Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Or did they just speak to her in Polish because she was in Poland ?
That isn't how she told the story. I have been to Poland and nobody thought I was Polish, because I don't look Polish. She looked Polish.

When I was in Germany (as I often used to be on business), people tended to speak to me in German. I don't think I look particularly German.
Maybe it depends on how cosmopolitan the environment is? It really isn't very hard to tell that Poles, Romanians, and Albanians aren't English.
 
That isn't how she told the story. I have been to Poland and nobody thought I was Polish, because I don't look Polish. She looked Polish.

Then you should have told the story better.

She was using the fact that people living in a country will typically start talking to you in the native language(s) for that country to support her belief that she looks Polish.

I could have used my experiences to support similar beliefs that I look German, Italian or Spanish if I had them.

Maybe it depends on how cosmopolitan the environment is? It really isn't very hard to tell that Poles, Romanians, and Albanians aren't English.

Really ?

I mean I understand that recent arrivals may stand out due to their clothing or haircut but someone who has been in the UK for a while is IM indistinguishable from the crowd.

Sounds like you're suggesting that different nationalities have unique, distinguishing physical features.


edited to add.....

People see what they want to see.

The staff in Daddy Don's care home swore that I was the living spit of him. I don't think I looked particularly like him but they knew I was his son so maybe they convinced themselves, maybe they were just being polite. I doubt I am closely related to Daddy Don genetically because when I was conceived, he was thousands of miles away.

Parental family friends swore that I looked just like my maternal grandfather. I don't think I looked particularly like him but they knew I was his grandson so maybe they convinced themselves, maybe they were just being polite. I doubt I am closely related to him genetically but I suppose it's possible, my birth parents only lived 50 miles or so away.
 
Last edited:
Then you should have told the story better.

She was using the fact that people living in a country will typically start talking to you in the native language(s) for that country to support her belief that she looks Polish.

I could have used my experiences to support similar beliefs that I look German, Italian or Spanish if I had them.
She looked Polish. Polish people and French people look different. Take a look at a picture of Vladimir Putin and tell me if he looks Welsh.

I mean I understand that recent arrivals may stand out due to their clothing or haircut but someone who has been in the UK for a while is IM indistinguishable from the crowd.

Sounds like you're suggesting that different nationalities have unique, distinguishing physical features.
Yes, obviously. It doesn't wholly map to national boundaries if you are planning to go pedantic about it, and there is some room for error.... but the chances of not realising that a Polish builder was not native British is very low. Loads of them turned up in the late 90s and early 00's. They looked Polish, dressed Polish and all worked as builders. The odds of looking at a builder and being unsure if he was Polish or Irish would be tiny.
 
She looked Polish. Polish people and French people look different. Take a look at a picture of Vladimir Putin and tell me if he looks Welsh.

I reckon that's simply confirmation bias on your part.

Does he look Welsh ? I don't know, what do Welsh people look like ?

Yes, obviously. It doesn't wholly map to national boundaries if you are planning to go pedantic about it, and there is some room for error.... but the chances of not realising that a Polish builder was not native British is very low. Loads of them turned up in the late 90s and early 00's. They looked Polish, dressed Polish and all worked as builders. The odds of looking at a builder and being unsure if he was Polish or Irish would be tiny.

Again, I reckon that's simply confirmation bias on your part.
 
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there. I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities. I recall other examples of similar statements. Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.

Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people. That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.

I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird). I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide. Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out. I know people here are certain it will, but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%. Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it. Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder? De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not. That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.

I presume you use those reasons for doing absolutely nothing on any subject because you can never know it wouldn't have unintended consequences.

It was a surprisingly illuminating question though.
 
Ah, the old Stephen Colbert bit about not seeing race. OK.

Polish is a race now ? :confused:

IMO it's all down to confirmation bias. I have an Italian surname and have often been told that I look (specifically Northern) Italian - even by some Italians. AFAIK there's nothing Italian about me.
 
I presume you use those reasons for doing absolutely nothing on any subject because you can never know it wouldn't have unintended consequences.

It was a surprisingly illuminating question though.
For once, why not take seriously and consider positions other than your own. I have referred Burke. Any educated person with an interest in the topics we are discussing has read him. He is one of the key figures in the thought that is opposed to your point of view. Presumably you have given serious consideration to different political philosophies?
Edited by sarge: 
removed off-topic comment
Rather than throwing sass, why not explain why the case made by Burke is wrong... rather than acting as if you are ignorant of it? If you don't understand it, that would be like arguing against conservatism while having no clue what conservatism was.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
She looked Polish. Polish people and French people look different. Take a look at a picture of Vladimir Putin and tell me if he looks Welsh.


Yes, obviously. It doesn't wholly map to national boundaries if you are planning to go pedantic about it, and there is some room for error.... but the chances of not realising that a Polish builder was not native British is very low. Loads of them turned up in the late 90s and early 00's. They looked Polish, dressed Polish and all worked as builders. The odds of looking at a builder and being unsure if he was Polish or Irish would be tiny.

What has Putin got to do, with being Polish? :confused:
 
Polish is a race now ? :confused:

IMO it's all down to confirmation bias. I have an Italian surname and have often been told that I look (specifically Northern) Italian - even by some Italians. AFAIK there's nothing Italian about me.
Weird, so these other people also think there are particular appearances that are typical of particular regions? Very strange how that idea got about. You see it all the way back in Roman histories where they describe the characteristic appearance of different peoples. I've heard other people claim that they can tell the difference between different African tribal groups, but you must be right that they all look the same. This must be a very widespread misconception.
 
I don't know, what do Welsh people look like ?

Actually Flanders and Swann had this covered ;)

The Welshman's dishonest, he cheats when he can
And little and dark, more like monkey than man
He works underground with a lamp in his hat
And he sings far too loud, far too often, and flat!
 
On what possible, non-dogmatic, ideological grounds could I answer this question on?


I have answered it honestly. The issue is you can not conceive of somebody not thinking about the world in the liberal enlightenment way you do. I can't imagine who would be making it illegal and what incredible circumstances would have to have come to pass to make it possible. There is no answer that does not depend on that context.

I suspect if somehow somebody had a stroke and tried to implement such a thing it would bring down torrent of state approved activist violence and in any case it would not come in to force. In these circumstances, the only ones in which I can imagine it being tried.... It seems pointless and harmful to me.

Your imagination is faulty, then, since the thing I'm talking about was only recently changed here in the US. It was criminal in Virginia until the Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional in 1970, and the law was not removed from the books in Alabama until 2000. Some of the people currently agitating for the removal of constitutional protection for abortion and birth control are going after that as well, and interracial marriage is one of the "problems" mentioned in the so-called "replacement theory," an idea of growing popularity among white supremacist politicians and mass murderers.

I do not think you have really answered the question, which goes down essentially to a basic question of what, in service of your stated goal, you would consider acceptable in principle. Because if you cannot say where your bottom line is, one must assume there is none. This is not an idle or silly thing to wonder. We are at this moment in a situation where many people are so invested in an idea that they will pay any price to implement it.

I am not talking about the world, or what the world might do or entail. It is not about what is possible but about what you would accept. You are making statement about values and speculating on what might be acceptable in the achievement of those values.

So go ahead, call it ideological, call it what you want. I am asking a pretty simple question.

I contend that if you cannot exclude a radically, unquestionably racist law from the things you would accept to achieve your dream, then you are including it, and the dream includes it, even if you equivocate and say it seems pointless and harmful. We all likely pay a certain price for the things we want most - even small things that seem pointless and harmful might be accepted if the end result is important enough. Values are relative but they are still values, and we can still, I hope, identify them.

So this is one of those things. If it cannot be excluded, then it can be included, and if you cannot say "I would never accept that," then you are saying that even if you hope your dream does not include that price, it would be worth it. And that is where you stand now.

I think it's an important enough component of the ideals you pursue that it deserves to be addressed.
 
For once, why not take seriously and consider positions other than your own. I have referred Burke. Any educated person with an interest in the topics we are discussing has read him. He is one of the key figures in the thought that is opposed to your point of view. Presumably you have given serious consideration to different political philosophies? You are a forum mod holding forth on this topic. Rather than throwing sass, why not explain why the case made by Burke is wrong... rather than acting as if you are ignorant of it? If you don't understand it, that would be like arguing against conservatism while having no clue what conservatism was.

Forget the namedropping - although Burke did seem to be very much in favour of the status quo. Which was all very well for someone for whom the status quo was comfortable.

In your case, you are using this to claim that you are agnostic on whether mixed race marriages should be banned and seem to use the argument that you're not sure of the wider societal impacts of allowing it.

That is pretty lame.
 
Weird, so these other people also think there are particular appearances that are typical of particular regions?

Yes, that's the way confirmation bias works, remember the hits and forget the misses

Very strange how that idea got about. You see it all the way back in Roman histories where they describe the characteristic appearance of different peoples.

Just because a belief is old or persistent, it doesn't make it correct.

I've heard other people claim that they can tell the difference between different African tribal groups, but you must be right that they all look the same. This must be a very widespread misconception.

There are also people who claim to be able to use Technical Analysis to predict the stock market, use the position of the stars to predict the future and tell all kinds of things about wine just by tasting it.

Under laboratory conditions those skills diminish to the point of being indistinguishable from chance.
 
There are also people who claim to be able to use Technical Analysis to predict the stock market, use the position of the stars to predict the future and tell all kinds of things about wine just by tasting it.

Under laboratory conditions those skills diminish to the point of being indistinguishable from chance.

I would also like to know what the relevance would be to the wider discussion even if one can distinguish between a naked photo of typical French person and a typical Dane.
 
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

Mixed-race marriages have been legal around the world for centuries. I think that's enough time to evaluate their effect, which I can summarise with a reasonable degree of confidence as being 'none at all.'
What 'chaos' do you think will arise from mixed-race marriages?

You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there. I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities. I recall other examples of similar statements. Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.

You have this backwards, then. You are saying that the marriage itself is the root of the problem, rather than the intolerance from the people around them, which is the actual problem.

Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people. That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.

I know a good number of mixed race/ mixed nationality married couples. None of them have reported this problem. In fact, it's the opposite: all of them, without exception, have told me how they have been welcomed into both communities, and how their lives have been enriched by this process. Specific examples: English/Korean (two couples I know); British Asian/Egyptian; English/Iranian (two couples I know); American/Vietnamese; English/Turkish.

I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird). I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide. Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Just because you personally do not approve does not mean it's wrong or bad. All of this is speculation based on your own prejudice.
I still do not understand your statement that 'culture is a proxy for race', by the way.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out. I know people here are certain it will, but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%. Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it. Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder? De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Here you go again with your appeal to possible future consequences. Whilst there are obviously problems with both prejudice and integration, I se no evidence that multiculturalism has failed, nor any reason to suppose it will fail. To take a historical example you have used before- the Roman Empire. Hundreds of years of multiculturalism, which provided strength to the empire, not weakness or division. To give you another historical example of the opposite, look at China. Ming Dynasty China closed itself off from the outside world. This led to stagnation and weakness, and ultimately to its conquest and division by outside powers.

Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not. That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.

Abortion is irrelevant to this discussion, but it is revealing you use this as further support for your views. Once again, you seek to deny people the right to control their own destinies, based on some vague and undefined antipathy to things you personally don't like or understand.
Let me ask you this: do you think it preferable that your unquantifiable biases be written into law and forcibly applied to everyone around you, or alternatively that you should allow people to make their own decisions about who they love and who they marry, and that you apply your biases to your life and leave everyone else alone? Claiming that actions contrary to your personal prejudices somehow endanger unspecified aspects of society, and therefore should be banned as a precaution is not a principle I would like to see any society run by. Why your prejudices and not someone else's? Do we all get to dictate who marries whom, or is it just you?
 
I know a good number of mixed race/ mixed nationality married couples. None of them have reported this problem. In fact, it's the opposite: all of them, without exception, have told me how they have been welcomed into both communities, and how their lives have been enriched by this process. Specific examples: English/Korean (two couples I know); British Asian/Egyptian; English/Iranian (two couples I know); American/Vietnamese; English/Turkish.

It could be pure projection. Someone who is uncomfortable with mixed marriages might be tempted to shun someone who has "married out" and assumes that most people feel the way they do and would act accordingly.
 
Your imagination is faulty, then, since the thing I'm talking about was only recently changed here in the US. It was criminal in Virginia until the Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional in 1970, and the law was not removed from the books in Alabama until 2000. Some of the people currently agitating for the removal of constitutional protection for abortion and birth control are going after that as well, and interracial marriage is one of the "problems" mentioned in the so-called "replacement theory," an idea of growing popularity among white supremacist politicians and mass murderers.
OK. So you had some dead laws that haven't been enforced since before I was born. What do you want me to say? I'd have to think about the specific circumstances. At the moment there seems no reasonable likelihood of such a thing being found constitutional.

I do not think you have really answered the question, which goes down essentially to a basic question of what, in service of your stated goal, you would consider acceptable in principle. Because if you cannot say where your bottom line is, one must assume there is none.
Not one that is invariant of circumstances, no. Everything is a tradeoff. Everything has unintended consequences. I don't understand what is so incomprehensible to people about saying that my views are Burkian.... I'm not writing this in Yiddish.

This is not an idle or silly thing to wonder. We are at this moment in a situation where many people are so invested in an idea that they will pay any price to implement it.
I really don't think you guys understand what the other side thinks. The ability of this forum to get opposing views and see what the world looks like from within other perspectives is close to zero. I used to be like that too and it took me several years of really trying to understand conservatives rather than arguing with them to come out of it.

I am not talking about the world, or what the world might do or entail. It is not about what is possible but about what you would accept. You are making statement about values and speculating on what might be acceptable in the achievement of those values.
There is no point in talking. You aren't able to step outside your way of seeing this. I don't know what more to say. None of what I am saying in this conversation is particularly unique or original. These ideas have been around and quite prominent for hundreds of years.... again Burke is a rather dull, but well known, example of aspects of them.

So go ahead, call it ideological, call it what you want. I am asking a pretty simple question.
I'm not ideological on this question, so there is no answer. How many times must I answer your question?

I contend that if you cannot exclude a radically, unquestionably racist law from the things you would accept to achieve your dream, then you are including it, and the dream includes it, even if you equivocate and say it seems pointless and harmful.
I don't see it as having anything to do with achieving a "dream" of mine. It's an irrelevant issue to me that for whatever reason is enormously important to you. You finding it important does not make it important to me.

I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead and excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.


We all likely pay a certain price for the things we want most - even small things that seem pointless and harmful might be accepted if the end result is important enough. Values are relative but they are still values, and we can still, I hope, identify them.
Interracial marriage is not a value.

So this is one of those things. If it cannot be excluded, then it can be included, and if you cannot say "I would never accept that," then you are saying that even if you hope your dream does not include that price, it would be worth it. And that is where you stand now.
Could be. It seems utterly irrelevant to me from anything I want. I've told you from the start that this wasn't something that I had a yes or no answer to, so I don't understand why you are talking like you have drawn this truth out of me.

I think it's an important enough component of the ideals you pursue that it deserves to be addressed.
It's not important at all. If I think it is going to cause more misery than it saves, I am against it. If I think it is going to save more misery than it causes, then I am for it. It's like "if by whisky...".
 
Last edited:
I still do not understand your statement that 'culture is a proxy for race', by the way.

Perhaps because it's borderline acceptable to claim to find fault with a culture whereas it's unacceptable to find fault with a race.

"N-words are lazy" is unacceptable

"The Jamaican culture doesn't promote a Calvinist work ethic" may be acceptable
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom