Can ID be disproven?

There are two aspects of ID theory.

1. The theory of Natural Evolution is wrong.
2. Godidit.

Number 2 can't be falsified. Number 1 can be. If you disagree that number 1 can be falsified, could you please explain to me how "Natural Evolution is right" can be falsified.
The theory of Natural Evolution is wrong, in the same sense that Newtonian physics was "wrong". It is wrong because it is, and will always be, incomplete. Evolutionary scientists have never claimed otherwise. (And a good thing for them too, or else they'd have to find something else to study.)

But does aspect 1 mean that the theory of Natural Evolution is completely wrong about everything? I suspect it does not to people like Behe. However, if ID proponants are doing nothing more than saying that there are some problems with the theory, then that ain't pertikerly watcha call breakin' news. Bits of the theory are falsified all the time, but always by the scientific method. ID doesn't get to take the credit for that.
 
And if you showed any one of these, then both Natural Evolution and Miraculous Evolution would be falsified. The only thing that distinguishes Natural Evolution from Miraculous Evolution is the question of whether or not natural laws are adequate to explain evolution.

No, it would not. The prediction of any specific one theory would be falsified. Once again, the falsifiaction of one gives you one falsified theory. Not two. Not one false and one true. Just one falsified theory. And ID can never be falsified.

Long ago, I mentioned, "the fruit fly experiment". NE and ME make opposite predictions to the outcome of that experiment. Run it and see what happens. Oh, you don't have a thousand years? Or more? Provide analytical models that show what would happen if you did. So far, no one is impressed with existing models, but both sides are trying.

Please explain "the fruit fly experiment". Then, perhaps, I can comment.
 
There are two aspects of ID theory.

1. The theory of Natural Evolution is wrong.
2. Godidit.

Totally, utterly, wrong. One theory is not simply the negative of another theory. The theory of 'twinkepuff' is a theory saying the theory of gravity is wrong. It is a theory which leads to the conclusion that the theory of gravity is wrong. ID leads to the conclusion that evolution is wrong, because certain parts of the theory of evolution are incompatible with the 'theory' of ID.

Number 2 can't be falsified. Number 1 can be. If you disagree that number 1 can be falsified, could you please explain to me how "Natural Evolution is right" can be falsified.

No one is saying "Natural Evolution is right". We are saying "ID is not a scientific theory, and can not be compared with Natural Evolution". This leads to "all the evidence points to the theory of Natural Evolution being correct". The theory of evolution is a falsifiable, scientific, theory. ID is not. The answer to the OP question is "No, ID cannot be falsified". It is not scientific, it cannot be compared to the theory of evolution, which is scientific, and is seriously logically flawed in a number of places.
 
So it's perfectly scientific except where its not? Okay.

No. It is perfectly scientifice, everywhere, despite that it makes a nonmaterial claim. The nonmaterial claim is just as scientific as the material parts.
 
Please explain "the fruit fly experiment". Then, perhaps, I can comment.

Early in the thread, I mentioned the possibility of an eccentric billionaire dying, and in his will he decided to fund an experiment that would prove or disprove the Theory of Evolution, since then renamed the theory of Natural Evolution for purposes of this discussion.

So, he sets up a foundation to tend to and fund an experiment. He will keep fruit flies isolated in a specialized environment, gradually varying that environment in such a way that the flies are subjected to intense selection pressure that would require them to adapt. For example, the food would be placed behind a fine screen. Gradually, the screen would be changed to be a thicker screen. The fruit flies could only get the food if their mouths fit the holes. Gradually, the fruit fly mouth parts would have to lengthen and change shape.

There are lots of other possibilities, though. You get the idea.

He's an eccentric billionaire, so his wealth can be used to fund the experiment for several hundred years, which means several thousand generations of fruit flies.

The theory of natural evolution says that they will do just that. The theory of miraculous evolution says they won't.

Some of you might be hitting the keys to say that such an experiment proves nothing, but if that's what you are doing, please google "speciation" and "fruit flies" and you will find much less ambitious experiments, with much less significant results, touted as having confirmed the theory of evolution.
 
But -- and this is mostly a question for Meadmaker -- how do you work them into your theory while preserving anything useful, or indeed meaningful? Scientists don't reject God or the immaterial. They simply find Him impossible to work with.

Fairly good summary. You are correct in your statement of what I was getting at.

Let us imagine that God exists. Really. And that he interacts with and modifies the physical world. Then, in order to explain the physical world and its behaviors, you would have to include God as part of the explanation.

So, you've gotten the question right. What do you have to say about the "theory of Kashrut"? Note: I think the theory of Kashrut has subsequently been falsified, but to wandering Hebrews with no microscopes or refrigerators, "God doesn't like pig eaters" seems like a perfectly good theory that made specific predictions that were verified by experimental evidence. What's unscientific?
 
Meadmaker said:
So how complex is a watch? According to complexity theory, that isn't some subjective question. There's a number attached to it. And how is that number computed? It's computed by treating the watch as a discrete combinatorial object.
By all means, compute its complexity for me. I can't wait to see the math. I can tell you its probability, though: 1.

I've done programming work on the information content of DNA. You can see it here:

http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/~toms/papers/ev/

The information content is not computed by treating the DNA as a discrete combinatorial object, nor by treating what it codes for as a DCO. The information content is calculated by subtracting uncertainties (H) before and after evolution occurs.

Let us imagine that God exists. Really. And that he interacts with and modifies the physical world. Then, in order to explain the physical world and its behaviors, you would have to include God as part of the explanation.
And God would have to be physical, too. Otherwise you will have a hell of a time explaining how a supernatural entity interacts with the physical world.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Meadmaker said:
So, you've gotten the question right. What do you have to say about the "theory of Kashrut"? Note: I think the theory of Kashrut has subsequently been falsified, but to wandering Hebrews with no microscopes or refrigerators, "God doesn't like pig eaters" seems like a perfectly good theory that made specific predictions that were verified by experimental evidence. What's unscientific?
The goddidit part. There are no explanations or predictions about that part; it is unfalsifiable. The scientific hypothesis is "eating pig is bad for you."

~~ Paul
 
No. It is perfectly scientific, everywhere, despite that it makes a nonmaterial claim. The nonmaterial claim is just as scientific as the material parts.
It is not the least bit scientific. We have no evidence that the nonmaterial even exists. So how can a theory be scientific if it can never have evidence for or against it? Just saying "I can't think of anything else" is not evidence for the nonmaterial. It's just evidence that you can't think of anything else.

If nonmaterial things have evidence, then any nonmaterial thing I happen to think of (like IPU's) has equal evidence.
 
Meadmaker doesn't seem to agree that once you've proposed one magical theory, all magical theories are equally good. He hasn't said why he doesn't agree, but he just doesn't seem to.

~~ Paul
 
Early in the thread, I mentioned the possibility of an eccentric billionaire dying, and in his will he decided to fund an experiment that would prove or disprove the Theory of Evolution, since then renamed the theory of Natural Evolution for purposes of this discussion.

So, he sets up a foundation to tend to and fund an experiment. He will keep fruit flies isolated in a specialized environment, gradually varying that environment in such a way that the flies are subjected to intense selection pressure that would require them to adapt. For example, the food would be placed behind a fine screen. Gradually, the screen would be changed to be a thicker screen. The fruit flies could only get the food if their mouths fit the holes. Gradually, the fruit fly mouth parts would have to lengthen and change shape.
This is a test for Lamaarkism, not evolution. You cannot force specific mutations. Evolution would say that the flies would either adapt or they would become extinct under intense environmental pressure. It does not insist that they adapt. This experiment in no way supports miraculous evolution over natural evolution. Quite the opposite.
 
This is a test for Lamaarkism, not evolution.

I'm quite certain that the test could be formulated in such a way that it would satisfy any reasonable person, although, exactly as presented, you have a point. Still, if that is the case, what do you think of sites like this one:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html

who cite such experiments and their outcomes as supporting evolution?
 
(If you piss people off long enough, someone is bound to provide some information, slipped in through the whining.)

I've done programming work on the information content of DNA. You can see it here:

http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/~toms/papers/ev/

Thanks for the link, Paul.

Now, I have a suggestion. I took a look at your paper on dissecting Dembski. Very interesting. But more than interesting. It looks like a fairly good evaluation of Dembski's argument. It was a bit too thick for me to evaluate in one sitting. Or a few, actually. It will probably take some time. But, if you are right, then it is more than interesting, and it is more than a good evaluation.

If your claims are correct, then Dembski is falsified. Hear, Oh world. Paul, in his other incarnation as a guy with a real name, has published a paper in which he claims to have evolved specified complexity of the sort Dembski claims cannot evolve without a designer. If he is correct, then Dembski is falsified.

Your work looks good. Why put it down by saying it is a refutation of idiocy? Lose the putdowns. Lose the attack dog language. Lose all that stuff that causes your argument to be lost in the noise.

So, the next time you hear someone ask if ID can be disproved, try, "No matter what arguments are put forward, the supporters of ID will never accept the refutations of their argument, but I've published a paper that shows the core of their argument is incorrect. You can find it here." It might save 18 pages of drivel.

ETA: But you are still wrong about Kashrut.
 
Last edited:
Meadmaker said:
Now, I have a suggestion. I took a look at your paper on dissecting Dembski. Very interesting. But more than interesting. It looks like a fairly good evaluation of Dembski's argument. It was a bit too thick for me to evaluate in one sitting. Or a few, actually. It will probably take some time. But, if you are right, then it is more than interesting, and it is more than a good evaluation.
It's not my paper, but probably one by Schneider. There are plenty of good ones floating about. Google Howard Van Till, Mark Perakh, Kenneth Miller.

If your claims are correct, then Dembski is falsified. Hear, Oh world. Paul, in his other incarnation as a guy with a real name, has published a paper in which he claims to have evolved specified complexity of the sort Dembski claims cannot evolve without a designer. If he is correct, then Dembski is falsified.
That's Schneider's paper. The Ev program has been around for a decade or more. Schneider is the guy who invented sequence logos. You need to do some reading.

Your work looks good. Why put it down by saying it is a refutation of idiocy? Lose the putdowns. Lose the attack dog language. Lose all that stuff that causes your argument to be lost in the noise.
I didn't write any of that text.

So, the next time you hear someone ask if ID can be disproved, try, "No matter what arguments are put forward, the supporters of ID will never accept the refutations of their argument, but I've published a paper that shows the core of their argument is incorrect. You can find it here." It might save 18 pages of drivel.
I mentioned Schneider on page 1 of this interminable thread. It didn't seem to help.

ETA: But you are still wrong about Kashrut.
You mean the theory that the Flying Spaghetti Monster doesn't like pig eaters. Or was it the Invisible Pink Hamster Orbiting Neptune? No, wait, it's the Transdimensionals. Or, ...

~~ Paul
 
Let us imagine that God exists.

And here's where you go off the rails.

I see no reason whatsoever to cooperate with you in this particular act of the imagination.

Persuade me to.

I submit, as politely as possible, that you have no rational justification for making such a supposition.


Re-quoting
Let us imagine that God exists. Really. And that he interacts with and modifies the physical world.

If you can't even persuade me to imagine that God exists, then you have even less chance of persuading me that he not only exists, but interacts with and modifies the physical world. For example, I might be able/willing to accept the Deists' Watchmaker God, that exists but has no causal effect on the world. But if you're asking me to assume not only that God exists, but that the God that exists is actively self-contradictory (an immaterial object having causal effect on the material world?), then you're essentially asking the equivalent of "Let us imagine that God exists, and He's a four-sided triangle."

Then, in order to explain the physical world and its behaviors, you would have to include God as part of the explanation.

And a more charming example of begging the question I've not seen for a long time. Let us imagine that God is a necessary part of the explanation of the world. In this case, you would have to include God as part of the explanation.

Can you produce a non-circular argument, an argument that doesn't hinge on the assumption of a causally efficacious God?



What do you have to say about the "theory of Kashrut"? Note: I think the theory of Kashrut has subsequently been falsified, but to wandering Hebrews with no microscopes or refrigerators, "God doesn't like pig eaters" seems like a perfectly good theory that made specific predictions that were verified by experimental evidence. What's unscientific?

I think that further belief in a falsified theory is unscientific. The theory of Kashrut was never scientific in the first place (there's such a creature as the scientific method -- contrary to your assertions, "God doesn't like pig eaters" was not observationally derived, doesn't make any predictions, nor to my knowledge was it ever subject to experimentation), but there are certainly counterfactual variations of the theory that could have been. (Rabbi Simon Bar Sinister : "Hmmm, if God doesn't like pig eaters, then He will make the crops fail if the farmer eats pigs. So if I secretly feed my neighbor pig meat, his crops will fail. Let's see if that happens.")

More to the point, whether Kashrut was or was not "scientific" in 4000 BCE has little to do with its status today. Science marches on, usually over the dead bodies of previously "scientific" theories that have been relentlessly mown down by further experimentation and observation. Regardless of how good the evidence for phlogiston might have been in 1700, three hundred years later, phlogiston is superstition and nonsense. However, I don't think that belief in God has ever been scientific; as soon as "science" diverged from "natural philosophy," it was fairly obvious that evidence for God could not be established by the methods employed by scientists.
 
You mean the theory that the Flying Spaghetti Monster doesn't like pig eaters. Or was it the Invisible Pink Hamster Orbiting Neptune? No, wait, it's the Transdimensionals. Or, ...

Heretic. It's the Invisible Pink Unicorn (BBHHH), as you well know. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is clearly and self-evidently a deception of the anti-IPU to confuse people and draw them away from the One True Faith.

I just telephoned the Holy Seeker after Penitence and Truth and she should be arriving presently, cheese grater in hand, to discuss epistemological and ontological matters at length with you. Please drop your trousers when she arrives.
 
No. It is perfectly scientifice, everywhere, despite that it makes a nonmaterial claim. The nonmaterial claim is just as scientific as the material parts.

No.

The non material claim is not testable, not falsifiable, thus not scientific. It is a tumor on an otherwise workable theory. A good indication is that we can remove the claim (...and they died because they displeased God by eating shrimp), without changing the results. Without the God part, ben Levi's people still don't eat shrimp. The only difference is that they don't (yet) know the mechanism of death, and admit as such.

In fact, the God claim inhibits the actual science part of the kashrut theory. With God, we just don't eat trafe because God said not to. This prevents us from finding out that it is the way we cook the meat that makes a difference. We just stop looking.

Cheers,

Hank
 
Drkitten said:
Heretic. It's the Invisible Pink Unicorn (BBHHH), as you well know. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is clearly and self-evidently a deception of the anti-IPU to confuse people and draw them away from the One True Faith.
This is a damnable outrage! The IPU is a twisted, unholy charicature of the IPHON. Everyone knows that the IPU eats pork, anyway.

~~ Paul
 
I'm quite certain that the test could be formulated in such a way that it would satisfy any reasonable person, although, exactly as presented, you have a point. Still, if that is the case, what do you think of sites like this one:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html

who cite such experiments and their outcomes as supporting evolution?

There's a difference between observation of undirected evolution and attempting to produce a specific example of evolution in action. They're also, for the most part, looking at evidence of reproductive isolation, and not actually any positive change in the organism itself.

The real point is in the interpretation of "negative" results. Suppose that the fruit flies of our hypothetical billionaire all died out because they were unable to reach the food. Does this imply that evolution is false? Not under the conventional theory -- organisms are expected to die out all the time because the environment changes and they are unfit for their new environment.

Basically, Lamarkian evolution (which has been falsified already) predicts that the fruit flies would change form in order to be more fit for eating.

Darwinian evolution predicts either that the fruit flies would stay the same (if they are already fit), die out (if they are insufficiently fit for short-term survival and/or the necessary mutations aren't present), or adapt to be more fit. It's hard to falsify Darwinian evolution using an experiment where any outcome would be compatible with the hypothesis.

This doesn't mean that Darwinian evolution is unfalsifiable -- it just means that you designed a bad experiment. A better experiment would look at something that did falsify evolution, such as genetic drift in reproductively isolated populations. If I have two strains of fruit flies and I breed them in isolation, I would expect their gene pools to change over time and independently.

So the foundation runs such a test, and then gene-sequences sample flies from the three different populations -- experimental strain A, experimental strain B, and the control strain from standard fruit flies. If no difference is found between any of the strains, the experiment is as yet inconclusive and needs to be run longer. If the genes in A and B are substantially different from each other (irrespective of the control group), then this is in accordance with evolutionary predictions.

On the other hand, if experimental strains A and B are similar to each other, but differ substantially from the control strain, then evolutionary theory has been falsified. (And someone probably wins a Nobel prize.)

I'm still not sure what would falsify "miraculous evolution," though. If God can cause any form of genetic change He feels like, what kind of genetic change is impossible? This is why "miraculous evolution" is unscientific -- no experiment can possibly disprove it. This isn't the case of a single badly designed experiment, but a badly chosen (unscientific) hypothesis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom