welsh valleys* who turn down work in Cardiff because the 20 minute train journey is too far - I know who I'd like to see contributing to the economy.

Then again, I am biased. My father was an immigrant (though in his later years he'd go on Telegraph fuelled rants about immigrants flooding into rural County Durham), I married an immigrant and I suppose as "and Englishman in Newport" I'm an immigrant too. :o

* - a lazy stereotype but they do exist and Mrs Don comes into contact with them regularly as part of her charity work supporting families who need help with children under 5.

Nah, you're OK- Newport is practically England anyway ;)
 
That sounds kind of racist. I've been told that people are fungible. Is that only not true when we are saying non-whites are better? Seriously though, if there is something about our society that is failing to produce productive people, maybe that is something we need to fix rather than just importing labour? Plenty of civilizations have collapsed by losing their vitality and trying to import new blood.

Immigration allows government to avoid dealing with this fundamental issue. It's like if a parents child was failing at school and so they adopt a couple of hard working indian orphans to keep the family average grade up. Problem solved.

Many of the people The Don is describing, whilst they would consider themselves Welsh, likely came to the area only a few generations ago following the jobs that opened up in the South Wales coalfields. I recognise the stereotype and ironically they will also often be anti-immigration as well, despite the fact their great (or great, great) grand parents were immigrants from the Midlands or the North or elsewhere, seeking work.

Sadly, as The Don says, they don't have the get up and go their forebears had now that work has dried up. This is not a universal, of course and I work with a number of people from those communities who are the complete opposite...but they do exist.

Even in my own hometown, which has much more of a farming, than industrial heritage, old school friends are 'astonished' that I would travel an hour to work and feel there should just be 'more jobs around here'.

Interestingly, my father and grandfather were very proud Welshmen (and I certainly consider myself Welsh) but my surname and our own family history clearly shows we came here from Scotland several generations ago. So, how far do you go back before deciding your nationality or immigration status? After all, aren't most people in the UK immigrants if you go back far enough...and in the US you don't have to go far back at all!
 
If the people are coming for the culture, then surely they will want to adopt the customs etc when they arrive? Otherwise your premise is faulty.

Not necessarily. Suppose for a minute that conservative values create nice, clean, well policed, polite neighbourhoods. One might come to be part of that without wanting to become a conservative. One can go somewhere for the culture without wanting to adopt the culture. I like France, but I wouldn't want to be French.

This - People are coming for the standard of living that the culture has engendered, not necessarily to adopt the culture itself. Of course some do, but clearly many don't.

European culture is presently under threat from both inside and out. Whether it can survive or not will not be decided by simply "keeping a white majority"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom