Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

I really don't think you guys understand what the other side thinks. The ability of this forum to get opposing views and see what the world looks like from within other perspectives is close to zero. I used to be like that too and it took me several years of really trying to understand conservatives rather than arguing with them to come out of it.

Your continued refusal to say what you think is not really helping that, is it?

I'm not ideological on this question, so there is no answer. How many times must I answer your question?

Once would do.

I don't see it as having anything to do with achieving a "dream" of mine. It's an irrelevant issue to me that for whatever reason is enormously important to you. You finding it important does not make it important to me.

Then answer the question, and give your reasons. Moreover, explain the 'chaos' you think would result from what you say is an irrelevant issue.

I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead an excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.

No, you don't. At least, not the extent of allowing them to marry whom they wish, or to live where they wish.
And please don't pretend that the opposition to your racism is some form of religious dogma. It's not. It's based on humanitarianism, nothing more.


Interracial marriage is not a value.

The right of people to marry who they choose to marry without interference is absolutely a value.

Could be. It seems utterly irrelevant to me from anything I want. I've told you from the start that this wasn't something that I had a yes or no answer to, so I don't understand why you are talking like you have drawn this truth out of me.

Yet everything you have said points to a no answer. How curious.

It's not important at all. If I think it is going to cause more misery than it saves, I am against it. If I think it is going to save more misery than it causes, then I am for it. It's like "if by whisky...".

And beyond unsupported anecdote, you have yet to explain, let alone support with evidence, what kind of misery will be caused by letting people who love each other , marry each other.
As a matter of interest, do you support gay marriage? I'm asking because exactly the same arguments were advanced by opponents of gay marriage too.
 
As a matter of interest, do you support gay marriage? I'm asking because exactly the same arguments were advanced by opponents of gay marriage too.

There are some trenchant views expressed in this thread about the role of the traditional family.
 
Mixed-race marriages have been legal around the world for centuries. I think that's enough time to evaluate their effect, which I can summarise with a reasonable degree of confidence as being 'none at all.'
I am highly doubtful that the necessary work has been done to hold that position with any confidence. The best that could be done is to look at it in some isolated, taking a clock apart kind of way. Burke explains the flaws in this way of looking at things.

What 'chaos' do you think will arise from mixed-race marriages?
Read Burke.

You have this backwards, then. You are saying that the marriage itself is the root of the problem, rather than the intolerance from the people around them, which is the actual problem.
I didn't say what was at the root of the problem. The concept of blame and guilt is you using your morality to understand the situation. Please, park that. I don't know how many times I can tell you guys, I do not share your secular religion.

I know a good number of mixed race/ mixed nationality married couples. None of them have reported this problem. In fact, it's the opposite: all of them, without exception, have told me how they have been welcomed into both communities, and how their lives have been enriched by this process. Specific examples: English/Korean (two couples I know); British Asian/Egyptian; English/Iranian (two couples I know); American/Vietnamese; English/Turkish.
Good for you. We aren't having a debate on whether mixed race marriages were a good idea or not. I was asked to come up with things that might be downsides. I'm certainly not going to get dragged in to defending a topic I have no strong opinions on. I've already said, I don't know and I don't care. Your personal anecdotes are no more convincing than mine. If in one community mixed marriages are all terrific, maybe that is an argument in their favour in that community. If there is another community in which the reverse holds, well maybe that is an argument against them in that community. I am not arguing for a universal solution for all peoples and all time here.

Just because you personally do not approve does not mean it's wrong or bad. All of this is speculation based on your own prejudice.
I do not disapprove. You are doing this on the basis of approving/disapproving. I am not.

I still do not understand your statement that 'culture is a proxy for race', by the way.
The two things are highly correlated. The reason race is significant is because, in an information theory sense, it contains lots of cultural information. Often race, nationality and so on are just easier ways of asking questions about and recording culture. Are they as accurate, probably not... but such is life. Race is also important because people know race encodes cultural information, so they alter their behaviour accordingly, hence there is a feedback loop.

Here you go again with your appeal to possible future consequences. Whilst there are obviously problems with both prejudice and integration, I se no evidence that multiculturalism has failed, nor any reason to suppose it will fail.
I know you don't. Arguing the point would be a thread in itself. I was just asked to give a list of the kind of things that might be problems, not agreeing to debate them.

To take a historical example you have used before- the Roman Empire. Hundreds of years of multiculturalism, which provided strength to the empire, not weakness or division.
I disagree. They allowed foreign tribes to settle in their territory who they did not assimilate. They used the vitality of the foreign tribes to make up for their own flagging strength. This allowed Roman civilisation to become even weaker. Eventually, the foreign tribes became generals, seized Imperial power and abandoned Rome which fell into ruin.

To give you another historical example of the opposite, look at China. Ming Dynasty China closed itself off from the outside world. This led to stagnation and weakness, and ultimately to its conquest and division by outside powers.
Closing yourself off from the outside world is not the only alternative to inviting barbarian tribes in and giving them control of your army. Imperial China lasted a lot longer than Rome.

Abortion is irrelevant to this discussion, but it is revealing you use this as further support for your views. Once again, you seek to deny people the right to control their own destinies, based on some vague and undefined antipathy to things you personally don't like or understand.
It's not about antipathy. If I had to pick right now, I would be content for the legality of abortion to run a broad sweep from being very accessible, to being much more restricted as the populations of individual states and countries desired. You have got to stop projecting your reasoning onto me. Just because to you abortion is all about "a woman's control over their bodies" wouldn't mean that if I was against it I am opposed to women having control over their bodies. It's enormously unlikely that or motivations would be symmetrical in that way.

Let me ask you this: do you think it preferable that your unquantifiable biases be written into law and forcibly applied to everyone around you, or alternatively that you should allow people to make their own decisions about who they love and who they marry, and that you apply your biases to your life and leave everyone else alone?
I think it is better that different societies do things in different ways rather than having a particular liberal progressive conception of individual rights imposed on everybody. That way we can compare the outcomes of different philosophies, and we don't create tensions by trying to force everybody to live under a single system. It seems to me that that might be a good way of reminding ourselves to be humble and that our preferences and moral assumptions are particular to a relatively small group of people rather than being universal.

Claiming that actions contrary to your personal prejudices somehow endanger unspecified aspects of society, and therefore should be banned as a precaution is not a principle I would like to see any society run by. Why your prejudices and not someone else's? Do we all get to dictate who marries whom, or is it just you?
It's a principle that all societies run with. Society is too complicated for everything to be evidenced based. Again, this is Burke. What is standing out to you is that my prejudices, such as they are, are different to yours which you see as universal truths and hence not prejudices.

John J Mearsheimer talks about this in his book Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities talks about the way this view that a particular set of moral assumptions are universal ends up being a call to war.
 
Your continued refusal to say what you think is not really helping that, is it?
I don't think it is me. Again, I started out on this forum thinking as you do. I realised I just couldn't get pro-gun people. It bothered me. They found things convincing that made no sense to me. So I spent a few years trying to understand. You just can't get it without really doing a lot of work and being open and trying to see the world through their eyes. Debates and explanations are next to pointless. Generally this forum has no understanding of conservative thought, so I really don't think the issue is with me.

As to not saying what I think. I've exposed myself to being called a racist on the forum. What secrets do you think I am hiding and why?

Once would do.
I have answered you. You do not like the answer.

Then answer the question, and give your reasons. Moreover, explain the 'chaos' you think would result from what you say is an irrelevant issue.
I didn't say chaos would result. Read Burke.

No, you don't. At least, not the extent of allowing them to marry whom they wish, or to live where they wish.
That the two things are equivalent is part of your belief system not mine. For the love of God absorb that I do not accept your liberal assumptions about the world.

And please don't pretend that the opposition to your racism is some form of religious dogma. It's not. It's based on humanitarianism, nothing more.
No, not humanitarianism. Humanism perhaps, which is a secular religion. You keep trying to smuggle in your religious catechisms as if they were universal self evident truths. They aren't.

The right of people to marry who they choose to marry without interference is absolutely a value.
That is a very specific value. The list of values must be very unwieldy. How do you remember them all? Are you sure you are thinking of all things that your humanistic beliefs tell you have value, or are valuable rather than values themselves?

Yet everything you have said points to a no answer. How curious.
Nope. That is your binary conception of things. Why would I tell you all the things I have told you guys and conceal this secret truth? Do you think I'm afraid the forum is going to think negatively of me if I reveal the horrid truth?

And beyond unsupported anecdote, you have yet to explain, let alone support with evidence, what kind of misery will be caused by letting people who love each other , marry each other.
Will be caused? I don't know. It depends on the circumstances. I do not have your universalist beliefs. Interracial marriage is neither intrinsically good, nor intrinsically bad to me. It doesn't seem like a complicated thing to understand, and yet I fully expect I'm going to be asked it again because you can't conceive that this wouldn't be a moral question for me.

As a matter of interest, do you support gay marriage? I'm asking because exactly the same arguments were advanced by opponents of gay marriage too.
Exactly the same. It isn't a moral question for me. Feel free to ask me this again in your next post though.
 
I am highly doubtful that the necessary work has been done to hold that position with any confidence. The best that could be done is to look at it in some isolated, taking a clock apart kind of way. Burke explains the flaws in this way of looking at things.


Read Burke.


I didn't say what was at the root of the problem. The concept of blame and guilt is you using your morality to understand the situation. Please, park that. I don't know how many times I can tell you guys, I do not share your secular religion.


Good for you. We aren't having a debate on whether mixed race marriages were a good idea or not. I was asked to come up with things that might be downsides. I'm certainly not going to get dragged in to defending a topic I have no strong opinions on. I've already said, I don't know and I don't care. Your personal anecdotes are no more convincing than mine. If in one community mixed marriages are all terrific, maybe that is an argument in their favour in that community. If there is another community in which the reverse holds, well maybe that is an argument against them in that community. I am not arguing for a universal solution for all peoples and all time here.


I do not disapprove. You are doing this on the basis of approving/disapproving. I am not.


The two things are highly correlated. The reason race is significant is because, in an information theory sense, it contains lots of cultural information. Often race, nationality and so on are just easier ways of asking questions about and recording culture. Are they as accurate, probably not... but such is life. Race is also important because people know race encodes cultural information, so they alter their behaviour accordingly, hence there is a feedback loop.


I know you don't. Arguing the point would be a thread in itself. I was just asked to give a list of the kind of things that might be problems, not agreeing to debate them.


I disagree. They allowed foreign tribes to settle in their territory who they did not assimilate. They used the vitality of the foreign tribes to make up for their own flagging strength. This allowed Roman civilisation to become even weaker. Eventually, the foreign tribes became generals, seized Imperial power and abandoned Rome which fell into ruin.


Closing yourself off from the outside world is not the only alternative to inviting barbarian tribes in and giving them control of your army. Imperial China lasted a lot longer than Rome.


It's not about antipathy. If I had to pick right now, I would be content for the legality of abortion to run a broad sweep from being very accessible, to being much more restricted as the populations of individual states and countries desired. You have got to stop projecting your reasoning onto me. Just because to you abortion is all about "a woman's control over their bodies" wouldn't mean that if I was against it I am opposed to women having control over their bodies. It's enormously unlikely that or motivations would be symmetrical in that way.


I think it is better that different societies do things in different ways rather than having a particular liberal progressive conception of individual rights imposed on everybody. That way we can compare the outcomes of different philosophies, and we don't create tensions by trying to force everybody to live under a single system. It seems to me that that might be a good way of reminding ourselves to be humble and that our preferences and moral assumptions are particular to a relatively small group of people rather than being universal.

It's a principle that all societies run with. Society is too complicated for everything to be evidenced based. Again, this is Burke. What is standing out to you is that my prejudices, such as they are, are different to yours which you see as universal truths and hence not prejudices.

John J Mearsheimer talks about this in his book Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities talks about the way this view that a particular set of moral assumptions are universal ends up being a call to war.

Dogwhistle for "If I want to hate brown people, I won't let these pesky libruls tell me not to!!!!"
 
Dogwhistle for "If I want to hate brown people, I won't let these pesky libruls tell me not to!!!!"
Your knowledge of the secret language of fascists is astounding. You must have all the latest code books. Do you have the decoder ring that comes in the boxes of fascist cereal? I thought I was going to slip under the radar here, but you got me!
 
It strikes me that “Read Burke,” is about as good an answer as “read the Bible.”
 
Plus a heavy dose of the "I don't have a strong opinion on this, I'm just repeatedly belaboring the point while ignoring all criticism and taking umbrage at how everyone is treating me" tactic.
 
Forget the namedropping - although Burke did seem to be very much in favour of the status quo. Which was all very well for someone for whom the status quo was comfortable.
He also a Whig who supported the American Revolution, but then predicted the Terror and Napoleon, so maybe he was on to something? He did lose many friends over his position, so I'm really not sure that he took it out of comfort. Do you have a response to his argument beyond pointing out that he is bourgeois and therefore can be ignored?
 
Last edited:
It strikes me that “Read Burke,” is about as good an answer as “read the Bible.”
The idea that people would hold forth on liberal political philosophy and not have read him, and not feel any need to read him, is kind of startling. It's not even a long. How incurious are you guys?
 
Without hope of being understood, I will answer... This isn't something I have given much thought to, so it's just a back of a fag packet answer.

At root of it is Burke's critique of the French Revolution. The workings of society can not be understood with certainty and we need to be humble and cautious about our ability to make changes. It is much easier to ignorantly steer a complicated system towards greater chaos than greater order, and changes often can not simply be undone such that things return to how they were.

Burke was a moron. Seriously, the guy was a traditionalist for the sake of traditionalism. He never supported any of his bald assertions with supporting evidence. I can see why you like him.

You know he rejected the use of reason as the primary tool of deciding what should be done right? Burke was a cautious conservative even for his day. His ideas are not worth much unless you want to argue that all change is bad because something something reasons.
You guys were looking at this in terms of individuals, so I will start there.
I recall a recent statement by a mixed race man saying that he was neither properly one thing or another, an outsider in both communities.

One example by one guy that you don't even bother to provide a source for. Gods you're bad at this.

I recall other examples of similar statements.
...but won't bother providing any links or sources for the claim that there have been similar statements.

Even if you did provide those statements of course, that would absolutely not be evidence of anything society wide unless you could show that this was a common enough attitude to be causing a problem.

Is being born mixed race a source of net strife or happiness? I don't know.
I don't either, but fortunately there are people who DO know. They're called anthropologists and sociologists, and they are not reporting this as being an issue in any of the journals that they publish actual research in. So hey, how about instead of morose navel gazing and hand-wringing, you actually look up the research on this topic. If you find any that indicates that this is a real problem rather than just something you extrapolated from vaguely recalled examples you once read from unnamed sources please let us know.
Following off the back of this first one.... it seems plausible to me that people who are neither quite in one community or another are more likely to be nowhere people.
Navel gazing without a shred of evidence. Just your own supposition based on your own personal biases and not on say, the research being done into the situations of people all over the world. Boy it sure is fun when you can say "I don't know, therefore I assume no one does and I am free to pontificate all I like". Oh wait sorry, I didn't mean fun, I meant idiotic.
That is to say, people who are not rooted to a particular place, community, culture or country. I think that it is at least possible that this would tend to increase the rate of break up community.
More pontificating without any evidence and indeed running contra to the evidence there is.
I have known a few people who have married people from completely different cultures, countries etc... One of my observations is that often the things that one of them will regard as attractive traits of the other are in fact just what people from country X are typically like, where as things that are seen as cultural differences are in fact the other person's personality (and their new husband is kind of weird).
That's nice. Say, remember when I said I didn't want you to give examples of individuals who had a bad experience because it was worthless?
I think the capacity to not understand these things is much greater the further the cultural divide.
Again, it's fun stupid when you can pontificate on things you know nothing about.
Culture is a proxy for race, hence I think this is likely to be far more of a problem in mixed race relationships.

Culture is a proxy for race is it? Tell me then, what is the "white culture"? Or let's be more specific, what is "White British culture"? Please tell me. In fact please provide a detailed description of ANY ethno-culture. Any one at all. Here's a hint, they don't exist.

Now, let's suppose multiculturalism hasn't worked out.
Well I mean it's been going on for over 2000 years, so I think your thought experiment is redundant.
I know people here are certain it will,

Has, not will. At the very latest, the Roman Empire was a large scale experiment on multiculturalism that worked extremely well.
but let's suppose it doesn't. Rather than black men committing 50 odd percent of violent crime, maybe it's 80%.
So we're going to ignore socio-economic reasons for crime rates, ignore racial biases in the criminal system and then straight up just make up statistics to paint black people as bad? I mean it's your (pointless, evidence free) thought experiment but I have to tell you, it's pretty ******* stupid.

Affirmative action is still going on because 60 years of failure has just had 100 years more failure added to it.
What? What is this gibberish?
Would having a significant mixed race population make that problem easier to deal with, or harder?
I don't know, that would depend on a lot of factors such as implicit racial bias and socio-economics. You do understand that it isn't just a case of "black people commit more crimes" don't you?
De Tocqueville thought that thoroughly intermixing the populations to do away with distinct races was a solution. Maybe. I do not think that that is achievable though.

Well not with people like you around, certainly.
Finally, I think things like this, abortion and many other issues have a huge impact in terms of whether society regards them as a good or not.
Yes. So?
That effect has nothing to do with the individual instances, but bleeds into all sorts of other things in a way that is very difficult to quantify.
No. Just...no. It's very easy to quantify a lot of things. Just because you personally think it's hard doesn't make it so.

To take this away from race as an example and use abortion which you have mentioned, we can look at statistics and find that open access to abortions leads to a variety of positive outcomes across the board for the society which has it compared to one that doesn't, not least the number of women who die getting one because even if it's illegal, women will still be having abortions.

However that doesn't mean that people will support open and free abortion rights, not because these benefits don't exist (they do) but because the people are against it for utterly irrational reasons such as religion. Just because public perception of an idea may be poor does not mean the idea must be a bad one, and just because something is obviously beneficial to society does not mean that the public will automatically be for it.

You didn't actually answer my question in any of that vague waffling and hand-wringing though. What is a downside to allowing interracial marriage? Actual examples, not your ignorance based navel gazing.
 
Dogwhistle for "If I want to hate brown people, I won't let these pesky libruls tell me not to!!!!"

And this is what I'm talking about.

I'm so done, just done, with hatred and stupidity being defended with vague, glib, overbroad to the point of meaningless references to truisms about "free speech" or "I'm allowed to think what I want" or any other related broad moral or philosophical concept.

The Nazis didn't get to go "Oh so you just want to live in a 'Jews shouldn't be gassed bubble!' I see you're intolerant of other people's opinions!"

I'm done with people pretending like "The Paradox of Tolerance" is some new fancy concept that hasn't been explained a billion times.

Not being tolerant of intolerance doesn't make you a hypocrite.
 
The idea that people would hold forth on liberal political philosophy and not have read him, and not feel any need to read him, is kind of startling. It's not even a long. How incurious are you guys?

1. I've read Burke as part of the philosophy of politics modules I did at university. I don't recommend him. He was a moron.

2. Even if he wasn't a total dumbass, you should be able to articulate the points that you agree with yourself. Telling people to just "read Burke" is not useful because it does not actually show that you yourself understand what you are instructing people to do.

If you were asked a question on evolution, and you told the other person to just "read Darwin" that wouldn't be a very good answer because you've passed the burden of articulating your response onto the questioner. Had you given a detailed response to the evolutionary question and used Darwin's work to support the argument that would have been fine.

Equally, actually explaining your point of view while referencing Burke would be much more acceptable than just saying "Read Burke" especially without giving any indications as to the specific parts of his published works you expect us to glean understanding from.
 
1. I've read Burke as part of the philosophy of politics modules I did at university. I don't recommend him. He was a moron.
Weird that they would assign him then. Maybe you are smarter than the professors? You remind me of somebody I once knew who claimed to have disproved philosophy by its own arguments. I don't ever recall him reading any philosophy or knowing anything about it. I know you are going to ask, but I'm afraid I don't have a citation to a peer reviewed article for that anecdote.

2. Even if he wasn't a total dumbass, you should be able to articulate the points that you agree with yourself. Telling people to just "read Burke" is not useful because it does not actually show that you yourself understand what you are instructing people to do.
I have articulated them and been ignored. Pointing to Burke is a lot easier than retyping the same thing in different ways only to have it ignored. For anybody on the forum who wanted to learn, Burke is not a bad way in to conservative thought.

If you were asked a question on evolution, and you told the other person to just "read Darwin" that wouldn't be a very good answer because you've passed the burden of articulating your response onto the questioner. Had you given a detailed response to the evolutionary question and used Darwin's work to support the argument that would have been fine.
Perhaps, but if after explaining it repeatedly they seemed to be completely ignorant about the concepts of science even to the Elizabethan level and my explanations were not getting through, maybe my answers might start to become more terse?

Equally, actually explaining your point of view while referencing Burke would be much more acceptable than just saying "Read Burke" especially without giving any indications as to the specific parts of his published works you expect us to glean understanding from.
The thing is, that it is very hard to have a conversation when people seem to be completely ignorant of the two or three hundred years of thought that have led up to the position of the other side. Not only that but they have no interest in understanding it. When ever it is explained, they ignore the explanation and complain it clashes with the arguments of their side. There are a few people here who I would happily talk to, but most of the people posting are just dogmatic ideologues.
 
Last edited:
There are some trenchant views expressed in this thread about the role of the traditional family.

Without actually ever defining what they mean by "traditional family".

ETA: or "white culture" or "problem" or "problems" or in fact anything at all that would mean anyone could begin to understand their apparently well thought out points.
 
Last edited:
Weird that they would assign him then.
They assigned him (well not really, we were given autonomy on what we wanted to read actually) because he's influential. That doesn't make him right, or even useful.
Maybe you are smarter than the professors? You remind me of somebody I once knew who claimed to have disproved philosophy by its own arguments. I don't ever recall him reading any philosophy or knowing anything about it.
Your posturing is amusing, but this is a poor attempt at baiting.

No, I'm not claiming to have been "smarter than my professors". Indeed we were praised if we could provide a critique of what we read. I got a very good mark for an essay in which I ripped into Huntington's deeply racist "Clash of Civilizations" even though it was expected that we read it. All I did was essentially smack talk the man and his ideas, at one point explicitly calling his ideas worthless and without merit and I got a very good grade. It's almost like they don't assume that you should accept what you read and are instead expected to provide critique of it. Funny that.


I have articulated them and been ignored. Pointing to Burke is a lot easier than retyping the same thing in different ways.
If that is true then ok, but were you ignored, or were you told that you needed to provide evidence for any of your claims? Because you do you know. Burke didn't and in fact couldn't because his ideas were nonsense. That isn't to say that unrestricted social change is always necessarily a good thing, but his attitude that everything is fine stop ruining society was predicated on everything being fine when it manifestly was not.

Perhaps, but if after explaining it repeatedly they seemed to be completely ignorant about the concepts of science even to the Elizabethan level and my explanations were not getting through, maybe my answers might start to become more terse?

Again, understandable if that were a good mirror for this discussion. However if all you were doing was making unevidenced assertions, albeit in your own words rather than Burke's, and you were being told that you were doing this, maybe it isn't you that were the aggrieved one?
 
Plus a heavy dose of the "I don't have a strong opinion on this, I'm just repeatedly belaboring the point while ignoring all criticism and taking umbrage at how everyone is treating me" tactic.

It seems to be a variation of JAQing off.

In the end what we have here is a bad faith argument where one side refuses to acknowledge their position believing that they can't be challenged if they cannot be pinned down.

Unless a person either comes from Mars or grew up in a place where they were not exposed to other cultures, they have opinions regarding the issues at hand. Anything else is just bad faith effort at arguing.

That said, legitimist positions can be more complicated than good/bad and yes/no. But that does not make those nuanced positions a good thing. Refusing to acknowledge holding any such positions while using dog whistles and thinking others won't see it is incredibly stupid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom