Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

The problem here is that very often these things can't be rolled back, or not without some terrible consequences. Political capital is invested in these policies. Careers and bureaucracies are built on these policies. They aren't rolled back.

why would you want to roll them back?
Clearly, the past policies let to them being replaced by something worse, so the solution needs to be something better than what we started from.
 
On what possible, non-dogmatic, ideological grounds could I answer this question on?

You could just say what you think. It's really not that hard.

I have answered it honestly.

No, you haven't. Look at the first part of your post. That's you refusing to answer the question.

The issue is you can not conceive of somebody not thinking about the world in the liberal enlightenment way you do. I can't imagine who would be making it illegal and what incredible circumstances would have to have come to pass to make it possible. There is no answer that does not depend on that context.

That is not the question you were asked. You were not asked who would make it illegal, or if such laws could be passed. You were asked if you wanted it to be made illegal. Stop ducking and diving, because it makes you look dishonest. Just answer the question.

I suspect if somehow somebody had a stroke and tried to implement such a thing it would bring down torrent of state approved activist violence and in any case it would not come in to force. In these circumstances, the only ones in which I can imagine it being tried.... It seems pointless and harmful to me.

Irrelevant smokescreen.
What do you think? That's all you have to do- just say what you think. Should it be forbidden or not?
 
As a final point here, given that so many EU workers have left, can you point to any effect on British culture? This, after all, is your claim, that British culture is somehow weakened or diluted by immigrants. Now a lot of them have left, has our culture become stronger in any meaningful and measurable way? If not, why do you think removing more immigrants would make any difference?

Immigration has continued, but many EU workers left (unsurprisngly). What has changed is that people are less worried about immigration. Which is interesting.

https://www.ft.com/content/f2d72f42-af5f-4922-8fcb-f50a32f37afc
https://fullfact.org/immigration/eu-migration-and-uk/
 
why would you want to roll them back?
Clearly, the past policies let to them being replaced by something worse, so the solution needs to be something better than what we started from.
Let's take immigration as the example under discussion. Value of tolerance - you let people in until you find it's not working. By the time you find it isn't working, the situation can't be fixed short of the most terrible choices nobody wants to take.

People never really do reassess these things because they become political and tribal and were done for ideological reasons and the cost of admitting error is too high and the solutions too unpleasant. Kicking off these kinds of things is always massively easier than unwinding them. It's like saying - "ok, I think we should squeeze all the toothpaste out of the tube onto this antique silk shirt, and you think we shouldn't. I think your fears that it is going to cause a mess are unfounded. Let's be reasonable and try it and if it causes a mess, we can do it your way".

Even where the change notionally could be undone, the cost of undoing it often rises year on year. I distinctly recall this with the UK's progressive entry into the EU. When moving in, each step is a small thing that we will try and can always be undone. Once in, we are too tightly integrated for it to be conceived that we could possibly leave and the ill will it would create is beyond imagining. This process is repeated with all sorts of programmes and policies. They start as small things, that only the most ill intentioned person would resist at least attempting and in any case are temporary measures designed to remedy particular social ills. 50 years later they are leviathan bureaucracies that can not be rolled back and yet still haven't achieved their original goals.

I do believe that you are genuine in terms of what you are presenting, I just think it isn't how the world operates.
 
Last edited:
Immigration has continued, but many EU workers left (unsurprisngly). What has changed is that people are less worried about immigration. Which is interesting.

https://www.ft.com/content/f2d72f42-af5f-4922-8fcb-f50a32f37afc
https://fullfact.org/immigration/eu-migration-and-uk/

AIUI, acceptance of immigration typically increases as people have more contract with immigrants. Obviously there are people who are frightened/sickened by interactions with "others" but most people find that immigrants are mostly just like us. :confused:
 
Immigration has continued, but many EU workers left (unsurprisngly). What has changed is that people are less worried about immigration. Which is interesting.

https://www.ft.com/content/f2d72f42-af5f-4922-8fcb-f50a32f37afc
https://fullfact.org/immigration/eu-migration-and-uk/
I would say a lot of where it comes in people's list of concerns is news cycle related. You have the EU migrant crisis and Brexit as an example of things that pushed it up the conversation. I would say that this is partly way things like the Muslim rape gangs are ignored, and the race of particular criminals and terrorists is obfuscated. The issue can be managed by not triggering people to think about it.

Do you have the content of the FT story? It is demanding I give it money.
 
[semi-obscure film reference]Somehow this picture springs to mind ;)[/semi-obscure film reference]
When did you stop beating your wife? The only honest answer I will accept is a date in the recent past. Do not duck this question.
 
When did you stop beating your wife? The only honest answer I will accept is a date in the recent past. Do not duck this question.

That's not at all the same, the question "When did you stop beating your wife" contains an implicit confession that you beat your wife - although an answer of "I have never beaten my wife" would seem to deflate that particular "Gotcha".

OTOH "Do you think interracial marriages should be illegal" carries nothing of the same inference in the question and the answer should be pretty simple

  • No, if you don't think interracial marriages should be illegal
  • Yes, if you think interracial marriages should be illegal

I suppose you could try to give a more nuanced answer such as "Even though I would never consider an interracial marriage and would attempt to dissuade anyone I care about from entering one, I still think they should not be illegal" or "They should be legal, but only between people of the same faith" or "Interracial marriage between non-whites is fine, it should just be illegal between whites and non-whites" - but a simple Yes/No could cover it.
 
I would say a lot of where it comes in people's list of concerns is news cycle related. You have the EU migrant crisis and Brexit as an example of things that pushed it up the conversation. I would say that this is partly way things like the Muslim rape gangs are ignored, and the race of particular criminals and terrorists is obfuscated. The issue can be managed by not triggering people to think about it.

Do you have the content of the FT story? It is demanding I give it money.

This is not how it was played before and during the Brexit vote.
It was all about those pesky Poles, that were driving around hauling stuff in their truck, of repairing British houses. Working on the fields, doing all the jobs the British didn't want to do (and still don't) And you can say a lot about the Poles, but not that they are Muslim. Firm Catholic country that is.
 
You could just say what you think. It's really not that hard.
I have. How about we turn it around and you give me your answer and reasoning (particularly the reasoning) and I explain in the context of your answer how my thinking differs? Maybe that will be more productive.

No, you haven't. Look at the first part of your post. That's you refusing to answer the question.
This is like saying that somebody who says they have never been married is refusing to answer the "when did you stop beating your wife?" question. It isn't a universally answerable question. You may have an answer to it... terrific. I don't.

That is not the question you were asked. You were not asked who would make it illegal, or if such laws could be passed. You were asked if you wanted it to be made illegal. Stop ducking and diving, because it makes you look dishonest. Just answer the question.
It isn't an answerable question. Why on Earth would I have a position on whether or not there should be a given law in the absence of any knowledge of the context into which the law was applied? Maybe it would be a great law, maybe it would be terrible.... I don't know. The only thing that makes the question answerable is if you ideology gives your an answer so you don't actually have to consider it.

Irrelevant smokescreen.
What do you think? That's all you have to do- just say what you think. Should it be forbidden or not?
I'm not part of your ideology. I don't have a dogmatic commitment on this point. Unless one has some equivalent of a holy book that gives you divine axioms for the answering of such questions, there is no answer.
 
Last edited:
This is like saying that somebody who says they have never been married is refusing to answer the "when did you stop beating your wife?" question. It isn't a universally answerable question. You may have an answer to it... terrific. I don't.

Seems a pretty simple question to answer to me

"Should interracial marriages be forbidden ?"

I can easily answer that question - no they should not be forbidden.

edited to add...

Even if you that they're a really bad idea because they lead to a dilution of blood race culture, you may still think they should not be forbidden.
 
Last edited:
This is not how it was played before and during the Brexit vote.
It was all about those pesky Poles, that were driving around hauling stuff in their truck, of repairing British houses. Working on the fields, doing all the jobs the British didn't want to do (and still don't) And you can say a lot about the Poles, but not that they are Muslim. Firm Catholic country that is.
A lot was involved. It can't be boiled down to "we don't like Poles". Immigration has never been popular in the UK going back to the earliest records I have found. It was unpopular long before the mass arrival of Poles. It isn't about any one group of immigrants, and as you kindly point out, it isn't about peoples colour.
 
Seems a pretty simple question to answer to me

"Should interracial marriages be forbidden ?"

I can easily answer that question - no they should not be forbidden.
Why should they not be forbidden?
 
Seems a pretty simple question to answer to me

"Should interracial marriages be forbidden ?"

I can easily answer that question - no they should not be forbidden.

Exactly.

It is not a gotcha.
 
Why should they not be forbidden?

Transferring the burden I see.

Just answer the original question please.

edited to add....

Any takers on an over/under about how long it'll be before this is hijacked into a discussion about incestuous marriage, marriage under the age of consent or marriage between different species ? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I recall seeing a book (over 10 years ago), that blames the decline of Western civilisation on jazz. Bascially, it goes back to the 1920s, as before that, music was much more civilised or something.

Unfortunately, I can't find it now. Although this idea is clearly nonesense, as the rot only really started with CocoPops.

I guess you could blame a wide variety of things on some sociatial change you don't like, all the while thinking that things were better in the past overall.
 
Um

WHAT?

Why should we not forbid two consenting adults from marrying?

BECAUSE IT IS NONE OF OUR BUSINESS
Exactly. That's what I'm driving at. You have enlightenment axioms, some version of liberte, egalite, fraternite that you can look at and get the answer from. I kind of think The Don has them as well, given that his answer purely focuses on the two people getting married. I don't think like this. I don't have a set of self evident divine truths, whether the 10 commandments, or the declaration of independence, to fall back on. Your reasoning is the same as a Christian who knows adultery is wrong, because the Bible says so.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom