Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Was Enoch Powell right? Have there been rivers of blood?
That is a historical illusion. But yes, I would say he had been broadly proved correct.


Your information about the wishes of the public is incorrect.
Please educate yourself:
https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac....ation-overall-attitudes-and-level-of-concern/
I'm well aware of the data. Currently, according to your link, and that GALLUP data I was looking at earlier, 44% of people think immigration should be reduced was 17% think it should be increased. This is besides the point. At the point where immigration was being ramped up, that number was north of 60%. Immigration has happened contrary to the will of the majority of the public.
 
Last edited:
Your dads path and mine may be somewhat similar. 20 years ago, I was a normie soft left liberal.

At least with Daddy Don we could put it down to age-related mental deterioration. He was also unaware that my mother was dead and wasn't entirely sure who I was most of the time, but was absolutely certain that immigrants were going to swamp his town and drive down property prices.
 
I have no clue, opinion polling isn't that much a thing as far as I know.
What I do know is that the political parties that make it their political focus do not do particularly well. So most people care about other things more.
No. I know nothing about Netherlands politics, so I won't speak about it.... but given the rise of the AFD in Germany and le Pen in France, and the EU migrant crisis of a few years back. It would be very odd if such surveys weren't part of the national discourse in the Netherlands.

Political parties can be tricky. As I say, the majority of Brits have been against immigration for decades, but no party opposing immigration has even really polled anything significant aside from a brief moment prior to Brexit. Even in other systems, I'm not sure that you should read the election results of a single issue party as an opinion poll on that issue.
 
Maybe in the US, but most EU countries do not have the two-party system of the US (barring the UK of course, but well, Brexit and all that)
Here in the Netherlands there are also parties claiming immigration is against the 'will of the silent majority'. And it's their main (and frankly only) political focus to bar foreigners and even make Muslims second class citizens.
Yet at every election they do not go above 15% of the voters.
So while these people are very vocal they are actually a minority, no matter how much they scream to be a majority.
Duverger's law in action.
 
Pardon me if this is a duplicate post, as I've shuttled back and forth to be sure of things...it comes from Hercules56's original post, in which he suggests exiling citizens (for a price).

Got it, thanks. I missed that, so your post seemed to me to come out of left field. Makes sense now.
 
I'm not advocating anything. I think the situation is non-fixable, and in any case nobody in power is interested in fixing it which amounts to the same thing. Honestly though, if you want strife.... import millions and millions of people from other cultures against the wishes of the existing population. Then tell the native population that the new people you've imported are better than them - more "get up and go".


Sure. This is partly why importing millions of immigrants against the wishes of the local population is such a wicked thing to do. There really is no pleasant fix for it once it's done.


De Tocqueville claims that that is pretty much what the North did when they phased out slavery. Lots of the slaves were sold to the South and you have Lincoln supporting assisting others to leave for Liberia. Is somebody in this thread advocating doing this?

I think Lincoln and others were wrong, but as far as I know, even though wrong, they were not so wrong as to suggest deporting those who did not wish to go.

We are a nation of immigrants, of course, and I imagine the content of your first paragraph is a pretty good paraphrase of the argument made by the first colonists. If the will of the "local population" were that relevant, the Indians would have tossed us out , and if they hadn't, the subsequent now-local population would have thrown out the Irish, and they the Italians, and they the Poles, and so forth.

I might have been vague when I used the word "adoption," but I meant those legally here, and those who have become citizens. There is indeed no "pleasant fix" for that because there is no decent, moral or legal "fix" for it unless you redefine citizenship so far as to deprive it of its meaning., and approach the issue with the assumption that what is good about this country is bad.
 
"So if racism is popular that means it's okay, right?"

No. No it doesn't.

But if you use more words and take pains to say that your not a racist its fine.

Hey, how many of you love curry and have best friends who are black or asian?
 
The data shows that going back to the 60s, the majority of the public wanted immigration to be reduced. Mass immigration has happened against the wishes of the public.

The fact that you could not be bothered to show us that "data" tells me a lot. :)
 
This is your goddamn grandpa going on an hour long rant because "Why should I have to press 1 to hear it in English" slightly reworded and polished.
 
We are a nation of immigrants, of course, and I imagine the content of your first paragraph is a pretty good paraphrase of the argument made by the first colonists. If the will of the "local population" were that relevant, the Indians would have tossed us out , and if they hadn't, the subsequent now-local population would have thrown out the Irish, and they the Italians, and they the Poles, and so forth.
Was there a time during that early period of America when the majority of US citizens wanted immigration to stop? I thought there was a constant labour shortage as people moved west. I'm not sure what the argument is here. Are we agreeing?

I might have been vague when I used the word "adoption," but I meant those legally here, and those who have become citizens. There is indeed no "pleasant fix" for that because there is no decent, moral or legal "fix" for it unless you redefine citizenship so far as to deprive it of its meaning., and approach the issue with the assumption that what is good about this country is bad.
I'm from the UK and the problems here are somewhat different, though I think equally unlikely to be solved. Many problems have no pleasant fix, and yet they are fixed all the same. It just depends on how much pressure builds for a solution. The Civil War wasn't a pleasant solution, but it resolved the tensions that had built up in the 50 years leading up to it.
 
Why does a bunch of 18th century white guys conception of "rights" get to tell the rest of the world how to live? Claiming their view of rights as "universal" seems kind of colonial. Like most colonial projects, it really only works at the point of overwhelming military or economic power.

The idea of the nation state becoming mainstream in Europe is even more recent than that.
 
No. I know nothing about Netherlands politics, so I won't speak about it.... but given the rise of the AFD in Germany and le Pen in France, and the EU migrant crisis of a few years back. It would be very odd if such surveys weren't part of the national discourse in the Netherlands.

Political parties can be tricky. As I say, the majority of Brits have been against immigration for decades, but no party opposing immigration has even really polled anything significant aside from a brief moment prior to Brexit. Even in other systems, I'm not sure that you should read the election results of a single issue party as an opinion poll on that issue.

The AFD is currently collapsing on every front. And before they self destructed (which was predicted long ago) they literally had no power because only the hardcore Neonazis voted for them.

Also, the "EU migrant crisis" was a story made up by the same Neonazis. But good to know who your favourite political parties are. :thumbsup:
 
"The assumption that what is good about this country is bad." Well summed up, bruto. You've condensed reactionary emotions down to a single phrase.

The opposite is also true: they assume that what's worst about this country (or any country; look how they esteem and admire Russia) is best. Hence the right-wing love of brutality, and the glee they find in being coarse, ignorant, stupid, and deliberately destructive.

I said "reactionary emotions" on purpose. Thinking is not their department.
 
Send aid and promote democracy in foreign lands and slow down the wars if you don't want the foreign poor flooding into your country and mating with your women. Developed countries, most of whom can be considered "majority white", are in a privileged position and should exercise restraint imo. Of course some brutally shameless regimes in East Asia and Africa may close their borders to migrants. I think developed nations should be better than that.
 
And in this case "White" is a proxy for European Culture and all it entails. The culture is what draws the migrants from far and wide to the US/Canada, Europe itself and Australia/NewZealand, not the colour of the European skin. Whether the culture can withstand the influx of migrants from other cultures is whole separate question.
If the people are coming for the culture, then surely they will want to adopt the customs etc when they arrive? Otherwise your premise is faulty.
 
If the people are coming for the culture, then surely they will want to adopt the customs etc when they arrive? Otherwise your premise is faulty.
Not necessarily. Suppose for a minute that conservative values create nice, clean, well policed, polite neighbourhoods. One might come to be part of that without wanting to become a conservative. One can go somewhere for the culture without wanting to adopt the culture. I like France, but I wouldn't want to be French.
 
Last edited:
Send aid and promote democracy in foreign lands and slow down the wars if you don't want the foreign poor flooding into your country and mating with your women. Developed countries, most of whom can be considered "majority white", are in a privileged position and should exercise restraint imo. Of course some brutally shameless regimes in East Asia and Africa may close their borders to migrants. I think developed nations should be better than that.
Generally the political class in all of these countries is pro-immigration regardless of what their voters think. The negative consequences of these things don't really apply to them, and you get the boost to GDP to make the graph go up.
 
If the people are coming for the culture, then surely they will want to adopt the customs etc when they arrive? Otherwise your premise is faulty.

If you don't ghettoize immigrants, they assimilate quickly and effectively vanish. Most of their remaining culture seems to be culinary, oddly enough.

Well, wait. If you grow up on essentially English cookery (I did), maybe invasion by cuisine isn't so odd
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom