Can ID be disproven?

It is posited by ID proponants that life is designed because it is complex. Weather is also complex, but I do not hear ID proponants putting forth the theory of intelligent raining.

I did some digging. While IDers skip the whole "design" issues I raised in my post, they are falling hard on "Detachable specification" as the big issue to push ID through the "other stuff is complex" issue.

I really can't find a nice summary definition of what the are meaning by "Detachable specification", but supposedly this is why weather is complex but not designed. All I can glean from poking around is that old old pal the flagellum (the prime example of "Detachable specification") can be removed as a complex design from it's host (thus it's detachable :p ) but it has a "specificity" of function (make that bacterium go! go! go!).

And it's too complex to evolve and evolutionist have no evidence that it did (shame on them for not finding millions of fossilised flagellum precursors :mad: ).

However, I could be wrong about my interpretation of it - anyone have more insigh?
 
I'm an atheist. I read on a Christian forum that all atheists were immoral, so I decided to try it out.

P.S. I'm not really a McCarthyite, but please, don't blow my cover. I have almost infiltrated them.

ETA: I have to add something. Obviously, everything after the first sentence is B.S. It's just making fun of Bill. I hope that it isn't actually making fun of him. I hope he can't possibly be taking himself that seriously, in which case all I'm really doing is playing along. However, just to avoid some confusion, I want to say that the first sentence is not B.S. I really am an atheist.
Get real, turkey.
 
Stephenv2 said:
I did some digging. While IDers skip the whole "design" issues I raised in my post, they are falling hard on "Detachable specification" as the big issue to push ID through the "other stuff is complex" issue.
Yeah, detachable specification, what a larf. The idea is that the flagellum fits a detached specification of ... what? ... a locomotion device for vehicles in liquids? Sure, fine. Unfortunately, it is not the flagellum that matters, but the DNA that codes for the flagellum's components. So what detached specification fits the DNA that codes the flagellum's components?

None.

~~ Paul
 
I really can't find a nice summary definition of what the are meaning by "Detachable specification", but supposedly this is why weather is complex but not designed.

However, I could be wrong about my interpretation of it - anyone have more insigh?

It's not a term I had heard before, so I had to look it up. It refers to "detaching" an event from its surroundings. I don't know if it's a made up Dembski term, or if philosophers use the term. That's one of Dembski's problems. His first book, "The Design Inference" was actually his philosophy PhD dissertation. Philosophers love new terms and bandying them about. Clarity of speech is not exactly rewarded in those circles. So, what is it?

Let's go back to those poker hands. Suppose I deal 5H 5C 3D JH QS. That hand is no more nor less likely to come up than any other hand. So would you say that it is a totally unremarkable hand, or an incredibly unlikely hand? In most circumstances, you would say that it is unremarkable, and you would keep the pair of fives and hope for the best. But suppose this was the third time in this game that you had drawn exactly the same hand? Suddenly that unremarkable hand becomes a remarkable hand. Those previous hands "specify" a hand that should be considered remarkable. The knowledge of the previous hands allows you to "detach" those apparently random cards from their surroundings, and recognize them as something significant. And if you recall that each of the two prior times, you drew your third five, but the other guy had a flush, you would probably figure out the significance of the hands, and try to find out how he is stacking the deck. In other words, you would say that the cards fell that way by design.

The whole subject relates to quantifying complexity. How do you say that the DNA sequence that specifies a bacterial flagellum is significant? In general, for anything you want to quantify complexity for, you have to decide how many ways there are to rearrange the parts in order to meet a given specification, and how many total ways there are to rearrange the parts. Then you have to apply a formula I don't remember.

That's why it's proper to treat the parts of the flagellum as a discrete combinatorial object. Remember? That's how you quantify its complexity.

But, now, suppose that you have an existing object, with no a priori specification. You just have a thing. The DNA looks like just long strings of letters. Every string is like every other string. The only way you can make any judgement about the complexity of DNA, or parts of an organism is to first find a specification that allows you to detach it from its surroundings. I think, and here I'm a bit fuzzy, Dembski uses functionality as his "detachable specification". In order to analyze the complexity of a flagellum, you would have to make an estimate of all possible ways to arrange those parts in such a way that they would perform the flagellum function, which I think he would say is motility.

So that is what he is trying to do. He's trying to get an accurate measure of complexity. Is he doing it well? I doubt it. First, he is rather biased. Second, it is almost impossible to make such estimates in a meaningful way. In poker, we know the ways in which cards are dealt, so we can make exact measurements of the combinations in which the cards can be dealt. In biology, we don't know that. Exactly how many parts are there in a flagellum anyway? So, while his estimates are probably wrong and might even be meaningless, it's a legitimate attempt. It isn't some weird Dembski thing that no scientist has ever heard of. It's just not clear that his application is correct.

And about the weather. Why isn't it as complex as life? Well, I hesitate to say that it isn't, but it seems to me that in most cases, all the weather pretty much looks like weather. If you could find a meaningful pattern that allowed you to "detach" random looking weather from the background noise, then you could determine that some weather was more complex than other weather, and also compare it to living systems.
 
It's not a term I had heard before, so I had to look it up.

Thanks for the additional explanation esp. on the numbers game, but it seems like a deeply flawed thought process. With poker you calculate based on 52 card. With a flagellum are calculating DNA, molecules, atoms, subatomic, quanta? Where does it stop?
 
When it comes to his numbers, this is an area where Dembski will get no defense from me. First, for exactly the reason you mentioned. How do you compute the complexity in this real world example. Other scientists try to do the same thing in other applications, but most are on shaky ground as well.

Second, it is unclear whether we ought to be looking at the complexity of the "product" of evolution, i.e. the organisms, or the process of evolution. It is possible to create highly complex systems from very simple processes.

Also, consider where this is supposed to be relevant. Dembski's argument is that some systems are very complex, and when we know the origins of similarly complex systems, those systems were designed.

Suppose, instead, that his argument was that some systems look like they were designed, and we know they were designed. These other systems look like they were designed as well. Maybe they, also, were designed.

It doesn't sound so fancy, does it? And yet, it's the same argument. The whole specified complexity argument is an attempt to formalize what it means to say something "looks like it was designed."

The argument itself and the reaction to it are amusing in a way. If you strip away the highfallutin gobbledygook, you are left with, "I don't know. It looks like somebody built it to me. Does anyone know how this thing got here? I think something put it here on purpose."

This attitude might seem to contradict my earlier comments, but really, it doesn't. But that deserves further thought before committing bits to the forum.
 
My info theory text books would accept them, and the two concepts are so closely related that it would be hard not to confuse them.
You would expect a PhD not to confuse them.

Here for example (http://www.iscid.org/papers/Dembski_WhyNatural_112901.pdf) Dembski says:
Specified complexity is a type of information. Both complexity and specification are
well-defined information-theoretic concepts. Complexity here is used in the Shannon sense and denotes a measure of improbability.3
and the note he refers to is
3The (Shannon) information I(A) associated with an event A is by definition -log2P(A), where P(A) is
the probability of that event and the logarithm is taken to the base 2
So this is somewhat ambiguous. In any case the I would have thought that his definition of Shannon information is only a component of what Shannon information is. And what is it doing in the footnote for complexity? I would not have thought that there was an accepted definition for complexity in classical information theory anyway.

Actually I am not advanced enough in this topic either, but my feeling is that neither is Dembski.

Why, for instance, does he keep insisting on calling Dawkin's "Methinks it is like a weasel" program a genetic algorithm. Since when does a genetic algorithm already know the precise target in advance? All Dawkins program is is a parallel blind search.

Why does he describe what a genetic algorithm as having one person know the answer and another person trying to guess it?
 
No, you don't have RNA. And I'd be interested to know why you think any abiogenesis theory can ever be deemed falsifiable.

Ok. You tell me which molecules are alive and which ones aren't. And why. Then we can discuss it. Also, please explain why we do not have RNA?


ID does -- or at least can -- deal with the origin of life. You are correct that The Theory does not. That's one major disclaimer IDers want stressed as The Theory is discussed with students.

Not a single teacher I've met has ever taught that the Theory of Evolution deals with the origin of life. It is your strawman. The Theory of Evolution does not deal with the origin of life, period, so it is dishonest to equate that part of ID with the Theory of Evolution.

You failed miserably.

Actually, I did exactly what I set out to do.
 
I'm going to pick on Ossai a little bit here, but it could apply to all of you who bring up the "ID is not falsifiable" argument.

Yesterday, we coined a term, "Miraculous evolution" to describe Michael Behe's belief that evolution happened, but it could not have happened without the miraculous intervention of God. More accurately, it says that natural laws as we know them are inadequate to explain the origin and subsequent development of life.

We also coined a term, "godidntdoit", but that term is surprisingly difficult to type. So, I will coin a new term to describe the theory that evolution happened, and that natural laws are adequate to explain the origin and subsequent development of life. I will call this "Natural Evolution". It is what we normally think of as the theory of evolution, but we are adding the explicit qualification that divine intervention was not required. (Note: It may have happened anyway, but it wasn't required. Natural evolution, what everyone here except maybe Hammegk believes, does not require divine intervention, and says that if it happened, it left no visible trace.)

So, is natural evolution falsifiable? I think it is. And how would it be falsified? By demonstrating its null hypothesis. And what is its null hypothesis?

You're fine up to here.

One of them is Miraculaous Evolution.

No, it isn't. The null hypothesis of evolution would be one of many things. It could be that animals do not show variation. It could be that animals do not inherit traits. It could be that the earth is not old enough. It could be that variations in inheritible traits do not produce change in the long term. It could be any number of things. But it would be only one of them at a time. 'Miraculaous Evolution' is many of these things at once, so it could not be evolution's null hypothesis.

If Natural Evolution, our theory, is falsifiable, then Miraculous Evolution, Behe's theory, is falsifiable. They are opposites.

No they are not, for the reasons given above.

They are falsifiable. Falsify one, and you have demonstrated the other.

Simply not true. Falsify one, and you have falsified one. The other could also be wrong.

Finally, Miraculous Evolution is just another term for one form of ID. (The other major form would be creationism.) Therefore, unless you are willing to assert that Natural Evolution is not falsifiable, then you must acknowledge that ID is also falsifiable.

See reasons above why this is false (ha!) reasoning.
 
Last edited:
As an aside, if I had to chose one 'theory' of life that is the 'opposite' to evolution, it would probably be 'biblical creationism'. That is to say, that god made all the animals as they are now, and evolution doesn't happen at all.
 
And I'd be interested to know why you think any abiogenesis theory can ever be deemed falsifiable.

It's quite simple, really. Any scientific abiogenesis theory would be falsifiable, as falsifiability is a requirement for a theory to be scientific. Now, how about telling us why you think it wouldn't?
 
Nope. My point is that supernatural has no more meaning, or merit, than phlogiston. What I object to is the implication that IDers necessarily believe either.
Well the main argument seems to be that complexity cannot arise from just natural processes and so design is implied. So presumably a designer is implied. Somewhere along the line an undesigned and presumably extremely complex designer must exist.

But complexity cannot arise from just natural processes.

So the undesigned designer cannot be natural - so it must be supernatural.
 
It could be that animals do not show variation. It could be that animals do not inherit traits. It could be that the earth is not old enough. It could be that variations in inheritible traits do not produce change in the long term. It could be any number of things.

And if you showed any one of these, then both Natural Evolution and Miraculous Evolution would be falsified. The only thing that distinguishes Natural Evolution from Miraculous Evolution is the question of whether or not natural laws are adequate to explain evolution.

Natural Evolution: Natural laws are adequate to explain evolution.
Miraculous Evolution: No they are not.

Long ago, I mentioned, "the fruit fly experiment". NE and ME make opposite predictions to the outcome of that experiment. Run it and see what happens. Oh, you don't have a thousand years? Or more? Provide analytical models that show what would happen if you did. So far, no one is impressed with existing models, but both sides are trying.
 
You would expect a PhD not to confuse them.

I was unclear. Mathematically, they are exactly the same thing. It gets difficult sometimes to keep straight the mathematical and common usages of the word.
 
And if you showed any one of these, then both Natural Evolution and Miraculous Evolution would be falsified. The only thing that distinguishes Natural Evolution from Miraculous Evolution is the question of whether or not natural laws are adequate to explain evolution.
That and the fact that one is scientific and the other is not. If I may expand on your statements a bit.

Natural Evolution: Natural laws should be adequate to explain evolution, even though we don't know them all yet.

Miraculous Evolution: No they are not, and we are confident that no further investigation into natural laws will ever yield answers to the unexplained parts about evolution.
 
In general, for anything you want to quantify complexity for, you have to decide how many ways there are to rearrange the parts in order to meet a given specification, and how many total ways there are to rearrange the parts. Then you have to apply a formula I don't remember.
No, no, no, no, no. That is COMBINATORICS, not complexity. There are many ways to define and to compute complexity.

That's why it's proper to treat the parts of the flagellum as a discrete combinatorial object. Remember? That's how you quantify its complexity.
No, no, no, no,no. That's how Dumbski tried to do it. It is wrong from the get-go. Try to do the same thing with any molecules found in the universe. Let's try: let's see, figure all the atoms, figure all the available space, assume uniform distributions of all the atoms throughout all the space, and now compute the probability of creating the amount of quartz on earth. Whoops, it can't have happened; it is sooooooo improbable. Now, sir, what is desperately, naively, howlingly wrong with this approach?
 
BTW, folks, theories are not normally considered falsifiable. Predictions resulting from the theories can be falsified. Theories are explanatory frameworks.
 
Meadmaker
I'm going to pick on Ossai a little bit here, but it could apply to all of you who bring up the "ID is not falsifiable" argument.
Your entire argument rests on your own ignorance. You don’t understand evolution so you make something up that, to you, sounds simpler or somehow includes god in the process.

I’ll repeat my earlier question since you still haven’t bothered to answer it.
How did you come to that conclusion when ID proponents themselves have put nothing forward to be tested?

Ossai
 
Meadmaker said:
The whole subject relates to quantifying complexity. How do you say that the DNA sequence that specifies a bacterial flagellum is significant? In general, for anything you want to quantify complexity for, you have to decide how many ways there are to rearrange the parts in order to meet a given specification, and how many total ways there are to rearrange the parts. Then you have to apply a formula I don't remember.

That's why it's proper to treat the parts of the flagellum as a discrete combinatorial object. Remember? That's how you quantify its complexity.
I don't think so. Does it make sense to treat a watch as a DCO? Did it fall together from a pile of gears, springs, and screws? No.

But, now, suppose that you have an existing object, with no a priori specification. You just have a thing. The DNA looks like just long strings of letters. Every string is like every other string. The only way you can make any judgement about the complexity of DNA, or parts of an organism is to first find a specification that allows you to detach it from its surroundings. I think, and here I'm a bit fuzzy, Dembski uses functionality as his "detachable specification". In order to analyze the complexity of a flagellum, you would have to make an estimate of all possible ways to arrange those parts in such a way that they would perform the flagellum function, which I think he would say is motility.
You are correct: Dembski uses the function of the flagellum as the detached specification, because he is calculating the probability of it falling together. He never mentions a detached spec for DNA, yet the flagellum is assembled indirectly from DNA. His calculation is irrelevant.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom