Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

I recall seeing a book (over 10 years ago), that blames the decline of Western civilisation on jazz. Bascially, it goes back to the 1920s, as before that, music was much more civilised or something.

Unfortunately, I can't find it now. Although this idea is clearly nonesense, as the rot only really started with CocoPops.

I guess you could blame a wide variety of things on some sociatial change you don't like, all the while thinking that things were better in the past overall.

Personally speaking, if you're talking about Dixieland, 60's Free, or 80's Fusion, I'd be willing to consider that hypothesis. :D
 
Exactly. That's what I'm driving at. You have enlightenment axioms, some version of liberte, egalite, fraternite that you can look at and get the answer from. I kind of think The Don has them as well, given that his answer purely focuses on the two people getting married. I don't think like this. I don't have a set of self evident divine truths, whether the 10 commandments, or the declaration of independence, to fall back on.

Show me where that is the case.
 
I recall seeing a book (over 10 years ago), that blames the decline of Western civilisation on jazz. Bascially, it goes back to the 1920s, as before that, music was much more civilised or something.

Unfortunately, I can't find it now. Although this idea is clearly nonesense, as the rot only really started with CocoPops.

I guess you could blame a wide variety of things on some sociatial change you don't like, all the while thinking that things were better in the past overall.
It wasn't Spengler, was it?
 
Show me where that is the case.
Your posts have been edited and I don't have permission to see what they said before you edited them. My recollection of what they said originally was as I describe, if your reasoning is about . Maybe I'm wrong, it doesn't matter.
 
Your posts have been edited and I don't have permission to see what they said before you edited them. My recollection of what they said originally was as I describe, if your reasoning is about . Maybe I'm wrong, it doesn't matter.

If I edit my posts I include the edit after an

"edited to add....."

Unless the edit is just to correct spelling.


edited to add....

Looked back at the post and the edit was just to add content, clearly indicated, after an "edited to add...."
 
Last edited:
Exactly. That's what I'm driving at. You have enlightenment axioms, some version of liberte, egalite, fraternite that you can look at and get the answer from. I kind of think The Don has them as well, given that his answer purely focuses on the two people getting married. I don't think like this. I don't have a set of self evident divine truths, whether the 10 commandments, or the declaration of independence, to fall back on. Your reasoning is the same as a Christian who knows adultery is wrong, because the Bible says so.

Of course, whenever I use the word "should" in this sort of discussion it is according to my moral framework.

You seem to be saying that your moral framework is agnostic on the rights of individuals when they don't affect anyone else.

The underpinning of any moral or ethical framework is ultimately based on axioms or values. Mine is generally that increasing suffering is bad and increasing happiness is good. Of course there are difficult questions where one is balancing one against the other, but this particular question is not that.

If your moral framework is agnostic on whether marriage between consenting adults should be banned, then in my view, it's pretty useless and also highly distasteful.
 
Let's take immigration as the example under discussion. Value of tolerance - you let people in until you find it's not working. By the time you find it isn't working, the situation can't be fixed short of the most terrible choices nobody wants to take. ...snip.

You are at it again you can't just say "not working" and expect us to know what YOU mean by that. It's like you keep dropping the word "problem" as if you have already told us what the problem is.

What do you mean "by not working"?
 
You are at it again you can't just say "not working" and expect us to know what YOU mean by that. It's like you keep dropping the word "problem" as if you have already told us what the problem is.

What do you mean "by not working"?

He means those lazy Pakis who are only in England to game the social system, rape and steal.

ETA: Oh, and of course, to replace the white majority by having lots of children, who will get informed about the plan when they are old enough.
 
Last edited:
Of course, whenever I use the word "should" in this sort of discussion it is according to my moral framework.

You seem to be saying that your moral framework is agnostic on the rights of individuals when they don't affect anyone else.
I disagree that such things don't affect anyone else. You, as a single individual, doing something may have a negligible impact on other people, but it's like the Kantian conception of ethics "what if everybody did it".... most issues that are treated as individual issues actually have huge social implications when a significant number of people are engaging in them.

I think individual issues are like perfect circles, they don't exist in nature. You are right though, what ever ethics I may have is certainly not based on any enlightenment rights of the individual idea.

The underpinning of any moral or ethical framework is ultimately based on axioms or values. Mine is generally that increasing suffering is bad and increasing happiness is good. Of course there are difficult questions where one is balancing one against the other, but this particular question is not that.
That's fine, but I don't think that that is typically the basis of liberal reasoning. I think people much more commonly just equate a thing like liberty or equality with happiness, and then reason from those things. I'm more of a Burkian.

If your moral framework is agnostic on whether marriage between consenting adults should be banned, then in my view, it's pretty useless and also highly distasteful.
Moral ethics that clash with our own always appear distasteful. I'm sure that yours are distasteful to me. This is a given. As to whether inter-racial marriage should be allowed, you are reasoning based on a conception of things that impact the wider society being purely individual matters. Does this in fact increase suffering or happiness? I think these are complicated questions that really depend on the circumstances. If it increased suffering, would it still be good because it's an individual choice and that really takes precedence?

What I see a lot is a denial of the possibility that there is conflict between things like liberty, equality, and the general happiness of man. I think the world is a complicated place and very often they are in conflict.
 
Ok if you won't answer if you think interracial marriage should be allowed or not how about this: What problems arise from allowing interracial marriage? Not "Here is a specific case about two people who were in one and it was bad" but on the whole. What issues arise from allowing interracial marriage?
 
Ok if you won't answer if you think interracial marriage should be allowed or not how about this: What problems arise from allowing interracial marriage? Not "Here is a specific case about two people who were in one and it was bad" but on the whole. What issues arise from allowing interracial marriage?
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there. I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities. I recall other examples of similar statements. Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.

Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people. That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.

I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird). I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide. Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out. I know people here are certain it will, but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%. Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it. Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder? De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not. That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.
 
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there. I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities. I recall other examples of similar statements. Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.

Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people. That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.

I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird). I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide. Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out. I know people here are certain it will, but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%. Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it. Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder? De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not. That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.

I suppose that asking for evidence for your many, many assertions is as ever going to fall on deaf ears?
 
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there. I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities. I recall other examples of similar statements. Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.

Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people. That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.

I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird). I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide. Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out. I know people here are certain it will, but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%. Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it. Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder? De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not. That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.

Highlighting mine...

Interesting example you chose there...why not 'White men' or 'Asians'? Why racially profile it - how about 'Poor people'?

You may want to ask yourself the tough question as to why that example so readily sprang to your mind.
 
I have told you this already Darat. Your mod privileges prevent me from hitting the ignore button, but I am ignoring you. Conversation with you is pointless.

I guess it is if you refuse to answer questions or provide evidence to support your assertions and people keep asking you to.
 
Highlighting mine...

Interesting example you chose there...why not 'White men' or 'Asians'? Why racially profile it - how about 'Poor people'?
I'm being asked a question about race.

You may want to ask yourself the tough question as to why that example so readily sprang to your mind.
Don't tone police me. I'm being asked to speculate. There is no magical property of race that means on average members of different races need to behave the same. This is your sacred cow, not mine.
 
A lot was involved. It can't be boiled down to "we don't like Poles". Immigration has never been popular in the UK going back to the earliest records I have found. It was unpopular long before the mass arrival of Poles. It isn't about any one group of immigrants, and as you kindly point out, it isn't about peoples colour.

The problem the Poles had in the UK, was that you couldn’t see at a glance that they were foreigners. There was that nice hardworking man, but when you tried to talk to him, suddenly you found out he was some kind of alien?
People from countries like India, are also hated in the UK, but as these ‘have the sense to be colour coded’, one can at least keep track where all these pesky foreigners are.

This particular British ‘thing’ of theirs is not a culture that is worthy of emulating. Other parts are better, but they gave a very dark streak in their culture. One which I hope they will grow out of, but am afraid this will not be anytime soon.
 
The problem the Poles had in the UK, was that you couldn’t see at a glance that they were foreigners.
You pretty well can. I mean i guess you'd be wrong sometimes, but not often. I knew a French girl whose grandparents had come over from Poland. She went to Poland and people would speak to her in Polish because they assumed she was local. You looked at her, and you could see it.

There was that nice hardworking man, but when you tried to talk to him, suddenly you found out he was some kind of alien?
This is simply not generally true.
 
You pretty well can. I mean i guess you'd be wrong sometimes, but not often. I knew a French girl whose grandparents had come over from Poland. She went to Poland and people would speak to her in Polish because they assumed she was local. You looked at her, and you could see it.

Or did they just speak to her in Polish because she was in Poland ?

When I was in Germany (as I often used to be on business), people tended to speak to me in German. I don't think I look particularly German.

When we were skiing in Italy in March, people tended to speak to me in Italian. I don't think I look particularly Italian.

When we went to Barcelona last month people tended to speak to me in Spanish or Catalan. I don't think I look particularly Spanish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom