Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

I think they want to reduce/stop immigration from certain places without outright banning interracial marriage. The first part sorta saves them from having to advocate for the second. There will be interracial marriage in a free society, however that is understood, but it will be kept to a low enough level to keep the the racists comfortable.
 
It's a bit of a hyperbolic definition allowing you to wiggle out of the label on technicalities. Forget about the absolutism "any" would indicate. There is a continuum. Put yourself on that continuum from mildly bigoted to full-blown bigot.

I believe your posts indicate you are more than intolerant of some beliefs like say how I might feel about the Evangelicals that come to my door to preach.
Honestly, I think you guys are utterly blind to how intolerant you are. There is nothing special about my level of intolerance, except that it maps out differently to the intolerance of the forum.
 
I don't think it's trivial at all. I think it is a question of paramount importance, and not one of ideology unless you believe that ideology includes basic ideas about what humanity is and means.
Of course that stuff is ideology.

I think it is relevant and ought to be answerable in its own right. Any person espousing any opinion about anything ought to be able to answer the question simply: do you or do you not believe interracial marriage should be banned?
This is something you really need to grasp or we will keep going around and around in circles. I am not coming at this from some kind of first principles idea of what an ideal country would be like and being against everything that isn't in it. Neither am I coming at it with some revealed universal truths that are invariant across time and circumstances. That's an enlightenment, rationalist, progressive approach. I do not think the world works like that.

I am for or against things based on thinking about what their effect is on the world and what the available options are for changing them. Whether I am in favour of or against interracial marriage isn't something I can answer in the abstract because it isn't an abstract question. For it to happen now the world would have to be so upended that I can't even imagine it in order to form a an opinion. It also seems like such a trivial part of the problems I've been talking about that I see no relevance in it. It could be a good thing, or a bad thing.

You guys have to understand that most of the world does not think in the way that you do.

Of course you can say it's a bad question or a stupid one, or a leading one, or that I'm a fool or something else for asking it, but that is not the same thing as saying it cannot be answered.
It is only an answerable question if ones answer is coming from dogma and ideology.

If it's actually true that race just isn't that big a deal for you, the answer should be simple. If it isn't that suggests that it's a bigger deal than you'd like to admit.
In and of itself it doesn't matter very much to me. It's so utterly correlated with things I do care about though that tripping over it is kind of unavoidable.
 
I simply believe the cultures of this world are all beautiful, unique and special and should be preserved. I believe unlimited white settlement to the Americas was a terrible thing and should have been prevented. Look what it did to the Native Americans.
I like this sentiment. Unfortunately, I think we are coming up against the same irresistible looking forces that did for the Native Americans.
 
Joke all you want. I would say it is the red queen that is behind both. "Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!" Compete, or die. Expand, or the other guy will eat your lunch. That's the game we are in.
 
.... I think we are coming up against the same irresistible looking forces that did for the Native Americans.

I wonder what you believe about North American First Peoples* today. Do you think that they don't exist, that they were wiped out?

I don't wonder how much you know about the FPs before white man. ("Before white man" is Wyoming shorthand for every era before about 1867.) Damn few wasichu know anything about those many, many stone age cultures and their sometimes delightful ways.


* The Canadian term for Indians, Aleuts, and Inuits. I prefer it to Native Americans.
 
Can they? Not really (see below) but they could probably stop further immigration and race mixing if they really tried.

Should they? Hell no. To take my own country as an example, there is no such thing as "British Culture" that can be separated from all of the other cultures that we have either been invaded by or have invaded over the centuries. There is no country on earth that has some kind of "pure" ethno-culture. Not one. There are snippets here and there, Morris Dancing for example is VERY English, but individual practices do not equal a culture. There is no such thing as a pure ethno-state. It just straight up does not exist. Sweden is influenced by the wars it had with its neighbours and the trading it did around the world. France, Belgium, Germany, Spain and the Netherlands all imported and mixed ideas from the various colonies they had. The Roman Empire pretty much ensured that most of Europe and the near and middle East were pretty well mixed before the change to the Common Era.

Are there cultural practices that should be preserved like Morris Dancing, or specific holidays and traditional celebrations from specific areas? Absolutely, these things are culturally valuable and should be preserved. But to pretend this means that there is a specific "British" culture that is somehow under threat from immigration is rampant racist nonsense. It's delusional to think like that and shows a deep lack of understanding of the actual reality of life in these countries. That it sometimes is espoused by people who live there and should know better is just sad.
 
Last edited:
Can they? Not really (see below) but they could probably stop further immigration and race mixing if they really tried.

Should they? Hell no. To take my own country as an example, there is no such thing as "British Culture" that can be separated from all of the other cultures that we have either been invaded by or have invaded over the centuries. There is no country on earth that has some kind of "pure" ethno-culture. Not one. There are snippets here and there, Morris Dancing for example is VERY English, but individual practices donot equal a culture. There is no such thing as a pure ethno-state. It just straight up does not exist. Sweden is influenced by the wars it had with its neighbours and the trading it did around the world. France, Belgium, Germany, Spain and the Netherlands all imported and mixed ideas from the various colonies they had. The Roman Empire pretty much ensured that most of Europe and the near and middle East were pretty well mixed before the change to the Common Era.

Are there cultural practices that should be preserved like Morris Dancing, or specific holidays and traditional celebrations from specific areas? Absolutely, these things are culturally valuable and should be preserved. But to pretend this means that there is a specific "British" culture that is somehow under threat from immigration is rampant racist nonsense. It's delusional to think like that and shows a deep lack of understanding of the actual reality of life in these countries. That it sometimes is espoused by people who live there and should know better is just sad.

:)
 
Can they? Not really (see below) but they could probably stop further immigration and race mixing if they really tried.

Should they? Hell no. To take my own country as an example, there is no such thing as "British Culture" that can be separated from all of the other cultures that we have either been invaded by or have invaded over the centuries. There is no country on earth that has some kind of "pure" ethno-culture. Not one. There are snippets here and there, Morris Dancing for example is VERY English, but individual practices do not equal a culture. There is no such thing as a pure ethno-state. It just straight up does not exist. Sweden is influenced by the wars it had with its neighbours and the trading it did around the world. France, Belgium, Germany, Spain and the Netherlands all imported and mixed ideas from the various colonies they had. The Roman Empire pretty much ensured that most of Europe and the near and middle East were pretty well mixed before the change to the Common Era.

Are there cultural practices that should be preserved like Morris Dancing, or specific holidays and traditional celebrations from specific areas? Absolutely, these things are culturally valuable and should be preserved. But to pretend this means that there is a specific "British" culture that is somehow under threat from immigration is rampant racist nonsense. It's delusional to think like that and shows a deep lack of understanding of the actual reality of life in these countries. That it sometimes is espoused by people who live there and should know better is just sad.
I'm curious. Who is making claims about an ethnically pure, completely discrete culture? I don't think I have seen anybody advocating this in the thread.
 

And consider the poor 'Merricans. When the older ethnicities sing the songs of their people, or parade in native costume, or dance to their gods, or create the dishes of the homeland (Finnish herring pie in rye crust! have you ever had it?), or sell their unique handcrafted crafts, what're WE supposed to do? Get up on stage and eat a cheeseburger? Dammit, it's not fair!
 
Can they? Not really (see below) but they could probably stop further immigration and race mixing if they really tried.

Should they? Hell no. To take my own country as an example, there is no such thing as "British Culture" that can be separated from all of the other cultures that we have either been invaded by or have invaded over the centuries. There is no country on earth that has some kind of "pure" ethno-culture. Not one. There are snippets here and there, Morris Dancing for example is VERY English, but individual practices do not equal a culture. There is no such thing as a pure ethno-state. It just straight up does not exist. Sweden is influenced by the wars it had with its neighbours and the trading it did around the world. France, Belgium, Germany, Spain and the Netherlands all imported and mixed ideas from the various colonies they had. The Roman Empire pretty much ensured that most of Europe and the near and middle East were pretty well mixed before the change to the Common Era.

Are there cultural practices that should be preserved like Morris Dancing, or specific holidays and traditional celebrations from specific areas? Absolutely, these things are culturally valuable and should be preserved. But to pretend this means that there is a specific "British" culture that is somehow under threat from immigration is rampant racist nonsense. It's delusional to think like that and shows a deep lack of understanding of the actual reality of life in these countries. That it sometimes is espoused by people who live there and should know better is just sad.


Here here!
 
Of course that stuff is ideology.


This is something you really need to grasp or we will keep going around and around in circles. I am not coming at this from some kind of first principles idea of what an ideal country would be like and being against everything that isn't in it. Neither am I coming at it with some revealed universal truths that are invariant across time and circumstances. That's an enlightenment, rationalist, progressive approach. I do not think the world works like that.

I am for or against things based on thinking about what their effect is on the world and what the available options are for changing them. Whether I am in favour of or against interracial marriage isn't something I can answer in the abstract because it isn't an abstract question. For it to happen now the world would have to be so upended that I can't even imagine it in order to form a an opinion. It also seems like such a trivial part of the problems I've been talking about that I see no relevance in it. It could be a good thing, or a bad thing.

You guys have to understand that most of the world does not think in the way that you do.


It is only an answerable question if ones answer is coming from dogma and ideology.


In and of itself it doesn't matter very much to me. It's so utterly correlated with things I do care about though that tripping over it is kind of unavoidable.

Well, good, because that is, emphatically and absolutely, not the question I keep asking, and which you keep dodging.

I don't care what you are for or against, or what your taste is. I asked, and ask again, specifically, whether you believe interracial marriage should be forbidden.

This is a very simple question for which the answer ought to be very simple. If you cannot answer it, it must mean that you can conceive of a circumstance in which it would be - not only ill advised, not only discouraged, not only unwise, not only contrary to taste nor other interest - but should be forbidden.

If you can't answer that question honestly, what question can you answer honestly?
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I think you guys are utterly blind to how intolerant you are. There is nothing special about my level of intolerance, except that it maps out differently to the intolerance of the forum.

So now everyone is like you? That's a common way to avoid self-examination.

Alcoholics use it: I'm not an alcoholic because everyone drinks this much.

Are you claiming people on the forum who don't feel the way you do about immigrants are no different than you, we are just intolerant of different people?

It's true I'm not very tolerant of right-wing gaslighters and people in Rump's cult. I think I already mentioned how I feel about extremist Evangelicals coming to my door to convert me. I'm not blind to that at all.

There's a difference between that kind of intolerance and lumping certain immigrant groups into something to be feared because they are coming here and will end up replacing one's own culture. There are Rump cultists in my neighborhood. I don't want them to move out. I want them to get out of the cult.
 
Last edited:
I think it comes about from ignoring an unspoken part.

When someone urges tolerance of things that are foreign, or unusual, I think it's usually safe to assume they mean things that are not clearly harmful. So to throw in harmful examples as an accusation of hypocrisy is completely a dishonest ploy.

"Oh, if you're so into tolerance, why aren't you being more accepting of murderers? Huh? Huh? Where's your tolerance now?"

There is no "paradox of tolerance" without that willful and performative misunderstanding. The difference between real examples and what I made up just above is only a matter of degree.
 
Last edited:
I think of tolerance mostly as the antidote to the "slippery slope" fallacy: that we take the time to actually wait and see what effect a trend has before deciding that this particular baby needs to get strangled in the crib.
 
I think of tolerance mostly as the antidote to the "slippery slope" fallacy: that we take the time to actually wait and see what effect a trend has before deciding that this particular baby needs to get strangled in the crib.
The problem here is that very often these things can't be rolled back, or not without some terrible consequences. Political capital is invested in these policies. Careers and bureaucracies are built on these policies. They aren't rolled back.
 
The problem here is that very often these things can't be rolled back, or not without some terrible consequences. Political capital is invested in these policies. Careers and bureaucracies are built on these policies. They aren't rolled back.

Firstly, you have still not spelled out what the exact problems are, that would need immigration policies to be rolled back. We've heard, for example, that you dislike the fact that 43% of Tower Hamlets' residents were born outside the UK. What you haven't said is why that is a problem. Moreover, if those people were somehow sent back to their countries of origin, how do you think Tower Hamlets would benefit from that?
As another point, we have seen what happens when migrant workers leave, as has been pointed out to you numerous times already. After Brexit, the hospitality and agriculture sectors suffered serious shortages of staff, which have still not been resolved. The NHS is also reporting difficulties, and is having to recruit more foreign staff due to a shortage of qualified and/or willing British employees. Reversing immigration has led to more problems, and I am not aware of any problems it has solved.
As a final point here, given that so many EU workers have left, can you point to any effect on British culture? This, after all, is your claim, that British culture is somehow weakened or diluted by immigrants. Now a lot of them have left, has our culture become stronger in any meaningful and measurable way? If not, why do you think removing more immigrants would make any difference?
 
Last edited:
Well, good, because that is, emphatically and absolutely, not the question I keep asking, and which you keep dodging.

I don't care what you are for or against, or what your taste is. I asked, and ask again, specifically, whether you believe interracial marriage should be forbidden.
On what possible, non-dogmatic, ideological grounds could I answer this question on?

This is a very simple question for which the answer ought to be very simple. If you cannot answer it, it must mean that you can conceive of a circumstance in which it would be - not only ill advised, not only discouraged, not only unwise, not only contrary to taste nor other interest - but should be forbidden.

If you can't answer that question honestly, what question can you answer honestly?
I have answered it honestly. The issue is you can not conceive of somebody not thinking about the world in the liberal enlightenment way you do. I can't imagine who would be making it illegal and what incredible circumstances would have to have come to pass to make it possible. There is no answer that does not depend on that context.

I suspect if somehow somebody had a stroke and tried to implement such a thing it would bring down torrent of state approved activist violence and in any case it would not come in to force. In these circumstances, the only ones in which I can imagine it being tried.... It seems pointless and harmful to me.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom